Robert Friedland — Billionaire Canadian financier (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 264 was recorded on March 25th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company Ticker ABRA on TSX Venture and ABBRF in the United States. Billionaire Canadian financier Robert Friedland will join me as this week's feature interview guest. Now, as we explained last week, Robert already gave me a terrific 2-part interview on the Smarter Markets podcast on the subject of what it's really going to take to green the global economy. In today's MacroVoices interview, we'll discuss how to invest in the formative green revolution and where the best opportunities can be found for investors. So if you missed the 2-part interview on Smarter Markets, we suggest you listen to that first. You'll find the link in your Research Roundup email or at smartermarketspod.com.
Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck will be titled Flirting with the 50-Day Moving Averages.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump into that S&P 500 because we're now going about 5, 6 days of selling off of the highs that were put in, and it's been weakening a little bit. What's your take? Do you think this is just gonna be a buy-on-dip opportunity?
Erik Townsend: You know, I don't know, Patrick. It's been a whole week since there was an all-time high, and people are starting to get upset about that. Boy, if ever there was a sign of a top, it's when people think it's a big deal that there hasn't been a new all-time high in the last week. On the other hand, boy, the evidence for a crack-up boom and central bank-driven liquidity just carrying these markets higher is pretty darn strong. So no real change in my outlook. I think this could go either way. I don't think this is an easy market to call by any stretch of the imagination. But I do think if I was going to make any play on it, it would be something like your rolling straddle or calendared straddle strategy, where you're betting that there needs to be a big move in one direction or the other without taking a directional assumption as to which way it's going to go.
I don't think it's safe to make big directional calls in this market.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because we are now decisively above 92. We almost got up to the 93 level today. Is this a breakout in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I definitely think we should put a chart of this up in the postgame segment because yes, we did finally get our daily close over 92 only a couple of days ago because as much as you'd had a few tests above it, it was only intraday. So it's only a couple of days, but boy, in those couple of days since we did get that closing print above 92. It's continued to move up from there almost to 93 as we're speaking.
You know, looks to me like there's some legs to this and that we're going to see at least some further upside. The thing is, I've said before, Patrick, is I just don't care about the dollar index as much as I used to because it's a relative measure. It's the dollar versus other currencies. The value of all fiat currencies is going down, not up. What we're seeing here in the dollar index is that the US dollar is strong.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: than other fiats. Not that the dollar is gaining purchasing power relative to real things in the real world. So I'm not as focused on it as I used to be, but it does look like the trend is actually starting to turn up and we're beyond that consolidation range that we've been stuck in for the last several months.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's get to that crude oil because the correction seems to be continuing. I'd love to get your take on what's going on here.
Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, as we told you last Thursday, that big, huge move down definitely changed the game. So we've now got on the daily chart a downtrend, not an uptrend. And, you know, this is totally to be expected. How many times have I said in the course of this meteoric rise where crude oil has effectively doubled in price since November that at some point we had to see a significant pullback? So far we got about $10 of downside. Maybe that could be the end of it. I think it probably has farther to go. I'll be very surprised if we move below $50 and stay there.
I could imagine I imagine maybe worst case that there is a brief challenge on an intraday basis below 50 just to knock out any stop orders that might be sitting just below that round number support. But frankly, even getting down to 50, I doubt it. I think we'll stay probably in the 55 to 60 range as far as where we might get at a bottom. Now, there is an argument that says maybe the bottom is already in, and that argument is so far the bottom has been almost perfectly on the 13-week moving average at 57. 57.38. We already know that the daily chart pattern has shifted from uptrend to downtrend, but on the weekly chart, which is much longer in terms of its time scale, we're still in an uptrend. Now, a weekly close below the 13-week moving average— so that would be a close on Friday below 57.38— that would change the direction of the weekly trend to down as opposed to up.
Now, is that really going to make any difference? Is anybody paying attention to that, I don't know. But certainly when we do get that signal, if we get it, of a weekly close below 57.39, that would really say, okay, there's probably more to this, there's more coming. Maybe it'll take another month to play out, as corrections and consolidations tend to. If we stay above 57.39, that suggests maybe this is just a short-lived spike down and might be over soon. Any hope of it being over soon would be abandoned, though, on a weekly close below 57.39. So I'm watching that.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But Patrick, this doesn't change the big picture. We're in a secular bull market in terms of commodities generally, and particularly in terms of crude oil. Anytime the price of anything doubles in the course of a few months, the fact that you get a significant pullback shouldn't surprise anybody.
As far as inventory this week, crude oil built 1.9 million barrels, a bigger build than expected. But there was also a gasoline build of fairly small, 203,000 barrels, but a pretty significant Pretty significant distillate build of 3.8 million barrels. So builds across the board. On a net basis, it's a build of 5 million barrels of petroleum products between crude and finished products. That should have been a bearish signal. And of course, the market crashed on that news. Down, down, down in a sell-off that lasted for— wait for it— 9.6 minutes. before it had fully retraced back to pre-inventory levels, and it just took off to the upside from there. When I saw that, the market shrugging off what could have been a bearish inventory report and moving fairly aggressively higher and also taking out the 5-day moving average in the process, I really thought for a while on Thursday, okay, maybe this is already over. But the retest today of that 13-week moving average at $57.40 really says to me, meh, okay, there's probably more downside to come before It's over.
I don't think it's a whole lot more downside.
US production, 11 million barrels, ticking up by just 100,000 barrels from where it was and back to exactly where it was before the Texas freezeout. So we've recovered US production back to where it was. It's going to be really interesting to see what happens, Patrick. I don't think that we have a crash or the end of the world. Some people are saying, oh no, look at what happened to the May contract last year. Look, we had a completely, totally different fundamental backdrop last year. This is not the beginning of a crash that's gonna take us to negative prices just the way the same thing happened last year. This is the beginning of an overdue correction, which may take us another $5 or $6 lower before it's over. Who knows? Maybe it's a whole $10 lower, but it's a perfectly healthy correction in a bull market.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to gold. We're now several weeks off of that low, and— but gold really seems to be struggling here. What's your take on the price action?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's really not impressing me that much in terms of a lot of people were saying, okay, it's, you know, that's got to be it, it's over, we're— it's all headed up from here. First of all, you would need a daily close above 1780, which is where the channel resistance line is now, in order to even have a signal that there had been a change in direction. And frankly, off of that low that we had at 1680, we only got about halfway there, and already the market appears to be rolling over. Furthermore, it doesn't seem to have been able to get beyond its short-term moving averages. The 5, 8, and 13-day moving average. And that's often a sign that, you know, maybe we're getting to the point where this bounce has topped out and we're about to head down. We haven't taken out all of those short-term moving averages to the downside yet, but we're right on the hairy edge of that.
So just a little bit more downside on a closing basis, and it would really suggest that we're maybe headed down to another lower low or to retest that low. And again, I don't think any of this should really come as any great surprise to anyone.
We're seeing a perception that real rates are backing up and that there's a trend of increasing real interest rates. I think that's just because inflation is lagging in its reporting. But at the same time, that's what people think and that's what they're trading on. It's perfectly reasonable to expect further downside. And if it happens, I think it's a gift to gold bulls who will seize that opportunity to buy even more gold at even better prices. And I won't be at all surprised if there's another $200 of downside from here. Long run, it's gonna be all up for gold, but it's a story that's not ready to play out yet.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's wrap up by touching on this 10-year Treasury yield. We printed about 1.75 a week ago, and we're really off about 10, 15 basis points off the high, nothing crazy. What's your take? Do you think that's like a meaningful turn in the yields, or is it just a typical little pause?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think the real question is not where the number is right now, but where the trend is headed. We have had a couple of false signals where somebody famous like David Tepper says, okay folks, that's it. We've reached as far as we're gonna see on the backup. And everybody's like, okay, somebody famous said this is over. Let's breathe a sigh of relief and forget it ever happened. Then we go to higher yields and everybody panics again and the world is coming to an end and the sky is falling and so on and so forth. And then we start to see a little backing off in those yields. The question is, are we in the middle of a trend which is going to continue to higher yields or have we seen a peak? I don't know the answer to that question, Patrick. I'm gonna continue to ask our macro interview guests and try to get their perspective in coming weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is billionaire Canadian financier, Robert Friedland. Now, Erik, why did we invite Robert on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: This is an important one, Patrick. There have been moments in MacroVoices history where we supplied you with serious edge. The last and most notable one would be January 30th, 2020, when we dropped everything and changed our production schedule to bring you Dr. Chris Martenson to explain that a global pandemic was very possibly coming, that eventually led to me discussing selling crude oil futures and buying puts on crude oil futures and so forth, which turned out to be an incredibly lucrative trade.
I'm gonna make the argument that Robert Friedland's revelation, which was already expressed in the 2-part series that many of our listeners already heard in the Smarter Markets podcast, that all you have to do is figure out how to drill the right-sized and shaped tunnels through very hot rock, and you can completely solve the clean energy decarbonization problem for the whole planet. That is really profound. Now, Robert Friedland doesn't have the solution. He does have $1 billion of investment of his own and his friends' money into a unicorn company that's trying to find that solution. But regardless of whether Robert's company or somebody else figures this out, Getting a real solution to climate change and eliminating dependency on fossil fuels is a game changer for the whole planet. And I think it's really important to understand where this geothermal opportunity lies, what the technology barriers are that are preventing us from solving this problem right now, and what it's gonna take to overcome them.
Let's come back. I wanna— I don't wanna steal Robert Friedland's thunder, so let's let him talk about this in the feature interview and touch on it again, Patrick, when we get to the postgame segment. Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik's interview with Robert is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My 2-part interview with billionaire financier Robert Friedland, exploring what it will take to green the global economy, is already available now at smartermarketspod.com and is strongly recommended as prerequisite listening before today's feature interview.
My guest on Smarter Markets this coming Saturday morning will be Dr. Leemon Baird, co-founder of Hedera Hashgraph and the inventor of Hashgraph, one of the first distributed ledger technologies to be based on proof of stake.
Patrick Ceresna: Hi, everyone.
Erik Townsend: Proof of stake rather than proof of work validation in order to provide a much faster and more efficient alternative to blockchain. But you won't find Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to separately subscribe to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is billionaire financier Robert Friedland, best known as the founder and CEO of Ivanhoe Mines but perhaps more relevantly to this conversation, Robert is also the chairman and CEO of Ivanhoe Capital Corporation, the private venture capital and family office enterprise which invests in a lot of fascinating technologies that I want to talk to Robert about today in this interview. Listeners, if you didn't catch it in the Before we get into the introduction with Patrick Ceresna, please be sure to first listen to my 2 interviews with Robert on the subject of greening the global economy on the Smarter Markets Podcast, because what we're going to do in today's interview is to expound on that conversation. If you didn't hear that conversation, today's conversation isn't going to make sense. Robert, let's start not with those topics, but with you as an investor, because your mind absolutely fascinates me. You wowed our Smarter Markets audience with the story of camel polo in the snow on your albino racing camel.
So we kind of have this vision of Robert Friedland as the camel-riding mining executive who sounds like an Indiana Jones kind of character. But you were one of the principal investors and creators of satellite radio, Sirius and XM satellite radio. So I'm just trying to imagine, how does a mining executive sit down one day and say, hey, I, I think I'll take advantage of advancements in MOSFET transistors and, you know, invent SiriusXM radio. How do you know about all these things and thorium reactors and all the other things that we're going to talk about today?
Robert Friedland: Well, you know, um, I grew up in the 1960s, uh, when the, the motto was turn on, tune in, drop out, and then my dad crawl back. So So, having lived in the 1960s and the psychedelic era, I think from a very early age, a lot of my friends and I sort of thought that it's possible to create a reality distortion field.
And so, unconventional thinking has been a part of my life for as long back as I can remember. And I've always liked to hang around with people who think that nothing is impossible. And so, we always look at everything from first principles, perhaps with a different sort of viewpoint. than most people, but I've seen miracles created in my lifetime. I've seen many things become huge out of nothing.
And so, that's always changed my view and made me feel that truly anything is impossible and that we're really limited only by the human imagination and focusing our attention continuously until we achieve what it is we imagined.
Erik Townsend: Well, let's dive into some of these topics that we discussed in the Smarter Markets series on greening the global economy, starting The green revolution and decarbonization is obviously a big political theme. Jeff Currie from Goldman Sachs told us the biggest priority of financial markets has to be putting a price on carbon.
How should we as investors think about decarbonization specifically? Where are the investment plays? And we'll get later into some of the energy generation stuff, but just about this idea of decarbonization and now the trading of carbon credits on markets. How do you think about that as an investor?
Robert Friedland: Well, just to start with a minor protest, we can't really eliminate one of the most common elements in the universe, carbon. We're a carbon-based life form, as is our pet dogs and cats. So, it's really carbon dioxide we're speaking about, a global warming gas, which is not as potent a global warming gas as methane, for example.
whole family of gases in the environment that really apparently, to the best of modern science, are leading to a greenhouse effect and are going to cause enormous long-term problems for humanity unless that trend is reversed. You ask the average person what percentage of the atmosphere is carbon dioxide, I wonder if you happen to know.
Erik Townsend: I ought to know that.
Robert Friedland: Well, let's take a guess. CO2, not carbon. I mean, it's carbon dioxide. So let's take a look at Google. What does Google say?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't— that's cheating. I want to say less than 2% because I know you got 21% oxygen and about 77% or 78% of nitrogen. So that only leaves 1% or 2% of CO2 and other gases.
Robert Friedland: Exactly. You're quite warm. So carbon dioxide is 0.04 of 1% of the Earth's atmosphere. 0.04 of 1%. So that's not very much, at least optically or intuitively. But combined with other global warming gases, it doesn't take much to get a few degrees temperature increase. And then All that permafrost in Siberia can melt and release a lot more global warming gas into the environment. And we could get sort of a runaway effect that we don't really want to gamble with.
So, the fact that we've evolved as a species with sufficient introspection to think that it's possible that anthropomorphic global warming is even possible. is not unlike the evolution of our thinking that the Earth is not flat or that the, the sun does not revolve around the Earth. And so these big concepts, they're very, very slow to be realized throughout the mass of total human consciousness.
The whole thought of plate tectonics, the, the fact that the continents are floating on a liquid golf ball as we hurtle through space And that all these continents are eventually going to be recycled back into the core of the Earth. New York City is going to go down back into the mantle. Los Angeles and London will eventually go back into the mantle. These startling concepts of plate tectonics that modern geology now understands, these ideas have only been with us for 30 years or so and really haven't permeated into human consciousness.
So, this idea about global warming gas has taken about a generation. My daughter, Uma, who was sort of raised in an alternative lifestyle from the time she was a kid, was always talking about global warming gas. It's now gotten to the point where it's precipitating an almost species-wise study of the Earth's atmosphere and humanity's impact on nature. In general. And this may mark the first time as a species we abandon fire.
There's a lot of places where you might not be allowed to have a fireplace anymore and burn wood, even though that's closer to being carbon neutral, carbon dioxide neutral, to be precise. So, I'm sort of amused by everybody talks about a war on carbon when in fact, we're made out of carbon.
And the concept about reduction of global warming gas is complex because when you're a dog, is sitting there panting. He's exhaling carbon dioxide, and so are you every time you exhale. So, it's a very complex problem. And it requires us to look at all living systems and all technological systems in a completely new way.
So, this is going to be around for a long time.
And this change is going to be a lot bigger than, as we said in a previous talk, when In Ronald Reagan's time, you could get long the bond market at 21% interest rates. And going long bonds was a great idea from Ronald Reagan to, say, Joe Biden. And now the bond market is looking like, well, maybe that's not such a good idea anymore.
It's going to have a similar longevity as we look at the transformation of the elimination of global warming gas in all of our systems and everything we do. Just not to take chances because of how disastrous it could potentially be if the worst case came to fruition. So, this is going to be a really interesting topic a year from now, 5 years from now, 10 years from now, 20 years from now, 30 years from now.
And these long-term changes affect the financial markets and they affect the perception of what has value. Or what is currency? Or what is money? And of course, everything is going to change through this enormous generational-long transformation. And that's where we're playing. We're playing where disruptive technology is going to have a big effect on what elements in the periodic table are going to be more valuable in the future and which elements in the periodic table are going to be less valuable.
And if carbon dioxide and other global warming gas are the Let's say they're the thermometer, the temperature in the thermometer. We have to look at what elements are going to be required to monkey with the temperature in that thermometer. And that has a lot to do with technology and the nexus of raw materials, which is the great space we're playing in.
Erik Townsend: Robert, in the Smarter Markets interviews, you described electrifying the global economy, not just as a good idea, but the only way forward for global society in order to get through this green challenge that we face. That's a really big deal. And as we discussed in that interview, it's going to require building a whole new electric grid. And as you described, the United States is a long ways behind China in terms of the quality of engineering and advancement of technology in the electric grid. It seems on the surface like, okay, this has gotta be a fantastic investment opportunity, invest in building the grid. But hang on a second.
You and I are talking about how the US electric grid has to be rebuilt. We get it. Most people don't. This doesn't even seem to be a subject of public conversation. So is there an investment right now in the build-out of the electric grid, or is this just, we hope the government gets their act together sometime in the foreseeable future?
Robert Friedland: Well, that's an interesting and narrow little question. I'm sure people that are in Texas who just lived through a failure of the grid, which would tell you that there's something that's going to have to be done about that particular grid, which incidentally is not linked to the federalization or national electric grid in the United States.
For strange and bizarre circumstances in the past, Texas's grid is not connected to the rest of the United States. Now, that may be very good for the independence of Texas when it was an independent country, But unless they find a way to winterize their grid and harden it against future shock, I think people are going to rethink that one from first principles.
So, you know, there have been failures of the grid in the past. New York City was plunged into darkness in a citywide failure, say 20, 25 years ago. The electricity in New York is largely hydroelectric power that comes down from Quebec. The Canadians are so kind as to have Dammed their lakes and built dams 40, 50 years ago, and they pumped that power down electric wires to New York City. There's only one nuclear power plant near the city that is scheduled to be dismantled.
So when you start talking about how we generate electricity, how we transmit electrical energy, how we bring it the final mile into your home, Clearly, electrification is the only way to keep us out of the Stone Ages, whether it's a school or a hospital or an educational institution, whether it's for the provision of food.
Energy is fundamental to how we run this planet. And the carrying capacity of the planet is debatable. We have roughly 7 billion people on this little ball of iron and silica hurtling through space. We may go to 8 or 9 billion people in our natural lifespan, and then it may or may not taper off. A lot of the world's great religions still advocate large families.
And so it seems like in a lot of developing nations, population growth is still explosive. Take Nigeria, for example, quite explosive, or Indonesia, very young demographics and a lot of growth.
So the world is going to look very different in 20 years as we have a massive increase in urbanization. When I was born in the 1950s, maybe a third of the world's people lived in cities. And now in our lifetime, we're going to have about 60% of the global population moving to cities with an ever smaller percentage of people living in rural environments. And those cities obviously are very dependent on the rest of the planet for everything they consume.
And let's hope that we electrify them so that the air pollution alone doesn't lead to a massive increase in dementia, heart disease, cancer, and other diseases. Because I'd say clean air is probably the number one human requirement. Clean water would rank a close second. And then linked to clean water is good food.
And what could be more basic than food and air and water? And those 3 things are affected by the whole energy system. So the whole system has to be looked at cradle to grave, sperm to germ, or womb to tomb. The whole system is coming under analysis so that as a species, we can live in tune with Mother Nature. It's possible.
It's doable. And it's achievable in our lifetime.
Erik Townsend: Robert, let's talk now about how to make money in terms of investing in this electrification trend. Just so that you don't get accused of talking your book, I'll be the one to make the observation that copper is a huge, huge winner here. Your own company, Ivanhoe Mines, ticker IVN, is an obvious play. Let's talk now about what's not so obvious. What are the other things that you invest in if you want to bet on the electrification of the global economy, including probably a rebuild of the US electric grid at some point?
Robert Friedland: Well, there are about 6 or 8 elements in the periodic table that are critical to the electrification of the world economy. The first major trend will be lightweighting. Everything that moves from point A to point B in transportation has to be made stronger and lighter so that there's less carbon dioxide or global warming gas involved In getting you from point A to point B. So aluminum and all of the alloys that strengthen aluminum, like magnesium and scandium and lithium, are winners.
Then those metals that conduct electrical energy are winners, and copper is the best electrical and thermal conductor, save for gold and silver, which are too expensive for most uses in electrification. So copper is an enormous winner along with aluminum. Then come a suite of specialty metals that are critical for a whole host of uses in catalytic converters as we phase out the internal combustion engine, platinum and palladium and rhodium, and specialty metals that harden steel and create all kinds of industrial magic like niobium and vanadium.
And scandium as an additive to aluminum turns aluminum into something like titanium, another very important metal. So let's say we could identify 10 elements in the periodic table whose value is certain to rise against the United States dollar or any other fiat currency.
And then we have another series of commodities which over time, and I'm talking about over a considerable period of time, are likely to be less valuable. And that would be hydrocarbon and coal. Now hydrocarbon will still have value for plastics and petrochemicals and specialty uses. And probably once a year you'll roll out an old internal combustion engine and get a permit to take it down Fifth Avenue in New York on say the Fourth of July.
But there's going to be a generation of kids that are about to grow up who will have never experienced an internal combustion engine. So, the world is going to change. And as a consequence, there's a very safe long-term play in playing those electrification metals.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk now about not just the battery metals, but the battery technology. I hear a lot of investors saying, look, you got to speculate in lithium because, boy, electric vehicles are coming. They need lithium to build those lithium-ion batteries. And I think, wait a minute, every few years we get an advancement in a new battery chemistry and something's better than the last one. We went from nickel metal hydride to lithium to lithium-ion.
What comes next? And I know you've talked a lot about nickel in the past. Is nickel the common denominator that there's some metallurgical or physics reason that the nickel is going to be in the batteries regardless of what the next chemistry is? Or is there a possibility that the next chemistry doesn't involve nickel?
Robert Friedland: Well, first of all, we'll talk about batteries, but let's not forget the hydrogen economy because these 2 massive technological changes are not really enemies. They will travel together in different lanes. But starting with batteries, basically what we're doing with the transportation batteries is we're on a super intensive sustained effort to make them more energy dense.
To make the energy contained in a battery more like gasoline. If we have a gallon of gasoline between us and I light a match, you can see the enormous amount of energy stored in a gallon of gasoline. We'd be in a flash of fire. There'd be an explosion.
So as these energies become more energy dense, certain metals and technologies are required. We started with nickel metal hydride, And the current rage is lithium-ion batteries. And yes, they're not really made out of lithium. There's lithium in them, but the predominant constituent in the current generation of batteries is actually nickel and to a lesser degree cobalt and then lithium. And we're going to be moving away from lithium-ion batteries into quasi-solid-state polymer or gel-related batteries. That will be safer and even more energy dense.
So the holy grail is to make these batteries extremely energy dense and yet relatively safe from the possibility of fire. A lot of people don't know that it's not just wood in your fireplace that burns, but lithium burns and aluminum burns, and most metals will burn. So you're you're trying to make the battery more energy dense and yet make it less. Likely to catch on fire in the event of an impact or a penetration into the battery system. And so the technology is very, very rapidly evolving.
And within 5 years, we will be beyond lithium-ion batteries. The anode side of the battery will probably evolve from its current generation to a silicon anode or a lithium metal anode. And the cathode side of the battery will have more and more nickel for a high energy density. The luxury batteries for a Porsche or for a Mercedes, for a high-quality car, will be very nickeliferous.
It will have some cobalt, not zero, perhaps less, but a lot of nickel. And it doesn't matter whether you call it solid-state or quasi-solid-state, all of the high-end energy-dense batteries will require nickel. It will be possible to make a cheaper battery with phosphorus and iron battery, but it'll be an inferior battery for a cheaper car. If you just want short range and you want to run down to the store to pick up a dozen eggs, it's possible to have a cheaper car with a cheaper battery.
But since everybody wants something great, most of the pressure's going to be on nickel metal. Lithium will have to be mined in much greater quantities than it's mined today. But fortunately, lithium is an extremely common salt in the crust of the Earth. Lithium metal is found around the world in numerous deposits. Nickel is a much harder fish to catch.
And so we're going to see a shortage of nickel long before we really have to worry about the physical supply of lithium.
Erik Townsend: Where are the investment plays there? Is it in mining companies that mine those metals? Is it in battery companies that engineer new battery chemistries? How does an play this advancement of battery technology?
Robert Friedland: The battery companies that are getting into actual alliances with the automakers are going to be big winners on the electrification side. You hear the names of the legendary automobile companies, but they're basically assemblers of components. And the critical component in the electric car is the battery itself. It replaces the internal combustion engine because the electric motor is widely available and extremely reliable. Nidec from Japan is the world's biggest builder of electric motors, and Nidec is a great company, privately owned.
But the batteries, they're going to be competing technologies. There'll probably be 3 or 4 or 5 industry leaders, and the market will be vast. So for vehicles up to the size of an SUV, better battery technologies will come from a relatively small group of disruptive battery producers, but all of them are going to need nickel.
And all of them are going to have to make their anode out of either silicon or solid carbon or graphite or lithium metal. So the technology is converging on those winners. That can increase energy density and yet prevent their batteries from bursting into flames, either with software management systems that warn you before a battery is going to fail and hence become unsafe, or internally engineered systems to make sure that the batteries don't get to thermal runaway.
Thermal runaway is the term of art about when a battery gets so hot, you gotta worry about it bursting into flames. Or exploding. That's when it's pretending to act like gasoline. And I can assure you that as we get to energy-dense batteries, that's our single biggest concern is safety, because anything with that energy density is inherently potentially dangerous.
So if you want to, you know, have room for your kids in the back seat and a set of golf clubs, you're going to be buying a car with, with great energy density in the batteries. And those batteries are going to be brought to you by a handful of disruptive technology companies.
Now, you can either have a basket or a portfolio approach of those companies. QuantumScape was an early mover with a lot of market reaction, as you well know. It was put into a SPAC and had a spectacular run-up. But there will be others coming to market soon, probably 3 or 4 or 5 of the better ones. The ones that have a relationship with an automaker, Where you can see that they're going to be supplying batteries to a major automaker will probably trade at the highest valuations.
Erik Townsend: Robert, let's move on from the electrification of the economy and the grid to the actual generation of that electrical energy that we need. We talked in the Smarter Markets interviews about the thorium reactor cycle, and specifically, I've followed Kirk Sorensen's videos for years and years now on the liquid Liquid fluoride thorium reactor, which just blows my mind. This thing was prototyped and demonstrated and proven like 50 years ago. So we know it works. At the time, it was rejected because specifically it does not create weapons-grade plutonium as a side effect of its process of generating electricity. And that's what they needed at the time for the Cold War. Now that we don't have a Cold War, it seems so obvious to me that somebody ought to commercialize that, what really is a 50-year-old proven technology of the thorium reactor. Frankly, I would commit my life to that if I had the assets to do it, but I don't.
Robert, you do. Why doesn't a guy like you organize a venture to create this thorium reactor, build it in a factory so you've got modular ones you could ship anywhere, And say to the world, look, there's a new source of energy which doesn't have nuclear proliferation risk. It doesn't result in, you know, risking any nuclear wars because it doesn't create the metals that are needed to make the nuclear bombs. It cannot possibly melt down. It's a completely different approach to nuclear, and it's a much better approach.
Nobody's— well, I guess you said the country of India is doing a lot of research. on this. What about commercialization of it and selling it to the rest of the world? It seems to me like it's such an obvious play.
Robert Friedland: I think you'd want to do an interview with Laurent Frescaline, my partner. He's a plasma physicist, and he's spent a lifetime in strategic weapons engineering and deep, deep knowledge of nuclear fuel and thorium cycles. And you're absolutely correct that it is an accident of history that we went on the uranium cycle because of its advantage that it produced plutonium and other materials that were required for atomic weaponry.
And the whole regulatory system, the whole governmental system in most countries is geared to using uranium and the recovery of uranium in the nuclear energy industry. And any good plasma physicist will tell you that absolutely you're correct. The thorium cycle could be developed. As I'd mentioned to you earlier, the Indian government is a world leader in the thorium cycle, and it would be a wonderful thing for humanity. But I think there's still, you know, when you ask me as an individual investor, what's stopping anybody from doing this are enormous regulatory burdens.
And just the inertia of the current industry. You're underestimating the difficulty of getting the American government, which changes frequently, you know, to actually allow the creation of such an industry and the demise of the current nuclear establishment. That's a really tough row to hoe for one entrepreneur to think about.
Clearly, it has to be done at a governmental level. If the Chinese want to develop a thorium cycle or the Indians want to develop a thorium cycle or the Americans or the Japanese, if they put their mind to it, absolutely we could do it. And that's why politics, you know, would be better to move from such stupid issues as whether to wear a mask or not and focus on the truly important issues of why don't we just find better ways to generate endless electrical energy for humanity without the deleterious effects of the uranium cycle. It's certainly doable. And basically, I violently agree with you, which means I'll beat up anybody that disagrees with us.
But there are simpler and better ways to get there from here.
Erik Townsend: I know where you're headed because I've been thinking about this since our Smarter Markets interview. And one of the points that you made is there's a gigantic nuclear reactor. It's called the center of the And it's generating intense amounts of heat to the point that there are major granite formations that are heated to several hundred degrees Celsius that are just— I don't know how many thousand feet it is below the surface, but not that much farther than current technology has the ability to mine. And you made the point in those interviews we did on Smarter Markets that all you need in order to deliver the world a safe, completely clean source of unlimited electric energy is figure out how to drill deeper holes, drill them horizontally the same way that we drill oil wells horizontally today, but at a larger diameter, and drill them through very hot rock, several hundred degrees granite.
If we could drill radiators, as you put it, into granite submerged— you'll have to tell me how many thousand feet below the surface.
Robert Friedland: 10,000 feet.
Erik Townsend: You could create geothermal electric plants that could supply the entire world with unlimited, completely clean, green energy. And all you have to do is what? It's build a better drill bit?
Robert Friedland: What—
Erik Townsend: tell us again precisely what's the technology that's needed in order to enable that outcome? And why couldn't we just take existing lateral drilling oil rig technology? It seems like To me, it's not that far off. What's the shortcoming? The drill bit can't drill the big enough hole, or it can't drill the hole through the hot enough rock? What's the problem?
Robert Friedland: We have a private American unicorn called iPulse, which has commercialized non-military applications of ultra-high-energy pulse electrical power technologies that heretofore were used only for strategic weaponry, electromagnetic pulse weaponry, And other military applications.
So setting aside our private company, and to answer your question, we're all very fond of Mother Earth, but we're not taught in grade school that Mother Earth is in fact a nuclear reactor, just like the sun.
When you're talking about solar energy, that is nuclear. That, you know, that's ultimately nuclear fuel drives the sun, which creates the energy that comes to us as solar Radiation. It's obvious to you when you get in the sun, you can feel that heat from that nuclear reactor. The ancient Egyptians called it Ra, the sun god.
But what you might not know, that at the center of the Earth, there's sufficient remnant uranium and very, very high natural rock pressures due to the gravity pushing on the center of the Earth, that the center of the Earth is a natural nuclear reactor. Mother Earth is a nuclear reactor.
At the center of the Earth, we think the temperature at the core is approximately 11,000 degrees Fahrenheit, just about the same temperature as the surface of the sun. And there's enough remnant uranium to, to cause that fission reaction in the core of the Earth to last several billion years.
So in terms of the timescale of human evolution, several billion years is a long time from now before the core of our Earth goes cold because it runs out of fuel. So modern understanding of plate tectonics indicates that there's really almost nowhere in the world, if you drill a hole more than 20 kilometers deep, you don't get below the solid of what you'd call rock or solid floating continents, and you go into the mantle, which is molten.
And you see that bubbling up, you know, in Haleakala in Hawaii, for example, or any volcano. The source of all that heat at the center of the Earth, that is our Mother Earth. She is a nuclear reactor. So we can look to the sun god Ra for solar energy, or we can just look beneath our feet to our mother nuclear reactor and tap limitless amounts of geothermal energy. It's the cleanest solution because the sun doesn't shine all the time and the wind doesn't blow all the time. And the tides, while regular, are somewhat difficult to harvest.
But the geothermal energy below our feet is always there.
Now, the areas along the edge of the The continents, you take from Alaska down to Chile on the west coast, the Rim of Fire, or the big fractures like they run through Indonesia or Japan, you find that when you look at a heat map of the Earth, there are very, very large areas on this planet where the continental crust is very thin.
And there are very large rock masses called granites, which are solidified molten rock that are not very deep and very, very, very hot. In the United States, we have hot dry granites that are 30, 40, 50 miles across. And some of them are not very deep at all. They're 1,000, 2,000, 3,000, 4,000, 5,000 feet deep, quite shallow compared to an oil well.
And if they're hot enough to make steam to run a generator, You can generate a limitless amount of free electrical energy with no global warming effects.
And more importantly, with the capability to generate baseline electrical loads. Because unfortunately, because the wind is intermittent and the sun is intermittent, you need baseline power, you know, sort of for base demand. And that could be nuclear, it could be natural gas. as a transition fuel, but something has to provide that electrical energy when the wind is not blowing or the sun is not shining, and geothermal is ideal.
Erik Townsend: Hang on a second, Robert. I just want to understand more specifically with respect to the technology that we already have in the oil industry, which is the ability to drill down and then turn the drill bit and drill sideways and do these long lateral Well, in the case of oil, it's oil wells.
What is the problem with just repurposing those same oil drilling rigs and saying, let's go to where some of this hot granite is, drill down, drill sideways, drill that radiator you've talked about, and create the limitless source of geothermal energy? Is the problem that the oil drilling rig can't drill into that type of rock? Is it because of the heat of it? What's the challenge? Why can't we just use the stuff we got?
Robert Friedland: No, there's absolutely no possibility to use the current generation of oil drilling rigs. So forget about it. Forget about it. That won't work.
Erik Townsend: Why not? What's missing?
Robert Friedland: So the way we've drilled for the last 200 years is we put an enormous amount of mechanical pressure on a rotating drill bit. Usually you use industrial diamonds at the head of that bit. And it takes an enormous amount of energy to turn that drill steel. And in order to really bend around corners, you need a completely different way to drill. You need a much cheaper way to drill.
You need a sort of a robot that can get into hot rock and do the drilling for you, a Pac Man machine that has to be completely re-engineered and redesigned. So the electronics in that device would have to tolerate temperatures of about 250 degrees centigrade, or 2.5 times the temperature of of boiling water.
And we'd have to use a completely different physical principle to drill large diameter holes in hot rock.
We're quite confident that this is achievable with the current state of human technological development within a period of, say, 5 or a maximum of 10 years. We know how to do it. We're heading in that direction. And we're also seeking and likely to receive support from one or more governments to achieve that end.
Hopefully, the new Department of Energy in the United States, for example, will take an interest in this obvious solution, but we have another government that is taking a great deal of interest. So what this entails is using electromagnetic pulses to spall rock, to turn rock into a gas.
And to drive a series of devices that to our mind could drive these tunnels through hot rock. And once you've done that, you just inject water into those tunnels, make steam, and then recycle that steam when it condenses after it generates electrical energy into an endless loop and generate free electrical energy with no, you know, with basically no moving parts required other than the steam generator.
So it's the same as a nuclear power plant. A nuclear power plant generates steam with the uranium reaction making heat. In this case, we just use the heat from Mother Earth. There's no global warming effects, and we can do it. It's a lot easier than putting a man on the moon or Mars, believe me.
Erik Townsend: Now, that's one of the things that your company iPulse is taking on. Robert, why are you doing this? You said it's a unicorn company, so upwards of $1 billion of market capitalization. Obviously, with your personal background and, you know, accomplishments in your career, it's not like you you can't launch an IPO.
Why wouldn't you take this company public that's going to invent this Pac Man machine that can drill these large diameter holes that could potentially create unlimited amounts of energy?
Robert Friedland: We have a lot of other more immediate commercial uses for derivatives of that technology. We're using that technology for a new generation of geophysical instruments to see water in the crust of the Earth or to see copper or gold or electrically conductive metals. That's in the mining division, HPX, which stands for High Powered Exploration. We're using those technologies in a new suite of machinery to find new ways to make things out of metals. So we're involved in manufacturing with major aircraft manufacturers, major automobile manufacturers, and in luxury goods manufacturers.
And we're also working to disrupt the existing hydrocarbon industry to get a lot more oil and gas out of an existing oil well. So the projects that we look at for generating and finding more water from the crust of the Earth or generating energy from the crust of the Earth are sort of our main dreams. So a lot of the tech billionaires, they like the idea of going to Mars. I like that idea too.
But I think it's even cooler to figure out a way to get infinite carbon-free electrical energy for humanity right here on this particular planet. And so that's something we're focusing on as a very important and achievable industrial dream at iPulse Now, we really kept it quite private for a long time, but we do have a website now, www.ipulse-group.com.
And I'm quite findable at robert@ivanhoe.net. We're working with one of the world's major investment banks, and we are contemplating whether to stay private and raise more capital or be more public about our efforts. But the good news for you, Erik, is we've never spoken about this to anybody, to any broadcaster or news media.
Erik Townsend: Well, Robert, I'm sure that a lot of our listeners are thinking the same thing I am, which What you say makes perfect sense. And frankly, regardless of whether your company, iPulse, figures out this Pac-Man machine or someone else beats you to it because they've got an even better idea, all it's going to take is for somebody to invent that Pac-Man machine, the thing that goes down a few thousand feet below the surface, drills large diameter tunnels through very hot granite. So it's got to be a temperature, high temperature tolerant machinery, which adds some engineering challenge. Whoever builds that first can create an unlimited source of geothermal energy to provide as much electricity as we need to run the global economy forever.
That's a really, really big deal.
Robert Friedland: Well, we violently agree. That means we'll beat up anybody that disagrees with us. You know, the best ideas, the most brilliant ideas are the simplest. So these are the irrevocable facts. Mother Earth is a nuclear reactor. All the energy you need is right beneath your feet.
You've experienced it if you went to Japan and sat in a natural hot spring, in a hot tub, you know, a natural hot tub. There's hot springs all over the world. You can see it in Yellowstone, Montana, for example. In Yellowstone, Montana, that hot rock is right below your feet. You're basically standing on it when you go see Old Faithful, for example.
But even in the heart of New York City, if you drill a deep enough hole, there's an infinite amount of heat. So the energy we need, it's right underneath our feet, provided by Mother Earth, our friendly mother female nuclear reactor. And we know that this is doable. And quite frankly, we're fully intent on doing it.
Erik Townsend: Well, as much as I would love to give you a chance to quote unquote talk your book and sell your company, iPulse, you don't wanna do that 'cause it's private. So what can you tell our investor audience about other ways to play this revolution in geothermal energy? Because somebody, whether it's you at iPulse or someone else, is going to figure this out. And it seems to me like such an obvious solution that geothermal power generation could provide us with all the electricity that we need. If that and the real build-out of a completely modernized electric grid, give me something that you're not doing in a private company people can't invest in to help our investors out.
Robert Friedland: We're living in an era of an explosion of human creativity. There are 2 or 3 Hyperloop companies and they say, why is a train sitting on the surface when you can bore a tunnel in rock? Perhaps, maybe what you want to do is remove some of the air in that tunnel so you have a partial or full vacuum and let the train go screaming over a rail, perhaps magnetically levitated at 500 or 600 miles an hour. It wouldn't bother you underground and it would use very little energy. And so the Hyperloop concept is just an idea.
Definitely, we can do it. You need a cheaper way to drive tunnels, underground, and that's the same problem.
The Nobel Prize came from dynamite, and the invention of dynamite made it much easier to drive a subway tunnel, or say the Callahan Tunnel getting from Logan Airport to downtown Boston, or the new tunnel we're going to put from New Jersey to New York City. Tunneling is a big deal because you're going into Mother Earth, and if you can figure out a cheaper way to tunnel and you tunnel through hot rock, Then we're finished with the energy problem. We don't need hydrocarbon anymore.
We don't need natural gas anymore. We don't need nuclear power anymore. We don't need solar energy anymore, and we don't need wind power anymore. And so the solution is blatantly obvious, and focused human technology and intent will achieve it in our lifetime. I'm certain of that.
Erik Townsend: Robert, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Looking for exposure to rising silver and gold prices? AbraSilver Resource Corporation, ticker ABRA on TSX Venture Exchange and ABBRF in the United States, is rapidly emerging as one of the premier silver and gold-focused exploration companies. AbraSilver has an advantage advanced-stage project with a large resource base of over 140 million ounces on a silver equivalent basis and has recently announced several very high-grade silver and gold drill results, with more results pending. AbraSilver is very well funded with a strong shareholder base and excellent exploration upside potential. Visit abrasilver.com for more information. That's Visit www.abrasilver.com for more information on this silver and gold exploration stock.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Robert on the show. Just so many great insights as to the way things are going to be evolving in the Earlier, you were mentioning that you wanted to elaborate a little bit on this. What's on your mind?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, to put this in context, I really think that Robert shared a profound insight with us, which is, look, geothermal power has been around for decades, and based on the available technology, it is one of the viable sources of renewable energy, but it's not a game changer. It doesn't solve the whole problem for the whole planet. It's only a small part of the solution based on the technology that we now have. And what Robert pointed out in the Smarter Markets interview, and what we started to talk about in today's interview, is all you really have to do is figure out how to go only a little bit farther than the technology that already exists in the oil industry.
We already know how to drill horizontal oil wells miles through rock. The thing The thing is, it's oil shale. It's not super dense granite. And more importantly, it's rock which is at a temperature that the drill bit can operate in. It's not super hot granite. But if you could just invent that Pac Man machine, and you know what the machine looks like, you've seen it in all kinds of sci-fi movies, you know, it's pointy at the end and drills through rock and makes a tunnel and leaves rubble behind it. If you can just invent that Pac-Man machine that drills long horizontal tunnels through very hot granite, say 250 to 300 degrees Celsius, you can literally solve the clean energy problem for the entire planet and supply enough clean green electricity to recharge all of the electric vehicles that the world could ever build. It really is a It's a profound game changer for society, for the future of the planet. It completely solves the decarbonization climate change problem.
It is just huge. Now, what we don't have in this conversation is a solution. Robert's company, I-Pulse, is working on a very innovative way of trying to address this problem. Is Robert gonna crack this nut or is somebody else? I don't know, but whoever does is going to change the future of world history.
And it completely changes my perspective. I've been assuming for a long time that we had to eventually have a nuclear renaissance, that we would have to accept that nuclear is the best option, get over our emotional hangups and the very difficult baggage of the various accidents like Fukushima that the world has been through, and recognize that we need nuclear energy. This is the first time I've really seen that there is a viable solution that provides enough energy to supply the entire planet with all the clean green energy it needs without even needing to go nuclear. And the question is, can somebody invent that machine that has to drill holes in very hot, very deep rock? You know, Patrick, considering that we sent a man to the moon 50 years ago, it's just not an unthinkable technological challenge that we could figure out how to get better at drilling holes in rock, something that oil industry has been very good at doing for decades.
So I really think this is something that I want to encourage MacroVoices listeners to really take to heart. Imagine that you've got the answer, which is the way we're going to solve this climate change problem is a new generation of geothermal energy that doesn't exist yet. One where you can just have a deep well in the ground, you pump water down in it, it goes through essentially a radiator that's drilled Pulled through very deep, very hot formations of granite. And what comes back up through the other end is not hot water, but highly pressurized steam that's ready to run a gas turbine and actually produce electricity that can fuel the entire global economy.
It's all possible if you could go deeper, larger diameter holes in hotter rock than we know how to drill holes in today. I've got to believe these are challenges that modern science can take on. It's a question of who's going to be first to solve the problem and what it's going to look like. And I think this is just a really, really fascinating investment trend that we should all pay close attention to in coming years.
Erik Townsend: Anyway, that's enough of my soapbox. Let's move on, Patrick, to this week's postgame chart tech. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says flirting with the 50-day moving average. And on page 2, we have, you guessed it, a chart of the S&P 500 stock index futures. Patrick, what's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I want to just stop and go back to the 50-day moving average in a bigger picture, which is it's the average price of 50 days. And so when a market trends, it breaks away from that 50-day moving average, and you can usually identify trends and really beautiful trends. Inevitably, the market always moves in and flow, and every rally that occurs in a market mean reverts, and there's some sort of backfilling. And it is quite common for a very typical pause in the market or a correction to just mean revert back to its average price of its, uh, of the, let's say, last 50 days. And that's why a lot of technicians and trend followers tend to anchor on that 50, 100, and 200-day moving averages, or 13-week moving average, or whichever one that is to your fancy. And, and really what I wanted to, to identify when we're looking at these charts is, is that we had markets that were trending quite strongly over the last kind of 5, 6 months.
And almost all of these charts are showing that mean reversion, that correction, and they're all flirting with now having dropped to their 50-day moving averages. And this is such an interesting crossroad in the market because if this was just the market pause, and if it was just a little correction, then the question is, is this a buy on dip on all of these things, or is there something more ominous afoot where these corrections can turn into something a little more bearish? And I just wanted to kind of go through these charts and see where we're at with all of these at these different points. And so the S&P 500 on page 2, we have flirted with that 50-day moving average average both in January and March, earlier in March, and we're back there again. And each time that we've corrected down to this 50-day moving average, the market has more or less— the buy-on-dip traders came back each time.
And we find ourselves now again testing this zone. It's going to be really interesting to see whether the bulls can hold the line here right around this 3,850 level on the S&P.
Erik Townsend: Okay, so 3,850, about where we are, just a little below where we are right now as we're recording on Thursday afternoon, is the number to watch on the S&P 500. Let's move on to the other indices. We've got the Russell on page 3. Looks like we're already below it. Is that significant?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's significant actually with the magnitude of selling in the last week. And what we've seen, uh, and something we've, uh, talked about here on this show numerous times, was during the whole reflation trade and everything that was working, we had everything from the financials to cyclicals to value and small caps all doing incredibly well. And the Russell actually, during the entire period since November, has been leadership and it's been outperforming. And what we witnessed happen in the last week on the Russell was a selling of such magnitude that it wiped out the entire March rally. While the S&P 500 is barely mean reverting that rise, the Russell has given it all back. And that immediately acts as a warning to me because it's like, has something shifted in that, uh, that let's say Russell over NASDAQ chart that we've shared in the past as well?
Now often when you see this type of selling, if we see a failed rally come on the other side of, of a bounce here, that may often indicate that the Russell is going to either underperform or even go through a deeper correction.
Erik Townsend: And I think that we can't ignore what's happening in these small NASDAQ 100 futures is the next chart, and it too is already below the line, below the 50-day moving average. What do you make of that?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, it's not just that it's below its 50-day moving average, but unlike the S&P and the Russell that were in the month of March able to make higher highs, the NASDAQ has not. In fact, the NASDAQ has like barely beat a 50% retracement of the sell-off that started in February. And almost every attempt to rally has been met with selling. And it just feels very much like almost a gold chart, which is like just rolling over. And this is going to be key because the NASDAQ has been the leadership higher.
And if we see things like financials and small caps and all these other sectors that have been doing so well, if they begin correcting And something like the NASDAQ doesn't step up and, and take the baton to be some sort of leadership in this rotation, then you have to ask that question, what part of the market can be the leadership in order to drive another bull run? And the fact that we're seeing cracks in the armor for the Russell and the NASDAQ misbehaving, it really does ask that really important question. What is going to drive the next advance in the market if these supports do hold, right?
With that said, Erik, I want to look on page 5 here on the chart of the financial ETF, the XLF. And what was really interesting is that the financials, whether you're talking regional banks, even global banks, all of them, the money center banks, they have truly been one of the hottest sectors throughout this last kind of 4, 5, 6 months. And they have been continuously advancing even when other parts of the market were correcting. It's really interesting, in the last week we finally have seen that correction kick in on these financials, and the financials are slowly approaching that 50-day moving average where back in January acted as a great buy-on-dip opportunity. And this is, uh, also again something that I'm watching, because if we see that, uh, the financials can turn around and be that leadership, well, that would be a bonus or a Plus for the bulls.
But as we approach here, whether or not the financials act as a buy on dip here, I think is one of the little puzzle pieces that is totally worth watching.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, as I look on to page 6, I'm having a hard time reconciling what this VIX chart is showing me with what you said earlier, because, you know, boy, when you talk about the S&P flirting with its 50-day, the Russell's already below it, the NASDAQ, which led the way up, appears to be leading the way down. It's already ventured substantially below its 50-day, and it's, it's now still below it, but, but trying to hug it a little bit more. Boy, it seems like things are heating up. Volatility is increasing. The situation's getting a little bit scarier here. But then I look at page 6, and it shows that we've just passed a new— looks like 1-year low in stock index volatility.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, this is actually one of the more interesting things I wanted to observe, right? So the 50-day moving average, I'm not a— I don't want to use it as a predictive power on something like the VIX, which is far more range-bound. But it— the moving average shows you just sort of what the average price has been. And what I find fascinating is the last 2 times we had little quick market corrections, the VIX went ripping higher up into the 30-plus, 38 range. And here we haven't even seen the VIX react in any meaningful way off of the lows. In other words, like that fear premium that tends to be put into options for people that are hedging. Doesn't seem that this time around we're getting that kind of blast higher. And I'm wondering whether that is something that's warning of too much complacency into this little correction, or, or whether there just is that much active vol selling that, that is allowing this to be suppressed.
Erik Townsend: But watching whether the VIX starts to react on the upside here during this little pullback is 100% on the Let's move on to the dollar index, Patrick, because one of the things that a lot of people have said is that the biggest threat to the stock indices would be if a dollar rally started to go out of control, which some people have cited as a major risk factor. Hasn't gone out of control yet, but boy, this dollar rally is starting to look like it's got some legs to it.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, Erik, when we're looking at this dollar index, the interesting part to me is, is that because the US dollar still is the world reserve currency, It tends to be still an anchor for the reflation trade. And really, one of the things that we've been watching on the show for the last month is whether or not the dollar was gonna put in a bottom. You know, we were talking about it all the way through January and February. And really what we have seen for the first time in over 6, 7 months, a sustained period from which the US dollar has been able to maintain above that 50-day moving average. I mean, during the entire US dollar bear market in traditional form, it stayed decisively below that 50-day moving average. And so, so there is a shift of trend. And what we have now is 3 consecutive days of attempting to break out above 92 and consolidating well above that 50-day.
And so really, it's starting to look like that dollar index may very well go here. And what will be interesting to see is, is that will that be to send the ripples through the intermarkets and cause other markets to start getting a little bit nervous. One way or another, there's definitely some sort of a shift happening there.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to your Bitcoin chart. Now, I noticed finally, it seems like the news flow is starting to say, oh my gosh, there's a real serious risk of Bitcoin being outlawed by governments. Whoever could have seen that one coming? I don't know why that wasn't an obvious risk to everyone before, but it seems like it's suddenly on the radar. Is that what's driving the downside?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I don't even know if I want to overread the downside just yet. What I find really interesting with that 50-day moving average there is that almost every advance Bitcoin has had, the buy-on-dip traders were very quick to buy this 50-day moving average. Every time we mean reverted and retraced some sort of an advance, This is the zones where the buy-on-dip traders came in, and it worked in January. It worked again in late February, early March, and here we are again in late March, and we we are testing this 50-day moving average.
And I think it would be a huge tell if the buy-on-dip traders didn't show up this time. And before I make a big predictive call on this, I think it's worth at this moment just observing over the next. Next, uh, week whether or not we see, uh, some sort of new accumulation come off of here. I think that it would be a blow to the Bitcoin bulls if we saw selling south of $50,000 and failed rallies on the other side, and that would really mean that some sort of a distributive cycle has potentially kicked in. It's premature to jump to that conclusion, but boy, are we at an interesting crossroad right now where typically we would have seen those buyers come back in.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to my own favorite chart, crude oil on page 9. Boy, we certainly see that 50-day moving average has, if nothing else, generated plenty of volatility in the chart here, hasn't it?
Patrick Ceresna: Exactly. And again, this is just the way that we describe the 50-day in the first place, which is that during bull trends, the price decisively moves away from that average price and goes in full trend higher, and then often mean reverts back back there. And what's interesting here is, is that the 50-day moving average now is where the crude oil is toying with. There are some Fib retracements that lie a little bit lower in the mid-50s that could also be where crude oil could correct into. But we have seen in the past the 50-day moving average at least offer a reaction. And so was yesterday's reaction all we're gonna get, or is there still going to be a quick bounce here into the low 60s.
It's going to be really interesting to see. But this really is very consistent with where we are on so many other commodities as well, because like when we go to page 10 and look at the copper chart, similarly copper had that huge run in February, and again we're just mean reverting and correcting right to that 50-day. And in a commodity bull market, these types of corrections happen, and these are the levels that typically would be bought on dip. And this is why Flirting with the 50-Day is the title of this whole presentation, is because we're literally there at so many of these markets.
And it's going to be revealed to us over the next few weeks as to whether this was just a great buy-on-dip opportunity in these markets, or whether, um, these corrections are going to be much deeper, more prolonged. Because typically, if the 50-day doesn't hold, then one of those, uh, kind of multi-month, much deeper corrections ensues. I, I, I think it's premature to conclude a bear market or something more ominous like that, but for many of these markets, this is a moment where we're going to find out whether the trend that's been established for the last 6 months has, uh, or is going to be interrupted.
Erik Townsend: Before we close, let's go back to page 9 and look at crude oil again. I'd like to talk a little bit more, since you're the technician in the house, about Let's talk about levels that are possible. Let's assume for sake of argument that we do get a breakdown below this 50-day moving average.
Okay, we had one of those back in October, and it actually set the stage for just an epic rally. So, you know, maybe that's not a bad thing in terms of, you know, shaking the weak hands out of the system and preparing the market to maybe stage another big move higher. Let's talk about where the downside targets would be if we do see sustained closes below the 50-day. Where do you think the next levels are? What should we be paying attention to?
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, if the 50-day moving average doesn't hold, then looking for a 50% retracement of the entire oil rally off of that, that $36 low that subsequently rose up to that $67 high, a 50% retracement would be roughly around $52, where that January consolidation occurred. And so I think that that would be a very realistic first target for a quick correction down where one would be able to potentially look for the next buy-on-dip opportunity. But first, I think before already assuming that that's a given, I want to see whether this 50-day holds here. But if it doesn't, then that would be definitely where I would be looking for the next little correction to go.
Erik Townsend: Well, I think we're in strong agreement then, because what I'm looking for here is almost the same number you are, Patrick. You, you've got the 50-day at 58.24, and that's one number. I think another interesting number is the 13-week moving average, because that would be the signal if we close below it on a weekly basis that tells you not only the daily trend has changed, but also the weekly trend has changed. So if we see a close below $57.41, the 13-week moving average, and by that I mean a weekly close, not just a daily close, that says to me probably we're headed, I think, to exactly where you said, somewhere around that January, the top of the January consolidation range, around $52, $53.
If there was some particularly bearish news, I could see maybe a very brief test of $50 or just below $50, but I don't think we're going to spend much time below $52 or $53. And I think $53 is probably about where the buying zone starts if this level doesn't hold.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. And well, the really interesting part about this moment as well is, is that no matter where it goes, whether it stops here or whether it goes down toward that $52 range, I do believe that these are going to be great buying opportunities. And that's one of the things that we're looking at doing with You know, we locked in the advance in a lot of the energy stocks and other things at Big Picture Trading with collars. And so we have a lot of our profits already locked in. And so really the question is, when is the next great buy-on-dip opportunity for us to be able to reposition for another leg higher? And so it's certainly something on my mind.
Erik Townsend: And needless to say, the best way for our listeners to tune into what's on your mind, not just every week on Thursday, but every single day, is by signing up for A free 14-day trial of Big Picture Trading. Information is on page 11. We're going to leave it there for this week's podcast. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole.
And by AbraSilver Resource Corporation, a premier emerging silver and gold exploration company, ticker ABRA on TSX Venture. and ABBRF in the United States. Patrick, what's in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find a transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article from Charlie McElligott about stocks are fragile as quarter-end rebalancing overwhelms the weaponized gamma. You'll also find a link to a Jesse Felder article, Gold Goes Out of Style. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend— that's Erik spelled with a K— and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account today.
Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit more guests to join us on the show. High-profile feature interview guests for future programs, so please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time.
MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. The following program is brought to you by or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, Visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Guests:
Josh Crumb- Founder & CEO, Abaxx Technologies Inc.
Joe Raia- Chief Commercial Officer, Abaxx Exchange
Annoucer: [00:00:00] This is a special edition of MacroVoices with hedge fund manager, Erik Townsend. The premier financial podcast, targeting professional finance, high net-worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. Now for this special edition of MacroVoices, here's Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: [00:00:29] MacroVoices Spotlight episode six was recorded on March 11th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend.
When we had Kyle Bass on MacroVoices and talked about Singapore really becoming the heir apparent to Hong Kong as Hong Kong loses some of its independence from China. Kyle brought up Abaxx Technologies, a company that both Kyle and I have invested in. And when I asked him about it, he said, look, you really have to get Josh Crumb, the CEO of Abaxx on your show to talk about all the different dimensions of this because, as Kyle put it, he said, look, frankly, I invested because they're doing something cool in Singapore with natural gas and because Josh Crumb is involved and frankly, Josh Crumb's the only guy who really understands all the dimensions of this in his head. So we're following up on that advice.
Juliette Declercq — JDI Research founder (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 263 was recorded on March 18th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by SS&C Eze, delivering cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to optimize operational and investment alpha across the entire investment process. JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from secular inflation to how far the long end of the Treasury curve can go, to why Juliette thinks the stock market stands on firmer ground than some skeptics are suggesting. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck will be titled Is volatility set to return?
Next week, my feature interview guest will be billionaire Canadian financier Robert Friedland. That interview is based on my 2-part interview with Robert on the subject of what it's really going to take to green the economy. The 2-part series is already live right now at SmarterMarketsPod.com. So in the MacroVoices interview next week, Robert and I will discuss how to invest in the green revolution. The point is, next week's MacroVoices feature interview will assume you already listened to the prerequisite 2-part series. So please do that between now and next Thursday so you're ready for next week's feature interview. Again, you'll find the 2-part series linked in your Research Roundup email or at SmarterMarketsPod.com.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump into this S&P 500. I mean, we've been gravitating higher all week, but we're in the post-FOMC statement period. We see the markets here getting a little A little bit wobbly off the highs coming. We're down about 30 points at the time of recording. We're at 3,930 here. What's your take on the S&P 500 here?
Erik Townsend: Well, yeah, what you say is true. We are down today. But, you know, in the grand scheme of things, the way I see the big picture here is the market couldn't even go a whole month without making a new all-time high. And furthermore, when it almost did, people started to panic. Oh my gosh, what's going on? So, you know, clearly the signs of a top or an imminent top are all there, but I think this market is incredibly difficult to call because yes, all of those late-stage bull argument euphoria stage, you know, we're close to the end, those arguments all make sense, but so does the argument that this is just the beginning of a crack-up boom and that we've got much, much higher to go. Frankly, I'm quite happy not to have any directional trade. In either direction. Juliette Declercq is going to tell you in today's feature interview that she thinks the market is on firmer ground than some skeptics think.
I guess that tends to support the crack-up boom argument. One way or another, Patrick, if I was going to be in this equity market at all, I think something like the rolling straddle strategy, which you talk about a lot at Big Picture Trading, would make a lot more sense than a directional bet here, 'cause I could see it going either way.
Patrick Ceresna: For sure, Erik, because in the post-OPEC period, when volatility tends to start up, so there should be some big movements starting Next week, we'll see which direction that is in. Let's move on to that US Dollar Index though, which generally it's been pinned near 92, a little higher, a little bit lower, but just winding up. Do you think there's an imminent big move coming here in the dollar or is it just gonna be more of the same?
Erik Townsend: No, I don't think so. You know, everybody's talking about today's move as if it's, you know, hugely big upside. Look, we still didn't make it to 92 today. It's 91.76 as we're speaking at about 2:30 in the afternoon. Maybe we'll get there by the end of the day, but frankly, Frankly, I doubt it. So we don't have any big news of a breakout. We're still in a consolidation. And it's certainly, you know, it's close. It's definitely something to watch, but we don't have any signal yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to crude oil because today, big down day. We're down over 7% right now at the time of recording. I'd love to hear your take on what's happening here in the crude market.
Erik Townsend: Well, of course, everybody is trying to ascribe a reason to today's action. I think the biggest reason, frankly, Because look, ever since the 1st of November, this market has gone nothing but straight up. And we got to the point of testing the highs that the market was unable to break through in January of 2020 before there was any word of any coronavirus crisis coming in early January of 2020. So, you know, we hit a pretty major resistance level. And at the same time, you've got a bearish EIA report, you've got a lot of changing perspective on inventory and so forth. We finally had a build that really was a build this week. So there's a number of factors, but I think the main one is just that it's been up so much, so hard. In any case though, Patrick, this is, you know, a game changer today. Today's tape action broke through a trend line that was unbroken since November 2nd, at least on the continuous chart.
On the contract chart, it's a little bit more iffy as to whether we really broke through that or not. We also closed below the 21-day moving average for the first time since early February. And in fact, we closed below the 34-day moving average for the first time, I don't know, since a long time ago. So this is what it looks like when you see the beginning of a big crash. And certainly at the close here, we're looking at a $5, uh, 5-day gap. That's the difference between the 5-day moving average, which is right at $64 right now, and, uh, $59.60 or so, which is where we're, uh, we're trading just a few minutes after the pit close, this really looks like the market has changed direction and we've got a trend change. There's almost always a bounce when you get this wide of a 5-day gap. The bounce itself doesn't mean anything, it's what happens after the bounce. So I expect we'll get a bounce and probably get back up at least to the 34, if not to the 21-day moving average.
But then what? You know, is it the beginning of a new downtrend? Certainly if we had another $10 down from here, we've already had Uh, $7 down at least since, uh, or more than that actually. We're actually approaching $9 down from the very high. Uh, you know, maybe it goes to $15 before this is over. It still wouldn't really change my very bullish long-term outlook. I think we're in a bull market here. We anticipated here on MacroVoices that when we got to that key resistance level or resistance zone between $65.65 and $66.60 on WTI, uh, we thought it was maybe going to top there. And sure enough, that's what happened. It got all the way to $68. Now we're going to go the other direction. The question is, is this just the beginning of a sideways consolidation or are we going back down into the $40s?
I think anything's possible, but it doesn't change my view that we're still in a secular bull market in commodities and particularly in crude oil.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, why don't you touch on the inventories?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, we actually had a bona fide build of 2.4 million barrels in crude oil inventory. And what I mean by bona fide is in the past few weeks we've had much larger builds, but they were offset by even bigger drawdowns in finished products. This week it's not just crude oil. It's crude oil building 2.4, gasoline building 472,000 barrels, distillates building 255,000 barrels. So it's builds across the board. The only drawdown was Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 624,000 barrels. So in this situation, we see there ought to be at least a little bit of downward tape action. I think this was more the straw that broke the camel's back than the real cause of the change in price direction. It was after inventory that the selling started, and it just continued, especially from about 7 o'clock on Thursday morning. And it'll be very interesting to see how far this goes.
We were way overdue for a pullback, so now it's a question of how deep of a pullback before this bull market continues.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, so it looks like gold put in some sort of a short-term low at the start of March, and since then, for about 2 weeks, we've been gravitating a little bit higher, but nothing impressive. I mean, we're trading around $1,730 at the time of this Do you think there's more downside here in the short term for gold, or do you think that's going to be a more meaningful bottom?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, maybe there's an argument that that $1,675 that we saw was the bottom and it's all uphill from here. But frankly, we need a daily close over $1,800 in order to get above the channel resistance line that we've been following for several months now. So that's still quite a ways above the market. We came off the bottom and we got about halfway to where we need to get to in order to say That's right. That's what's going to signal an actual trend reversal. And already it looks like this rally is kind of losing steam. Hasn't really rolled over with conviction yet, but let's give it a few more days. It looks to me like maybe it's about to. There's still hope here, but a long way to go before we have a signal that the trend is reversed. I tend to lean still towards lower numbers, and I think Juliette Declercq is going to have some explanation as to why she thinks lower numbers are also possible.
As a long-term gold investor, I already see this as a buying opportunity. I've been buying gold mining shares here just today, in fact. Juliette has a shorter, more institutional trade duration window, so let's see what she says in the feature interview
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's talk about that 10-year Treasury yield, 'cause it was really a good chance that the FOMC could have been a turning point for putting in a short-term high on yields, but no sign of that after just an hour of pulling back. Suddenly the 10-year Treasury yield today The 10-year today is making a fresh high. We're at 1.73 at the time of recording. When does this stop?
Erik Townsend: Well, remember just last week, David Tepper was the guru of choice saying he thought that the 10-year yield had backed up as far as it was gonna go. Oops, guess not. And, you know, it's not just the 10-year yield. Look at the opposite action at the other end of the curve. The 3-month T-bill is now yielding 1 basis point. That means with a 1 basis point bid-ask spread, if you're on the buying side of that, you're getting nothing. for your 3-month T-bill. That's a scary proposition when you're really at truly zero interest rates on the 3-year T-bill. So now it's a question of how much farther that zero number goes out on the duration curve and whether or not we get to negative numbers at some point. It's gonna be interesting to see. In any event, Patrick, I don't know where it ends. I'm asking all of our feature interview guests.
This one's beyond my pay grade.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is JDI Research founder, Juliette Declercq. Now, Erik, why did we invite Juliette back onto the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, the primary reason is because these Treasury yields are not beyond her pay grade. Juliette has a fantastic record when it comes to the accuracy of her Treasury calls. So I really want to see how she interprets this Treasury market. And besides, it's just been too long since we've had her on the show. And in any event, Patrick, I'm always happy to have Juliette back. I do want to mention, however, this interview was recorded on Tuesday before the FOMC. So you don't have all of today's action reflected in the conversation.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Juliette Declercq is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors the Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. Part 1 of my interview with billionaire financier Robert Friedland, exploring what it will take to green the global economy, is up now at smartermarketspod.com, and part 2 airs this coming Saturday morning.
Do you remember when Kyle Bass suggested that I interview Abaxx founder Josh Crumb to explain all the dimensions of Abaxx Technologies and its business plan? That interview airs tomorrow morning, Friday, March 19th, as a full-length MacroVoices Spotlight episode. But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to separately subscribe to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now, with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq, who is perhaps best known for her incredible graphs and charts. So you're not going to want to miss the download for this week's interview.
Erik Townsend: Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not registered yet. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, just above Juliette's picture and immediately below the green Donate button.
Bonsoir, Juliette. It's great to have you back. I want to start with the question we're asking everyone, which is secular inflation. Is it really about to happen? Some people say this is the late 1960s. We're about to have a massive inflation driven by all of the government stimulus and everything that's expected. And frankly, at this point, I really hope you're a deflationist because we've been looking for one.
Juliette Declercq: Well, secular questions are difficult. I think I want to emphasize that That we're really at a very high uncertainty point. Nonetheless, that's a key question and I will constantly revert to it in my 2021 outlook and beyond. But really, I think a fair answer is that we do not know. So why we don't know? Well, we are talking about unpredictable, nonlinear human behavior exacerbated by the high level of macro uncertainty emerging from the 2021 global macro revolution.
A revolution towards a policy mix that is standing on 2 fiscal legs, 2 legs, fiscal and monetary. The first one, which is very highly political and therefore volatile, and the other one which basically embodies a new and much more dovish but largely undefined reaction function from the Fed. Also consider the added risk of pervasive social media groupthink, So let's think about it. You've paid people to sit on their butts for a year, sometimes more than they were paid when they were working.
Will they happily return to work for less pay, or will the Phillips Curve kick back in, forcing CEOs to bid up wages? Recently with my clients, although I'm navigating towards answering this key question, I'm trying to stay away from speculating on animal spirits and try to focus on what's priced and what we know for sure.
I think really another important element to consider, and that will take me to chart 0 of my chart pack, is that to answer this question, you have to also realize that the main risk to reflation is actually inflation. And you can see that for yourself on chart 0. The question there is, at what point do higher prices become self-limiting by curbing down demand? And that's a theme that basically has been stable over the past basically all decades on my chart. In my opinion, there is a non-trivial risk that the US breakevens curve, so the inflation curve, continues to flatten and invert in a move that would signal stagflation and eventually a return to disinflation.
And that's obviously if and when the fiscal thrust recedes. So just to answer your question, at this point, I don't expect runaway inflation. But I keep my mind widely open on the subject as the risk skew on inflation has certainly shifted dramatically over the crisis and certainly for the foreseeable future.
Erik Townsend: Well, that brings me to a closely related question, Juliette, which is the recent sharp backup in long-term bond yields has raised fear among a lot of investors that it could short-circuit the economic recovery, lead to an equity crash. There's every imaginable, you know, story out there about what this means. What's your take on it?
Juliette Declercq: So I think to answer this question in the clearest possible way, I would like your listeners to consider the second chart of my chart pack, which happens to be chart 1. Yes, markets are calling the Fed's bluff and refuse to believe that it will, or perhaps that it can fulfill its new FAIT mandate, which is flexible average inflation targeting.
Erik Townsend: Why?
Juliette Declercq: Because the new mandate is extremely vague so far. And I stress that this interview is taped before the 17th of March, which is just before the next FOMC. But I don't expect any resolution on this salient point. So the Fed has refused to quantify the length of time when inflation would be considered for the average, but also what sort of overshoot would they consider acceptable. So far, all we have is a vague promise of a moderate overshoot.
This tells us very little and therefore leaves markets to their own interpretation. So as a result, as you can see on chart 1, you can see that the Fed hikes have been priced as early as late 2022 now, which is a reaction function that is materially more hawkish than officially argued by the Fed.
So looking on the chart, you can see that 5-year inflation breakevens are now compatible with sustainably achieving the 2% target. On this, I want to add that the Fed targets core PCE rather than CPI on which breakevens are priced. So there is a circa 30 basis point wedge between PCE and CPI, which basically explains why breakevens at 2.5% only anticipate a tiny overshoot.
But what's more worrying at this point, as far as the Fed's mandate and credibility are concerned, is that the breakevens curve is dangerously flattening and is actually unprecedentedly inverted, which means that whilst the target could be reached in the medium term, markets do not currently anticipate that it would be sustainably met in the longer run.
So to answer the question of whether higher rates is a problem, we probably need to go through why it would be a problem for equities and eventually for financial conditions, which in turn would become a hurdle to the economic recovery. Well, a dominant equity sector, especially in the US, is priced on lower real yields. So it's the famous growth sector. And the fear is that it may crash, eventually dragging down global indices.
As a reminder, growth sectors historically tend to trade like long-duration assets. Why? Because they are made of new or pioneer industries full of promises of exponential earnings growth in the far future. These promises to deliver exponential earnings in the long run is easily revalued through lower long-term real yields. And collapse term premia. And this basically allows the sector to become positively correlated with bonds, which was the main countercyclical monetary policy lever over the past business cycle. So that's like for 10 years. Some of you traders who haven't been trading before the global financial crisis would only refer to this market dynamic.
As an aside, it was also the main source of disconnect between Wall Street and Main Street because bad economic news became a positive driver for the bond-like growth sector.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, having now established that the legitimate concern is a valuation concern for the growth sector, are higher yields threatening an overall bear market as a result?
Juliette Declercq: So again, for those who were not trading pre-global financial crisis, after which financial repression became the main source of monetary loosening, it's important to reiterate that periods of bear steepening, as happened year to date, actually tend to coincide historically with stellar earnings growth and equity performance. This should not be a surprise. The US yield curve tends to bear steepen when higher yields are warranted fundamentally, and the market dynamic is one that allows the front end of the curve to move higher without disrupting the positive repricing of the long-term cyclical outlook.
So that's something you can verify for yourself on chart 2 of my chart pack. Bear steepening periods have tended to coincide with periods of equity price acceleration. Conversely, the yield curve tends to bear flatten when higher yields result from an unwarranted hawkish tilt in the central bank's reaction function.
This is what happened in 2017-18 when Powell's Fed mistook a short-term bounce of confidence from a supply-side stimulus. So that was basically Trump's tax cuts with a demand-led sustainable cyclical bounce. So it led to 2 years of bear flattening, which basically culminated in the 2018 Q4 crash and the Fed's subsequent 2019 dovish U-turn.
Similarly, such bear flattening dynamic is what burst the tech bubble in 2000. Having cut rates by 75 basis points in 1998 to prevent the LTCM collapse from causing a recession, The Fed started to raise rates from mid-1999 in a bid to tighten financial conditions and counter the speculative tech mania.
Reflecting overly tight financial conditions, the US yield curve then started flattening, eventually inverting in February 2000 and triggering a 3-year equity bear trend, only interrupted for a few months at the end of 2001. Beginning of 2002 by a bout of bear steepening, which actually allowed an equity bear market rally of almost 25%.
So my message here really is not to look at absolute yield level. That's really not what matters for equity indices or even for the real economy in general. But what we need to look at is how this yield level relates to the outlook. So in other words, restrictive yields will tend to flatten the curve whilst accommodative yields tend to steepen the curve. So on chart 2, you can observe that US yield curve, the US yield curve has been bear steepening, which highlights the current market belief that higher yields have not turned restrictive and do not imperil the cyclical outlook.
In fact, given the faster vaccination rollout and constant overdelivering on fiscal stimuli in the US, In fact, I would argue that financial conditions have probably become more, not less accommodative this year. And the reason is that they're driven by macroeconomic improvement rather than an hawkish tilt in the Fed's reaction function. So I think the recent yield shock is very unlikely to trigger an equity bear market, quite the opposite in fact.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, your charts are so enticing, I can't help myself. So please forgive me if I seem to be questioning you, but I hear your point. But if I look at chart 2, you can see that the curve bear steepened back in late 2001, yet the equity bear market lasted well into 2002. So is that contradicting your analysis?
Juliette Declercq: So, Erik, that's a great question and a point that's been raised by my clients. The reason the 2001 bear steepening did not end the bear market is valuation and basically the existence of an equity bubble. However, including on MacroVoices last year when it was heavily against consensus, I have consistently argued against the equity bubble narrative. And I will really stick to my guns on this one and refer you to chart 3 of my chart pack.
So if you look at chart 3, which basically measures the developed world cyclical outlook against SPX forward equity risk premium. Again, many of your listeners will ask why using the equity risk premium. So let me go through that quickly again because it's important. When an investor buys a stock, he's buying the future cash flow potential of a company, and the valuation of this cash flow will depend on the real yield of the alternative safe investment, which is naturally US Treasuries. So the equity risk premium allows a thorough Comparison of valuations across business cycles. And that's really the key point here. On top of this, the earnings yield is also, in my opinion, a sound way to assess current valuation levels to expected earnings because the ratio accounts for both dividends and retained earnings. Some talking heads argue today that equities are in a bubble just on the basis that their dividend yields are lower than Treasury yields.
And I think that's nonsense. So of course, the huge caveat is that growth prospects of a company are a critical consideration when using earnings yield. Stocks with high growth potential will typically be valued at a much lower earnings yield. So in 1999, what happened amidst the internet revolution? It was certainly an argument to rationalize a negative equity risk premium for both SPX and the NASDAQ.
And I think in retrospect, markets got massively carried away and the lack of a spread cushion between the forward earnings yield and the 10-year real yields were a loud warning signal. Eventually, rising yields, real yields burst the bubble and triggered both a bear market and a recession. This allowed valuations to basically become more realistic and realign with fundamentals, as you can see on my chart. Which is using the DM composite PMI to picture the cyclical outlook in the developed world.
In other words, even accounting for a much greater growth environment in the late '90s, equity markets on aggregate were grossly overvalued, which is not the case today. In fact, I actually argued with my clients recently that the recent shallow correction actually offered value And remain quite bullish stocks on aggregate, which is basically a stance that I've retained since late March last year.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, that gives us a great foundation in the aggregate, but it seems to me like the big story that you hear in the financial media this year is sector rotation. Everybody's talking about cyclicals versus value and value versus growth and so forth. So as we go back to my second question, which was about the backing up in yield, what do you think this means in terms of sector rotation?
Juliette Declercq: So another great question. And of course, there are large valuation disparities, as your listeners will see for themselves on chart 4 of my chart pack, which pictures Euro Stoxx estimated earnings yield, which is a typically cyclical index. Together with SPX and the NASDAQ, which is a typical growth index.
So for SPX, the forward earnings yield today is just above 5%, above the 10-year real yield. And it was literally negative in 2000. And as you rightly point out, a fairly priced aggregate hides wide disparities between sectors.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Juliette Declercq: So the earnings yield cushion that you get in a cyclical heavyweight like Euro Stoxx is 90 basis points.
And you get a cushion which is 70 basis points tighter with the NASDAQ. So in this regard, one should really question whether the e-commerce and technology sectors, which are positively correlated to treasuries, should really still trade at such a massive deep premium. To cyclicals and value sectors. Let's think about e-commerce and digital services penetration.
It basically got bumped in 2020 as stay-at-home orders became prevalent. But if you were not using Amazon or got yourself a Netflix account over the crisis, how likely is it that you will jump into the services over the next 12 months? My really strong belief is that our focus should be on the absolute strengths of value and cyclical sectors rather than on the relative weakness in growth sectors.
And I think it's really worth considering that growth sectors have greatly matured over the crisis. So you can actually see on chart 5 that in the UK and the US, e-commerce penetration has seen 4 to 5 years of growth in 2020. And this really begs the question, will it stick?
And of course, I hear more and more stories of those thriving in their lives in a more appealing digital virtual world compared to the dull reality of today's lockdowns. I do see my 9-year-old son getting great satisfaction from the virtual world as the lockdown in London continues literally since December last year.
But personally, I am looking forward to escape virtuality Which probably makes me sound about 150 years old. But going back to markets, the infamous FANMAG sector earnings went from being more than 13% of S&P earnings at the end of 2019 to more than a quarter of S&P earnings at the end of 2020.
Those sectors' earnings growth, they won't fall out of bed in 2021. They're still expected to grow honorable and probably of a stretch medium rate of 20%, but that's actually down from 33% growth in 2020. Meanwhile, S&P operating EPS is likely to swing from -25% to +45% in 2021. Even more shockingly to younger generations, Whilst credit growth is unlikely to revert to its pre-global financial crisis days, steeper curves means that traditionally boring bank forward earnings, a sector widely believed to be doomed to secular stagnation, are now rising faster than forward earnings in the tech sector. You can see that for yourself on chart 6.
So So all in all, my considerations here really lead me to believe that the rationale for the large 250 basis point discount for the financial sector to the tech sector is really plummeting. So the change of leadership between growth and value and cyclical sector is not only a yield story. In fact, the differential in future earnings profile is a greatly overlooked driver of a sustainable rotation away from tech towards value and cyclicals outperformance. And you can see that for yourself on chart 7. So just a last chart to try and finish to convince you. So chart 8, I think you can really see, and that's really my opinion, that the powerful post-COVID reflationary backdrop Necessitates a continued rerating of financials versus the formerly hot FANMAG sector.
And there is a potential just for convergence between earnings yields. There's a potential for a further 40% price rotation. So it's really an underlying trend that has potential and has really just started. Look, my message here is that the global equity market is potentially standing on steadier Not shakier ground, which means that S&P 500's equity risk premium is actually likely to fall going forward, eventually offsetting the effect of higher real yields on equity prices. And this is something I show on chart 9, and which also justifies selling VIX spikes in a structural positioning.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, you never cease to amaze me with your graphs and charts. I count 5 amazing charts on that one question about sector rotation. Let me hit you with another question that I've been asking almost all of our feature interview guests, which is, it sounds like you think that there's reason to expect higher yields or that higher yields are warranted.
If that's the case, how far can they let them go? You know, a narrative that you'll hear is the US government cannot afford to allow the long end of the curve to go very far because they wouldn't be able to afford their debt service if it went beyond a certain level. Is that true? Is there a level that it can't go beyond? And what is that level? How far can yields go before they become restrictive?
Juliette Declercq: So I think this is the $3 trillion question, which was recently argued in a really interesting article from The Economist, which is titled, The World's Consumers Are Sitting on a Pile of Cash, But Will They Spend It? So I think this is what will ultimately drive the equilibrium real yield.
As in my answer to your first question on whether we risk secular inflation, I want to really emphasize the high uncertainty but fundamental change in the skew around future inflation outcomes. And as a result, I really try and focus on what we do know and extrapolate from there in terms of finding out what is the most likely path in terms of yields and real yields and inflation. Inflation.
We, and I should say at least JDI Research clients and your regular listeners, know that financial repression, and what I mean by financial repression is negative interest rates and depressed term premia. That's basically led us to a much worse equilibrium over the last decade. Firstly, by constraining lending, due to desperately tight bank margins. And if we are looking at Europe especially, capital flows there are still relying heavily on banks. So it's a major consideration. And you can see that for yourself on chart 10.
There is absolutely no question in my mind that banks are more likely to lend when it's profitable to do so, and that consumers are much more likely to borrow when they see a risk that rates may be moving higher rather than the opposite. Secondly, we've achieved an inferior macroeconomic equilibrium with financial repressions by incentivizing savings and basically constraining final demand in expectations of lower future earnings. So in other words, you have to save a lot more towards retirement if you expect that you will get no returns on your savings.
And you can see that very clearly on chart 11. And that's really against all central banks' common economic sense. But you can see very clearly that low real interest rates have not been and are not stimulative. But hopefully we are getting out of that pervasive depressionary cycle. And obviously a third thing, and probably equally important, is the move to greater quote unquote socialism in the US.
So whilst in Europe and UK, the poorest were hardest hit financially by lockdowns, the same is not true in the US according to check accounts data published by JP Morgan Institute. That's something you can see for yourself on chart 12. You can see that the poorest check accounts have increased by like 50% more than the wealthiest consumers.
And I think it's a safe bet to say that Biden's administration will address inequalities much more systematically in the future, which will unleash untapped pockets of final demand, which will fuel a real recovery. Obviously, the poorest are more likely to spend than the wealthiest. So in sum, I think that should really take us to chart 13 of my chart pack, And you can see that these 3 considerations that we sort of know for sure really justify markets pricing of a sustainable cyclical recovery. And that's actually what is priced in real yields by the markets. And we are still rising there and still in the process of repricing the cyclical recovery rather than in the process of ending this recovery.
So assuming a persistent cyclical recovery, which is my belief, I think we can observe from chart 14 that the Fed front-end repricing is in fact massively lagging the spectacular improvement in the cyclical outlook, which is measured by the cyclical sector's outperformance versus defensive. There's another chart that I really like and which I updated today, which is Global Zoo, which we calculate internally. And you can see exactly the same thing over the past like 4 decades. It was basically directly leading Fed repricing. And now we are basically making new highs with the Fed hikes hardly being repriced at all.
So all in all, my strong belief is that the front-end rates remain highly accommodative, even after bringing forward the expected timing of future policy rate increases.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, that's a great point. So I want to ask you, what do you think the Fed should do at this point?
Juliette Declercq: I really believe that the Fed would be completely wrong to deviate from its sort of laissez-faire attitude to a virtuous fundamental repricing. And basically from its hands-off approach to the ongoing bear steepening. So what I expect Powell will stick to tomorrow and in the foreseeable future is a party line of infinite patience, but otherwise he will try to refrain from controlling yields.
If and when markets start short-circuiting the recovery by front-running the upcoming economic recovery, the most likely answer will be a clarification of the Fed's forward guidance. with a calendar guidance rather than the current obscure current reaction function. But we are nowhere close to YCC given how positive this repricing has been.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, may I ask you to now give us some concrete perspective on what you're actually advising your clients to do with all of this macro backdrop that we've discussed?
Juliette Declercq: Well, the truth is that all the considerations we just discussed, Leave us with a continuation of the slickest macroeconomic cycle experience I've seen in my career. So first, we priced reflation on the back of much lower real yields, and we valued growth sectors and generally all liquidity-driven sectors. And I'm talking gold, Bitcoin, metals, real estate, and emerging markets, of course.
And that was the first part of the post-COVID repricing. Then cyclicals earnings started to recover with less need for financial repression. And consequently, long-term real yields started to rise as they tend to mean revert around an economy's potential. And that's really the point where I argued that the liquidity ship had sailed and recommended a strategic reset about last month.
And in this move, there is still 50 basis points to go, in my opinion, in a motion that will take 10-year nominals well above 2% and 10-year real yields back to zero at a minimum. And we are currently around -70 basis points. And that will basically cap long-term breakevens. So in other words, I've moved this year from recommending that clients pay breakevens to recommending betting on higher real yields, which is now likely to lead nominal rates. higher. And that's really a natural continuation of a cyclically grounded recovery.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, I know you caught a lot of our listeners' attention with your comment about real yields increasing from -70 bps to zero. That seems to be, or I should say that the trend in increasing real yields in the opinion of a lot of analysts is the reason we've seen weakness in the gold market. So I wonder if that means more So let's broaden that to both gold and the dollar. Tell us a little bit more about what this change in real yields is going to mean in terms of both of those things, the dollar index as well as gold.
Juliette Declercq: Yeah, sure. I mean, in fact, gold this year has sort of tripped me over. And I'll tell you why, because I think it will answer your question. Basically, I came this year with a very strong view that the US real yield curve would continue to steepen. And that's worked very well. But the challenge is what does it mean for all assets? So what I really did not expect to happen as quickly as it has, and this really I think will be the typical Q1 catch that might be continuing into the rest of the year, was for the real yield bull steepening to turn so fast into a real bear steepening. So what we had last year was the real yield curve overall steepening, but with the weight down. And we are now basically pivoting higher.
And what this move is doing, it basically spells the beginning of the end of financial repression and that of a macro cycle which relies purely on excess liquidity and fast and easy financial asset appreciation. And that's really why I recommended last month to— and that was premature in my initial framework— to get out of, to take profit in short dollar and also take profit in long EEM recommendation.
And that also led me to take a loss in the long gold recommendation I had. Going forward, with the Fed likely to follow rather than lead market pricing on yields, There is really no reason to believe that U.S. financial conditions will become too tight for the U.S. or for the rest of the world indeed. So this leaves us, as we discussed in earlier question, with still a positive global reflationary stance, which is a clear signal for the greenback, a clear bearish signal for the greenback, and it would be for gold as well.
And that's something you can. Also, front-end real yields differential still indicate a continuation of the dollar downward trend as shown on chart 16. But really, this is where it gets more confusing and why I'm actually no longer recommending either long gold or short dollar. Rather than overpromising and underdelivering, I'm actually recommending to be neutral.
Okay. The opposite has happened. And Biden has basically outdone the wildest market expectations in terms of fiscal stimuli. And that's really allowed markets to price a much faster return to trend growth in the US. And as a result, whilst I initially expected long-end real yields to just grind higher as the front end collapsed, which was justifying long gold and short dollar. The new dynamic, which I think will be perseverant, is one of a long-end upward trend. So that's where we're talking from going from -70 to 0, which is actually resulting from lower front-end real yields. So that's what I call basically the higher long-end real yields are now leaking into the front end. And this move is likely to continue accelerate upon economic reopening and support the dollar.
And this is a dynamic I pictured on chart 17. It's especially true because the Fed now appears more likely to accommodate higher term premia than its EM counterparts. We've seen recently the RBA, the ECB, really pushing back strongly on higher term premia. I think eventually the ECB, the RBA, and even the BOJ, which is now talking about allowing more of a free float of the 10-year as part of its review, I think they will all come to the view I expressed in this interview and in the report I published, that steeper curves, are absolutely conducive to much looser financial conditions. And that will eventually allow the dollar downtrend to reassert itself. But I think we're not there yet.
So really to answer your question more clearly, I'm a bit ambivalent about the dollar and I've given up on gold after a fantastic— in 2010, '20, really it was central to be long gold in my recommendations. And now because we are looking at higher yields being driven more by real yields than by breakevens, I think gold will lose an anchor. So I'm really going to be looking for opportunities to trade extremes in the dollar with a view to eventually re-embracing our bearish outlook. But for now, it's really on ice and not warranted.
Erik Townsend: Juliette, I want to go a little bit further on gold if we can. I couldn't agree with you more. It feels to me like gold has further to go to the downside, and the reason is increasing real 10-year yields. It feels to me like this is a gift, an opportunity. And of course, it's always hard to time exactly where market bottoms are, but it feels to me like we're coming into a buying zone where there's going to be a long-term opportunity. And that, at least in my thinking, is based entirely on an expectation That inflation is coming, and I think it's coming in a big way. And when that inflation is actually registered, we're going to realize that real yields, even with nominal yields backing up, real yields really are returning to negatives. And at that point, I think gold really takes off. I'm just curious, since a lot of our listeners have been following the gold market very closely, would you agree or disagree with that view and why?
Juliette Declercq: Yeah, so I think I completely agree with the first half of your question. You're thinking that we haven't seen the bottom. We haven't seen enough of a correction in gold to reenter here. I did consider recommending to sell gold, but when I've got a strong view, I try to go to where really to the root of my macro thinking. And my macro thinking really is that real yields will go up. I'll tell you why I recommended short TIPS. Rather than anything else is that I feel the biggest risk to my reflationary view at the moment is indeed inflation. And inflation, which like an oil shock would basically be shocking demand negatively, in which case I think the inflation curve would be collapsing, basically inverting and collapsing, which basically means that real yields would be shooting up. So I quite like the idea given I've been recommending a strong beta to risk assets, to have this sort of bubble where I think real yields go up in a reflationary scenario, but it could also be shocked higher in a deflationary scenario brought about by higher inflation.
So I would agree with your scenario on gold. And it's really a matter of probably looking at the shape of the curve, really, the shape of the breakevens curve and the shape of the real yield
Erik Townsend: Juliette, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview.
Erik Townsend: But before I let you go, please tell our listeners a little bit more about what you do at JDI Research. And I know in the past we've managed to wrestle a special offer for MacroVoices listeners on a trial to your service. Is that still a possibility?
Juliette Declercq: So what I do at JDI Research first, so I advise institutional clients, but I also have like a small pocket of retail or high net worth investors that have been following my views and benefited from my recommendations over the past 5 years and generally happy clients. What I do over every MacroVoices interview, which only happens basically twice a year, is I try and offer those MacroVoices listeners a small discount on a 1-year subscription. And that's something that I will be happy again to extend to your listeners. And I really emphasize the fact that I only do it twice a year and only over MacroVoices interviews.
Erik Townsend: Well, Juliette, I look forward to getting you back in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Run your operations like a well-oiled machine with SS&C Eze. Automate daily tasks, eliminate manual processes, and minimize risk. SS&C Eze has been providing award-winning solutions backed by unparalleled client service for over 25 years. Today, they're helping 1,900 hedge funds, family offices, and asset managers transform their investment processes. And grow their business. SS&C Eze delivers cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to maximize efficiencies across the entire investment process for all asset classes. Their solutions are easy to use with friction-free integration into your downstream systems. Meet investor regulatory and due diligence requirements, all while lowering cost of ownership. Set your business up for rapid growth growth and download their free guide at ezsoft.com/macro.
That's ezsoft.com/macro.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was a great interview with you. Juliette Declercq. I really enjoyed her entire segment on the rotation in the markets, and that's something that I want to continue that conversation with, with this chart deck.
Erik Townsend: Alrighty. Well, the download link is in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads just above Juliette's picture, just below the green Donate button. Patrick, the chart deck is called Is Volatility Well, it already returned to the crude oil market today. What's going on with the S&P on page 2?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, we are right now in the quad witching at the time of recording, which is the big option expiration roll-off. And we have generally a gamma pin that occurs in this window, which is essentially the market is naturally drawn to tighter trade ranges going into that expiry. But what that does, and what we typically do see, is things become volatile in the week after. And this is what's really interesting. So right now the market kind of came to where all these major strike prices are had the huge open interest between 3,900, 3,950, and 4,000 on the S&P. And what's going to be really interesting here is whether that brings about that new volatility and which direction that volatility will be. I mean, while I'm not opposed to it going higher. Higher, there are some warning signs that there could also be a bit of a correction coming on the other end. So I want to talk about that. So this S&P chart, all I really want to highlight here on page 2 is that so far the 50-day moving average has held. Uh, we
did temporarily poke below it, but overall, uh, at least on the S&P 500 front, the trend remains somewhat intact. But what is interesting, Erik, if we go to page 3, is where the real actual performance is, uh, is occurring. And so I have here the S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF, which, uh, kind of balances out those big behemoth FAANG stocks that dominate the S&P 500. And what's really amazing is that this is actually where the market has been performing. And even on page, uh, 4, we can see the, the performance comparison of the Equal Weight S&P versus the, the index itself. The index is up 20%, and the Equal Weight is up 32%.
And that's largely because those value sectors and cyclicals, everything from energy stocks to the financials, have just been where all of the major performance has been. And just like Juliette was talking about, it may even continue. And it's really interesting to see that, that, that's that underpinning almost real economy stocks that are driving this trend. But what is also interesting on page 5 is the NASDAQ, and particularly the fact that those really big behemoth stocks like the Apples and even the Teslas continue to actually be actively distributed. This really kind of tells the tale of the rotation that we have been seeing in this market. And while the S&P 500 and the equal weight and the Russell and the Dow have all roared to higher highs, the NASDAQ is nowhere near doing So in fact, uh, it's been just a Fibonacci retrace bounce off of that low, and it looks like it's rolling over and may very well even stay below the 50-day moving average on today's close.
And so really the question I have is that, can the S&P 500 hold up if the NASDAQ isn't done selling? And I think that's one of the big puzzle pieces that I'm going to be trying to solve next week, as to whether or not there's another round of selling and distribution in those FAANG stocks and the NASDAQ itself versus the S&P 500, and will that be something that drags it down with it?
Erik Townsend: Now tell me about page 6 and the momentum-to-value ratio. That's a ratio we don't see too often. What does that one mean?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, I just took the momentum ETF versus the value ETF, and it really continues to just support what we were just talking about, which is that, uh, it's those— the momentum growth names that are really being actively sold, while those value stocks are actually where the performance continues to be. What doesn't show on here is that this has been a 3-4 year trend where that momentum has really been dominant, and it really now has been almost 6 months that the value stocks have really been outperforming. And it really feels like some of a trend. And I guess so long as yields keep pressing higher, I don't see why this can't continue.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the reflation trade that we've talked about in a few past episodes. Look at the dollar index. Well, it's still nicely above its 50-day moving average. What do you make of this chart?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, I think that it's a very simple thing to just observe that 50-day moving average because of the very nature of what a moving average is, is just the average price of the last 50 days, there has been a very distinct downtrend in the dollar that's been dominant through the entire— most of the 2020 year, which has sustained the US dollar below that 50-day moving average. And the fact that we are now going, uh, you know, 2-3 weeks of the US dollar consolidating above it, it does ask that question as to whether this is developing into a trend change. One thing we can say is that bearish US dollar trade has been consensus. It's been a very crowded trade. And the question really becomes, is that— is there room for the dollar to offer a short squeeze where everyone in this crowded trade is shaken out with a little bit of a spike? I don't think we need to have a true macro fundamental backdrop for a shakeout like that to occur just because it's such a popular trade.
Erik, I wanted to move on to page 9 where I have the crude oil chart.
Patrick Ceresna: And this is particularly the April contract. And I drew on that trend line that you were talking about in the market wrap, and I wanted your take on this. But one observation I'll make before we get your take on is the fact that that entire rally that occurred on the OPEC meeting has now been given back. And one of the characteristics that I always look for in price action is whether or not the sequence of higher highs and higher lows can be maintained.
And with the fact that we are, are giving back that entire breakout, it does make me suspect that this is getting very heavy. Now, we don't— like you were suggesting in the market wrap, it doesn't have to be a bear market in crude or some really ugly bloodbath, but we are long overdue for a correction, and maybe this is where that correction has begun.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this red trend line that you see, as you say, has been in place since November. And we did break down and close below it today. On this particular chart, you see it says 61.04 there. That was taken just a few minutes before we started recording this segment. And already, as we got into the pit close, we ended up down to 59.70 as we speak at about 3 PM. So we're already below the line there, and that is a breakdown below a trendline.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: We broke through a trend line that was in place for, you know, at least 4 months or so. And now we're breaking down below it. Is that just because we're going to consolidate sideways here? Or are we going back to the $40s? I really don't know. I do think that this is a long overdue pause or pullback in a healthy bull market. I definitely don't think that was the top at $68.
I think that before the year is out, we're going higher. Question The question is, do we consolidate for another, you know, 6 months or for just another 6 days? We'll see what happens. And I also want to point out, Patrick, on the gasoline futures chart that we broke a trend line there. And more importantly, we closed below the 21-day moving average on RBOB gasoline. That when you close below all of the short-term moving averages, it's often a sign of a trend change in the entire energy
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, and the observation I'd also make on gasoline was that it has actually been the relative outperformer in the space. So since the November swing low, while we saw crude oil advancing 60%, gasoline futures were up 90% to their recent high. And that's really allowed crack spreads to widen, and it's been a real driver in all of this. And so it really does feel like some sort of a more meaningful market correction has really begun because it's really happening quite broadly in most energy markets. Anyway, Erik, what I wanted to do though is continue talking about some of these other commodities,
Patrick Ceresna: and particularly I want to now focus on copper. And so on page 11, we have that copper chart, and what's interesting is, is that copper has not done anything really bearish yet, but we have now seen at least a swing high establish itself back in February. And when we look at it just technically, there was every reason for copper to have already broken out on the upside.
And really, in the end, we're now like week after week just sideways consolidating here. And when I really start kind of stepping back and looking at this, even when we look at, uh, the Bloomberg Commodity Index on page 12, uh, the entire commodity complex seems to have really run out of short-term gas. And really, it has been an amazing trend move that has established itself over almost a year's time now. And we are overdue for a correction. And it will be really interesting to see whether all of these different commodities continue this correction. And if it does so, what will it do to inflation expectations?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to inflation expectations. We've got 30-year breakevens on page 13.
Patrick Ceresna: What's this chart Well, this is interesting to me because really, even after we had the FOMC meeting, the 30-year breakevens have not let up. We continue to see them crawling higher. Inflation expectations continue to rise. And I ask the question is, if we see that the dollar potentially may break out, 'cause we have, I wouldn't wanna call it a breakout yet, and we have commodities coming off their highs, is that the condition from which these breakevens will— can also finally begin some sort of a correction on the downside. And I think that that's something to watch because we're really not seeing any confirmation on this breakevens chart. It just continues to plug away higher.
Erik Townsend: And folks, don't forget you can get a free 14-day trial to Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, and get chart decks like this every day of the week. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies. Pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by SS&C Eze, delivering cutting-edge cloud, mobile, and on-premise solutions to optimize operational and investment alpha across the entire investment process. Listeners, if you haven't yet taken advantage of a free subscription to our Research Roundup email newsletter, Please do so. You can do that by clicking the red button that says Looking for the Downloads on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Patrick, tell them what they're missing in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Juliette's slide deck and the chartbook that we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to an article from Jeffrey Snider that the FOMC statement makes a statement without really knowing it, and a link to a Ray Dalio article, Bullish Stuff, Bearish Stupid, and Short Cash. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from Big Picture Trading. The internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team. Could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices MacroVoices is automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult your financial advisor. Consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented. on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Diego Parrilla — Quadriga Asset Management portfolio manager (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 262 was recorded on March 11th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by Diamond Standard, the world's first regulator-approved diamond commodity. A trillion-dollar natural resource is finally liquid. Visit diamondstandard.co.
Quadriga Asset Managers portfolio manager Diego Parrilla returns as this week's feature interview guest. With apologies in advance to those of you who are waiting for a deflationist, we really do have some of those guys in the pipeline, folks, but Diego is in the inflation camp. We'll discuss why and talk about what the inflation trend means for bond yields, equity markets, and commodities. We'll also discuss gold, the VIX, and much more. Then we'll And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Gold Royalty Corporation CEO Amir Adnani joins us to discuss the royalty and streaming business models for precious metals and where precious metals streaming shares fit into a portfolio allocation strategy.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump to the S&P 500. It really continues to be a tale of 2 markets. The NASDAQ is a huge laggard, but, you know, the Russell small caps, the S&P 500, everything seems to be back. Particularly those kind of cyclical areas and financials have continued to plug away and the S&P is trying to plug to a new high. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, my plan for this week, Patrick, was to use my same line from last week and say it's been 3 whole weeks since no new all-time high. Oh my gosh. Trying to make a joke about it. Guess what? It looks to me like maybe we are going to hit a new all-time high today if we didn't already. barely see on the screen whether it's a high or not. You know, this is obviously not what a blow-off top looks like. A lot of people for the last couple weeks have been panicking. Finally, we're seeing at least some consolidation in the market instead of straight up. But, you know, I think the message here is yields matter. As soon as we saw a reversal in the 10-year yield, all of a sudden they're buying the dip. So I think the real question to focus on is how far can that 10-year yield back up? Is it going to resume backing up, or is it over and done with?
We had David Tepper, who of course is very well known as the guy who was first to really be outspoken in saying QE is good for the stock market back in 2009, saying, okay, that's it, we're done with the, the bond yields, uh, little excursion. It's all up from here for stocks and all down for bond yields. Is this thing really over or not? It seems to me like the real question is bond yields and what the stock market's going to do next is probably dependent on that. And what bond yields are going to do is of course dependent on the Fed and how long they're going to take before they really start to step in and not allow yields to go any higher if they should continue moving higher. So I think this is really all about bond yields.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the dollar index. Uh, we had the ECB and Lagarde talking and the euro a little bit up, so the US dollar's giving back some of those gains that it had from the breakout temporarily above 92. You think this is just a pullback, or you think that's it for the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, you know, I was assaulted on Twitter this week by people saying, see, we got that, we got above 92, it's above 92, it's— you got it all wrong. And I said, guys, wait a minute, we had one daily close above 92, which promptly retraced and has been going straight down ever since. It's early to call this yet. What we know is 92 is the critical resistance level. We had a very good test of it this past week. It looked like maybe there was going to be a breakout. So far it's retraced back down and it's a false breakout, but it ain't over till it's over. And so maybe we're going to see another attempt. We need to see it get above 92 and stay above 92 in order for this to be a meaningful breakout and a reversal of trend direction. Right now, all I see in the chart is, hmm, it's starting to look real interesting.
Let's keep a close eye on it.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to crude oil. I want to know how the inventories came in and what you thought of everything on OPEC. But right now, oil is edging right back toward its highs. I mean, is this done? Are we going to see a $70 handle on oil here in the next week or two?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Sunday's opening price spike was all about the Saudi Arabia attacks over the weekend. And of course, the market has some memory that the last time prices spiked over a weekend because of an attack in Saudi Arabia, it actually turned out to be a sell. So the market has since corrected, but now it does appear, as you said, to be moving higher. We're back above all the short-term moving averages into uptrend territory. The Texas freezeout is still skewing all the inventory numbers, and therefore we have another week of people who don't understand the market completely misinterpreting the inventory. Crude oil building 13.8 million barrels sounds like a massive build until you consider that the drawdown in finished products was 17.4 million barrels. So 13.8 build in crude, 11.9 draw in gasoline, and 5.5 draw in distillates. That's a total of 17.4 drawdowns, or a net 3.6 million barrel drawdown, not build, in total petroleum products inventory this week.
Everybody's focused on the headline build in crude oil, and they don't understand what's happening. You've got to look at the big picture. US production Up a whopping 900,000 barrels, almost a million barrels. Again, don't take that out of context. What's really going on is it was 11 million barrels before the Texas freezeout. We went from way down to almost all the way back. So instead of 11, we're back up to 10.9, which is 900,000 higher than we were last week at a very artificially depressed print last week. It's not clear whether this market rally is going to have a more meaningful correction here or not. Frankly, we could see a $10 or $15 move down and it would just be a healthy correction in a bull market. So the way to interpret this market, Patrick, is I think that the fundamentals really are there for much higher prices. In fact, I'm going to go out on a limb here and make the prediction that I think by the end of 2024, we're going to see a new all-time high above $147. a barrel.
But the question is really not whether that's going to happen, but what's the path to get from here to there going to look like? And certainly, we're overdue for at least a technical correction.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to gold because gold's like 3 days off of its lows, but it's not really about— it's just bouncing off the lows, but it did turn about the same time as Treasury bond yields turned. Do you think that there's anything to this? Do you think a short-term low could be in, or is this trend still going to remain in play?
Erik Townsend: I think you touched already in the context of your question, Patrick, on the real answer, which is this is about real yields. And of course, nominal yields drive real yields. So if the Treasury yields continue to decline, I think that probably was the bottom. And frankly, there's a good technical argument to be made that 1675 was a key support level, and it made sense for that to be the bottom. Remember just last week when we had Ole Hansen on the program, he said that was a very key— actually, I think the number he gave us was 1680.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: We ended up getting down to 1675. He said that was the key technical level that had to hold, and if it didn't, we're in real trouble. The question is, are Treasury yields really done, as David Tepper told us that they were this week, or are they not done? And I think that's going to decide what happens next.
I'm buying this bottom. I don't know if it's the bottom or just an intermediate bottom along the way, but it's time to be buying here. So I'm buying both mining shares and futures. Also participated in an IPO for a gold royalty company. And we're going to get Amir Adnani, the CEO of Gold Royalty Corporation, to join us in the postgame segment to talk about this royalty and streaming business model, because I think it has a lot of appeal. And certainly the timing is right to buy it down here. So that's coming up in the postgame segment.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, that's a perfect segue into that 10-year Treasury yield, because we had the 30-year kind of already peaked out around 2.35% for the last couple of weeks, and the 10-year just above 1.60%. And it's Oil coming a little bit off their highs. I mean, nothing to write home about yet, but the yields certainly are backing off a little bit. What's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as you say, the gold question and the Treasury yield question are really the same question. If this backing up of 10-year yields is over, then I think the gold correction is over, and I'm not convinced that either one is over. I think it really remains to be seen. I've reached a point where I don't think I'm smart enough to really know the answer as to what's about to happen in long-dated Treasury yields? I'm trying to ask all of our smartest guests that exact question, and I'll certainly ask Diego that question in today's interview.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Quadriga Asset Managers portfolio manager, Diego Parrilla. Now, Erik, why did we invite Diego back this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Diego is a super smart macro guy. He's an energy guy and he's a precious metals guy, and those are all very important topics in this environment. It's frankly been too long since we've had him on the show, so I'm looking forward to getting him back on.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Diego is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My interview with Bill Pazos, head of Air Carbon Exchange, is available now at smartermarketspod.com. And my guest on Smarter Markets this coming Saturday will be a return of billionaire financier Robert Friedland for the first of a 2-part interview series titled What It Will Really Take to Green the Global Economy. This is an absolutely fantastic interview, folks, and I really encourage you to listen to this interview and the one next week, because those are going to be prerequisites to our MacroVoices podcast on the 25th, when we'll have Robert returning here on MacroVoices to talk about investing in how we green the global economy. So you've got 3 exciting interviews with Robert Friedland coming up in coming weeks.
But you won't find Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to separately subscribe to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Diego Parrilla, portfolio manager for Quadriga Asset Managers and bestselling author of the books Anti-Bubbles and The Energy World Is Flat. Diego, it's great to have you back on the program. A man who follows energy markets and whether or not they're flat or not I gotta believe is thinking about inflation, but I'd rather have you tell me you're a deflationist because we can't seem to find any smart deflationists left. Let's start with inflation versus deflation. How do you see the whole story?
Diego Parrilla: Well, thank you for having me back. Look, I think the endgame is inflation for sure, but what is very important to understand is there are very, very strong forces in both directions. Clearly, on the deflationary side, we're dealing with potentially unemployment. Obviously, the economy is recovering, but still lagging substantially. We have technological benefits and considerations that are deflationary. We have demographics. We have overcapacity. We have malinvestment. We have potentially bubbles, which are hugely deflationary.
So, all these things point one way. However, there's just one thing or one major force on the other side, which is money printing in the trillions that is basically more than offsetting them all and beyond. So, it's almost as if the more deflation in the system, the bigger of an excuse and the more room central banks have to print or try to print their way out.
Needless to say, The trillions of money printing are not solving problems. They are really doing a number of things. They are, in first instance, just delaying the problems. You're kicking the can through debt. Second, and very importantly, we're transferring those problems through currency and trade wars, which is hugely relevant.
And we're seeing a lot of action in that front with the dollar and everybody else trying to to print their way out. Thirdly, we are transferring the problem or transforming rather the problems, which is, as you mentioned, inflation, as well as inequality, let's not forget. And eventually, this is all leading to bigger issues. So, I think the inflation-deflation debate, based on the fact that there are lots of issues and deflationary forces, but ultimately, this major one, And things, I believe, eventually getting worse, we know that mommy and daddy pretty much have no choice but have to come back and do more of the same. So, it's just a matter of time before this fragility gets tested, and I think more to come. The scenario whereby we grow our way out and you normalize things, I think it's wishful thinking.
But yeah, I hope I'm wrong.
I think the decades of artificial low interest rates and these artificial high valuations, and these bubbles we've created everywhere are a ticking bomb. And that's why I think it's a matter of time that inflation picks up. And I think in that sense, we're looking at this first phase of contained, optically stable markets, but I think things could accelerate. And that's when things start to get a bit more tricky, and to some extent is what we're starting to see in the rates markets as a message to the Fed.
Erik Townsend: Let's go a little deeper on the rates market. Ever since Joe Biden took office and announced an intention to engage in fairly aggressive deficit spending, we've seen a backing up in long-dated Treasury yields. And on the Monday that you and I are speaking, a few days before this interview will air, the big news that hit the tape was fund manager David Tepper kind of declaring, okay, I think it's gone as far as it can go, the backing up of yields in terms of a a panic reaction or a knee-jerk reaction to the Biden administration is over, and therefore he's declaring it should be, you know, all uphill from here in terms of equity prices. How do you see this rates market, and particularly the long end of it, 10-year and 30-year? And at what point do you think the Fed is likely to start to intervene, whether it be with Operation Twist or something else?
Diego Parrilla: Well, I think it's helpful to put things in perspective. You know, we are heading into 2007, 2008, we have a yield curve with nominal yields and rates around 5%, and that was an incredibly flat curve. Your front end, your Fed funds, your 10-year, your 30-year, they were all hovering around that level. Post-2008, you have this major move down in the front end of the curve with QE, but But the back end of the curve initially stayed reasonably high. It was considered to be more of a short-term temporary thing, and short-term rates tried to do the job.
And then as these temporary things become permanent, the pressure on long-term yields increases. In Europe, we introduced negative interest rates. You go all the way into negative yields all the way out, and basically long-term yields come off. Arguably, for a sustained period of time, and then we go into 2018, that situation when famous Jerome Powell's autopilot, we got to the point where the normalization took us to about 3%.
Once again, you had a very flat curve. The front, the belly, the back end, it was all more flat, the market pricing hikes. And obviously, following almost a decade of printing and debt, Of course, the system starts to implode.
As a result of that, and since then, what obviously has been the biggest shock in memory, which has led to the biggest response across monetary and fiscal as well, we go to this situation where everything goes pretty much to zero, the front end, but also the long-term yields collapse to previous— to historical lows.
What we're seeing now, I think it's a bit of a repeat where we see this move up, as you point out, what's the limit? The 30-year at 2.25 and the 10-year, as we speak, at 1.60 are still somewhat a long way. The 10-year is pretty much half of where we were before in 2018, whereas the 30-year is two-thirds of the way.
But I think given the massive increase in debt, we're once again in a situation where the system can't really cope. As I always say, all the listeners on this call can afford a trillion-dollar mortgage at zero. The problem is when rates go up, even marginally.
I think in that sense, the one thing that is hugely important is not just about yields, is to understand that everything else, this artificially low level of interest rates, which we've had for a long time, have created artificially high valuations in multiple other assets.
And everybody, I guess, understands the relationship between fixed income and interest rates through duration, right? So, you look at 10-year bonds or 30-year bonds, and you see the impact that interest rates have. What is very obvious, in my opinion, and less well understood is the idea of equity duration.
And this is effectively the sensitivity also to long-term interest rates. And I think here, the math is less obvious. There's tons of academic work that looks into equity yields. And as a result, by comparing that to the equity risk premia, and you have this situation where people are comparing apples and pears, right? You compare whatever, the S&P or the NASDAQ with 10-year yields, and people would argue Treasury yields, and people would argue that equities are cheap or whatever. I mean, it's pretty obvious. I don't think anybody here will debate that equities are expensive in absolute terms. That's by any single conventional measure, they're incredibly expensive, and we're coming up with new measures. But this fallacy, in our opinion, that equities are cheap on a relative basis, it's such because according to our numbers, the Duration of the S&P is roughly about 28 years.
So, when you look at and you compare whether equities are cheap or not relative to fixed income, you need to compare to that back end. And certainly, and we published some analysis on this called No Premium in Equity Risk Premia. The situation is way worse for growth stocks and things like the Nasdaq, where the duration is, in our view, closer to 40 or 50 years. Just look at what's happened to long-dated bonds. And that's really just purely from a duration rates perspective what should be happening and in fact, what's been the case with the NASDAQ. But certainly, we think that there are limits.
Pinpointing exactly to what's that number, I think we could do some back-of-the-envelope exercises and say, well, ceteris paribus, all else being equal, what level were we in 2007 when we popped basis 5% interest rates and a level of debt of X, that translates roughly to where we were perhaps in 2018 with rates at 3%. And I think it's fair to say that where we're now is not far from those levels, if not surpassed.
And if you combine that to basically the linkage between all the other bubbles we've created in the process and the sensitivity of the system to long-term rates, I think it's a very fragile situation, which basically— It's a matter of time. Either this move up in— if this move up in long-term yields is unchecked, and the Federal Reserve is, as always, positioning these things as temporary, if this thing continues this way, I think you will see a bigger shock on the equities, which will almost self-correct through the fixed income. And I think it could be either something you do preemptively, Or just forced to do it.
And I wouldn't be surprised if you have a combination of both. So, as the equity markets start to be under more pressure, the Fed gets active, even if they don't make the formal full announcement, they're already monitoring and watching. So, they're putting a straight face now, claiming this is all healthy. This is potentially very dangerous, very fragile. And I think there's a number of mechanisms by which this accelerates, perhaps the most obvious one is volatility.
Erik Townsend: You know, this fascinates me, this idea of equities being valued based on bond rates. And you can make this logical argument that says, given where Treasury rates are, equities are actually undervalued. And people act like that's just perfectly logical. It seems to me, Diego, as soon as you get to negative Treasury yields, which we've already seen in Europe, Doesn't that mean that by that measure, equities have a value of infinity?
Diego Parrilla: Well, absolutely. So, it just, it just—
Erik Townsend: at what point do you acknowledge that this is kind of crazy to measure it this way?
Diego Parrilla: No, it is absolutely. I think there are so many crazy things out there and negative nominal yields was, and negative real yields and it's sort of how things are playing out. That's, it's, what you're describing is a change in rules of the game, right? And I think what's very important that everybody understands is this is 100% artificial.
It's 100% artificial. The whole level of front-end interest rates is artificial. Then that starts to put pressure on long-term yields through carry and desperate search for yield and QE and manipulation of long-term yields. If those things decided to have a life of their own and challenge valuations, then No worries, let's do Operation Twist and QE and manipulate long-term yields as well.
That crushes volatility, and you just continue this fully artificial setup, which all it's doing is creating this ginormous complacency and bubbles. Yeah, you could think about once upon a time, you would like to short the widowmaker, the JGB market. And you would argue at one point, if you're playing by conventional rules of the game, yeah, if I'm shorting this thing at 99.99, then what's my downside, right? It's just 0.01.
And suddenly, you go into negative rates and negative yields, and it's kind of game over. The bond market doesn't have a ceiling anymore, and it just becomes a number. And I think that translates directly into equities and this whole fallacy Eventually creates these bubbles that are— let's not fool ourselves, they're by now too big to fail.
And this is where we are. We are in a situation where we just build this massive house of cards with the wealth effect kicking the machine, and then we all have this perception of wealth. You look at your bank account or your share price or your Tesla or whatever you want, or Bitcoin, and you see all those valuations without recognizing that perhaps it's all artificial. And what we've seen over and over in this crisis is when the emperor has no clothes and these things get exposed, it's systemic.
And that forces mommy and daddy to come back and just do it all over again. And so, we're in this, from a game theory perspective, back to your first question on inflation, It's pretty obvious where we're going to end up. But the danger here is so obvious, and it looks so clear that mommy and daddy have a vested interest in not letting this thing collapse, that what shall we do? Shall we just lever the hell out of this and just play the game and go all in with all— and then the problem is you're going to have these major vol moves and shakeouts as we have in COVID, which could be more or less expected, but I think volatility is on the rise, and this is one of the things that will put things in check.
It's becoming increasingly more polarized. I mean, even the question, the debate between inflation and deflation, or Bitcoin, zero or a million or whatever, this polarization of the world eventually, it just translates into vol. One day, I'm correct, the day after, you're correct, and this thing just swings from one extreme to the other.
Then all we know is that volatility is bad news for risk, both realized and implied volatility. This eventually creates— it forces you to cut the size of the positions, and it creates a vicious cycle as volatility increases, and perhaps some of those positions get reduced, and then there's deleveraging, and then correlations increase because everybody has the same trade, and liquidity thins up. And before you know it, you get into a dynamic where— I use the analogy of fluid mechanics, where the world, nature, has 2 main regimes, the laminar regime and the turbulent regime.
And in a laminar regime world, it's all predictable, it's all linear, it all makes sense. But once you go chaotic into turbulent, then things get out of control. And that's, to me, one of the dangers. You're flirting here with the VIX. It's very contained, which I think if it breaks 40, everything's going really out of control.
And this is why we have this situation where I think the central banks need to be ready to act and why I read between the lines, I agree with you, that it's just a matter of time that mommy and daddy come in and intervene in the long end, because it's all related. I think this path of artificial low rates, artificial low credit spreads, artificial low volatility, complacency, bubbles becomes so one way that eventually even the Fed tries to put some steam out of it.
And the wishful thinking is they can do that without this thing imploding in their faces. And they know that in order to do that, they need to control to some extent and intervene. And this is the dependency we're in and why I think this is such a tricky market to play and perhaps a lot more fragile than it might look.
Erik Townsend: Well, it sounds like we agree that if you're dealing with artificial economics and everything is being created by the central bank, then Volatility really is your best indicator as to what's gonna happen next. Now, the VIX is clearly on the rise, but, you know, it's not back to 2008 levels or anything. Should we interpret this as the market is topping and perhaps it's time to think about a cyclical bear market starting? Or do you think it's just a question of time until the Fed intervenes yet again in a way that takes us even higher in terms of equity valuations?
Diego Parrilla: Well, I think volatility, we've clearly got into a new regime, I think, a regime of more higher sustained vol levels. Just about a year ago, heading into the February-March debacle, the VIX was in the low teens. We had this extreme level of complacency where you were able to buy insurance the cheapest, when you needed it the most.
And after a very prolonged period of time, plus obviously what happened, we had a spike that was only comparable to 2008 with the VIX 80+. So, since then, obviously, there's been a phenomenal move up in equities. We've made way more than— reached the previous highs and by a long way.
However, the VIX has been somewhat stubbornly holding above the low 20s. I would highlight a few things. The first thing is we're in this higher level of vol, so in the mid-20s. The second thing that is very remarkable is the shape of the curve. You have a very, very steep contango, currently almost 2 points from front to second month, The front month expires in— at the time of this call, there's another 9 days to go.
The market is actually reading this very calmly. It's looking at these moves in equities saying, look, I'm in contango, there's no panic. Once the shape of the VIX moves into backwardation, and you know this as a commodity guy as well, once the market gives you the hint of backwardation, these things can go a lot more crazy.
But for the time being, it's coping with it, although we're not far, and I think we need to be mindful about that. So, vol is high overall. The markets seem very steep contango. What does that mean for investors?
It means that it's super expensive to play the VIX. If you are buying the futures and nothing happens, you're going to roll down. And think about what 2 points means, 2 points per month. Over, call it, a year is 24 points on something that is worth 24, 25. So, you have a full 100% negative carry if you were to do this every month, which is obviously very expensive, but on the other hand, it's also attracting people that are saying, hey, I can get all this amazing carry, and so what? It's not going to explode, or I will stop out, or whatever. So, you build this meaningful position, which can compound, And this leads to my third point, which is vol-of-vol, so the volatility of volatility. The kind of moves you're seeing on the VIX are phenomenal. The sensitivity of the volatility of the VIX, or the moves in the VIX relative to what are, in all effect, tiny moves in the S&P.
So, you'll see 1% move in the S&P moving the VIX by 3 or 4 points. phenomenal. To me, it's a big warning signal. It's a sign that, look, guys, this could go any minute. Obviously, there's lots of forces against it, and perhaps the next round of checks and other things that could intervene, but I think the VIX, it's an indicator and a tool that I think is one of the best defenders as and when things go completely belly up.
But it's also super expensive to play, which means that the timing is important, the structures are important. And you have a— for those who are familiar with options, there's a phenomenal contango, not only in the futures, but also in the vol, and the call skew is phenomenal. Right now, we're looking at volatilities for the top-end strikes close to 300% for a 50, 60, strike. So, even with a few days to go, and the market pricing in some non-negligible probability of this blowup, and the market's not stupid. People are paying for that for a reason.
And yeah, I think in the meantime, it contributes to these ideas that I mentioned earlier of complacency and fragility. I think this is a sign or a signal for caution. In order to have this super bull market, I think you need the vol way lower. That would bring in strategies like risk parity, or trend following, or vol target, all of which effectively become— they're forced to buy more when the market goes higher and when volatility goes down.
That's something that we've seen missing. Some of that buying, has stayed on the sidelines because volatility has remained somewhat stubbornly high. It's not because some of the big banks and others haven't tried to get the vol to those levels and get that last nail in the coffin that could send maybe the S&P to the targets that they have, but it's all, in my opinion, incredibly exciting and dangerous.
If you are prudent, And you're staying on the sidelines or mindful of some of these dynamics, you look stupid until things really go. And if and when they go, it's so huge that you know that mommy and daddy will have to do something about it.
The big question is, can they continue to do this forever? Is that something that you can assume that they can stay in control? And I think there are potentially the marginal diminishing returns in the central bank policies and what sizes and trillions, and this is something that we're seeing already with yield curves doing stuff and markets being tested and things being even more polarized.
And so, as much as I hope that the vaccines are solving all the problems and we'll grow our way out of this, I think there's a legacy of imbalances that we need to navigate, and it's challenging. Throughout that process, there's going to be a few things that could change the regime in which we're in, and I think volatility is super important, because as volatility changes regime, the market fundamentals don't matter anymore.
2 plus 2 is not 4, it's whatever. And it's whatever the positioning of the market is. And so, if the market is long equities, then as volatility flies, equities collapse. And if the market is short gold and volatility spikes, the market will rally. It will just force those and expose those speculative positioning.
And so, I think it's going to be a matter of time that maybe some of these things get checked. And then it's potentially quite bumpy because correlations, not only volatility explodes, but correlations polarize, and that feeds on itself, creating exponentially higher value at risk and brings me back to that point of intervention and central banks. And it's all related. It just feels like the sequel is getting bigger and bigger. It's not Lehman 2, it's Lehman squared, as I call it.
Erik Townsend: Diego, if I listen to all of the things that you're saying and kind of sum them together between an endgame of inflation being pretty clear, equity market volatility really picking up, sending some warning signals, equity valuations clearly stretched by anything other than a duration comparison to Treasuries, you've got a number of things that you're describing that are suggesting, boy, risks in the system, you'd think logically, boy, gold ought to be testing its resistances with all this going on. But in fact, the opposite is true. Gold is not only not testing its resistances, but we're actually at what Ole Hansen told us last week is a very critical support level that if it doesn't break, there could be a heck of a lot further downside if we can't hold this current level, which as we're speaking on Monday morning is around $1,600. $1,682, right at the bottom of the, the range that Ole told us was, uh, was kind of the number that has to hold.
Why do we have gold down here with all these other things going on? Is it entirely about, about real yields, or is there more to the picture here?
Diego Parrilla: There's a lot of factors. Obviously, the market's speaking loud and clearly, and there's, there's a bunch of them we can, we can walk through. I mean, obviously The fact that gold and Treasuries are moving hand in hand, it's indicative. Of course, with higher nominal yields, then gold or any other asset without any specific yield looks less attractive. But certainly, I think they're both in the same bucket. They're both defenders.
And I think in that sense, that correlation could be justified.
The other interesting dynamic, we talked earlier about inflation-deflation debate, We could talk about the reflation, stagflation debate, and to what extent we've seen since August when the Fed announced this change in stance with respect to inflation, saying, look, 2% is no longer a ceiling. We're going to be accommodative, blah, blah, blah.
You've seen basically industrial commodities, copper, iron ore, cyclical commodities like oil up. 45%, 50%. In that very same period, we've seen gold down almost 20%. So, it's a phenomenal divergence between real assets that goes way beyond just inflation discussions or reflation. So, I think gold has been clearly decoupled from the commodity spectrum. It's much more on the US Treasury, and the momentum of those flows is brutal.
I think those things, again, could be overstretched. Gold is technically clearly oversold.
But again, we have a situation that goes and links us to the dollar. The dollar, I think a lot of the consensus positioning going into this year was a much weaker dollar, people very bullish the euro or others, EM, China. Obviously, we're starting to see that positioning For the time being, the correlation between gold and these currencies is high in the short term on the sell-off. I think those correlations could break. In fact, we play that very actively in our strategy, things that are gold higher, dollar higher, which are extraordinarily cheap. I think that could be very interesting in a vol breakout. Undoubtedly, I think there's obviously the fact that perhaps the market got a bit carried away into the summer making all-time highs, something that I thought it was just a matter of time, and it did happen. We all expected a bit of a fight and perhaps a sell-off, but what we're seeing now is perhaps beyond what most of us would have anticipated.
And I think it's clearly a long-term opportunity. But I think we can't forget also, you can't discuss gold these days without bringing crypto into the discussion. And I think here, There's obviously very polarized views. There's lots of people who see gold and crypto as 2 very viable parts of the solution. Some people are much more extreme, and they see gold as just useless old money and Bitcoin as the new miracle.
I mean, I've done a lot of work into this. I published a note called Bitcoin Bubble or Anti-Bubble, where I I do a lot of analysis on multiple dimensions, purely trying to understand really. And so as I open the article, I say, look, I don't want you to think like myself. I want you to think, which is Frida Kahlo's sentence. But covering a lot of arguments, I find that there are multiple areas of concern and consideration of fallacies, in the process. I encourage people to read through it. Happy to talk about some of those fallacies, like the inflation hedge fallacy, the scarcity fallacy, the value fallacy, that ultimately, to me, helped me or lead me to conclude that Bitcoin is 80% bubble, 20% anti-bubble.
And I think this is just one more factor. I mean, it's very obvious that very phenomenal traders have embraced Bitcoin, some of them perhaps ditched gold, or at least Bitcoin took a bigger part on the short-term bets. Famously, Paul Tudor Jones called it the fastest horse in the race against deflation, but that was at $8,000. That horse has run a long way.
And I think whether it's Paul Tudor Jones or Stan Druckenmiller, who are notoriously bubble traders, when they come into these trades, it's not because they're worth something, they just spotted a bubble. And they'll be making a ton of money on the way up and the way down. So, really, lots of things there. I think back to gold, it's really many, many factors. In my opinion, gold is a clear anti-bubble, both for the fiat bubble as well as crypto.
Personally, I think that these are levels where, whilst it's impossible to just put a floor and technically, to your point, I think the market's a bit Darwinistic. There are so many people in their homes trading historical graphs that have nothing to do with today's reality, and they become a bit of self-fulfilling prophecies. Arguably, if everybody's trying to buy the break, then buying the break doesn't work anymore, and you have a new predator around, which is strategies that cannibalize on people who who play on this.
I'm quite skeptical about many of these things. Of course, the market could look like it breaks, and then everybody's in, and then it just bounces in your face. A lot of caution. I think gold can be very explosive as and when. The pressure has been enormous. Liquidation has been notable.
Personally, we believe strongly, although we play this mostly through options, which allow us effectively the benefit of having the downside capped at the premium and then have very asymmetric payoffs, whereby if the market was to continue to sell off, you lose on a mark-to-market basis, but then you give yourself sufficient time, hopefully, to get to see these moves. But it's been phenomenally challenging for anybody that is long gold or gold miners or silver for that matter, which I was very strong fundamentals as well, even from the reflation story and others.
I think gold is truly fascinating, lots of drivers.
I think it's become very unloved. If I put everything in balance, it's something that I believe you should accumulate. I'm going to make this last point on gold. I think we've seen a lot of momentum in gold. People who were on the sidelines came in over the summer because once it broke, it was going to go to $3K.
And then the people that are now throwing the towel are probably those guys that came in. So, my recommendation is the opposite. I think here, you have to embrace the volatility of the market. You have to embrace the stupidity of the market. And moments like this, when gold is very unloved and equities are super, I mean, in my view, expensive, This is not the time to ditch gold and buy NASDAQ or Bitcoin personally. I think this might be a time to just calmly rebalance. I think it's going to continue to move. We'll see which way it goes. I don't have a crystal ball, unfortunately. Again, these things are not either/or. There could be many scenarios where equities and gold go up and inflation does whatever. But I think gold, it's an interesting asset that I think will have a role to play over the medium and long term.
But it's just like everything else, it's super volatile and under a lot of pressure.
Erik Townsend: Diego, let's come back to the US Dollar Index, which of course is a relative measure of the dollar's strength against other currencies. For the first time since late November, on the day that we're speaking, which is Monday, a few days before this episode airs, We finally, at least intraday, we haven't seen the close above $92 yet, but we're trading intraday at about $92.21 as we're speaking right now. Looks like maybe we're headed toward our first daily close today above $92. That was the previous support level for several months before it broke back at the end of November. Is this a significant reversal? Are we headed back to, you know, $102? Well, you know, Are we at a new cycle high on the dollar, or what do you think's going on here?
Diego Parrilla: Well, I think the dollar obviously has been driving everything over the last few months. More recently, it's yields, Treasury yields and dollar rates that are at the front of the show. But I think the dollar move is interesting because I would argue that it's been— you could almost see within the And DXY, you could see different components, almost like subsectors. So, for the first part, it was mainly the dollar exposing some of the moves versus DM, developed currencies, whereas the euro giving way from 124 to now 118, or dollar-yen, which is also breaking higher and gaining some momentum, or dollar-Swiss.
And now, where we're starting to see, in fact, today, is the first relevant move in the yuan, or Taiwan, or others. There's obviously other types of news and things happening, but the EM train is also starting to be exposed a bit. And I think this is whether it's the carry trade angle on China or other considerations that are linked, I think the dollar move is largely a positioning move, where the long-term yields and the interest rate differential is It's making the dollar more attractive, but more important than anything is the positioning, which was super crowded.
So, how far can it go? What does it mean to the overall index and correlations? I think correlations will also break. You will see certain things working better than others, some of the commodity winners, other losers. So, I think if you look at the overall, the dollar versus everybody else, I don't see any dramatic change in trend that is completely sustained. I mean, you could have 5%, 10% swings one way or the other, but this is a very reactive game where the central banks that are— the countries whose currencies are stronger are defending themselves and are suffering from loss of competitiveness.
I think a good example is China. I think China, since the summer, we saw the Chinese yuan appreciate by close to 12%, pretty much in a straight line with zero vol almost. And part of that was driven by inflows into a positive story. People like Ray Dalio, the 10-year Chinese government bond paying 3%, and it was almost like free money. So, I have a currency that appreciates, the bond's paying me 3%, blah, blah, blah. And my point has always been, look, be careful because as China becomes a carry trade and all this money goes in, volatility explodes, you're going to start to see some of the behavior that we've seen with other commodity currencies like the Aussie, etc.
I think in that sense, the dollar, again, that volatility in rates is transferring to FX very, very obviously. I think those correlations could add to the volatility. We're seeing a bit of a domino effect. Some of them have been leading, others are lagging, but certainly, for now, it's still somewhat orderly.
If volatility was to explode, I think you could see some of these moves accelerate. That takes out a lot of the technical guys that watch this very carefully and sucks them into the new positions, all knowing that if you do the numbers and 2 plus 2, it's should equal 4 eventually.
But in the meantime, $1.9 trillion and another $1.9 trillion, and then Europe, and then the other guy, this is all just parallel inflation. And I think you could see, again, back to gold, some of these assets and correlations breaking. And that could be interesting. So, I think overall, the directional move one way on the dollar doesn't just— the index doesn't do justice to what's happening inside.
You need to look into the attribution of the different components, carries, and other considerations. And if we go into a risk-off move, I think overall the dollar rallies, but it's not necessarily a sustained rally. It will be something that could run, but there will be responses for sure. We've discussed that before with the Fed and yield curve control and volatility.
So, it's once again, It almost feels like when you trade carry, you make money 95% of the time, but it's that 5% of the time when things go against you that can blow up so badly. I think many markets feel a bit like that carry situation where vol could expose some of the positioning, but yeah, the dollar story goes very closely with rates and vol and equities, and it's all part of the same. somewhat artificial setup where the currencies will be controlled to a certain extent, not just by the central bank, but also as a response function to other central banks who are trying to achieve the same game. And that's why currency wars and trade wars are so relevant to the whole thing.
Currency wars is really trying to transfer your problem to your neighbor, by devaluing your currency. Trade wars is the mirror image of currency wars, is trying to defend yourself from that abuse, that monetary abuse, someone effectively becoming more competitive through the FX channel. By you putting tariffs, you're neutralizing that effect. Currency wars, trade wars go hand in hand. I think they're on the rise.
The globalization is being reversed into a at least polarization with 2 main poles, with China emerging and the US. Again, this is all supportive once again of volatility and geopolitics and many other things that are inherently in these markets and that I think are considerations to worry about. But yeah, the dollar, absolutely key. Technical levels, very important. But yeah, I think it all goes hand in hand and watch out for vol and positioning.
Erik Townsend: Well, Diego, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. Before I let you go, tell us a little bit more about your books, Anti-Bubbles and The Energy World Is Flat. And also for the benefit of our institutional and accredited audience, please tell us a little bit more about where they can follow you and find out more about the fund you manage for Quadriga Asset Managers
Diego Parrilla: Yeah, I wrote 2 books, The Energy World Is Flat, published with my good friend, Daniel Lacalle, who's also been with you a few times, and The Anti-Bubbles. Both of them presented very contrarian thesis at the time of writing. The Energy World Is Flat, oil was 120, peak oil theory calling for 200.
We were calling for the flattening of the energy world with 30 to 50 oil. That was probably science fiction to many people when we first published, then it became current affairs, and now it's history. Similar things happening with the anti-bubbles, where I published in 2017, talking about this idea of monetary and fiscal policies without limits, and many of the things that we're seeing today are being reinforced.
Obviously, that endgame is critical. I think the important thing for investors and for everybody is to understand there's a paradigm shift, the rules of the game are changing, and I think the next decade will be very different. Perhaps just 2 takeaways, which are very important and linked to your point on the strategies that we manage.
I think I use the analogy of when you build a portfolio, I think it's very important to understand that it's a team. As a team, and I use a soccer team, football team, I'm Spanish, But you could use any team. But in soccer, you need strikers, which will score goals and make you money through capital and income gains.
But you also need goalkeepers and defenders that will basically do the mirror image. They will make a lot of money in crisis. And I think that's incredibly important. As a coach, you have 3 jobs. You need to define the strategy with which you play. And unfortunately, this leads me to a key message that we talked about in previous interviews, which is the concept of false diversification. It's the idea that people build a team thinking, oh, I own different asset classes, equity, credit, high yield, EM, commodities, private equity, private debt. And when a crisis comes, they all fall synchronously in a big way. So, you were not really diversified, you thought you were diversified. So, I think the first key thing that we tried to address with our strategies is to bring goalkeepers And in that sense, my strategy was best in the world in February last year, one of the best in March. It has suffered more recently, but as a team, I think the strategy proves the point.
And I think it's very important to embrace the stupidity of the market and the volatility. Therefore, times like recently, where some of the goalkeepers like volatility or gold are being sold, I think it's an opportunity to rebalance. I think that's important. If anybody wants to discuss in more detail, feel free to reach out through Twitter @ParrillaDiego.
Parrilla is P-A-R-R-I-L-L, so tricky spelling, and Diego, Parrilla Diego, or also through LinkedIn. I'll be happy to just send additional information, but I think it's very important to play with goalkeepers in this match, And I think the second key consideration is when you build your team, think about inflation. With inflation as part of the endgame, it's not just good enough to have strikers, midfielders, and goalkeepers.
Those strikers, midfielders, and goalkeepers should have a long inflation bias. So, you should favor equities to credit, you should favor real assets to cash, and you should definitely favor anti-bubbles to fixed income. So with that, I really appreciate and thank you for the opportunity. I hope people found it helpful, and I look forward to much cooperation and success. So best of luck, and overall, much, much health to everybody in these super difficult times.
Erik Townsend: And Patrick Ceresna and I will be back with our postgame segment as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Did you know that there's a regulator-approved diamond commodity? Every Diamond Standard coin contains the same geological content of diamonds, so the coins have the same value. Because they're fungible, you trade Diamond Standard coins quickly and easily, like gold, at a market price. Inside each coin, a wireless computer chip stores a blockchain token.
While a custodian holds your coin, you can trade the token instantly. The value is real. It's a blockchain-native physical commodity. For the first time, diamonds are liquid and marked to market daily, enabling institutions to build positions and to create securities. Futures are coming to CME Globex, and an ETF is pending SEC approval on the New York Stock Exchange. This $1.2 trillion hard asset is uncorrelated to stocks, bonds, and other commodities.
Investors own at least 15% of precious metals, but no diamonds, leading to a secular position-building opportunity. Find out more or place an order at diamondstandard.co.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Diego Parrilla. His views on the market in terms of combining options and get the convexity of options in with these macro views is, uh, just so in line with the way I like to look at the markets. But anyway, let's move on because now joining us is, uh, Gold Royal Royalty Corp CEO Amir Adnani for the post-game discussion on royalty and streaming business models and where precious metals streaming comes into a portfolio. Amir, thanks for joining us today.
Amir Adnani: Hey, pleasure to connect with you.
Erik Townsend: Amir, it's great to get you on the show. I want to ask you, starting from the perspective of what we learn about precious metals investing, if you went to a conference on precious metals investing, they would teach you that there's 3 ways to invest in precious metals. Number one, you buy the bullion itself. And the advantage there is you have no counterparty other than whoever's storing it for you. And it's your direct inflation hedge or fiat currency debasement hedge. The next way is to buy shares in an operating gold mining company or silver mining company. The people that are operating a business that makes more gold and silver by digging it out of the ground. And the advantage there is it can actually produce income because unlike the bullion that has no yield, They're creating a business profit as they sell the product that they mine.
Then the third way, which is much more speculative, is known as a junior mining company, a company that doesn't actually have a gold mine that's producing gold, but rather they're trying to figure out where the next gold mine ought to go.
So they're buying up land, drilling, testing, getting things to the point where they've proven out reserves and they can go to a big gold company and say, look, we found the next gold mine. We've proven that the gold is down there. Buy us out in order to build your gold mine. And that's the most speculative way that we're taught to invest. Amir, what's this royalty streaming thing, which I think Franco-Nevada was the pioneer of? What is this? How does it fit in? What does this idea of streaming and royalties mean?
Amir Adnani: Erik, in the mining business, royalties have been around for as long as there have been prospectors generating prospects, staking some ground, and then selling it to bigger companies to develop it. Typically, prospectors would keep a royalty interest, a typical 1% or 2%, which generally was— what it means is it's a contract. All it means is that when the mine starts producing, by contract percentage, 1%, for example, or 2% of the revenue generated, so right off of the top line, is paid to the royalty holder. And typically prospectors would retain this as their major payoff, and that's how royalties were created. You mentioned Franco-Nevada.
Pierre Lassonde, who founded Franco-Nevada— funny story how he actually acquired one of his most important royalties in Nevada on the Carlin Trend by answering an inquiry in the Reno Gazette-Journal Pays $1 million for this royalty. And since then, this royalty has paid over $1 billion in the Carlin Trend for Franco Nevada. And so companies like Franco Nevada or Wheaton Precious Metals, who have become, you know, Franco Nevada is, I think, a $25 billion company and Wheaton is a $20 billion company. These companies have kind of institutionalized the royalty business. Gone are the days where it would only just be prospectors that held royalties.
Now these royalty companies have aggregated a portfolio of royalties and provide investors the opportunity to get exposure to the commodity in the form of a royalty. Now why is this attractive? Royalty and streaming companies have very good operating margins. Franco-Nevada, you mentioned, let's go back to them again. Their operating margin is hovering around 90%.
And so what's happening here is that if you're a royalty company, you don't have new capital investments. You don't have sustaining capital investments. Mining is a capital-intensive business. It's one of the most capital-intensive businesses. So when your gross is your net, which is basically what a royalty company experiences, you just get a percentage of the top line.
You are not taking on operating risk. You have a portfolio of royalties, so you're very diverse. And ultimately, you have that embedded optionality when it comes to the commodity price. You have embedded optionality when it comes to exploration upside. So you, you get a royalty on an asset today where there might be, let's say, a million ounces in place as a resource or reserves.
If the company does a good job and those resources and reserves double or triple, it's not costing you as a royalty holder any money or any risk to realize that upside. Yet as it happens, you get to benefit from that embedded exploration upside as well. Now let's talk about streams for a second, and streams are quite interesting. They're not that different than a royalty, but where they're different is that the stream is basically a contract to purchase a fixed volume of the metals, a fixed volume of gold at a fixed price, whereas the royalty is simply a percentage of the revenue.
And what's interesting, Erik, is the fact that the founder, the father of the streaming model is Ian Telfer, who's also coincidentally the founder of Wheaton Precious Metals, one of the biggest precious metal royalty companies in the world. And they really created the model off of creating a stream on silver, which was a byproduct of the time of mines that produced gold and copper, and there was silver byproduct as well. So it was an excellent way, and you see streams typically set up on mines that operate multiple commodities or metals, and you can basically take one of the metals and create a stream around it while the operator continues to sell the other metals that it has, but uses the stream as a way of financing its operation. And the stream owner gets the ability to have that fixed volume of known amount of gold at a fixed price coming to it. which typically is set up below what the prevailing spot price is.
And that's how the stream holder can generate the return, again, without taking on operating risk or having the ongoing cost, expense, and capital related to owning and operating a mine.
Erik Townsend: So tell me if my interpretation is correct. Mining, gold mining, for example, is a business where the business you're in is digging holes in the ground in order to get gold out of them. And it's a very capital-intensive business. We talk about royalty and streaming companies like yours. It's not a mining business. It really is a capital business. And what you're doing is you're supplying capital to the mining industry with an understanding, almost like investment bankers to the precious metals mining industry, where if somebody is trying to build a gold mine and they need money to buy capital equipment, they don't, they don't have access to enough capital to build what they need to build in order to get the gold out of the ground.
You're giving them money up front saying, look, here's your $3 million you need for this big fancy crushing machine that you need to break the rock down to get the gold out of it. And we're going to not loan you that money as a loan because the interest rates are too low for us to make a lot of money if we did that. Instead, we're going to trade you that money for a royalty or a stream on your revenue. So as you start taking gold out of the ground, we get cut in on a percentage basis. And you're operating a money that is really mining capital out of the capital stream, like banking or providing financing to the precious metals actual mining industry. Is that a fair summary?
Amir Adnani: It's a fair summary of what the royalty companies have evolved into. As we talked about, we talked about what is a royalty or stream on its own. But if you put a collection of royalty and streaming assets together and it becomes a royalty and streaming company. Those companies today have evolved into being capital providers, as you pointed out. And the reason for that really goes back to cost of capital.
Investors like the business model of an aggregation of royalties that really diffuses both the risk associated with mining and exploration, but nonetheless creates the embedded optionality value of the commodity price exposure and exploration success. So coming back to your point, what I see, and you correctly point out, as the role of royalty and streaming companies today is that they really are an alternative to equity investment or debt when it comes to the capital matrix that a mining company can look at when it thinks about how to raise capital. And generally what we've seen over the last year is that the royalty companies trade at a better multiple than the mining companies do. On, let's just say, pure price-to-NAV, one of the metrics that you can measure a mining company, a royalty company might trade at 2.5 to 3 times net asset value, whereas a producer might trade at a 1.5 or 1 time net asset value, sometimes below net asset value, And so what
that implies is that the market's assigning a stronger, better multiple on the royalty company. That means the royalty company's cost of capital is lower and more efficient. Hence, the royalty company can pass that lower cost of capital over to a mining company that needs capital by being its capital provider and continuing to expand and build the royalty exposure. So absolutely, that's really over the last decade, We've seen this transformation of the royalty industry into being an important part of the financing side of the business for mining companies. But look, at the end of the day, it really is about building these exciting, streamlined ways of investing in resources.
And that's what I think investors really like about the royalty model. And I'm excited about it as an entrepreneur myself.
Erik Townsend: Amir, let's move on to the topic of greatest interest to investors, which is understanding how this fits into a portfolio. I understand if what I want is a fiat currency debasement, pure absolute safety play, I want the value, I want to have no counterparties. That's a clear decision. I want to buy gold bullion or silver bullion. The downside is it doesn't produce any income. There's no, no yield or return on it whatsoever.
Then investors are trained to kind of think about where both senior and junior mining companies fit in. The senior mining company gives you some leverage to the price of gold. But it's an operating business that has business risk. You know, it could be nationalized by whatever country it's in and so forth. So you have to think about more risks than you have with bullion. And then in the case of a junior mining company, it's a pure speculation. It's basically wildcatting for trying to find the next gold mine. How do we think about when does it make sense to own shares of a royalty or streaming company? And how should we think about allocations in a portfolio? Now that there's kind of a new choice on the menu, so to speak?
Amir Adnani: It really comes back down to the fact that we invest in commodities. You and I like, for example, what's happening here with gold because we believe in higher gold prices. If ultimately you're looking for the right combination of commodity price exposure, but at the same time, what brings that torque when it comes to commodity investing, which is exploration success, which is operating leverage. All those points, which is the reason why people sometimes say, well, owning a mining stock in a rising commodity price environment, that's the way to go to have outsized performance versus owning the commodity. What I really like about the royalty investment thesis is that it combines all those elements. Again, it's about the combination of the embedded optionality towards the commodity price, operating success, and exploration success, because all those elements end up affecting and impacting top line revenue line for the operator. And as a royalty holder, you're getting a percentage, a fixed percentage of that top line.
It, it really is beautiful, and it really is, I think, why we're seeing the— why this model has become a fan favorite really with institutional investors the rise of the royalty companies in the precious metals sector and how some of them— you look at Wheaton Precious Metals, Ian Telfer spun this out of Goldcorp and it ended up having a larger market cap than Goldcorp itself. Now, mind you, Goldcorp went on to merge with Newmont to become the world's biggest gold producer. But nonetheless, what we've seen here is that this is a business model that has proven to be successful. And the embedded optionality is really what I'm excited about. And it doesn't cost the investor anything to realize that. Once you own the royalty, that's it. You don't have capital contributions. You're not making ongoing investments into the project or into the mine as a royalty holder.
And royalty companies really benefit from having a low headcount. You know, Frank Holmes from US Global made an interesting point about how royalty companies in some cases, in, in the case of Wheaton Precious or Franco Nevada, have higher cash flow generation capacity per head or per employee than Goldman Sachs, you know, than, or, or top investment banks.
Uh, that is an exciting value proposition as well, as you've got small G&A footprint, small team, small overall organizational requirements, yet the ability to generate outsized returns based on that.
Erik Townsend: And certainly Franco-Nevada and Silver Wheaton, later Wheaton Precious Metals, have proven the huge capital appreciation potential of this business model. Amir, let's talk about your own company, Gold Royalty Corporation, which just went public this week. In the interest of full disclosure, listeners, I am a participant in that IPO. And tell us a little bit about why you decided to get into this side of the business and what Gold Royalty Corp. is going to do.
Amir Adnani: Well, for full disclosure, I'm an investor in it as well and invested in the IPO. But what really got me excited, Erik, as an entrepreneur for this, for launching Gold Royalty Corp., was first of all, the opportunity to team up with individuals who have written the book on streaming and royalty. Here we were just during this interview referring to Ian Telfer and Wheaton Precious Metals. Wheaton Precious was founded by Ian Telfer and has gone on to become one of the largest and most important precious metal royalty companies in the world today.
It was spun out of Goldcorp. The former CEO of Goldcorp, David Garofalo, teaming up with him, David has joined me as the chairman and CEO of Gold Royalty, where we've got between David and Ian individuals that have operated at the highest levels of the gold industry, having done record M&A deals, having seen the biggest transactions or led the biggest transactions. Ian was also the chairman of— former chairman of the World Gold Council. To have the opportunity to team up with this caliber of individuals where they're putting their own capital also into the IPO and launch a new company with sponsorship from a bigger player. So in this case, as you know, I'm the founder, chairman, and largest CEO of Gold Mining. A company that has a very large portfolio of gold projects throughout the Americas, we were able to basically underwrite and create 17 new royalties from that existing portfolio, combine that with the team of individuals that we mentioned that have never before done this.
You know, it's fascinating. Ian Telferson's founding of Wheaton Precious has never before joined to start or to build another royalty company. That's an exciting value proposition for, for myself and other investors who are joining us on this, where we're combining the royalty endowment that gold mining is bringing to the table, bringing on board a team that also includes other fellow directors that I have here and investors in the IPO like Warren Gilman, who's been investing in the mining sector on behalf of individuals like Li Ka-shing, the wealthiest man in Asia.
You look at the Chief Development Officer that we brought in, John Griffiths, who ran metals and mining investment banking for Bank of America, left that to come join us at Gold Royalty. You see a small team, but a team that has the most impressive track record when it comes to the gold industry, the royalty industry, and the mining industry, the mining side of gold.
Combine all that together, we had a very successful IPO that closed today. And it is really the foundation for a situation where we're going to go out and I think build a new alternative, something new for investors in the gold sector to look at and consider that's got the right team with the right balance sheet now after this IPO, a very strong foundational portfolio of royalties. And at a time in the gold sector where the gold price is a bit soft and it really is the right time, I think, to be acquiring new royalties and to build the business out. Longer term, of course, if you're bullish gold and you believe in higher gold prices, now really is a fantastic time to deploy capital. And we're putting our money where our mouth is. We're doing exactly that.
Patrick Ceresna: And again, any listeners interested and want to learn more, Amir's company, Gold Royalty Corp., just went public this week under the symbol GROY. Amir, thank you so much for joining us.
Amir Adnani: Thank you so much for having me and look forward to connecting again soon.
Erik Townsend: We're going to have to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole. And by Diamond Standard, the world's first regulator-approved diamond commodity, a new hard asset whose time has come. Visit diamondstandard.co.
Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as there's also a link to an article from Dylan Grice on central banks are going to overcook the economy, and a link to a David Rosenberg article, stop worrying about inflation, there are bigger risks on the horizon. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K, and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register. Your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, MacroVoices and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Ole Hansen — Saxo Bank commodities guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 261 was recorded on March 4th, 2021. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks.io, bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Saxo Bank commodities guru Ole Hansen joins me as this week's feature interview guest. As we've discussed at length in recent weeks, a lot of our macro experts are telling us we're at the beginning of what could be an epic secular bull market in commodities as inflation expectations begin to take hold. So we're going to be bringing you more commodities experts in coming weeks, starting with Ole Hansen this week. We'll discuss everything from the macro drivers of the move higher in commodity prices to where the best opportunities exist and how to trade them.
Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick's chart deck is titled Markets Get Wobbly.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 started Monday with a big update. It looked like the bulls were back in control, and here we are breaking to a fresh weekly low on the downside. We're trading or closing right around 3,770 on the S&P here. What's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, boy, Patrick, 2 whole weeks and no new all-time high. And the crazy part, or what really makes me think, is the number of people who are freaking out because we've gone for 2 whole weeks without a fresh all-time high in the stock market. The thing is, at least until today, this really didn't look to me like a blow-off top or, you know, the sky is falling or the market's crashing or anything. In fact, it really looked to me like the 50-day moving average once again was going to be the buy-the-dip moment. The market was set to reverse. All we had to do was get through a little bit of a speech from Jay Powell. And as soon as that was behind us, the sky was clear for up, up and away. Guess what? Jay Powell must not have said the right thing. I had my eyes glued to the crude oil market today because we had an OPEC+ meeting. So I didn't tune in for Jay Powell's press conference.
But boy, by the time it was over, it wasn't the 50-day moving average the market was flirting with. It was closer to the 100-day. Patrick, you listened to Jay Powell today live. What happened?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, the market did tumble over 100 S&P points in the period right afterwards, and definitely the market is showing a little bit of a wobble, and we'll talk more about it in the postgame. Really, up until this meeting, the story of this entire market correction has been just rotation, which is until today we had energy, cyclicals, financials, value all going higher while the tech sector, particularly the FAANG stocks, all were very heavily distributed. And that was the case, but then really today in the And then in the afternoon, in the post-speech period, the market really started to get nervous. And we saw some more panicky selling.
And, you know, the thought that came to me was that there's that old adage that the market stops panicking when central banks start to panic. And I think that Powell really was saying they're not worried too much about things. They're not worried about yields where they are. They're not too worried about where the markets are at. And I think that that actually is somewhat concerning the market because it means that the Fed is not gonna backstop it anytime soon. And I think that that's maybe contributing to this volatility one way or another. I'd love to talk about it with some charts in the postgame. Anyway, let's move on to the US dollar here because really started to move higher in this period right
Patrick Ceresna: after the speech. We're back to where we were last week. What's your thinking here on the dollar?
Erik Townsend: Well, to me, the key of what you said is back to where we were last week. So, okay, we came down some and came up some. Still, there's no change. We're consolidating in a range. Range between 89 and 92, and we're not even close to 92. So, you know, wake me up when we get a closing print outside of that range. Until then, we're trading sideways until further notice. And so I don't think there's really any reason to, you know, there's been a lot of rhetoric in the market. It seems like people saying, oh my gosh, look at all the strength in the dollar, strength in the dollar. It's back up to where it was a couple of weeks ago. It's not a big deal. We need to see a closing print above 92 before there's any meaningful technical message as far as I'm concerned. Until then, My general comment on the dollar is, remember, even though there are very strong fundamentals to say that fiat currency gets debased, the dollar is measured by the dollar index relative to other fiat currencies.
So it's not really an indication of the dollar's weakness. It's only an indication of the dollar's weakness relative to the euro and other currencies.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because we started the week with a little bit of weakness. We dipped temporarily below $60 and then OPEC. And boy, what a day we had. today. I'm dying to find out what you think happened here.
Erik Townsend: Well, there were 2 big stories this week, so let's take them separately. The first one was earlier this week, rumors were leaked that OPEC was mulling an increase in production. Now, this is just a page out of the OPEC playbook. It's what some people call a trial balloon. What really is going on is OPEC wants to test what the market reaction would be if they were to increase production. So they, they leak a story to a journalist saying that's about to happen, and they see what the market does, and they know that they can always go the other direction at the meeting if they want to. So that happened earlier. We got almost $5 down in the price of crude oil.
Not really a big deal. Uh, it was the first time— or not the first time, it was about the 3rd or 4th time since the 1st of November that we got 2 closing prints below the short-term moving averages in a row. That's only happened a few times since the beginning of November, and that would normally indicate the beginning potentially of a more significant correction. But just like the last couple of times, the 21-day moving average caught the market. Then what happened was when the meeting actually happened, they didn't increase production, and the rhetoric in the meeting was very much in the opposite direction. They opened by emphasizing the need for caution and prudence and A lot of words kind of saying we need to wait this out.
Now, I have a theory here, and this is definitely conjecture on my part, but I think that what the OPEC+ people are doing is they're looking at exactly the same technical number I'm looking at and saying, boy, if you could engineer a breakout past $65.65 and sustain it, there's just not a lot of resistance above, and, and you could potentially launch an epic rally that could really, really start to pick up.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah. Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And I think that's gonna pick up some steam here, especially with the inflationary backdrop. I think that OPEC did an intentional head fake with this trial balloon. They kind of hinted that they might go the other direction. They let the market absorb and sort of shake off that news. Then they went and surprised everybody with a push in the opposite direction, I think hoping to take out $65.65 to the upside. And they almost got there. We got to $64.87. So we're less than a dollar away now from what would be more than a 2-year high, I think, If we can take out $65, spot $65.
I think what they're doing is they're waiting to increase production until after that breakout really gets going. And let's say we're up to $70, and at that point they can start increasing production. That's just my guess as to what may be going on behind the scenes. Then the next big event was inventory, which came in at 21.6 million barrels. That is the largest recorded build on crude oil inventory ever in the history of the market. That caused a whole bunch of people who don't understand how the market works to completely freak out. In reality, it was no big deal and entirely expected. Yes, there was 21.6 million barrels of oil that was added to inventory this week. Why? Because 23 million barrels, a larger number, was drawn down from distillates. Why is that happening? It's entirely about the Texas freezeout. What's occurring here is a bunch of refining capacity was shut in due to the freezeouts.
And that means that you draw down the inventory of finished products and the crude oil piles up because you're not able to process it because the refineries shut down. It's not really a surprise. What you care about is the net number, which is a drawdown, not a build, of 1.7 million barrels of petroleum products overall, including both crude oil and finished products. So So it's really not this panic bearish number that a lot of people in the media were claiming it was. So crude oil build 21.6 million. Cushing, Oklahoma, a much smaller build of 485,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 13.6 million. Distillates drawing down 9.7 million. Again, that's a net drawdown of 1.7 million barrels. So whenever there's a weather event, What happens is it really just makes the inventory data essentially meaningless. We use inventory data in order to figure out trends in markets. There's no trending information from a disrupted market where a shut-in of both producing assets and refining capacity has completely corrupted the numbers.
So the numbers really don't mean anything when this happens, but they still freak people out because it was the biggest build in recorded history. US production up 300,000 barrels. Sounds like a lot, but actually that's just the beginning of a recovery. Remember, it was down well over a million barrels last week. So from down 1.3 million, we're down to down 1 million from a few weeks ago at 10 million barrels even. Again, this is all about the Texas freezeout that has caused this. So again, my next technical target, as I said before, is $65.65. I won't be surprised if we take that out sooner than I previously expected. I think last week I said, you know, that's just such a formidable resistance level. Surely we'll have a few weeks, if not months, of consolidation before we take that level out. My spidey senses, Patrick, say that might come sooner than we expect. And that mostly, that opinion is driven by my interpretation of what OPEC appears to be trying to do.
Art Berman, when we had him on as our very first feature interview guest in In 2021. He said $65 by the end of the year. And we got all kinds of feedback from listeners who said, Art's crazy, that number's too high for 2021. Well, look, it's the 4th of March. We almost got there today. We were within 13 cents of it. I think that a new all-time high, that means more than $147 a barrel, is entirely possible, if not likely, by, let's say, the end of 2024, in the next few years. A lot of people said that was just such a crazy event 2008, you know, it'll be at least 15 years before we ever see prices like that again. Okay, 2008 plus 15 equals 2023, just about on schedule. Time spreads meanwhile are to the moon. My favorite spread, Z1Z2, broke 4.50 today, 4.55 as I look at the tape as we're recording here.
So fantastic performance there.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold really, there's nothing else to say other than it's been outright distributive. Every rally fails. It's breaking to lower lows. The trend is decisively down, but inevitably a buy on dip will happen. How low does it go, though, before we see a buying opportunity here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the only thing that surprises me is how many people seem to be surprised by this. It's very much in line with my own expectations and what we've described here on MacroVoices in the last several weeks, which is, although I'm still very bullish long-term on where we're headed, there's just no good reason to expect anything other than more weakness and more So long as 10-year real yields are increasing, which they are. So I'm already buying both bullion and mining shares down at these prices. Note particularly, though, that today we hit $1,688 was the low on the April contract. Listen for that number again in this week's feature interview with Ole Hansen. He's gonna describe that as a really important technical level that needs to hold. That means there's an argument that this could have been a bottom today. What Ole is telling us is if we get daily closes below today's low, that really could mean that there's a whole lot more downside coming.
And frankly, that wouldn't surprise me at all. I think another $100 to $200 of downside is entirely possible here. And frankly, I hope it happens. I would love to buy more gold $200 lower.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to that 10-year Treasury yield. We're above 1.5%. Certainly it wasn't Powell's speech that talked the yields down. Do you think we are going still Much higher here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think there was a lot of expectation in the market that Powell's speech would include at least a hint toward Operation Twist version 3.0 or whatever, however many Operation Twists we're up to. And for anyone who's not familiar, Operation Twist means the Fed intervening to bring up the rates at the front end of the curve while suppressing the rates at the back end of the curve. And There was a lot of expectation that they were about to announce that. I didn't watch the Powell conference today myself, but I'm assuming just from the market reaction that that did not get promised today. And I think that probably has to do with what's going on here. So the question really is, when does the Fed step in? And a lot of people thought it was gonna be today with Jay Powell's speech. I guess it wasn't. We're gonna have to find out. But that's the real question is how far does the Fed How far does the Fed let it go?
Because I think the fundamentals are in place for yields to keep on backing up until there is some kind of intervention. When is it coming? How far do they let it go? And what do they do? That's really what remains to be seen.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Saxo Bank Commodities Chief Ole Hansen. Now, Erik, why did we invite Ole back on the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Ole is one of my favorite commodities guys in the whole world. I really enjoyed interviewing him back when we used to do the Energy Week podcast. And he's also had some remarkable Remarkably accurate price levels on gold. He called that 1762 cycle low to the penny, to the mark, when that happened— what was it, a month or so ago? And now his next call in terms of a level, which he'll mention in this interview, happens to be almost exactly where the low print was today. So, uh, he's a very, very accomplished guy. I almost feel like inviting him back for another interview because today's interview was recorded a couple of days ago on Tuesday.
And I think you'll see that he's predicted a lot of what has happened in the last couple of days. I'd love to get an update from him. Maybe we'll have to bring him back in a few more weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Ole Hansen is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by Abaxx Technologies, which also sponsors my new Smarter Markets podcast, which airs every Saturday morning and explores how the markets themselves could be redesigned to better serve market participants and society as a whole. My interview with John Goldstein, Sustainable Investing Chief for Goldman Sachs, is available now at smartermarketspod.com. My guest on Smarter Markets this coming Saturday morning will be Bill Pazos, co-founder of Air Carbon Exchange, a man who's doing what Jeff Currie was the most important thing we need to do, putting a price on carbon.
But you won't get Smarter Markets on your MacroVoices feed. You have to separately subscribe to Smarter Markets in your podcast app to receive this free new podcast.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Ole Hansen, head of commodity strategy for Saxo Bank. Ole has prepared a slide deck in association with today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means you're not yet registered at MacroVoices.com. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button above Ole's picture and right below the green Donate button that says Looking for the Downloads.
Ole, it's great to have you back on the podcast. Boy, commodities, kind of forgotten, it seems, by most people in the macro world for the last few years, and all of a sudden, whammo, it seems as if the commodity sector overall has bottomed and reversed quite vigorously. Would you agree with that assessment? And how would you describe the macro drivers? What's going on here? Is it just a bump? Is it a dead cat bounce? Or are we really seeing a secular return to a commodity bull market?
Ole Hansen: Well, hello, Erik, and thank you very much for, for having me. You're absolutely right. I've been covering commodities in my current role for the past decade, and definitely the last 6 months, I haven't seen so many requests from clients looking for how to get exposure to the market. So it's obviously something that's suddenly attracting a lot of attention. And I think rightfully so, because I think in order to understand where we are today, we obviously have to go back exactly almost a year to the peak of despair when the pandemic started more or less a year ago. We saw a massive collapse in demand, obviously primarily hitting the oil sector. We saw producers step in to support the price. And that really set the oil market on a recovery trend.
If you look at the agricultural space, we've seen China reemerging on the buy side or accelerating their buying of key products such as soybeans and corn. They obviously had a hog herd that was decimated a couple of years ago. That's now rapidly being rebuilt, and they need massive amounts of corn and soybeans in order to do that. So that helped as well.
And then the whole, as we moved into the year, we were once again presented with a massive amount of stimulus. Coordinated race to the bottom by central banks around the world, obviously led by the majors, US and Europe, Japan, the UK. And suddenly money was basically for free and stimulus was coming. And again, we've seen the market react, suddenly starting to increase and to look for reflation and look for inflation hedges. And I think there's a key time if you look over the past year, that was basically beginning of November. We had the first vaccine announcements and also we We had Joe Biden winning the election in the US. That kind of turbocharged the whole decarbonization theme, green transformation. And we've seen some of the commodities respond to that as well, because we do have to remember that in order to turn green, we cannot turn green without many of these key raw materials.
So I think on the— just to look at some of these amazing gains we've had on slide 3 and In the deck, we've seen at least performance since early November, as I mentioned. And as you can see, we just basically got broad gains, basically apart from precious metals. And I think that's the one that stands out because— and the one I think that's surprised many because if part of the rally was driven by reflation, then why on earth has gold done as poorly as it has?
And I think in order to understand that, we need to see that recent yield spike. The spike began back in January and which accelerated last week. It's simply a period that gold is struggling to put up a defense against. But generally, we're looking for stimulus. We're looking not only for banks to be supported over the coming years, we're looking for governments increasing to step up their spending. And that basically means a lot of money will flow into infrastructure and into the hands of consumers. And that will continue to lead growth in the market.
And then just finally, I think very importantly as well, one thing is that we're seeing a pickup and expecting a pickup in demand, some of which we're seeing already, but also we're coming out of a decade where, as you mentioned at the beginning, commodities has really not been in vogue. It's not been a sector where investments has gone to. People have been piling in money into the technology sector as well. And that basically leaves us with several of these markets, key markets, with underinvestments, and therefore also the risk that we see supply basically not keeping up with demand over the coming years.
Erik Townsend: I find it very interesting given the narrative that at least I perceive in the market. It's really about stimulus and And of course, green energy is a big priority of the Biden administration, and definitely infrastructure buildout. That would say to me, okay, infrastructure buildout, I would expect the metals and industrial commodities to be the strongest. I would have expected the agriculture to kind of lag behind them because the story is not really about agriculture. It's more about government spending on infrastructure and particularly the focus on green energy. But boy, look at the grains and the softs in, in your chart here on page 3. They're the only things that are— or I should say energy is the only thing that's outperforming grains and softs. Any explanation or insight as to what's going on there?
Ole Hansen: Yeah, I think we have to boil that down to China, Chinese demand and weather. We've basically come out of— we've had 4 or 5 years where, where crop production around the world has been relatively unharmed by all the, all the potential risks from, from, from climate change. Especially in some of the key production areas in Russia, in the US, and in Southern America. And that started to change last year.
We saw several moments of worries, which was related to the production. But then clearly the massive amount of buying that came in from China also did its part. So the rally has been driven by primarily corn and soybeans. And this is really the bad type of inflation because that's the one that hurt the one that afford it the least. We are already now seeing countries starting to complain about rising inflation, rising food costs. And just last month when we saw a spike in wheat prices after Russia introduced export taxes on the wheat in order to maintain local supplies and keep domestic prices down, we saw wheat prices come within, I think it was within 10%, probably less than that, of the peak we had back in 2011. And obviously that was the one that partly led to the Arab Spring where we had food crisis in several countries. So, so it is a— we come out of years of plenty suddenly into a market where we see tight supplies.
And we've got a slide later on as well just highlighting how, how much that, that market has moved from, from contango for a number of years and now into quite a steep backwardation.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk a little bit more about precious metals and why they're underperforming here, because as you say, on one On one level, the narrative about governments spending a lot of deficit spending, printing money, debasing fiat currency, sounds like it ought to be really good for precious metals. Of course, it is easy to see that if you look directly at the observed values for real yields, they're increasing. This baffles me, Ole, because yeah, I get it that gold's enemy is increasing real yields.
Ole Hansen: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: But it seems to me like inflation is just lagging, and, and I would expect the market to look beyond this or look across this and say, look, you know, the inflation's coming at some point, that's going to offset those real yields, gold's eventually going to move up. You'd expect people to be, you know, buying the dip a little more aggressively. They're not. We're really seeing these real yields drag gold down hard. Would you agree with, with the way I've described it as to what's going on, or what am I
Ole Hansen: I don't think you're missing anything, Erik. And we are of the firm belief as well that inflation is coming and it is going to be higher than what the market is currently anticipating. But it also means that we've got breakevens now, 10-year breakevens just around 2.2%. And that could easily be a lot higher in 6 to 12 months. So it seems like it is just the market, they need the confirmation in order to respond to it. And also, we know also how hedge funds, they react to Many hedge funds, they trade primarily on momentum and technical signals. And we obviously have almost— we've been in a downtrend now since August. So there's nothing in the price right now that's telling a fund to get back in the market. So they're sitting on the fence waiting for the breakout. And I think a lot of these, they will— I worked for a hedge fund in London for 10 years before I returned to Denmark in 2008. And I mean, we were missing— we would miss the bottom and we would miss the high, but we would get in involved when the signals were right.
And right now there's absolutely no buy signal in the gold price. And we probably need to see it probably from this level, maybe even $100 higher before that starts to emerge. But I think the narrative is the key driver still are 2. It's the real yields and it's the dollar. And the big discussion right now is, I think, is really, and we've been talking about this in our notes recently, that we probably needed to see some pain before the gain because we need to see yields rise to a point where the FOMC starts to blink and potentially start to talk about some kind of measures to cap the upside on yields. And obviously, if that happens right at the time where inflation starts to pick up, then obviously there's only one direction for real yields and that's back down again. So I think the market didn't like the speed of the change that we have had over the past week.
We broke a key level, 17, 1760, 65, that old band. And that basically just attracted some additional selling. But we haven't broken any major level right now. I think really the big line in the sand for me is the 1670 to 1690 area. That's both the local lows we had May and June last year, but also it's 61.8% retracement of the whole rally we had from March up to August. So that really is a key area that needs to hold.
Erik Townsend: And if we were to see a close below that, if we were to break below, say, $1,680, what would that tell you? Does it mean the floodgates open and we're all the way back down to $1,350, or what do you think happens at that point?
Ole Hansen: I would doubt it because I still firmly believe and still see a reason for holding commodities, holding precious metals in a portfolio. But it will obviously, from a technical perspective, further delay recovery and potentially also obviously lower the eventual peak that we We then will reach, but it will attract some additional selling. But I think on that basis, we also just have to remember that, as I mentioned, hedge funds, they have been cutting back exposure since almost since August last year. And their length now is down to, I think, the lowest in almost 2 years.
So the position that potentially needs to be adjusted further is not as great as we've seen in the past when we've seen some major breakouts.
Erik Townsend: Now, the alternative explanation that some people have put some stock in is, look, what's really going on with gold is all about Bitcoin. What's happening is a significant number of investors who are concerned about fiat currency debasement, who previously would have invested in gold, are choosing Bitcoin instead, or other cryptocurrencies.
Have you guys done any analysis? Do you have any way of measuring whether that's going on? I mean, it sort of sounds plausible, but how do you measure that? Do you think that's what's happening?
Ole Hansen: I've heard that now, and for, for a long time now, and, and obviously it is a It is a very valid discussion. I just struggle to see Bitcoin as a— well, you can't call it a safe haven, but a place to park your money because the volatility is just simply too great. When you see 30% moves up and down in no time, that basically means that it is, I think, from someone who wants to preserve their wealth, it just simply is too volatile. But no doubt it's attracting a lot of attention. And if you are a paper investor, not a physical investor in the gold market, just looking for direction, then silver comes into that category as well, being a high beta gold. Then clearly the Bitcoin or the whole coin area has offered great opportunities, but boy, also a lot more volatility.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on now to the green revolution. Certainly with the shift to the Biden administration, we've got a clear message that there's going to be more focus in the United States on something that frankly the rest of the government around the world were already focused on, which is climate change and in general being more environmentally conscious. Moving on to page 5 of your slide deck now, what does this mean in terms of commodities? Which commodities will benefit from a green revolution?
Ole Hansen: There are several of them, and we can start with the most quirky ones. Obviously, the rare earth metals, they are still going to be in strong demand, and that potentially could become a geopolitical punchbowl over the coming years. But the one that obviously has attracted most of the attention and most of the imagination from investors is copper because it is the metal that's required for the whole electrification process. We've seen China obviously come up with a 2060 plan for that area, and Europe is already en route. We still wait to see what comes out from the Biden administration, but there is obviously a clear expectation that the demand for copper towards that transformation is going to pick up over the coming years.
And from a copper perspective, From a price perspective, it can't really happen at a worse time because the pipeline in terms of new production coming online over the coming years is pretty weak. And that basically means— and we're starting the year 2021 with inventories already at very low levels for this time of year. So it is a market where there's a lot of potential for higher prices and one where we are probably likely to see a new record price.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ole Hansen: It is also of the metals, probably the one that got the biggest amount of liquidity. Also basically meaning that it's one that from a speculative perspective has become very popular. We saw just recently news from China that one of the big whales out there accumulated $1 billion worth of copper in just 4 days after the Chinese New Year. These positions obviously does create some nervousness if we are seeing a short-term pause or consolidation in the market. But so far, copper has taken We've seen a small correction this week, but so far, just like oil, we haven't come close to breaking any key levels. And something like copper could actually— it could easily drop 10%, 15% and still only just return to the uptrend that has been put in place since March last year. So there is still probably in the short term some risk if we continue to see yields move up, thereby seeing volatility move up both in bonds and in stocks, that could trigger some period of deleveraging just like we saw last year.
And obviously deleveraging at this moment time could potentially have an impact on some of these commodities where there's been quite a lot of pent-up demand from speculative investors.
Erik Townsend: Speaking of speculative investors, let's talk a little bit more about copper in that context. This is a tough one for me, Ole, because on the one hand, I couldn't imagine a better bull market argument than we have right now for copper in the long term, because we've got to accept that this electric vehicle revolution is real and every single electric vehicle needs something like 10 times more copper than, than a conventional vehicle takes to produce. What most people don't even consider is that we really are going to need to rebuild the entire electric distribution grid in order to charge all of those electric vehicles. That's more copper. And we're also contemplating infrastructure spending for the sake of stimulating the economy. That's more copper. You just couldn't ask for a stronger argument But boy, you couldn't ask for a more crowded trade either, could you?
What are you telling clients? Is it too late to get in on this? Do you wait for the pullback? I mean, I've been waiting for a big pullback. There haven't been any big pullbacks.
Ole Hansen: I think at this moment in time, we are urging caution because of potentially not because what's happening in copper or in some of the commodities where fundamentals are sound, but just the outside markets because commodities are not an isolated island because these days it's not just purely producers and consumers that meet to discuss prices. There's a lot of so-called paper demand involved as well, and these are impacted by developments elsewhere. And we just saw that over the past week here that after the bond spike that we have actually seen some mild profit-taking hit the market. I think there's still a risk that we haven't seen the end of the rally in yields just yet. And on that basis, urging some caution here. And as you also said, could easily see it Well, they could drop quite significantly without even changing the— changing an iota, changing the bullish uptrend that we have had in place since the low last year.
Erik Townsend: Ole, you mentioned rare earths earlier. I'd just like to clarify, what is the reason that you see it? Is it because of their use in windmills and electric motors, or why do you see the rare earths as being so important?
Ole Hansen: It's a component that's used in so many different appliances, and from, as you mentioned, from From brakes in terms of very, very powerful magnets to the arms industry as well. So the thing about rare earths is that they're not actually that rare, but no one really wants to refine them apart from China these days. And that means that rare earths are being produced around the world, but shipped to China in order to be processed. And that has obviously given China quite a big say in this market, and one that we are starting to see potentially breaking down a little bit. A couple of new major companies has been established over the past year. And obviously I live in Denmark. Greenland is part of Denmark, and I think there's going to be an increased focus on Greenland. Trump obviously offered to buy it a couple of years ago, was turned down by the prime minister, but I think there's going to be a lot of focus on Greenland from a rare earth mining perspective.
Erik Townsend: Returning to page 5, what else in terms of the green revolution should we be thinking about in terms of commodities?
Ole Hansen: I think 2 other metals which I like and which we obviously follow quite closely, and that's silver because of the solar panel, and then also platinum because of the increased regulations in terms of emissions from vehicles, especially recently in China. And we've seen platinum as a major winner since November where it was trading at a discount of around $1,100 to gold. Now that discount has narrowed to close to $500, and there's even the the potential for that discount to evaporate over the coming years.
Because again, demand staying robust. One thing is industrial, obviously another one is financial paper demand. Then we have to look at the supply side, which is quite limited, primarily deriving from South Africa. So platinum, I think, is— the reason why it hasn't really caught on that well is because it's just a tiny metal. It's a factor, multiple factors smaller than the gold market. It's smaller than silver. And it basically means that it is one of those It is one of those trades where when it gets too crowded, you want to get out. The door is just simply too small, and that creates some volatility. But just like palladium had a phenomenal run in recent years, it looks like the time has now switched to platinum. And there are emerging signs that some of the producers of the emission control systems, they are starting to switch to platinum.
So platinum is one. Silver is again from the increased use of solar panel together with the investment demand, which has also been quite strong over the past couple of years.
Erik Townsend: What about battery metals that are used in producing electric vehicles?
Ole Hansen: They would be part of it as well. I tend to focus primarily on the metals that we can trade. Some of them are a little bit more quirky, but anything that— any metals that is used in the electrification process, in batteries, clearly will continue to be in demand until potentially new discoveries are made within the battery or new Battery technologies are found. But for now, as we say, we can't turn green without getting some stuff out of the ground first.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 6, this is the slide that scares me a bit, Ole. It reads, hedge funds have accumulated a record-long exposure. I hate to say it, but hedge funds are kind of known as the dumb money in the commodity business. Usually when they accumulate a record-long exposure, it means the market's topping.
Ole Hansen: Is that Well, it's most certainly a signal that they're looking for even higher prices. And I think the phrasing, dumb money, is clearly because they're always the one having the biggest position when the market turns. They are the most exposed on the long side when the market suddenly flips around. But obviously, what we have to remember as well, that hedge funds, they trade on momentum. They're looking for the big moves. And having been long since 2010, Well, have been long aggressively since August last year. They they have obviously reaped a lot of rewards for that. So so they will take some pain if we do see a correction. But I think also it means that the the pain threshold for many of these positions are quite substantially lower than than where the than where the current market levels are. So we we need to see, I think, a a major change in the technical or the fundamental outlook in order to really in order to to rip into into that. That long.
But I think the one that potentially you could be most worried about is the agricultural position, because what we have to remember is if you want to produce more copper, it can take you 5 to 10 years from the decision is made to copper is coming out of the ground. If you're having a strong year in terms of crop prices, farmers, and anecdotally, I'm a farmer boy myself, grew up on one. And if we had a good year and we had a good production, we didn't go on holiday to Mauritius, we bought a new tractor instead. And that basically, because we want to constantly improve improve production. And that basically means we could expect, weather permitting, a strong response in terms of crop production this coming season. So I think the next few months as we enter the US planting season and the growing period, that could be quite critical for the agricultural space.
So that's probably the one that because the cycles are so much shorter, that could potentially be most exposed.
Erik Townsend: And on page 7, you're saying that this cycle involves broader exposure than previous Why is that? What is it that's getting exposure that wasn't getting exposure before?
Ole Hansen: Well, I think we can just combine slide 6 that we just talked about and slide 7, because this is the table I produce on a weekly basis based on the data from the CFTC. And if you look back in the previous spikes we had in terms of positioning from funds in '14 and '17 and '18, it was primarily driven by the energy market, a strong buildup in energy exposure. But this time around, We can see that the agricultural space is really participating quite aggressively. Almost, I think we're close to a record long. If you look at some of the main, or basically the crop commodities that are agricultural commodities, I'm highlighting in the table here. But if you look down in the net, which is highlighted with the red line, you just see we've got long positions across the board. It's not that often we don't see one or two or more commodities where there's a net short held.
The fundamental drive has just simply been so strong that we're seeing net long positions across the board. I think also we have to remember that a lot of investments are handled through investment funds, ETFs, which buy into some of these major tracking funds, tracking some of the big providers of commodity indices like the S&P GSCI and the Bloomberg Commodity Index. And for every dollar invested into these, that money obviously has to be spread out across the whole sector. So if you are seeing strong index buying of some of these commodity index funds via the ETFs, it will have a positive impact on most of these commodities.
Erik Townsend: Ole, let's move on to page 9 because I think you're making a really important point here about roll yields. In a contango market, as we had in crude oil after the crash, boy, you really have to believe in the market in order to invest in the front month contract because you're You're losing ground every single month as you roll that contract forward. You get a worse and worse price. Now we get a better and a better price as we move into structural backwardation.
How is that— I personally follow the crude oil market most closely. Is that happening across other commodities? And what does it mean in terms of— I would think it would bring more confidence and more investment into the sector.
Ole Hansen: Absolutely, Erik. And I think we just— if we just go back one slide to slide 8, this just basically highlights what has been going on now for the 6 months across the commodity space. You're absolutely right. We come out of a decade where we've seen ample supplies almost across most commodities. We have had pockets of tightness, which has led to brief periods of backwardation, but generally it's been a decade of plenty. Basically, we had the massive bull run during the first 10 years of this millennium, creating a lot of excitement about the sector, a lot of investments going into the market. And as supply suddenly starts to be beefed up, the demand growth That didn't catch up with the increase in supply. And that led to almost a decade, at least in the last 6 years, where we've seen ample supplies.
And that's reflected in the curves because as people normally say, the curves doesn't lie. If it's in backwardation, it does indicate that someone is prepared to pay up to get immediate delivery. And looking at the left-hand graph on slide 8, you can basically see how the roll yield, if you take just— it's kind of non-scientific, but you take the average roll yield of 25 commodities excluding natural gas because it's a bit of a beast on its own. But for the first time last year, the end of last year, you can see that the average roll yield moved into backwardation for the first time since 2014. That is a major change and it is one if you are a passive long investor in commodities, you would have been suffering for the last 6 years from negative roll yields. But now we can see it's basically jumped to at least a decade high. We are close to 5% that you get as a passive roll by holding a long basket of 25 commodities for a year.
And if you look on the right-hand side, we can see where the big changes has occurred. The light blue is where we were 12 months ago and the dark blue is where we are today. And you can see for now, the big change has really been in the agricultural space, especially the soybeans and corns where we are now suddenly looking at roll yield returns of more than 1% on a monthly basis. A year ago, it was hovering around negative 5%.
But generally, there's not that many commodities is left where we don't have a positive carry, and that really does matter. And that takes us back to slide 9, as you mentioned, Erik, with the roll yields.
Because for the past 5 years, if you just look at the spot contract and you look at where the spot contract is trading today relative to 5 years ago, well, it doesn't look too bad. But you obviously have to remember that these contracts, they have to be rolled on a monthly basis. And with the contango in place for so long, you have basically been rolling yourself out of money. And that basically means that the Bloomberg Commodity Index, Which is a bit more broad. We can look at that a little bit later. It has, you can see the gap there of around 40% and a gap of around 45%, 43% on the S&P, which is a bit more heavy in energy. And that has now started to turn around. And if I had a broader chart just for the last 6 months, we could see how suddenly that it started to reverse.
Erik Townsend: Ole, some of our listeners, myself included, are commodity traders who trade the futures markets directly. But that's not for everybody. One of the things that may not be clear to our listeners, I'm not sure from this slide on page 9, is what this chart is really telling you is that whole business about how commodity traders tell you, don't buy the ETFs, you get killed by the contango. Don't do it. Don't do it. Well, it's changed. Buying the ETFs is a good idea now when you have structural backwardation. So, for people who are not trading the futures Which ETFs? How do you pick one? Let's take a look at page 10.
Ole Hansen: Absolutely. And you're absolutely right. There's no doubt that the market structure has changed and suddenly it's no longer a drag. But it's also important to note that there are many different indices out there, but I've just highlighted 2 of the biggest that's being tracked, being shadowed by billions of dollars of investment from funds around the world and through ETFs.
In most regions. But what you have to be aware of is that the S&P historically has always been very weighted towards the energy sector. You can see that on both on the pies and also on the chart on the left, on the right, that the energy sector is something like 54% of the total exposure in the S&P GSCI.
That is obviously important because if you are an energy bull and you think that's where the biggest pull is going to come from, well then that's the one you should look at. But at the same time, you also just Just put a few more eggs in your basket just to spread your risk a bit. So that could be a good idea. But if you are more inclined to look at the— first of all, looking at those where we've seen this big move towards backwardation and thereby roll yields, and you're also looking at, I'll say, a broader inflation hedge, then it's probably the Bloomberg Commodity Index that you need to focus on because they're set up in order to more or less track 1/3 from each of the main sectors.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ole Hansen: sectors, energy, metals, and agriculture. And if we, for instance, as we talked about the green transformation, if the metal space is really going to be where a lot of the focus is going to go into continuously, also from the fact that again, the metal space is not— you cannot just bring supply back online.
If prices go high enough in the oil market, the shale oil production will increase, no doubt, because it's just, there's money to be made. But the metal space will be the one that's least reactive to increased demand. And that means that that's probably where the prices, the price potentials are the greatest. So, so just be aware that there are different compositions, but that also means they can— there are different ways to earn, that they can serve individual preferences.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 11 because I want to come back to this question of precious metals and real yields. I think our listeners understand from previous shows that real yields are super important to precious metals. What's been baffling me is it feels It seems like the market just can't see what to me is obvious, which is, yeah, real yields are increasing because nominal yields are increasing. The nominal yields increasing with no inflation ain't gonna last. It's gonna change. But it seems like the market doesn't wanna look past what's in front of us right now. How do you make sense of this? And what do you think comes next? How much longer does this real yield-induced temporary cycle down and go on?
Ole Hansen: Yeah. It will until we start to reset our inflation expectations or we start to see yields break high enough in order to force some kind of response from the Federal Reserve. Because as you can see on this one, on this slide here on the right-hand side, the yields are— the nominal yield is a factor, is the sum of the inflation and the real yields.
And what we have seen over the past year or so, even probably even longer, that breakevens has slowly been creeping higher to a reflect higher inflation expectations going forward. But over the last few months, it's almost plateaued. And during that time, that means basically as nominal yields rose, it was real yields that had to give, and they were rising almost in line with nominal yields. So we need to see the— so it's all about inflation.
Whether we're right or wrong on that inflation is going to play a bigger part than the market is currently pricing in. I think what could really turbocharge the precious metals would be yield curve control. I think there's a lot of arguments for and against. One thing is that Australia go in and Japan go in and cap their upside on the yields. But the world's reserve currency and the US, I think that it's basically if they're capping yields, they're almost giving the government a blank check to spend because they're going to keep the yields financing at— prevent financing rates from moving.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Ole Hansen: Moving higher. But at the same time, I think there is— I think it's too early for yields to move dramatically higher. So if we do see some kind of an attempt to curb yields, then real yields is likely to— they're likely to go lower. If our expectations for inflation, that inflation will be higher than where we're seeing it right now, if that comes to fruition, then that would be your next move in gold.
And potentially that could be 3, that could be 6 months out in the future. So I think gold right Right now, it's very much a patient game.
Erik Townsend: Now, let's play devil's advocate and look at the other side of this, of how we could be wrong here. Let's suppose that somehow you and I and a whole lot of other smart people just got this inflation call completely wrong and we're just going for deeper deflation. I suppose one side of the argument would be, well, that really spells bad news for gold because if you saw no inflation at all and yields continued to back up on a nominal basis, well, that would really just do a number on the real yield. The other side of that though is, well, wait a minute, uh, if you really saw deflation, then this backing up of nominal yields would probably reverse. Is that a safe bet, or is there a scenario where this really turns sour for gold?
Ole Hansen: I think if we are wrong on inflation, then, uh, then the reasons for, for having a, a portion of, of gold in your portfolio starts to be reduced, and that could have an impact. But I think at the same time, if it's happening in a scenario where yields just continue to move higher, do you really want to be long bonds where you're losing capital?
You obviously will get repaid your full investment, but from an investment perspective, continuous rise in yields is really not an environment that you, as from an investment perspective, is going to gain much from during that period. So I think that the risk is obviously there, but looking at the tightness that we're seeing across the world, and obviously commodities are up a lot, freight rates are 3, 4, 5 times higher than they are normally. There's a lot of congestion.
I think we are just literally weeks, if not a few months away from business starting to pass on higher prices to consumers because they have to go somewhere to pass on the costs. We're seeing PPI Rising in China. China is being a major exporter of consumer goods, will— that will have an impact as well on price pressures. So yeah, it is obviously healthy to be the devil's advocate, but it's just very difficult to see a scenario where inflation is not going to move higher and potentially even surprise to an accelerated extent.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 12, copper prices have more than doubled since their March lows. And hey, the pandemic's not even over yet. Once the pandemic is over, does that mean we're headed toward a triple?
Ole Hansen: Well, I suppose there's always the old saying that the best cure for high price is a high price. The question is if that's still valid when it comes to something like copper. And if you look at where it's used, I suppose in electric car manufacturers, even though the price goes up, it's still a relatively small part of the total cost of the car.
But how much further it can go? Well, it really, if we are having a major supply deficit, then in theory, the price can go a lot higher and most certainly not rule out that we're going to eclipse the record highs that we saw in 2011. I think the biggest risk to copper in the short term is probably China because we're seeing some weakness in some of the data. Credit impulse is slowing and that could indicate that we may not, that the impact of the massive spending that they did last year potentially starting to fade a little bit. I put in on the slide, you can see the copper and its relation to the Chinese renminbi. So if we do see a period of renminbi weakness, that potentially could also just take the top out of copper and create that pullback that you've been looking for.
And we have to remember, if you look at China, that they consume roughly around 50% of the The global mined copper, and they probably hold what, around 5% of global reserves. So they are obviously a key driver, but I think that what will carry copper higher will not be China. It will be the electrification of the world, which we'll see to an increased extent both in Europe and in the US.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 13, green transformation and its relationship to copper.
Ole Hansen: Yeah, that's a little bit of a quirky one because again, you can always find a chart that suits your narrative. But I think this one is quite interesting. This is just basically looking at the copper-gold ratio relatively to 10-year bond yields in the US. And you can see that to me is pretty much a correlation that has been playing out for the past 10 years at least. I probably could go even further back. But what we know Well, since the low last March and accelerating during the past 6 months is how we've seen the dislocation. First of all, copper's been rallying faster than gold, so the ratio's been going higher. But at the same time, it's also rallied faster than the pickup that we've seen in US yields. And the question is really whether that is due to the green transformation that we are seeing a shift in demand patterns for copper, which basically means that it can command a higher price going forward.
relatively to other assets that it did in the past. Or it could just basically be telling us at this stage that it is too high relative to gold, or yields need to go even higher. So obviously there are 3 variables here that could move. I think the scenario that could be really quite fascinating would be, again, if we see some kind of a yield curve control, because then the yields will stop rising. At the same time, we potentially could see the copper-gold ratio come down because gold will start to reclaim some of the lost ground.
Erik Townsend: ground.
Ole Hansen: But for now, there's a dislocation indicating that either copper is too expensive or yields are too low, or we basically have a new world where the green transformation is going to cater for much more copper demand than we've seen in the past.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to my own favorite topic of crude oil. Boy, it seems to me we're almost up to $65.65, which was the kind of double top At the end of 2019 and then January of 2020. I'm not sure if we break through that, what's next. There's not a whole lot of obvious resistance levels up there. What do you make of this market? Are we nearing a top or are we just beginning?
Ole Hansen: I think we're nearing a near-term top before eventually moving higher again. I think the fact that we have rallied, what, almost 30% since Saudi Arabia cut production back in January, that obviously highlights the importance of supplies being kept away from the market. So the rally we've seen so far has been a supply or lack of supply-driven rally. Now, obviously, we expect that it will be replaced by a demand-driven rally going forward once we all get— or the COVID clouds start to lift and we can get back on planes and back in the cars and start to be more mobile. That's obviously the narrative at a time where as well the US producers are more— suddenly have become more responsible, more interested in passing money back to the investor than just going all out on drilling craziness.
So I think that's the narrative.
But I think we also just have to see this. There was quite a significant amount of demand from Asia during the past 6 months. I've read a few reports now over the past 48 hours that some of that demand is starting to— they're seeing slowing demand from Asia, from refineries. There, we're seeing India contemplating lowering taxes on fuel because prices are just simply getting starting to get too high. Inflation is getting uncomfortably high. So we are already at these levels starting to see the the potential impact on some of the some of the major consumers around the world. So but I think the narrative that that we are seeing a we are going to see a return in demand to to where we came from a bit more than a year ago. That's going to hold truth because even. Even though we are seeing, even though we see the green transformation and electrical vehicles and so on, we still have a growing population in parts of the world where demand growth is, where most of the demand growth is coming from.
So it'll still take a number of years before we see a peak in oil demand. And into that, we are seeing a US shale oil sector which has become a bit more prudent than it's been in the past, lack of investment because of the the sector is just not attractive for many investors these days, and that's the whole ESG. That's something that's impacting mining companies as well, that the availability of finance is not as great as it has been. That will eventually drive the price higher, but I think there is a— I got a sound bit of skepticism at these current levels.
And as you can also see on slide 14, we clearly need to see a more optimistic optimistic view coming in from OPEC, IEA, and EIA. Ever since August last year, they have been downgrading their demand growth forecast for 2021 on a monthly basis down to around 5.5 million barrels of growth this year. And as we recall, OPEC+ still has around 7 million that they can unleash onto the market. Not strong growth in the US, so that will still be below the previous peaks, but generally, I think the rally in oil, potentially not a much further rally at this time, I think it's going to be a little bit more difficult to come by. But as we move into '22, I could easily see it move higher.
Erik Townsend: Ole, you mentioned agriculture previously. Anything you want to add here on page 15?
Ole Hansen: Just what I've mentioned before, that we've gone from years of plenty to tightening supply. The 1-year roll is now across the agricultural sector. That's really where you find the biggest roll. also find the biggest speculative long. So I'm just, as I mentioned earlier, I'm a bit cautious for the coming months because we are getting into a massively important planting season in the US, which could really set the tone for the prices into the summer. But we're starting the year on a very strong footing.
Erik Townsend: And uranium, a subject near and dear to many of our listeners' hearts. The price of the URNM ETF has more than doubled Since we first discussed it here on MacroVoices. What's going on?
Ole Hansen: I think the realization that we can simply not move to a less carbon-intensive energy supply without uranium. Wind and solar is obviously an important part of the mix, but we need some baseload. And that baseload is really sorely missing. We've seen that in recent incidents. And that basically means that I think uranium is becoming less of a bad word than it was back when I was young in the '70s and the '80s. The technology has moved on. So I think it'll come back. We're already now seeing quite a big growth in number of new reactors, primarily in Asia. But I think what is pretty certain is that if uranium or U3O8 stays at these current levels, we are going to run into a massive deficit because it's just simply not profitable enough for the mining companies to beef up production. So I think uranium sector is one that I want to have an exposure to over the coming years.
Erik Townsend: Ole, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Before I let you Before I let you go though, we have a broad audience here, mostly institutional family offices, high net worth investors, but there's also a retail component. You guys are one of the most respected commodity advisors in the institutional space, but I believe you also have some retail offerings as well. Tell people how they can find out more about what you do at Saxo Bank.
Ole Hansen: Well, for those of you who doesn't know, Saxo Bank is basically a platform. We offer access to, to more than 35,000 markets or tradable products around the world. We are— we got clients in more than 170 countries. So, so we operate in multiple legal jurisdictions and in multiple languages. And if you want to follow us from the strategy team, we're all relatively active on Twitter. You can find me at Ole_S_Hansen.
And otherwise, if you can take a look at analysis. Saxo. And if I should just highlight 2 daily publications, it's our, it's our podcast where we, where we try to stick our neck out on a daily basis, just what's, uh, what's moving and where we see the market go next. And also just a quick take that we put out early in the European hours, just summarizing what's been going on overnight.
Erik Townsend: Well, Ole, I can't thank you enough. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor. Monetary and fiscal measures by governments and central banks are inflating asset prices globally. As investors prepare for future inflation, demand for scarce real assets is rising. How does the 1% prepare for this? They invest in art. Masterworks.io is the first company that lets you invest in multi-million dollar paintings at a fraction of the cost from artists like Basquiat and Keith Haring. 84% of ultra-high-net-worth individuals collect art, according to a 2019 Deloitte survey. And it makes sense. According to Citi Private Bank, contemporary art returned 13.6% year over year in the last 25 years versus 8.9% for the S&P 500. Over the same period, art had the lowest correlation to the stock market of the Masterworks.io is making art investing accessible to everyone, regardless of accreditation.
Start diversifying your net worth today. Visit masterworks.io to learn more. See important information at masterworks.io/disclaimer.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Ole Hansen. You know, I really learned something when he talked about the term structure, and because I've always assumed that with futures that you're always going to have a negative carry when you're rolling on these contracts. But the fact that the term structure is shifting and the fact that you can now actually invest into these commodities without that drag is, uh, was something that was, uh, just caught my attention. What did What'd you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: That's a really important point, Patrick. And I think that for our listeners who are not futures traders, when you hear me and lots of other people say, look, don't try to buy the commodities through the ETFs because you get clobbered with contango yield and it just wipes you out. It's not a good plan. Don't do it. That's all changing. And the question is, is that commodity in structural contango or structural backwardation? We got so used to everything in contango that we just assumed it was. Now, as things move into backwardation, that actually means you make a roll premium, not a roll cost, but a roll premium every month. You're buying the same commodity for a slightly lower price as the ETF rolls its positions forward. So for commodities that are in backwardation, the ETFs suddenly make a lot of sense.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on, Patrick, to the Postgame Chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email.
If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Patrick, the title of this deck is Markets Get Wobbly. Boy, no kidding, especially the stock market this afternoon. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: So Erik, the, the story up until now has been rotation, and we've heard Julian Brigden talking about the impact on those FAANG stocks and other growth names with higher yields. And really what we have seen is structural weakness in those growth names and rotation into those energy, cyclical, financials, and so on. And that's been the story. It's held up the Russell. The S&P has more or less— the correction has been contained, and almost all the selling has been in the NASDAQ. And one of the things we were asking was, will that be it? Is this just going to be like a NASDAQ driven correction, or does this get into something bigger where there's a broader liquidation cycle or liquidity event that happens on the short term that drives a deeper correction?
What's interesting is the S&P on this chart too is only down about 6% from top to bottom, and it's just breaking below the 50-day moving average. A 10% market correction in the S&P, which is not uncommon to have, well, you know, typically even once a year, in the markets, could see the S&P drop toward 3,500 where all those previous highs are. But if we go to page 3, this is the interesting part, is that the NASDAQ has already surpassed a 10% correction, and we've already done a 50% retracement, and we've already now come back to retesting those September-October highs. And so this is a really interesting moment. Is this really a bigger kind of traditional correction that happened in the NASDAQ and the S&P was just dragged down with it, or is there a more ominous drop coming in the NASDAQ in this rotation and the S&P will come down to that 3,500 level?
This is such an interesting moment to determine that, but really there is no denying it. The NASDAQ is where the relative weakness we've seen, so much selling in ARK and all of the EV names and so many of those bubble stocks, uh, that, that have really got all of the money from flow earlier are now in very distinct profit-taking cycles.
And what I wanted to highlight on page 4, 5, and 6 is just picked 3 of the FAANG stocks— Apple, Amazon, and Tesla— and we can see they're decisively all below their 50-day moving averages, very decisively being distributed on the downside. And it's really going to be interesting to see, like, is this just one of these 1-month corrections and this is all a buy dip on these FAANG stocks, or is there something much deeper in store for them? I mean, can we see Apple, like Julian Brigden was talking about, do a 50% correction off of its high if yields are pressing 2%?
Boy, is it an interesting moment in the markets.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think this is all strong evidence to support a story we've been talking about for months, if not years, here on MacroVoices, which is this market has become entirely about the Fed and Fed-supplied liquidity. And what's going on here is everybody was expecting that the Fed would continue to support the markets. We saw all-time high after all-time high after all-time high.
Now today, when Jay Powell didn't say what he was expected to say and didn't allude to Operation Twist version 3 and so forth, all of a sudden people are starting to panic.
And I think that what happens next is entirely dependent on the Fed. The most likely outcome, my guess as to what happens next, is Jay Powell pulls another rabbit out of his sleeve and says, okay folks, we're gonna do, you know, whatever it is, Operation Twist or who knows what. Market participants are reassured, and before we know it, we're powering back to yet another all-time high.
If we go the other direction, particularly if the Fed were ever to make a statement and say, look, bailing out the stock market is not our job, we're not going to worry about what the market is doing. We're going to let the market find its own level. We're going to focus our efforts on other things in the Main Street economy. I think you'd see a crash start instantly if they ever said that.
Erik Townsend: And for that reason, I don't think they're ever going to say that. But moving on to page 7, Patrick, what is next for the reflation trade?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, I wanted to really just have this conversation with you because I kind of look at the markets today and I ask what is the single most consensus view out there, I think you'll agree that it's the idea that inflation is here. And there's really been this cycle where everybody's rotating into these commodities and resource names, and everything— it's such a crowded consensus trade. Consensus dollar down, consensus everything. And, and while that view probably will be correct in the years to come.
Often what happens when a market gets overextended and so crowded in one way, often the market checks that rally and we see mean reversion and corrections, and, and a lot of the weak hands get shaken out of these trades.
And I asked the question, is like, can this crowded trade be broken or shaken? And so on page 8, uh, there's an interesting chart from Pavilion that is showing the China credit impulse. And a lot of people today are anchoring off the Fed balance sheet and off money supply and all these other inputs that are showing that in things that are inflationary. But at least over the last decade or more, it's really been the China credit impulses that has driven many of the commodity cycles that have driven the— those inflation impulses and the reflation trades. And what's interesting is we have seen a turn in that Chinese credit impulse. And I haven't heard too many people talk about this. And I, I just want to ask the question, I mean, could this potentially be what lets some of the air out of this balloon and where we could see some of these different countertrend moves occur, where some of these markets correct?
And so when on page, uh, 9 I have that US Dollar Index, and we were just talking about the idea that the US dollar, which has been in a very clear bear market, and it's only been in a range for the last few months.
But this has been consensus. It's consensus that the US dollar is going down, and again, it probably will over the next couple years. But what if, what if we do get a, a US dollar squeeze here and this goes higher? That would certainly be some of the first warning signs, like a canary in the coal mine, that some of the air might be taken out of this reflation trade. And I think, uh, with that US dollar, I also have the US dollar against the renminbi on page 10, which is also showing that huge US dollar downtrend that's been very well in place since the second quarter of last year. And for the first time, we're seeing it sort of taking a break, and, uh, and it's kind of turning up. And I don't want to already be touting that some new uptrend is emergent. But it's really interesting that this moment in the markets that we're, we're seeing a lot of these warning signs that would typically come at this moment.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, and as you say, the dollar is really going to be interesting to watch. I want to see what happens at 92. Yeah, we're kind of getting close, 91.63 as we're speaking Thursday afternoon. That's just about exactly where the high print of the day back on the 5th of February, which was the previous high, was. So we're just back to testing what happened a month ago, or a little more than a month ago. We're not really into, you know, moving to a high yet. We're on the edge of it, but let's wait and see what happens. Closing print above 92, I'll be convinced, okay, now something's up.
Erik Townsend: In any event, let's move on to the Bloomberg Commodity Index futures chart on page 11. Looks like maybe at least a short-term top
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, what I wanted to talk about is this, the commodity index. We heard Ole Hansen talking about it earlier. And really what we've seen, even though crude oil has punched to a higher high, we've seen so many of these other commodities already kind of put a short-term top in everything from lumber to copper to many of the grains. They have had these amazing bull runs and they've really driven higher. And we really are seeing at this moment where this almost like broader risk-off impulse is happening where the dollar's slowly creeping higher, equity markets are backing off, and many of these commodities are putting in some of these short-term highs. And it'll be really interesting to see whether or not we do get just a natural market correction in this advance, and, and certainly be watching where some of the buy-on-dip opportunities may emerge there.
But what I wanted to really leave off here was on page 12, just to show where we stand on the 10-year yield. And what we continue to see is that the yield keeps pressing higher. And I think one of the big warning signs that I'll be looking for is, will we see some short-term blow-off in this 10-year yield that kind of has it start to mean revert back downwards? And right now, it looks like it wants to try to punch to a higher high, and I think that That needs to be our base case at this moment.
Erik Townsend: And finally, on page 13, folks, don't forget you can get Patrick's service, Big Picture Trading, every single day for 14 days, 2 weeks with a free trial. Information on page 13. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode is brought to you by Abaxx Technologies, pioneering the design of smarter markets that better meet the needs of both market participants and society as a whole, and by Masterworks, Bringing fine art investing within reach of all investors. Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Ole Hansen's slide deck, as well as the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to an article, Albert Edwards and Scott Minerd Agree That US Yields Can Go Negative, and a link to a Jeffrey Snider article, Reflation Amplitude is important, but what about frequency? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.
Now, for those of our listeners that write a blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we We will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend. That's Erik spelled with a K. And myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Erik Townsend: Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library, and the more registered users. The more users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants. And do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC.
For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.