Charlie McElligott — Nomura Securities Head of Cross-Asset Macro Strategy (as introduced on the show)

Announcer intro

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode 193 open and feature preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 193 was recorded on November 14th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, which happens to be my favorite podcast when it comes to quant and rules-based investing. Nomura Securities Head of Cross-Asset Macro Strategy, Charlie McElligott returns as this week's feature interview guest. Charlie and I will start with the high-level macro picture, then drill down on the details of everything from equities to how Nomura's CTA predictive model works, to why VIX futures are back to record short speculative open interest, to what's next for gold. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick and I will take a deeper dive into all of the subjects in our market wrap with the benefit of one of Patrick's famous chart

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year yield

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, let's start off with that S&P 500, which has been incredibly range-bound right at this 3,100 level on the S&P. And I'm sure we're gonna get Charlie to give us insights on the gamma situation around those strikes. But what's your take on the markets here? What's next?

Erik Townsend: I think that the melt-up wants to proceed higher. You know, when you get to round number resistance, as we're seeing here at 3,100, you always see several days of kind of, you know, trying to struggle to get through it. And then usually when you do get through it, There's a pretty quick move to the upside. Charlie sees a different scenario though, and I think it's much more tactical. It's not that he doesn't see this melt-up continuing through the end of the year, but in the next few weeks, I think Charlie's gonna be looking for some kind of pullback to occur. If you wanna play the melt-up, maybe that pullback, if it happens, is a buy-the-dip opportunity. But let's save the rest of that for the feature interview with Charlie McElligott.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index, which overall has not been doing that bad. It's been down a little bit today, but We've seen the dollar recovering over the last week or so from its worst levels. Do you think this is a turnaround point for the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, we've stayed above 98 all week on the dollar index, at least on the December futures contract, just barely above 98 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. All indications are that the recovery is still in motion. But, you know, this was the easy part. We got down to a little bit of an oversold condition. There had to be at least some kind of a bounce. The question is, is that a bounce that's going to take us to a new cycle high, let's say 99.50 or higher, or are we going to just partially retrace and then move to a new lower low, perhaps confirming that outlook that a whole bunch of people seem to have, thinking that the early October high point was the high for the dollar? I'm still leaning on the side that there's new cycle highs still to come for the dollar, but I'm opening my mind more and more to that other viewpoint. There's certainly a lot of very smart people who I have a lot of respect for who see it that way.

I think the jury's out, but let's see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil, which has been incredibly range-bound for the last week or two. What's your thinking on oil, and how did the inventory numbers come in?

Erik Townsend: Well, as I said in last week's episode, Patrick, there's been a persistent bid for WTI crude oil. I've noticed this. Several other traders on Twitter have noticed this. Something I just noticed in the last week is this bid really seems to have a US regular trading hour bias. In other words, it feels like almost Almost every morning, you know, Europe has sold crude oil down to its key support level. The chart looks like it's about to fall off a cliff. People wake up in North America and start buying, and by the time we get to noon, we're back up to our range resistance level, which has been for the last couple of weeks now the 200-day moving average. And I got a count on my chart here. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. Today was the 9th attempt to break through that 200-day moving average. And We did get through it before inventory. We were trying to break higher.

It felt like that persistent bid just wanted to take the market higher, but then we got to inventory. Crude oil, now API, the private service, had set expectations around a small drawdown on crude oil inventory, but EIA reported a build of 2.2 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma was a drawdown of 1.2 million barrels. A lot of people saying, okay, that means that streak of builds in Cushing is all over now. I I really think that is a bad misinterpretation of the data. You have to keep in mind that a spill on the Keystone Pipeline shut it down for almost 2 weeks, about 10 days, and that took 4 million barrels out of Cushing last week during this reporting period. So that drawdown of 1.2 million barrels, if not for the pipeline situation, would have been a massive build of 2.8 million barrels. And hey, the pipeline is back online now. Now it's operating at reduced capacity with reduced pressure, which is their standard operating procedure, but eventually it'll be back up to full pressure.

And it seems like that string of Cushing builds is likely set to resume as we get into next week's reporting period when we have the benefit of the pipeline being back on. Meanwhile, gasoline building 1.9 million barrels, distillates drawing down 2.5 million barrels. So overall, it was a build. Cushing was a drawdown, but again, there's special circumstances that define that. Meanwhile, even more bearish data. US production ticking up not just 1 tick but 2 ticks to a new all-time record of 12.8 million barrels. And that's despite the fact that the rig count has been declining in recent weeks. Imports 5.7 million barrels, exports 2.6 million barrels. Tape action fascinating to me. I many times have said on this program, it's not so much the inventory data but the market's reaction to it that I pay the most attention to.

Obviously, with that very, very bearish inventory report, we had to see downward tape action. We were down 1% to about 57.15 in the first 10 seconds after the data came out. But you know, Patrick, we rallied back up and spent several minutes again trying to push through that 57.46, which is the 200-day moving average, and you didn't manage to get through it, stayed below it. But you know, the the bulls, even in the face of a very bearish inventory report, were still trying to see if they could find a way to take the market higher. And we've seen that several times in the last couple of weeks. And it does seem like whoever's doing all this buying seems to be in a North American time zone. So it's been very fascinating to watch. As we speak on Thursday afternoon, we have drifted back down below the short-term moving averages to about 56.82. Just about a dollar below the high of the day, which was just before the inventory data came out.

I expect that we are going to get back down to the 13-day moving average, which is where we've seen support, maybe back down to the 100-day moving average at about $56, which is where we've seen stronger support. But, you know, I won't be surprised if we see another repeat of this pattern where Europe takes us down in the morning and the US takes us back up. And by noontime, we're pushing on that 200-day moving average. Will the 11th time be a charm? We'll see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's, uh, move on to gold because last week we saw obviously that all those lows at $1,480 taken out and we traded down to $1,450. And, uh, we're seeing gold bouncing a little bit in the last few days. What's next in for gold in your mind?

Erik Townsend: Well, I took advantage of that and bought a little bit down there just above $1,450, although not very much. The number I really like is around $1,420. That's where you get to a number of key technical levels kind of converging. One of them is the 61.8 Fibonacci retrace of the move up from the breakout zone to whatever the, the top was. So I'll be buying in, in much larger size if we get down to $1,420. But I'm starting to think that might take a little while because $1,465 was an important support level on the way down. As you say, we broke through it, looked like we were headed lower. Well, just in the last day or two, we've pretty impressively rallied back above. You know, normally you break down below a support level, it becomes resistance in the other direction.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: We saw a little bit of resistance in the other direction coming back up, but not much. And we're back up as we're speaking now to about $1,472, a good $7 above that $1,465, what should have been our new resistance level. It had served before as support. And I think probably what's driving this strength in gold is that it's starting to feel like that backup on Treasury rates has perhaps run its course and that Treasury yields are going to head lower. And of course, Lower real interest rates mean higher gold prices. So I think that's giving gold a boost here.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields, which have backed off. I mean, it looked like we were about to test 2%, and we're back here towards 180 on the yield. What's next?

Erik Townsend: Well, it feels to me like this correction in yields is maybe over, but Charlie McElligott knows this fixed income market a zillion times better than I do. So I'm gonna defer to his greater wisdom. He's gonna have plenty to say in the feature interview

Patrick Ceresna: This week's featured interview guest is Nomura's Charlie McElligott.

Why Charlie McElligott is back

Patrick Ceresna: Why did we invite Charlie back this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Charlie has been both incredibly popular and very widely requested by our listeners. It's been several months since we had him back on, but particularly, he's been really good at calling some of these big trends and where the reversal points have been in these trends in fixed income markets. The question that was on my mind before we even booked Charlie is, okay, we're clearly seeing a backup in interest rates.

You know, is it a change in direction or is it just a correction? I was leaning much more toward just a correction, but how much of a correction is still to come? Is it over yet? And I thought Charlie would be a particularly good guest for that subject. As we'll get into in this interview, I think Charlie thinks that it is over and that we're headed back down toward lower yields. Certainly what we've seen in the last few days seems to be consistent with that.

Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. I did a full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, the host of this excellent podcast, back on September 7th, 2019. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. We discussed a number of key issues about the value of having a rules-based investment strategy in a portfolio. In our conversation, Niels shared some some insights that may surprise you, especially when it comes to how trend following strategies don't really operate the way some market commentators suggest they do. For more information, including a free book about trend following and the accredited investor slide deck from my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, go to toptradersunplugged.com/macroslides.

Check them out, you'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Charlie is coming Coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Late-cycle thesis revisited: the steepener signal and the crowded duration trade

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Charlie McElligott, head of US cross-asset macro strategy for Nomura. Charlie, it's great to have you back on the program. Listeners, we do have a small chart deck that Charlie prepared that will accompany this interview. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. Charlie, I want to start with the really big broad stroke, big picture, and then we'll get into some of the details that you've been writing about in some of your daily notes. When I first interviewed you more than a year ago, you were talking about late-cycle dynamics. The end of the economic cycle. And I don't think you got anything wrong. I think you were spot on. But now we are more than a year later, and I think we are seeing that the economic cycle really is ending. But boy, the stock market's just got this persistent bid.

What is going on here? And is it telling us that that late-cycle analysis was wrong, or is it just that the dynamics have changed and the market can melt up no matter what the economy's doing?

Charlie McElligott: It's a pleasure to be back. I appreciate the conversation as always. Look, I think that initial conversation sometime a year ago, a little over a year ago, was and remains still very consistent with what we're seeing now, which was that at the time, I think people were really— this is probably closer to last summer, people were still very much believing in this idea that, look, we were late-cycle— well, we were above-trend growth, above-trend inflation.

We were just so many months into the actual fiscal stimulus. And at that point, a slowdown or recession seemed— was very unlikely, I would say, for most people's beliefs, but there was a lot of consternation with regards to what was happening with the shape of the yield curve. And at that time, we were seeing this powerful flattening. And that message, I think, on one of our first podcasts a year to a year and a half ago was it's actually the signal with regards to the actual recession is the steepening of the curve. The flattening happens when the market sees this slowdown building, sees financial conditions tightening.

The steepening begins to happen once the market begins to price in Fed easing. The front end moves lower. And then ultimately, you hope that the long end moves higher in conjunction with that under this easing of financial conditions and the stimulus added from the Fed. The idea was that typically, traditionally, per backtest and analogs, that you see curves steepen in those final moments before the recession. That is the actual signal there.

As that relates, say, back to equities, it is really a thematic, it is less about directional equities at that time, it is more about the thematic Typically, a flat curve is associated with slow growth, low inflation, or just what I'd call this muddle-through of the last umpteen years of what it feels like in the post-crisis period, which is this 2%-ish, 1.5% to 2% GDP growth, sub-2% core CPI, which has grown this very crowded everything duration trade. over the last few years.

Generally speaking, you're long the bond proxies, which is everything from typical minimum volatility defensive sectors. And we see the way that utes and REITs and staples have really been the best performing S&P sectors over the past year, in addition to those secular growth names like the high-flying SaaS software types of names, the FAANG tech type stuff. which actually acts like a bond because of valuation. It benefits from the lower yields justify the expensive valuations, and they return, they grow earnings. They grow as in this world of low yield and low growth. On the flip side, people have been short cyclicals. So, that is a product of this slowing growth, grinding, muddling through world that we've come to expect. The thing that started happening last year, was that the curve began to steepen because the market began sniffing the slowdown. The market sniffs the slowdown, then you price in that Fed action. We got all that.

That steepener call that we made last year, and then the catalyst for some of this momentum unwind that comes with that, the momentum unwind of trend trades has very much been the theme of the past year, these very stark, sharp kind of shockdown periods where prior carry-type trade, prior momentum trades really, really come unglued.

Now, we are at this point again where in the last 2 months specifically, where I've been talking about the implications of the bond market rally over the course of 2019 having overshot, that people were potentially misinterpreting that absolute level in interest rates as this signal of imminent recession, when instead, we were actually still holding that model through.

My message over the last 2 months has been, look, if bonds unwind some of this overshoot rally, you're really going to get another shock down because the market is underweight cyclicals. Overweight the bond proxies, and underweight anything growth-related. That has also been this very tactical story, and that has been bang on, too.

Now, I think everybody is trying to readjust for a world where they are starting to get rid of that probability of the now recession, and now beginning to push it back into a 2020, 2021 story.

5s/30s steepener, the 2019 bond selloff and the Fed's mid-cycle adjustment

Erik Townsend: For the benefit of any new listeners, I want to call their attention to your earlier interviews, Charlie. Listeners, if you type Charlie's name into the search box at MacroVoices.com, look for an interview that was titled Fear the Steepener, and there's a lot of really great content that was just as relevant right now today as when it was recorded several months ago.

Let's come back to that theory again. As I look at the 2s-10s chart now as we're speaking, Charlie, We, we got down to the point where the 2s/10s actually went negative very briefly. Looks like a bottom. And, you know, it's bounced back to about where it had been trading for the first half of 2019, kind of muddling through there. Is that the, the steepener that you said to fear, or are you talking about a much bigger steepener still to come that we need to fear? And where do you see this going and playing out from here?

Charlie McElligott: So, you know, the steepener that I was really focused on last year was, was 5s/30s, just because I want to truly capture that long-term growth and inflation view that only the very duration-sensitive part of the curve, meaning the long end, captures. The 5s-30s was the place that I was really advocating a significant steepening into the 5s-30s cash curve from last summer when I was pushing it, ultimately ended up almost quadrupling. It went from 20 bps to 80 bps, say, from Q3 last year into summer of this year. That was that first signal that, okay, market has adjusted. They smelled the slowdown, as I said, they're now pricing in Fed activity. Then we began to realize that things were not quite so bad as all of this permanent, almost constant recession talk that we've seen over the course of 2019. in these last 2 months. And with that, bonds have sold off.

And actually, it was the front end that was sold, and thus you had a little bit of a flattening here as the market began to price out so much Fed activity. So that is a big part of this where I think people went from one side of the boat to, okay, fiscal stimulus, late cycle, already hot economy, up, up and away, this view at one point last year into this, oh my gosh, imminent recession. We went from one extreme to the other. And now I think we're being a little bit more adult here with regards to saying, look, the mid-cycle adjustments undertaken by the Fed probably have extended this cycle because they've once again eased all of that financial conditions tightening that was at the core of the cross-asset bouts of volatility that we saw all year in 2018, specifically as it related to the balance sheet unwind on top of the Fed hikes. We've reversed some of that damage.

Now, I think people can be in a little more pragmatic neutral spot that the world is not ending imminently. That said, these steepenings come before the recessions do tend to hit. On that 6 to 9-month lag. People are by no means capitulating on that view that the recession is an inevitability, that the business cycle is coming to an end. I think they're really more about adjusting the positioning and the sizing of some of these trades, and certainly based on the timing of those trades, where in their minds, it's now been pushed off a year, probably because of that Fed liquidity injection.

Why the 2019 bond rallies were mechanical, and the momentum reversal

Erik Townsend: Now, in your daily note on Wednesday of this week, you wrote that the momentum reversal of the past few months was the easy trade. That was the, the easy one to see coming, but the hard part is where we are right now. What did you mean by that? Why is it the hard part, and, and what is it that we should be looking at here?

Charlie McElligott: So, I mean, whether it was just kind of from speaking with clients, that, that how crowded in a qualitative sense, the narrative became with regard to this end-of-cycle skepticism and that the trade war had thus pushed this already end-of-cycle slowdown view into an outright imminent recession view, that that overshot. There was 2 big bond rallies over the course of 2019. The first was March, where we had just a vapor move lower in Treasury yields.

The most recent power bond rally was in August. Both of those were very much convexity-related in my mind, meaning mechanical buying. The March episode was due to big bank dealer desks that have been shorting options to clients for frankly the last 2 years who were buying these big crash recession hedges.

Those trades were the curve cap trades that I started advocating last year on the podcast, which were basically bets on the curve going steeper and bets that the Fed was going to have to cut rates into a slowdown. Big banks had sold tons of these option structures to large clients from asset managers to family offices to hedge funds for the past 2 years and was just collecting premium and they were expiring worthless. It was a great trade. Well, in March, you had a really significant global growth scare, a slowdown scare. You started seeing some bad data come out of China, especially as it related to some of the rhetoric around the trade wars.

And all of these dealers that were short these options that were basically tied to low-strike receivers, which were calls that Treasuries were going to go higher, or short options that the curve was going to steepen, which were basically bets that the Fed was going to ease in the front end and the market was going to to price in more Fed cuts on the front end, they just got lit on fire.

That was the first part of the rally where it was very much just about dealers having to hedge these short options exposures. The most recent one in August was convexity hedging of another sort, which was really from the mortgage space. We had another large global growth scare over the course of August and July, frankly, European data was absolute garbage. The Asian data was really accelerating worse.

From there, You ended up having a situation where mortgages are inherently negatively convex. So, as bonds rally, mortgage— those that play in the mortgage space, whether it's MBS accounts or bank portfolios or bank treasuries or mortgage REITs, which are heavily leveraged, 7 to 10 times type of entities, they had to go out and buy more and more TY, more 10-year future to stay hedged. the lower the yields went. So, in both of those cases, the point I'm making is that it was a mechanical feature, not necessarily, though, a view of this imminent recession, and that was at risk of being misinterpreted.

My whole point then over the last 2 months has been that specifically in August, there was this false optic that the world was ending, and all it took was a little bit of a less bad outcome on China trade, a little bit less bad data, something constructive to hang your hat on that was going to see the same mechanical rally have to reverse, especially as positioning had grown so extreme. So you were seeing whether it was bonds, whether it was record buys in duration across Treasury futures, or Eurodollar positioning in 95th percentile extremes, to equities, Where there also was this end-of-world, end-of-cycle slowdown trade that I just spoke about earlier, long the bond proxies, both secular growth and the defensive min vol stuff, and you're short cyclicals, which are the growthy stuff, the inflation stuff.

We saw that with prime brokerage data where tech was 99th percentile owned by hedge funds, and conversely, energy, financials, materials are 10th percentile down to 0th percentile, if that actually is a word, with regards to historical ownership. Everybody had this trade on. It was very crowded. It was levered. We saw the hedge fund data show that funds had low net exposure. They had a very low directional lean long by historic measures, but they had big grosses on because both sides of the trade from the long side, being long secular growth and long defensives, had worked so well, and they were very short.

the cyclicals that kept going down every day over the course of the year. My point was in August that the moment that we get some positivity injected into this market, you're going to have a way outsized market response, as we've overshot, and now this positioning would have to unwind, and probably painfully so. And that was at the core of this cross-asset momentum reversal that we've seen. So, in today's note, Wednesday's note, I spoke about that. Since the end of August, You had a 43 basis point cheapening in 10-year.

The zero coupon ETF is down 11%. A cross-asset momentum strategy, quantitative strategy built by our QIS group, down 14% since that start of September. Equities price momentum factor, long the top decile of Russell 1000 performers versus short the bottom decile of Russell 1000 performers over the past 1 year, down 15% over that time. Value over growth, cyclicals over defensives, everything reversed.

The hard part is now. We got the overshoot, we got the positioning cleanse, we've gotten the deleveraging in a lot of these positions. Now, this momentum too, this momentum unwind has passed. And now I think the whole world is set up for this yields higher, stocks higher trade into year-end. Which is partially based on fear of missing out, just the psychological nature of it, a very positive Q4 seasonality for S&P, which is just a fact of nature for the past 90 years, and then expectations too around this phase 1 China-US deal signing. My concern now is that investors have potential to get caught flat-footed by another rally in US Treasuries, another rally in US rates.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

Charlie McElligott: Just as everybody has now shifted to the other side of the boat and is now short Treasuries, short rates, and that stocks are susceptible because there's so much new fresh long added into this rally that we've seen off the back of some of this China-US trade deal positivity.

How the Nomura CTA model works and why volatility is the trigger

Erik Townsend: I want to pick up on that point about stocks because you did write about equities in your Wednesday note as well, and you reference your CTA model, and I know that that's something you've gotten a huge amount of press attention for. We'll often see, you know, a piece on ZeroHedge that says, okay, Nomura's Charlie McElligott says the magic line in the sand on the S&P is blankety-blank number. If we get a daily close below that number, it's all over.

I've had the opportunity to interview an expert on these CTA systems and how they work, and the information I'm getting, Charlie, is really, you know, maybe 30 years ago it worked that way, but the most sophisticated traders, the people who are running most of the money these days, are the RenTechs and the D.E. Shaw's, these big quant shops that have incredibly sophisticated models that are reacting in real time. And from everything I understand, they really don't have any magic line in the sand that gets crossed. Their models are processing data on a continuous basis. So help me understand Exactly what your Nomura CTA position estimating model is. How does it work? What does it do? And help us reconcile how it works with this idea that I'm getting that, you know, it seems like maybe the, the way these quant trading systems work is very real-time, and it seems like it's hard to understand how there could be a magic line in the sand, so to speak.

Charlie McElligott: Sure. So, I mean, look, there— I think there's a couple points here. One, one I think is simply the way that That information is exchanged these days where a snapshot in time is then extrapolated or passed around as, as you said, some sort of line in the sand magical trigger that in actuality, in reality, is dealing with so many moving targets and moving inputs in this case, that those levels that we release on a daily basis, building this, reverse engineering this model with our QIS group. Yeah. Are constantly moving. And they're constantly moving because of the volatility inputs to the various underlying instruments. I mean, we're talking about a very complicated portfolio with 4 asset classes, 5 time horizons, 20 different strategies, where this aggregate portfolio and the volatility inputs and the price inputs and the fact that there's 5 different tenor windows, short-term, being 2 weeks, 1 month, 3 months, and then longer term, 6 months, 12 months, and the loading of each of those, there never is just a static point where we are buying and/or selling.

That's the first point that I would make. I mean, at the end of the day, yes, it's incredibly complicated because you're dealing with 5 windows of a time series momentum construct, and the sizing is inversely proportional to the instrument's volatility. It is pure risk control, which is the way that CTAs manage their exposures and manage their risk.

That speaks to the fact that the number of inputs are incredibly complicated, and that you cannot have something that is snapshot in time at some level be anywhere close to telling the same story the next day. It is a new slate almost on every day.

The other point that I would actually make here, too, This is almost more of a qualitative observation or a philosophical conversation point of discussion, but I've felt this way for the longest time. I view the world from the lens of volatility. I think the most powerful and most meaningful flow in the market is gamma, which in some ways is saying that the tail wags the dog with regards to what people think moves markets actually does not move markets. I spend a lot of time working with our vol teams.

And we have a tremendous look under the hood with regards to what investors are doing and particularly what dealer desks are doing with regards to hedging of their risks.

And this is very important because I think the CTA is such a hot topic, not simply because we're talking about this actual universe where BarclayHedge estimates that the actual size of the AUM, and they update this monthly on their website via reporting CTAs into them, of $360 billion, and it's clearly one of the most heavily heavily leveraged strategies out there on top of that, which matters, because then we are talking about ultimately trillions of dollars of notional exposures being managed and moving around, not necessarily sloshing around, but with the potential to slosh around, is more on this idea that certainly in the post-crisis world, desks, whether long-short equities, or a long-only real money account, or a relative value 10x levered fixed income arb shop, or a 20x levered market-neutral strategy, quant strategy, generally speaking, are all under a VaR constraint. That is the world of risk management in the post-crisis world, specifically with the buy side as it relates to investor expectations for managing that risk.

And their consultants expect certain risk parameters met, certain institutionalized risk management structures built. The point is that volatility is the trigger. Volatility is the toggle by which positions are grown or reduced, and volatility is that tail that wags the dog.

The other is that in the post-crisis period, banks, through regulatory oversight, now manage their risk very differently. And have to manage their risk very actively on a daily dynamic fashion. CTAs are important because what they are is picking up a very unemotional reversal of a trend. When you get a reversal of a trend, and as I said, the size of the positions are inversely proportional to the instrument's ex ante volatility. that that is picking up a shift in positioning, a shift in volatility that then ripples out across all types of strategies that are not pure momentum. And the point is that everything, when you're allocated in this current real-life 2019 into 2020 market structure, volatility is the toggle, and everybody becomes a de facto momentum trader.

So that's the thing. I mean, people have said, do you really think When we nut one of these calls that at this level, the signal flips from long to short or something of the like, and that has happened a number of times over the past 2 years, do you really think this is ticking the generalized CTA community and their behavior? I think, look, there is something to it.

Absolutely. We regress this to the index, and it tracks, it replicates the benchmark index. For years going back. We continue to track those cumulative returns. So we know we're doing it right. We regress it on a weekly basis to see where the slippage is and make the according changes on that basis. So it fits.

I also too, though, think that because people know that they're so volatility sensitive, and I'm talking about discretionary traders, fundamental traders, that there is an element of front-running these levels. There is an element of self-fulfillment of these levels where people try to trade ahead of these levels, of a game of telephone of these levels that enhances the feedback loop, enhances the echo chamber. I think that is also part of why the story has grown bigger than what I am actually trying to capture, which is simply these critical reversal levels. These critical inflection levels that then start that larger snowballing across all strategies.

Equity positioning, dealer gamma at 3,100 and the pullback analog

Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and move on to the signals that you're getting now and what you've written about equities, because it sounds like you think with a little bit of good news recently, maybe we're in kind of an overbought situation that makes us vulnerable to a reversal in equities. What are your models telling you? What do you see on the horizon? What are the numbers to watch for?

Charlie McElligott: I think there's an interesting dynamic where in this most recent tactical view in the Wednesday note, where I'm saying that the bond sell-off is tired, positioning has been cleansed. With that, and there's no next sell levels at this point, because positions are established and the duration position has been taken down. With that, a lot of these cross-asset momentum trades that have really accelerated And these momentum reversal trades that have accelerated over the last 2 months are probably fatigued, too. That thematically matters then at this point, if I think the bond sell-off is largely washed for now, because you probably won't be seeing that cyclicals over defensives trade, that old tech over new tech trade. As I said, all the software names that were up 80% year to date have lost 20% in a couple of weeks.

I think on the micro level, that's where it matters. I think, though, with regards to the macro story, the macro takes a little bit of a backseat here.

And now, to me, the short-term risk is purely just about positioning with regards to investors who have either directly or indirectly become very long equities over the course of this recent rally escalation, which was generally attributed to positive news. Not as bad global growth data, a couple of nice US data beats on top of this general positivity around China trade. So if I'm talking about very long equities, what am I talking about?

Well, if you look at the net dollar absolute position in S&P futures for asset managers from the TFF data, we're looking at a 98.5th percentile position dating back to 2006. I mean, very long. equities in that sense from real money. If I'm talking about our CTA models' estimated positions, we're now back to plus 100% long signal in 12 of the 13 global equities futures that we track versus a month ago where a number of those had deleveraged and a couple of them were even flipped short.

Then specifically, and this is one near and dear to my heart, because again, I look at the world through this volatility lens, through this vol lens, if I look at S&P index options, if I look at SPY ETF options and look at their consolidated Greeks, we see that the net long dollar delta is 98th percentile since 2013, which means that frankly, you have a market that protected themselves on an upside rip via options.

They don't have the big net exposures right now. They're generally speaking, and that's why the momentum unwind has been so profound, momentum factor down 15% in 2 months, they've been in the more bond-sensitive stuff and have been short the high beta stuff. So, they haven't performed the same way that the market has to the upside. So, they've slacked on positioning into this rally, they've slacked on performance into this rally, which has made it a not feel so good rally. They're not losing money, But they are not capturing the actual extent of the move.

What now that means is that through all this options upside exposure to hedge themselves on a melt-up, they are now long what I call soft delta. They are not long in their underlying single stock names. They are probably, when you get 98th percentile plus type of options positioning, options dollar delta, they're more prone to begin to take profits. They're very long. The market has moved up significantly. Now, it makes sense to monetize some of this stuff, especially just if you're looking at where we stand over the course of the year and the fact that they haven't performed quite as well as the index has over the last 2 months.

So, I ran a really interesting study last week, and I think it's important to talk about. I just talked about 98th percentile net dollar delta across S&P and SPY equity options positioning. Again, it's this length that has been added via those option structures, via the upside strikes. Well, if you test a 98th percentile dollar delta in conjunction with basically a 95th percentile, let's say, dollar gamma position, and that is a net dollar gamma position I'm actually capturing in the dollar gamma position the fact that the market has ground and made this power move grinding higher to such an extent that overwriters, sellers of volatility, are now short a fair bit of optionality, and they have dealers very long gamma.

Right now, that's the reason that we're stuck at this 3,100 level. There's $16 billion of dollar gamma. At the 3,100 strike. That is just a massive number. I actually can't think back off the top of my head the last time we had an absolute dollar gamma at one strike of that size.

That's why we're stuck here. But the interesting thing about this analog, this backtest that I ran, is that when you look at that extreme dollar delta and that extreme dollar gamma in conjunction, you actually show potential for near to medium-term equities downside. And really significant VIX upside over the next X number of months. So what does that actually look like for S&P? It looks like over the next 2 weeks, you see a pause to a pullback, down, let's say, 30 bps over the next 2 weeks median return. Over 6 months, that looks like an almost down 4% median return.

But really where you see it is in the VIX complex. The median return over a number of these samples that we've tracked previously, a 55% VIX return over a 3-month window.

So that iterates to me that this positioning has overshot a little. And now if you do get a scenario where, look, the market has really baked in a significant amount of positivity with regards to these phase 1 talks, And if you look at Donald Trump's speech to the Economic Club yesterday, and a market that I think was telling us that people wanted to short that mid-December finger-in-the-air phase 1 deal signing, because everybody knows that phase 2 is the hard part that we'll probably never get to, that now you're probably further incentivized to take profits because he didn't back down on tariffs.

And now they've adjusted, himself and Kudlow, over the last few days, backing away from a hard date on signing. It feels like the easy money has been made there. And if you're long all this market upside via options, and you're soft delta, I'm going to start taking some of that off.

If I'm an asset manager, and collectively that universe is 98th percentile long the S&P futures, $130 billion of length, I'm going to start taking some of that off. So to me, it's about this positioning And now this kind of macro, like, oh, wow, we priced in best case all of a sudden on this China trade stuff. It maybe is a little murkier than we thought. I'm probably going to take some of that off. And why you do tend to see this kind of 2-week, 1-month window for a pullback when you look at some of these analogs of the options positioning.

VIX futures record short and the VIX ETN offset

Erik Townsend: Charlie, I want to stay on this topic of volatility and the VIX in particular. As you remember, about About 18 months ago, there was this widely reported just blowup of the vol complex after a whole bunch of retail traders who literally had no idea what they were doing were all short the VIX. Now, there's an old saying that the hardest learned lessons are the longest remembered, but it seems like that may not be the case here because some analysts that I've been reading are saying that the COT reports are now suggesting that they're at it again, that we've got that record speculative level of short interest in the VIX futures contract. People trying to pick up that contango yield that sets them up for that same kind of blow-up risk that happened at the beginning of 2018. Now, you just said a few minutes ago you see significant upside potential in VIX. That could be the next blowup event.

So is it accurate to say that they're at it again, or is the picture maybe a little bit more complicated than that?

Charlie McElligott: No, it's a great capture of the dynamic, Erik. I mean, I think the challenge is this, and I know we've spoken about this previously, the dynamic of February 2018 will never be seen again. And, you know, and I don't like saying this, but, you know, unless a bomb goes off in the middle of downtown Manhattan in the middle of a trading day, you know, point being that we will never see that amount of short vol need to be rebalanced at the end of the day. Why is that? Because February of 2018 was the extinction event of the leveraged short vol complex. Those products do not exist anymore. That just created an impossible amount of rebalancing into a tiny window at the end of the day where, God forbid, you had this filing Filing meaning a bankruptcy event for some of these products, where there was a macro catalyst over the month of that prior January, where all of a sudden inflation became a thing and the market had to suddenly shock adjust to the possibility of the Fed power tightening, which is exactly what happened over the course of last year.

Now, the reality is this, those products are gone, and if those products are gone, We can never have that squeeze. More importantly, I think right now, you are seeing this discussion where people are taking in isolation a snapshot of the CFTC non-com, meaning spec position in VIX futures, and they are hyperventilating on the fact that the net position is the most short it has ever been.

The trick to me, is this. A lot of folks don't realize that the VIX ETN complex on the other side actually more than offsets that short vega position in the CFTC futures because it is the other side of the trade. The short-term VIX ETNs, which if you backtest this type of extreme long that they have, which again, more than offsets the net vega short in the non-com futures position.

The ETNs tend to have the near-term forward returns right, like they're long vol, and you actually tend to see higher near-term volatility when you see this type of extreme.

Right now, the net vega position for ETNs is 99.7th percentile since 2011. If you look at that non-com spec hedge fund VIX futures net vega position. Yes, it is extreme. It's 0.2 percentile since 2011. But again, the point is there's the other side of that trade, and it's the VIX ETNs, which to me, a lot of people aren't advertising the full story here.

So that's why I appreciate the opportunity to clarify it. I am of the view that equities are going to pull back in the next 2 weeks to 1 month. Might be down 2%, might be down 5% because of this extreme positioning.

And yes, VIX is low on an absolute level, let's say, like a 13 handle in the index, not necessarily front month future. But one other point that I'd like to make on the non-com VIX futures position is that it's so short right now because systematic rolldown players who play the shape of the VIX curve are massively into that trade.

Right. Because of the shape of the curve right now. The curve is so steep. And that is part of what's happening right now. They get a signal due to the steepness of the curve, right, where front month vol has been smashed partially because the VIX ETNs just had to rebalance. And for 7 months in a row, when VIX ETNs rebalance, you've seen the VIX trade down multiple vol points the one week into the event. They have to sell the front month to buy the second month. That is an inherent steepener of the VIX curve. That is then a signal for systematic VIX rolldown guys to come in and try to trade the shape of the curve with such a steep rolldown. And to me, they actually end up getting run over on this trade, why I think there is VIX upside in this next 2 weeks to 1 month. I think that type of rolldown, that systematic rolldown, they hedge indiscriminately in some ways.

I think that's a big story to me, but you can't talk about vol without really going into the larger offsetting other side from the VIX ETNs.

Gold: real yields, the CTA signal cut and the bond rally view

Erik Townsend: Finally, I want to move on to gold, a subject that we haven't talked about since the breakout occurred that surprised a lot of people, myself included, past $1,350, which had been a key resistance level for almost 5 years. First of all, how do you interpret that? A lot of people think, okay, this is a clear signal that we're now in a new secular gold bull market. Do you agree with that? And if so, does that mean it's time to buy, or does that mean it's time to wait for a more significant pullback before getting back in?

Charlie McElligott: So to me, gold, gold is a shapeshifter. Gold at times And I think a lot of people probably incorrectly associate it with some sort of a risk-off hedge in and of itself, which is not always the case, because other times gold acts like an emerging markets risk currency.

To me, the story of gold over this past year rally kind of story— and we started getting pretty bullish on gold late December last year— was core to my Steepener thesis. My Steepener thesis was That front-end yields were going to probably be collapsing as the market sniffed the slowdown, forced the Fed into a much more aggressive easing cycle than many people believed was possible. So the trick then, to me, is that gold began to trade off of lower real yields. It began to move higher opposite it correlated, so indirectly correlated to lower real yields. Now, I think that markets have seen this dynamic where you're instead looking at a normalization of yields over the last 2 months. Gold has given back. Yields, it wasn't this end-of-days scenario. It wasn't this imminent recession scenario.

With that, I think that was pretty important because you ended up seeing You ended up seeing gold get pretty hard hit. And actually, it's funny.

So like a week ago, on the day, on the 5th, where you had a huge purge, our CTA model had the gold position reducing from 100% to 38%. And that still is where we sit right now. We had been pretty much over the course of the year long, 100% long in the trend signal. That has now been reduced. Just on account of, come from a macro indicator, the fact that real yields stopped going lower and frankly began going higher again. So, I think now the trick is that my view here going forward is that the bond rally can actually continue. We've washed out that excess positioning. We had that big 40-plus basis point sell-off in 10 years. I think now that as we pivot towards a more likely deterioration in the China trade story again, as we look past this phase 1 and into the tougher phase 2, That bonds can rally again, and bonds rallying again means lower real yields, means higher gold.

Erik Townsend: So it may be that right now is the time to be getting into that long gold position as we see what looks like maybe a reversal point in the bond market, which you think is probably the driving factor here.

Charlie McElligott: Yeah, yeah. I think that bonds have scope to rally again here, especially as it's tied into the potential for stocks to pull back. And with that, lower real yields should mean higher gold.

How institutional clients get the daily note; wrap-up

Erik Townsend: Well, Charlie, I can't thank you enough for another fantastic interview. You write an absolutely terrific daily note, and it's only available to institutional listeners who have a business relationship with Nomura. And folks, please understand, Charlie's not trying to be a jerk. His hands are tied. There are regulatory issues here. He can't send it out to our retail audience, but for the benefit of our institutional audience, people who do have an institutional relationship with Nomura, how do they get your daily note? Because it really is one of the best pieces of reading that comes across my desk every day.

Charlie McElligott: No, I appreciate those kind words, Erik. Thank you. So, look, it's, it's, um, if you are an institutional trading partner, uh, and client of Nomura Securities, you can, you know, reach out to your salesperson, and that includes, you know, the Instinet side or the cash equity side of our business, and reach Reach out to your salesperson and, you know, at certain kind of revenue threshold expectations, we'd be more than happy to add you to the dailies and to have further dialogue from there, you know, as it relates to kind of the more tactical intraday conversations.

Erik Townsend: Well, Charlie, we look forward to getting you back on in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: takeaways and the gold question

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to get an update from Charlie. It's always great to hear, you know, at the quant and institutional level, just some of the insights as to where we are on the markets. What did you take away from it?

Erik Townsend: Well, I thought it was an excellent interview, and I was particularly interested in Charlie's call that he thinks the backup in interest rates, the correction if you will, in bond yields is ending and that we're headed toward lower yields. And it's got me thinking about gold price. You know, I've been holding out for $1,420 to start really buying in size here. And actually, I bought just above $1,450. Should I have bought more there? Could it be that this was the bottom if interest rates are really going to turn around here? So I think what we should do, Patrick, is dive into your chartbook and go into a little bit more depth on our market wrap subject.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Postgame: S&P 500 gamma chart, expiration pattern and pullback levels

Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the link to Patrick's chartbook in your Research Roundup email. It says Postgame Chartbook. Patrick, let's dive right into the S&P 500. You've got the daily chart on page 2, but it looks like you've added something new on page 3. What's going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: So on page 3, since Charlie spends a lot of time talking about gamma exposures in the markets, I snagged off of spotgamma.com's website just where we are on the gamma charts on the S&P 500. This is for the SPX here. And, uh, what we continue to see, and, and Charlie referenced it in the interview, is that there's this big huge amount of gamma up at the 3,100 strike on the S&P 500. And as this chart shows, that actually creates a low volatility hurdle that's like a wall that has actually been a major overhead resistance. Now, how much of that overhead resistance rolls off here in the November expiration coming up tomorrow is something I didn't calculate, but it certainly has been the big hurdle for the markets. But there's a couple other interesting observations I wanted to make on this chart, which is the high volatility zone where dealer gamma flips isn't until under 3,000 on the S&P.

So even if we were to have— like, uh, Charlie, I remember him saying something around a, a 2-3% correction would not be out of line. I mean, if we had a 100 S&P point correction and went back down to like 3,000, it still wouldn't be enough to drive at least, uh, aggressive dealer selling in the gamma flip.

So with that in mind, I wanted to go to that chart of the S&P 500, and highlighted there in the 10 circled areas is the expiration of each option cycle for the 10 months of the— that have passed this year. And what's an interesting characteristic that I've seen a number of people on Twitter point out is that we've seen a lot of times where the market will rally and get pinned into an expiration, and that there's a tendency for the markets to step back, pause, and/or correct in the post-expiration cycle.

And what we have here is a scenario that the only 2 times that we've seen where the market continued to rally right after the expiration was in January and this past October. And with the market overextended and pinned right above 3,100, I suspect that the market is vulnerable here for at least a pause and/or a market correction.

But with that being said, I think that it would take a lot of damage for this to Flip. In other words, we could easily get a pullback, retest what were the previous highs of the S&P, you know, around that 3,020 level, find very legitimate support there, and that becomes a base for a continuation pattern higher.

I marked off in the box there the Fibonacci retracement zones, is sort of in the 2,950 to 3,000 area where there's a number of fib retracement zones from the prior rally. And for me, in order for the bears to get any traction, we would need to see the price action legitimately starting to crack 3,000 to the downside. Then we start seeing, you know, CTA flips and all sorts of things start to happen where selling could accelerate. So I'm— I, at this moment, I think the market is vulnerable for a step back, but I don't necessarily think it's the big one yet. It's, uh, we probably could see a 50 to 100 S&P point pullback here before we correct. What's your take on

Erik Townsend: That sounds very consistent with what Charlie said. It sounds like he's expecting in the next couple of weeks that there is some kind of pullback and then maybe a rally after that into the end of the year. It sounds about right to me. My feeling in general, as I've said many times, is I think that the equity market is melting up. It's being driven higher by what I'll call unnatural forces. It's not that the economy is wonderful and, you know, there's going to be wonderful earnings that are going to support higher share values. This has everything to do with the Fed being extremely accommodative and providing low interest rates, fueling corporate stock buybacks, and allowing the market to continue to melt up. So I think the idea of a pullback before year-end, then a rally into year-end, Christmas rally, certainly makes sense. I don't really have a strong directional view on the market though.

Postgame: crude oil, the 61.8 retracement and the morning bid

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to page 4 where I have a crude oil chart. And after hearing your market wrap, I kind of wish I added the day moving average on here just so that we had a reference point. But I did draw a little line there where the— it's the 61.8 retracement of the, uh, the sell-off that we had from that, uh, Saudi attack in September to the bottom in October. And for me, while the crude oil, like you were saying, has been bid pretty consistently, we have a major hurdle that has to be beaten for the, for the oil markets, I think, to flip bullish. Because at this stage, if we have, uh, crude oil fail at this level, and for whatever reason a catalyst, you know, drives us down to $54 or lower, that really opens the window for another full measured move extension lower. And while I'm not necessarily forecasting that, I certainly feel that the bulls better show up for the party and punch through some of these overhead resistance levels.

Otherwise, that bear scenario starts, uh, becoming a real possibility. What's your take on

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I really have fairly low conviction about the direction of this market from here. And the reason is I feel 2 competing forces. One is it feels toppy here. It feels like we can't seem to get through this key resistance level. We ought to head lower. If I just take a look at the chart there in this trading range that we've been in, another test down to, let's say, between $51 and $52 seems like it could very easily be in the cards. It just visually looks like that maybe is what ought to happen next on this chart.

The thing is, for the last couple weeks, there's been this just really weird feeling in the market that every morning around 7:30, 8 o'clock Eastern time, just as the market looks like it's about to fall off a cliff, all of a sudden the buyers come out of nowhere. Sometimes there's news behind it and they buy more and faster than the news warrants. Sometimes there is no news and they just start buying because it's, you know, it's morning time in Eastern time zone.

Yeah. So it feels to me like either some big funds have taken a longer-term view and have begun accumulating, or somebody's doing more and more buying. And I think it's a question of, are those buyers going to get more aggressive? Are they willing to push the market through those levels in order to get it higher? Or are they real smart buyers who are going to say, hey, let's, let's give it a little break now and let it drift back down to $51, $52. Feels to me like somebody is ready to do a whole bunch more buying. They certainly have been doing plenty of it, and they've been coming into the market at strange times. So it's a question of what they do next, and I'm not sure who that is that, uh, that we're talking about. So I could see it go in either direction here.

Postgame: gold chart, $1,420-$1,450 support and sizing

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, you know what, I personally would love to see it break higher, but let's— we'll see whether or not that comes to fruition. Anyway, I want to, I want to move on to page 5 where I have a chart on gold. And I felt, uh, putting on a chart on gold and Treasury bonds was warranted considering Charlie had such a— well, he shared a conviction that he thought both of them were poised to strengthen on the interim. So I wanted to kind of give us something to talk about while looking at the chart here.

But to me, the interesting part about gold, irrespective of the fact that it broke to a sequence of lower lows from its high out in all August. Overall, the pullback has all of the same characteristics of a retracement, or where a bull market advance usually tends to give back, you know, anywhere from a third to half of its prior advance in a consolidation before resuming back in its bull market form.

So for me, I'm— I still could see the scenario where gold is bullish. It'll be interesting. There's a— the consolidation that we saw in gold back in July, and that's around that $1,420 area. And, uh, one of the more interesting things for me will be whether or not gold can stay decisively above that kind of $1,420 to $1,450 area, even if it tests into it temporarily. And if it nicely rolls up from there, that would be, uh, very bullish in the way the chart pattern will be developing if that kind of support line holds.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I'm hoping that we get there. I think that $1,420 is a very attractive place to start buying in more significant size. I still think there's a good chance that we're going to get below $1,400, but, you know, $1,420, $20 is not that much to ride down a little bit of a move, even if you've just bought a significant position.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, exactly. Like, you know, when we had Alex Gurevich on, he was basically saying that, like, whatever, a $50 or $100 downside risk is peanuts versus the upside potential you have, and that it doesn't matter if on the short It's coming down here. This is an asymmetric level still to own gold. And so I guess we're splitting hairs in terms of whether or not there's another $20, $30 little dollar downdraft, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, it could be considerably more than that. I think it's really— it's a question of whether you're trading with leverage and how much dry powder you want to leave for the possibility of lower prices. You know, you hate to get into a situation where you spent your whole wad and you do get that break back down to $1,350, which would be an extremely appealing technical level to buy. Probably not that likely that we'll get there. You don't want to get back to $1,350 and be panicking and thinking about selling instead of buying more. You want to be buying more down there. So I want to leave at least room to be buying more at $1,350 if we get lucky and get that chance.

Postgame: is the bond bull market over? Dalio and the Fed

Erik Townsend: I think $1,420 is a good place to start buying in size, and I'm already accumulating

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, on page 6, I just had the 10-year Treasury chart on the bond futures. And what a lot of technicians have been observing has been like a double top formation developing between the September, October tops and calling that this is the end of that 30, 40-year bond bull market.

Erik Townsend: How many ends has this 30, 40-year bond bull market had?

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, it's every 6 months, it's over, right? Um, and, uh, what's interesting is, is that, uh, whenever you have a topping formation, it obviously is again doing a retracing move. I feel that after a bond market rally of the magnitude we saw, it would actually be very natural for us to have a 2 to 3 month consolidation of the rally, backfilling and unwinding the very overbought state of the bond market. I'm with Charlie in the sense that I'm not remotely as bearish bonds now. I, I, I have not been in bonds for a couple months, and maybe I should start considering getting back in. I took my profits on bonds all the way back in August, a little bit too early. But, you know, the question for me is, is that, is there a reason this big bond bull market is over? I don't think I see it.

I, I think that this is a, a market correction, and as soon as the market correction plays out, I think there's room for this to

Erik Townsend: Well, you got to think about Ray Dalio's comments. You know, is there a reason for this bond bull market to be over? Well, the reason for it to be over is because the market is sensing that the US is not going to be able to finance its deficit spending, and we're going to get into a real fiscal crisis, and the Fed is not going to come to the rescue. Well, wait a minute, why would the Fed not come to the rescue and allow everything to fall apart? Now, in the long In the long run, I think the Fed coming to the rescue ultimately probably does more damage than it does good because it sets us up for an even worse fall later on.

But that's not the way politics works. Politicians want to solve the immediate threat right now, the one that affects them while they're in office, and they don't worry too much about what they're setting the next guy who's not coming into office for a few more years up with. So why would they allow interest rates to back up significantly so that it creates a financial crisis for the US government being unable to unfund its deficits. Why would the Fed allow that to happen when they still have a printing press?

Well, one reason is total runaway inflation. They don't have any choice. Well, we're not there yet. We're not anywhere close to that. I think it's coming someday, but it's not rational to worry about runaway inflation right now. So why wouldn't they keep interest rates suppressed for a while longer. And that's, I think, the crux of Ray Dalio's argument. Someday they won't be able to. They'll be fighting impossible inflation, and, and they'll have to let Treasury rates get away, and it'll be a really scary situation for the US government then. I don't think we're anywhere close to that. So I, I think that the outlook for continuing lower bond yields makes perfect sense.

Postgame: TLT versus gold and real rates

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to chart 7, where I thought it was just an amazing chart because what I did over here was just on a performance chart overlaid the performance of the TLT, which is the 20-plus-year Treasury bond ETF, with gold. And to me, it's just uncanny how the correlation between the two is literally tick for tick. And I asked the question is, how long is this correlation going to stick? I mean, are supposed to conclude that, uh, we need a meaningful bond rally in order for gold to start the next bull phase, right? Like, uh, what's your thought on this chart and, uh, how do you think this will play out?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as Charlie described in this interview and as Keith McCullough described a week earlier, the real correlation for gold is to real interest rates. That's interest rates adjusted for inflation. So I think the correlation that's seems so strong between gold and TLT, where TLT is not inflation adjusted, is just because we've been in a pretty consistent condition of no particular monetary inflation in the system. This correlation, which appears to be tracking so perfectly here, is going to break down and stop tracking so perfectly when inflation really starts to take off, as Keith McCullough has predicted.

Erik Townsend: But we're not seeing that But Patrick, there's one thing that I do know with absolute certainty, which is that you are going to be in Vancouver on Saturday, November 30th, and Calgary on Sunday, December 1st, doing Options Education Day for the TSX exchange. Give us a little bit of background on what topics you'll be covering and tell our listeners how they can register if they want to attend those events in person.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, I'm excited to be a part of the Options Education Day, which is being hosted on Saturday, November 30th in Vancouver and on Sunday, December 1st in Calgary. And I'm going to be speaking at the event in the morning. I have a topic talking about using options to overcome fear and emotional obstacles. And then in the afternoon, I get to tackle the topic of understanding options pricing and the Greeks to optimize your trading there.

And there I'm going to be touching on all sorts of neat things like the deltas and gammas that you heard Charlie talking about. So anyone that would like to attend, you can click the link right in the chartbook. There's also the link in the Research Roundup email, or simply visit the Montreal Exchange website, m-x.ca, to register. And look forward to meeting many of our MacroVoices listeners out there.

Erik Townsend: Thanks.

Outro and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Sounds like a blast. I wish I could make it myself. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Be sure to check out my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen published on September 7th, 2019. The link is in your Research Roundup email. Now, if you don't have a research roundup email, that means you haven't registered your free account at MacroVoices.com yet. Shame on you! You can do that very easily for free; only takes a couple of minutes. The benefit is you will receive our free research roundup email, which contains links to all of the. best free research that we could find on the internet each week, including slide deck downloads for our feature interviews here on the MacroVoices podcast. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook for Charlie's presentation and charts that we discussed in the postgame. There's also an article about why the repo markets went crazy. And why December could be even worse. And also an interesting article asking the question, will China disrupt the monetary system with a cryptocurrency? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email Send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Close and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please Register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library, and the more registered users we have. The more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants. And do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Keith McCullough — Hedgeye founder (as introduced on the show)

Intro and episode preview

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 192 was recorded on November 7th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, which happens to be my own favorite podcast when it comes to quant and rules-based investing. By popular request of our listeners, my feature interview guest this week is Hedgeye founder Keith McCullough. We'll discuss why Keith says accelerating trading inflation will be the key macro driver to pay attention to, and then we'll translate that view into some actionable trading strategies.

And be sure to stay tuned for our post-game segment after the feature interview when Patrick and I will discuss Ray Dalio's recent article, The World Has Gone Mad and the System Is Broken. There's a link to that article in your Research Roundup email. We've also got a post-game chart book where we'll review all of the S&P sectors, talk about which sectors are hot and which are not.

Market wrap: S&P 500 melt-up and narrative failure

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's get to this S&P 500. It's just not quitting. I mean, we almost tapped 3,100 today on the S&P. What's your thinking on the markets?

Erik Townsend: Well, clearly the melt-up is on, and it's no surprise at all to me. Needless to say, if this keeps going, the ratio call spread advocated by Tian Yang a couple weeks ago on this program is going to start paying off in spades. And I really think that's the way to play this market. Now, the ratio call spread is just one specific strategy, but, you know, I think what's happening What's interesting here is there is a backdrop of really bad fundamentals and lots of reasons that if the old normal where economic fundamentals still drove the stock market was, you know, what was driving this, it would be time to go short, if anything. It's definitely not time to go short. It's time to recognize that a melt-up is on us. I think it's being driven by a couple of things. One is that it's clear that the Fed has the market's back. More easy money policy from the Fed means more money is available to finance corporate Buybacks, companies buying back their own stock, that drives the market higher.

And to be sure, I think the trade talks are playing into this, but I think probably the main thing that's going on here, Patrick, is what I call narrative failure. Everybody had convinced themselves, okay, Q4 of '19 is gonna be just like Q4 of '18. It's gonna be a repeat of that great big dramatic sell-off that starts in October and lasts through the end of the year. Oh boy, brace yourself. Well, a whole bunch of people were positioned for that. Some of them were short.

Patrick Ceresna: Mm-hmm.

Erik Townsend: They're covering. Some of them just scaled back on their long allocations. They're into fear of missing out mode and they're piling back in. So that's what I think is driving this exuberance that we're seeing. How much longer it lasts, I'm not sure. You know, Patrick, we got to get Charlie McElligott back on the program soon. He's been writing about some of these bullish scenarios recently. And again, it's not a story of economic fundamentals.

It's about the reasons that positioning in the market, people big institutional players being where they are, there's a lot of reasons that Charlie thinks there are setups to take the market even higher. So let's try to get Charlie back on the show as soon as we can.

Market wrap: the US dollar squeeze

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's move on to the US Dollar Index, which actually has been more or less recovering since last week. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Back above 98 on the December futures contract puts me back into my comfort zone that this is going to play out the way I expected. You remember what I've said in past weeks is, hey, the big pullback that we had was completely called for. And should have been expected given the news flow. The Fed basically announced QE4 and then told us it wasn't really QE4, but in many ways it was. They're certainly conjuring money out of thin air to supply liquidity to the market. They're just doing it at the other end of the curve at the moment. So I think the squeeze is back on. That's played out. And I think that the dollar bearish factors have probably run their course. The dollar squeeze effect that Jeff Snider has spoken so much about here on MacroVoices.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: is now taking grip, and I think it's probably going to take us back up to new highs. I'll say, though, that my conviction about the new highs part of that is starting to weaken.

There's quite a few smart people that I talk to that really think that October high was going to be the top for this cycle. I'm not quite there yet, but I'm opening my mind to that possibility. If you want to hear that bearish argument that says the top is in, it's all downhill from here for the dollar, stay tuned. Keith McCullough is going to have exactly that argument in today's feature interview.

Market wrap: crude oil's persistent bid

Patrick Ceresna: All right, so now, Erik, we discussed crude oil last week and the chart looked awful and we thought crude oil, there was at least vulnerability for it to head down to retest $50, but it seems to have reversed course Friday morning after last week's show. What happened?

Erik Townsend: Well, that's really the operative question. What did happen that caused so much of a bullish impulse to come into the crude oil market starting right after our last show on Friday morning? Now, the press is attributing this to China trade talks and then And also later in the week, we had Iran-sourced OPEC rumors saying, you know, maybe they'll extend the cuts even longer or do deeper cuts or whatever. Frankly, I don't buy it. We've heard those things before. The chart was really looking awful when we spoke last week. It didn't explain the amount of exuberance that we saw just slicing through all those moving averages, all of what should have been resistance levels, intermediate little resistance levels on the way up. Just really, really strong tape action. So there was really strong tape action Friday and then Monday of this week, even as the trade talk news changed, which kind of took away that explanation. And even with that change where the trade talk news had turned negative on Monday, it kept trading higher.

Then on Tuesday, API inventory came out and it seemed like that was sure to kill it because API suggested that there would be a build on crude oil inventory double analysts' expectations. It would still be a net drawdown after products, but still a really big crude oil build, double analyst expectations. Even in the wake of that bearish news, we still broke— you know, we came down on that news when it came out at 4:30 on Tuesday, but Wednesday morning, before we even got to the EIA data release, we broke through the 200-day moving average. That's a major, major result. Resistance level to the upside before we even got the news. Then the news came out from EIA. It wasn't double the analyst expectations, it was 4 times analyst expectations. Huge, huge crude oil build that resumes a string of 6 or 7 weeks of builds with only one down week in that stretch.

Cushing, Oklahoma, really just blowing my mind. Building 1.7 million barrels. Now that's a big build in any week, but this is a week when the Keystone Pipeline went offline and we lost at least 1.5 million barrels to the fact that during this reporting period there was 2.5 days of the Keystone Pipeline being offline. So that would be like 3 million barrels if you adjusted it for the Keystone outage. Gasoline drawing down 2.8 million barrels and distillates drawing down 0.6 million barrels. So crude oil, much, much bigger build. Net build much, much bigger than the than it was offset by drawdowns in finished products. Meanwhile, U.S. production maintaining that record level of 12.6 million barrels per day of domestic production. That is an all-time record set several weeks ago, which has been sustained for several weeks. Imports 6.1 million barrels. Exports ticking down to 2.3 million barrels.

Wow! You talk about really just incredibly. Bearish inventory news, of course there's an instantaneous drop in the market. Well, you know what, 5 minutes later we had retraced right up to the same level that the market was trading at before that horribly bearish news came out, as if there's just a really persistent bid in this market that's bigger than the short-term trading events that normally drive the market day to day.

So we had all of these things happening. Finally, on top of really, really bearish inventory numbers, we got news that OPEC, according to Bloomberg, was not really considering deeper cuts. In fact, most OPEC countries are not inclined to extend cuts. Then after that, we also got more news about the trade deal with China not looking so good after all. It was only after all that news came out that finally we started to see some serious downward price action, and even then it only got down to its 5-day moving average before it started to rebound again. After So after all of that horribly bearish news yesterday, by this morning, Patrick, we're back up retesting the 200-day moving average. Now, at the end of the day today, just before the close, the tape reversed. It was straight down. We took out the 200-day moving average, which is a key resistance level to the downside. We closed nicely below that.

And meanwhile, RBOB gasoline, which is oftentimes an early tell of where the crude oil market is headed, which was holding on to its 8-day moving average all day today, suddenly lost it just before the close, got almost down to the 13-day moving average by the time we hit the close. So as of the close, Patrick, we're rejecting and vigorously rejecting that key resistance level. That seems to suggest, okay, it's over, we're headed down from here. But we've had that exact same signal for the last 4 days in a row, rejecting the 200-day moving average to the downside. Looks like it's all over, feels like it's all over. And then the next morning we're up to new highs again. So I won't be at all surprised if this continues.

So what the heck is driving it? I think what's going on here is longer time horizon buyers are coming into this market. It's not the people that are trading crude oil day to day based on these little signals like what's this week's inventory number. It's people like Hedgeye's institutional client base which are hearing the same message that you're going to hear from Keith McCullough today. Which is on a much longer trading horizon. Keith really thinks that we're out of what they call Quad Four. We'll explain that in the feature interview. Moving into a period of increasing inflation, Keith really thinks that we're coming into a secular move up in energy prices. So we'll save the bulk of that for the feature interview. But the gist of it is, it seems to me like there's suddenly a very strong bullish impulse. I'm not sure where it's coming from, but I think it's longer timeframe Traders that are coming into this market.

Keystone outage and the WTI time spreads trade

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, though, this afternoon you tweeted a thread about a trading opportunity for sophisticated investors who have the ability to put on or trade time spreads on the futures markets. What's going on? What did you see, and what's the ripe opportunity you're talking about?

Erik Townsend: Well, this is the best opportunity that I have seen in the market, Patrick, since the Abqaiq dislocation that we had. Specifically, I think a lot of our listeners know that primarily my own trading is time spreads, not the outright price of oil, but the difference in price from one month to the next. And this pipeline spill on the Keystone Pipeline directly affects those time spreads, therefore it's right up my alley. Now, exactly as I predicted on this show last week, everybody was saying, okay, the pipeline's gonna be back on in 7 to 10 days because that's how long it took to fix it last time back in November of '17 when it went offline. I don't think that's right, and I'll come back to that in a minute. But in any case, the time spreads, Patrick, have been moving dramatically higher ever since that event, and that's to be expected. It's exactly the same thing that we saw in the November 17th situation.

The reason for that is that time spreads, especially near the front of the curve, reflect storage demand. And if you've got less oil coming into Cushing— Keystone Pipeline is upwards of 4 million barrels per week that it delivers into Cushing, 590,000 barrels per day. That goes offline. If it stays offline for a long time, it dramatically reduces the demand for storage because there's no oil that needs to be stored. It didn't come in from the pipeline. So the big question is how long it's going to be offline. The longer it stays offline, the more it puts upward price pressure on those time spreads. Now, in the November of 2017 spill, Time spreads peaked 8 days after the event. So if you figured all things being equal, right now, about 8 days after the event, ought to be the ideal time to fade that move and short the most directly affected time spreads.

Now the thing is, all things are not equal. I think most of the market doesn't get it yet. They're assuming that the time to return the pipeline to full service is going to be the same as last time. I think it's going to be longer than last time.

In any event, the most directly affected time spreads are already a very ripe short. It's February through July of 2020 WTI time spreads. So that trade is short CLG, Charlie Lima Golf 20, and long Charlie Lima November 20. Anything above $2.15 is a ripe short. It actually hit $2.41 today, which was a terrific entry price. Now, Now, if it was the same circumstances as last time, I'd say, okay, this was the top, it can't go any higher, you know, you want to pile into this short because it's going straight down from here. I don't think that's the case. I think there's probably one more wave of the market realizing, hey, this is going to take longer to fix this thing than it took last time. And I wouldn't be surprised if there's one more wave that pushes those spreads maybe even up above 50 cents a month so that you're looking at $2.50 maybe, if we're really lucky, on this 5-month spread.

Full disclosure, I'm short several hundred contracts, so I do have skin in this game. But I think that there's plenty of room for these spreads to move higher on news, but there's no way it's going to last until that first contract expires in the middle of February. So I think it's a terrific trading opportunity. Unfortunately, it only works for traders who are sophisticated enough to trade futures spreads, which is not for everybody.

Market wrap: gold breakdown and scaling in

Patrick Ceresna: All right, so let's move on to gold because gold had a pretty significant breakdown this week. I mean, it looked like just earlier last week that it was going to attempt to break out, and suddenly we're breaking to multi-month lows, at least on an intraday basis. We printed below the October low. What's your thinking on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, as a listener on Twitter said after last week's show, he said, okay, we finally got the major bearish signal. Townsend capitulated and started scaling into a long position. That means the market's about to crash. And as much as it sort of sounded like an insult, I really enjoyed that tweet. I was sort of toasting that guy saying, yep, exactly what I was thinking when I, when I started scaling in. I said, if there's anything that'll make this market finally go down, it's me buying. And sure enough, that started to happen. I think we still have More to go to the downside. I still think $1,400 is probably coming, but you know what, I'm gonna continue to scale in each time we get a day like today. After we're finished recording here, I may go and buy some more gold because although we are bouncing off of that October low, you know, I think we're going lower, but I've been wrong about that in the past, so I'm gonna continue scaling in.

I definitely want to save some dry powder though because I think it's quite likely that we'll get down to low $1,400s if not below 1,400.

Market wrap: 10-year Treasury yield

Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to that 10-year Treasury yield, which, uh, we had a pretty significant pop in yields today. I mean, we, we came a stone's throw on an intraday basis toward 2%. I mean, what's going on here?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, clearly a more substantial backup in rates is now upon us, and it's tempting, I suppose, to say, okay, the trend has reversed, you know, it's time to short the bond market. I don't think so. I'm glad that I already closed my long position But I'm definitely not going to go short here. If you look at how far we moved, so far, so fast, as yields collapsed over the last year, we're long overdue for a significant pullback. And if you look at how far we moved, just a 38% or a 50% Fib retracement takes you way the heck above 2% in yields. So I think that long-term, the secular trend toward lower yields is probably still intact, but I'm not sure that it's time to be long here. I think it's maybe time to get out of the way. Yeah. and wait for a better entry opportunity.

Why Keith McCullough, and why now

Patrick Ceresna: So this week's featured interview guest is Hedgeye founder Keith McCullough. Now, why did we invite Keith back onto the show this week, Erik?

Erik Townsend: Well, 2 questions embedded there. First, why Keith? And second, why right now? First answer, why Keith? Keith is one of the most popular guests that we've ever had on the show. We frequently get emails from listeners requesting that we get him back on the program. We can also always count on the Hedgeye guys for a really solid slide deck. We've got a terrific slide deck for you this week, so be sure to download that, guys. We're going to make extensive references to it throughout this interview.

The second part of the question, why this week? Frankly, you know, we let all of our guests sell whatever they're selling at the end of the interview. I try to give everybody a chance to tell our listeners what product or service their company has on offer. Hedgeye, as a matter of very firm policy, only really goes deep discount on their subscription products once a year, and that's Thanksgiving Cyber Monday special, which they're running right now. So my policy has always been, as much as we love Keith, if we're going to have Keith on the show, I know he's going to be promoting Hedgeye products. I want to do that at a time when we can get our listeners the very best price of the entire year. And thanks to your work, Patrick, although it's already time for Hedgeye to have their prices at the lowest they ever put them all year, we got an even deeper discount, which is just for our MacroVoices listeners.

The slide deck that you're going to download has all of those links to the discount codes that you need in order to get that very best pricing. So the reason we waited for now, even though we had quite a few requests to get Keith on the show, is I like to have Keith on when he's got his stuff on sale.

Erik Townsend: And this episode of MacroVoices is made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Now, I did a full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, the host of this excellent podcast, back on September 7th, 2019. The download link is in your Research Roundup email next to Niels' picture. In that interview, we discussed a number of key issues about the value of having a rules-based investment strategy in your portfolio. In our conversation, Niels shared some insights that may surprise you, especially when it comes to how trend following strategies don't really operate the way some market commentators suggest they do. For more information, including a free book about trend following and the accredited investor slide deck from my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, go to toptradersunplugged.com/macroslides.

Check them out. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Keith McCullough is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Hedgeye's process and the four quads

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Keith McCullough, founder of Hedgeye Risk Management and one of the most popular guests that we've had on the show. Keith, it's great to Great to have you back. Now, our regular listeners already know that the guys at Hedgeye can be counted on for some of the best slide decks in the business. So listeners, I strongly encourage you to download the slide deck which accompanies today's interview. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Keith's picture.

Keith McCullough: Great.

Erik Townsend: on the homepage.

Keith, the first dozen slides or so in the slide deck talk about the process that you use at Hedgeye, and I can't emphasize strongly enough the importance of process and having a process. But since we've covered this whole process before, I'm going to refer our listeners to several of the previous interviews that we've done with Keith. If you haven't heard those interviews, I do encourage you to learn all about the process that Hedgeye Risk Management uses. It's It's one of the best in the business. Just type in Keith's name on the search box at MacroVoices.com. Go back to his first interview where we went into this in detail. Keith, I want to skip ahead and just do a quick review of your process, at least the essential process concepts from slides 4 and 5 before we move on to the rest of the deck, because I'm really looking forward to going deep on your recommendations for this quarter.

Slide 4, you talk about the second derivative. And the slope and why that's so important. Please give us a refresher course starting on page 4.

Keith McCullough: Sure. And thanks, Erik, for the kind compliments. Process, if I didn't have one, I probably shouldn't be on MacroVoices. So, I appreciate that. We focus on the rate of change or the second derivative move on both growth, GDP growth, and headline inflation. The reason why we do that is, of course, because it backtests as being the most causal factors for your asset allocation at the macro level, which would fully include sectors, long and short, and your factor exposures. So on slide 4, we're just showing you what the prevailing consensus wisdom is, which is not that people focus or anchor on valuation as a starting point. This time is different, economic gobbledygook theory, etc. But again, I'm just trying to figure out where the next and most probable dot is, if you will, for growth and inflation within the confines of that sine curve. So that's on slide 4. And then on slide 5, we wrap that into What is effectively a 2x2 model.

So you have 2 things, you have growth and you have inflation, and both are being measured and mapped on a trending basis, which means 3 months or more, all the economic data. We run that 30 data points per month, which would give you 90 times per quarter to change your view based on a data-dependent view. So there's no politics to it, of course. And again, there's no valuation bend to it. Quad 1, 2, 3, and 4 is what you see there. Quad 1 and 2 are pro-growth. So that's when everything is great, rainbows and puppy dogs from a growth perspective. Quad 2 is, of course, when you have both growth and inflation accelerating at the same time, and even the Federal Reserve figures it out, and they have a central tendency to raise interest rates. That's why in Quad 2, Treasury bonds, for example, across the curve are a terrible place to be, and so is gold.

Conversely, Quad 4 is the best place to be for long-term Treasury bonds and for gold because you have both the rate of change of growth and inflation. slowing. At the same time, when the Fed figures that out, they try to cut interest rates, devalue the dollar, and drive you— essentially, they'd like to have you back in Quad 1 or 2, but they have a central tendency to take you to Quad 3, which is— you could just name that stagflation, where you have the rate of change of inflation accelerating as real growth declines, which is where I think the US economy is right now.

Exiting Quad 4: long inflation, TIPS and energy; short staples

Erik Townsend: Okay, so you're characterizing the current condition of the economy into one of these 4 quads at any moment in time. And again, And listeners, if these concepts are new to you, I highly encourage you to listen to Keith's first interview where we really go into details about this process. Let's skip ahead now though to slide 13, which is where we get into the current condition. You're saying we're coming out of Quad Four and maybe into Quad Two or Quad Three. Tell us what's going on here.

What— why is that the case and what does that mean in terms of asset allocation?

Keith McCullough: Well, the biggest thing that it means is that what already happened for the last year, Erik, is in the rearview mirror. Now, Quad Four, as I pointed out, loves Treasuries across the curve. It loves anything that looks like a Treasury, which would include utilities, REITs, bond proxies, gold, silver, housing. It loves Quad Four. So again, we started making the Quad Four call last year in September, September 27th, 2018. You'd make that call when the US economic cycle is officially at the peak, then you slow from the peak, and then you just continue to slow.

Okay. So the end of Quad 4 was comparing against the 2018 US economic cycle peak because we had Quad 4 in Q3 of 2019. So that's, um, that was the end of Quad 4. The market's been trying to price that in. That's sensibly the next move is into Quad 2 or Quad 3 is what we're saying. It's, uh, the data stacking up much more so in line with Quad 3. So again, Quad 3 is stagflation, whereas Quad 2 is up, up and away. And, and I do think it's quite an interesting setup. Because historically there's no precedent to have the President of the United States, you know, trumping up and tweeting up the stock market, you know, and talking about deals and people getting excited about what could be a Quad 2, but there's no data that supports a Quad 2, which would fully include buying a lot of soybeans. So that's where we're at on that.

On slide 14, you can see how our quads are, which is again United States, our most probable outcome, deal or no deal. And again, if the deal post-deal data were to change that, we'll change our mind. I'm not in the business of you know saying what the data should do. I'm telling you what the data actually is doing. So if you look at the world's economy, what you see here is the top twenty countries by GDP. The USA is at the bottom, and it goes our our outlook is Quad Three, Quad Three, and then Quad Four, with Quad Four again coming back in the middle of 2020 ahead of the U.S. election, which would be a pretty nasty. setup for, for the stock market if you were to take it from the all-time high, which is of course at the time of us having this conversation. So I think it's a pretty, pretty interesting setup, suffice to say. I don't really care, um, what quad it is.

I'm long the things that work in both Quad 2 and Quad 3, which again, the data is tracking in Quad 3, both in China and in the US, which matter more than anything else.

So what I'm going to be long is inflation. So that is what's similar in Quad 2 and Quad 3 is that you have, no matter what, you have inflation going up for the the first time in a year instead of down. So there's a lot of different things that we can do in terms of asset allocation on that. The biggest pivot when you look at it in terms of fixed income is to get long TIPS. If you look at it in terms of equities, the biggest pivot from being short in Quad Four to long in Quad Three is energy, energy stocks. Energy, of course, is hated and under-owned on a historical measure, I might add. And then on the short side, what you do at the US equity sector Another style level is you get out of what was a great long during Quad Four, which is a bond proxy sector called consumer staples, and you short that.

So consumer staples in Quad Three is a good example really, Erik, of stagflation because you have input costs rising. Stagflation is when you have inflation rising, both labor in this case and the input costs. You know, we're bullish on commodities in Quad Three, just to reiterate that, but you don't have any pricing power. So you got these companies that are older than dirt in some cases that have not really had pricing power for a long time.

And then all of a sudden their costs start going up, so their margins compress and the stocks go down. So that's one simple way, I think, to read through how Quad 3 can play into a sector and a company.

Gold as an inflation hedge depends on the quad

Erik Townsend: Now, I want to address specifically, you said inflation accelerating is one of the key trends you've got on slide 13, and you just said a moment ago that's what you want to be long is things that do well when inflation is accelerating. Some people would say, okay, number one rule of macro is gold is your inflation hedge. So, if you think inflation's coming, it has to mean that you're stepping up your allocation to gold. I'm not sure that you guys see it that way. Please give us the perspective on how gold plays into this story.

Keith McCullough: That's a real important question that took— it still takes me— I mean, every year is a new year trying to learn something that I don't know. And what I didn't know when I was a younger man was that what you just said is not true if indeed the economy is in Quad Two.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Keith McCullough: So Quad 2, you have inflation rising, but you have real growth rising. Gold hates that because real yields are rising. So gold, what it really likes is when real yields, as you know, are falling. Now that can happen with inflation or without it. That's why gold works, you know, in Quad 4 and Quad 3. So again, when you look at it in Quad 3, that's when you have stagflation and real yields are still falling. So I think, you know, when you think about gold as an inflation hedge, it's especially a good inflation hedge when you have a stagflating economy and the lack of alternatives. Alternatives to invest in. So that's, again, you can go back historically and see that there have been many times, notwithstanding one of the most epic Quad Threes that has ever happened in the US economy. And again, these quads aren't subject to debate. They're just economic facts. It just characterizes what the economy was doing.

And if you go back to 2011, when gold hit an all-time high, I mean, you didn't have Quad Four, you had Quad Three. And that's when you had plenty of things that people would believe, oh, wow, Look, you know, Bernanke is devaluing the dollar to a 40-year low. I got inflation ripping to new highs. That's when the CRB index, which is a broad base of commodities, 19 different commodities, was hitting new all-time highs. So, of course, you had inflation, and, of course, he wasn't admitting it. But you, of course, also had gold work in that environment, too.

China's slowdown, the trade deal and the Fed

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 15, we're getting into China. Now, it seems like almost everybody, at least the mainstream media, our friends on the cable networks are talking about how, hey, as soon as a deal with China, a trade deal comes through with China, that's just the game changer. Everything is unicorns and roses from there. Is that the right way to think about this? And I know that you have the utmost respect and esteem for our friends on the cable networks, but do you see it maybe a little bit differently?

Keith McCullough: Yeah, I mean, that's a joke. I mean, it's like, you know, you wouldn't be on MacroVoices if you're a macro tourist like that. I mean, that's what macro tourism is. I mean, to define it, it's when people jump from headline to headline Because they don't know what else to do, as opposed to jumping from time series to time series. And that's what a good rate of change person does, is that they don't care what anybody on CNBC says or otherwise. Some of these other ones, I'm surprised people even watch. But the reality is that what we're trying to watch is what the data is doing within the lens of the process.

So, on slide 15, you can take 2 different views of China, i.e., it's bottomed, which is on the left side of that chart, or on the right side of that chart, If you use a 3-year comp or a 3-year base effect, or simplify that, a 3-year lookback on what actually happened in the world, you'd say, oh no, it's gonna continue to slow at a faster rate as we're signing phase 1 of the deal and doing the curtains and everything and celebrating the all-time highs in the stock market. And it's gonna slow and slow and slow for the next 3 quarters post the deal. So again, the reason why we're using a 3-year lookback on that chart, Erik, which you know, but just to explain it, I mean, Yeah.

What it's showing is secondary industries in China. So that's heavy construction, partly empty cities, all the stuff that China stimulated back in 2016, and for that matter, which they stimulated in 2009. These are the, you know, the 64 million empty apartments and the most concrete used in human history. This is what they do, and this is what they did, but they're not doing it right now. So that's the point. You know, the biggest stimulus in the history of China, and I think everybody on this call, because they're macro aware, knows that there's a long history in China. But if you look at slide, you know, do you talk He took that from 0% growth in 2015, late 2015, 2016, when Xi was about to get elected for life, and he ripped it to 14% growth, which equated to 50, 5-0%, of Chinese GDP growth.

And now, as the base effects of that stimulus continue to heighten, incoming data continues to slow at a faster pace. And even the Chinese who are making up their numbers are admitting that. That's why they continue to cut their numbers and are actually willing to try to do some kind of a deal, 'cause they think that they need it. But it's not gonna change that this is a secular picture. And I can't use that word more often. You know, it's— and I'm not talking about secular growers, which everybody on the planet Earth that's long tech continues to talk about, but I'm talking about secular slower.

You know, China is a secular slower. And that's the point here is that we're well past their peak. They've stimulated multiple times to have the world believe that that wasn't a secular peak. And from here, I mean, I actually think China, if the data continues to look as bad as it does on their own made-up numbers, it looks like Japan in the 1990s.

And it's going to be— you're going to have to have a hell of a lot more tweets and bean deals to eliminate the economic gravity associated with that.

Erik Townsend: Now, if we go 5 years back even, there were lots of people predicting, okay, China's, you know, just at this unrealistic artificial level, they're going to start going into decline, it's going to send a deflationary shock around the world. Half of that came true. I mean, they really are in significant decline, as your charts are showing here on slide But we haven't seen a contagion to where China blows up the global economy. Is there still a risk of that? Was that just a crazy idea in the first place? How do we think now about what could happen in China and what it's going to mean to the rest of the world?

Keith McCullough: Well, that's a real important question. And at every stage and at every point in the next cycle, again, these are cyclical factors that run into new realities. So, you know, the new reality here is that the dollar's at a 20-year high. And that the Chinese, you know, like, if you just look at that, actually, on the next couple slides, slide 16 in particular reminds you that, you know, this isn't like 2016, by the way. You weren't at a 20-year high on the trade-weighted dollar index, and the Chinese themselves weren't all that willing to devalue the currency.

So again, they're short of dollars is the other point. So again, if you think about that in terms of slide 17, we just remind you of why they're the world's largest borrower of US dollar-denominated debt. Well, unlike in prior cycles when China was running a big surplus, current account surplus, now they have a developing current account deficit. And the only way they can fund their deficit is in dollars. So if the Fed doesn't get off the schneid and cut interest rates more aggressively, I think the way you ask the question is important because to me the answer is, you know, how do things blow up? It's if the Fed does doesn't get the dollar down, then you're not gonna be able to get away from these realities that are, A, new, and B, making the transmission mechanism for Chinese liquidity, quote unquote, to not be impaired.

On the right side of slide 17, you can see that it literally is impaired. You've basically cut the reserve requirement ratio, or interest rates in China, 6 times since they started slowing again in 2018, and it hasn't done anything for Chinese demand. In fact, it's actually, we're on the lows in terms of even shadow financing demand for loans fully loaded.

So, so that's the problem is, is if the Fed, and that's really the final point on, on, on, and I'm not, you know, I'm not the guy that tries to get famous writing a book on how the world blows up on what day of what month, Erik. I mean, that's, I think that's a little ridiculous. If you get that right, then cool. But that's not what I do. Uh, what I would just submit is on slide 18, if the market's right on what the Fed should be doing, which is devaluing the dollar, and that's what I'm showing you here, in order for Beijing to bail us out, the Fed has to capitulate and cut rates more aggressively.

If the Fed doesn't do that, then this thing, it can— there's going to be a nonlinear pattern to the downside that most people aren't prepared for. So again, this has actually never happened before. For those of you that follow the Fed's dot plot, which is accurate about 30% of the time at best, again, it's showing you the Fed's forecast versus what Fed fund futures are implying.

And it's at its widest deviation or divergence, however you want to characterize it, going all the way back to when the dot plot was invented. You know, by the Federal Reserve, or at least published.

So again, what this is saying is that if you think that the China bean deal and that the Fed are going to be right post the deal, that everything's going to be back to rainbows and puppy dogs, well, that's completely offsides with what you know the market's expecting in terms of interest rate cuts, and more importantly, like I said, what the market needs and global economy needs, which is a weakening of the U.S. dollar, which you can only have if the Fed indeed goes incrementally more dovish from here.

The dollar top and the Hedgeye Risk Range

Erik Townsend: Now, I've been following your daily updates on the dollar, and obviously, as you know and as our listeners know, the dollar hit an all-time high on some indices. On the dollar index, it's not an all-time high, but it's still certainly a cycle high back on October 1st. But ever since these announcements from the Fed, it's been selling off. We've reached the point where at least your short-term support levels, the Hedgeye bottom of the, of the trading range, has kicked in. Does that mean that we're going to see a reversal here, or is this going to be maybe a dead cat bounce before we break through those levels and see a new trend emerge?

Keith McCullough: Yeah, I think the peak— like, our call on the dollar was crystal clear. I mean, I couldn't make it more clear. When we're in Quad Four, when both the global and US economy are in Quad Four, the dollar goes up. You know, that's it, period. And that was our call going back to when China, EM, and Europe for that matter all started slowing at the beginning of 2018. It was pretty easy to see that the dollar The dollar liked that in lieu of other people's currencies and problems. And then the dollar really liked the fact that the Fed had to go from hawkish to dovish at the end of 2018 and early 2019. So that's it. If you can't show me, which by the way, so I do think it's a 6-month call, short call, or get out of the dollar long position and think of the other side of it, which is, we can get into that too, which is I think just buy commodities.

That's the easiest way to go right to the asset allocation vein. But again, until we get back into the market discounting that we're going to reenter Quad Four, i.e., when both growth and inflation are slowing at the same time, which we have happening again in the middle of next year, then I think that the dollar starts to break down. I mean, that's basically what you're pointing out on the Hedgeye Risk Range is that when the risk range starts to develop a series of lower highs and lower lows, the trend eventually breaks to the downside. And that's what— I'm not willing to believe that just market signal that I've been betting.

When I look at a market, I look at where are my quads? Where's the most probable outcome? Economically, A, and B, what's the market signal? Is it, is it agreeing or disagreeing with that? The market signal is agreeing with what my quads see. And again, in Quad 3, the dollar is not a long, it's a short.

Erik Townsend: Okay, so the October 1st top, you think that has a good chance of being the top, at least for a while?

Keith McCullough: Yeah, for at least 6 months, because again, it would fit right on the screws when Quad 4 in Q3 of 2019 ended. So again, I'm using these words specifically because mathematically that's just a fact. I mean, you had, you know, Quad Four in Q3, you know, and obviously at the end of September, and lo and behold, the damn dollar just stopped going up right at that point in early October.

FOMO, the melt-up debate and earnings divergence

Erik Townsend: Got it. Let's come back to slide 19 in the deck where you're saying that equities are a 2019 fear of missing out story. What's going on here?

Keith McCullough: Thanks for spelling it out too. I mean, I'm, I'm, I am, inasmuch as some people are compensated to be addicted to the FOMO, I think people need to understand the link. They are gainfully employed to buy stocks. You know, like, uh, FOMO to me is like, I have, I have my own personal FOMO on not using the FOMO because it's just like such a great narrative that only Wall Street could be addicted to.

But just remember that the story this year is that you have to be willing to believe. Believe me, in the words of your favorite president, you gotta believe. You just gotta believe that earnings have bottomed, even though nobody on Wall Street a year ago said that the earnings have topped other than us and maybe some others. Maybe you said it too, but you You know, that you have to believe, even though you couldn't believe that you were gonna slow from the cycle peak of earnings to now negative year-over-year earnings, that you just gotta buy stocks. You know, that you just gotta buy. Even though historically, when this has happened and we're at the widest divergence, and again, I pay a lot of attention to divergences that have a central tendency to mean revert or come back to where they've always been. You have, you know, the difference between the level of the S&P 500 and the earnings revisions to the downside hasn't been this wide going all the way back to, and I'm showing you, you know, what the forward PE implied Right now on slide 19, relative to where we started the year, going all the way back to 2000 to 2001, which is not a good reference point to buy stocks.

That's just not smart. I mean, so I think that even though, even again, if you go back to October of '07, obviously the stock market, what could possibly go wrong? It went up almost every day and then finally stopped going up in early November.

So it is an interesting thing. On slide 20 though, like you can see this, I mean, the global GDP trend is obviously down into the bottom right. That's why bond yields globally did what they did this year. And at the same time, on the right side, which is this like Wally World chart, I think it's crazy. I mean, I guess being a macro person, you're always gonna see crazy, but you don't wanna be crazy. Like, you don't wanna be the person buying this. The next 12 months of earnings expected in the S&P versus the Russell, like, look at that. You could drive a truck through that. That's the widest it's ever been. So the way I read that chart is that the Russell earnings don't hope for any bean deal or any big China resolution, 'cause it's more local. And the S&P 500, You're just waiting for companies to tell you the truth, which by the way, and systematically has started to happen.

So you're seeing an earnings season now, earnings are down about 2 to 3% year over year, which is the worst it's been.

And it's a broadening. So you're seeing it broaden to negative 6% year over year in tech, consumer discretionary, which is the other big sector people are long, have now have negative earnings and falling. You have to believe that that's a bottom that you never called slowing to begin with. And then an acceleration. Which is, I think that's like the stuff of madness personally, but that's how I look at it. I think that it could only be summarized with the acronym FOMO. I mean, how could you not just chase year-end benchmarks? Because that's what you get paid to do. So, it's interesting because that's obviously always been Wall Street's problem, is that they'll take living in the fear of God of that index return, and they will be willing to believe pretty much anything.

Erik Townsend: Keith, I couldn't possibly agree with you more. And if I look ahead to slide 21, you can see CapEx is already on the decline. These slides are all painting a really, really strong picture of, hey guys, you know, the party's ending. It's not time to be, to be piling into stocks expecting the next big move up. But I want to play devil's advocate for a minute because I've become pretty cynical about this market. What if I were to say, look, we're living in a kind of screwed up reality of central bank control now?

Keith McCullough: Right.

Erik Townsend: Now that we didn't used to have. And so if I look at all this, what I see is bad economic data. That means, as you've said, the Fed is going to need to continue cutting. That's going to enable more easy money financing for corporate buybacks. That's going to allow the S&P to melt up even more, as crazy as it might seem to you and me.

Therefore, maybe fear of missing out is not the right rationale.

Keith McCullough: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: But there's certainly— I don't want to be jumping into the short side of this market right here. I'm afraid that we could see a melt-up just based on easy money driving more corporate buybacks.

Keith McCullough: Yeah, we are. We already— I mean, to characterize what's happening today or throughout October, early November as a non-melt-up, I think would be a mischaracterization. We are seeing a melt-up. I mean, there's a melt-up across the board and people chasing, like I said, You're willing to pay a higher and higher multiple for less and less earnings.

And that is, I think you're in it. I mean, I think that if you also kind of take a step back, I always look at what the market's done going backwards, because there've been multiple periods of FOMO where within 5 to 6 weeks, people are on their knees kind of crawling on the linoleum floor begging for more cowbell. And by the way, buying every one of those non-stressful dips was the thing to do. And so I think I agree with you on that as well, because again, at the end of April, at the end of July, right now, I mean, if you get sucked in at the wrong spot, you can have a 6% to 8% drawdown in a very short period of time. And then who really is willing to buy at that level? So for me, I resolve this by basically buying what I like anyway at the low end of the range.

I mean, the current part of the melt-up, by the way, has been driven by a sector that I'm long and most people won't touch with an 80,000-foot pole, which is energy. So I think it's more about being long, and that's essentially the genesis of the Hedgeye process. Relax. Stop being so stressed about CNBC marketing of the Dow Bro and SPYs.

You can be smarter than that. For the last year, you could have owned something that outperformed SPYs by almost 2,000 basis points in REITs and utilities. So again, we're trying to find the thing that we can own within the thing. So again, the sectors of the S&P 500 that we want to be long and not live in daily stress of trying to beat the S&P 500's benchmark gain or loss for that matter. Don't forget that the S&P lost 20% of its value over a 3-month period at this time last year. Not that anybody remembers, but it certainly— you'd be reminded of that if it happened to your own capital.

Erik Townsend: Now you guys are obviously data junkies. I think that we agree that what's going on right now is there are already clear, clear macroeconomic signs that say stock prices should be lower. That's not happening because we are seeing a melt-up for the reasons that I've described, having to do with easy money enabling buybacks and so forth. Is there some indicator? Is there some magic Hedgeye chart that says, okay, here's the signal to watch for that tells you that gravity is about to set in and reality is going to take over instead of this melt-up on easy money mentality that we've been in? Or is that unpredictable?

Keith McCullough: I mean, unless again, unless it's different this time, which, you know, as we alluded to at the beginning of the That's not what I do. You know, you get somebody who's got a much bigger brain than me to come up with all these different theories on how it's different this time. I'm a student of cycles, and never in the history of cycles have earnings deteriorated from peak cycle to slowing to negative, then more and more negative on a year-over-year basis, and you not seen a commensurate decline and multiple compression in stocks and/or a widening of credit spreads. Credit spreads. So that's it. We're literally right at the end of the thing. I mean, most credit investors will say, okay, that's fine. Look at credit. Credit, the all-time tights were in early '18 when the global economic cycle peaked. USA continued to chug along, so there are plenty of parts of credit that did fine over the course of the next year. But the parts of credit that were linked to China and China demand falling, they widened.

And again, so you had— credit has been deteriorating underneath the hood inasmuch as the S&P 500 has been. Don't forget the Russell 2000 is still down 8%, 9% from where it peaked. in 2018. And plenty of sectors have been horrendous places to be relative to the alternatives. So again, I just think that it's actually still happening with the boogeyman being the thing that macro tourists stare at, which is the headline Dow in points, saying, oh, it's all clear. And look at the amount of new highs in either the S&P or the Dow for that matter, relative to the Dow and the S&P 500 making new all-time highs on their own. It's at a very wide divergence, which is also pretty consistent with, by the way, a market top and people capitulating saying, oh my God, I can't take it anymore. Yeah.

It's never going to go down again. And then it could go down in a ball of flames. Again, that's not my call, but I'm certainly— if it does go down in a ball of flames, I'm not going to lose money like the people that don't think that it won't will.

Wages, margins and recession risk by Q2 2020

Erik Townsend: Let's come back to slide 22, where you get into labor share of income and corporate margins. Talk us through what's going on here.

Keith McCullough: Yeah. So, that's another— it's probably less of a rant of a way to just showing a picture of what I just said. I mean, and another reason why, to be clear, that We're super bullish on growth and all the stocks you should be long in quads one and two is when you have GDP growth growing faster than wage growth. So that was you know Hedgeye's call from mid 2016 until we said basically the peak of the cycle of two three of 2018. That was a long for me that's a long ride, but it's also the ride that you're on. GDP growth was greater than wage growth. Now we have GDP growth falling and falling below wage growth. So the whole point on wage growth is that it's the late. It's the latest of late-cycle indicators. So 100% of the time, again, this is not different this time, Erik. 100% of the time, wages continue to accelerate into a recession and perpetuate a profit recession and a broader recession. So basically, we're right at that point now.

And what I'm trying to say with the quads is that by Q2 of 2020, your highest recessionary risk on this basis will have— will be staring you in the face. Because again, there's no catalyst to get people's wages lower. Right. There's a reason why GM has had a successful strike, you know, the people did against the company. And the last time they had one like this was in 2007, again, at the cycle peak. That's when the people have more leverage because corporate profits are coming off their peak. So again, you know, we're going to see margin pressure. I think it's a foregone conclusion. I think Wall Street is offsides on it, on seeing a continuation of that. So if you look on slide 23, I'm just showing you the rate of change of year-over-year sales and earnings for the S&P 500.

And what the street's basically saying is that, okay, I get it. This whole China thing is— you can blame everything on China. You got to blame it all on China, nothing on the cycle, God forbid, or tax reform perpetuating the peak of the cycle in conjunction with the Chinese stimulus. Those 2 things back to back are like the most epic stimulus you could think of in historical terms. And the street's looking for a reacceleration of earnings in the first half of next year. Of course, as companies continue to guide down on the 4th quarter, so you're You're going to have basically 2 quarters going on 3 in a row of negative year-over-year earnings. And that's, again, it's pretty simple to understand. If the Fed doesn't get that dollar down and demand continues to slow, labor continues to rise against peak comps, then you will see a further and I think a faster degradation in earnings. We think that earnings could be easily down 5% to 8% year-over-year within the next, you know, either this quarter or the next quarter.

And that's, you know, that, that if it's like 2001, that's the beginning of a very nasty period for US stocks. And, and, and 100% of people that I worked with, never mind the people that were spewing old wall research to me as a young analyst in 2001, 100% of them had that wrong because they said, oh, you know, we're growth investors, we're all long tech and comms and everything else. And then lo and behold, you know, S&P earnings were actually down in the teens year over year for, for multiple quarters in a row. And that's, that's when real proverbial poop hits the fan.

Software bubble and the long-energy, short-software pair

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 24, we're coming to my former occupation, which was the software industry. What's going on here?

Keith McCullough: Well, it's peaked. I mean, I think that, that to me is, is like the call within the call, is that you have a bubble.

Erik Townsend: Well, it peaked when I got out of it in '98. Obviously, that was the secular catalyst.

Keith McCullough: But you should have come back to it, Erik. I mean, it's like, um, you know, MacroVoices as a service, you know. I mean, You could, you could have got a multiple on that, right? Like, this is crazy. It's not, it's not crazy what happened. It's actually predictable. I mean, so we have tax reform and we have the largest sales force in, in America right now, or at least the, the biggest and, and, you know, best paid is, is that that sells software as a service. You know, you know that. And that's where all the market caps have been created. And there's a bubble that was being, you know, was, was brewing. All this great technology, all these apps and everything that people love. Now we have massive sales forces. Salesforce.com is almost metaphorically the big building. It's built for that in San Francisco. To me, it's kind of like Encana at the peak of the energy market in Calgary, Alberta. But again, I digress. You basically had a catalyst at the end of what was a developing bubble, which was tax reform. So tax reform, for anyone who doesn't know, you can depreciate 100% CapEx against your net income.

So if you're like me or Erik or anybody who has their own company, you're looking for things that you can deduct, right? What can I invest in my business that can make, you know, my business better? And software becoming a capital expenditure as opposed to an operating expenditure became, you know, basically what you see there. The peak of software's growth rate was basically at this time last year. So growing like double-digit growth year over year, we're showing you software software CapEx on a year-over-year basis. And again, the whole point is that as you compare against those peak growth rates, you're going to slow anyway. So that's the point. Like, at this point, Amazon Web Services, which is basically one of the largest cloud companies in the world, has slowed 260 basis points year over year, which is a lot, but that's in line with the base effect or the comp going up about the same. So to me, it's just math.

Your software might be the greatest thing since the last time I was told that the internet was not called the cloud. And to your back in 1998, that was a great, great ride to be on. But again, you know, we've renamed a lot of different things, but we've given them similar multiples. We talk a lot about the TAM, 15 to 20 times revenue, and it's all good and fine until the companies tell you that their growth rates are slowing with rising labor forces and cost pressures. So to me, that's why we're short software, and it's been working really. I mean, it peaked obviously back in July. So even though the market's making— like, the SPYs are making all-time highs and people have to buy stocks You know, if they bought the wrong software stock, they got their ass handed to them. And that's the problem.

I mean, that's, that's, I see, I see more short selling opportunities in these secular growers that are meeting a cyclical slowdown, i.e., a secular grower, which Wall Street affectionately came up with that, is just a company that's never seen a cycle.

So I think there, there are loads of companies like that, not, not the least of which are the ones that are most famous and kind and, and dear to their hearts.

Erik Townsend: Keith, moving on to slide 25. I know you guys at Hedgeye very much embrace the long-short equity strategy, and I happen to know that just because I just released a video on how to run the long-short equity strategy, which is the original hedge fund strategy in a private investment account. And, uh, I actually mentioned Hedgeye in that video because you guys are the only ones I know of that are available to retail investors who provide both long and short equity recommendations. Talk us through the concept of what a long-short pairs trade is, and why is it that long energy, short software right now is a particular favorite that you're describing here on page 25?

Keith McCullough: Yeah, that's, that's, that's perfect. And by the way, most people aren't perfect at making short sales. So again, when you, when you think about a long-short strategy, you have to have not just somebody who has short ideas, but somebody who is accurate So the number one place you should go is thinking about the rates of change. So again, you can think about that in terms of a company, or you can think about that in terms of sectors. Now sectors, like which we're showing here on slide 25, I think it's a great pair trade just using CapEx as trends. So again, CapEx from a top-down perspective is slowing. Now software CapEx is slowing at a faster rate against bubble comparison. Okay. Whereas energy CapEx has negative comparisons, easy comparisons, because energy's been blowing up for some time now, as it should during Quad Four. So now you got energy CapEx can be down five to ten percent year over year, whereas software CapEx can slow.

In the prior slide, we show from up eleven twelve percent year over year to something in the low single digits. I mean, it already did back in 2015. You can see that. So again, now when you look at that. Because again, it's based on the same premise. You're starting with the cycle, and you're like, okay, what's what's going to accelerate? What's going to decelerate?

Then you look at the index weights. Now, as a percentage of the S&P 500, energy is on its lows. Everybody knows that. That's why you can't get a diversified portfolio manager, mutual fund manager to buy energy because they haven't had to. So again, they all own tech. They all own consumer discretionary, and most of them really owned soft.

Okay. So software, as you can see, is coming off its highest level ever as a percentage of the index, and energy is coming off its lowest level. So all I really need to have this work, Erik, is energy to go up in terms of price. So if I'm right on my inflation accelerating theme and natural gas and oil continue to make a series of higher lows and break out to the upside, then energy just has to be 5%, 6%, 7% of the index, and it has to come out of some somewhere, and I think it's going to come out of the place that has the, the most obvious slowing, which is software.

Erik Townsend: And again, just to explain this concept for any newer listeners who are not familiar with hedge fund strategies, the whole idea here is you don't know what's going to happen to the S&P. Is it going to go up 30% or is it going to go down 30%? What you want to have is a balanced portfolio of both long and short positions so that you make money if the market goes up and you still make money if the market goes down, because in that scenario your shorts outperform your longs. That is the subject, both what I think you teach, Keith, on an ongoing basis on your Macro Show on the Hedgeye Network, and it's also the subject of a video that we just released on the MacroVoices YouTube channel. It's a free video, so be sure to check that out. Let's go ahead and move on to your final slide, which is what I'm glad to hear what you guys are doing.

Hedgeye products and listener discounts

Erik Townsend: Keith, we actually waited until now to get you on the program. We've had several listener requests to get you back on, but we happen to know that your marketing guys wait till Cyber Monday right after Thanksgiving for your very best pricing of the year, and we wanted to wait to have you on when you could offer our MacroVoices listeners the very, very best deal. It's already this time of year is when Hedgeye offers their products at the lowest available prices. negotiated with Matt and Dan on your side to get an additional discount for MacroVoices listeners only. So give us the rundown between the Hedgeye Elite Pass and Platinum All Access Pass products. What are these things? Who are they for? And give us the story.

Keith McCullough: Yeah, sure. They're, they're, um, they're for everyone. What we're learning is that as we open up more of what we do in terms of the entirety of the process— and again, there's a singularity to our process, so there are a lot of components to Good risk management process. And what we're doing here is you're seeing, and it's tiered in terms of access to those components of what we do in terms of price. What we've learned is that people prefer to get a bucket. So if the, you know, the smallest bucket of course is the one where you get our quarterly macro themes, which is the Hedgeye IQ product. So again, you're going to know every 3 months what our themes are and where the big changes are coming. And then we give you ETF Pro Plus, which is basically long and shorts across the board, as Erik and I have been talking back and forth. And again, this is global macro long shorts.

So again, it includes a bunch of commodity ETFs on the long and the short side, depending on where we are in a different quarter. The Elite Pass just broadens that out. So you get the early look, the Macro Show, the daily ranges. That's for more of a power user, real-time alerts, obviously. And then the big one, which is the one that's actually, I think, the most popular, even though it's the highest price, is the Platinum All Access Pass, which basically gives you every single thing that we publish to the newsletter. non-institutional community, but it also is, is our large components of what we, we provide to our institutional clients who pay a lot more than that price, I can assure you. So that's the deal, and, um, we like to do it like you said. You figure it out when we do it because we only do it once a year.

Erik Townsend: Well, and the deal for MacroVoices listeners is actually even better than the deal that you only do once a year for everybody else. I'm going to take personal credit for a part of that story. I know you guys didn't used to offer the Macro Macro Select product as part of the packages. And I've been telling Dan Holland for a couple of years now, you know, don't underestimate the high-end retail people. We have a lot of guests on MacroVoices who assume that their boutique institutional research, they think, well, we don't sell it to retail because they would never understand it.

There's a few people that do understand what you guys do in your Macro Select, which you used— I believe you used to only do that for your institutional clients.

Keith McCullough: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: And so I'll take credit for having encouraged you to expand your offerings. Now, I want to also— I wanted to start by giving you your chance to plug your product. But even for the benefit of our listeners who are not interested in buying anything, I want to give you a little tip, guys, because there's a lot of free stuff here that's not obvious. In your Research Roundup email, there's a download link for the slide deck that we've just talked through. There's a separate download link for the podcast. Link for what looks like it's just a one-page sales brochure for these different products. What's not obvious is the whole list of products that are in blue. Those are links to free issues of each one of these different products. So even the high-end Platinum All Access Pass, which includes Macro Select, which is institutional-level macro research and Demography Unplugged, which is Neil Howe's podcast.

A lot of our longtime listeners know that Neil Howe is probably my favorite intellectual alive in terms of his work on, on Fourth Turnings and so forth. Absolutely brilliant guy. There's free examples of all this stuff, and it's not obvious. It looks like it's just a one-page sales brochure. It's actually a list of links to free stuff. So I strongly encourage all of our listeners, whether you're interested in buying anything or not, to take advantage of the free samples that are included through the links on that sales brochure, which is a download in your Research Roundup email. If you do want to buy anything from Hedgeye, be sure to use these links that are on page 26 of the slide deck because they do give you additional discounts that are even lower than the going prices that other people are paying during this Cyber Monday promotion. So the $899.95 For the Elite Pass, I think it's $999.95 for the general public, and I think the Platinum All Access is $2,000 for the general public.

It's $1,750 for MacroVoices listeners. So be sure to use the right links in order to get the appropriate discount. We're going to have to leave it there in the interest of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Keith. It inspired me to put together a chartbook to talk about the different sectors in the S&P 500 and wanted later in this postgame get to that chartbook. But many of our listeners that don't download the chartbook need the link. Can you share that with our listeners?

Erik Townsend: Sure thing, Patrick. And again, these links are all in the chartbook if you did the download in your Research Roundup email. And actually, the links themselves are in your Research Roundup email, but for some reason we always get people asking us for them. So again, the links are hedgeye.com/macrovoicespaap for the Platinum All Access Pass product, hedgeye.com/macrovoicesep, Echo Papa, for the Elite Pass product, and hedgeye.com/macrovoices.com for the H-I-Q, that's Hotel India Quebec, for the HedgeIQ product. All of those links will give you substantially lower prices than even the very lowest Hedgeye price that they have for their Cyber Monday special, and actually by a considerable margin. So be sure to use those links if you want to get in on Hedgeye's products. But Patrick, before we go on, I just want to mention for people who are not interested in buying anything from Hedgeye, don't miss the free research giveaway. This is the first time they've done this with us.

In your Research Roundup email, there's a download link for what is ostensibly a sales brochure trying to get you to buy one of those products. There are sample issues of all of their different research products. Now, a few of them, which are like daily, you know, price levels, obviously are not relevant if if it's not the same day. But most of the content in there is very interesting macro research, which is just as relevant today as the day that it was written. So I strongly encourage all of our listeners to take advantage of the free research from Hedgeye, regardless of whether you care about signing up for the paid subscription service.

Dalio's article: asset prices, bubbles and money creation

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I wanted to move on. There was that great article from Ray Dalio, and both of us had a chance to read it. It was called The World Has Gone Mad and the System Is Broken. And both of us agreed that it was worthwhile conversation to have our listeners, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, the conclusion here is inescapable, Patrick. Obviously, Ray Dalio must be a MacroVoices junkie. He's been listening to our best ideas, and he's now publishing them as his own. No, actually, I don't really believe that, folks. If anything, what I would say is the best ideas that we've been talking about for years on MacroVoices— I am so envious of Ray Dalio's gift for taking very, very complex macro subjects that usually only very, very smart people are able to understand and distilling them down into simple language that your grandmother could understand. So folks, I cannot recommend this article strongly enough, even if you already understand all of this stuff. If you're looking for something to give to the people in your life that don't understand all of this investment stuff that you do and are just trying to understand what's wrong with the world and why the financial system is so screwed up. This is just such beautiful, plain English writing.

I'm so envious of, of Ray's writing style. I wish I had his ability to articulate myself as concisely as he does.

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, I want to first tackle the one segment he has in there where he talks about the pricing of financial assets. So he goes on to say that prices of financial assets have gone way up and the future expected returns have gone way down while the economic growth and inflation remain sluggish. It goes on to say that more companies than any time since the dot-com bubble don't have to make profits or even have a clear path to making profits to sell their stock because they can instead sell their dreams to those investors who are flush with money and borrowing power. It goes on to say that there is now so much money waiting to buy these dreams that in some cases venture capital investors are pushing money onto startups that don't want more money because they already have more than enough. And so I had to ask you, I mean, you were— you sold your software company in 1999, but does it really feel like the dot-com bubble?

Erik Townsend: Oh, it does to me, but I have to qualify it and say, at the time, I was a software entrepreneur. I didn't understand any of this macro stuff. And what I do remember is all of the other CEOs that I knew were kind of looking at each other in the first-class lounge in United Airlines saying, you know, I'm getting offers to sell company for more than I know it's worth. And, and I don't really get it, like what's going on with these finance guys. And none of us got it. We didn't understand, but we knew that the valuations were just too good to be true. And this was '98, before it even really got to the total blow-off top part of it. And, you know, the reason that I sold my company is I wasn't ready to retire, but I just looked at the valuations they were paying for, for little companies like mine. And I was— I knew that it was some kind of bubble.

And I I didn't understand any of the factors that were driving it because I didn't know about macro stuff, but I knew it was crazy. This feels just as crazy, but as Ray describes, it's a totally different set of circumstances that are driving it this time. At that time, everybody knew the internet was going to be a really huge thing, and it caused all kinds of just crazy irrational exuberance, and people just wanted to get in on it even if they didn't understand exactly what it was. This is a completely different scenario. The problem now is that there's too much money. We had this big credit crisis, the, the whole great financial crisis. It was resolved by central banks coming to the rescue, conjuring money out of thin air, and using it to buy financial assets. And the result is that the professional money management industry now has too much money to invest, and that means that they pay more for assets than they're worth.

And that means that the yield or return on those assets is low and expected to stay low. And we've gotten into this Greater Fool theory where, you know, you're buying things that are clearly, you know, negative-yielding junk bonds in Europe. How do you buy that? How can you possibly justify making that purchase? Because somebody else is going to pay even more for it when you turn it around and sell it to them. So it's Greater Fool theory that is been institutionalized by central banks. And the thing is, as much as it's tempting to say this is crazy, it's nuts, it can't last, which is the big mistake that I've made since 2008, is I kept convincing myself this can't go on any longer, it's too crazy, surely it's not sustainable. Well, what Ray Dalio explains very, very succinctly in this article, Patrick, is yeah, it can go on.

They've got a printing press, and it does lead to other problems, but the idea of them being able to continue to conjure money out of thin air and pump it into the financial system, there's nothing stopping them from continuing to do that.

Patrick Ceresna: Now, you were talking about conjuring money out of thin air. I want to move on to the next segment where he talks about this in a little bit more detail. So he goes on to say, at the same time, large government deficits exist, and most likely will increase, and it's going to require huge amounts more of debt to be sold by the governments that naturally cannot be absorbed by the markets without driving interest rates higher substantially. And this is at a time when interest rate rise would be devastating for the markets and the economies because the world is so leveraged. And goes on to say, so where will the money come from to buy these bonds and fund these deficits? He says they'll come from the central banks, which will buy that debt that is produced with freshly printed money. The whole dynamic in which sound finance is now being thrown out the window and will continue to probably accelerate, which is especially the case in the reserve currency countries such as the US, Europe, and Japan.

And it goes on to the scenario that we're, I guess, all turning Japanese, where essentially we run big deficits and the central bank just buys all that debt, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, and Patrick, I think the really key point to understand here, and again, it's the one I've been missing, is a lot of people are saying, okay, this can't go on forever, we've got to see some kind of blow-off top in this 35-plus-year bond bull market. Surely we're gonna get into a secular bear market in bonds. And what Ray is saying is, no, it doesn't have to go that way. If we had natural market forces, supply and demand, give and take, economic normal, the old normal, maybe that would be true. But in the new normal where the central bank is ready to come riding in, the choice that they've got is they can let the natural forces in the market take interest rates much higher and bankrupt governments and pension systems and cause massive, massive social disturbances across the world, or they can conjure even more money out of thin air and keep propping the system up until something else breaks.

And what he describes is, as much as it seems crazy, the path of least pain, the, you know, the one that's most likely to be chosen, is the one of central banks continuing to keep interest rates suppressed. And we're not likely to see bond rates go screaming higher. We're likely to see central banks continue to keep them lower in order to keep this game of musical chairs, uh, keep the music running a bit longer. Someday that music's gonna stop, Patrick, and Ray goes on to explain what will eventually stop it.

Unfunded liabilities, printing and reserve currencies

Patrick Ceresna: Right, and so he continues on to talk about these unfunded liabilities and how this is going to move forward. He touches on demographics, saying there's going to be fewer earners that are going to be obviously taxed to support a larger population of baby boomers, and there simply isn't going to be enough money to fund all these obligations. And so how will that gap be bridged? And so he, he says there's one of 3 things that can happen. Either A, you're going to cut the actual benefits, all these unfunded liabilities, or 2, you're going to raise taxes, or 3, you're going to print money. And he gets to the point that the easiest path is printing the money because it's hidden way in creating a wealth transfer. And at the same time, it makes asset prices rise. So it's— there's going to be the least resistance by choosing the money printing path.

And because there's no limitations to the amount of money that can be printed, the big risk is that it threatens the viability of the 3 major world reserve currencies as a viable store of wealth.

Erik Townsend: And I think that point is really important to clarify, Patrick, because some people think, okay, so that means the dollar index, the DXY, DXY has to crash at some point. No, it doesn't, because remember, the dollar index is relative to those other major currencies. It just measures the relative strength of the dollar compared to other fiat currencies. The real point that Ray is making is the major fiat currencies of the world are going to be devalued in terms of purchasing power. How do you translate that to actionable trading strategies? strategy, it's gold. Or if you believe the cryptocurrency argument, there's an argument for crypto there. I don't happen to agree with it, but I'll acknowledge that it makes sense to some people.

Capitalism, inequality and the Fourth Turning

Patrick Ceresna: So the final segment here that I want to talk about is that he touches on how capitalism is broken. And it says that because the trickle-down process of having money at the top trickle down to workers and others by improving their earnings and creditworthiness not working. The system of making capitalism work well for most people is broken. This set of circumstances is unsustainable and certainly can no longer be pushed as it has been pushed since 2008. And this is why he believes that the world is approaching a big paradigm shift. So, you know, Ray is really getting to this stage of thinking that there's some sort of big shift coming in, and it's coming— we're closer to it than we've ever been I think he's exactly right.

Erik Townsend: And what I would love to ask Ray about, because he doesn't mention it in this article, if we could somehow get him onto MacroVoices— we've been inviting him for years, and unfortunately his staff have declined— I'd like to tie this into Neil Howe's work on generational cycles and turnings, because this is the classic Fourth Turning setup where major institutions in society get torn down and replaced with new ones. And it's really important for old guys like me to listen to what younger generations are saying. Doesn't mean you have to agree with them, but you know, they're— the young generation is coming of age. They're going to be the ones making the decisions going forward. They have different values than I was brought up with. And frankly, I think of Howard Beale in Network. They're mad at as hell, and they're not going to take any more of this. Well, what are they mad about? They're mad about the fact that there is horrific wealth inequality and it's getting worse, and they're right about that.

Unfortunately, I think most of them are misdiagnosing the cause. They think the cause of that horrible inequality, which is horrible, is capitalism, and I disagree. I think capitalism is the cure. If we could go back to capitalism, something that we haven't practiced in decades. That, I think, would be the best way to cure this horrible wealth inequality. But they don't see it that way. And I think that if you look at where most of the sentiment exists in younger generations, it's some combination of much more socialist both policies of government generally and particularly monetary policy. And I think modern monetary monetary theory is going to be used to justify a whole lot of much larger government, you know, everything from universal basic income to free college tuition to healthcare for everyone. We're going socialism as the solution to a problem that socialism can only exacerbate.

And it's so sad to me that we've done such a poor job with education that so many of these younger people who are justifiably mad as hell and don't want to take it anymore think that capitalism is the problem that needs to be solved.

And I think they're exactly right that there's a problem. Unfortunately, I think they're misdiagnosing it.

Chartbook: tech, financials, staples, discretionary, healthcare

Patrick Ceresna: That's right. Anyway, so let's move on because I put together a chart book. I was inspired by Keith during the interview. He was talking about the energy sector and that he viewed that a lot of the bond proxy sectors could really start to roll over, like consumer staples. I thought it was a great opportunity for us to kind of take a tour through the S&P sectors to see what's been working and what's rebounding and how it's all kind of unfolding. And so let's get to the chartbook, Erik.

Erik Townsend: Okay, listeners, you'll find the download link. It says Postgame Chartbook in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Keith McCullough's picture. Patrick, let's dive right in. Page 2, you've got the S&P chart. Let's start there.

Patrick Ceresna: Really, the S&P chart, we— I mean, you were talking about it in the market wrap. Really what I wanted to just have a reference point on this chart to compare to all of the other charts. I mean, we've basically broken to a fresh new high over the last several weeks, and the market continues to tread higher as we approach 3,100. And what I really wanted on page 3 was just to show the breakdown of the S&P 500 by weightings. And you can identify that technology, financials, and healthcare, the 3 sectors, basically make up over 50% of the index. And so really wanted to just see what's working and what isn't in that entire space. So it's on page 4 where we have the technology sector, and this is using the XLK technology ETF, and we can really see that the leadership continues to be the tech space. I mean, obviously it's stocks like Apple that continue to rip higher. The semiconductor space is doing so very well, and there is no doubt that the technology space is the leadership.

What's particularly interesting though, Erik, is, is that the financials on page 5, which have really been dogging it for almost the entire summer— for 6 months they were just ranging range-bound really have broken out, and this is truly where some of the leadership is. In fact, I would argue that the financials in the last week or two have been one of the strongest sectors by far, and, and see some real acceleration in some of those money center banks.

Erik Townsend: Now, these are ETFs that only trade during stock market trading hours, Patrick, but as a technician, what do you make of all of those numerous daily gaps. The conventional wisdom, of course, in technical analysis is all those gaps need to be filled, and that would suggest that a pullback is coming.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, I don't know if I would personally overread too much into each of those gaps, but I would certainly think that after such an extended move, we're going to be due for some sort of a throwback in the markets. I think the exercise that I want to go through here is, is more about trying to grasp what sectors are working and which aren't. And that's really where I want to get to page 6 and talk about, on pages 6 and 7, consumer discretionary and consumer staples, because the 2 sectors simply have not been bid. I mean, we are talking complete and total range-bound markets within consumer discretionary and consumer staples. They simply have stopped participating in the last 2, 3 months. This is an area that is not getting any money, and we've seen on a lot A lot of those Coca-Colas of the world and McDonald's of the world that all have rolled over. Amazon hasn't participated. I mean, really, this space has just not been touched.

But going on to page 8, this is where I wanted to talk about healthcare. And what's interesting is healthcare, which has been very similarly to the financials, a dead space for the last 6 months, really has broken out. And we're finally seeing some of these healthcare sectors really gaining some traction. It'll be interesting to see whether healthcare continues to be a bit of a leadership sector moving forward. Clearly, the financials and technology are really the big leadership group, but healthcare is definitely participating.

Erik Townsend: Now, how do you reconcile that leadership that you're seeing on page 4 in XLK in the technology space with Keith's call that software is the short here and that the new place to be long as we get into this sector rotation ought to be energy?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I'm not opposed to that view that he has, but there's certainly no technical evidence that technology is letting up here. And so, I mean, usually, you know, when you look at a space such as consumer staples on page 7, which he's short of or believes it's rolling over, This is typically the type of price action you would see before a rollover, which is the momentum stalls, the price can't break higher highs, distribution starts becoming more prevalent. These kind of characteristics of the kind of rollover we're seeing in consumer staples, there is zero sign of that in technology. But when you're doing a long-short the way Keith is suggesting, you don't really need the technology space to stop going up. You just need the energy sector to be outperforming it. And so maybe it will work, but it may happen just that the energy space is just going to have more traction, right?

Chartbook: industrials, materials and energy

Patrick Ceresna: So anyway, Erik, I wanted to move on.

On page 9, we have the industrial ETF, and the industrials have participated. That's definitely moving. And same with materials. And that's— I find that interesting that materials are finally moving, kind of plays into that reflation narrative. And maybe these sectors will finally get a little bit of momentum. But really, on page 11, where the energy ETF is, and this is where Keith really believed that there's room for the sector to rebound. But the energy sector has truly been the dog. I mean, it has it has been the serial underperformer, and it is finally getting some traction here. I mean, from a very old. Oversold state, there is definitely lots of room for this sector to go. The question is, will we see that follow-through? I mean, I don't know whether you have an opinion on it, but I've— I generally feel that in order for the energy sector to really have a solid tailwind, you want to see oil prices properly breaking out.

And, and, uh, you know, will we see, let's say, oil getting north of $60 or something like that? That's what would, uh, I think, be necessary for this energy sector to truly get some proper tailwind?

Erik Townsend: Well, just a few weeks ago, Patrick, even a couple of weeks ago, I would have said, sorry, I just don't see it because what I'm seeing looks to me like this market is waiting to get through a little bit of China trade exuberance before it eventually dumps and goes lower. What we're seeing, though, especially in the last couple of weeks, as I described in the market wrap, is it feels like on one hand you've got the usual short time horizon oil traders that are doing their thing, reacting to inventory numbers and so forth. But overlaying that, there seems to be this persistent bid. It seems like longer time frame traders are coming into this market and they're buying it as a much longer time horizon macro trade, and they're not worrying about what this inventory number or that OPEC rumor happened to be. They're just looking at it for the reasons Keith described in today's interview, which is over the next quarter to 6 months, it looks like there's a lot of macro reasons to expect outperformance of the sector.

So it feels to me like there are traders in the market that seem to jibe with that explanation. Now, I suppose those traders could be somebody else who has some completely other non-political public news that I don't know about, but somebody is bidding up this market in a way that just doesn't feel like the market has felt. And I'm only referring to the last couple of weeks.

Chartbook: utilities and real estate as bond proxies

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So the final thing that I wanted to just touch on, on pages 12 and 13, I have the utilities and the real estate ETFs, and both of them look like they've put in legitimate tops, and both of them look like they've begun a correction. And I would say of all the sectors, they are the ones that you can label as true bond proxies and sensitive to interest rates. And so when you're looking at those charts on the 30-year Treasury bonds or the 10-year Treasury bonds, you can really see some correlations developing here. And the question that is in my mind is that if we have seen short-term tops in bonds and we're going to see interest rates, let's say, head back to 2% or 2.25% on the 10-year yield? Will we continue to see the sectors of utilities and real estate have been outperforming the other sectors throughout much of the first part of the year?

Are we now seeing this, this big sector rotation that is now going to see them materially underperform? It's a real risk and something that's on my radar.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, definitely. And, you know, this chart, I think just visually you can see there's been a pretty darn We've got a consistent channel here and we've broken that channel to the downside. We've got a couple, several candles, full candles outside of the channel below it. So it looks to me like there's definitely been a change of direction here. Patrick, we're gonna need to leave it there in the interest of time.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Today's episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Be sure to check out my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen published on September 7th, 2019. The link is in your Research Roundup. Roundup email. And listeners, be sure to sign up to get your own Research Roundup email every week. It's free and it provides you with links to all of the best content we can find on the internet, including free research downloads associated with our program and so forth.

This week it also contains those discount codes for the Hedgeye offers. Patrick, tell them what else they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chart book for Keith McCullough's presentation. And the charts we discussed on the sectors in the postgame. There's also an interesting article from Jim Bianco talking about the repo market has been drugged into submission, as well as that link to that Ray Dalio article we discussed about the world has gone mad and the system is broken. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how. We can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikST. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by the generous support of viewers like you. By sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based. On information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Alex Gurevich — hedge fund manager (as introduced on the show)

Announcer opening

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Erik's open and guest preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 191 was recorded on October 31st, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Happy Halloween. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, which happens to be my own favorite podcast when it comes to quant and rules-based investing. My feature interview guest this week is hedge fund manager Alex Gurevich, who couldn't be more bullish on gold.

Alex is known as a fixed income guru, so we'll focus much of the interview on interest rates and bond yields, both in the United States and around the globe. We'll also take a deep dive on the US dollar and the euro in the wake of Christine Lagarde taking the helm of the ECB from Mario Draghi this week. And be sure to stay tuned after the feature interview for our postgame segment. Patrick has compiled another of his famous postgame chartbooks and will have extended equity market coverage, as well as a number of other discussions.

Market wrap: S&P 500 at all-time highs and the election

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into that S&P 500. We break to 52-week new highs on the— actually all-time highs on the market. And we kind of pop into the FOMC and we're giving it all back here today, at least FOMC pop. What's your take on the market?

Erik Townsend: Doesn't surprise me at all that we broke to new all-time highs. It doesn't make sense to me. But if you look at the way this market's been trading, it's been looking for an excuse to move higher, even though the fundamentals, in my opinion, don't really support it. I think that the next big thing, you know, we're exactly a year away from the election, and usually that's when election-related forces start to become much more dominant in the market. Markets don't like uncertainty. So of course, we don't know how polls are going to turn out and so forth. But to the extent that in coming months we see uncertainty as to who's going to win the election, I think that's going to put a lot of downside pressure on the market. On the other hand, if it becomes very, very clear from polls that, let's say, a reelection of President Trump is a near certainty, I think that regardless of whether you like President Trump or not, that removal of uncertainty would probably tend to support the market.

So I think how the political process goes is going to weigh heavily on the market in the next year. There's lots of room for all kinds of volatility in either direction. Paul Tudor Jones made some comments at the Sohn Conference this week suggesting that you could see just wild differences if there was an Elizabeth Warren That would probably, according to Paul Tudor Jones, be very negative for the market. He believes that a Trump reelection would be very positive for the market. Now, regardless of whether you agree with those views, it should be clear that election politics are going to play a much bigger role than they have so far in the market. You'll hear Alex Gurevich make a very excellent point, I think, in this interview, Patrick, which is if you think about equity prices in terms of CAPE ratios and so forth, it seems like they're crazy overvalued. But if you think of it strictly in In terms of relative to the alternative of fixed income, you know, how much capital do you need to produce a certain amount of income yield?

Well, equities almost look cheap next to today's fixed income. So I'm happy to be on the sidelines. I don't want to be any part of this stock market. I'm happy to be trading commodity futures.

Dollar index near 97 and the dollar short squeeze

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because the euro strength and corresponding dollar weakness is pretty relevant here. What do you think is the next move on the dollar from here? Is the consolidation going to continue?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as we're speaking on Thursday this morning, we touched just barely that 97 round number, so we're flirting with it again. As I've said before, uh, if this is the bottom, okay, but if we move and get a daily close below 97, you know, that really starts to establish a pattern of lower highs and lower lows and suggests that maybe this move to the downside has farther to go. Now, Patrick, I still am convinced that the dollar short squeeze that Jeff Snider has talked so much about is in place. I think it's going to continue to be the dominant force, and I think it's eventually going to push the dollar index much higher. But do we go considerably lower before that happens? I don't know. I can tell you that if we get a daily close below 97, I'm going to take my long position off just to wait this out and see what happens.

Crude oil: time spreads, EIA build and the Keystone leak

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Now, Erik, on Monday you tweeted that crude oil was rallying to new cycle highs, but the time spreads were signaling the market was topping. As it turned out, the market topped within 1 tick of the level it was trading when you posted that tweet, and oil since has dropped And then it dropped about $3 lower. So congratulations on the call, but please elaborate to our listeners. How did you know from the time spreads that the market was about to run out of steam?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, first of all, the timing was pure dumb luck. It was very clear that the market was running out of steam. The fact that the tweet happened to get posted right at the high, it just was coincidence. But time spreads are a really, really strong indicator in some circumstances. Now, they don't always give a signal. But in this case, what we saw was the front month and time spreads rallying through Thursday and Friday last week, and then all of a sudden the time spreads just gave out. They were collapsing on Monday morning, even as the market was rallying to new highs beyond where it had been on Friday. That told me that the rally was over or was about to be over, and that's the reason for the tweet. And it turned out that I just purely by coincidence happened to peg it right at the top of the market. Then we got the EIA inventory report on Wednesday, which helped to accelerate the selling because API, the private service that reports on Tuesday afternoons, had set an expectation for a small drawdown on crude oil inventories.

Instead, EIA reported a 5.7 million barrel build on inventory. That resumes a previous streak of 5 builds in a row. Then we had one drawdown next week. So if not for that one drawdown, it would be 7 in a row. And Cushing, Oklahoma, also building 1.6 million barrels, continuing the trend there as well. The drawdowns were on finished products— gasoline drawing down 3 million barrels, distillates drawing down 1 million barrels. Meanwhile, US production is holding at 12.6 million barrels, unchanged. That's still a record-high level. The record was set just a few weeks ago. Imports 6.7 million barrels per day, exports 3.3 million barrels per The tape action was already down on the day, but of course that inventory report just helped to accelerate the selling to the downside. But then all of a sudden those time spreads reversed again and took off to the upside just like crazy, starting at about 12:45 PM on Wednesday.

What's going on there? Well, this time it wasn't forecasting the direction of the front month; it was news of a leak on the Keystone Pipeline, which very directly affects inventory logistics of supply coming. into Cushing, Oklahoma. So we do have the Keystone Pipeline still shut down as we speak. Now, a lot of people on Twitter are saying, hey, look at the November of 2017 spill on the Keystone Pipeline, only took a few days to fix, this shouldn't be a big deal. I'm not so convinced of that, Patrick. The reason is this is on a submerged section of the Keystone Pipeline. So the pipe is a subterranean pipe buried underground, and specifically this involved wetlands. So now we have contaminated wetlands The pipe can't be repaired until they dig it up first. Who knows what kind of environmental regulation comes into play in digging up a submerged oil pipeline when what it's submerged in is wetlands that have already been contaminated?

How many different government agencies are involved in deciding what the rules are for that one? So there hasn't been a clear announcement about the timeline of how long the Keystone Pipeline will be offline, but it won't surprise me, Patrick, if it turns out to take a little longer than the previous spill repairs that we've seen, which occurred on pipes that were not submerged.

Gold: scaling into a long on the breakout

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because last week gold tried to break out, gave it back. Again, today we're trying to break out. We're at $1,515 at the time of recording. Is gold gonna break out here or what?

Erik Townsend: Well, after we saw that false breakout last week, Patrick, I decided to start scaling into a speculative position. I've already had a core position in gold that I've held for years. I was waiting for a pullback, and frankly, I'm still convinced That there will probably be a lower opportunity to get a better entry price here. But at every turn, we've just seen unexpected strength in the gold market. So I have started buying on an unleveraged basis. As far as any levered speculation, I'm going to wait for a better opportunity. I'm definitely keeping some powder dry. But it just looks to me like we could end up breaking out of this consolidation. We've got a chart coming up in the postgame segment where we can talk in more detail, but we're seeing a break above an important trend line that we saw a break above that same trend line last week, but it was just intraday. It was a pop and drop.

We closed below it. Looks like we're going to close well above that trend line today. That potentially means a new bullish move. Again, I think there will be a lower entry opportunity before this is over. We really haven't seen any significant pullback after this really big move up, but it hasn't come as quickly as I expected, Patrick. So I'm starting to scale into a larger long position on gold. Alex Gurevich is gonna have a ton to say about gold. He's incredibly bullish. So we'll save that for the feature interview.

10-year Treasury yield and Erik's closed long

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury, 'cause we have a nice pop in bonds as yields are backing up to now below the 1.70 level, as bonds are liking the fact that the FOMC or the Fed is looking to stall their rate cut cycle there. What's your take on what's going on in the bond markets?

Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, Alex Gurevich is the fixed income guru. So we're gonna save most of the bond market coverage for the feature interview. I did close, actually, my long position. I still think yields are going lower, but frankly, I don't have as much conviction as I've had before because just the way we've seen this pattern established, we're starting to see what looks to me like a pattern of lower highs and lower lows in price, higher highs and higher lows in yields. That may have reversed in the last couple of days. Maybe I closed my position at the wrong time, but I decided to just get out at breakeven. rather than wait this one out. So I'm happy to sit on the sidelines, but we'll go into much more detail in the feature interview with Alex Gurevich.

New MacroVoices YouTube video and why Alex Gurevich

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, thanks for the market update. Now, before we move on to this week's featured interview, we just released a new video today on MacroVoices YouTube channel. Please tell us about it.

Erik Townsend: This one is an instructional video. It's designed for advanced retail investors, and it's teaching you how to use the long-short equity Hedge Fund Strategy to Trade Your Own Account Like a Hedge Fund. The idea was to develop a series of advanced investing videos. That was a plan, frankly, that we had as part of the expanded new content for MacroVoices. I'm not sure that we're going to do the rest of the series, but this particular video was recorded back in July. It just finally got finished with the editing process. So enjoy it, everybody. It's on the YouTube channel. You can also find a link to it in your Research Roundup email. And by all means, let us know what you think in the comments section on YouTube.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview features HonTe Investments CIO Alex Gurevich. Now, why did we invite Alex to the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, there's a few reasons. Number one, Alex is just a really smart, big-picture thinker. He's a really, really smart fixed-income interest rate guy, but he really thinks long-term. He's not the what's happening this week, tomorrow, and so forth. It's an FOMC week. We wanted to have somebody who was knowledgeable about fixed income markets and interest rates and so forth to comment on what's going on with FOMC. But I also wanted to get the big picture view as to whether or not Alex is still bullish on fixed income, as he has been in the last couple of times we've had him on the show, as well as to get an update from him. He's also a very, very expert currencies guy. And we've got Mario Draghi leaving the ECB. Now Christine Lagarde is taking over. What's that going to mean? I wanted to ask Alex about that.

Erik Townsend: So he's just a guy who's got experience that was very relevant to a lot of things that are going on in the market this week.

This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. I did a full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, the host of this excellent podcast, back on September 7th, 2019. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. We discussed a number of key issues about the value of having a rules-based investment strategy in a portfolio In our conversation, Niels shared some insights that may surprise you, especially when it comes to how trend following strategies don't really operate the way some market commentators suggest they do. For more information, including a free book about trend following and the accredited investor slide deck from my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, go to toptradersunplugged.com/macroslides.

Patrick Ceresna: Check them out.

Announcer: Check it out.

Erik Townsend: You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Alex Gurevich is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

FOMC day: the October 2019 cut and 'the next hike is never'

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is HonTe Investments Chief Investment Officer, Alex Gurevich. And of course, listeners, you know Alex is a big fixed income expert and interest rate guy. Obviously, Alex, we need to get deep on interest rates in today's interview. But first, what's on everybody's mind is it was FOMC day. Give us the rundown. Obviously, 25-point basis cut. What's your perspective on what happened here? What does it mean? And how do we fit this into the big picture?

Alex Gurevich: Okay, good to be back. So yes, today is FOMC day. And whenever we are in the middle of our cycle of actually action cycle, that is right now in the middle of an easing cycle. Every FOMC day is very important, not only in terms of what happens today, what exactly they do, but also people look for clues as to the next meeting because it's not so easy for them to change course between meetings. So, it's brick by brick, they lay out the expectations for the next meeting a few weeks ago, and this is the first significant installment of our expectations for the month of December too, not just what happened today. As of today, the market priced like 95%, depending upon what chances you would put in, maybe even 97% chance, depending on exact computation of ease.

So, it was completely baked in. If you ask me, I would say that the actual probability was 99.99%. The reason is that there is just really absolutely no incentive, there is no scenario, no course of discussion that would likely lead Fed to actually not lower rates today. And I can go into this a little deeper. You might see some dissents and some people saying that they don't want to do it, but reality is, it's just— people are just showing their philosophical dissent. Everybody knows that rates needed to be lowered today because market already priced it in.

And if they didn't do it, it would be too much of a shock to risk assets and to the system. And it was completely unnecessary because there was no pressure on them. There's no inflation pressure, and we'll get back to that too a little bit. There was no data pressure. In fact, data was kind of soft last month.

So, there was nothing urgent that would tell them not to do it, and they could very easily do it and then manage the expectations going forward, and that's what they tried to do.

So, to avoid parsing exact words of Powell or exact questions, in a very broad sense, just of what he tried to convey is that basically what Fed always conveys, we currently think the policy level is appropriate. First of all, Well, that is almost by default truth. If they didn't think it would be appropriate where they ended up today, then they would have done something else.

So, they have to, by default, be at the level which they consider to be correct at the moment, right? And he tried to convey that this might be the last cut because they have overall relatively positive outlook on the economy. There were some positives and some more negatives, some more questionable things about the economy and the global economy that were mentioned. During the press conference. But overall, he tries to convey that overall there are some risks, but overall things are okay, and this rate should be accommodative enough for the economy to muddle through at trend growth.

And this is what he tried to convey.

However, to me, there was a very interesting element of the message which is very consistent with what I philosophically expected for a long time, and which I think very strongly will be true. But I heard much more of acknowledgment from that of that from Federal Reserve than I ever heard before.

Basically, the way I would translate what Chairman Powell said, that there will be— the next rate hike is never.

Big picture: yields to zero, Treasuries as a free option

Erik Townsend: Okay, Alex, I wanted to start with today's news, what happened at FOMC today, because obviously you're an expert on the subject. But our longtime listeners also know that you are really not a what happened today kind of guy. You're a really big picture thinker, and you've been extremely prescient in understanding in a long-term view what's going on and what's been driving the fixed income markets and rates generally. So let's zoom way back out now and give us the big picture overview of where we stand. Last time we spoke to you, you were still looking for 10-year yields to continue to move lower, possibly to new all-time lows. Is that still your outlook? And what's the big picture? What should we expect to see from here?

Alex Gurevich: Definitely no major changes. I'm still expecting on this cycle to Fed funds rate end up close to zero and yields continuing to fall and longer-dated Treasury is either earning money by either getting significantly lower in yields or starting to earn significant money via carry as they did in the past years. That is, even if, for example, even if 10-year note yield stayed where it is but the front end went to zero, we'd be earning 1.5% carry. And I would imagine the situation to persist till yields go significantly down.

I think everything points towards much lower yield. I think current Treasury yield, if you look at US Treasury Yields versus yields on pretty much everything in the world, on all instruments in the world. This is a huge aberration spike. There is— it defies my words to explain how cheap Treasury bonds are as an asset class relative to other asset classes.

I mean, there are other asset classes that might have more upside, and we can talk about gold or cryptocurrencies or whatever, but looking like in terms of a safe asset and how historically cheap Treasury bonds are to everything else, it's been very persistent, but it's been persistent not in the sense that it's cheap and it's losing money. It's cheap and it keeps making you money as you put money in it.

And it's just been a treasure trove. Sorry for the pun. Treasuries were a treasure trove and they continue to be one. And we can go into more detail. And I think what is very interesting about— here's the interesting thought that Chairman Powell said, and this thought was actually, in some sense, it's not Well, every time the Fed says something, it might affect today's market moves, but it actually does not really mean very much in terms of long-term policy because generally, as far as I'm concerned, they say things that I already know. It might just affect daily price motion. But for example, when they say, we cut today, but we'll be data dependent afterwards, there is no new information. Of course, they're going to be data dependent.

By the same token, when they pivoted, when there was so-called pivot in the winter of 2018, 2019, I actually don't believe there was any pivot. I think the policy response stayed consistent. Things turned and they turned. It's not like there was ever any question that— and if they did not say those things, bond market would have continued to rally because then stock market would have gone down and forced them to cut anyways.

However, it is interesting to see them acknowledge certain things just as an internal mental check. So this is what he really said today during the conference call, which is very interesting. He's been very pushed on when do they think is appropriate time to raise rates. And he said, well, we really don't have any inflation pressure whatsoever.

And he was very clear on the fact that there is no reason to raise rates again until inflation pressures will become ominous again, not just go above 2%, but go above target and sustain what— of course, there are different measures of inflation. You can argue with inflation high or low, but they basically need to somehow have a very uncontroversial and sustained measure of inflation putting pressure on them. And this is just not on the cards. We're not seeing this. I strongly doubt that we will see it in the near future because what we're having is strong dollar. And if they're not going to keep cutting rates, dollar will just continue getting stronger, which is in itself deflationary. We can argue whether strong dollar is good or bad thing. Most people think it's a bad thing for the world, but it's also— there is no question it's deflationary for US economy, and we're having very contained— of course, like, commodity prices could turn very quickly.

For example, oil is now very contained. It could rally 50% for all we know, and it might change somewhat short-term inflation picture in US. But even that in itself probably will not be enough to precipitate rate hikes. So the bar is very— given the global situation, given the current interest rate differential that favors US even after a recent bout of cuts, it's very hard to imagine any kind of inflation pressures arising in the US, which means that basically rates cannot go higher than now, which means that everything from now on to downside is a free option.

And market is not pricing very much more eases. So, in the event of Fed stays on hold, you can lose a little bit of money, but if they continue going to zero, as I think, you have much more to gain.

Time to go long Treasuries? LIBOR and the front end

Erik Townsend: Now, based on that view, Alex, we've come down on the 10-year Treasury yield from 3.25% more than a year ago, all the way down to a low print that was below 1.50, at least on an intraday basis. It was, as we're speaking on Wednesday afternoon after the Fed, Alex, we're looking at a 1.78 print on the 10-year. So it's backed up more than 25 basis points. In a normal market, countertrend move of 25 basis points is big. It's time to make a stand there. But in this case, we've come down 125 basis points in the last year. Is this time to make a stand and go long Treasuries, or maybe does this backing up in yields and this natural correction that we're seeing have further to run?

Alex Gurevich: Well, making a stand is a very strong statement because last stands are just really very good in movies but not very good for traders. So when you, when you're talking about make a stand, you have to be cautious of the fact, cognizant of the fact that things can always go further and you just need to stay in business. So with that With that caveat, I think it is definitely time to be long, and I'm long, and I'm willing to. But I'm long with the thought that it's quite possible to take some pain in the wrong direction there.

But I think, yes, yields came down quite a bit, but we also have more information. This is an unavoidable thing in markets. You're not always going to buy things at the best level. Sometimes you have to say, like, oh, well, yes, of course, we could have bought Bitcoin at $0.25 or Apple computers at whenever it was, Because in the year 2000, and if we trade in hindsight like this, we could be always perfect. If we put 100% on our position at 3.25-year or 10-year notes, that would have been the best, right? But, and then pyramided all our gains continuously, right? But it's never perfect. Sometimes you miss a big move, but what you gain during that move is a lot of new information.

First of all, we did have— the policy did change for whatever reasons. We had a— we did find out that there was no big inflation when in 2018 people were worried about some inflation burst in the US because of wage pressure, even though that was contrary to historical evidence, but people were for some reason worried about that.

But it did not happen. We have more information about global slowdown. We have more information about how inflation looks, how commodity prices look. And with new information, I think the cap on yields is just not that far from here. I am very reluctant to say, like, to draw lines in the sand on the longer-dated Treasuries. Because they're just kind of animals in themselves, and the curve can always steepen if it wants to.

In the front end, however, I feel like, yeah, you could go a few basis points higher, but how high can LIBOR go?

LIBOR today— so the 3-month LIBOR, for listeners, that's a 3-month London Interbank Offer Rate, which is a benchmark— today it was set at close to 1.91. And tomorrow it'll probably come down a bit because the Fed actually eased. Even though people knew that it was going to ease, usually after ease, it's going to come down a little more. It's actually actually relatively very high right now because it reflects a lot of recent funding pressure and funding shortage. It has a lot of space to go down with Fed funds, even where they are right now, probably easily can go down another 10 basis points without offending anybody, which puts LIBOR at like 180, right? And where is LIBOR have to— if you look at Eurodollar futures, which forecast LIBOR in the future, yes, they actually do put in a decent probability of rates going a little lower, but they're not pricing so much that there is a catastrophic loss on the horizon. I mean, I don't think, for example, if it stayed 180 forever, you could maybe lose like 30 basis points on the most expensive contracts.

Meanwhile, there is at least 100 basis points to run in the other direction. So that's my point.

My point is on the front end, you have a very clear risk-reward profile. And even if you go on a shorter horizon, if you go to just the most immediate bet on the The current probability on this meeting is

Why a December cut is 50/50

Alex Gurevich: fairly low. It's like maybe 10% of a cut in December, while there is still enough time for them to— if we see some weak numbers or maybe some weakness in the asset markets, I think, honestly, I think the probability for the cut in December is 50/50.

Erik Townsend: Whoa, 50/50. I wasn't expecting you to say that, Alex. Please elaborate.

Alex Gurevich: Well, I have traded now— it's my 3rd major easing cycle in my career, including the cycle of 2000, 2001, 2002. 2007, 2008, and not counting the midterm adjustment cycle of '98. And by the way, where we're at right now looks absolutely nothing like '98 and absolutely everything like 2001. And I've reiterated this idea many times, at least that's my perception. And what have I observed from those cycles? What we're seeing right now is actually not at all strange for people, a lot of younger traders have some, not to offend them, but they might have some preconceptions maybe based on charts and based on how they think things should be. But if you traded those markets and have a visceral sense of how they trade, I have a good memory how it looked and it looked very much like this.

So what happens is within the easing cycle, there are periodic periods of risk-on where things look, where risk assets do well. And then regardless when, how, what economic numbers say, when risk assets like stocks do high yield, high yield instruments and spreads, everything does well, the sentiment is very positive and it feels like no more cuts are really needed.

And market very easily settles on the perception this is the last cut, and then if anything, we should look for hikes. And that happens again and again and again. And what happens actually is another cut, because risk sentiment goes in waves.

We're just completing a wave of positive risk sentiment, and that led us to here, to the perception that we'll not need another rate cut. Now, whether or not we'll have a negative wave of risk sentiment. I cannot be sure by mid-December, but just probabilistically, there's a pretty good chance we'll have at least a minor wave of negative risk sentiment. It doesn't have to be the same as last year, but it could be the same as last year on the outlier, or it could be just a more minor wave.

And if this wave of risk sentiment, negative risk sentiment happens, then in combination with soft economic numbers that we're seeing, it will be very easy to price in another cut. And in my opinion, it's about as likely as not to happen.

Gold: secular bull market, buy now with no stops

Erik Townsend: Alex, considering that your long-term view is that interest rates will eventually go to zero, we got to talk about gold. Give us the big picture. What do you see coming in both short, medium, and long term for gold?

Alex Gurevich: Well, I see secular bull market in gold. I see we're at the beginning of secular bull market. I think the move that occurred so far, depending on where you think it's like from $1,200 to $1,500 is just a minor blip at the beginning of a move which could be several times higher in magnitude.

And I think that given how we measured the previous bull markets in gold and how we're in a cycle, I would be surprised to find gold below $3,000 5 years from now. So, I think that it's a very high positive expectation asset right now.

Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more with the long-term view. If you look at the challenges that central bankers have, interest rates going to zero, they're probably going to be forced to keep them there for a long time. It really makes sense. Do you have a view about the current entry level? We've moved a lot really fast. A lot of people, myself included, were expecting there to be a natural pullback after that. And so far we've just seen a sideways consolidation. Is it time to buy here, or do you think we're going to get better entry opportunities?

Alex Gurevich: Yes and yes. In my opinion, yes, it is time to buy. And, and yes, we might get a better entry opportunity, but it's not Because the upside is way too big to wait. You see, if your upside is $3,000, say if you could go up to $4,500 on gold and make $3,000, do you really want to give it up trying to save $50 on the entry?

I think you need to enter if you have that view. It's very easy to have a different view. But if you have that view, you need to enter, but you need to keep your position You need to enter, you need to have no stops, view it as an option, and potentially increase— have a little space to increase your position size if things go against you, of course, if that's how you like to trade.

What is the worst thing to do right now, in my opinion, is put in— enter at 1,500 and put some kind of stop at 1,400 and get stopped out of the trade just when you want to be doubling down. That you definitely should be avoiding. So you should really be cognizant of what size you can afford, and you don't have to have so much size if If you think that gold can triple in price, and this is a big if because there could be other views on gold, but if you think as you and I, I think you absolutely have to rush to the screen and buy gold.

You need to stop this conversation, pause in the middle of this interview, and buy gold if that is the view you subscribe to, and then sort out the entry levels as a later problem. That's how I trade. But, of course, other people, again, might have different strategic approaches. Approaches. And in terms of timing, in a sense, I know you've been talking about this a lot. In a sense, I agree that the timing on gold this year was somewhat confounding.

We touched it in our previous conversation a little bit because historically gold does not start moving till a little later in the cycle. So, I was a little surprised by how fast gold started to move this summer. It was a little bit not the standard time when gold moves, but the fact that it eventually moves, it to me is much more important than what path it takes.

Erik Townsend: Well, I'm in complete agreement, Alex. I still think we're going to get a lower entry opportunity, but I couldn't agree more with your logic that you don't want to miss this. It's time to be invested in gold if you're not already, and hopefully we'll look forward to a dip down to $1,250 or $1,350 or whatever the number is so that we can buy more.

The US dollar: carry, Fed bill buying and regulation

Erik Townsend: Alex, let's move on to the US dollar. We We had seen a pretty significant downside move in the US dollar ever since the Fed announced their— it's not QE, folks, really, trust us, it's not— policy of injecting more non-QE money into the system. Just in reaction to FOMC today, the dollar index came off of a low. Looks like maybe it put in a short-term high there.

Have we seen the bottom in terms of the downside in the dollar, or could there Well, it is hard to tell.

Alex Gurevich: Again, I'm not a big expert on calling short-term bottoms, but I would point out that overall, unlike in the case of gold, the performance of dollar is generally consistent with this portion of the cycle. Typically, early in the easing cycle, dollar performs well.

And I think it is very important to realize when you look at the longer-term charts, even like starting from 1-year to 5-year charts, chart of something like DXY, which is just the weighted dollar index, is very deceptive. Dollar, in fact, is performing much better than any of those charts imply, because it's carrying very positively against other developed market currencies. It's the highest yielding developed market currency.

So, dollar-euro, for example, on a total return basis, dollar-euro is hanging around the levels it has not been at since 2003. It has surpassed the levels of several years ago, even when dollar-euro touched like 105. If at that point you bought dollar versus Euro, you would have still made money now, even though euro is higher nominally. But because of the carry, you would have still made money from that moment. So, that's how well dollar has been performing recently.

And I think that is very consistent. I do think I would not ignore what the Fed does with regards to dollar. It's been long my thesis. It's hard for me to measure what this QE, non-QE buy of T-bills means. And a lot of people are trying to prove to me that it's not actually going to affect liquidity so much, though. I think it does.

It is incrementally dollar negative, but probably not hugely. That's my feel. However, the talk about relaxing banking regulations—that is not something to be completely ignored. I think if banking regulations were to be relaxed so that banks could expand the balance sheets, that would increase the cash supply. It would be incrementally look like an ease. It would it would be very positive for Treasury's worth.

Other physical assets versus off-balance sheet assets. But we might be going into a little bit of a technical detail here. But it would also probably incrementally act like an easing, somewhat stimulate economy, and somewhat weaken dollar. I don't know, and I don't think it's likely that the magnitude of any change in regulations or those like temporary measures by the Fed would be big enough to offset broader, massive trends that are going on in the world. So, the odds are still— the odds on the current trend still support— supportive of dollar.

The euro and Lagarde replacing Draghi

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the euro currency, since I know that you follow that one quite a bit as well. We've got Mario Draghi is out, Christine Lagarde is in effective tomorrow as the head of the ECB. Does that affect the outlook for the euro, and what do you see on the horizon?

Alex Gurevich: Well, the interesting thing is that the short-term and long-term effects could be very different. For example, there is a lot of talk of Lagarde potentially being more of a fiscal impulse person. And the thing with fiscal expansion is that the first reaction to fiscal expansion could be actually negative for euro.

That's what happened in the US when we had fiscal expansion. Dollar originally went down in the beginning of 2018 after the tax bill passed, and then it proceeded to rally. The reality is fiscal expansion is actually not currency negative. It could even be aggregate currency positive. If you go into the math of capital account, it basically may serve to diminish European capital account deficit because it will— if you start issuing more sovereign debt, it might increase people's desire to buy it and not necessarily either flow money overseas or any money can come from overseas. But Of course, maybe to do that, the yield will have to go a little higher first, not being like negative 70 basis points or whatever it is out there. So, it's a difficult game to see how it's going to affect things.

I do think though, like right now, disclosure, I have no position on euro, which is pretty rare on me. I've been generally short euro and I recently got flat euro. I'm long dollar against other currencies, but I don't have a strong view on euro because I feel like it's been a pretty good run.

And I feel that Europe is actually next year prepared to give us relatively positive economic surprises, because negative economic surprises already all kind of happened and been priced in.

Equities: never short, long bonds instead

Erik Townsend: Alex, I know that you're primarily a fixed income and interest rate kind of guy, but give us your outlook on equity markets, both US and globally.

Alex Gurevich: Well, equity markets, as we all know, have been somewhat confounding to many people. I've heard you talk a lot about how you struggled yourself with the dichotomy between feeling that fundamentals are negative for the equities, but technically they continue to perform really well and continuing to shrug off any selling pressure very quickly. And it is as if like there is someone standing by to buy equities all the time. And this has been the flow situation. Generally, when I have a very strong conviction, I am generally not afraid of adverse technicals and adverse flows.

However, with regards to equities, it is not my strategy to ever go short equities. The reason is that over super long horizon, being short equities is generally always wrong, with some very few regional exceptions, because eventually equities rally. And right now, when you ask me what I think is going to happen to equities, I'm caught between— what is it called— caught between a rock and a hard place, right? On one side, historical pattern indicates that we should be topping here. Early in the easing cycle, equity, even when pre-recessionary conditions form, typically equities perform well, but in a more choppy fashion, make low new highs, very marginal new highs, and eventually they start the real bear market. So, what is happening right now would not be inconsistent with bear market in equities being very close to around the corner.

Yet, it's hard for me, unlike other people who feel very convinced that equities are overvalued, it's very hard for me to see equities as overvalued. That is just something I cannot buy into no matter how hard I try, because I still think about discount curve, and I still think about the environment of perpetually zero, negative interest rates globally. And in this environment, anything that can generate any profit looks cheap.

So what the multiples, what the P/E multiples should be right now is very hard to tell. And people will come back with arguments showing that P/E multiples don't actually matter, are not so tied to interest rates as we can think. This kind of model of just looking at yields and trying to price equities, it does not work, that it's all equity valuations always mean revert. Yes, probably, but also I don't see any fundamental force, like I don't see any fundamental gravity stopping equities from going higher.

So personally, I would generally stay out of equities if that was— stay out of heavy speculations on equities if it was my choice. I wouldn't be telling people not to buy some solid companies which can make it through the cycle that they like, and I wouldn't be telling people not to short equities if they have a huge conviction, but in my strategic system, I would say, what's the point of going short equities? You can just go long bonds. Every scenario in which equities have a bear market, rates will— interest rates will go significantly lower. So why bother with equities if you can make so much more money on interest rate futures?

And in terms of going long, well, you could stay long things you like to stay long, but I wouldn't be too long because, well, that's been a pretty good run.

China credit risk and a Minsky moment

Erik Townsend: Finally, Alex, since I know that you are a heavy-duty fixed income guy, some people think that Chinese credit expansion is where the really big risk factor is. Some people have even gone so far as to say that a Chinese credit blowup could cause a deflationary shock bigger than 2008 to hit the global economy. What do you think of that view? And how do you see the Chinese situation with respect to credit and fixed income?

Alex Gurevich: Well, I definitely agree that there is a risk there. In some sense, Chinese situation in certain ways is new and unprecedented because China just had been so big portion of the global growth and their credit expansion, their private debt has been both in a relative and absolute levels really, really large.

And typically, countries which have such weights of debt tend to go through catastrophic unwind. I don't know if there are any counterexamples to having this type of debt buildups leading to catastrophic unwind. The time horizons are very difficult with that because of the command economy and the many tools at their disposal to kick the can down the road. It's been— people thought that were going to blow up in 2015 and they did not. Some people are calling for a blowup of China even much earlier, even several years before that, and they keep kind of defying gravity and modeling their way through.

I tend to, if not 100% subscribe, but respect the theory that as China slows down, even though the slowdown seems to be very gradual and moderate, incrementally it becomes much and much harder for them to service the debt. Because as long as the economy grows very, very rapidly, Even if you're not profitable, you can service your debt through ever-pyramiding cash flows. But now that the growth becomes more normal, this kind of debt expansion might— it might be very difficult to service it.

And how are they going to manage to solve it and unwind it? That's a very big question because we don't have a history of a modern-day command economy. In the past, they've tried to do it and always catastrophically failed, but we don't know how could the economy of this size can deal with this, with all the tools, with Google, with whatever they have there, Baidu, with understanding of what's going on in the country, how to allocate resources, who they need to forgive debts to, who they need to prop, where they need to inject cash.

With having all this information, can they handle it? Probably not. I think there is a— from just purely theoretical perspective, there is an elevated risk of what they call a Minsky moment in a sense that unlike in Western economies, when you get this gradual decline and then it's just accelerating, rolling down the hill, there is some philosophical— you can expect it might be something like falling off a cliff in China. That is, China will just be okay, okay, okay until they're not okay at all. And I think that's the risk that people are talking about that you've been referring to. I think philosophically, Philosophically, there is definitely a possibility of this outcome. But I say philosophically because while we have no evidence that that's yet happening, we don't know. So far, they seem to be managing to contain things. We see all those cracks in the cement. They seem to be able to paint over it and make it look like new over and over again.

And at what point it will all just crash down, we don't know. And I found that it's hard to time it. It might happen 20 years from now, and even for long horizon traders, that might be a little too long to wait. But definitely risk is to be accounted for.

Wrap-up: reaching HonTe Investments; announcer break

Erik Townsend: Well, Alex, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. You run a hedge fund for a living, and as many of our accredited investors understand, you're not at liberty to talk in detail about your fund. But for the benefit of our accredited investor audience who's qualified to invest in hedge funds, how can they you to get your tear sheet and get connected with what you do there at HonTe Investments?

Alex Gurevich: Okay, so we could be found at HonTeInv.com. It's H-O-N-T-E-I-N-V.com. And you could— if you're an accredited investor, could register on this website to receive more information.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. Alex, I really look forward to getting you back in a few more months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air during the program. The program is brought to you from by Aalo Atomics, time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: hosts react to Gurevich; chartbook intro

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Alex back on the show. You know, I tend to still remain bullish bonds. I think as a tactical trader, I'm more willing to jump off that boat a little bit sooner than his long-term view. But a lot of the reasons why he remains bullish bonds, I still completely agree with so many of those views. At the same time, I absolutely love the fact that he was giving it a 50/50 that the Fed still moves in December. You know, that's something I think the market is not pricing in. So if, if that starts to be priced in, I think there's an opportunity to profit from that. Anyway, what did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I was shocked by just how outspoken Alex was about gold. I mean, I thought he was going to be super bullish. No surprise, you and I are both bullish on But the, the comment about drop everything, don't even finish listening to this interview, go buy gold right now, I wasn't quite expecting. Accordingly, let's go ahead and jump into our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered and don't yet have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, click on the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Alex's picture on the homepage.

S&P 500 breakout and momentum divergence

Erik Townsend: Jumping in here, Patrick, on slide 2, we've got an S&P 500 daily chart with some arrows showing these big rallies that we've had this year. What's going on?

Patrick Ceresna: Right, so to just give this context before we talk about the chart, I mean, we're at a really interesting moment in the S&P because whenever a market breaks to a higher high, if it's a legitimate breakout, there tends to be multiple months of rallying that subsequently follows that could easily see hundreds of S&P P points run to the upside, but a lot of people that are relatively bearish point out very quickly that often markets will have a fake out breakout, very similar to what we witnessed in October of 2007, where the market proceeded to make a higher high, but then it didn't stop the bear market from emerging on the other side. And so to me, this breakout is. Interesting, right? So we've broken to a higher high and we're about to get the big tell. Is this for real, or are we— is the market going to give it back and was it a completely false start? And one of the interesting clues I wanted to point out was looking at momentum, which, uh, is an indicator that looks at the velocity of the market moves.

And particularly what's interesting is that on all 3 prior rallies this year there wasn't a legitimate breakout in velocity and momentum as the market rallied. January 2019 was a no-brainer. When you wipe out, you know, close to 20% of the stock market in short order, the counter rally has usually got some serious velocity behind it. But even the June and, and September rallies that we saw in the markets that just drove the markets back to their highs saw a material pickup in momentum during that whole move. Yet this entire rally we saw in a October didn't even uptick momentum.

And, you know, it just makes me ask the question, does this in any way give more validity to the fact that this could be a false start? And that's one of the really interesting puzzle pieces that I'm going to be watching in the coming weeks with members.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think that's exactly the right question to ask. As I said in the market wrap and in the discussion with Alex, you know, you can make such a good argument either way. There's lots technical reasons to say, hey, fresh breakout to new all-time highs, could be hundreds of points higher from here. There's also plenty of reasons to say, look at why did the Fed just do what the Fed just did? The whole explanation of why we had to have a rate hiking cycle was so that they would have room, so that they would have ammunition to use when they needed it to fight a crisis. Well, why are they suddenly using up most of their ammunition? Could it be that they're a lot more concerned about this liquidity squeeze, which is causing repo markets to go crazy, than they're letting on? I think it's very possible. So there's room to make an argument for why the stock market maybe is about to crash 2008-style here.

There's plenty of room to make an argument for why it's going to go 500 points higher. I'm happy to be on the sidelines there. There's other things to trade. The stock market's not the only game in town.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So what I'll just add to that is that the one thing our listeners can keep an eye out, and that's going to be the big tell, is that does the market start a sell cycle that wipes out the entire October rally? I mean, if we're back to 2,900 in short order and that entire attempt to break out is given back, that would be a very bearish wave of price action. And for bulls, they want to hold 3,000. They want to hold the market up at along its highs during a consolidation and then use that as a springboard to launch a rally.

Gold chart: breakout candle, 1,520 and impeachment

Patrick Ceresna: So those are 2 kind of really interesting levels to keep in mind.

Anyway, on chart 3, page 3, we have the chart of gold. And last week we, uh, had that chart of gold had a big green breakout candle, and by the, the next day it was already given back and it was a false start. But here we are a week later, and here's that breakout candle again on gold. Now, to me, all of the consolidation highs at around $1,520 need to be broken. So even though the trend line has more or less been broken, uh, descending trend line's been broken, the— those highs have not been beat. So I wouldn't call this a breakout yet, but it'll be really curious to see whether gold can follow through. The one thing I believe, Erik, is, is that if this is a gold bull bull market, it's not going to give people a chance to buy the dip at $1,350.

I know that a lot of people talk about that, but a lot of the characteristics of bull markets is that the market runs and everyone has to chase it because it doesn't give opportunities to buy dips on with ease.

And if this was a true bull market, then this should just take off and leave everyone behind.

Erik Townsend: So I'll be curious to see whether gold can actually make a Well, and I think there's plenty of room to argue either side of this, Patrick.

The bear side of this is, hey, look, you've got one and only one daily candle in this chart that's moved above that trendline, and it's on a day that the House of Representatives is seriously debating impeaching the President of the United States. Obviously, the impeachment proceedings are contributing to the price of gold. If we don't have an impeachment vote by tomorrow or something, it's entirely possible this could all retrace. We could be back below that trend line, and, you know, maybe we are moving back down below the, the 1450 level at some point here. But frankly, as I look at this chart, if we have more geopolitical unrest, if we have more things go wrong, and certainly what if these impeachment proceedings led to a rise in US civil unrest and you had riots going on because people didn't— either didn't like the fact that the president was being impeached or a different group of people didn't like the fact that he wasn't being impeached, whichever the case may be.

That could drive a huge rally up. So we're at the beginning, I think, of something that could be a really big upside move. And I think the first thing to wait out is whether or not it's just impeachment fluff in the market that's going to come back out as we get past that vote and also to get past those recent highs. Once we do and we get above 1525 or so, if we stay above it, then I would look for maybe a drift down to retest that same trendline as support and then a move much higher. So as I said, I'm scaling into an unlevered position position in gold, a speculative position. I still want to keep some dry powder. I think there is a good chance that we'll get a lower entry point at some point, but I don't want to miss the move either. Just as Alex Gurevich said, when gold is at $5,000 an ounce a few years from now, you don't want to have missed it because you were trying to get in at $1,400 instead of $1,500.

So, I'm starting to average into a position, but I still want to keep some dry powder in case we do get that move lower.

Crude oil chart: $51.60 and $50 support

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, for sure. And so let's move on to chart 4, where I have a chart on oil. And there's that top end of the range where you called the turn earlier on Twitter, but this is kind of rolling back down. But what I want to really illustrate with oil is that we're still very much bound in what on this chart shows the volume by price, the high volume nodes where the consolidation Consolidations in oil really have happened, and we're right in the middle of that consolidation. So oil's not broken out in any significant way, either broken down nor broken higher. And my inclination is is that this is kind of rolling over, and we probably are going to see short-term weakness before we see a more bullish turn on the other side. But will we break those lows around that kind of 51, 52? That's a big question.

Do you have an opinion on that?

Erik Townsend: Well, I definitely agree. I think we're headed back down to $51.60, which is the lower end of this range that we've been in. There's a good argument to say that we'll get right down to $50 because that's where the low-volume node is on the TPO chart. So there's definitely, I think, a very bearish air going on. Now, this Keystone Pipeline disruption, that's, you know, shutting down a major pipeline that brings oil into the United States. Because it is in wetlands and there could be some environmental complications and the repairs might take a little longer than people are assuming, that could be a really big deal for the oil market. Yet still, the, the bottom's falling out of the price even on the day that that news is unfolding. So it really tells you that the oil market wants to move lower here. Getting back down to $51.60 Unless something big changes, seems like a cinch to me. The question is what happens from there?

Do we get the next move, which is down to $50 even? That's where the low-volume nodes are in the TPO charts. And if we saw a break below that, there's not a lot of support below that. It would really open the door to a potentially significant move lower. Everything we've seen, though, so far is, you know, for quite a while now, this $51.60 level has been saving the day. So it'll be interesting to see what happens when we get back down there.

10-year yield: double bottom or continuation

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, on chart 5, what I wanted to just touch on is that 10-year Treasury yield. I mean, you talked about it in the market wrap at the start, but what I find fascinating about this consolidation is a technician can see 2 things. One technician that wants to be bearish bonds will be looking for that as a double bottom on yields, while someone who is bullish on bonds will at this as a sideways, like horizontal triangle or a flat pattern that's a consolidation that will ultimately be a midpoint for a continuation pattern. And one of the big tells for me is really about 5 or 10 points lower as we approach 160, 165, because if we see yields, let's say, go south of 160, we're going lower. I mean, at that stage, I would even be banking we're going 130, 125, which is— I've been incredibly neutral bonds, and that would certainly make me feel like I need to put a position on with some urgency.

I'm actually wondering whether I should be in at all right now, like, or whether I should be already positioning. But I just wanted to point out that this consolidation will reveal a lot in the coming few days here.

Erik Townsend: Well, you can also argue the other side of this, Patrick, which is that last low was a higher low, and if we get a series of higher highs and higher lows, that starts to say that, that we are headed toward higher yields. As you said, if you go below 160, we're probably going much lower. Well, what happens if we get a daily close above 190, which is about where that green candle was a few weeks ago in September?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, that's what we'd call the double bottom, right? Like, that's, that's what the bond bears are looking for, right? Is, is that, you know, you want to see that the yields find support here, let's say 160 165, roll back up and punch 190 and higher, and that really solidifies an intermediate timeframe top in bonds and bottom in yields. And so I think that in the next couple of weeks that we're going to get— the market's going to reveal a lot of these interesting things.

December Eurodollar futures and the repo market

Patrick Ceresna: So moving on to chart 6 here, we have the chart on the Eurodollar in December 2019. And what I find fascinating here, Erik, is, is that it really doesn't look like the, uh, Eurodollar markets are worried about, uh, the Fed. And in fact, what I'm going to be watching so closely— I mean, Alex was saying that it was like a 5 or 10% chance of a cut in December, but be so curious whether or not this bullishly breaks out on the upside, forcing the hand and the market once again playing a scenario where they're pricing in a cut and making the Fed either have to oblige the market or So one of the more interesting things I'm going to be watching here in the coming week or two is whether or not these Eurodollar futures break out on the upside.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, it's going to be very interesting. And of course, the other thing that relates very closely to that is, do we continue to see this repo market craziness? I think a big reason that the Fed made this most recent cut and this whole series of cuts is because they're afraid of what's going on in the repo market. Is that liquidity situation going to solve itself, or is it going to get worse?

Erik Townsend: That's going to play a big role in this. In any event, we're going to leave it there in the interest of time, folks. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Be sure to check out my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen published on September 7th, 2019. The link is in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research If you haven't received our Research Roundup email, that means you're not yet registered at

Research Roundup contents and hosts' sign-off

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices.com.

Shame on you. Go to MacroVoices.com, register your free account, and the benefit to you is you will receive our Research Roundup email each week, which contains a list of links to all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week.

Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as the link to the charts we discussed in this postgame. There's also a really interesting article I linked in there from Chris Whalen titled Repo Madness and the Rest of the Story, and it kind of gives some great color on that repo thing you were mentioning as well. Uh, in Canada here we had, uh, the general elections, and, uh, there's an interesting David Rosenberg piece I linked in there on the new Canadian government, which saying the last time the Liberals had a minority, investors had no place to hide. And so you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.

Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer outro and disclaimer

Announcer: That concludes this week's episode of MacroVoices. This concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information.

Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag Bag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Diego Parrilla — Quadriga Asset Management CIO (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 190 was recorded on October 24th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, which happens to be my own favorite podcast when it comes to quant and rules-based investing. Quadriga Asset Managers CIO Diego Parrilla joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Diego has been getting a lot of attention for his anti-bubbles macro thesis, which we're going to discuss in full detail. Then we'll translate Diego's macro view to actionable trading strategies. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick and I will discuss the explosion of civil unrest which has occurred around the globe in the past week. And we'll also have a small chart book for extended precious metals market coverage.

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now listeners, please note that we taped this show early this week, late morning Eastern time on Thursday, So our market wrap and postgame discussion will not be informed of Thursday's closing numbers.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year yield

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's get to the S&P 500, which at the time of— we're recording is just over 3,000. Keep edging towards those highs. Are we going to break out?

Erik Townsend: You know, it feels like it to me. And as I've said many times on this show, I think that's crazy. I think the fundamentals ought to be sending the market straight down. But I think it's the bad is the new good doctrine where people are expecting more accommodation from the Fed and they expect that to drive markets higher. Maybe that'll work for another round. I've been surprised before. Someday that narrative is going to fail and it's going to fail hard, but it's not failing yet. The big macro risk, though, that I feel like almost everybody is mispricing right now is this explosion of civil unrest around the globe in the last week and the risk that it could come to the United States. And I do think that that's a much bigger possibility than most investors are considering right now. That's a long discussion. So let's save it for the postgame segment.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index, which is finally getting a little bit of a bounce after a pretty ugly week last week. So what's going on with the dollar here?

Erik Townsend: Well, we've seen a very significant pullback from almost 99.50 down to 97. We, we haven't seen a daily close below 97 quite yet, although there were some right on the hairy edge of it. So I think this is still a healthy pullback given the news flow that we've had, the Fed announcing this QE that's not really QE thing that they're doing.

There's plenty of reason for this pullback, and I still feel okay with it. But, you know, it's kind of gone as far as I want to see it go. Looks like we're bouncing here off of 97. I'm hoping that we continue to bounce. If that rally fails and we end up seeing closing prints below 97, I'm going to get a little more concerned and start to think, hmm, maybe Luke Gromen is being proven right sooner than I expected him to be. I've always known that Luke's dollar bearish view would triumph in the end. I just didn't think it was time yet, and I still don't, but a close below 97 would cause me to take pause.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil. What's your take on the inventory numbers?

Erik Townsend: Well, crude oil inventories were a real roller coaster this week. API, the private data service, reported a 4.5 million barrel build on inventory, very bearish signal, and that would have been, if it had been confirmed by EIA, it would have been the 6th weekly build in a row. So pretty long streak of builds there. It wasn't confirmed by EIA. EIA reported a drawdown of 1.7 million barrels, ending that 5-week build streak, but Cushing, Oklahoma still building 1.5 million barrels. That's a continuing trend in Cushing, and it reverses the previous trend. A lot of people, myself included, were concerned that the opening of 2 new pipelines was maybe going to drain Cushing out of most of its inventory. That doesn't seem to be happening. We are seeing a healthy replenishment of Cushing stocks, even in the face of nationwide builds. The big drawdowns, though, were in the finished products. Gasoline drawing down 3.1 million barrels, distillates drawing down 2.7 million barrels.

So between big drawdowns in finished products and a modest drawdown in crude, that sent the tape up, up, and away. And in fact, it didn't even wait for inventory. I don't know if somebody had the, the data early or what, but a couple hours before the inventory data came out, The, the market was really marching higher. And of course then that bullish inventory report accelerated the news to the upside. We got very easily to the 100-day moving average and even above it. That was at 55.65 on Wednesday. Looked like maybe that was going to contain it, but as we're speaking on Thursday, it's still early, before noon as we're recording this, we were all the way up to about 56.45, which happens to be the 5-month moving average. Earlier this morning. As we're speaking right now, we're just around the round number at $56.

Is this rally failing here? It looks to me like maybe this is just a pullback and we're probably headed up toward the 200-day moving average at $57.06. Might be over here, but I'm guessing that we're going to still see a little push higher. Fridays, just from a seasonality standpoint, Fridays are often up days for crude oil. So I wouldn't be surprised if by the time we close the week, we touch that $57.06 200-day moving average.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold. I know we're gonna discuss it a little bit more in the postgame, but what's your thinking here in terms of gold's consolidation at this $1,500 level?

Erik Townsend: Well, gold continues to just impress me at every turn with its resilience. Every time we start to see the beginnings of a sell-off, and I think to myself, okay, the pullback that I've predicted based on overdone sentiment indicators and so forth is finally upon us, as soon as it gets started, Something happens, and at the moment it seems like fear associated with the upcoming Brexit vote is helping to push gold higher. Very strong day as of this morning. We're up quite a bit, kind of breaking out of a fairly flat consolidation pattern for the last week or so. You know, we're not to the point of a real breakout to the upside, but definitely it's time to reevaluate whether or not the pullback I've been expecting is really coming or not. So let's save the rest for postgame when we can go into some more detail.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield, which is hovering around 1.75% as we're recording. What's your thinking here on the next big move in interest rates?

Erik Townsend: Well, I do think we're going to go back and retest 1.50% again, but I'm a little more inclined to take profits at 1.50% if that's what happens, because it feels to me like we're really getting into a trading range here between 1.50% and 1.75%. And are we really going to see that break lower than 1.50%? I definitely I do think there's bearish fundamentals in the economy, but on the other hand, everyone's expecting the Fed to come riding to the rescue. And this current version of short-term QE that they've introduced is not designed to push long-term interest rates down. It's only designed to provide short-term liquidity. So that's not unto itself a reason to expect lower yields. So I think we'll see 150 again. I'll probably take profits on my long position, which is still open, just above breakeven right now.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay. Okay. Well, thanks for the update, Erik. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Diego Parrilla. Now, why did we invite Diego to be on the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Diego is a really big picture macro thinker. He's got a great perspective. He's in Europe, which I think is important to get that European perspective because obviously the situation with the changing of the guard at the ECB and so forth, it's a whole different dynamic that European asset managers are dealing with. And we haven't had a European fund manager as a feature interview in several weeks now, so it seemed overdue. And he's just a really smart guy, first-time guest, and I'm really looking forward to having

Erik Townsend: him on the show today. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. I did a full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, the host of this excellent podcast, back on September 7th, 2019. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. We discussed a number of key issues about the value of having a rules-based investment strategy in your portfolio. In our conversation, Niels shared some insights that may surprise you, especially when it comes to trend-following strategies not really operating the way some market commentators suggest they do.

For more information, including a free book about trend following and the accredited investor slide deck from my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, just go to toptradersunplugged.com/roundup. Check them out. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Diego Parrilla is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Diego Parrilla introduced: The Energy World Is Flat and The Anti-Bubbles

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Diego Parrilla. A portfolio manager with Quadriga Asset Managers, and a good friend and co-author with our good friend Daniel Lacalle. Daniel and Diego co-authored The Energy World Is Flat: Opportunities from the End of Peak Oil, published in 2014. And Diego is the sole author of The Anti-Bubbles: Opportunities Heading into Lehman Squared and Gold's Perfect Storm.

Diego prepared an excellent slide deck to accompany today's interview, and I strongly encourage you to download it. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Diego's picture. Diego, thanks so much for joining us. I want to go ahead and jump right in with the investment thesis that you focus your work around. Of course, you co-authored You co-authored that book with Daniel Lacalle with respect to The Energy World Is Flat: Opportunities from the End of Peak Oil, and your new book is called The Anti-Bubbles. Tell us what those are about.

Diego Parrilla: Well, thanks, Erik. The Energy World Is Flat presented a highly contrarian view of the world. I mean, we're looking at 2014, we have $120 oil, we have the consensus view of peak oil, which was looking at say $200. And there we came in with a thesis that was arguing for the flattening of the energy world, which had 2 major implications. One was the convergence across energies with big losers such as oil. And second, the convergence across regions, the globalization with big losers such as natural gas, or in this case, LNG. Now, the combination of these powerful forces through the flatteners effectively led to the variable convergence, the flattening of the energy world, which we argued $30 to $50 oil was a reasonable target. That probably sounded like science fiction to a lot of people at the time. It didn't take too long for some of these flattening forces to take force, especially with OPEC folding, and we saw what happened.

So, I guess that But being a contrarian, being a bit of a chess player, being early in the game, identifying more forces. As an engineer, I do look at the world more as equilibriums, balances, forces. And sometimes you find these sort of big imbalances that it's a matter of when, not if, that things will happen. So, some of these forces are more obvious. Some of them might be slow grinding. Some of them might be driven by paradigm shifts, like obviously technology. and other game changers. But eventually, it's a matter of when, not if, that these dynamics play out. And sometimes, they turn out to show the emperor has no clothes. There are massive winners, massive losers in the process. So, I found this process incredibly powerful. As I always say, I thought I knew it. And teaming up with Daniel was fantastic. He came in more from the energy equities world, perhaps, and me from the energy commodities. We tend to share views, but very often, we also found ourselves looking at a square and a circle thinking this is what's going on.

It turns out talking to each other, we're looking at a cylinder. We're both correct. It really brought this perspective and the analysis and the views after finishing the book to a different level. I learned so much through that process. That I kept that discipline of writing. I guess my brain looks for these relationships. Yeah, the second book reflects this thinking. It's a similar framework in the sense that I'm looking at imbalances, I'm looking at forces.

This time around, the book is more focused on the macro space, and it goes hand in hand with the strategies and the funds that I manage. But the common theme is we're looking at effectively a highly contrarian investment thesis that challenges the status of the world. And perhaps it might be a bit early, but the process is, in both cases, not only survived, but it's actually been reinforced. So, in this sense, The second book, which is very relevant to today's world and dynamics, it's also bringing and coining the concept of the anti-bubble or anti-bubble, potato, potato, which I think it could be very helpful for the listeners.

What an anti-bubble is: Soros's framework inverted

Erik Townsend: What is the anti-bubble? Please explain that concept.

Diego Parrilla: Yeah, so perhaps it's best to start with the definition of a bubble, and I like to borrow George Soros's definition. He talks about bubbles as assets that are artificially expensive based on a belief that perhaps is very deeply entrenched in people's minds, but it happens to be false, what he calls a misconception.

We could debate at length today on whether Bitcoin is going to change the world or not, it's out of scope, but certainly, the belief that it might do can drive certain valuations. For other people, it might be a very different world. To be honest, only time will tell, but to a certain extent, certainly, beliefs can actually distort reality.

In that sense, the concept of the anti-bubble is born from a generalization of George Soros' framework. Perhaps the first dimension of the concept leads with the fact that misconceptions not only distort reality through artificially high prices, which we call bubbles, you could also have artificially low prices and valuations, which I define as the anti-bubble. We're looking at effectively assets that are grossly artificially cheap based on a belief that happens to be false, where it's a matter of when, not if, that they will go up.

Now, there's a second dimension that is important, and it is the fact that bubbles and anti-bubbles are somewhat like distorted mirror images of the same misconceptions. They're effectively 2 reflections of the exact same process. So, by construction, once the misconception is understood, and the bubble burst is the exact same catalyst and timing as the anti-bubble goes up, because they're effectively the exact same process. So, I called it anti-bubble, a bit like an antivirus or an anti-missile. It's a defense mechanism against the bubble, as I say, which is pretty close to perfect hedge, because they're the same process.

But there's also a third dimension that is relevant, and it's the fact that these bubbles and anti-bubbles are also interrelated. There's some sort of a symbiotic relationship between them. They feed on each other.

If we look, for example, at what in my view are clear bubble-antibubble relationships, such as the S&P and the VIX, they're not independent processes. One might argue that some of the artificially high valuations in the S&P are partially driven by artificially low VIX, whether it's in the form of complacency, whether it's both for qualitative and quantitative reasons, which we can discuss in more detail. Either way, the interesting thing and the opportunity is that, or the ironic thing we could argue as well, is that nobody wants to buy puts in the S&P at 3012 vol, yet everybody seems to be rushing to buy that insurance when the S&P is at 2400 and the VIX is at 40.

In that sense, what we see is a great opportunity. In fact, the market is willing to give us the insurance the cheapest when we need it the most. There's an element here of risk premia, where we are being compensated for taking the other side of complacency and panic. So, in that sense, the anti-bubble has these 3 dimensions of value, of hedge, and of risk premia. which effectively lead us to bring tremendous opportunities. There's a wider framework. And I guess the question here is, okay, focus on the beliefs and focus on the misconceptions because they are the ones that will actually give you the clue. And again, looking back and looking forward and where the opportunities might lie.

The central bank put, financial bullying and the search for yield

Erik Townsend: Diego, when I hear you talking about beliefs and misconceptions, what immediately comes to my mind is this notion, which a lot of people call the central bank put The idea that, hey, no, it doesn't really matter what happens, what goes wrong, because the Fed's got our back. We've seen for the last 10 years, they're gonna come riding to the rescue with more accommodative monetary policy. They're gonna rescue the market. We don't need to be worrying about buying those puts that you're talking about on the S&P because the Fed's got our back. I think this has got to be the greatest complacency bubble in the history of the world. Everybody's just convinced nothing can go wrong.

I think valuations are out of sight. Does that come into your thinking, and how does that play in?

Diego Parrilla: Well, 100%. I would argue the central bank put is central to— it's perhaps one of the biggest beliefs, in my view, misconceptions that is effectively shaping, has been shaping global markets for a long time. Linking it back to OPEC, for example, in the first book, there was this very widely held belief in the OPEC put. You remember this idea that oil was perfectly— it would hold at such high prices because mommy and daddy, Saudi and OPEC, were infallible and full control, whereas the reality was quite different. At the end of the day, Saudi needs X dollars per barrel, or rather, they need, let's say, $100 for fiscal and other big issues that they may need to finance. And whether that's produced with 1 barrel at $100, or 2 at $50, or 4 at $25, they still need that money. But nevertheless, there was this perception that they could just cut production and be fully in control, which obviously wasn't the case. In fact, this relationship, this metastable equilibrium breaks.

And once it breaks, then it actually collapses, because then it brings this race to the bottom. Obviously, with the benefit of hindsight, that's pretty obvious. In the energy book, we were challenging that put. In fact, we were looking at this as one of the sources of risk and game changers. I think we have a similar dynamic here. The central bank put, I would describe it as the belief, in my view, misconception that central banks and governments are infallible and in full control, and they can print and borrow their way out of problems without any adverse consequences. Now, this is, I think, flawed. And it feeds into arguably 2 sub-beliefs that are very important. The first one is the belief that monetary policy has no limits.

And the second one is the idea that fiscal policies have no limits. And we have seen this belief being played out. It takes many names. It takes never fight the Fed. It's Draghi's whatever it takes. It's PBOC in China is in control.

We have seen the relentless bullying and financial bullying with not only playing by the rules, which I would argue that bringing interest rates to zero and to some extent, QE and printing money was within the rules, but then actually breaking into what in my view is just one step too far, which is negative interest rates and what's to come in the form of helicopter money and other things that I believe we will certainly In fact, they're already happening, they just accelerate.

This central bank put, again, you mentioned, and we agree, it's central. It has, I would argue, 2 main implications. The first one is complacency, the perception that there's no risk, but even if there was, don't worry, because if things go wrong, mommy and daddy will come and rescue us. The second one is arguably even more dangerous, which is the financial bullying is in Europe, Facing negative interest rates, we're literally being told we're pretty stupid just holding, saving money or holding your cash.

This drives, I guess, a second wave, which is also critical in the process that might be even more complex and complicated because they feed on each other, which is what I would define as the complacent desperate search for yield.

Erik Townsend: Diego, as we talk about these complacencies and so forth, I think as you said, a huge one is this idea that we can have negative interest rates. We haven't talked about modern monetary theory yet, but I think there's this desperate search for yield and this complacency that people don't think if they keep searching for yield that they're eventually going to introduce risk that's going to come back and bite them. So, how does that factor into your whole thinking about all this?

Diego Parrilla: This is very important. I guess the complacency and the financial bullying, and we've been incentivized, or perhaps rather forced to take more risk. We've been building the house to the roof. Once upon a time, we would go to the market and say, hey, I want to take X amount of risk, how much do you pay me for it? We're in a situation now where we say, listen, I want my 5%, tell me what I need to do.

What we've done is really take incremental risk in each and every single dimension you can think of. The first one, and perhaps critical, is term premia, is the bubble in duration, is fixed income government bonds, is lending for longer and longer for lower and lower yields. We've seen 30-year bonds now negative. We've seen obviously this thirst for duration with 100-year Austrian bonds, a process that has been driven by this combination of thirst for yield and also artificially high demand from governments in the form of QE and others, benchmarks, etc. I would argue that this is the epicenter of the problem, but not the problem itself. Things really start going wrong where effectively, we go into the second dynamic, which is the credit risk premium. Obviously, with negative yields in AAA bonds, we are going down the chain with perhaps investment grade, mezz, high yield, and obviously, emerging markets, lending to weaker and weaker credits for longer and longer for lower and lower yields, and creating what I think is a major bubble across the spectrum, including high yield and zombies and everything else.

This distortion of the fixed income market, Credit markets leads into the third wave, which is equity risk premia. The put-call parity relationship, it's broken with negative yields. You're discounting highly complacent expectations with artificially cheap interest rates, artificially low. You're looking at artificially low inflation. You're looking at so many things that impact buybacks, that impact the valuations, which lead us to investors wanting to capture the liquidity premium, which I would argue is that fourth dimension, whether it's private equity with this hot potato of higher and higher valuations and more leverage, or private credit, where we have effectively shadow banking with lending all over the place, disguised very often as FinTech, this cool word. But this is stuff that is happening off the system, unregulated, and very dangerous. Liquidity, I think, as we'll come back, is one of the major issues we've seen already, people gating. We've seen a lot of the issues with the the repo, and many other ways in which liquidity is a wider term, but it's critical in what's to come.

Then brings us to leverage. Of course, I want my 5%. My mom used to earn that in Europe, her 5% with 1-year AAA unlevered bonds not that long ago. Today, she'd have to go to BBBs, 10, 15 years x-time levered.

This process, if you add on top of that, what I think is effectively a case of gross mis-selling, these income strategies, quote unquote, where people are selling short volatility strategies in multiple ways disguised as income strategies. It's very different if I own a house in Miami and I rent it, what I collect is indeed income. If I am selling hurricane insurance on your house, what I collect is not income, it's insurance premium at the expense of insurance liability. You have a Feb 2018 VIX hurricane come and people get completely wiped out. What's happened in here, the conclusion, and these 2 forces, the central bank put and the desperate search for yield are feeding on each other. This complacency, this financial bullying, this desperation for yield are leading to what I would summarize as from risk-free interest to interest-free risk. That nice little concept we have in the textbooks, R sub F is now given way to a world where we're literally doing insane things like locking in negative yields for incredible long times.

What it's done is it's created, in my view, this series of parallel synchronous bubbles, which I would argue that after years and decades, it's taken us to a point where I would argue they're too big to fail. This is effectively a new paradigm, which brings tremendous risks, and I would argue also opportunities for investors.

Too big to fail, Lehman squared, and why the rules will change

Erik Townsend: And how do you translate— I mean, too big to fail, obviously, these institutions that are not allowed to fail even when they should because it's feared by regulators that they're too big to fail. Someday they are going to fail and there's nothing that's going to be done about it. So when you say there's opportunities for investors, do you mean that you're speculating they will eventually fail, or are you talking about how to profit from the fact that regulators are likely to keep them propped up as long as they can?

Diego Parrilla: Well, I would argue that obviously too big to fail takes different forms. 2008, it was all about the banks. It was all about keeping the systemic risk of Lehman. It's almost a lose-lose, right? Or a win-win. I mean, you need to keep them alive, otherwise the system collapses. But if you keep them alive, then you're incentivizing the wrong behavior.

But the reality is the too big to fail is now a much broader term. We're talking about China being too big to fail. We're talking about the duration bubble being too big to fail. We're talking about the zombies in Europe being too big to fail, which means you can't hike rates. We're talking about all these massive bubbles that we've built that go way and beyond institutions.

That's where the Lehman squared, I would argue it's more like Lehman cubed in terms of the challenges that we're facing. Obviously, I think To me, 4Q, the Q4 of 2018 was an inflection point. I think this process of normalization of monetary policy, where there was a perception that after all these years of excess and low rates and QE and increased debt, we could just turn things around and normalize things, it became pretty clear to the Fed and the rest of the world that that's just not going to be possible. A lot of people forgot about this. It's not even a year ago, but we saw GE, amongst others, being on the brink of collapse with the implications it would have had. I think the Fed realized that it was a lot closer. This increase in volatility, this increase in correlations, this increase in forced liquidation, which was starting to have an impact in liquidity, was pretty close to becoming a major liquidity event.

We barely dodged the bullet and what could have been also a reflexive move. I think what we are seeing today, again, I'm particularly worried, and I think China is a great example of what might come, but the reality with too big to fail is they simply cannot fail. As a result, they will be transformed.

I think if I look at the macro picture, if I had to summarize it very quickly, I would argue that all these years of money printing and debt haven't really solved the problems. All we've done is it has delayed, enlarged, and to a certain extent, transferred these problems across currency wars, beggar thy neighbor. Now, we are in a situation where all these dynamics, which are contagious, complacent, etc., have led to bubbles that are so large that we can't let them collapse, therefore, we're going to see a very, very preemptive central banks all over the world sending rates to zero, including the Fed, effectively paving the way for massive fiscal expansion with expenditures and debts and MMTs that will never be paid back, will be effectively extended to maturity, they'll be whatever, but they'll never be paid back. We have clearly a problem medium-term, longer-term of inflation.

We are now— the problem of bubbles that are too big to fail effectively means that we are in the process of transforming these bubbles into inflation. Now, there's plenty of room for miscalculation here. There's plenty of risks. The losers are pretty obvious to some extent, but there are also anti-bubbles in the process, and they're also widowmakers, to be honest.

I would argue that number one of the rule of the investment game is that they will change the rules. If you play the game thinking, oh, inflation is the endgame, therefore, rates will go up, I should short bonds, long bonds, I think you might find yourself in deep trouble, because the new enemy is the bubbles, it's not inflation. They're going to let inflation run, and it will also feed through the currency, which is what they want. But you're not going to see the rules of the game are changing. And this, again, opens a complex world that is becoming increasingly polarized between extremes of either these bubbles completely implode into what would be catastrophic in terms of their potential size and impact, or we transform those into a different problem, which today, Today, inflation is seen as the lesser evil. I'm sure our grandparents would disagree. In that sense, the damage is done. I think it'd be foolish to think that everything that we've done is something you can just get out nicely.

This is something that is compounding these problems and is extremely polarized and is accelerating. Yes, there's lots of risks, but there are also anti-bubbles and other opportunities in this framework. Although, as I always say, I hope I'm wrong because it's not a pretty picture.

China, currency wars, trade wars and gold

Erik Townsend: Diego, as we take this, first of all, I couldn't agree more with you on this big picture. And I think, as you say, they're going to change the rules. They're going to take desperate measures in order to keep things propped up. And it's probably going to result in a whole bunch of government spending and a whole bunch of bond issuance and so forth.

One of the conclusions that I come to is it's hard for me to see how gold doesn't benefit stupendously from this. And there's lots of ways this could go down, but it's hard for me to see how they, they bailed things out and changed the rules without eventually resulting in a major increase in the US dollar per ounce value of gold. I'm guessing that you agree with that from the title of your book, including gold's Are we on the same page there? And how does that play into your thesis?

Diego Parrilla: We're 100% on the same page. I think gold is sort of part of the checkmate of these dynamics. There are very clear processes. I think it's worth discussing how we get to this checkmate and how it— and I think China is a good example, right? So China is a country that operates under either a semi-open or semi-closed system. I mean, it does trade with the world, but it does it in a way where there's lots of rigidities on the exchange rate and monetary policy and other manipulations.

What's been happening is they know what they need to do, but in reality, every time they face the crisis, they've done 3 things. They've printed money, they've lent that money, and they've created implicit guarantees on people. If you're about to bail out, whether you're a broker or a construction company, suddenly, you're state-owned or whatever else. Now, this process, this money that has been printed and lent that can't leave the system effectively finds its way like water into 2 main buckets, infrastructure and real estate, whether it's another bridge to nowhere or a ghost city or whatever. You have this dynamic where all this monetary and fiscal abuse ends up up a bit like Spain, where I'm originally from, feeding and finding its way to these bubbles. We're talking about real estate, and these are not my numbers, this is some of the main investment banks, over $40 trillion of real estate bubble.

I would argue this is definitely in the too big to fail category, because if you actually think about, okay, what would happen if these bubbles fail and what is the process, you think about the asset values going down, the developers going down, your collateral at the bank, your wealth effect, the banking asset liabilities, the lending, etc., the house of cards collapses.

What's going to happen is in the case of Spain, we have leftist countries like Podemos. China obviously has other issues. 3% of the wealth of the Chinese is in equities. Think about it, it's all bricks, other forms of wealth. If that shoe fell, this is pretty major. So, it's not going to fall, but it's not going to fall because it shouldn't fall. It's not going to fall because they will keep those housing prices in yuan artificially high. Now, that doesn't mean that those house prices will stay high in dollars or euros or yen or whatever. So, the degree of freedom, and this is very, very important to understand, the way in which China blows up is through the currency front. So, currency devaluation, manipulation, et cetera, which we're not talking about a small 5% move, we're talking about a major move. Effectively, it's more of the same. As a European, I would argue that part of the 2012 crisis came from the US QE in 2008, sending the euro to 150, and along with it, the euro-yuan, which with the Chinese currency was pegged.

As a European, I have sympathy for Draghi, who walks into the office and says, hey, man, I need to defend myself and Europe came in, and not only did QE in another form, it actually had to go way bigger and way farther with negative rates as part of this contagious process, which then led to China doing stuff in August '15 and January '16, etc., etc.

This circle eventually brings us to a situation where, why are we doing currency wars? What are the benefits and risks? I think it's important to understand that there's obviously positives and negatives. The positives, well, start with the negatives. You have certain bubbles, you have inflation, because if the yuan is 20% weaker, then oil in yuan is 20% more expensive. Now, this is more than offset in the case of China by the benefits, which is, oh, I am a cheap labor, I'm competitive, I'm a cheaper economy to produce. Therefore, people send their factories, they do the investment, the spending. The economic activity, employment, etc. China is balancing these 2 forces of the negatives of inflation and bubbles with the positives of other until you get trade wars, because trade wars is very critical, is the new phase, and is very much a defense mechanism against currency wars. We need to understand that when you have a beggar-thy-neighbor, when someone is misbehaving and sending you the crisis, in the way of cheaper, artificially cheaper production costs and whatever.

At the end of the day, Mr. Trump, whether you like him or not, he basically looks at this and says, hey, General Motors, I didn't bail you out so that you produce in China. I bailed you out to produce in Chicago and Detroit. So, you know what, by law, you're not going to be able to do this. And by the way, Apple, I know you don't owe me anything, but to be honest, if you want to produce 20% cheaper, in China, I'm going to tariff you by 20%.

All trade wars are doing is neutralizing these currency wars. The important thing to understand is that then the emperor has no clothes, because the economies that have been effectively trying to print and borrow their way out of their problems, they begging through beggar-thy-neighbor, find that they're left with the bubbles and the inflation, and they have no benefit. Then you have Venezuela, and then you have Argentina. So, the flip between China from a perceived world power to a complete Ponzi, it might be more fragile than people think. And to some extent, it might fall by its own weight, or it might be triggered by some of these dynamics.

So, in this sense, going back to gold, if I look at the currencies around the world, and this is a marathon race, you would ask me, Diego, who's going to win the race, or who's going to lose the race? I would think this is an easy call. I think gold will win the race, and people like Venezuela or Turkey or Argentina will lose the race. It is less clear to me whether the dollar, the euro, or the yen, how they will peg in this race.

My contrarian view, because believe it or not, it is a view that gold and the dollar are both up, happens to be a contrarian view, and it gives you opportunities also to structure trades with very, very attractive risk-reward. So, I do think gold will be a big winner, and it's a critical part of this process of printing and borrowing your way out and currency and trade wars.

Portfolio construction as a football team

Erik Townsend: Diego, I couldn't agree more with you on the big macro picture, but I know our listeners will thank me if I ask you to translate that now to portfolio construction. How do we take all of these big picture ideas and translate them to what to invest in?

Diego Parrilla: Well, great question. I think Warren Buffett has 2 rules of investment. He often talks about don't lose money, and rule number 2, don't forget rule number 1, which sounds great and very wise, but I think it's somewhat cynical in the approach because many of the long-only people will face very significant losses during a Lehman scenario or others.

I do agree with him that this is a game of capital preservation. First and foremost, and I think what he means is you need to compound on that capital preservation. To some extent, cash might help you there in the short run, but I think there are much more efficient ways to do this.

Let me perhaps— this is a global audience, but let me take an example using a portfolio as if it was a soccer team, a football team. Trust me, it has quite deep messages. The first point I would make, and this is for the listeners just to reflect on, is many people think that investing is a game where you win by scoring goals. It's all about making money. I'm investing my money, I want to make money. I want to make capital gains, I want to make income gains. It's this mindset of striker, it's all about scoring goals, whereas in reality, whether it's the case in football or basketball or any sport, there's also a very important aspect of the game, which is playing defense.

In fact, I think that in order to win, you must first not lose. To me, it's all about capital preservation and compounding on that. When you build a portfolio, the first thing we need to be aware of is this, that some people might be playing by the wrong rules. We think that it's all about scoring goals, and as a result, we have 10 or even 11 strikers.

Your equities, your credit, your high yield, your EM, your commodities, your private equity, private debt, venture, real estate, the whole lot is designed to go and make me money.

I think in that sense, when you look at the team, there's some hidden risks, particularly one, which I define as the risk of false diversification. False diversification is confusing the fact that you have a lot of stuff in your portfolio. I have some Argentina, some oil, some Amazon, whatever, thinking that I'm actually diversified when in reality, it's all one trade, all one big trade.

I think we don't need to go that far. I would ask investors, and I'm not trying to be clever or anything, I'm just saying, hey, how did your portfolio do in the last quarter in 2018? How did you do? Were you as diversified as you thought you were?

Were you running more risk than you thought? The answer probably is that many have been caught into this perceived or artificially low volatility, which is perhaps the most important anti-bubble in the system, is an asset that is grossly artificially cheap, the volatility and the perception of risk, but also artificially low correlation. You have a portfolio that for a while looks like it has no risk, low volatility, low correlation, But when things go wrong, you get volatilities going exponentially higher and correlations increasing to +1 or -1, effectively resulting in exponential growth in value at risk and risk-adjusted measures. What it means is you have this forced liquidation, everybody has the same trade, and this compounds.

I think this is a major concern, and I would actually urge investors to look at their portfolios And watch carefully for that possibility of only strikers and looking at the area, false diversification.

Now, if you look at the rest of the team, going back, some people tell me, Diego, my defender is cash. I would argue, keeping the football analogy, soccer analogy, is that cash is not really a defender. Cash is a striker in the bench. You have money set aside, which you're holding there, waiting for the right opportunity to buy another striker, but it's not going to make you money necessarily. It's there, and it works just like if you had a striker. If you leave it there for a few matches, it's okay. You leave it there for a few years, you're going to have a problem with inflation.

Then we have what I call Beckenbauer. Those who are old enough and fluent enough in soccer will know he's is one of the Michael Jordans, one of those amazing footballers from Germany in the '70s, captain, great defender, and he has done effectively the German Bund, has been an incredible defender for the portfolio, but Franz Beckenbauer is now 73 years old. There's very limited room to, in my view, with already 30 years at deep negative rates, well, negative rates, that it will have significant room for defending This is a major problem, because this whole concept of 60/40 balanced portfolios, the idea that my equities, if they ever fall, my bonds are there with my 5% yield to protect me, in Europe is certainly not the case, neither in Japan. The thought that rates are going to go to -5%, I think is ludicrous. I think you will see 0% to -1% being the sweet spot of negative rates.

I think Germany is more likely to borrow 5 trillion at -1 than 1 trillion at -5.

What it brings us, and just compounding the problem and putting the perspective, is not only we have— we're playing the game by the wrong rules, which is we think we only win by scoring goals, we're playing with 11 strikers, by the way, many of them very expensive. This mindset that you win by having perhaps 11 Ronaldos, where that's not necessarily the case with cash, that is suffering from long-term inflation and bonds that are suffering. Obviously, in the US, and I think Treasuries have a role to play, they're arguably one of the very few markets in the world that has AAA dollar and room to actually make gains in duration. I think Treasuries should play and have still room to play, but it actually urges, it creates the urge for us to find defensive assets. Defenders to balance back those portfolios.

I do agree that gold has a big role to play, but I'd like to elaborate on a couple more people that— because this is about educating the listeners and investors.

I think, again, I'm not in possession of the truth, but let's look at conventionally a piece of the puzzle that is generally viewed as a defender, which are trend followers, CTAs. Very often, it is understood They did well in 2008. But in reality, if you actually ask yourself, okay, what position is the CTA playing in the pitch? What am I asking this guy to do? The reality is that we're basically telling the trend follower, hey, when I'm attacking, go and score all the goals for me. In fact, in a situation like today, where markets, the trends have been very strong, where volatility is very low, effectively, they're playing at the very top, and they're all in and probably levered.

Unfortunately, when the team counterattacks, what we're telling the players, listen, run really, really fast, put the gloves on and do all the saves. Then by the way, when we attack again, go and run and score the goals for me. What sounds totally stupid in a football pitch somehow seems feasible for some people or rational in the portfolio, it is not. Some of these perceived defenders are not.

Currently, or defenders. In fact, they're pretty much the opposite. I think this is important to understand because sometimes in the industry, you have a lot of frustration with, okay, I bought this strategy, I thought I had a defender and turned out I had a guy in offside or red-carded or whatever.

I think in that sense, the portfolio needs to look at strategies that are going to behave the way we expect them, the way they're meant to, And in that sense, I am the goalkeeper of the portfolio. I run a strategy that believes strongly in gold. It believes in Treasuries, but perhaps the key asset that will provide very, very explosive and highly predictable payouts is financial insurance, is options. Here, I think there's tremendous opportunities to achieve what I would argue is almost the Holy Grail, which is artificially cheap premium with very low carry, potentially even positive, and very explosive returns when you need them.

This is part of the construction that I would look at.

Clearly, before we get perhaps into some trade examples, if you're interested, I would just complete the picture by saying be careful with credit. Credit is an asset class that in this endgame, where we are either going into a major blowup or inflation, Unfortunately, credit is going to do bad in both. You will lose if there's a big credit event, but I really don't know what your €94 will buy you in 30 years or with inflation kicking in.

Those gains, those principal repayments that you will get in a long time with inflation, I think they're not going to do that much. If you want to play with strikers, I think selectively equities, will do better, at least in an inflation scenario. I think real assets like real estate, whilst they might look quite expensive, I think they have a role to play more in the midfield. But certainly, my focus and what I do is goalkeeping. And in particular, I think these 3 assets, gold, Treasuries, and financial insurance, have a lot of value to add.

Diego's funds and contact details

Erik Townsend: Diego, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Unfortunately, in the interest of time, I'm not going to be able I'm not going to be able to take you up on your offer to get into specific trade examples, but for the benefit of our listeners who may want to follow up with you and learn more about what you do at Quadriga Asset Managers please tell us first of all what business you're in and how people can contact you.

Diego Parrilla: Thank you so much for the opportunity. It's been a pleasure. Sure. I'm a portfolio manager. I run a series of strategies. I'm the goalkeeper. We have an offshore strategy. With daily liquidity, and which has the support from large institutional investors. We are in advanced discussions and process to launch also a US onshore solution. In that sense, what we do is differentiated in the way it's constructed and likely to perform. It uses those building blocks I discussed. It's precious metals, it's Treasuries, and financial insurance I'm reachable directly on my email, perhaps easier for people to look me up in Twitter and then I can link them up. I am @ParrillaDiego, double R, double L, and at Quadriga is diego.parrilla@quadrigafunds.es.

Once again, Parrilla, double R, double L. It'd be my pleasure. We don't run retail strategies. We work at the accredited level. But certainly very happy to continue the dialogue and the education, hopefully preventing some mistakes or potential accidents, and hopefully contributing to creating those large returns when we need them.

So thank you again for the opportunity, and I look forward to continuing the dialogue.

Erik Townsend: Okay. And for the benefit of the accredited investors in our audience who are qualified to invest in your funds. What is the Twitter handle and email address?

Diego Parrilla: Twitter is @ParrillaDiego. That's P-A-R-R-I-L-L-A Diego, D-I-E-G-O. That's my Twitter. And my email address is diego.parrilla@quadrigafunds.es.

Erik Townsend: Well, thanks so much for a great interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here Here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, that was a great interview. I really enjoyed the way Diego used the analogies towards sports and this idea of a lot of people are looking for diversification through having a whole bunch of strikers. I like the way he put that. And truth is, you have to build a portfolio that actually can play defense. The problem, I guess, until about, uh, last year, having a whole bunch of defense in your portfolio really forced your portfolio to underperform. But, uh, at least, uh, in the last year, Treasury bonds and gold and things like this have actually been doing well. What is interesting though is that he did mention options, and, uh, particularly the idea of using options as a way to build these asymmetric trades, to build hedges in there. And I— that's definitely something that I always find, uh, at least I have a lot of passion in doing. But it was really good. I really enjoyed the interview. Anyway, moving on though, you did want to talk a bit about the civil unrest and what's happening, and you had some ideas.

So what was on your mind, Erik?

Postgame: global civil unrest in Chile, Hong Kong and the US

Erik Townsend: Well, there's been an absolute explosion of civil unrest around the world in the last In Chile, there were massive, massive protests, riots. I think it was 38 subway stations that were burned beyond recognition by people who were supposedly upset about a 30 Chilean peso— that's 4 cents US, less than a nickel— increase in subway fares. And I think there's a common trend here. You know, you look at the situation in Hong Kong, and the— I think we're up to something like 20 weeks of protests that have turned violent in Hong Kong as well.

Well, the Hong Kong situation was brought about by this extradition bill, which has now been formally rescinded and withdrawn, but that's not causing the protests to stop. And I think that what we're seeing is these things are straws that broke camels' backs. Really, the situation in Hong Kong is about the fact that Hong Kongers don't trust China to honor the 2047 treaty date for fully absorbing Hong Kong into Chinese culture. They're afraid that Hong Kong is going to be annexed before that, and the extradition bill was just one particular straw that broke that camel's back. Similarly, in Chile, I think what happened there, this tiny little 30 peso increase in subway fares was really something that just broke the back of a population that was very, very frustrated and unhappy about what they perceived to be extreme social inequality. They don't like the fact that President Piñera is a rich guy. And frankly, I'm not sure that there's a whole lot of logic there, but there's a lot of people who are very upset.

And we're seeing these trends all around the world, and the things that they share in common are that it seems like it's very slow at first, and then all of a sudden, all at once, there's an explosion of violence and mayhem and crazy stuff going on.

Well, most Americans are in the habit of saying, yeah, but that's— crazy stuff goes on in other countries, and it never happens, you know, it's not going to happen here. Well, consider the fact that in just a few weeks, President Trump is either going to be impeached or I should say the House of Representatives will either vote to impeach President Trump and send that impeachment bill to the Senate. If that happens, it is going to cause the most ardent Trump supporters to go absolutely bonkers. They're going to interpret that as the deep state trying to undermine the President of the United States and remove him unjustly from office. They're going to, or at least some of them are going to see it as their patriotic duty to their country to take up arms and fight a civil war. You're going to have a group on the other side if it goes the other way, and if, let's say, the Supreme Court says, no, this is illegal, you can't have this impeachment inquiry, some judge votes it down and says, you can't do that, it's not allowed, that's going to result in the other side, the anti-fascist action group going absolutely berserk.

It's a setup as this impeachment inquisition comes to a head the next few weeks for one large group of people or another to get very, very upset. And I think that there is a very real risk that that could suddenly mushroom into violent riots all across the country, just as nobody expected a 30 peso increase in Chilean subway fares to cause people to burn 38 subway stations to the ground almost.

Crazy things happen all of the sudden when people get to the point where they lose their cool. And I think there's a perfect setup in the United States for that to happen. Now, I'm not predicting that that's going to happen. I'm not saying that that's the most likely outcome, but I think it's a very real risk and it's one that very few investors seem to be taking seriously. So I think in the next few weeks we need to watch that situation very carefully, as well as what happens around the rest of the world.

In the case of Chile, for example, the increase in subway fares— the president of Chile already announced that that's going to be withdrawn, but that hasn't stopped the rioting and protests. And there's a tremendous amount of looting going on. People, you know, they're upset by what they consider to be social injustice and And in their mind, they're justified when they go and steal that widescreen TV set from a store. They perceive the store owner as being corrupt, or the government as being corrupt, or whatever. You've got a lot of people doing a lot of crazy things who feel entitled to be doing so. They don't think of themselves as doing criminal acts when they're looting stores in Chile or burning stores down in Hong Kong.

These situations are all a reflection of a growing global wealth inequality dissatisfaction, and I think that it's going to come to a head. If not over this impeachment inquisition, there will be something else, and eventually we'll see it in the United States as well. So I think that's a very important risk that investors need to take seriously.

Postgame: precious metals sentiment, gold and silver charts

Erik Townsend: But Patrick, on a more upbeat note, let's talk about precious metals, because as much as I felt like, hey, if you looked at that Commitment of Traders report just a few weeks ago. It was at all-time record speculative long interest. That was a real setup. If you look statistically at other times that that condition has existed, it's very frequently been a setup for a major downside correction. Not only have we not seen that downside correction, but boy, gold is looking awfully strong right now. No, I think that it's the Brexit vote coming up that's helping to buoy the price, but we haven't seen it.

And meanwhile, that huge, huge record sentiment indicator is off by about 25% from its record highs. So I'm starting to think maybe what we're gonna see is a further extended sideways consolidation to allow that sentiment extreme to wear out of the system before precious metals actually move higher. And Patrick, I should mention for our listeners who are not old-time regulars, you can find the download link for the postgame chartbook that we're about to discuss in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and click the red button that says looking for the downloads.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, so Erik, what I wanted to do is just give a little context on your comments. And so on pages 2 and 3, I just have the standard daily charts of the gold and silver markets. And one thing that I've been sharing with a lot of my members is, at least I've been more or less skeptical that gold was— if, if we're assuming that gold is in a bull market, I was skeptical that we would have a pullback as deep as $1,350 or deeper, because I think that one of the things that causes a gold market to be a bull market is everyone's got to be chasing. And I think that if gold gold pulled back to $1,350, giving an amazing opportunity for everyone to buy the dip at a perfect moment, it would just be too easy. And I would argue that if we got down to $1,350, maybe it's not even a gold bull market. Maybe we're going to even have a deeper pullback than that.

And so to be honest, the, the fact that we've consolidated up here and haven't even printed $1,450 on a pullback is actually relatively bullish. Now we have not had the breakout yet. So I don't want to already be rah-rahing the next leg higher in gold. But so far, the fact that we've spent several months consolidating gold with, uh, being a very shallow consolidation, I interpret that very bullishly. And even silver's pullback has been just a more or less a 50% retrace of its entire leg higher. And considering the magnitude of the spike that we saw in August, this type of a deeper pullback in silver was a little more expected.

But where I want to move on though is talk about those Commitment of Trader reports on pages 4 and 5, because you were referencing that. And that's a measure of looking at commercial hedgers, large speculators, and small speculators, how they're positioned in the futures markets. And you were commenting on that oversized positioning on the long side of speculators. And while it does look pretty significant in terms of how large the position is, and so I want to reference here on the Commitment of Trader reports the way Adam Collins puts it out.

And what he does is he shows it as a 5-year percentile of the net positions on the Commitment of Trader reports adjusted for open interest. And this more accurately normalizes those COT reports. And what's interesting is that the, uh, at least from a commercial hedging perspective, we have not seen any major extreme in the last month. I mean, we're more or less like at 57% on that 5-year percentile right now. And so while the large speculators are definitely bullishly positioned, we have not seen any major extremes on the positioning of, uh, the commercial hedgers, which I think is in itself a bit of a clue that, that maybe we're not yet at major, major extremes like it may appear on the surface.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, this mirrors the feeling that I've had, which is, you know, that extreme in sentiment is definitely a setup for some kind of pullback, but that can be resolved either of two ways. It can either be resolved by a sustained consolidation, which allows the extreme to bleed off, or it can happen in a snapback where everybody freaks out and Nobody's freaking out and panicking, and we've seen this consolidation continue for a few months now. So, you know, the old saying, the longer you base, the higher in space. If we end up breaking out of the current consolidation to the upside without ever going, say, below $1,450, on the one hand, well, too bad for those of us that were waiting for that pullback to $1,400. But on the positive note, that's a really bullish sign. The fact that we could have moved as far as we did and get out of it with just a sideways consolidation as opposed to a really significant pullback, if that happens, that's a big if, we don't know that yet, but if it goes that way and we end up breaking to new all-time highs and we get to $1,600 in gold without ever having gone below $1,450, it just adds even more strength to my long-term bullish conviction that gold is headed much, much higher in coming years.

Postgame: hedged long gold and the Silver and Gold Summit

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, the one interesting thing that I would offer you as a consideration, and I'm going to be talking about at the Silver and Gold Summit during a number of the presentations, is that for gold, because of its contango and the forward price being higher, it actually translates into a really interesting options market. More importantly, there's also a natural skew in the gold market, a right-tailed skew in the option series. This allows you to actually get some very cheap hedges into gold and be able to offset a lot of those cheap hedges quite far out of the money with some option writes. And so it allows you to actually take a very decisive long position in gold here. And even if we are proven early And that pullback to $1,350 happens, that I don't think will, but let's say it does happen. You can actually have hedged out a lot of that and still be long gold here today.

And so I actually think that anyone who wants to be long gold, the options market gives you lots of ways to manage the risk and, and be in the position today.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I know you're speaking in San Francisco this weekend, October 27th and 28th, at the Gold and Silver Summit. Are you going to be covering those hedging strategies and how to get into a protected long position in gold that hedges downside risk?

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So I'm going to be covering all of that. So anyone that can make it out to that Silver and Gold Summit, do so. If you do register online, if you use the Macro50 promo code, you can get 50% off. I'm going to also be speaking on a panel with some of our All-Stars. Like Brent Johnson and Grant Williams will be on there, and Marin Katusa is going to be moderating it. So it's going to be a great session. Looking forward to seeing so many of our MacroVoices listeners out there.

Erik Townsend: And again, that's at the Hyatt in San Francisco this weekend. Today's episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. Be sure to check out my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen published on September 7th, 2019. The link is in your Research Roundup email. And for those of you who haven't registered yet to get that Research Roundup email, please be sure to go to our homepage where you can do so.

Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: The benefit to you is you'll receive that list of download links every single week, which provides access to the download materials associated with our own interviews as well as the best investment research that we could find on the internet each week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook to accompany Diego's presentation, as well as the charts we discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an interesting article discussing Robert Shiller's view that a recession is likely years away due to the bullish Trump effect, as well as an article about Bank of America declaring the end of the 60/40 standard portfolio. You'll find this and so much more in the That's it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. And we'll see you next week. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to Supporting documents from our featured guests, and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com.

If you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only.

The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Stephanie Pomboy — MacroMavens founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview: Stephanie Pomboy and Rick Rule

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 189 was recorded on October 17th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by our friends at TopTradersUnplugged.com, which happens to be my own favorite podcast when it comes to quant and rules-based investing. MacroMavens founder Stephanie Pomboy joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Stephanie put together a terrific chart deck to accompany this interview, and we'll discuss everything from retail sales data to the disparity between corporate earnings and S&P 500 earnings. Stephanie will explain why the two really are not the same thing, even though almost everyone assumes that they are. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, when Sprott Global's Rick Rule will be joining us. I'm going to ask Rick to talk to us about how sophisticated investors let's say a family office with $100 million of assets under management, should pursue not only investing in precious metals but also both public and private equities in the sector.

So we're going to cover some advanced material relative to gold and silver investing in our postgame segment, and of course Patrick will also have one of his famous chart books with an update and extended equity market coverage.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 has recovered much of the little market correction we had in the start of October. What's your thinking on the S&P now that we're around this 3,000 level?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, it feels to me like every time there's more bad news, the market trades up on it. And I think that what's driving it is, again, that this Fed put, the expectation that if there is more economic weakness, and I think the economic data looks pretty darn awful, the result is going to be that there will be accommodation from the Fed. And everybody's expecting quantitative easing to drive markets higher. Now, someday this narrative is going to break down. Quantitative easing won't drive markets higher. There's going to be one of those Wile E. Coyote moments where the market says, uh-oh, we thought the Fed had our back and it turns out they didn't. And then things are going to get really, really ugly. But I've been wrong quite a few times thinking that moment was already upon us. It seems like it's not here yet.

And what it looks to me like is this market is trying to break out higher, as crazy as that seems to me.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index because we had a bit of a spill here on the short term. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Well, finally we have something to talk about, Patrick. You know, so many times the dollar bears were just whining, saying, oh, the, you know, the end is nigh, the dollar is going to crash, when in reality the technical chart pattern looked very bullish. Well, now we've actually seen a breakdown below that channel resistance line. So yeah, there's something to talk about here. But, you know, as much as there has been a very significant pullback, this came on news of the Fed, although they tried to say it's not QE, but it really is QE. The Fed has announced another asset purchase program, which clearly has to be dollar bearish. So I look at this and I say, okay, we've pulled back, what, from 99.50 to what, 97.50 or a little bit below that? We haven't even gotten down to the 97 round number yet.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: And maybe we're headed there, I don't know. But Patrick, given the news flow, I think a pullback of this magnitude is entirely consistent with what I would expect. Now certainly this could be the beginning of the end. I think it's more likely that we're going to bottom out here somewhere around where we are, maybe a little bit lower. If we go much lower, I'll start to get concerned. But given the news flow, it's no surprise that the dollar's taken a beating here.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because it looks like it might be a short-term low. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this crude oil market has been acting funny ever since Tuesday morning, really. And just to, to go over the, the way this market has played out, at least in my perception, Sunday night when futures opened, we saw the selling begin in earnest. And there's no surprise there. A lot of times we'll see a Friday rally. Nobody wants to be short into the weekend. Once the weekend is over and nothing big happened on the weekend, the market starts selling off. And that's exactly what happened Sunday night into Monday. We got back down between the short-term moving averages on Sunday night, stayed between them on Monday, looked like the market wanted to break lower but couldn't quite do it. We managed to hold on to that 8-day moving average, which was the bottom of the 3 short-term moving averages, on Monday afternoon.

But then Tuesday morning, as the European session opened about 4 AM, there was a really, really hard break to the downside, taking out all of those short-term moving averages. That really looked like the sell signal, like the market was ready to move lower. But then a funny thing happened Tuesday morning around 6 AM. All of a sudden, the market did a U-turn. Somebody started buying. It was almost like somebody in North America woke up and said, wait a minute, I know something other people don't. I want to buy this dip. I want to buy any dip. And sure enough, we saw a complete reversal. No news that I'm aware of to explain that reversal. And after breaking down below all 3 of those short-term moving averages, by noontime we were above them all again. There was a really sharp rally. But then going into the close on Tuesday, the market couldn't hold it and it sold off very aggressively, closing below all 3 of those short-term moving averages, even though it had traded above them during the day.

That would normally be a pretty bearish signal. It seemed like, okay, Now finally, that, that closing print below all 3 of those short-term moving averages is in. We're moving lower. What happens the next day? Well, we move higher. And again, we get up to the top of that, the 5-day moving average, which was the top of that trading range, start to trade back down. Then on Wednesday afternoon, we get API announcing, and that's the private inventory service. Inventory was delayed by a day this week because of the Columbus Day holiday.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: API announces a 10 million barrel build on inventory. That's an incredibly bearish sign. Crude oil trades off, but not that far off. And by morning of Thursday, we're back up to where we started, right around the 13-day moving average.

What the heck is going on here? How come we're ignoring this, this sign? We get to the EIA data. EIA almost confirms the API number. API said 10 million barrel build on inventory. EIA came in with an official print of 9.3 million barrels build on inventory, Cushing, Oklahoma accounting for 1.3 million barrels of that build. Gasoline and distillates did have drawdowns this week, 2.6 million on gasoline, 3.8 million on distillates, but still net-net it's a build on inventory. That causes the market to trade down sharply for all of about 60 seconds and then it starts moving higher again. By the end of the day on Thursday, we've broken through all of those short-term moving averages and we're breaking out to the upside on the back of what should have been incredibly bearish news. Now, how do you explain that? Well, one distinct possibility is today was also options expiration day and there was a lot of open interest at the 54 strike, which is just about where the market closed.

Okay, that seems to make sense, but if this was about artificial buying to get to that pinning effect of options expiry, you'd expect to get up even in the face of what should have been a bearish signal on inventory. You'd get up to that $54 round, you'd stay there for 30 seconds, and you'd make an abrupt U-turn and start selling off. Even after those options expired at 2:30 this afternoon, Patrick, as we're speaking now, we're looking at $54.08, and the market is drifting higher.

It feels to me as if somebody knows that something's coming that's awfully bullish. Now, the commentators that I've seen today have said, well, it's because of growing optimism around Brexit and China trade talks. Dude, we just had a 10 million— 9.3 million barrel, according to the EIA official data— build in crude oil inventories. That's an incredibly bearish print, and the market's going straight up. There's more to this than just Brexit and China, as far as I'm concerned. I can't tell what, but one thing I do know is I don't want to be short into this weekend.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, I wanted to pick your brain on gold. We've been more or less pinned around this $1,500 level. What's in store for gold next?

Erik Townsend: Gold never ceases to amaze me with its strength and resilience here. There is a head and shoulders pattern, an incomplete head and shoulders pattern on the daily chart, and gold has rejected that neckline a couple of times now. So it looks like that head and shoulders, which was potentially something the bears were hanging on to saying, Oh, you just wait till we break that neckline, that's where the selling is really going to accelerate, we'll be looking at $1,350 before you know it. Well, we only got, what, 1 or 2 daily prints below that neckline and then it quickly reversed and has stayed above it ever since for the last week and a half or so. So it seems like gold is a lot more resilient than I expected.

Now, from a Commitment of Traders standpoint, we still have record speculative long interest. That is normally a setup for a correction to the downside. Too many people on one side of the boat all at the same time. But so far we're not seeing that correction. And, uh, you know, I'm watching this very carefully. I want to buy the dip here. I thought we were going to get a much bigger dip. I was expecting sub-$1,400 prices. I'm being forced to reevaluate that. I'm not rushing to back up the leveraged truck yet. But I may start scaling into a gold position here. I've already got a core position, of course, but a speculative gold position. If we don't see some action pretty soon here, maybe we're just going to consolidate sideways before moving higher. I, I thought there were lower numbers to come. We'll see what happens.

Patrick Ceresna: Sure. Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury, and we're more or less around the 1.75 on the yield. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: It feels like we found kind of a support level here right around where we are, just a little bit lower than this on price or a little higher in yield. We tried to see a break this morning that was not sustained. So it looks like almost the ingredients of a reversal day today. We'll see what happens in the next few days. But I still think we're headed lower in yield. I think all the fundamentals are there. What would take us higher? I suppose the argument maybe for higher is China's about to come to a deal.

Everything's going to— there's going to be a Brexit deal. There's going to be a China deal. Everything's going to be fixed. Everything's going to be hunky-dory. The stock market's going to move higher and bond yields are going to move higher. Everything's going to be great. I think at the end of the day, the economic news still looks pretty bad. Maybe the China deal will come together. I don't know how long that's gonna sustain higher yields.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, thanks for the update. Now, this week's featured interview guest is Stephanie Pomboy, founder of MacroMavens. Why did we invite Stephanie as a guest this week?

Erik Townsend: You know, Stephanie has an amazing history. She got her first job in finance at the age of, I think, 21 or 22, and somehow she just lucked into a job where she's hanging out with Stan Druckenmiller and George Soros. At the age of 22 and just made connections with people in finance that most people, you know, spend their whole career dreaming of meeting. And she's a 22-year-old kid hanging out with these guys.

She's really had a very successful practice as a boutique institutional advisor. She's not very well known in the retail space, but I think she's got a terrific market outlook and she really has a knack for charts.

Erik Townsend: I love the charts that she puts together. So I'm really looking forward to this one, Patrick, and this episode of MacroVoices. Was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. I did a full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, the host of this excellent podcast, back on September 7th, 2019, on the subject of trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. We discussed a number of key issues about the value of having a rules-based investment strategy in a portfolio. In our conversation, Niels shared some insights that may surprise you, especially when it comes to how trend following strategies don't really operate the way some market commentators suggest that they do. For more information, including a free book about trend following and the Accredited Investor slide deck from my interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, go to TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroSlides.

Check them out. You'll be glad you did.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Stephanie Pomboy is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Stephanie Pomboy: late-cycle economy and the 2016 parallel

Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Stephanie Pomboy, founder of MacroMavens, and very possibly the hardest-to-get interview guest that we've dealt with to date. I know when Grant Williams interviewed you the first time. You made a joke about playing hard to get. I thought you were kidding until we've been through this. So, thank you for finally coming and joining us for an interview, Stephanie.

Stephanie Pomboy: It's my pleasure. Actually, I sort of fashion myself the J.D. Salinger of macroeconomics. So, don't take it personally. I just prefer to remain hiding under my desk most of the time. But thank you for having me.

Erik Townsend: Well, we pride ourselves in digging out the people that are actually worth listening to, and I certainly respect you in that category. So, let's talk about the big macro picture. I think the, the big question in everybody's mind is, uh, you know, as a lot of us have been saying, that we're very late in the economic cycle and it's time for the markets to roll over.

Markets aren't rolling over. So, what's going on here? How do you see this picture?

Stephanie Pomboy: Yeah, it's fascinating and, and frustrating at the same time. I guess, you know, I increasingly And being brought back to 2016, it seems like we've seen a lot of economic data that is now posting its weakest readings since 2016. You know, in the early part of the year, and I got back to thinking about what was happening then and what the similarities are, and importantly, what the differences are. And it's kind of an interesting road to go down, as you undoubtedly recall, in early part of 2016. It was just on the heels of the very first Fed rate hike. You know, they had dragged their feet following the taper tantrum in 2013 and waited and waited and decided in December of 2015 to start raising rates. And the reaction in the markets was swift and painful. I think the markets clearly perceived the Fed as having misstepped, and the economic data at the time clearly indicated that, you know, the economy was slowing sharply. Which sort of begs the question of why they decided that was the moment to start to raise rates.

And obviously all of this reversed on a dime with the election in November of that year, as, you know, people started to anticipate sort of a pro-business agenda and massive tax cuts. So, you know, that whole experience of 2016, when we looked like we were heading into recession and the Fed had made a policy mistake, has now been sort of erased from the collective memory by this, you know, shift in, uh, in policy from DC.

So you flash forward to today and the economy again looks like it's slumping over into recession. And as you said, you know, the markets seem to be dismissing that as sort of not where we're ultimately going to go. And the interesting thing to me is that the thing that might rescue us this time is sort of hard to identify. You know, it doesn't look like we'll see any kind of pro-growth fiscal stimulus. You know, we're busy trying to figure out if we're going to get anything positive out of Washington. And then on the monetary front, and obviously we could spend a lot of time talking about this, it's not clear that doing more is necessarily going to help the situation. So that's sort of my overarching focus right now, and I'm happy to go through and look at the specifics on the ground. But that's sort of where I am from 10,000 feet up right now.

Fed balance sheet, non-QE QE and the repo shock

Erik Townsend: As we come in a little closer, why don't we talk about the quantitative— well, it's not quantitative easing— the expansion of the Fed's balance sheet quantitatively for the purpose of providing easing, which is not quantitative easing, that thing that happened last week. What do you think's going on there? Because a lot of people thought, okay, markets are going to start to crash, the Fed's going to bail them out. With QE, it feels almost like the market is being preemptively bailed out before it even takes a turn south by QE. Or is this the Fed trying to stave off that recession that they see coming, even though they say they don't?

Stephanie Pomboy: I've given up trying to figure out what the Fed is thinking because it's just really hard to tell. I guess, you know, one might conclude that they haven't been thinking. I would argue, and actually did argue from the moment they started to Unwind the balance sheet, that they really were underestimating the impact that that would have both in the marketplace and on the economy more broadly.

And it is kind of amazing to me that they you know they first described it as watching paint dry. You know this would happen behind the scenes, and it really would be a non-event that didn't have any discernible impact, which would beg the question if. Unwinding the balance sheet was going to be an odd event. Why did you expand it in the first place?

So, you know, it just seemed to me that they had done all this analysis about the impact, the stimulative impact that expanding the balance sheet had had, and then described this as, you know, being on autopilot and sort of not important, which just didn't make any sense on its face. And then, you know, obviously, as they got deeper and deeper into this process, you saw more and more signs. You know, the economic momentum was slowing. And, you know, the financial system, I think they, they believed that there was so much in the way of excess reserves that they had a long runway before it would ever get to a point where, you know, it was an issue. And they clearly really miscalculated on that front.

And to me, it kind of comes back to the broader question about the Fed's credibility. You know, we hang on every word, every utterance that they make as if they've got some great gift of insight as to where the economy is going and a real handle on the markets, and that, you know, no matter what happens, economic or financial, these guys will, you know, navigate around these issues and steer us past any rocky shoals and everything will be fine. All evidence to the contrary. And I'm just surprised, as one who's been sort of let's say cynical about the Fed's grasp on what's going on, that the markets still believe that they have some kind of handle on what's going on. So I think to me, the biggest takeaway about this whole repo market exercise is that it illustrates how clueless the Fed is about really the impact that its policies have had And obviously, the effect that unwinding those policies— I mean, this unprecedented stimulus that we saw was completely uncharted territory, and they had this kind of, you know, maybe hubristic notion that, oh, we can handle this, no problem.

Erik Townsend: I've talked to several guests who've told me, look, Jay Powell had it pretty much right. It's end-of-quarter technicalities in the repo market. It's no big deal. And I've talked to others who've said, look, This right here, right now, this is your TED spread blowing out in the summer of 2008 moment. This is your warning signal that the shit's about to hit the fan.

Those are 2 extremes. Where do you fall on that spectrum in terms of the significance of this liquidity shock that we seem to be experiencing?

Stephanie Pomboy: Well, I'd say I definitely fall more in the latter camp. I mean, again, I think it comes back to the fact that You know, the New York Fed is really on the front lines of this, and no one really should have a better grasp on the potential liquidity issues in that market than the New York Fed. And they clearly, you know, when the Fed funds, when the overnight rate jumps up to 10%, they clearly miscalculated something. So yes, there are a lot of, it was sort of a perfect storm of events. As we look back on it now, but the fact that they had not allowed any margin for error for these things, I mean, it wasn't news that the Treasury was going to be borrowing a lot, and these are all things that you would think they would have anticipated might happen or modeled for, since they model for everything, and yet it wasn't just sort of like a minor mistake, it was a fairly massive miscalculation.

So, you know, again, I, I do— it doesn't— let's say it doesn't imbue my confidence that they really have a handle on, on what's going on.

Consumer spending vs credit card borrowing

Erik Townsend: Stephanie, you also put together a terrific chart book for our listeners. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads, Next to Stephanie's picture on our homepage. Steph, let's talk about this chartbook. What caught my interest right on page 3, it looks like you're showing here at one point you've got 3 question marks. It looks like people started actually spending money they already had rather than buying stuff on credit, but it only lasted for 6 months. What's going on bigger picture? Why did you start with the discretionary spending and revolving credit retail sales? What's the bigger picture of where you're coming from, but particularly what's going on with that credit anomaly there?

Stephanie Pomboy: Yeah, I am a simpleton when it comes to analyzing the US economy. I always start with the US consumer because I figure if I can get that right, I pretty well have got the story. You know, at 70% of the economy, that's really the thing you want to get right. And I just continue to be confounded by this strong consumer narrative because if you just bother to look at any of the details in the numbers, you find out that, you know, the consumer numbers really aren't strong at all.

And just to sort of step back and paint the backdrop here, before you even look at these charts, you have to bear in mind that we have sort of the ultimate environment for the consumer right now. We've got record high net worth, we have record low debt service, Mortgage rates, you know, back at what, 3.6%?

We have the unemployment rate the lowest in 50 years. The Fed can't seem to conjure 2% inflation. So when you think about, you know, back in the '70s, Arthur Okun created the misery index, which was just a simple addition of the unemployment rate and inflation to kind of capture misery for the consumer. Right now, that's at record lows. So I describe it not as the misery index, it's the mirth index right now. I mean, The consumer basically has everything going for him today.

And then you look at that first chart on page 2 of discretionary spending. So basically everything he has a choice to spend money on. And, you know, going back to 2016 and that analogy, you see we basically round-tripped. You know, we had this little blip up on the heels of the election, and now we're right back to where we were before. And the pattern is one of sort of slow churn, sideways to downward in terms of nominal total discretionary spending. And then if you get to the next page, and the reason I put that chart overlaying revolving credit, essentially credit card use versus retail sales, which again is just a way to capture the discretionary portion of consumer spending, what you see is that they're slowing their discretionary purchases at the same time they're accelerating their credit card borrowing. This in the past has been a harbinger of recession. You know, if you've got to put more on your credit card at the same time you're slowing your spending, it's generally not a positive indication.

So these 2 charts really make me concerned about this confidence in the strong consumer, and that really comes back to this whole You know, mistake that the Fed made late last year in raising rates again, and their whole underestimation about the impact their balance sheet unwind would have. But it also feeds into the stock market looking through all of that because the strong consumer narrative directly imbues this corporate profit story. And as you're well aware, we're potentially going to have our third. Quarter of negative profit growth. So we're clearly in profits recession, and yet the market has looked through that on the idea, I believe, that the recession is strictly a function of this whole trade war weighing on activity and slower growth abroad, that it's not a reflection of the US economy. And I come back to those consumer charts and I say, hmm, maybe it is more of a reflection about things that are going on here.

And not just a trade-related issue, in which case, you know, now we're gonna see potentially weaker earnings numbers in the, in the quarters to come.

Erik Townsend: Steph, as I look at the recession areas on the left, it's easy to see what's going on when you have credit card borrowing moving above retail sales. In other words, people are spending money that they don't have. It looks like where you've got the question marks on the right side of the slide, that retail sales continued to increase even as credit card borrowing was decreasing, almost seeming like people were saving up again before they bought stuff. What's going on here? What does this mean?

Stephanie Pomboy: Oh, well, in this chart, essentially what I'm trying to highlight is that starting really at the beginning of this year, you saw credit card borrowing start to pick up at the same time retail sales growth started to slow. So that trend, which is why I put those question marks there, has in the past been associated with recessions. And the question is, is that what it's signaling again this time? You know, whenever people, as you said, are having to rely on their credit cards more to fund their purchases, much less discretionary spending, that has generally been an indication of recession. So, you know, the jury is out, but I think this is an important one to watch. And again, it kind of flies in the face of this whole strong consumer narrative. And when you think about it in the context of the things I just mentioned about, you know, record high net worth and low unemployment rate, etc., the consumer really shouldn't have to be ramping up his use of credit card borrowing to fund his marginal spending.

Erik Townsend: So, the recession signal would be that red line crossing the blue line, which have not crossed yet, but boy, they sure look like they're set up to cross awfully soon.

Inventory-to-sales ratios and the profit outlook

Erik Townsend: Stephanie, let's move on to page 4, where you're graphing inventory-to-sales ratios. What's going on with this chart?

Stephanie Pomboy: Well, again, this one brings us back to 2016, and I think this one is interesting as relates to this whole idea that, you know, the profits recession is strictly a function of weakness abroad, etc., and the trade issue. And when you look at this, you might say, well, this is the trade issue. You know, companies are just shrewdly stockpiling stuff ahead of what they thought would be, you know, further tariff increases down the road. So that's what's behind this increase in the inventory-to-sales ratios at both the wholesale and retail level. But when you drill down and you actually look at the inventory component versus the sales component, what you see is that the problem here is that sales are slowing much faster and that, you know, the inventory accumulation is pretty solid. It's not eye-popping in any way. What's eye-popping is the deceleration in sales. So again, it gets back to this idea that there is a demand story here. It's not just a function of, you know, the trade war boosting supply of inventories.

It's that companies are finding that yes, they ordered early as much inventory as they could, but they still overestimated because the sales just continue to disappoint.

And then on the next page, I think this is an amazing chart because in the past when you've seen, you know, time was when inventories were the thing that led you into recession. This is before just-in-time inventory management when, you know, companies would Miscalculate, and that would be the thing when they overstockpiled, and then they'd have to liquidate, and that would send us into recession. And so you can see on this chart I identified that actually inventory peaks were normally the thing that caused the Fed to shift its policy and shift to cutting rates. And so I've highlighted there in all those episodes that the peak inventory. Was associated with the first rate cut by the Fed. At this time, in late 2015, the Fed decided that was the time to raise rates in the face of the largest inventory overhang we had ever seen in history. So it's again an indication that they completely miscalculated back then. And obviously, as you can see, you know, we're still facing a pretty substantial inventory overhang. Which really, the only

reason I bore everyone, including myself, talking about inventories is that this really is going to be critical in terms of the outlook for profits.

I keep coming back to profits because maybe I'm incorrect about this, but I feel like that's the thing that is driving the stock market higher in the face of all the weaker economic data that we've seen, all these indications that, you know, PMIs are the weakest since 2016. And, you know, these inventory numbers are the steepest we've seen since 2016. And they just brush it off with, I believe, this confidence that, you know, the profit hit is just this trade story. And then as we get into 2020, we're going to go back to double digits. You know, the S&P earnings forecast for the analyst estimates for S&P earnings next year are 10%.

So clearly The prospect of this inventory liquidation cycle weighing on earnings and the idea that it's larger than just trade, that the consumer is really weak, isn't yet factored into the markets whatsoever.

S&P earnings vs BEA corporate profits and buybacks

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 6 then. I think this is a very important chart because to the uninitiated, corporate profits and S&P 500 earnings are the same thing. It sounds like the same thing. You're showing here they're not at all the same thing. Explain this chart.

Stephanie Pomboy: Yeah, this has been really fascinating. And as you can see on this chart, it's very unusual to see a divergence like this between corporate profits, which is the total profits for the US economy that is reported by the BEA, who put together the GDP report. So, every quarter that they calculate total GDP, they also come up with a calculation as to what total corporate profits were. And as you can see, their estimate of corporate profits has been substantially weaker than the S&P earnings numbers. And in the past, when you've had disagreements like this between these 2 measures, which I show on page 7, generally it's been the BEA, the government broader statistics, that have won the argument at the end of the day. And there are a variety of reasons for that, and 3 in particular, which I would argue are even more compelling today. One is that obviously, because they capture the entire economy rather than just the top 500 companies, it's a better grasp on what's happening, you know, more broadly.

It's not idiosyncratic. It's not going to be a function of just Google pushing the numbers up. The second thing is they tend to hew more closely to GAAP accounting. So, you know, these, let's say, accounting shenanigans aren't as prevalent in the broader corporate profit data.

But the most important reason, and I think the one that's really driving this yawning gap today, is share buybacks. The government measures its profits in total dollars. The S&P obviously measures profits on a per-share basis, so it is flattered by the reduction in share counts. So as you can see here, you know, according to the government, profits actually peaked at the end of 2014 and are down 4% in the time since, while the S&P shows them up 30%, largely because of the impact that share buybacks have had in flattering the numbers.

So this idea, I mean, this really gets to valuations in the market. If people believe these S&P earnings numbers are correct, then they can justify valuations on stocks. If it turns out, as in the past, as you see on page 7, that the BEA numbers are actually the more accurate numbers, then we're going to have a come-to-Jesus moment in the markets as that reality comes into focus.

Erik Townsend: Do we really have to have a come-to-Jesus moment, or does Jesus come to the market in the form of accommodative monetary policy saving the day again? And, you know, I could go on for hours arguing why I don't think that accommodative monetary policy should boost markets. But you know what? History has been pretty clear for the last 10 years.

Bank of Japan shift and the limits of QE

Stephanie Pomboy: Yeah, no, I'm with you. And it gets back to my frustration. Actually, it's sort of, for me, an existential question. Why do I do what I do? In terms of trying to figure out what's happening in the economy if the fundamentals don't matter and the Fed's going to rush in and just encourage people to take risk all the time. So who cares about the fundamentals? So I mean, it's, it's a question I wrestle with a lot. Why will it be different this time than it has, you know, every time it looked like we were slowing and, you know, on the cusp of some market meltdown in the past?

And I think I mean, maybe I'm guilty of putting too much emphasis on it, but I think that what we've seen in terms of the monetary policy developments globally in the last couple weeks has been really important and represents, I would say, almost a tectonic shift in the way people are going to perceive, or even central banks perceive, this, let's call it repressive interest rate regime and the benefits of QE.

And the first indication of that for me was the Bank of Japan, which basically has finally figured out that, you know, negative interest rates and inverted yield curves aren't exactly great for banks, and that, you know, having a healthy financial sector is fairly critical to having a healthy economy. And so they have basically said, you know, we're going to try to scale back our purchases of long-dated paper and focus more on purchasing at the front end in a way to try to steepen the yield curve.

So to my mind, you know, this was kind of a revolutionary epiphany on the part of the Bank of Japan. It took 30 years, but, you know, they finally have started to figure out that maybe, you know, there is a point at which you can push rates too low. And so I think that was a real important event. And then of course you've had a lot of comments by people formerly employed and around the ECB who've made a lot of similar remarks of recent. So I think there's, there's starting to be a little inkling that maybe we've passed the point where these policies have a benefit.

And I can go through in more detail the evidence of I like to call it sort of the George Costanza effect, where every intention of the policy has actually had the opposite effect, where, you know, the idea was obviously to conjure inflation. And in fact, most of these policies have had very disinflationary consequences and have, I would argue, depressed growth rather than stimulated it.

The endgame catalyst: earnings revisions, credit spreads, buybacks

Erik Townsend: Well, I'd be particularly interested to get more perspective from you on how the endgame plays out, because what I see as a common theme in all of the smartest people that I talk to is they all tell the same story, really, which they express it in different ways. But what they say is, look, in the end, economic fundamentals always have to win out, but central banks have more power than anybody else to delay the inevitable. And so that's why we've been You know, 10 years of this, but in the end, economic fundamentals have to be the deciding factor. Well, my question is, okay, what defines the endgame? What causes the end to come? What causes the expiry, if you will, of the Fed put?

Is there reason to think that this regime of monetary— of accommodative monetary policy enabling stock buybacks, allowing markets to just grind higher, Despite you and all the other smart people saying, guys, the economy's not as good as everybody thinks. You know, the economy's not as good as everybody thinks, but it hasn't stopped markets from grinding higher. What's going to be the catalyst or the thing that changes that, that brings about that endgame?

Stephanie Pomboy: Well, I keep coming back to this corporate profit story. It's why I've spent so much time kind of really drilling into these numbers. Because I think that, you know, obviously you need to have that story to support the valuations, to justify the valuations. And if you get to a point where people start to say, hey, wait, you know, maybe we're not going to have 10% earnings growth next year, maybe the number is actually going to be zero, I have a hard time believing that's not going to have a real impact on the stock market. Actually, on page 9, This is exactly kind of what we had at the end of last year.

For all of 2018, the estimate for this year's 2019 earnings was 12%. And basically, when we went through almost the entire year of 2018 stuck at this 12% estimate, and then in the 4th quarter, the wheels started to come off and people realized, hey, maybe we're not going to get 12% earnings growth next year. And I think there's a really good chance that we get a repeat of that this year, and then going to have that at a time when it's not clear again that this stimulus, this Fed rushing in, that you know Pavlovian response to come rushing in with the fire hoses is necessarily going to solve the problem.

I mean, it may, but I really think that we're now at the point where we're already three quarters into recession for profits. And if you throw out there to the markets, hey, next year is going to be pretty bad too, and we have no prospect of pro-business fiscal stimulus coming out of Washington, quite the contrary, we've got, you know, real dysfunction and impeachment talks, etc., that will, you know, bog down anything there for a while, you know, it comes back to the Fed.

And then you start looking at What's the impact? What's going to be the benefit of cutting rates from here and doing more QE? And you look at the financials, and you know clearly they're already struggling with the slope of the yield curve and the level of interest rates right now. You are seeing consumer delinquencies pick up in the non-mortgage space. You've been seeing that for a while. So there is. You know, a deterioration in credit quality at the same time banks are already struggling with net interest margins. So I think all that swirling around, and if you start to see this profit story ricochet through the credit markets, which it's hard to believe, you know that corporate credit spreads wouldn't start to expand as the profit outlook deteriorates.

Then you really set in motion. The negative feedback loop pretty quickly where, you know, as credit spreads increase, the funding for share buybacks disappears because they've all been funded with cheap debt. And that then takes another peg out from under the stock market and also hits earnings because again, they have all been flattered by these share buybacks. So you create this kind of vicious circle where, you know, the wider credit spreads get, The lower the buybacks, the worse the earnings, and then that feeds back to credit spreads, which blow out farther still. And, you know, so I could see that situation setting up pretty quickly. And, you know, I, like you, puzzle as to what's going to be the catalyst. And for me, I keep coming back to the profit story as the catalyst, because I think people are still in fantasy land about what earnings are going to be next year.

Erik Townsend: So are you expecting a 4th quarter '19 risk-off event on the scale that we saw last year, or is the more accommodative Fed policy going to put a damper on the downside risk?

Stephanie Pomboy: I think there's a really good chance that we see a repeat of the 4th quarter meltdown this year. I think that, you know, the chart on page 9, I expect we'll just repeat the pattern and those earnings estimates will get slashed, and that will create some real turmoil in the markets, at which point, you know, people will then start to scratch their heads like, does the Fed really have a handle on what's going on here? And does cutting rates more and expanding the balance sheet more, whether it's non-QE QE or real QE QE, does that really set us up any better?

So, you know, I think that's For me, that could be the catalyst.

Unfunded pensions and unicorn write-downs

Stephanie Pomboy: The other side of it that's kind of silently going on in the background, and to be honest, you know, I'm just starting to think about this and try to figure out what the impact is. But on page 13, you know, the sort of doomsday scenario is that the whole repricing of risk happens and it reveals what the Fed and central banks globally have done. Through their years of repressive interest rate regimes, which is silently to bankrupt all of the pensions globally. I mean, essentially these unfunded pension liabilities have mushroomed like we've never seen before, and they're completely untenable. You know, for the US economy, we're looking at over $6 trillion in unfunded liabilities now with stocks basically near all-time record highs.

So you've had this massive rally in risk assets, and yet the funding deficit has actually expanded in that time. And one thing that I'm starting to think about a little bit is that these guys, in their effort to make 8% returns in a, you know, 1% risk-free world, obviously they went to every corner of the credit market and bought levered loans and all that. Most toxic stuff they could get their hands on to get that yield. They also were really big in all of these unicorn companies that are now starting to be revealed to be not so fabulous as, you know, the valuations on these companies were completely fantastical. So it's going to be interesting to see how that plays out from the pension standpoint. Do we see a lot of these pensions, state and local governments having to put more money into their pensions because they have to write down a lot of the positions they had in those companies.

It's just something I'm starting to think about, but I think that's going to be fascinating to watch as this cycle plays out because obviously between Uber and WeWork and Peloton, you've had a lot of these companies where the valuations that were placed on them were revealed to be, let's say, a tad excessive.

Helicopter money, MMT and a pension bailout

Erik Townsend: Stephanie, you make such a terrific point about unfunded liabilities. Something that I have long predicted is that there's going to be a major political agenda around some kind of helicopter money to provide— and of course, the view of the politicians who favor that, they would describe it as a solution to this problem of unfunded liabilities. They don't see it as exacerbating that problem.

How do you think this might play out? And would you agree, first of all, that the upcoming election year might be when this starts to become a major issue? And if some of the politicians were to maybe misinterpret MMT a little bit in the interest of interpreting it to mean it's okay to just print money like crazy and spend it on social programs without taxing anybody, what would the potential consequences of that be? And how might that play out?

Stephanie Pomboy: Well, I mean, this is, this is the terrifying scenario that I try not to think about too close to bedtime, because it's just going to keep you up all night. But it's really hard to envision us going down the road, at least as I've laid it out, and as I see it taking shape, without getting to this MMT moment. You know, I guess MMT obviously is a terrifying prospect for anyone who values hard money. So whether it's MMT or QE, you know, it's all variations on that, that same theme. And I guess the best I could hope for is that if they were to pursue some form of MMT, which as you say seems almost inevitable, that it will at least be part of the discussion, that they would explicitly tie the program to funding the pensions. I mean, if they were to, let's say, allow state and local governments to issue bonds to fund their pensions and expressly bought those bonds that were issued to fund the pensions, then at least we're not, you know, having some social agenda that's being pushed through this MMT, you know, money growing on trees.

So it becomes less of a debate about where you stand on different issues, because I think one thing that's clear is that if—pardon my language—the shit really hits the fan and these pension liabilities double or triple, which seems pretty easy to happen based on what we saw happening to them during the global financial crisis, you know there's clearly going to be. A human cry to bail out these pensions. You can't bail out Wall Street in 2008, 2009, and then leave all these workers who by no fault of their own had their pensions invested in subprime real estate or whatever, you know, suddenly be disenfranchised and have no, no money for retirement. So I think that would definitely— is going to be a discussion. And like I said, the best I can hope for is that they do something where they limit it to something that's funding the pensions directly.

Is it time to short junk bonds?

Erik Townsend: I don't think that's the agenda that most of the politicians that are thinking about this have in their minds, but I'll keep my fingers crossed that they're listening. I want to come back though to the corporate side for a minute because we skipped over page 10, which really caught my interest when I looked at the slide deck. I think I hold the record for the guy who's been too early more times than anybody else to thinking it was time to short the junk bond market. And I've lost money every time because, as you know, the carry cost of that trade is very high.

You've got to get the timing pretty close to right. And I keep thinking this is so crazy, it can't continue. And then it just accelerates. But it looks like you're starting to show some divergence here on On page 10, is it finally time to short the junk bond market?

Stephanie Pomboy: Gosh, I mean, when I look at those charts, it takes every ounce of self-restraint for me not to run out and, you know, just short junk myself. But yeah, I mean, it's— unless you believe, which I guess people do, that this slump in the ISMs, both on the manufacturing side and the services side, is temporary and it's immediately going to bounce right back. Unless you believe that, I would say it seems pretty clear that these risk assets are really hanging out over their skis and there's going to be some repricing there. And again, you know, when I couple that with my outlook for on page 9, you know, the, the revision to next year's earnings estimates I just see this setting up as this is where we're really going to see some big moves in the fourth quarter, I think. But you know, like you, I've thought that it was time before and been really frustrated and chastened. But you know, it's really hard. It's not just the ISMs too.

I mean, if it were just these two charts, maybe you could dismiss it, but it's not. I mean, we've seen. so many indicators, again coming back to the inventory-to-sales ratios and discretionary spending, that this is a much broader story, and it's not one that can be readily dismissed as a function of, you know, the trade war and global slowdown. This is really something that has roots closer to home.

Gold, the gold/copper ratio and fiat money

Erik Townsend: Stephanie, I want to make sure we touch on gold in this interview. You've got a chart on page 14, but why don't we broaden out to the bigger picture? Feels to me like, okay, finally it's time for, you know, the argument's been there. Grant Williams has been making this argument for years and years, but the strength in the dollar and other factors have stopped gold from really making an advance. It seems like the gold bull market that so many of us have anticipated is finally upon us. Would you agree? Do you think that we're overdone here? Should we still expect a correction? And where do you see gold in the next several years?

Stephanie Pomboy: I'm about as gun-shy about that as I am on the, on the credit spread side, because I've said it so many times before. But I am impressed with gold's performance in the face of what has been, you know, real dollar strength here. So, I think it does feel like it's different now, as dangerous as it is to say that. And I think maybe You know, in part that reflects this increasing recognition that where we're going, if we have a real slowdown here, if this devolves, the current situation in the economy devolves, is not a good place. You know, we're gonna do more QE, maybe we get into MMT. You know, we're gonna see a lot of these candidates in the next year get up and express some views that I think will be pretty scary to the markets.

And I think that gold is sort of reflecting an increased possibility that that we see something in that direction. And that chart on page fourteen is really it's an interesting one just because it's been a real signal flare of issues in the past, be they domestic or or foreign or you know economic or financial. But generally, when gold is outperforming copper, basically what you're doing is you're saying that the number one, let's say, metallic barometer of financial security versus the number one metallic barometer of economic security, Dr. Copper sort of being the preeminent indication of the global economy, when gold starts to outperform, it's been a sign that trouble is brewing. And so I've denoted all the financial crises that we've seen when we've been at these levels in the past. And maybe it's kind of a neat way to tie this all up by pointing out that the last time we were at these levels of gold outperforming copper was 2016, before, you know, the election turned everything around.

We were really clearly on the, on the cusp of a recession back then. And Now we're every bit as high today. So that's going to be interesting to watch.

But I do think that gold is really starting to reflect not just what we're seeing here domestically, but this idea that central banks maybe have now pushed to the point where they've essentially— these unfunded liabilities of pensions, not just here in the US, but around the globe, are so extreme that the next phase of monetary policy, when we have the next downturn, whenever, you know, if it's coming now or next year or the year after, is going to be so enormous that it really could shake the foundation of fiat money.

MacroMavens website and wrap-up

Erik Townsend: And finally, Stephanie, I noticed that your website, macromavens.com, got a facelift recently. What's going on there, and what can people expect to find when they get there?

Stephanie Pomboy: So yes, I have undertaken a facelift on the website, and now people will be able to see over the 17 years— I can't believe it's been that long that I've been at this— some of the, the major calls I've been making, which till recently have been accessible only to the institutional investment community. And I'm now allowing some high-net-worth individual investors to get to benefit from these insights. So I'm hoping that people will take a look and see what we're all about over here at MacroMavens.

Erik Townsend: And again, the website is macromavens.com. We didn't get to all of the charts in Stephanie's chart book, but I do highly recommend that you download the chart book. The charts are all very interesting. And again, you could follow up with Stephanie at MacroMavens.com. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@MacroVoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: Rick Rule on a family-office precious metals portfolio

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Erik, that was a great interview with Stephanie, but joining us now in the postgame is Rick Rule, who is the president and CEO of Sprott US Holdings. How are you doing, Rick?

Rick Rule: Life is very good, thank you.

Erik Townsend: Rick, as you know, we differentiate at MacroVoices by focusing on a more sophisticated audience. I think most of our audience has heard the basic gold interview with Rick Rule, which has been done so many times by so many other podcasts. I don't even want to go there. Let's talk about a hypothetical sophisticated investor. Let's suppose we're talking about a family office with, for sake of round numbers, $100 million of assets. assets under management. First question is, for what I think, and I'm guessing you'll agree with me, is a coming secular gold bull market over the next decade. Feels like it's more than just a 10% allocation, but what is the allocation for a large sophisticated investor and for someone who has the wherewithal? Let's assume that our audience understands options, understands and is qualified to participate in accredited investor instruments such as private placements.

Rick Rule: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: How do you play this? If you were advising someone to lay out a strategy for that family office to participate in precious metals— could be gold, could be silver, could be other precious metals— how do you do it? What instruments do you use? What percentage of it is metal versus equities? How much of that is private equity versus public equity? Give us the whole rundown.

Rick Rule: Well, a lot of the answer depends on the nature of the family office and the family business. A family fortune which is involved mostly in fixed income instruments like bonds over the longer term needs to hedge against the possible ravages of inflation. So we begin there with an allocation to physical precious metals, insuring the rest of the portfolio.

An investor whose business gives them the ability to fight back against inflation, a private business that can be price makers as opposed to price takers, would of course enjoy a different sort of asset spread.

But we begin by saying, if you think that gold and silver are going to go up, start with owning physical gold and silver or gold and silver surrogates. Our preference, of course, being the Sprott Physical Gold or Sprott Physical Gold and Silver products on the New York Stock Exchange.

Moving on, I think it's important to note that if you look at a 40-year gold chart, I refer to the 40-year Barron's Gold Mining Stock Index, you will see that at least in a historic context, we are either approaching the bottom, at the bottom, or just off the bottom. of a fairly dramatic bull market in gold equities. Your listeners who have been through it, of course, understand that.

The importance of that is really threefold. The first is that people's timing is probably pretty good at the bottom, close to the bottom, just off the bottom.

But the second thing to note is that recoveries from bear market bottoms are very dramatic in the gold space. They vary between about 200% on the low side to 1,200% on the high side. And these recoveries take place over fairly constrained periods of time, between 2 years and 4.5 years, which means that what we're looking forward to, if past is prologue, is somewhere between a 200% gain and a 1,200% gain in the equities, which is fairly dramatic.

The point of that is that early on in a gold bull market, you participate not in terms of trying to outperform the market itself, which performs well, But trying to obtain market performance with less risk. In other words, about 75% of your allocation to gold equities should be in extraordinarily high-quality equities. Reduce your risk rather than attempting to maximize your gain.

Mercifully, for a family office, as you describe, a $100 million account, having 75% of their equities exposure in the market still gives them a fairly substantial sum of money to attempt to outgain what is already an extremely attractive investment proposition.

That is traditionally done for sophisticated investors via private placements. Private placement, for those who don't know, is the ability to buy equity directly from the company rather than a secondary market transaction. And the advantage of doing that is really threefold. The first is that you can acquire a rather large position without having to worry too much about moving the market as a consequence of your position. The second is that your timing is usually good because a well-chosen private placement allows you to contribute capital to a company to answer an unanswered question. It might be with a series of drill holes, but the idea is almost always that the capital is employed in a fashion that, if successful, will generate a fairly immediate response in the value of the equity you bought.

The 3rd advantage of a private placement, at least a well-structured private placement, is of course warrants— the right but not the obligation to buy more stock at a fixed price for a fixed period of time. That's important because if the answer to the unanswered question that you financed with the capital contribution comes back as yes, you have the ability to take advantage of that after it's been de-risked, which is really important. So, in answer to your question, start with the bullion, move from the bullion to the highest quality gold and silver equities, and move from there to private placements.

I would also say one other thing, and I'll be talking about this at a conference that you and I will be attending later this year.

Don't forget, in constructing a sophisticated precious metals portfolio, looking at debt instruments. At Sprott, we have provided capital for mine construction for many years, but also in bridge and mezzanine finance. And when I look back at the last decade that we've had, the period of 2010 to now, the Toronto Stock Exchange Venture Index of sort of sub-billion market cap mining companies Nobody needs reminding of this, but the index fell by in excess of 80% over 10 years.

At the same period of time, accounts at Sprott that were dedicated to lending, in particular the on-balance-sheet lending activities of Sprott Inc., generated in excess of 15% compounded internal rates of return. So sophisticated investors of the type that you described, family offices or $100 million portfolios, should consider including debt instruments to a normal equity portfolio. And we'll be talking about that a lot this year.

Rick Rule: allocation percentages and 'invest before you speculate'

Erik Townsend: Okay, can you give us— obviously, the particulars of a client's circumstances have to dictate this, but at a high level, can you give us a breakdown between those 4 asset classes that you described, which is physical bullion, public equities, private equity through private placements, and debt instruments? What's the percentage allocation?

Rick Rule: Well, in a normal circumstance, in a normal market, I tell family offices, again, depending on individual circumstances, that they should be between sort of 10% and 15% invested in precious metals. For a variety of circumstances, the low valuations of the equity and my own concerns about things like the US dollar, sophisticated investors, I think, now can go up to sort of 20% involved in precious metals and precious metals equities.

I believe in having lots of liquidity in accounts, meaning, as an example, lots of cash. And although gold and silver are volatile, I consider them to be bedrock currencies. So my own suspicion is that most accounts at present should be sort of 10% of the total account in bullion, particularly if other aspects of their portfolio are really bond-centric, in particular long bond-centric. Where the account needs protection from the ravages of inflation.

From there, I would suggest a portfolio that is— once we're past the bullion into other investment instruments, I would suggest a portfolio that is at least 75% investment-oriented.

This can be done either by buying the equities of the highest-quality gold companies or creating a portfolio that is combining the equity of the highest-quality precious metals mining company with debt instruments from other companies where your upside is perhaps less, but your downside is constrained because you are at the base of the capital stack ahead of all of the other participants.

And from there, after you've taken care of bullion, after you've taken care of investing so that you capture the bull market beta that you see in the gold equities, then you participate by trying to outperform the market. Now, it's worth noting, and I'll tell this joke on myself at this upcoming conference. The truth is that all of the money that I currently invest prudently, I made by speculation.

So I'm not saying don't speculate. What I am saying is invest before you speculate. If you look at the chart that I mentioned, the Barron's 40-year chart, and any of your listeners who contact me, I'll send them a copy of the chart.

If you look at this chart, one of the amazing things that comes out of it is the incredible performance of gold equities in these recoveries. As I said earlier in this interview, recoveries are commonly between 200%— that's the whole index, not the best stocks— and 1,200%. So for most of the money that you have invested in the sector, the idea is just catching market beta. With as little risk as you can have in place. Of course, the historic gains occur with the money that you invest more and more aggressively, but I can't say enough, invest before you speculate.

Erik Townsend: Okay, so to summarize, we're looking at about 10% of total net worth in physical bullion— gold and silver bars, coins, whatever the, the denomination is— and then on top of that, another 7% or so of total net worth in a combination of public equities and debt instruments, and maybe another 3% in speculative private placement kind of things. Is that a fair summary of, of the allocation?

Rick Rule: Yeah, in a very general sense, that's absolutely right.

Silver and Gold Summit preview

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Rick, you're going to be covering this topic and so much more at the Silver and Gold Summit with me coming up in just over a week. It's on October 27th and 28th. Now, you've got a number of panels that you're a part of, but you're also doing some keynote presentation. What do you plan on talking about when you're out there at the show?

Rick Rule: Actually, surprisingly, a lot about what we just talked about. Strategies for participating in a gold equities bull market. It has been so long since we've been in a bull market that many speculators and many investors forget the lessons that they should have learned in prior bull and bear markets.

So, interestingly, the topic that we talked about today will be the focus of what I'm talking about in San Francisco. The importance of capturing beta and how to capture alpha if you're after alpha.

Patrick Ceresna: Right, right. Well, Rick, you know what, I look forward to seeing you out there, and I'll see you in a week.

Rick Rule: It'll be a pleasure. Thank you.

Patrick Ceresna: No, thank you for joining us.

Mailbag: Dr. Steve on whether the Fed should stop or do more

Erik Townsend: Patrick, it's always great to have Rick. I'm sorry I won't be able to join you guys in San Francisco next week. I really want to get into your chartbook and get a quick update from you on the equity market, but before we go there, I saw in the inbox In the inbox this week, our friend Dr. Steve, who's a longtime listener, sent us a question. What was Steve's question?

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So Steve reached out to us and he had a question about— after listening to all of our interviews with so many of our guests, and it came up asking the question that the Fed hasn't been all that productive with monetary policy in terms of its impact on the real economy and not necessarily helping or maybe even making things worse. But at the same time, many of our guests are spending a fair amount of time saying the Fed is behind the curve and needs to be more aggressive in extending the cycle. And so, he's just trying to wrestle with this idea.

On the one hand, we are saying the Fed should stop manipulating the markets, but on the other hand, we're saying that they should be spending more time kind of juicing up the market for another run. And he's asking, would that not make the problem even bigger down the road? And how do you struggle with this idea of whether the Fed should stop manipulating or whether they should actually be doing more. What's your take on that, Erik?

Erik Townsend: I think it's a question of choosing your battles and, you know, the old saying of changing the things you can't accept, but at the same time accepting the things that you can't change. I think a lot of our guests that are on the program would agree with me that the world would be a better place if the Fed were not trying to manage financial markets.

But at the same time, we live in a world where they They think that's their job. And if you live in a world where the Fed thinks it's their job to manage the economy and manage financial markets, you'd like to at least encourage them to do a good job of that if they insist on making it their business to do that.

And I think that when our listeners— Steve mentioned in his email, Juliette Declercq and Julian Brigden saying, hey, you know, the Fed's behind the curve, needs to get to it. You know, why are Julian and Juliette saying the Fed needs needs to do more of what seems to be a bad idea.

I think it's because they accept that we live in a world where the Fed thinks it's their job to manage the economy. And if they think that that's their job, they ought to at least pay attention to the indicators that Julian and Juliette are watching. And those indicators seem to suggest that they're behind the curve. So I think it's a question of choosing your battles, Patrick. But in any case, let's move on. Speaking of choosing your battles, Thank you.

Patrick's chartbook: S&P 500 and global equities near breakouts

Erik Townsend: Listeners, you'll find the download link for Patrick's postgame chartbook in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads on our homepage. Patrick, you've got the S&P 500 daily here, almost, just almost on page 2, scraping back up to new all-time highs. What's going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So, the chartbook in itself is looking at actually global equities. The S&P here, I wanted to particularly just use as a reference because I find it fascinating. We're at this kind of end-of-business-cycle kind of dynamic, and at the same time, we have a global manufacturing recession underway. And normally, when I hear that kind of stuff, it would make me think that the charts should be very toppy and bearish. And yet, when I look at these charts, it's amazing how resilient the bulls have been and, and holding it up. So now when we take a look at that S&P 500, it's, uh, been a, a week of some positive news on the global geopolitical front that is pushing the S&P back up to its highs. And this is such a fascinating crossroad on, uh, for the market because I think the big tell comes in literally right here because the bulls are given enough juice that they should theoretically break this market to an all-time new high, and then all sorts of feedback loops will push the market and have it gain some momentum as many investors are going to be forced to chase these markets potentially higher.

But if the market can't use this kind of short-term positive news to push to new highs, I think that then we have the risk that this becomes just another shoulder of a bigger topping formation, and things could really get ugly toward the tail end of the year. And I'm not actually going to make the big bold call. I actually think that the next few weeks are going to be just crucial for determining what's in store for the market for the 4th quarter, and at least how the remainder of the 4th quarter plays out.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'm particularly interested in your commentary on page 3, because if I'm looking at that correctly, it looks like just today we've got a breakout to a new all-time high on the MSCI World Index. Now, that's very much at odds with the commentary we've heard from some of our guests that are saying, hey, the S&P is the last man standing, the rest of the global markets are already rolling over. What's going on here?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is exactly it. You know, we're looking at all of this kind of bearish news and economic data coming in soft, even in the US, but yet you have the, the world index here about to break to fresh highs. And we see that in so many of the other major global market developed markets, such as let's say the Nikkei, which has broken to a 2019 high, at least breaking the, the to a year high. Or even on page 5, we have the Euro Stoxx 50 breaking to a fresh new high for the year. And so it's really an interesting question, is, is that are we witnessing another leg higher in spite of all of this bearish news? Because every bone in my body wants to be bearish, Erik. Just like you often say, it doesn't make a lot of sense to kind of keep bulling, but these charts just continue to look like they want to go higher.

And I just feel that it's going to be a really interesting moment to find out whether or not this happens.

Erik Townsend: You know, I really think these charts are telling a very important story. There's so many good reasons, and you listen to so many of the things that Stephanie said in today's interview. There's so many good reasons on a fundamental level to be bearish, but look at what the chart's telling you.

I see charts here that all want to break out aggressively higher and are waiting for an excuse to do so. And it's crazy to me in contrast to the way I interpret the fundamentals, but there's no way I want to short this market right now. I'm afraid it's about to break higher.

Patrick Ceresna: I agree. The one thing though I'll say is that why I'm not ready to be outright super bullish, because this This is actually a huge tell. All the technicals are pointing for this breakout, and under all circumstances, the bulls, if they show up here, should be able to make a legitimate push to the upside. But what if they don't show up? What if this breakout fizzles very quickly and some sort of a variable is introduced to the market, some news event that basically makes it give it all back? That would actually make me very quickly want to flip-flop, but I'm going to give the benefit of the out to the bulls. They have, they have a possession of the ball here, and they have a chance to run with it. And I'm dying to find out whether they pull it off. On page 6 though, I wanted to just put one chart because we were focusing really on the developed markets.

But even when you go to Brazil, where you have in many cases considered an emergent market, and you see here that the chart pattern looks very similar. It's right near its 52-week highs, just kind of rolling up Making higher lows sequentially right up to there. Will we see a breakout here? This is such an interesting moment in the market.

San Francisco summit and Big Picture Trading free trial

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to page 7, I'm wishing I could break out and be with you as you're going to be hanging out in San Francisco with Brent Johnson and Rick Rule and Grant Williams. I think you're actually speaking on a panel with Grant Williams and Brent Johnson. Tell us about what you're going to be speaking with, But more importantly, for the benefit of our listeners who may want to join you guys in San Francisco, what's the scoop? How can they get signed up?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's not just hanging out, me hanging out with them, but all of our listeners that would like to come out can hang out with all of us. And we're going to be there for the 2 days on the 27th and 28th, and we're going to have all sorts of panel discussions and opportunities to meet so many of our listeners. Uh, it would be great, uh, any of our MacroVoices listeners that can make it out, please do.

There is— it's just important to know that if you are going to register, you can get 50% off of the ticket by using the promo code MACRO50, which is, uh, the, the promo code for MacroVoices listeners. So make sure you take advantage of that if you register. I have my own little keynote thing that I'm doing talking about those commodity cycles that I've, uh, done some many times before, but I'm also going to be on the big gold panel moderated by Marin Katusa, and it's going to be Brent Johnson, Cal Everett, and Grant Williams on there with me. It's going to be a great time.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. And that's all happening next weekend, October 27th and 28th, at the Hyatt in San Francisco. Finally, Patrick, moving on to page 8, we are still getting some inquiries about the ratio call spread and where people can find that video. Tell us about the 14-day free access pass for Big Picture Trading.

Patrick Ceresna: That's right. When Tian was on the other week, he reintroduced the ratio call spreads out there, and I still think it's an amazing strategy at this stage in the market because that right tail risk, the way we were looking at those charts, it really does exist. Anyway, it's a great way of putting on some trades just in case the market really does gain some juice to the upside. We have a boot camp video available at Big Picture Trading. Anyone can access it with a 14-day complimentary access, so you can just visit bigpicturetrading.com and register for the free trial.

Sign-off and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: We're gonna have to leave it there in the interest of time. Today's episode of MacroVoices was made possible by toptradersunplugged.com. Be sure to check out my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen published back on September 7th, 2019, when we go in-depth on the subject of trend-following strategies. The link is in your Research Roundup email. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/sponsorinfo.

And be sure to sign up for your free account at MacroVoices. That gets you access to our free weekly email blast, the Research Roundup, that contains links to all of the best free download content that we can find on the internet, including supporting materials for our feature interviews. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook that accompanies Stephanie's presentation, as well as the chartbook that we discussed here in the postgame. There's also an interesting article asking if Facebook's Libra is a threat to national sovereignty And also a link to a great article from oilprice.com about the complete history of the oil markets. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com. MacroVoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account. At MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. or sponsors.

MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, Visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top