Lakshman Achuthan — Economic cycles guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is. Bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 245 was recorded on November 12th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by Masterworks.io, which gives investors of any size the opportunity to invest in the $1.7 trillion fine art market through fractional ownership, and by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM.
A focused play on miners and holders of uranium. Economic cycles guru Lakshman Achuthan returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll build on Lak's May 7th interview on MacroVoices and talk about why Lak sees an inflation cycle on the near horizon. We'll also discuss where we stand in the economic cycle and the outlook for financial markets. Then be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment when Patrick has prepared another of his famous chartbooks.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, before we even get to the stock market, how do you see the big picture in the wake of the election and the vaccine news that came out this week?
Erik Townsend: You know, Patrick, I think this should be called National Fake News Week. I mean, over the weekend, we hear that the election's over, Joe Biden is president-elect, it's a done deal, Trump is out, Biden is in. And then the, the other news was the blue wave didn't happen and the GOP keeps the Senate.
So, you know, this was all presented as if it was a certainty. Then Monday morning, we get Every day we get news that Pfizer's new vaccine is a game changer, completely changes everything, ought to be approved for mass use by Christmas. You know, pandemic is over. Hooray. The thing is, no part of any of that is true. It's all complete nonsense. The election works the way we described it last week. There is no president-elect. We won't know for sure who is president until January 6th, although frankly, that's a technicality because by December 14th, everything but the possibility of a last-minute objection will have been ruled out.
And frankly, both houses of Congress upholding an objection seems profoundly unlikely in this environment. But technically, we don't really know who the president is until January 6th. And between now and December 14th, we talked last week about unfaithful electors and all the things that can happen. Now, I'll be the first to acknowledge that it is very, very likely that Joe Biden is going to win. But this nonsense about calling him president-elect, he's not president-elect of anything. The election is not over yet. And it's very, It's very, very likely and almost certain that Biden is gonna win, but it is not done yet.
And frankly, people who are saying, oh, every other president, you know, has always conceded, Gore didn't concede until December 12th, the meeting of electors, which this year it'll be December 14th. So, you know, President Trump is doing exactly what Biden would be doing if this had gone the other way. Now, before I'm accused of taking sides, I'm not trying to side with President Trump here. One of the things that's being presented, one of the bits of fake news, is that the Democrats did not get their blue wave and they didn't take the Senate.
Frankly, there's a very real possibility, a much greater possibility, I would say, of the Democrats still taking the Senate after the runoff elections in Georgia in January. So that is still possible and it's not over yet. So it could be that the Democrats— it would actually be a tie, but if there's a tie and you've got a 50-50 split in the Senate, then the tie-breaking vote is cast by the Vice President. You can count on Kamala Harris to take the Democrats' side on pretty So you can still have the blue wave happen, and all this stuff that's being presented as if the election over is simply fake news.
Erik Townsend: Now let's get to the real news about the coronavirus COVID crisis. There has been a massive increase in both infections and deaths, both globally and in the United States. To put this in perspective, that big scary peak that we had in April was when we got to the point of 35,000 new cases per day in the United States. The last few days have been been more than 135,000 new cases per day. Yesterday was 143,000 new cases. Globally, April was about 85,000 new cases. It's now over 600,000. And we had also a new record of more than 10,000 deaths in a single day yesterday for the first time. So the Northern Hemisphere is leading, suggesting— for a while we thought the seasonality of cold weather didn't really have anything to do with it. Seems like maybe it does because This resurgence in deaths and new cases is primarily happening in the Northern Hemisphere as the weather gets colder.
And then on Monday, for about the 5th time in this pandemic, you'd think we would have learned by now to recognize obvious patterns. What happens? We have some relatively mundane news, which is positive results in a clinical trial. It's great news. Don't, don't get me wrong, but it's not game-changing. It doesn't mean the pandemic is over. It was a perfect opportunity for the CEO of Pfizer to follow in the footsteps of the CEO of Moderna and do what? Sell most of his stock on the rally because he's smart enough to know that this is nonsense. So the Pfizer CEO sells more than half of his personal holdings in Pfizer stock on this stock rally. It's not a game changer, folks. This is approximately the same thing as the Moderna news. Some pretty good news that says they're getting some positive results and they're making some progress in a clinical trial. It doesn't mean that there's a vaccine that's ready to be rolled out.
Now what's real heat Here, RNA viruses are tricky because the antibodies don't last very long if you use a conventional vaccine. This is a brand new kind of vaccine called an mRNA, messenger RNA vaccine. And the significance of that is it doesn't only stimulate the creation of antibodies, it also stimulates T-cell immunity, which is a different kind of immunity. That potentially could mean that the immune effects last longer than a conventional vaccine. But this is a brand new thing. They've never even done a clinical trial of an mRNA vaccine on human beings before. Nothing has ever been approved. It's brand new. So this Pfizer vaccine might very well turn out to be very important. I'm not discounting that. Time will tell. But it's not known yet. It's not as if the vaccine is ready to go and the pandemic ends next week, which is the way that the market seems to have interpreted the news this week.
Meanwhile, what nobody's talking about is the mink strain, which frankly is very concerning. The executive summary of this is the virus has jumped from human beings to another species, minks in this case, the little rat-sized animals that they make mink coats from, and it mutated and then got passed back to human beings. And the significance of this is that when a virus jumps from one species to another, from, in this case, humans to minks and then back to humans, For reasons that are way beyond my pay grade, that apparently makes mutations more likely, including mutations that might render a vaccine that worked on the old strain completely inoperative on the new strain. And I have no idea what the medical explanation is for why it works that way, but I'm told that's how it works. The point is, what's really going on is there's a huge upturn in cases, a huge upturn in deaths, new news about this Mink strain, which for the first time proves that this this virus can jump from humans to another species and back to humans again, which may have some very significant consequences in terms of how long a given vaccine would be effective, and perhaps a new vaccine would have to be developed each time this jumping from species happens.
Most of the news, the balance or preponderance of news, is very negative, but the one headline that seems to have occupied everybody's attention is the Pfizer headline, which makes perfect sense. It sets the Pfizer CEO up to sell his stock. So congratulations, sir. I'm glad you made a good profit. Maybe the rest of the market will catch up with reality sometime soon.
But let's come back to the presidential election. Now, as I said, the election is not over. There is no president-elect, but it seems very likely at this point that Joe Biden is going to win, even though he hasn't quite yet. Remember Dr. Pippa Malmgren's prediction made, I think, 3 years ago on MacroVoices, where she said, look, as soon as
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: She said, if Trump can't get reelected, he's going to start his own news network to compete with CNN and Fox News and so forth. And what she predicted is that that would be a step up, not down, in power for Donald Trump, moving out of the Oval Office, out of the White House, and into his new TV studio behind his gold-plated news desk or whatever he's going to have. That, in Pippa's assessment— and remember, she worked in the White House as a presidential advisor, she knows what she's talking about— In her assessment, she thinks that is a step up in power, not down, for Donald Trump.
So it's gonna be very interesting to see where that goes.
And just today, President Trump is tweeting to his followers, encouraging them to dump Fox News and intimating his plans for a new digital network designed to crush Fox News. So it seems that Pippa's prediction is coming true even before the official results of the election are even announced. So I think it's probably most likely that Joe Biden is going to win the presidential election. It seems nearly certain at this point. And when he does, President Trump is going to take up residence behind a gold-plated news desk at the Trump News Network. And that's going to be really, really interesting. We need to try to get Pippa back to talk more about that scenario.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's move on to the S&P 500, because once that vaccine news came out, the S&P 500 just rockets higher to an all-time new high. And then the markets just give it all back. And we're not necessarily selling off yet, but we certainly are not following through on any buying and are not really holding anywhere near above all the previous highs in September and October. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: You know, it's really interesting. On the vaccine news, it was an instantaneous reaction of stocks straight up, oil straight up, Gold straight down. And as you say, the stock market retraced most of it pretty quickly. I think it was before the closing bell on Monday afternoon that the stock market had woken up and said, hey, wait a minute, you know, the crisis is not really over. But the oil market just kept going to the upside, and really the, the gold market didn't recover. So bottom line, Patrick, I don't think the market is yet in touch with the negative side of the coronavirus news. It seems like the initial Okay, the Pfizer vaccine changes everything. This is the game changer. The pandemic's over. That came back out of the market. But what didn't get read into the market is the fact that we've got a really big increase in cases and infections, and also this mink strain news, which is brand new.
And then the scientists are still trying to figure out what it means, but it doesn't sound good. That stuff has not been digested yet, as far as I can tell. One way or another, I doubt that President Trump is gonna win, but I do think that the resolution of this this stock market situation will be upside.
It'll resolve to the upside once we've gotten past any uncertainty. We know for certain what the outcome of the election is. And then, you know, there's more stimulus coming. So I think eventually this resolves to the upside, but I think there might be a little bit more volatility as maybe we come to terms with the fact that there really is no president-elect quite yet.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, let's move on to the dollar index because the dollar immediately sold off. We were trading down at the 92 handle. The euro was up along the 119 level. level. It really looked like the US dollar weakness was coming in there. Now we bounced a little bit. We're back toward the 93 level, but by no means are dollar bulls back added to the upside. Do you think there's more downside to the dollar from here?
Erik Townsend: Well, so far, you know, the 92 support level held just like it did in August. In August, there was an intraday dip below 92. We didn't even see that this time. So, so far it's holding up just as well as it did in August. Until there's a clean break, a closing print below 92, I don't think there's any technical signal of The fundamentals are muddy. You know, the market can't decide between the election and the pandemic status. It doesn't seem to know how to interpret them. So I think things need to get clear before we see any clear direction. I'm not making any bets here. I think anything's possible.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, 'cause the moment that news started coming out, crude oil just started ripping. And I mean, 2 weeks ago we saw the low down along the $34 level, and suddenly we're back in the $40s. Do you think this is the real turning point for oil?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's really confusing, Patrick, because first of all, before you even get to the vaccine news, in theory, a Biden win is bullish for oil prices because of Biden's policy on fracking. You know, if US producers can't frack, then that means there's less supply and that pushes the price up. So there was certainly some upward movement on oil prices, a slow drift up higher after the futures market opened on Sunday night, but it wasn't till the vaccine news that the big Big, you know, just moonshot to the upside really happened. So it seems to have been driven mostly by the vaccine news.
The thing is, as we talked about earlier, the stock market was straight up on the vaccine news, but it retraced by the end of the day. It didn't come out of the oil market the way that it did.
Now, the crazy part is OPEC announced lower demand expectations because they seem to be paying attention to what's really going on with the coronavirus crisis and the increase in cases and so forth.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: So OPEC is talking about lower demand expectations. When that news came out, oil sold off, but it didn't retrace the, the big move up on the vaccine news. And I don't think the vaccine news was being interpreted accurately. So it's kind of backwards. Meanwhile, we got inventory delayed by a day this week, came out today on Thursday at 11:00 AM, and it was expected to be a big drawdown on crude oil inventory, which might've propelled the price higher. Turned out to be a build of 4.3 million barrels.
Patrick Ceresna: Wow.
Erik Townsend: So a pretty darn significant build in crude oil inventory this week. Cushing, Oklahoma, drawing down 518,000 barrels. The place where we did see the big drawdowns was in the finished products. Gasoline drawing down 2.3 million barrels and distillates drawing down a massive 5.4 million barrels. So on the one hand, we didn't see the drawdown on crude oil inventory that was expected this week, but we did see a net drawdown on petroleum products. Distillate and gasoline drawdowns together were almost double what the size of the build was in crude oil. So it wasn't quite what the market expected. Tape action was a down reaction in crude oil in, in reaction to that surprise build, but it wasn't even down to a new low on the day, although it did later move back down to a new low.
So I think the market is just trying to come to terms with with what's important and what's not in correctly interpreting the virus and demand expectations and the various different data points. Let's come back to this, Patrick, in the postgame segment when we can look at the charts and talk about some of the levels and where this may be headed, 'cause I don't think it's a very clear picture.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because last week on the show, we were just talking about this beautiful breakout in gold that it looked like it was finally getting some traction. And then the moment this vaccine news came out, Over a $100 drop on the downside and right back down to the multi-month lows from September and October. What's going on here in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I've been saying for weeks that a clear winner in the presidential election could be a gold-down scenario, especially if there's no increase in civil unrest. And essentially that's what we have. Regardless of the issue of whether or not the election should have been called already, it's pretty darn clear that Joe Biden is strongly in the lead. Most people are perceiving that He's already president-elect. So it kind of helped that that happened. But as you say, the big move down didn't really happen until the vaccine news. And again, what I find really interesting is the stock market was crazy up and it came to its senses and realized, hey, wait a minute, there's no good reason for this to be happening. And it all retraced. Gold market hasn't retraced. Now, I did end up buying here on the dip on Monday afternoon. And I I don't think this is necessarily over yet. I think there's still room for a test of the 200-day moving average.
It's $1,798 now and rising slowly. But at the end of the day, you know, MMT is here to stay. Gold is definitely going higher. I think there's still room as the market stays confused a little bit and we do get a final resolution to the election and we know for sure who's president. And if the market continues to think that this Pfizer vaccine is a game changer, which I don't think it is, maybe there's room to get that tech technical correction down to the 200-day moving average, I would be buying much more aggressively there.
I looked at this and I said, you know, I'd rather wait for the 200-day, but, you know, it could be that the market wakes up to what should be obvious, which is the Pfizer story doesn't really change anything, and maybe this is going to be the bottom. So I bought Monday. So far, unfortunately, it looks like I caught the bottom just about perfectly. I'm hoping to be proven wrong and to get another opportunity to buy even more at a lower price. We'll see what happens.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because as soon as all that news came out, the yields go ripping higher. We almost hit 100 basis points. It's— but we're obviously back off now about 91 basis points at time of recording. What's your thinking on what's happening here with interest rates?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, as our regular listeners know, I've been kind of no opinion on the bond market for a while now. I'm going to change that this week. I still have no opinion very short-term. But I'm really coming around to the view that rates have probably bottomed. And I know a lot of people have been proven wrong saying this before, but I think the 38-year bond bull market probably really is over now and has reached its final conclusion. And I think that at some point, I don't know how soon, we're going to have inflation that's going to result in higher long-term yields. Let's see what Lak has to say in the feature interview. This is certainly something he looks at very closely.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is ECRI co-founder Lakshman Achuthan. Erik, why did we invite Lak back this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, Lak gave us a terrific interview back in May, and if you go back to that interview, which I recommend— and by the way, I tell you in the beginning to go back and listen to it. I didn't tell you where to find it. Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, put Lakshman's name— you can just start with L-A-K-S— into the search box at MacroVoices.com.
And you'll find that interview from May 7th. That was a great interview. And first of all, he got a lot of calls right. He said he thought that the market had bottomed, the business cycle was turning, and he talked about how we needed to watch as these trends developed, specifically for the reemergence of a self-reinforcing virtuous cycle. So I wanted to find out, okay, he got a lot of calls right in May as the crisis was beginning.
How are the things that he said to look at or to focus on and keep an eye on back in that May interview, how are they evolving now? So I wanted to come back to this. And certainly with the discussion we've had with a lot of guests about whether inflation is coming and how far off it is, I wanted to pose that question as well.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Lak is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: If you haven't already heard me talk about Masterworks.io, I encourage you to go back and listen to my interview from May with their CEO. Masterworks.io lets you invest in the $1.7 trillion art market. Art prices rose 8.9% annually between 2000 and 2018, more than double the return of the S&P. Masterworks.io recently sold their first Banksy, resulting in a 32% return.
Having a portion of your wealth in alternatives like art is important during times of political uncertainty. Art had a correlation factor of just 0.13 to the stock market, the lowest correlation of the 10 major asset classes. With 97% of bonds yielding less than 5% and stocks trading over 31 times earnings, investors need a place to preserve their wealth. That's where Masterworks.io comes in. To learn more, visit Masterworks.io today. Important disclosures at Masterworks.io/disclaimer.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Lakshman Achuthan, co-founder of the Economic Cycle Research Institute, or ECRI. Lak, it's great to have you back on the show. Before we get started, listeners, first of all, there is a slide deck you're going to want to download. The link is in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads. Here's the thing I also want you to take to heart. Lak was last on the show back in May. Yes. We did a lot of coverage of the way that ECRI analyzes cycles. So we talked about the 3 Ds of every recession, which are depth, diffusion, and duration. We also distinguished the different types of cycles. Economic cycles can be growth cycles, they can be business cycles, they can also be inflation cycles.
So understanding those different All of the content in that May 7th interview is as relevant today as it was the day that it was recorded. We're not going to go back and cover old ground. So I encourage new listeners, if you don't remember that interview, to go back and listen to it because we're going to build on what we started there. Lak, I want to focus on a couple of things you told us in that interview. First of all, that was May 7th. You said you think that it looked to you like your signals were telling you that a bottom was being put in on those indicators. And boy, sure enough, from a stock market standpoint, you nailed the bottom there. But you also went on to say that you really have to be careful when things turn up. It's not just the cycle turning up, but you got to be able to distinguish, well, which cycle is it?
The inflation cycle or the business cycle, the growth cycle? Which one is turning up? And you also said it's important to look for a really key event, which is the emergence of a self-reinforcing virtuous cycle. In other words, a feedback loop where whatever is causing things to turn up just keeps causing that effect to increase in its effectiveness. So clearly something's going on here because we're still in really the middle of a pandemic crisis. Global infections and deaths, both globally and in the United States, are spiking up to new all-time highs. You'd think that would be really bad.
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Yet the stock market is rallying to new all-time highs. Is this about a growth cycle? Is it about an inflation cycle? Is it the political cycle? What's going on and how should we interpret this whole story?
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah, no, I hear you. It is kind of mind-boggling. And thank you for the opportunity to kind of break it down. We're going to talk about business cycles. We'll talk about growth rate cycles. So once you're in a recovery, you know, what's going on with the growth? Is it accelerating or decelerating? And then separately, but super important, especially today, inflation cycles.
And so just to link us up and listeners up to the May interview that you just summarized, we were looking for a bottom at that time.
Actually, in early April, we had, based on just some of these cycle dynamics, how far we had fallen and some bottoming in our forward-looking leading indexes, we thought it was going to be one of the shortest recessions ever, the one that we just had. And in retrospect, it looks like technically speaking, it will be really short. I think this is going to be the shortest recession technically in US history. Of course, the end of recession does not mean recovered. We have a lot of things that we're watching to see if we can get back to where we were before the recession.
And when on business cycles, so we're saying the business cycle recession has ended, we are in the business cycle recovery, meaning the level of activity continues to improve, continues to increase. And in terms of, is it self-sustaining? Is it virtuous? Do we have a positive feedback loop in the way that the economy operates? And the answer there is yes. Yes, we do.
And the reason we know that we have this virtuous feedback loop is based on leading indexes.
And we had talked about leading indexes like the Weekly Leading Index starting to bottom last time, so over 6 months ago. And listeners can see a picture, the current picture of the Weekly Leading Index growth rate on page 1 of the chart deck we're providing with this interview.
And you could see it's run straight up. And those leading indicators, right, in the Weekly Leading Index reveal if indeed it's virtuous in terms of the recovery. Is it self-feeding, or is it simply that, you know, you ran out of milk and you had to get more milk, and so now you have a little pop in activity? It's much more than that.
Okay, confidence is coming back. There's pent-up demand. So there's increases in employment and income away from stimulus, which is feeding back into sales, which is helping with production. And so that cycle, each one of those items, and if you have more production, you, you have more people working. So that cycle is revving to the upside. And when you're in the vicinity of those cycle turns, they're quite powerful.
Even though there are plenty of things to worry about, and I share the concerns of listeners about the things to worry about, the cycle is pretty darn strong and can really barrel through a lot of that stuff.
We had also discussed, Erik, how stock prices typically bottom just before the end of recessions. In this case, the bottom everybody knows was in March, right? You look back on your charts, for 2020, and you see, yeah, there it is. It's in middle to late March. Given our understanding of cycle dynamics on which we had based that earlier short recession call, we were able to recognize not too long after that March low that the market had very, very likely made a cyclical bottom.
In other words, regardless of the ongoing debate about what's the Fed going to do, or how many infections, are they going up or down, or what's going on with the vaccine and all those things? You know all of the back and forth on that over the last several months.
We knew that because the cycle, the direction was up, the direction of growth was up, that stock prices would keep rising at least for the next few months. That was several months ago. I would submit that for anyone wondering, if cyclical fundamentals matter to the market, this is pretty concrete evidence.
And here's the thing, the same logic that I just described held in March of '09. And I mean, it's a decade ago, right? But back then we had the same kind of situation. And in March of '09, we had the indicators, leading indicators, the same leading indicators showing a virtuous cycle to the upside. turn up just after the market low. And you recall, or some listeners may recall, I think you recall, Erik, the debate raged for months on end in '09 about is it a double dip? What's going on? But the leading indexes were emphatic in saying, no, it's a recovery.
Erik Townsend: Now let's talk about what is driving the recovery, because I think one of the key distinctions that we discussed in May is, okay, it may in the beginning feel like a growth cycle, bottoming and entering a virtuous cycle to the upside and an inflation cycle doing the same thing. In the beginning, they kind of look the same to the economy, but boy, they have dramatically different endings. So do we learn enough from what the indicators tell us to be able to diagnose what cycle is actually driving this at this point?
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah, yeah. And we're really, really focused like a laser beam on The sequence of these cycles. So to be clear, first we have the recession end, the contraction in the level of activity stopped, and it started— the level of activity started to expand. So the growth rate of the economy started to improve, and that's a business cycle expansion begins and a growth rate cycle upturn begins at about the same time.
And When we look at the leading indicators, what's driving the recovery, there is a story to be told there.
We had talked about, and many people have talked about, the K-shaped recovery. It happens, higher-income households are doing better than lower-income households for a host of reasons, but it also, there's a K-shape to the sectors of the economy. That have been improving. And, and the real foundational block of this recovery has been in the goods sector, the manufacturing sector of the economy.
And that's both happening here in the United States and around the world. And so that's both a domestic and a global industrial upturn cycle that is within the overall business cycle. Separately, you've had a very strong upturn in non-residential construction, and that is also quite real. It has legs. It's not faltering. It's not a one-off kind of pop off the bottom.
The interesting thing about these 2 sectors is that their cyclical amplitude relative to the overall economy is quite high. It's many times the cyclical amplitude of the overall economy. So even though they don't make up the majority of the economy, which is really on the services side, they can— at times you have a situation where like the tail's wagging the dog.
And here with the strength of these upturns, it's certainly helping overall growth continue to improve. And so we turn to services where there was a good pop off the bottom, but that has been slowing. So it's still growing, but it's growing slower. And that's because there's a lot of people-facing kind of services activities that are hampered, of course, by the virus.
And so we see that story, but we don't get too hung up on the services sector being a little less robust on its growth rate, because we see that power, that cyclical power in the goods and the construction side is really lifting all boats right now.
Erik Townsend: Lak, we're talking so far conceptually about cycles and so forth. How do we actually manage risk around these prognostications that the cycles, the indicators tell us which way the cycles are heading? What do you do from a risk management standpoint in response to that?
Lakshman Achuthan: Okay. Well, to be clear, our analytical framework is not about market timing, even though I mentioned just now a couple of lucky timing calls on growth, business cycles, and the market share prices. Our approach is really about managing cycle risk in a systematic way. It's more than just economic growth. That's a really important cycle, and we just went through some reasons why it's so important. But one of the really, really big insights that our research group had decades ago, actually my mentor Geoffrey Moore, is that there's separate cycles in inflation.
And as simple as that sounds, it's actually really, really profound. Because most people don't think about it that way. So in our world, in managing cycle risk, you've got to know which way to look for growth in economic activity, but you also have to be looking to get the cyclical direction right on inflation.
So if you don't appreciate that inflation is cyclical, you're going to be repeatedly blindsided. And today, that's a clear and present danger. I've heard very bright people talk about inflation and very bright people talk about deflation as a result of some of the big issues that are out there with debt or with stimulus or with weak growth and structural things.
So I think first, what would be super helpful is just to understand what an inflation cycle is. And so listeners can refer to page 2 of the chart deck. Here, we just have a thin line showing actual CPI inflation since the early '80s, so several decades. Then there's a thicker, just to make it easier to see, a thicker zigzag line.
Those segments show upturns, cyclical upturns and downturns in what is actually a cycle in inflation. This is a paradigm shift. It's a different vantage point. This is very different than your mainstream way of looking at inflation. In fact, when you look at it this way, you see that there are many more inflation cycles than business cycles.
Chart 3 of the chart deck makes that pretty evident because it juxtaposes business cycles, and I think people are familiar with business cycle shading, with inflation cycles.
And you see something else, which is kind of revealing once you see it, is that the vast majority of inflation cycles are unrelated to actual business cycle recessions. And if you let that sink in, it becomes pretty obvious why the Fed's reliance on the Phillips Curve has or had been so damaging. They've kind of been walking away from that recently.
So in fact, if your framework for thinking about inflation, where inflation is headed, is relying on the output gap or full employment, and most economists have long held that that's the way to look at it, our research, what I'm showing you here, reveals that you're going to get caught flat-footed and often looking the wrong way on inflation.
So a good case in point to really drive this home, because I want to make a strong point about what's
Lakshman Achuthan: going on today, but I think you need to understand a little bit of the history, is 4 years ago, just ahead of the last presidential election. Then on the flip side, in 2018.
In 2015, '16, some listeners will remember there was a global slowdown, and it hit the US and the industrial sector in particular, and our indicators caught all that. Following that global slowdown, there was this secular stagnation thesis. If you go back to whatever the research reports then everybody was talking about it.
Basically, the low growth and lowflation had cemented the narrative around inflation and the bond market and all of that. It really helped push 10-year yields down to a record low by the summer of '16. It was pretty extreme for the time. Of course, inflation expectations were really low back then too. But now, leading indicators of the inflation cycle, just the same way we have leading indicators of growth or recessions and stuff like that, separate leading indicators.
Once you know it's a separate cycle, you work on separate leading indicators. So we have something called the Future Inflation Gauge. That Future Inflation Gauge is a leading indicator of inflation, and it took off in '16. It foresaw the upturn, which was the opposite of the narrative in the markets, right? So as a result, that cyclical reflation really blindsided the markets. Around the 2016 election, our leading indicators of growth had been pointing to the strongest growth since 2010. So we had synchronized global growth, inflation moving higher. The impact was the mood of policymakers was ecstatic.
It was palpable. By mid-2017, they really were convinced, not only the Fed, ECB, other banks, they were really convinced that we had turned a corner in a structural sense. That's how far they talked themselves into this. They believed that the era of low trend growth and lowflation, all that secular stagnation, they believed it was over.
They didn't understand it was just a This is why it sets us up for these policy mistakes, basically. This is why the Fed kept hiking rates through the end of 2018, especially following the Trump tax cuts in '17. That all helped the bond bear market thesis take hold. If you remember summer of 2018, you had a lot of big shots, all the bond kings and queens and all were pounding the table. They were like, 4, 5, Even 6% 10-year Treasury yields. This is it. This is our big call.
And of course, we're sitting here looking at cycles. We're not following that thematic or event-driven narrative. We're just looking at the cycle indicators. And the FIG turned down in early 2018.
So again, based on our understanding of cycles, we were looking the other way. And by the summer, we're saying, whoa, there's an inflation cycle downturn. And the sequence of what unfolded there is really interesting, right? So the Future Inflation Gauge actually peaked in early '18. Inflation itself, actual inflation peaked in July of '18.
Bond yields, okay, they were slow on the uptake, but they got there. They started, they peaked out in in November of '18, and the Fed was the slowest of all, and they didn't pivot until January of '19. So, I mean, you can wait for the Fed or you could wait for bond yields, but I think in terms of risk management, cycle risk management, you can do better if you can let go of some of the output gap and all that kind of stuff and look at inflation cycles. I think that's the real kind of offering here.
Now, the Fed has said that it's just given up on the Phillips Curve, and they're not even going to try to be preemptive, really. They don't know how. So the bond market, it seems, is fully fixated on an event-driven view of inflation. It's like, okay, the Trump tax cuts cemented the confidence in the bond bear market in '18, Now, around the election, markets were betting on a blue wave delivering a big stimulus package, which would then push rates higher. Instead, we got a purple wave of sorts, and yields took a little step back very recently before the Pfizer vaccine came out. That's another event, and it boosted the yields back In other words, it's like the bond market is just at the mercy of the next big event. That seems to be all that's left of the analytical framework, because I don't think the markets, and I don't really think the Fed really understand— I know the Fed doesn't understand inflation cycles.
Erik Townsend: Lak, talk to me a little more about how we interpret this chart on page 4, where we see the US FIG, the Future Inflation Gauge. Okay, looks like it's back above 100 now. 100 was the 1992 baseline. I guess, you know, you could read this either a couple of ways. One way you could say is, okay, well, it's sloping up here clearly. This must mean more inflation is coming. We should be setting our portfolios up to hedge for more inflation coming. The other way to look at it would be to say, well, gee, if I look across the— what's shown here, which I guess is really just 2020, We're kind of coming back to a high point. Maybe it's peaking, maybe it's about to roll over. How do I interpret this? What does this mean in terms of what might be coming next?
Lakshman Achuthan: I like your initial interpretation. Be prepared for inflation to continue to surprise to the upside. As you said, on page 4, there's a picture of the Future Inflation Gauge. And what's interesting there, first and foremost, just to underscore That gauge is rising in a pronounced, pervasive, and persistent way, meaning that it is pointing to the cycle in inflation continuing to rise as far as we can see, which is a couple of quarters.
So actual inflation should continue to rise over that timeframe. And then we keep updating the Future Inflation Gauge to see if there's a risk developing on the horizon of a downturn a couple of quarters later. We don't see that today. You could see from the chart it's going to the upside.
Now, the other thing just to underscore is that view on inflation is pretty objective. It's not driven by any events. It originally wasn't driven by the election or the gaming of a stimulus package or a vaccine. None of that figures into this. What we're monitoring are cycle dynamics, which I think are actually more powerful than all of those, even though those are pretty colorful stories.
I think the actual cycle dynamic in inflation is stronger. Just observing again, the 10-year yield, as low as it was, has just about doubled off its March lows. So that's something. Now, inflation's going to keep rising in coming months, and the FIG will warn us when it's going to peak. What kind of gets interesting, right? Because I'm sitting here staring at that, I know, because I have a pretty high conviction having used these indicators for decades, that there's a very, very, very strong risk that inflation's going to keep surprising to the upside. So I'm thinking ahead and being like, Huh. All right. So the Fed has promised to do nothing, but if that FIG doesn't turn down, what's going to happen when PCE deflator— that's the target of the Fed's rough target— when that growth tops 2.5% or 3%?
If the FIG doesn't go down, that's going to happen at some point. And what's the Fed going to do? That's a real interesting moment. I think if the FIG is continuing to rise, then they're going to be between a rock and a hard place. They're going to start hemming and hawing all over the place.
I guess it's also possible that the FIG turns down. We're watching for that. I can't predict the predictors. But this, I think, is critical to your original interpretation. You should be prepared. Do not be surprised. by inflation rising more than expected over the next couple of quarters. And so to kind of take that inflation cycle risk and where is the cycle in growth going, they're both going to the upside.
It is a real cyclical reflation call that impacts nominal GDP. which certainly has a relationship with nominal yields. So I'd kind of wrap it up by saying, bottom line, if you manage risk based on the cyclical direction of growth and inflation, you don't have to be a predictor of where COVID is headed, or when is the vaccine actually out, or who won what election.
Or other events that are going to come on the radar screen.
Erik Townsend: I want to back up to page 3 and just talk about different timeframes here, because something you said a couple of times is these indicators are designed to look ahead maybe a couple of quarters. And as we can see here on page 3, you're talking really about cyclical patterns in inflation and in growth and in your other indicators that are tracking I want to talk about a different question or a different subject, which is, I see this, I can clearly see how it's very useful to have these separate indicators that are telling us where inflation is headed on a cyclical basis. But hang on, separate from the cyclical discussion, I've had a prediction I've been making for years, frankly, and I've always said, I don't know, it could be many years off. But at some point, I think that a secular, not cyclical, but secular shift toward much bigger inflation.
I'm talking 19th century inflation.
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: 1970s scale inflation and stagflation.
I think it's coming, and the reasons that I say that are, look, we've had this disinflationary backdrop for years and years. The Fed's been stimulating into it as much as they think they can get away with. Now all of a sudden we see the growing popularity of MMT among policymakers. At some point we're going to generate a whole lot of inflation, and I think that That it really is going to be a game changer in terms of limiting monetary policy choices once it takes hold. But I've also been the first to admit that, you know, I'm really convinced it's coming, but it could still be 3 or 4 years away.
How do I know when inflation starts taking off? You know, do I look at this chart and say, well, look, you haven't really gone above 3 or 4% in the last decade. Once it gets to 3%, that's the, that's the top of the range. That's when it's going to reverse. You want to start to be hedging your portfolio.
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: for disinflation at that point. When do I say, wait a minute, it's the secular shift, it's upon us, it's happening now?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, I think, look, on a very near-term tactical basis, look, I don't disagree with you, right? And in our past, we've talked many, many times, Erik. And so in one of our earlier discussions, we talked about the long-term decline in trend growth, the lowflation, and how the only policy response there has been lowering rates or QE or all this stuff to undermine the currencies and to push out debt, and debt fuels growth and all that stuff, and trying to get bubbles and how that zombifies stuff. We've had all that discussion, right? Now, this COVID recession has taken something that might have taken another 4 or 5 years for us to get to in terms of monetary policy and scrunched it into a couple a few months, right?
And where do we go from here? There's this lack of policy alternatives, right? So it's a little noteworthy that there's more and more talk about central bank digital currencies and what other tools are they going to develop in coming years to try and goose the economy here and there if the fiscal side's not really functioning.
And so I don't know exactly where they're going to go with that and how long it'll take to get there, but it seems like the policy response is very much centered on the central banks and messing around with debt and liquidity and possibly currencies. So currency volatility is probably in our future in the broadest sense.
As to which exact scenario is going to win out, I can't make a strong conviction bet, but the Future Inflation Gauge, the cycle information is a useful tool. If you hold a longer-term view. Either, let's say for the other half of the people who are out there on the other side of the trade saying deflation, because there's a strong argument that some people are making for deflation or disinflation as a result of all this. And then you, and I sympathize with that, are talking to the upside.
The question is when? And the Future Inflation Gauge can tell us when. So I, earlier in my comments, was saying, hey, what is the Fed going to do when the PCE deflator gets to 2.5% or 3%? If the FIG is still rising, that's an interesting moment, but that could signal, hey, maybe we're breaking out of that 3% top in the inflation range. Maybe something is afoot at that When listeners are looking at chart 3, they'll see the inflation cycle upturn that in '16 through '18 tricked the bond market and the Fed into believing that that was the time that you had the secular shift, that the higher— the secular, longer-term persistent inflation was upon us.
In fact, it turned out it wasn't, and the FIG warned us. of that at that moment. So I can't exactly bet on which is the secular timing when something's going to switch, but I could say that the FIG will help us pay attention around the right time. But you should probably have a plan. You should probably have a plan.
Erik Townsend: So it sounds like the plan is you watch the actual CPI print, and when it gets back to 3%, which has kind of been the ceiling for a decade, really since the '08 crisis. When it gets to 3%, you look at the FIG, and if the FIG's starting to turn down, it's like, hey baby, just another cycle. It's all ups and downs, the waves on the ocean. When the FIG's pointing straight up and you're already at 3% in US CPI on the official print, Houston, we have a problem. It's time to rethink everything.
Lakshman Achuthan: Yeah. And my guess is the Fed heads will start talking. around when you get to the mid-2s, right? When you get to 2.5 or so, if the FIG's still rising, they're going to start talking about this or that. And they're a little bit in a pickle because they've highlighted employment as a key marker, which is, in the end of the day, it's a variation on the Phillips Curve, but they're talking about more equality in employment and all of this. And because Because many of the lower-income jobs tend to be in that front-facing services sector, which is having a slow recovery, and many businesses are actually failing there, that jobs recovery may be pretty slow.
So the Fed has said, here's what I'm going to watch, and inflation may not cooperate with them. And it'll be revealing to see what is their reaction function. It seems to me, and I don't know anybody really at the Fed, a couple of people, but it's not like back when Dr. Moore was around. He was Greenspan's teacher.
It seems to me that everybody's event-driven. That's the state of inflation analysis. If you find that frustrating, then you go to the bigger picture and you say, whoa, that's a lot of debt. And that's a lot of stimulus. And this has to matter at some point. And I don't disagree.
But the question is when. I remember I picked up once at— you go to these library summer fairs and they have the books for 50 cents or a dollar. And there was some book, I think it was The Coming Currency Collapse, but it was from the '70s. And it was a well-argued book. I mean, I must say, but what I really enjoyed enjoyed was in the back of it was a summary of the Chinese dynasties where they had been at the forefront, at the vanguard of paper money.
They had a lot of fun with it. These dynasties would eventually collapse when the currency collapsed, when the paper debt collapsed, but it could take generations in some cases. That was kind of
Erik Townsend: Lak, final question.
Erik Townsend: Clearly, we're having some kind of, at least as we're speaking on Wednesday, there's some kind of pop in the markets in the last couple of days to the upside, apparently in reaction to some combination of the vaccine news and what most people consider to be an outcome of the election. Although frankly, it's not official yet. It seems like it's pretty clear that most people think Biden's has won the election.
What's driving it, and what does cycles work tell us about, you know, does this thing have legs? Is it time to jump in here before it gets away, or is it maybe a head fake?
Lakshman Achuthan: Well, you know, certainly the day-to-day stuff, I think you could point to the headlines, you know, that the election, you know, has kind of unfolded. The world didn't stop running. You know, we're still here. Hey, there's also a vaccine. These are positives given some of the fears that were out there. But I would posit that if you had the view that, hey, there's a business cycle upturn, a growth rate cycle upturn that is not decelerating, it's still moving to the upside, and there's an inflation cycle upturn that barring some massive catastrophe, you'd have to be embracing risk.
That story hasn't changed as a result of the last couple of weeks, as dramatic as things have been. That fundamental cycle risk analysis is the same today as it was a couple of weeks ago.
When I look forward, I would say it's not unlike late '16 into '17, because we have, for the most part, there's a couple of spots here and there, but I'd say generally speaking, in the US and around the world, growth is to the upside, On the upside, inflation is stronger, in a stronger upturn in the US than it is in some other countries. But around the world, it is bottoming. Those same types of inflation cycles are bottoming. So this is a variation or a rhyming version of the reflation cycle upturn that we had back in '16, '17. And of course, that was a pretty strong one.
I don't see anything that in our current snapshot today, looking at the indicators, suggest there's risk of a downturn anywhere. I think the thing to look for is certainly if the leading indicators were to turn down, that Future Inflation Gauge on page 4 or the Weekly Leading Index on page 1 of the handout. And then what happens with the Fed if inflation starts bumping near into their discomfort zone. How do they deal with that?
Erik Townsend: Finally, before I let you go, for people who do want to follow these indicators, about half of our audience is institutional. What are the products on offer for them, for people that want to follow your research? We also have about half of our audience are sophisticated high-net-worth individuals and other private investors. Is there a high-end retail product or is it strictly institutional?
Lakshman Achuthan: I'm afraid it's strictly institutional. It's not that I wouldn't want to talk to high-end net worth individuals, but I just don't have enough time. There's a lot of nuance in some of these indicators. We have about 100 indicators for the world, about probably 20 of them for the US, for all these different nooks and crannies of the cycle.
We put out reports and data, and that's an institutional arrangement. We do make a valiant effort to share what we can publicly. And I do that at businesscycle.com is the website. I think Business Cycle is the Twitter feed. And there's ECRI or Business Cycle or Lakshman Achuthan on LinkedIn. And when we're writing stories or doing things, or even like this interview with you, Erik, at some point that'll go up into that feed too. So we try to We try to keep that feed very active for people who aren't institutional investors, but want to manage their cycle risk.
Erik Townsend: Okay. So businesscycle.com is the place to go for non-institutional, basically free stuff for the non-institutional audience. For the institutional audience, how do they contact you to find out more about your services?
Lakshman Achuthan: They can contact Melinda, melinda@businesscycle.com, and she will give you all the information.
Erik Townsend: Lak, we look forward to getting you back on the show in 6 months or so for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Uranium, the fuel for nuclear power, is a contrarian investment whose returns are historically uncorrelated to other asset classes.
Low uranium prices lasted for many years after the Fukushima meltdown, leading to substantial supply destruction. At today's prices, uranium mining is uneconomical even for the world's lowest-cost producers. Uranium demand is already estimated to exceed existing supply, and future demand growth is expected. New mines aren't economically viable at today's prices, leading analysts to Predict that the price of uranium may need to double to over $60 per pound to incentivize sufficient new mine supply to meet expected demand. The NYSE-listed North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, offers investors exposure to both miners and holders of uranium. For more information, visit urnmetf.com.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Lak back on the show. One of the things that he keeps emphasizing, which I think is so incredibly important, is that the inflation cycle is not directly correlated to the business cycle, or they can diverge at least. And one— that's one thing that I didn't think at the beginning of my career, and only later did I actually start to realize that. And it's so important when he says it to emphasize that the two can really act on their own. What did you take away from the interview?
Erik Townsend: That's a really great point, Patrick, that keeping those cycles separate in your head is important. You know, this is just maybe the, the interview that was the straw that broke the camel's back for me. There's so many smart people we've had on, and to summarize many of our feature interview guests in the last few months, the consensus is pretty darn clear, which is we're going to see a return to secular inflation. And whether that happens in 3 months or 3 years, nobody's smart enough to know. I mean, you know, let's look at how long it's been since we really had secular inflation in the 1970s. And it was what, early '81, '82 or so that we finally broke out of with Paul Volcker's monetary sledgehammer approach to the market. We're headed back to some kind of secular inflation trend. I'm sure of it. And MMT, I think, will help us get there. Do we get there in 3 months or 3 years?
I don't know. If it's a 35-year cycle, being wrong by 3 years is still only 10% on a timescale measure. So, I don't know when it happens, but I think it's time to start planning that if this bond bull market isn't already over, that it's going to be really soon. And the next big trend is going to be inflation and a resumption of an uptrend in yields to replace the downtrend in yields that we've seen for what, 35 years now?
Erik Townsend: But Patrick, what I can predict in the short term is our postgame chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email. Just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, click the red button that says looking for the downloads. S&P futures, page 2. Boy, Patrick, look at that candle with the red circle around it where we had the vaccine news.
Patrick Ceresna: That's for sure. Like, I actually want to look beyond this in a moment. It really— I just wanted to give us a reference point, but it was one big breakout attempt on the S&P 500 that was almost immediately sold into And we haven't really begun any meaningful market correction, at least not yet, because I mean, a correction would have us already back down toward 3,400, and we're just not seeing that yet.
So, you know, I don't want to already imply anything bearish, but certainly one of the things that I would've been looking for from a news event like this is whether or not it would trigger a feedback loop of buying, and that would cause this market to just keep being up every single day, very similar to what we saw in the summer in 2020.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: August, and we're just not seeing that yet.
And so it will be really interesting to see how it plays out.
But really what I want to talk about is on page three, which is where we have the Russell versus the Nasdaq. And this is one of the most fascinating things that happened on the vaccine news, which is essentially this idea that the economy could recover and certainly could spur inflation risks and all sorts of different variables. And what's interesting is is that when we're looking on the left-hand side. Side, we can see that the NASDAQ on that news almost immediately started to sell while the Russell went screaming higher. And literally they went in opposite directions. And I thought that was quite significant that that was playing out that way. And we still have since that news event that the NASDAQ is more or less underwater from— at least it's not up since the news event. And the Russell though has been holding up. And that asks that question on the right-hand side: have we seen that trend shift that's been in place for years?
For years, we've had a material outperformance of the NASDAQ and the FAANG stocks over that of the small-cap Russell. And it's not just been a 2020 event in this, you know, coronavirus period. We've seen that trend in place for many, many years. And there inevitably was going to come a point where that trend was going to shift and small caps and international stocks may start to outperform. Now, one day or one week doesn't make a new trend, but technically we've had a substantial basing throughout much of this year on the Russell over the NASDAQ chart. And it's just an interesting question to ask as to whether or not this is the beginning of a breakout here.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it seems like that underperformance is on the NASDAQ, which I assume is mostly being driven by the FANG+ stocks. Let's look at page 4 where you've got the FANG+ index. You know, this seems to me like sideways consolidation, didn't get the, the new all-time high test like we saw on the S&P. What do you interpret out of this chart?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's see, I would even go and look underneath the surface. While I don't have the charts up here, what is interesting is substantial breakdowns in the last week or two on every Everything from Facebook to Amazon to Netflix. Microsoft has been somewhat weak. Twitter has broken down a lot. The only one of the FAANG stocks that actually continues to have a very clean trend and positive price action has to be Google, and that's like the last one of the FAANG stocks standing from in terms of that.
And so really, this is something I'm watching because really we've seen this period where this index. Was the leadership. And it's gonna be really interesting to see whether that baton is passed and whether other parts of the market start to outperform. And even if this does, this doesn't, sector doesn't have to necessarily crash, but will it underperform and will that not be where the money is flowing is one of the more interesting things to kind of find out in the
Patrick Ceresna: coming weeks as we see how this develops into the new year.
So what I wanted to though move on here is to page 5 where we have the Euro Stoxx. And what's fascinating here is that even before the vaccine news came out, but the vaccine news gave it an extra boost, we have just seen a huge rip higher in the Euro Stoxx, up 20% in just 2 weeks.
It's just been screaming higher, but more importantly, it has now exceeded all of the summer highs. One of the characteristics that we've seen in the Euro Stoxx was that it was just dragging. And while the US equities equity markets kept plugging higher and higher, the Euro Stoxx was just dead money and just couldn't get off of the mat.
And with this big rally higher, the question is, are we seeing a shift where global developed markets can actually outperform the US equity markets? Maybe that's correlated to the Russell as well. And what we can see if we go to page 6 was where the Japanese Nikkei as well in the last 2 weeks has just had an extraordinary breakout, finally breaking out of those January, February highs and just doing so with a great momentum. And it's gonna be really interesting to see whether or not these international markets can actually continue to outperform in the coming weeks.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, let's move on to crude oil here. And so we're looking at the December contract, and one of the interesting things is how strong this recovery has been in the last 2 weeks off that low. At the late October, early November, we were establishing low down in the Fibonacci zones around the 34 handle. And since then, we go screaming higher, consolidating well above those highs of September and October.
And it's just a— what a quick flip. And it really asks the question, was this a meaningful shift in the oil markets? And how does this play out from here? What's your take on this?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's really, really interesting because if I look at what I see on this chart, it really It really does look like the long-awaited breakout is perhaps finally starting. I've been saying all summer long that I thought basically, okay, we had that really big move up off of the April lows, then we've been consolidating. And I really think at some point we're gonna see another significant move up to sustain prices above $50 a barrel. And eventually, not immediately, but I'd say by the end of 2024, I wouldn't be surprised if we're in the $75-plus range. And the reason is we will have destroyed so much supply capacity. And when demand comes back— and it's certainly not right now, but eventually, you know, there really is going to be a resolution to the pandemic and the economy will be reopened and travel will be happening again— when all those things happen, we're not going to be able to produce the oil that we need to keep up with it.
And prices are going through through the roof. And I thought, okay, maybe finally the market is starting to sniff this out.
But if I look at the news flow, what really is happening, regardless of the Pfizer vaccine news, which frankly is mostly hype and hoopla as far as I'm concerned, the real news here is we've got a parabolic rise in both new cases, new infections, and in deaths. And at the same time, we've also got this mink strain news, which could have very negative consequences in terms of prolonging the COVID-19 crisis longer than anybody expected. So I would have expected this news flow to give us one last test of the, the bottom of the lows, and we're seeing a test of the high end of the range instead. It really doesn't make sense to me. Maybe it's just time that this rally is ready to move on in anticipation of that decline in US production capability. that Art Berman is still projecting at the end of this quarter and into next year.
It's hard to say. I really am surprised that we're seeing this much strength on this particular news flow right now.
Patrick Ceresna: You know, one of the things I'm gonna be watching is actually how well the bulls defend it, right? 'Cause if we find that by Monday or Tuesday crude oil's back below $38, then it could make it that just like how we saw in the stock market, it could have just been everyone getting a little too excited too quick.
Quickly, and then some smart money comes in there and starts to distribute into it. But if we see that the price action holds up in the 40s and really consolidates up here, that would demonstrate that it's not only got up to this price levels, but it's actually being well defended up here. And that would be something that would be very impressive by next week when we're doing the show if we saw prices hold up there.
What I wanted to touch on on page 8 was touching on the energy equities, and so here I have the SPDR Energy ETF, which is the symbol XLE. And those energy stocks had a 20% update, just went screaming higher. And what's interesting about this is that the energy stocks in many ways were throughout the summer predicting that oil was going to stay weak in a sense that they were very well distributed. Distributed. There was no follow-through to any rallies, and they just kept selling and selling even though oil was holding up. And what's interesting here is that we, for the first time, we've seen this space come to life. And I'm going to be very curious to see whether this is an indication that equity investors in this space are actually seeing a light at the end of the tunnel and starting to accumulate the space. A few days don't make a new I don't want to get overexcited too quickly, but it is certainly something that's important to watch.
Patrick Ceresna: So Erik, moving on, I want to just touch on uranium briefly. What is interesting is that after several months of consolidation— here I have the chart of the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF the URNM— and what's interesting is that we're seeing some breakout attempts on the upside after some consolidation. What will be really interesting to see is whether or not this buying follows through north of $30. And that's Something I think we're gonna keep a close eye on going into next week.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I bought both URNM and YCA after the uranium show that we did a few weeks ago. URNM is doing much better than YCA is to the upside, so it seems to be working pretty well.
But I saw also, and I don't have much detail on this, we'll try to get more for you next week, but I think one of the things that we lamented on, on that show is how ridiculous is it that the United States doesn't have some kind of strategic reserve for uranium to, you know, to keep uranium on hand so that we could supply our nuclear power industry if the global supply chains were ever cut off due to political crisis? It sounds like there's now a budget from the Senate that's been proposed. I don't know whether this is a done deal or just somebody's proposal, but maybe they're listening to MacroVoices. I don't know. It sounds like maybe they're going to create a strategic uranium reserve similar to the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Certainly, I think it's overdue. We'll try to get more information on that before next week's show.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to page 10. And I just wanted to illustrate that support line on gold that we've approached. I mean, in that one fluid motion on that reaction earlier, this week, we came right back to those September, October lows. And this is such a critical moment because in my mind, if gold can't recover back to, let's say, $1,920 in the coming week, uh, and the price action stays down here, it's like a little bit of an edge of a, uh, of a cliff. And if we see that price action breaking below there, then this consolidation may head down south of $1,800. Now, I'm not in any way big picture bearish, and that probably would lead to a buying opportunity if it did. But watching how it reacts along the support line is definitely one of the key things to watch this week.
Erik Townsend: Well, and the fascinating thing to me, Patrick, these are daily bars, but if you were to zoom in and look at that huge red bar on Monday, most of that happened in very, very short order on the Pfizer vaccine. news. And you would think that as the stock market retraced most of its knee-jerk reaction, that the gold market would have retraced too. But gold went down and stayed down. And I'm hopeful that we will get a deeper correction. I'd love to have a chance to buy some more. A couple of technical levels that I'm watching are the 200-day moving average, which is at $1,798.50 right now, moving higher every There's also another technical level at about 1,757, which was the daily R2 resistance level. We'll see what happens here, but it's very, very curious to me that the tape action is what it is here, and the reaction to the same news event is completely different in the stock market.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so the last chart I wanted to touch on is just looking at the US high-yield credit spreads. And one of the most interesting things that's going on is that we continue to see yields rising on US government bonds. So Treasury bonds are very, very weak. And we've also on investment-grade corporate bonds seen highs all the way back in July and August. And generally they've been treading water since.
But when we go to junk bonds and all our high-yield bonds, they're making multi-month highs and pushed higher, obviously with some correlation to the equity markets and this idea that there could be a recovery. But this has pushed the spread down toward 400 basis points. And so this junk bond market is not at all pricing in the fact that there's got to be some wave of defaults coming from this coronavirus. And even if the Fed is buying it, at what point do you price in that the Fed can't stop companies from having some rise in defaults? And I ask the question, is this being priced in or Or is this mispriced? And I tend to be in the camp thinking that this is mispriced. And considering that we are already seeing weakness broadly in the bond markets, it'll be really interesting to see where this starts to turn.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I mean, it's a whole new world that we live in, Patrick. It used to be that you looked at default risk objectively and that affected price. And now price maybe is affected by default risk, But probably to a greater extent, the expectation is the Fed has already bought junk bonds and will probably buy more and will probably not be that concerned about those default rates. And it might even be buying them in reaction to those defaults that you're talking about coming in order to defend or save the market from capitalism actually happening the way it's supposed to.
So it's— I don't know. I don't know what's coming next, but in this world that we live in, I think anything is possible.
Erik Townsend: Folks, don't forget that Patrick does webinars 4 days a week with all of these great chart decks. You can get a free trial of his service, Big Picture Trading. Information for signing up is on page 12. We're going to leave it there for this week's show. This episode was made possible by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium.
And by Masterworks.io, which gives investors of any size the opportunity to invest in the $1.7 trillion fine art market through fractional ownership. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to Lak's slides and the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to a Jesse Felder article that this is the textbook definition of late cycle in the stock market, and a link to an article discussing Blessing that good news could actually lose you money. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com.
Or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week. Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com the internet's premier source of online education. For traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by Sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Marin Katusa — Natural resources investing guru (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 244 was recorded on November 5th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by the Perth Mint, one of the world's largest precious metals enterprises and the leading provider of trusted gold investment products, including their latest offering, GoldPass, and by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium. Natural resources investing guru Marin Katusa returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from MMT and how it will drive a secular bull market in precious metals, to why some of the best mining companies are only listed on Canadian exchanges, to how to allocate a precious metals portfolio to benefit from all of these trends.
Exactly as we predicted months ago here on MacroVoices, the US presidential election outcome is But now I want you to ask yourself a question. Just how contested could this thing get? And how much of a mess could this turn into for both the United States as a country and for financial markets before it's over? I've done a bit of research this week on the mechanics of the Electoral College system, and quite frankly, it's worse than I thought. So be sure to stay tuned after the feature interview for our post-game segment, when we'll take a deep dive on the Electoral College and specifically what happens next and what can still go wrong between now and Inauguration Day. We'll also have a post-game chart deck to discuss some post-election macro trends in the market.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's get to that S&P 500. In the post-election period, we've pretty much undid all of the selling and are pretty much back to October highs here. What's your take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, remember what I said last week and the week before, which is I thought we were looking at a setup for a sharp rise in stock prices once the election was behind us and the outcome was reasonably clear. And I think it was certain that there would be some degree of contested election. We don't have total mayhem breaking out in the streets. It hasn't gone crazy at this point. And I think that what you're seeing right now, frankly, is a little bit of excessive complacency. I think just about everybody in the United States has been given the same message, which is The guy that you voted for won. And yeah, the other side is trying to steal the election, but we're not gonna let 'em get away with it.
Half of those people need to be disappointed sooner or later and find out that their guy didn't win, or maybe did win, but isn't gonna be allowed to take office or something. And I think that's where it gets a little bit uglier. So I think that we're in a false sense of certainty that's leading the stock market to recover because everybody's assuming, okay, if it's not final results yet, but it'll be finalized in the next day or two, and then we'll be able to move on. I don't think it's going to be finalized in the next day or two. Of course, I could be wrong, but I think there's plenty of room for more volatility, particularly downside volatility, if we discover that this thing's not over quite as quickly as a lot of people think it's going to be over. We'll get into that in more detail in our postgame segment. Meanwhile, we have new news breaking today on the pandemic front.
Danish researchers have discovered a new strain of coronavirus. It's basically in a mink farm, and so this is human to mink and back to human transmission. The salient point here is this new mutation of the SARS-CoV-2 virus appears to be non-responsive to all of the vaccines that are presently under development. So the consequence of that, if it is proven true, would be that potentially This new strain of coronavirus, the vaccines that are currently under development might be effective against prior strains, but not against this new mutated strain.
And that's very consistent with what we've discussed on MacroVoices in previous shows, where I've said, look, everybody's assuming the vaccine is just around the corner. There's never been a successful RNA virus vaccine in human beings ever before. There's no reason to assume that it's going to come easily this time. So this virus is mutating quickly, and it may be that this new mutation is going to present a new set of challenges. Now, does that mean prolongation of existing lockdowns and new lockdowns and so forth?
I don't really think it's likely to go that way.
I'm gonna make a new prediction with respect not only to this current medical discovery, but the overall situation with the COVID-19 crisis. I think we're headed toward a situation where you're gonna see the same kind of division in society that we see politically in the United States spreading globally, and it's going to be The crowd of people that on one side is saying, look, this is a horrible plague, a pandemic, we've gotta take it seriously, we've gotta go back into lockdown, we've gotta do everything that we can to save as many people as possible. And there'll be an opposite faction that says, look, we've already shut down the economy unnecessarily, it's not that big of a deal, just let it burn through, stop trying to fight it, life has to move on. And I think that will lead to civil unrest between disagreeing factions of people in society who hold different views about how governments should respond to the evolving SARS-CoV-2 COVID-19 crisis.
I hope I'm wrong about that, but I think that may be where it's headed. At this point, this new news about the new mutation, the mink virus, if you will, it's too new at this point to know whether it's a really serious big deal or not. We'll find that out in coming days. Hopefully we'll have more news for you next week.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to that US dollar because the US dollar's been so weak in the post-election period. We're back down toward the August and September lows. Do you think the US dollar downtrend resumes from here?
Erik Townsend: I do think it resumes. And remember, even though I've been bullish in prior weeks, I said last week, look, don't interpret the strength we were seeing last week as a new uptrend. It's just the opposite side of liquidation flows that were occurring. Now what we're seeing is the reverse. People that were selling stocks and bonds and gold all at once last week that are doing the opposite and they're buying them and they're selling dollars in order to do that. And that's resulting in dollar down. I think that if my fears prove right and the election result stays, let's say, less clear for longer, lower for longer, I don't know what to call that. If it takes longer than most people are assuming to sort out this election result, I think the dollar could move significantly to the downside in the weeks and months ahead.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because we got a pretty heavy breakdown hitting that $34 handle and then it snapped back. We're almost back towards $40. We're $38.66 on the December contract as we are recording. What's your take on the crude oil markets here?
Erik Townsend: Well, the coronavirus situation is still weighing on the market. The thing is that, and I think Libyan production coming back online also helped to push prices down. We had, I think, a $33 handle on WTI just very briefly intraday. Russia's statement that they were ready to support an OPEC+ extension of production cuts was what turned the market around. So this Russia/OPEC+/Saudi Arabia political theater or jawboning theater, whatever you want to call it, it's going to continue as it always seems to continue. But frankly, in the long run, I think the coronavirus trend and more importantly, the election and political sentiment around whether or not the right response to the coronavirus, if it is worsening infections, as clearly seems to be the case in the data. Does that mean governments should lock down again, as they're already doing in the UK? Or does that mean that they should just let it burn through, as some people have argued for? And who's gonna be in power?
And certainly with Biden saying one thing and Trump saying the opposite, the US election is going to weigh on that significantly. So I think the coronavirus trend and And what happens to demand as a result of whether or not more lockdowns in our future are ultimately going to be more important than whatever the latest jawbone statement is from Russia, OPEC, or Saudi Arabia.
Meanwhile, inventory this week, big unexpected drawdown on crude oil inventories of 8 million barrels. Now, Art Berman pointed out on Twitter, a lot of that was unaccounted for oil. So it may be a little bit of a reporting anomaly as opposed to that big of an unexpected drawdown really happening. And that's That certainly is supported by Cushing, Oklahoma showing a build of 936,000 barrels this week. Gasoline building 1.5 million barrels. Distillates was the drawdown on the board of 1.6 million barrels, but not nearly as big as those 4 million-plus drawdowns that we've been seeing in recent weeks. US production back down by 600,000 barrels, erasing half exactly of last week's 1.2 million barrel increase. I think what's going on here is we're just seeing the reporting and the accounting for this data to stabilize a little bit after the tropical storms, right about where it should be at 10.5 million barrels of US production reported this week. I don't think that we're yet seeing that big decline in US production that Art Berman said to expect toward the end of the 4th quarter.
Looks like we're stabilizing about where we should be.
Tape action after inventory. This bullish news with the drawdown got us above the 13-day moving average, managed to hold above it for the last day and a half or so as we're At the time of recording on Thursday afternoon, we're teetering just about 2 or 3 cents above the 38.61 13-day moving average, which is the highest of the 3 short-term moving averages. Generally speaking, closing prints above that level— and we did close above it today on Thursday— generally indicate a new uptrend, but we really haven't seen it close significantly above that level. So next few days will be telling.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: I wouldn't be surprised if there's another big move down in oil coming once we figure out that the election result is not really about to be determined in the next day or two. And particularly if we discover that the coronavirus is going to be complicated by a new strain, which is resistant to vaccines.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to gold because we are breaking out of a 6-week trade range. Gold looks very bullish here. Is this the beginning of a new uptrend?
Erik Townsend: Well, of course, our prediction here was— I said that if you had an uncontested election, a clear win by either party, that was going to be gold down. If you had a contested election, I predicted that would be gold up. That's exactly what we're getting now. So far, we've got a very impressive little rally in gold, but I mean, it's not new all-time highs or anything like that. I think that we could be headed toward a situation where this contested election gets a lot more contested before it's over. We'll come back to that subject in the postgame segment after the feature interview, but the point really with respect to gold is if that happens, I think it's definitely a catalyst to take gold much higher. Right now what we're seeing is a rally based on this uncertainty. I suppose that if one side conceded and said, okay, you know, never mind, we'll let the other guy win and wish him well, then I think gold would would tank on that news.
Frankly, I don't think it's going to happen.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's touch on these 10-year Treasury yields. With that split government, the market got spooked and the short sellers in the bond markets got squeezed. We had a pretty big drop in the yields. We're now trading down at the 77 basis point handle. What's your take on Treasury bonds here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, last week they were selling stocks, bonds, and gold all at once. It seems like this week they're buying stocks, bonds, and gold all at once. So I think what we're seeing is a reversal of last week's trade. And again, I don't think the contested election volatility is over yet. We'll talk more about that in postgame.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is natural resource investor Marin Katusa. Now, Erik, why did we invite Marin back to the show this week?
Erik Townsend: Well, clearly, regardless of who ultimately is president, we're going to get a lot more stimulus, a lot more debasement of fiat currency, not just by the United States Federal Reserve, but by central banks around the world. We heard, you know, the MMT argument from Stephanie Kelton a couple of weeks ago.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And I just look at what am I investing in? What am I focusing my attention on? Well, what's the smartest way to increase my allocation to precious metals when from a location standpoint, it's kind of hard to add a lot of leverage on the gold itself? I'm looking at miners. I'm looking particularly at private placements and new gold mining companies where you get a little bit of leverage beyond just the gold price. Marin is the guy that I rely on, frankly, for private placement opportunities.
And I'm I have become a big fan of his newsletter. So I wanted to get Marin back on to talk to us about this precious metals bull market, about MMT, and reactions that we've gotten from our audience to that interview, and just see what his take is on this and how we should play this gold bull market.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Marin Katusa is coming up as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Financial markets are facing unprecedented uncertainty, driving investors to gold as a trusted store of wealth. For a simple, secure, and easy way to trade or invest, consider GoldPass, the Perth Mint's market-leading precious metals app. GoldPass allows investors to buy, sell, redeem, and transfer precious metals 24 hours a day at the touch of a screen. Trade as little or as much as you want with no storage fees. With live gold prices, research, and interactive charting to help you decide when to trade, you can get started for as little as $1 worth of gold. Each digital certificate is 100% backed by physical Perth Mint gold stored in Western Australia, one of the safest jurisdictions in the world, and all assets traded by GoldPass carry a government guarantee. This means you can redeem your GoldPass holdings for bullion at any time and have your gold delivered direct to your door.
Build your wealth with GoldPass today. Download the app in the Apple or Android store or visit perthmint.com/goldpass.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Katusa Research founder Marin Katusa. Marin, it's great to get you back on the show. It's been too long. You know, I just had Professor Stephanie Kelton on a couple of weeks ago, and it blew my mind. We've had more reaction to that interview than anything we've ever done on MacroVoices. And what surprised me was people are angry at me. The Sound Money crowd is upset. They're like, you had the traitor on your show, you know, you've defected. And I'm trying to tell these guys, look, I'm not endorsing this. I'm telling you, you got to get ready for what's coming, like it or not. Stephanie Kelton has really one of the most influential voices in public policy and finance right now. How do you see this? How should gold investors be thinking about MMT? Does it make sense to dismiss it or should we take it seriously?
Marin Katusa: Look, Erik, I think anyone who's dismissing it is absolutely overlooking the biggest framework being applied, not just in the US, but there's about 65 countries in the world that have independent monetary and fiscal policy. That means that They can actually apply MMT. There's 192 countries in the world or somewhere around there.
You're looking at, this is the new framework. We've gone from the Austrian world of the gold standard, which, look, I am one of the largest players in the gold field, in the gold sector for financings, so I have even more pushback than you. When I talked about the swap lines, all these guys are like, what are you talking about, Marin? They still want to play by the gold standard rulebook. That's just— no longer the framework. Specifically, if the Dems do take the US election here, which right now it's tilted in their favor, Stephanie and her crew, like Warren's one of her mentors, these are highly influential people, but more importantly, not to the old crew of the Hillary or the Biden or Bernie Sanders.
They're still also somewhat stuck on the old rules playbook. When Bernie Sanders said, we'll give Medicare to everyone for free, Hillary responded with, you know, well, how are you going to do that? You know, how are you going to pay for it? Well, the next generation of the left, they're not going to ask those questions because, you know, under MMT, taxes are not how you fund the government program like you do in Austrian economics or early Keynesian economics. Taxes are 2 things. They create a domestic demand for the currency, which the government is the creator and issuer of. And think of it as a tap. It controls the tap on the inflation within the sector. That's what taxes are about in the MMT framework.
So for all the gold guys out there, I am a gold guy. But you have to understand that MMT is not going to be a short-term— like how QE just popped up to be a Band-Aid solution. I truly believe MMT is not just here for a year or 2 or 5. I think it's going to be decades of MMT.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: And look at Japan.
They've been doing it for almost 30 years and they've not been able to get the inflation going. So the demographics and all these factors, I think what Stephanie Kelton is doing needs to be specifically understood. This isn't even taught in universities yet. It's a real-time experiment and it's happening now, Erik.
Erik Townsend: I really want to ask you, because you're a dyed-in-the-wool Gold guy, and, and this is the part that a lot of listeners really push back on me on. What I said is I think that when they do this, it will be perceived as fabulously successful for the first several years. And a lot of people got very upset with that, said you're crazy, it's going to blow up the system, it'll never work.
How do you see this? Because I think that it's going to have the appearance of working just fine for a while. Eventually it will lead to serious problems, but at first It's going to appear to be a success, and that means it feeds on itself, and they're going to spend and spend and spend. And it seems to me, as you say, that the key to this— if you don't have to tax anybody to spend, they're going to spend like there's no tomorrow. And it seems to me that the debasement of all fiat currencies, not just the US dollar, but all global fiat currencies, is headed into a new phase of acceleration, which has to be good for gold.
Am I missing anything?
Marin Katusa: Well, what I would add— first of all, I'm with you on this. Second of all, as the euro goes digital, think of it— people forget that it was the US that held onto the gold standard 40 years longer than Canada or the UK or Germany or Russia or China or Japan.
It was the last— Switzerland is a different story, but I mean the nations that That had a big military and large economy. On that basis, I also believe that the US dollar will probably be one of the last major currencies to go digital. In that shift, as you go digital, gold will be even more dominant as an off-digital currency. Cash is going to be pushed out, but gold will still be even more— With that, you're going to have a few of the cryptos and you're going to have the government cryptos, like you're an expert in that.
your book. And when you came to my conference, we really tried to explain that to people. But yeah, look, at the end of the day, you're looking at gold. And more specifically, where are they finding gold, Erik? People forget that you look at the last 30 years of gold exploration, over 2/3 of the exploration dollars have been in the last decade, but they found less than 10% of the gold in the last decade versus the last 30 years. And more importantly, where are they finding the gold? They're not finding big world-class tier 1 deposits like they were 30 years ago. And the time to develop these is getting ever longer. And more importantly is in what jurisdictions, the political risk. Look, in the last 60 days, you've had over 15 nations increase taxes, royalties, ownership structures on foreign-owned developed mines. That trend is going to continue. And the governments around the world— I know this is going to piss off a lot of our viewers in this, But the US dollar still is the currency of choice.
For all those people who are saying, well, the yuan is going to dump— the Chinese are going to dump their dollars and the Treasuries, that's not how it works. It's not like they're going to go to the Fed and go, give me my $2 trillion back. That's not— it's digits on a ledger. And Erik, most importantly, they can't go and use those US dollars to buy oil from Iran. You have your sanctions list. And they can't convert it to gold, the Chinese. So that whole concept that they're going to dump it into the market is ridiculous.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: Ridiculous. And why would they do that when they're pegged to this currency?
So there's a whole issue there. But look what happened with the Ant IPO. Jack Ma got a little bit aggressive and made some comments about the banks in China, and boom, they pulled the IPO. Now, what is the real reason? Who knows? But the point is, is why would you want to be investing in a regime that can change on a 180 dime based off of some comments?
So at the end of the day, as bad as the US dollar is, It's still better than the others. And slowly, gold will be much more attractive to non-US individuals. And this is something you and I talked about a couple of years ago. If you're in Turkey or Argentina or Yugoslavia when it was still around, or look at Russia or any of the stans, your devaluation, if you had some gold, it was the ultimate inflation hedge. Americans aren't thinking that way yet, but the rest of the world is.
Erik Townsend: Here's the thing I really don't understand. I'm reading the work of some people that have been around the gold industry for a long, long time, and they're saying, you know, you got to understand, this bull market is a bull market, but it's pretty well developed now. The price of gold has just about bottomed from that, that low that it hit a few years ago up to the recent peak. It's just about doubled. And people are saying, you know, this is a great bull market, but maybe it's— to use the baseball analogy— in the 7th or 8th inning at this point.
Marin Katusa: Right.
Erik Townsend: Now, I know you just wrote about this in the last episode of your newsletter. Share your perspective, because I don't think we're anywhere close to the 8th inning. How do you see this baseball game?
Marin Katusa: First of all, I totally agree with you. How this all came about was my good friend Ross Beaty and Tom Kaplan and I did a little bit of an online interview for this large conference to give the keynote talk. Ross said, well, I think we're in the 4th or 5th inning. Tom said, well, I think I'm in the early innings.
I sat there and I went, I actually don't think we're in the big leagues yet. Let me explain why. I think we're probably in the 7th or 8th inning of AAA ball. We're in the farm leagues. We're playing in stadiums that hold 2,000 or 3,000 people, not Wrigley Field with over 50,000. You look at the large funds, the pension funds, the sovereign wealth funds, you look at the incredible amount of capital in the passive management sector, and that's continuing to grow. I do not see, Erik, the— you look at where Canada is for the number of companies listed is on the gold side is well over 450. And then you look at the gold companies on the New York, you got, you know, somewhere around 40. So the primetime, you know, the big leagues is the New York Stock Exchange. Now why? Well, look at the financing sector. Where's the money coming from? Over 80% of it is American money or coming through America.
Canada is not Yes, we are the capital of financing for these companies because it's the industry. It's where the CEOs and engineers and the companies, but the capital is not coming from Canada or Australia. The fact of the matter is it's coming from the US. When you have the qualifications to list on the New York Stock Exchange, that's the big leagues.
Canada, I'm Canadian. I'm a big fan of Canada, but here's the reality. There's too many garbage companies that are listed that are taking up space. And the big money is not going to take US dollars, convert it into Canadian dollars, get dinged by the brokers. And most of the brokerage firms, like the banks in the US, can't even own or buy these stocks in the financing. So the mining sector has to adapt and evolve and go to where the customers are. And frankly, I know people are going to hate when I say this, but that's the US exchange. So I don't even think we're yet in the big leagues yet.
Where I am at, I only want to own assets that are big league available, tier 1 category killers, as Tom Kaplan calls them, with tier 1 management teams that are heavily invested, meaning that their life is going to be much more impacted if this doesn't work than my own, meaning they got skin in the game.
And these are assets that are going to attract the capital of the passive managements. Look at the GDXJ, for example. That's the junior sector. They're not buying any juniors, juniors meaning— sub-$100 million market cap. They're not doing that. A junior to them is something like Equinox, which produces well over 500,000 ounces a year. That's where the juniors come to the big leagues. So that's where it's at. And a lot of guys have a hard time because the industry, Erik, is based off of— I call it Bs and fees, or fees and Bs. The bankers love their fees. They charge 7%, 8% commission. They charge 7%, 8% in broker warrants. The lawyers get it. The accountants get it. It's kind of like an old boys club. The exchange charges these companies for listing.
The exchange is a business in itself, and I'm making a lot of enemies talking about this, but it's the reality of the situation.
Erik Townsend: I want to come back to the Canada angle of this and companies that are listed in Canada, because I know you've written about that recently. But first, I want to go deeper on this question of hitting the big leagues, because it seems to me like, look, for years and years now, yeah, sure, a lot of these companies are listed in Canada, but there's also There's also plenty of gold mining companies that have been listed on US exchanges for decades. And frankly, it's stuff that gold bugs buy. You know, we had Milton Friedman calling gold a barbarous relic and so forth.
Really, institutional investors, almost as a matter of reputation risk, don't want to hold gold in an institutional portfolio because, you know, that's just not done anymore. I mean, and if you look at what's going on with, with MMT, about to change the world and all fiat currency on the verge of being debased. It seems to me that when you get some kind of catalyst where it becomes culturally acceptable for institutional money managers to have gold mining shares in their portfolios because they understand the macro argument for it, all of a sudden the world changes and floodgates open. What is the catalyst? What does it to change the investment mindset, to get all these institutional guys where the really big money is to say, wait a minute, we used to think of gold and gold mining shares as kind of all those kooky gold bugs, but maybe there's a time and a place for everything.
And the time and the place for gold is right now when Stephanie Kelton and company are counseling governments on how to debase fiat currency all around the world.
Marin Katusa: The simple answer is this. I published a report talking about the yield over the last 150 years from the mining companies. And it all kind of changed in the late '70s and '80s when MBAs and accountants took over these companies, and it no longer became a business. A business is like your business or my business or any business. You want positive cash flow, you want to make money at the end of the year. And the mining sector became about— specifically, the gold bugs started dictating the terms, and it became about It became about production. It was based off of higher gold prices. So let's go down the food chain on the projects. It's got to go back to the basics. And you look at guys like Barrick, run by Mark Bristow, or another great example would be Agnico Eagle, run by Sean Boyd. These guys have come out publicly and said, yeah, gold's $1,900. But we're not using $1,900 in our M&A.
We're going to use $1,250 or $1,300. Why? Because look what's happened in the last 20 years.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: Massive wealth destruction. How many CapEx overruns? Well, everybody wants to go build a mine at the same time. When we built Copper Mountain, when we started it 14 years ago, we had to sign up 3 years in advance to get a crusher, the big SAG mills and the ball mills. And we had to wait in line. And we were like number 48 in line. And if we didn't make our payments, we wouldn't get the crusher to site by 2010 or 2011.
Erik Townsend: Wow.
Marin Katusa: Back in 2008. Well, the global financial crisis happened, and a lot of companies just bailed on making their payments. So we accelerated and got it earlier. But my point is, is it's the classic boom-bust setup on such a cyclical business. Until it goes to a basic cash flow, paying yield, increasing yield, you know, in that standpoint, in an MMT world where we're going negative, where the governments are going to increasingly buying their bonds, That's when the gold companies will go into the big leagues and will become primetime.
And not just the active managers, but the passive management money will start coming into the sector because people want to get paid and make money off a sound business, not speculation, meaning gold has to go to $2,400, then I get paid. That ain't going to work for the big leagues. It's got to be a real business.
Erik Townsend: Now, for the benefit of our investor audience, let's talk about I want to talk a little bit about the different leagues, if you will, because on one hand, you've just made a very good argument that says, look, where the really big action is going to happen eventually, it has to be in US markets, which is where all the capital is. That's where the world is really going to change. But at the same time, you just wrote in your newsletter quite extensively about the culture, if you will, of the Vancouver finance community and why they tend to put all these new gold companies on Canadian exchanges. Tell us a little Tell us a little bit about that. Particularly, do investors really need to be prepared to invest in Canadian dollars? Is there something you gain? Is there an advantage that you get if you're an American investor to going through that hassle of opening an account that's able to trade the TSX and converting US dollars to Canadian dollars and all that?
Is there a reason to do that, or are you better off to just stick with US-listed companies if you're in the US?
Marin Katusa: Look, when it comes to early-stage exploration, and when you do a financing, you get a warrant, the earlier stuff is listed in Canada, which 99% 90% of the time, the financings are done in Canadian dollars. Now, there have been financings that they would accept US dollars because these companies do need US dollars. They fix the exchange rate and they move forward. Now, we've been involved in a few of those. But the point is, is that, yes, you should have the account available. But what people have to understand is you're also then— if you're an American, like my fund is American dollars fund.
Now, in 2011, when we put all that money in, the dollar was par. By doing nothing, the US dollar fund, if you're investing in the Canadian stock, and let's just say it hasn't gone down, it hasn't gone up, you would have lost over 30% just because of the currency factor. So this is something that people have to really pay attention to. When you start converting dollars, you also have to focus on the currency play that will affect you regardless of your investment.
So that's number one. And I talk a lot about that. Number two, this whole belief that you have to buy something really early stage with these geos with a box of crayons with maps who dress up and try to look like Indiana Jones. And they were socially awkward in university and now they think they're studs because they're using public money at bars and they're doing that game. Look, I've been there and done it, Erik.
And you don't need to play the early super high risk to get the returns. I've talked about this for years in my newsletter. You look at the big caps; they've actually outperformed the juniors, and you're looking at way, way orders of magnitude less risk. Okay, everything's about what is my risk-adjusted return? What type of risk am I taking for this return? And and I sat there a few years ago and saying the game's changing. Where's the money? And the big money from like it kind of ended at 2011, 2012 is when the big funds got so burnt by playing the illiquid.
Other currency playing the Canadian if you're American dollars, and you know this early stage stuff that they didn't quite understand, and the promotion and all the factors that come into the the game where they're looking at it going geez, you know I can make four times my money on an Equinox that's now on its way to produce a million ounces, or like in our newsletter where we made three times your money on a million ounce producer called B2 Gold run by my buddy Clive Johnson. The point is, you know you look at these exploration stories taking all that risk, and they've doubled or tripled.
Now, me personally, mathematically speaking, if I had a junior that went up 5 times, but it was very risky, say a sub-$100 million market cap, $50 million market cap that goes up 5 times, or a mid-cap or a major that goes up 2 or 3 times, I would every day of the week take the double or triple over that 5-bagger because of the risk involved.
And I can walk through hundreds of examples why. The risk-adjusted returns, the depth of bench of assets— is this a one-asset company, or does it have a portfolio? All these different factors. And the money— the bell that was rung that the industry ignored was when the GDXJ restructured about 3, 4 years ago and said, hey, we were created— the GDX was supposed to be for the big companies and mid-tiers that are producers. And the GDXJ was supposed to be— originally, inception was for the discoveries, the companies that are going to develop into to producers. Well, is B2 and Kinross a junior? Well, they're in the GDXJ.
So there was a huge pivot. Why? Because they significantly underperformed. The investors didn't want to own it. So the manager said, well, we either have to adapt and change, or we're going out of business. So they adapted and changed. So in this business, you can still think that the gold standard rules apply to economics, and so many people Look, I get it. You and I get the reasons why people want to go back to the gold standard, but that's not reality.
You either play with the rules ahead and the framework that we have at hand, or you live in a bubble. If you're going to live in a bubble, it's going to pop and it's going to be awful for you.
Erik Townsend: Marin, let's come back to the MMT prognostications that we started with at the top of this interview. You and I both think that we don't know yet, as we're speaking on Wednesday, a day before This interview will air on our podcast. The election has not been called yet. There's still a bit of a leaning toward a Democratic Biden win in the polls, but we're not even sure of that.
One way or another, regardless of who's president, I think you and I agree that governments, not just in the United States, but around the world, are going to continue to print and spend money. That's going to mean a lot of infrastructure projects. It's going to mean eventually, I think, inflation coming into the economy.
What does it mean for natural resources? Particularly, where do we want to be investing? Is that in some ways maybe an argument for gold rather than the mining shares? How do we interpret the MMT prognostication and translate it to the market?
Marin Katusa: For sure. Regardless from a framework on economics, it's irrelevant who wins the election because the only difference is the Democrats want to direct where the money's going to go and Republicans want to have the free market direct where the money's going to go. So that's really the only difference here. Now, depending on where the Senate is the next 2 years, there's going to be a lot of gridlock if Biden wins, because it does look like the Republicans will hold. So the stimulus will still come, but it's going to be debated and it's going to create more market volatility. But regardless, we know what MMT is going to do. You have the sovereign wealth funds trying to dictate against carbon and all these factors. So when you talk about inflationary, where you're going to see incredible amounts of capital come in, is the green energy sector. And this is something we talked about in March in the newsletter.
And in the green energy sector, it comes down to one thing. I wrote about this in 2015, Erik— cost of capital. That's it. That's all that matters. It's not like you're having this geologist who's got a brilliant idea, and he finds this gold deposit where no one else bothered looking. With the green energy, it's, hey, what is it going to cost us to build this? What is our PPA, our 30-year contract with the state or the government or the company's power purchase agreement? And what do we clip? What is our net gain? It's really a financial engineering industry. The bigger you are, the lower your cost of capital, the better you can grow. That's just how it goes. So a startup green energy company, its cost of capital will be anywhere between 8% and 17%. Well, if you take some of the big boys like Brookfield or NextEra their cost of capital is anywhere between 1% and 4%.
So through math, how could a startup compete. It just can't. So my thesis is, again, stay with the big leagues, liquidity, and the market is going to be funding the big boys to continue their growth. That said, what happens there? So I coined this phrase called crossflation. You're going to see incredible inflation in areas like the offshore wind and the CapExes, cost overruns, labor, the whole setup. And then you're going to see deflationary pressures in the coal and the natural gas sector that is going to be losing its market share to that. So you're going to see deflationary deflationary pressures in certain areas of the energy patch and inflationary pressures. Now, here's something if you really want to get all these gold bugs thinking we're crazy, Erik, is I published something called the GBOE concept, Green Barrels of Oil Equivalent, back in my newsletter. And I said, look, when I took on the Alterra project, which got bought out by Innergex, I tried to explain to the oil patch that their cost of capital was significantly lower than the green energy patch because the green energy patch went through its boom, bust, and echo with the first green revolution, when Obama took over in '09.
So what happened then? All these projects eventually got built, but investors got bored of the reality of a utility, because that's what green energy is. It's just a fancy utility that makes everyone feel good rather than burning coal or natural gas. It's windmills and sunlight and run of river and hydro, right? Or geothermal. Now, what happened then? All these oil companies, you look at Exxon, Chevron, I talked to directors of Suncor, all these massive—
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: Massive, big companies with hundreds of billions of dollars of market cap. And they looked at the math, and they said, you know, this is really cool, and you're a nerd, but we're a real energy company. Green energy doesn't make money. And I would argue that, actually, guys, it does. Look at the cost deflationary pressures. And they just— they didn't want to educate themselves. Fast forward 5 years, and this is where it sounds crazy. Brookfield today has a bigger market cap than Suncor.
Now, Brookfield's Canada's largest green energy company. Suncor's Canada's largest oil company.
Erik Townsend: And Brookfield—
Marin Katusa: Brookfield can now buy out Suncor, and 5 years ago, that would've been a joke. In the US, NextEra is America's largest green energy company, and it's got a bigger market cap than Exxon. People think that's crazy. Well, the cost of capital for Brookfield or NextEra is lower than Suncor or Exxon, and they can now use the same math that the oil patch used where they took natural gas and converted it into a barrel of oil equivalent using the formulas that I published.
I think in the next 10 years, you're going to see all these Goldman Sachs savvy guys make the push and be funded by MMT because it's ESG acceptable. It feels good. It creates jobs. And the only way you're going to phase out oil, which the Democrats have clearly stated they will, well, is to own it.
Therefore, imagine a world where the green energy companies start buying out the oil patch and use the barrels of oil equivalent The green barrels, where every barrel of oil is used to fund a new green barrel of oil. And technically, mathematically, you can argue that the sun is an infinite royalty. And that changes the game for the oil patch— the cost of capital, the recycle ratios, the return on investment. Everything is in favor for the green energy companies to do it. And how is it going to be fueled? MMT. And if you think that it's not going to Well, I can guarantee you this, MMT is not going to be plowing billions or trillions into the oil patch because that's not what the agenda is.
As crazy as it sounds, Erik, is it crazy that Tesla has a bigger market cap than Toyota or GM or Ford? But that's the reality we're in.
Erik Townsend: Now, along those lines, another question I wanted to ask you. I was talking to someone else the other day who's been around the gold mining industry for a long time, and I was asking him about gold mining and the opportunities. You know what? I think the biggest opportunities in mining right now, despite what's going on with money printing and all this, it's not even in gold mining. It's in copper mining. And the reason is, you've got infrastructure spend coming no matter what, regardless of who's in the White House. They're going to do a lot of infrastructure spend. And electric vehicles are huge copper consumers. There has to be a huge copper market. And this one individual at least thought that the opportunity in copper mining was even better than the gold mining opportunity.
Marin Katusa: Wow.
Erik Townsend: What's your reaction to that?
Marin Katusa: Well, look, what the individual is probably saying was copper porphyries. Copper, historically, the base metal producers have traded at a considerable discount to the gold producers. This goes back all the way down to Canada's greatest mining company. Basically, the foundation of Barrick was a company called Placer. Placer were the guys that really took copper porphyries Big open pit, bulk tonnage, 0.5%, 0.6%, 0.7% copper, which 35, 40, 50 years ago was considered low grade. Today, it's considered high grade.
And what they did was they created considerable cash flow, like the largest mining companies were always base metal companies.
Then when gold started rocking in the '70s, the gold companies, because of gold bugs, were a little bit less disciplined on the financial analysis of And they're going to hate when I say this, but here's a fact. Placer Dome eventually became Placer Dome, got bought out by Barrick in '06. Placer was the mining guys. It was run by engineers, guys like Jim O'Rourke, Erik Schultz. These are really smart, successful guys who built multiple mines around the world and it was based off cash flow and yield. But Dome Ventures was a gold company that kind of was cyclical and didn't really make that great of cash flow, but it had it traded at a higher multiple. So The bankers was Dome. It took over the real mining guys. That became Placer Dome. And in the boardroom, the bankers were a little bit— the bankers and accountants were a bit more savvy than the engineers who built the mines, because they were actually working rather than manipulating.
And they took over. And that's how Barrick became Barrick, was taking over Placer Dome. So today, the copper guys trade at a significant discount to the gold producers. Okay, on whether you want to talk on a NAV basis, a PE multiple, it doesn't matter.
But the big problem with the copper guys is now that the porphyries have— the low-hanging fruit has been produced, the CapEx are very high. And the market is very shy of that. So depending on where your porphyry is, Erik, which jurisdiction, infrastructure, do you have electricity? Is it a camp where you have to house and feed your guys, or can they drive drive up from a town locally. All these costs— labor is a big cost. Electricity is a big cost. You've got all these— crushing is a big cost. How hard is the rock? The metallurgy. Where are you sending your concentrate?
And where I think the future is— and I've been writing about this— is copper porphyries with high gold and silver credits, not moly. So there's different types of porphyries. And you don't really want a molybdenum byproduct. Because if you have a good gold byproduct or a silver, you can do a stream or a royalty on your byproduct. Right. Product and it'll help fund your copper. So yes, I believe that that's an interesting thing. I've been writing about it. But again, Erik, mining is such a difficult business. Just because you have a big copper deposit, will it be mineable and is it realistic? And it's so many factors that come into play, jurisdictional risk, permitting, where it is, infrastructure risk, and all those different aspects.
Erik Townsend: Marin, let's tie this all together. Let's suppose that the hypothetical investor wants to allocate $1 million to the natural resources sector and sees the MMT coming and everything, currently has no exposure to mining, whether it be gold or base metals or anything else. What percentage do we put into precious metals versus non-precious metals, natural resources?
In the precious metals space, how much of that goes into into the big cap companies versus the juniors versus private placements in startups? What's the breakdown of how you would approach that for, let's say, a family office or high net worth individual?
Marin Katusa: For sure. For 20 years, I've seen so many booms and busts in our sector where you have the private money come in. First of all, don't make the number one mistake everyone does is they're excited, they come in and they go, I've got a million bucks or 100 grand or 500 grand or 5 million, Whatever the number is, and they go, I need to now get into the game, and they start buying and buying and buying. That's the number one mistake. Be an alligator. And I use these analogies to really try to— so people can visualize. An alligator can go a year without eating. It can control its metabolism. So number one thing is control your impulse. It feels good. Like, I'm the first guy to admit, it feels great to negotiate a term and be the lead order and be the big swinging dick in the room.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: You've got to control your impulses, stay super disciplined. One of the biggest lessons I learned in the business is never try to compete with other financiers in the game on terms, because you're competing against yourself. What you want to be doing is being the source of capital when there's no one else there, number one.
Number 2, work towards building your allocation. I do this thing called the tranches. I always talk about it. So let's separate investments, Erik, versus speculation.
Erik Townsend: Sure.
Marin Katusa: Investments is, am I getting paid a dividend? Is this money, you know, is the company producing something? Are they building towards it? Or a speculation is, I'm buying it because I think they're going to find a deposit, or I think they're going to be bought out. It's catalyst-driven rather than cash flow and dividend and growth-driven, which is investments. So right off the bat, I'm 2/3 investment-driven, 1/3 speculation. Now, I never put more than 10% of my whole portfolio into any one stock on an investment. And on a speculation, never put more than 5% of your entire portfolio into any one stock. And I ease into these positions.
The best way to do it, Erik, is private placements. You get the warrant kicker. And it blows my mind. All the fund managers out there— and you keep saying, oh, Marin Katusa and his Katusa warrant, he's an idiot. No, you're an idiot. For those people to think that warrants are bad for the business, Warrants, if they're private and not listed, yes, they're an overhang.
But you as an investor are taking considerable amounts of risk. And these management teams issue themselves options for 5 years. And I sit here and go, wait a second. I'm taking all the risk. I'm putting all the capital in. You get options for 5 years, and you're telling me you're not going to give me a warrant? Go fuck yourself, right? So the whole point here is you want to invest in management teams who are writing huge checks and And not abusing the options.
It always starts with the people. And what I have found is if I can get a full 5-year warrant out of Ross Beaty, who, by the way, owns over 10% of the company himself and has invested $200 million of his own money at a price higher than our subscribers, and we got a full 5-year warrant that lists and trades, Erik, that's the way to play the game, is those types of deals. The private placements is the way to go. That's how you should start, specifically if you're an accredited investor. There's a huge advantage. And this is something you don't learn in the CFA program or MBA programs. Why? Because the teachers aren't investors. And look, I started out as a teacher. So I'm always fighting for the underdog guy. It's just my nature. But the reality is, is this whole business is set up where the bankers give the best deals to their big high net worth or big fund managers.
They get the warrant, but the retail crowd doesn't. The whole business is upside down. So I'm trying to change it, take it away from the institutions, take it away from the bankers and the brokers. And take those fees away, keep them in the company, and give us the warrants for taking the risk, and list them.
Because, Erik, here's another thing. There are so many, so many funds out there that are not allowed to buy mining stocks because it's against their actual articles of incorporation of their funds. But they want exposure to the gold sector. But you see, warrants are— it's an option. It's no different than a put or a call. And these fund managers— great examples when I did the Katusa Warrant on Northern Dynasty.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: I get a phone call from the CEO, and he's going, Marin, what the hell is going on? The warrants are actually trading higher than the share price. That makes no sense. And I go, well, you're not understanding that the funds that are speculating in it, they can't buy the stock, so they're buying the warrant.
And here's a great example for these who invested at $0.45, and you get a full 5-year listed tradable warrant at $0.65. The warrants are trading at $4. You could sell your warrant at $4 and keep your stock for free, whereas the old business was set up at the brokerages. They would sell their stock to the retail crowd and keep their warrants as an overhang. They would call— peel the shares and ride the warrant was the old saying. And I'm saying, by listing those warrants, you could sell your warrant and keep your share.
And that's what's happened with Equinox and Northern Dynasty. I can walk through many, many examples on that. So for everyone out there that thinks warrants are— you wouldn't believe how many management teams are saying, well, my big investor doesn't like warrants. And I'm like, that big investor ain't going to be lasting in the business that long, so you might want to think twice.
Erik Townsend: Now, Marin, I'm just going to slow you down a little bit here because I personally am both a subscriber to your newsletter and I've participated in your private placements, so I know what you're talking about. But just for the benefit of some of our listeners who may not be veterans of natural resource investing, what is sometimes part of these private placements is in addition to buying shares for money, which is of course what a private placement is. The investor also gets a warrant, or more frequently, a half warrant. So for every 2 shares you buy, you get an option to buy another share. Usually that's a long-dated option called a warrant that's good for several years.
The way most people in the business did this is, okay, you've got this private company that's maybe gonna go public at some point, but it's not yet. And now I've got a warrant in it, and that warrant is a piece of paper that I can only exercise with company. You've taken a different approach of getting not just the shares listed on an exchange, but the warrants listed on an exchange so that your investors in the private placements that are receiving both shares and warrants, not only can they sell the shares on the exchange, but they can also sell and trade the warrants on the exchange. And that's what you mean by a Katusa warrant. So I just want to get that terminology clear because otherwise we're going to be inundated by people people saying, what the heck is Marin talking about?
Marin Katusa: Yes, you're entirely correct. But the one thing I want to phrase to everyone is the industry uses private placement. You know, it doesn't mean that the company's private. What's ironic about the private placement, it's street code for the inside crew. Private means it's not for everybody. So you could have many of these publicly listed companies that are doing private placements. It's just another fancy term for a financing or an equity raise or whatever.
The big difference of what I've trying to push the industry to do is the bankers don't like listing the warrants because it's an inherent financing down the road if you list them. Bankers don't get paid fees on that. And more importantly, to list a warrant, you need to have 100 investors, accredited investors minimum, to list the warrant with no one owning over 80% of the warrants. There's like some rules. And bankers hate handling over 100 subforms for financing. They like to go to their 10 largest funds or their 12 largest funds, and, you know, they tuck in the deals. They wink, wink, nudge, nudge, let's go on a closing party. It's really an old boys network. And I came in with my East Van style saying, yeah, well, I'm not a blue blood. I'm self-made and I don't mesh with that crowd. This is how I'm going to be doing it. It's my money. I'm the lead order.
But to play against the big boys in the field, I need my alligator pack. I'm very open about that. They come in at the same terms, at the same price, at the same time. So it's become a me versus them, but it's just me. I need my alligator pack, which are my subscribers. And I say, rather than keeping these warrants private, an overhang, I'm educating the management teams and it's becoming more and more accepted. You'll see it's now becoming a, hey, this makes sense. Look at these companies. They're doing well and they're liquid and they're moving forward. So list the warrants. It's a little bit more effort on the management team's part, but it's becoming more and more mainstream. Stream with more and more time. And more importantly, I hope there becomes more volatility and liquidity because so many of these funds that aren't fighting for the basics and the fundamental proper values, they're fly-by-night money.
They're very quick money.
That's the opposite of what I do. You've seen for how long I've been talking about Equinox. I come in, and I believe the Warren Buffett strategy is when you buy shares, you're a partner in the company. And you try to add value. Like when I bought Alterra, and I became the major shareholder outside of Ross, who was the chairman and the largest. I become a partner in the company, and I worked with the management team to show how the debt— and it's a complicated story. I wrote it in my newsletter. But it was me pushing on the default of the debt, how it would be accretive by defaulting on debt. I know that sounds crazy, but that's the type of stuff that I get involved in and bring projects to the companies and merger ideas.
I'm a very active, positive investor. There's a whole crew out there that are activist investors that try to go against management teams. My thesis is life's too short. Number 2, why do I want to fight a management team when the odds are against me in the resource sector to take it on? Number 3, why not just find the best management teams, work with them, try to get in at their cost base or lower, make sure that they're the largest shareholders, and work with them in a positive way to create shareholder wealth?
That's been my framework, and it's played out really well. And that's where I'm going to continue, and I'm more leaning towards big league assets with big league management teams that have big league cash flow. Because after going to hundreds and hundreds of projects, the headache of building a small crappy mine is the same as building a big mine. The difference is crappy profits versus big profits. So I prefer the big profits.
Erik Townsend: Marin, we're just about out of time. But before I let you go, I do want to ask you about your newsletter, which you've just been alluding to. Look, let's face it. You're in a very different part of this newsletter business than a lot of the newsletter writers that we talk to that are doing these $200 or $300 a year things. Frankly, if an investor has a $10,000 investable net worth, it would be foolish to spend a third of it subscribing to your newsletter. So who is your newsletter for? Who's the target audience? Who benefits from it? And it's not cheap. It's usually $3,500 a year. I know Patrick, my producer, has beaten your guys down to, I think it's $1,998. for a subscription instead of the usual $3,500. But we're still talking 2 grand. Who pays that? Who does it make sense for? And what does it include?
Marin Katusa: It's guys like you, Erik. It's guys that are serious about their portfolio. This isn't a $19 monthly membership where you feel like, oh yeah, I'm going to go to the gym, and you don't. This is for guys that really want to educate themselves on how mining companies are built, true analysis, and skin in the game. I've never understood, Erik, why I don't think anyone would subscribe to a newsletter where the author, the guru, as you would call it, don't buy the stock. Because I can guarantee you, Erik, when these deals go against me and I'm the largest investor in the deal, you better believe I think about it all the time and at nighttime and how to fix it. It's not just another armchair analysis. Oh, well, that didn't work. Well, yeah, no, I'm the lead guy on all these PPs, and you've seen it yourself.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Marin Katusa: Who should be investing in it? One thing I've seen is we're seeing a huge increase in professional females. That's been the biggest growth in our newsletter. It used to be old white dudes. I've been doing this for 20 years now, and it used to be that Republican. It's changing, Erik. We have subscribers in over 100 countries, and the biggest growth is professional females who are looking at this sector going, hey, this makes sense. It's cheap. I want to invest in private placements. And that's been the biggest change I've seen over the last 20 years from back when I was the main guy for Doug Casey and then when I learned my chops.
And make sure if you're investing in it, it's a journey. It's the Ironman approach. This is not a sprint. And in my report that I'm publishing today is 47 pages long with complete detailed analysis. I'm not one of these guys that write cool stories that make you laugh and witty, this and that. It's about Making money and nothing else.
Erik Townsend: Well, when it hits my inbox, I always click and open it just about instantly. It gets my attention and often there's actionable advice there. So I really appreciate a terrific interview. We look forward to getting you back on the show in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Uranium, the fuel for nuclear power, is a contrarian investment whose returns are historically uncorrelated to other asset classes. Low uranium prices lasted for many years after the Fukushima meltdown, leading to substantial supply destruction. At today's prices, uranium mining is uneconomical even for the world's lowest-cost producers. Uranium demand is already estimated to exceed existing supply, and future demand growth is expected. New mines aren't economically viable at today's prices, leading analysts to predict that the price of uranium may need to double to over $60 per pound to incentivize sufficient new mine supply to meet expected demand. The NYSE-listed North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, ticker URNM, offers investors exposure to both miners and holders of For more information, visit urnmetf.com.
Announcer: Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, great interview with Marin Katusa. And for our listeners, there's a link in your Research Roundup email to the special offer allowing MacroVoices to subscribe to Marin's newsletter for $1,999 instead of the usual $3,500 price tag. You can also find the offer at katusaresearch.com/macrovoices. But frankly, Erik, something about Marin's pitch sounds a little too good to be true. It's pretty bold promising his subscribers that he'll tell them before he sells his stock so they can get a chance to sell their shares for first. Marin's a pretty big investor in these deals himself and has a lot of his own capital at risk. Why in the world would he invite his subscribers to effectively front-run him by telling them in advance before he starts selling the stock in his model portfolio? And on the private placements, he says his subscribers get exactly the same deal he gets, and he claims he doesn't make any capital introduction commissions for setting up the deal, which is completely at odds with the industry Norms.
Erik, I know you subscribe to Marin's newsletter yourself. What's going on here? Is everything really as advertised?
Erik Townsend: Well, frankly, Patrick, I was extremely skeptical at first. And, you know, this is compounded— Marin kind of has a salesman personality too, and I kind of wondered, okay, what is this guy's game? And in short, it's mostly as advertised, and I quite have come to really appreciate the newsletter and the value that I get from it. There are a couple of not-so- There are a few obvious little gotchas in this story, though. So let's debunk the Marin sales pitch, if you will, and talk about what the straight scoop is, what's real and what's not real. And to understand that, I think you've got to have the backstory of how this marketplace works. The way private placements usually work, first of all, in the gold mining business, unlike something like software where you have a very vibrant venture capital community that's financing the growth of most of these companies.
In the gold mining space, they need private placements to accredited investors to come and buy shares in these companies while they're still private before they go public in order to develop their mines and get to the point where they're producing gold and they can float a public offering and actually take the company public.
Now, the brokers that introduce accredited investors to these deals usually get to keep about 6 to 10% of the money that's being raised in the form of commissions. And the mining companies, of course, they hate paying those commissions, but that's just the reality of the industry. Sometimes the brokers are getting a percentage of the cut. Other times they kind of change the shape of it to hide it. So the, the story that's told to the investor is the broker's not taking any of your money as a commission. 100% of your money that you're paying for these shares goes to the company and they keep your money and the broker doesn't get any of it. Well, what they don't tell you is the company is also issuing warrants, which are like long-dated options, call options to buy the stock at a certain price. And the brokers are getting those warrants in lieu of a commission in exchange for providing the introduction to the accredited investors and so forth.
So they can tell the investors the company got to keep all the money, which is technically true, but they didn't tell you that the company actually did pay a significant compensation to the brokers in the form of warrants.
Now, what's going on? Why does Marin have his newsletter? What is he trying to do here? What's he trying to accomplish? What I've figured out over the last couple years is Marin, I think, wants to be the George Soros of natural resource investing. He wants to be the guy who's got so much money that he can tell these mining companies, look, forget about the brokers, forget about their commissions, forget about their accredited investors. I'm such a, you know, Daddy Warbucks, big money guy that I can do the whole deal for you. I can finance your entire capital raise myself. I'm going to buy all the stock that you need to sell me. And I want you to give me better terms because I'm such a, you know, big heavyweight guy that I can do the entire deal myself.
Marin's a very wealthy guy, but he's not quite that wealthy. So the reason he has this newsletter, as far as I can tell, is it allows him to effectively increase his own buying power so that what he can say to these companies is, look, I've got this army of alligators, as he calls them, accredited investors that are qualified to invest in a private placement. There's going to be no commissions. I'm not even going to get involved in dealing with them. I'll just tell my subscribers to deal with the company directly. I charge my subscribers a fee for getting the newsletter. It's a very big fee, by the way. $3,500 newsletter has got to be the most expensive precious metals newsletter on the market. And then you can deal with them directly. There's no brokers, there's no commissions, whatever. But I want the warrants not to go to brokers, but to go to me and to the other investors.
So the people that are buying the stock get the warrants. And then what Marin's added is his own little signature, which is those warrants normally are a contract between the investor and the company. They can't be traded publicly on any exchange. What Marin does is he gets those warrants publicly listed on an exchange so that the investors buying the stock not only get the ability to trade the stock once it goes public, but they also get the ability to trade the warrants as listed instruments on an exchange. And that's what's become known as a Katusa warrant because Marin was the guy who started doing it. So it really is true that he is giving his investors the opportunity to invest in these companies on the same exact terms that he's investing in, almost.
And the gotcha that he doesn't tell you is this. When Marin comes in, let's take JR Resources, a company that he's doing right now, and in the interest of full disclosure, which I'm investing in. Marin's the lead investor in that deal, $10 million check that he's writing personally.
Well, when he says you can invest on the same terms he is, what you can't do— and by the way, Doug Casey tried to do it— is say, okay, Marin, I can invest in the same terms as you do. Okay, I'll take $10 million too. And the answer is, well, no, Marin's already like more than half of the deal at $10 million. There is no second $10 million that's available because the whole financing's not that big. So what is not being advertised is you can't invest in the size that Marin is investing in and get $10 million for yourself. In Casey's case, he wanted several million. He ended up getting $100,000 or something. I wanted a large allocation. I ended up in that deal getting scaled back to only about 20% of what I asked for. And that particular one, there was a huge amount of interest and every Everybody got scaled back.
So the place where it's not quite true that you're investing on the same terms that he is, is Marin puts all the work into the research, setting these deals up. He gets to keep as much of the deal for himself as he wants to, and whatever's left gets divided up among his subscribers. And it is, I think, a fantastic opportunity because Marin has done an excellent job of scouting out and finding these deals to invest in.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: There's no broker involved. It's not like a broker who, you know, if the broker is selling you the deal that he's getting a commission on as a percentage, whether it's a good deal or a bad deal, he's happy to sell you that deal. Marin is finding deals to invest in himself, and he's allowing his subscribers to invest on the same terms, but typically in much smaller size than he's investing. And it really depends on, you know, if you're— what you want is to be able to do $25,000 or $50,000 per deal investments, it's gonna be fine.
If you wanna do several million dollars at a time, you're not gonna have that opportunity 'cause the deals are not that big. So that's where the gotcha is that maybe is not quite obvious.
Now, as far as the other part that you asked about, which is he says to everybody, well, I'm gonna tell you before I sell my stock so you can go first. Stop and think about that. Marin is an insider on most of these deals because the size of his investment is large enough that for exchange rules, he's reportable. He has to disclose publicly that he's going to sell before he starts selling.
So, you know, it is true that he does exactly what he promises, but I think he would kind of have to do that for regulatory reasons anyway.
Bottom line, I think that the service that he's providing is excellent. It's my go-to spot for private placement deals in precious metals, which is where I prefer investing right now. But Patrick, this is It's not something that makes any sense for small investors. If your financial net worth is $25,000, you don't want to spend 10% of it on Marin's newsletter. That's crazy. I think you need a bare minimum of $50,000 to invest in the natural resources sector before it makes any sense to spend that kind of money, even with the big MacroVoices discount, on a newsletter. And I think it's particularly opportune for accredited investors who can get in on the private placement deals. It's just a question of realizing that you won't maybe be able to get as much size as you might have wanted to, as these deals are very popular and oversubscribed in a lot of cases.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, let's move on to our main postgame topic, the US election aftermath. Now, for weeks and weeks, you've been telling listeners that the question is not whether the US presidential election will be contested, but rather how contested it will be and how much uncertainty and volatility that creates for the markets. So for this week's postgame topic, let's talk about this subject. How bad can it get here, Erik?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think this could get pretty bad, frankly. I did a bunch of research this week, and frankly, I was shocked to learn how much room the design of the Electoral College system leaves for uncertainty and how many different ways this process could be derailed before the president is finally chosen.
The whole system relies to a very large extent on state law, not federal law, to govern the actions of these electors, which are the people who take the popular vote and go and actually vote in the final election, which doesn't happen until December. So it's a big muddy situation where the laws of each state are a little bit different. And the concept of precedent, where once something is decided in And a court, that same decision binds on everybody else. Well, that's not true if you're talking about state law. If something happens in the Michigan election and a court makes a ruling on it, that doesn't establish a precedent that's gonna have anything to do with the Arizona state court's interpretation of its laws, 'cause it's a separate set of laws. So it's a very muddy, complex process, and each of these states have different laws.
So it's very, very confusing.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, let's walk through the process chronologically and discuss what could go wrong in each step of the way. Now, let's start what we know. Americans who choose to exercise the right have already cast their vote for the next president, either in person on Tuesday of this week or in advance through the early voting or the mail-in ballots, which had to be postmarked by Tuesday of this week in order to be counted.
Erik Townsend: No, that's actually not correct. I thought it was correct too until I did some research on this. In the Electoral College system, citizens never directly vote for the president. So when a citizen votes for John Doe or Joe Biden or Donald Trump or whatever, what they're saying is, I want my state to choose electors. There's 538 people called electors.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: electors who have the intention of casting their vote in the actual presidential election, the real presidential election, which by the way doesn't happen until the 14th of December.
I want my state to choose electors who are going to cast their vote for the guy that I voted for. So if I voted for John Doe, I want my state to choose one of those 538 electors to be somebody who's to go and vote for John Doe in the presidential election, which doesn't happen till December.
Now, the only reason that everybody acts as if the president was chosen on November 3rd is the assumption that the states are going to choose electors that represent the will of the people that were voting in that state. And those electors are in fact going to go and vote for the candidate that their state's citizens voted to elect. elect. And the rules differ from state to state. This is a matter of state law, not federal law.
And so, for example, Maine and Nebraska, the way it works there is the electors are chosen by congressional district. So you could have half of Maine's Electoral College votes go to Joe Biden and the other half go to Donald Trump. Didn't work out that way, or at least it hasn't so far. But in all the other states, there's a different rule where the winner takes So one candidate wins the entire state, and all of the Electoral College votes for that state go to that candidate. There's lots and lots of smaller details that vary from state to state. I just gave you an example of a big one, but the point is, it's state laws, and they're all different.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, but once those electors have been chosen in the election we just had, presumably they're required by law to cast their votes according to the will of the people. So in effect, it's the same thing as the the people choosing the president on November 3rd, isn't it?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, that is exactly what I thought, and it turns out to be wrong. You know, you'd think logically, well, surely if, if the whole purpose of these electors is to carry out the will of the people, surely they, they must be required by federal law that they have to vote for the guy that their state voted for, you know, take that vote forward. Otherwise, it's, I don't know, treason or something. No, federal law does not require the electors to vote as they pledged. Now, when they don't, they're called faithless electors. There's a Wikipedia page about that that's worth reading. Faithless electors. There have been 165 of them in US history. And in some cases, it makes sense. You know, in one case, there was a president who's elected. The guy died after the November election before the December member elector vote. And, you know, obviously it doesn't make sense to vote for a dead guy. So those electors ended up voting for a different candidate from that party who was still alive.
Now, there have been electors that, not for— because of a dead guy, but just because they didn't believe anymore in what they were supposed to do, that broke their pledge. So what you'd think, it would make sense to outlaw this. Well, the Supreme Court has ruled that the states, not the federal government, but the states have the authority if they want to, to impose laws requiring the electors to vote faithfully, to vote for who the people of their state voted for, and to set penalties if they don't.
The thing is, only 33 out of 50 states have enacted laws like that. The remaining states allow faithless Voting, where an elector, if he chooses to, can vote for somebody other than who the people voted for. And that election, the one that really chooses the President of the United States, only 538 people vote in it, and it doesn't happen until December 14th. A whole lot can happen between now and December 14th. And the rules that govern whether or not each elector is required to vote for the person that their state called for, and if they don't, if they break it, does that mean that the vote is overturned?
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: Or does it just mean that that elector gets some penalty, a fine or something, but the vote still stands? Well, it depends on the state. And this is not academic or hypothetical or anything. Faithless electors have never changed the outcome of a US presidential election, but under the law, they could.
In the 2016 election, there were 10 faithless electors, 10 people who didn't vote for who they were supposed to vote for. vote for. And in that case, you know, it wasn't— it didn't change the outcome because they would have needed 37 to not carry the, uh, the vote of Donald Trump. But this is not hypothetical, it's real.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, 2016 was when Donald Trump won the majority of the Electoral College votes in the popular election by the citizens, but Hillary Clinton was said to have actually carried the popular vote. Was that the reason the electors didn't vote as pledged?
Erik Townsend: That might have had something to do with why people were asking them not to vote as pledged, but what happened in that case is a lot of people on both sides were outraged by the election process in 2016. So there were 10 electors that voted unfaithfully, casting their votes for third-party candidates such as Ron Paul, Bernie Sanders, Colin Powell, And Faith Spotted Eagle.
3 of those votes were overturned because they came from states where the state law said not only is the elector required to vote for who they're supposed to vote for, but if they fail to, then the vote doesn't count. So 3 of those votes were overturned, but the other 7 came from states that didn't have laws like that. So those 7 unfaithful votes, where the elector voted for somebody other than the, the people people that they were supposed to vote for according to the outcome of the November election. The result of that, those 7 unfaithful votes were upheld by the court. They just weren't enough to change the outcome of the election. Hillary Clinton lost 5 electoral votes to unfaithful electors who were supposed to vote for her but voted for someone else because they were influenced not to vote for her. Donald Trump lost 2 electoral votes electoral votes this way, but it wasn't enough to change the election.
Now, the thing is, what happened in 2016, at least on the Trump side, there was a movement, an organized group of people called the Hamilton Electors, and they worked very hard to try to influence— what they were doing is lobbying to try to find 37 Republican electors to defect and not vote for Donald Trump as they had pledged to do, because because their state's population had chosen Donald Trump. If they could get 37 electors to defect and not vote for the guy they were supposed to, and instead cast their vote for Ron Paul or, you know, Mickey Mouse or whatever, somebody other than Donald Trump, then Trump would've lost the election. Those electors were subjected to coercion, including death threats.
Now, that was 2016, Patrick. If people were willing to resort Short to death threats in 2016. Well, consider the political climate then versus now. What would they do now in this much more heightened, much more tense situation? I couldn't even find a rule. I mean, if you— what happens if it's not just a death threat? What if somebody assassinated an elector in order to eliminate that vote? I'm not even sure if there's a procedure for that. If the law considers it, I couldn't find it. Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. So the president is actually chosen by the 538 electors, not the people directly. So the 538 electors are chosen by the people in the election we just had this Tuesday, but the results of the election aren't even certified yet. So what is actually being counted and certified here?
Erik Townsend: Well, the choice of who the electors are that are supposed to cast their votes is what's being chosen. In other words, there's somebody lined up in each state. This is the guy, if Biden wins, so-and-so is gonna be the elector, and a different guy is gonna be the elector if Trump wins. And presumably, and so the vote that we had on Tuesday was to choose those electors, and those electors do pledge in most states, almost all states, they make a pledge to vote for the candidate that the people voted for. But they're not required by federal law to actually do that.
Do so. So the first hurdle is in each state, not the federal government, has to go through its own process of counting the votes and choosing its electors.
The electors are people who were chosen by their party for their loyalty to that party. So if a Republican elector is chosen because Donald Trump got the popular vote in that state, that elector, the person who's chosen, is likely to be personally very committed committed to voting for Donald Trump regardless of what happens next.
So now imagine that in a swing state like Pennsylvania, let's suppose that the votes are counted and Trump is the winner, at least on the initial count. And so the elector who is loyal to Trump is chosen by that state in the election. But then let's say a week later, after that elector is chosen, millions and millions of mail-in ballots for Biden are Discovered, along with, let's say, a conspiracy of postal workers who were hiding those Biden votes and, you know, not allowing them to get through or something. So the state Supreme Court— this is just a hypothetical scenario— suppose that the state Supreme Court looks at the situation and orders the chosen elector, who's a person that's likely to be very loyal to Trump, and say, look, we're the state Supreme Court, we're ordering you, Mr. elector to carry out the will of the people.
Now that we've discovered this inconsistency, it's too late to change who the elector is, so you're still the elector, but we're ordering you, as a matter of court order, to vote for Biden instead, because that's the will of the people after we counted all the mail-in ballots.
Okay, you're in total, complete uncharted territory there. Does the state Supreme Court have the authority to make that order? Does the elector have to follow it? If the elector doesn't vote for the guy he's supposed to, or if he ignores the state Supreme Court and votes for Trump anyway, did he do anything wrong?
The federal law does not prohibit the elector from voting for Trump or for Biden, regardless of whatever else happens. Well, what is the consequence? You know that in uncharted legal territory, Everybody's gonna be making a legal argument for whatever they want to have happen.
So my real point here is not that specific hypothetical scenario, but just that there are zillions and zillions of possibilities as to what could happen at any stage of this process after the electors are chosen, but before the actual election happens, after the election happens, but before the January meeting of the joint session of Congress where the votes are read. Things can change at any point along the way, and there's all kinds of possibilities for things to go wrong.
Now, the states have a deadline of December 8th. It's called Safe Harbor Day. By December 8th, they have to choose their electors. Well, what if a state has chosen its electors and it's chosen the Trump electors because Trump won and, you know, they wanted to certify the outcome as soon as they could?
Trump wants— and then 3 days later, Later, they discover millions of votes for Biden, and the state Supreme Court or the state legislature or somebody says, okay, we're going to change it. We take it back. We don't want the Trump guy to be the elector after all. It's going to be the Biden guy. Do they have the authority to change it after they've already announced it? Nobody knows. There's no clear precedent or case law to cover that. It's not clear in the way that the law is written.
Could be argued either way.
There's a law about this which was brought into effect after a contested election back in the 1800s. It's called the Electoral Count Act, and it covers many aspects of this. It is widely criticized by legal scholars as potentially the most self-contradicting and confusing and And just generally ineffective piece of legislation ever written. So you've got a really screwed up piece of law, body of law called the Electoral Count Act that governs a lot of this. Nobody's really sure how to interpret it, and there's not a lot of case law.
My risk assessment— make this simple. Divide 10 faithless electors that you had in the 2016 presidential election. I didn't even know that story until I learned it this week. Take those 10 faithless electors, divide that by whatever your personal assessment is of the degree of public discontentment that existed in November of 2016, then multiply the result by your assessment of that discontentment that exists now. That's the expected value of the faithless vote potential in this election.
And at any point along the way, if new information is discovered and a state says, oh, we gotta change who our elector is, There's no process for that. It's not clear whether they have the authority to do it. If a state tells an elector, you have to vote for somebody other than who you had originally pledged to vote for because there's new information, there's no case law for that. There's no precedent for that. Nobody knows what the law is in that case. Everybody will be arguing their own story. So there are zillions and zillions of possible outcomes of things that could go wrong here along the way.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so far the key takeaways are that the American people did not choose the next president this Tuesday. They voted to choose 538 electors who are supposed to vote the will of the people in the actual presidential election in December. But under the law, and as evidenced by history as recent as the last election, 2016, the electors did not always vote the way they pledged to vote. And there's plenty of reason to assume that complication factors that could lead to faithless electors voting against the candidate they pledged to support are more numerous in this election than any other. Now, let's move on to what happens next. Once the states have all counted the votes that were cast by Tuesday this week and have chosen those 538 electors, what happens next?
Erik Townsend: Well, the actual presidential election in which only those 538 electors are allowed to vote, that doesn't happen until December 14th. And there's lots of opportunities for new evidence to come into play between now and December Either before the electors are chosen by the states or after the state chooses its electors, and maybe new information that might have led to a different conclusion comes out after the elector is chosen. So that could be voter fraud, it could be uncounted mail-in ballots, and we've already seen a couple of examples of that just in the last 36 hours or so. In Arizona, there is at least one case where the, the official uniformed poll workers are handing out these Sharpie markers for people to fill out their ballots with.
And there were reportedly observers who were there saying, hey, wait a minute, don't do that. Those Sharpie markers, you're not allowed to use those. That will invalidate the thing. Here, here's some ballpoint pens. Use these ballpoint pens instead. The polling staff that were handing out the Sharpie markers called the police and got the, the people trying to hand out ballpoint pens forced to stop doing so. Then afterwards, when they go to count the votes, all of the votes that are marked with Sharpie markers are disqualified because exactly as the guys handing out the ballpoint pens said was going to happen, you're not allowed to fill out the, the vote in that state with a Sharpie marker for some reason, even though the staff were handing out those to, to people.
You know, that was one example. There was another situation that came up in Michigan where supposedly a postal worker came forward as a whistleblower saying that he and his colleagues were ordered by their management to take ballots that were received on the 4th of November, a day late, if you will, and separate those from the other mail so that they could be manually postmarked, back postmarked to November 3rd, so that they would be counted even though they had missed the deadline.
Now, we don't know if either of those stories are actually true, but the point is there's going to be more stories like this. There's going to be more stuff coming out that's going to confuse this whole process, and it's going to upset a lot of people. Another direction this could take, Patrick, you could have new evidence come out about unlawful conduct or corruption on either candidate. You know, Joe Biden has been accused of wrongfully Wrongful activities in both China and Ukraine, and Hunter Biden has been accused of inappropriate activity trading in his father's name and so forth. Meanwhile, Donald Trump has been accused of having a Chinese bank account and other kinds of things. Both candidates have been accused of seemingly corrupt things by their critics. Well, new information could come out on either candidate that could influence this whole process.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: Process. So there's no clear precedent on how electors are supposed to respond to new news that comes out after they've been chosen as an elector. There's also no clear precedent on whether or not a state legislature or a state court has the authority to direct an elector to vote for someone other than the one that they originally pledged, because let's say the, the vote is recounted or something. If any state were to try to replace an elector after new information is collected and say, hey, you know, we changed our mind, you're not the elector after all, it's unknown as to whether or not they have that authority. That would be challenged for sure in court. Come November 14th, the electors eventually meet in each state's capital. So there is no nationwide meeting where they all go together in one place. It's in each state capital that the electors for that state meet. The president and the vice presidential choices are made.
The results are sent via registered mail to the president of the Senate and to several other independent parties. The idea is if there's a dispute, there's several different people who all received a copy of it that can corroborate the information and make sure it's correct.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so we don't really know whether the electors are going to vote for the candidate they were chosen to vote for until December 14th. And then history teaches us that they don't always vote as expected or pledged. But it sounds like once we get through the vote on December 14th, that the election is a done deal and the identity of the next president is certain. Is that right?
Erik Townsend: Well, you'd think so, but no, it doesn't work that way. The next step is a full meeting of both houses of Congress on January 6th. Each state's votes are read out loud in that joint session. Now, any state vote can be objected, not just by that state, but any— a combination of any one senator and any one representative. And that's— it doesn't have to be from that state, anybody from anywhere in the country. Combination of one senator and one representative can object to a vote from any state for any reason. If an objection is stated, the joint session is suspended and both houses houses of Congress have independent debates on the merits of that objection. Some or all of any state's votes can be rejected and not counted if the objection is upheld by both houses. For practical purposes, there are no legal rules. There's no, you know, rule of unreasonable doubt or anything like that.
It's basically the politicians get to and if they can get enough people in favor of something, they can uphold an objection, and they can disqualify and not count the votes from a state if they can get enough people to gang up on that state and vote against including it.
Now, objections were raised in 2000— actually, January 6th makes it 2001— in the Bush-Gore election, but only representatives from the House had objected. There was no objection from the Senate, so therefore they didn't consider it and they didn't actually suspend the joint session. All it would've taken is 1 out of 100 senators to defect and want to support just hearing the objection, and that would've forced that joint session of Congress to break down and each house of Congress would separately debate the merits of the objection. So it It only takes one defector to change this. Didn't happen in 2000, but we've got a lot more divisiveness now than we had in 2000.
If one candidate receives 270 votes or more, after objected votes are disqualified, so after you've taken out whatever you're gonna disqualify because of objections, if you've still got an absolute majority, then a president is If not, the House of Representatives chooses the president and the Senate chooses the vice president. So in theory, a Biden president and Pence vice president, you know, the Democrat wins the presidency, but the Republican wins the vice presidency, and you get 2 guys that don't like each other as president and vice president. That is entirely possible if the Senate were to choose Mike Pence.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Mike Pence, and the House were to choose Joe Biden.
Each state in that scenario gets one vote. So the whole Electoral College system where California has 55 votes, but a little state like Maine only has 4 votes. So there's like a 14-to-1 difference there. Well, Maine and California have the same vote in this special session of Congress that would occur. If there's a deadlock on the president and only a vice president becomes elected, then the vice president becomes the acting president until a president is elected. If there's a deadlock on both, the Speaker of the House becomes acting president. Now think about that. There's a scenario there where Democrats could filibuster that special session of Congress to intentionally allow Nancy Pelosi, as Speaker of the House, to take the presidency.
The thing is, in order to pull that off, they would have to somehow make sure that the Senate deadlocked as well and didn't choose a vice president, and it would be unlikely for them to be to do that. My point is not that, you know, it's at all likely that Nancy Pelosi would ever take the presidency. My point is there's an insane number of possible scenarios that could play out here. Everybody in the mainstream media is assuming this thing's going to be settled in the next day or two. I don't think it's going to be.
At any time in this process, legal challenges pertaining to the electors all have to be resolved at the state government level, not at the federal government level.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: federal level. So there is no, you know, the situation a lot of people imagine is the federal Supreme Court steps in and just decides the outcome and that's it. Really, that's not true. It would be a whole bunch of state Supreme Courts making independent decisions about the states that would eventually do that. Undoubtedly, the losers are going to demand that the Supreme Court of the United States intervenes eventually. So, you know, is this all going to be sorted out by January 20th. If it's not sorted out, the fallback is Nancy Pelosi. Well, or, you know, if it can be sorted out to the point where there is no president or vice president, then Nancy Pelosi is president until there is one. I don't think it'll come to that, but it's going to be a really interesting ride from here to January 20th, and I don't think it gets resolved in the next couple days.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik, thanks for providing our listeners with that reassurance that democracy is still intact in the United Anyway, final question. What's your personal take on all of this?
Erik Townsend: Well, again, the logical way to calculate the expected value of this potential risk factor is to divide what happened in 2001 and 2016, how crazy things got then, divide that by the degree of public discord that existed at those times, then multiply the result by the current level of public discord and general pissed-offedness that exists in society.
That's an inherently subjective calculation, and it leads to a result, obviously, which is biased by the perspectives of the person performing the calculation. When I apply that methodology of investment analysis, the conclusion I come to is we could be looking at a cluster Fuck on steroids before this thing is over. So I predict that Electoral College reform is going to be one of the biggest political issues between now and the 2024 election. And by the way, folks, the same distributed ledger technology that solved the double spending problem in Bitcoin could solve all of this election nonsense for once and for all, so that everybody has exactly one vote and a public ledger clearly shows on a pseudonymous level what the audit trail is of who voted how, and there's no room for fraud. It's so easy to solve this with technology. Unfortunately, I don't think there's any chance of that actually happening in our political system.
The point of this whole segment that we're doing here though, folks, is I was unaware of how much room there is, how complex this process is, how intricate and frankly screwed up a lot of the laws are that govern all of this, and particularly the part where it's individual states that have to sort out all of the disputes and discrepancies. There's a whole lot that can go wrong between here and December 8th when the electors have to be chosen, December 14th when the electors choose the president, and January 6th when potentially those votes from the electors could be objected to by any combination of just one representative and one senator, and that could derail this whole electoral process. So there's a whole lot left that can still go wrong. And I suspect that if there's a market crash resulting from this, that it would probably be short-lived. I think you could see a lot of downside volatility as people realize that this thing is less under control than I think a lot of people realize right now.
Unless it goes to all-out civil war, which is a possibility, frankly, but I don't think the most likely.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: the outcome, then eventually it's going to be a buy-the-dip moment. There's going to be a V-shaped recovery. And we all know there's going to be a huge amount of stimulus on the other side of this that's probably going to propel markets higher. But I think there's plenty of room to leave possibility that there is a whole lot of volatility and potentially market downside still ahead of us. Now, of course, you could have either side capitulate and concede defeat tomorrow, and that would just end the whole thing. And I think markets go up from there if that happens. I don't see that happening, and I think it's going to be a rougher ride than most people are expecting.
Erik Townsend: In any event, Patrick, on that pleasant note, let's move on to our postgame chartbook titled Is the Reflation Trade Dead?
Listeners, you'll find the postgame chartbook linked in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, just go to our homepage, MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads. Patrick, is the reflation trade dead? Let's dive in and look at page 2, S&P 500 and VIX side by side. What are these charts telling us?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, first, before we get to the reflation trade story, I wanted to just talk about the first impulse that happened in the post-election period. Going into the election, everyone was scared, volatility was high, everyone was degrossing, deleveraging, and there was a very large amount of hedges being put on into the markets. And when you have those kind of conditions, conditions. There's reflexivity that can happen that just as this, uh, more certainty comes on the other side, that this all gets unwound and money gets put back into the market. One thing that we saw on the volatility was, like we talked about last week, that in the post-election period volatility can normalize. We had a drop from like the, the 37 level down to about the 27 level on the VIX in, in literally a day or two. And there's a The impact that happens to option dealers when there's all these options open for put protection on the downside of a portfolio, when volatility contracts, there's this option term we call vanna, which is reflecting how much delta changes on options, particularly out-of-the-money options, when volatility contracts or expands.
And in this case, when volatility implodes, the amount of delta exposure that dealers had also contracted. In doing so, they did not have to be as short as they had to be to be hedged. And in fact, so they were short covering and providing additional fuel on top of a lot of traders that were waiting for the election results to buy, plus a lot of the FOMO that was coming in when everyone's seeing the market rallying in that post-period. So we have this reflexive rally in the market. The big question now that we're approaching this 3,500 level on the S&P, this is where there's some call walls, where there's huge open interest that could pin the market up here along those previous highs. Be really interesting going into next week to see whether the bulls can build on this momentum or whether this was just a quick snap that is going to mean revert. And that's definitely what we're watching next week.
But what I wanted to move on was on page 3, talk about the 10-year Treasury yield. What I have in that little window was a Bank of America research thing that was coming out, was talking about the different scenarios Scenarios of the election and what it would mean on a macro scale, and what you can see there highlighted in the red box was the Biden win with a Republican Senate or basically a divided government, and that that would lead to deflation. And what was the almost immediate result that we saw in the post-election period was Treasury yields collapsed from 90 basis points down to like 77 basis points, well more than 50. 15 basis point swing in 24 hours on yields in that period. And coupled with that obviously was the byproduct on page 4, which is a lot of people go long duration, particularly long growth and technology and momentum in periods of disinflationary pressure.
And so immediately the momentum over value trade started to work again. And one of the more interesting things in the next week is to see, is this a trend that can And so the idea that a lot of people are out there talking about is that this reflation trade died on the election. But you know what? I find that there's a lot of conflicts to this theme. And that's where on page 5, when we go to that dollar index chart, we can see the dollar continues to be very weak. And when you think about inflation and reflation trades, the typical things that we would see in the macro intermarkets is weak dollar and bullish commodities.
And that usually leads to the inflationary pressure and higher breakevens that lead to higher yields. And what we're seeing is that even though the bond market had that reaction, what we're seeing is the dollar remains very weak. And when we go to page 6, where we have the commodity Bloomberg Commodity Index futures, or crude oil on page 7, or gold on page 8, or copper on page 9, all of them remain somewhat stable and look like they're bullishly rolling.
Rolling up. And so this conflicting chart as to— it's not decided yet which way this is going. And the point I really want to get at is I don't think I want to make the call that the reflation trade is dead yet. I think that we need a little bit more information because these charts are all over the place. And being able to put the puzzle pieces together in the coming week or two as to which way this is going to break is going to be a key to how you position your portfolio. And that's definitely what we're going to keep an eye on.
Erik Townsend: Well, definitely we're going to have continuing coverage both between you and I and with our expert guests on the program. I think the thing to keep in the back of your head though, folks, is, you know, as much as there's a lot of uncertainty, and I don't think that we're going to— I'll be very surprised if we know with certainty by next week's podcast, which will be, what, 9 days after the election, if we know with certainty who the president is. I think it'll probably have become certain, but then we'll be starting to question whether or not it stays certain at that point. One way or another though, someday it will be resolved. We'll know who's president. You know what? There's gonna be more stimulus. Fiat currencies are going to be debased by governments, and there's going to be a lot of infrastructure spending and stimulus spending no matter what. So It's plenty of room to look at different ways this could go, but I think there are also some macro trends which are pretty darn clear already.
What do you think people should be focusing on in this period of uncertainty, Patrick? You talk every single day, almost every day, 4 days a week, you do webinars for your Big Picture Trading clients. What are you going to be focusing on in the next week or so when frankly, we don't know what the answer is yet? on the president?
Patrick Ceresna: I think the reaction in the bond market may have been overdone. There was an incredibly large amount of short interest in the bond market and it created a short squeeze. And that may have been more of a liquidity event than an indication of a new trend. And so I think the most important thing is that will the dollar continue to be weak? Will commodities continue to be strong? Is the gold breakout for real? And is the bond market going to follow through or was Or is this just a short-term liquidity event and then the bond market just comes back in line and all of those charts line up? That's, I think, the biggest thing to watch for, and that's what I'm going to continue to watch for with my members.
Erik Townsend: And listeners, if you want to tune in and join Patrick for those webinars, you can sign up for a free 14-day trial of Big Picture Trading. Just go to bigpicturetrading.com. We're going to leave it there for this week's episode. This episode was made possible by the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF. ticker URNM, a focused play on miners and holders of uranium.
And by the Perth Mint's GoldPass, the market-leading investment and trading app from the Perth Mint. Buy, sell, transfer, and redeem government-guaranteed gold securely on your smartphone. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook that we just discussed in the postgame. There's also a link to the Variant Perception blog titled Steeper and Cheaper, and a link to an article asking if oil prices are set to go higher year next year. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more Or we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Tian Yang — Variant Perception Head of Macro Research (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 243 was recorded on October 29th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all Accredited Investors. Variant Perception Head of Macro Research Tian Yang returns as this week's feature interview guest. Like most of the smartest guys we've had on MacroVoices in recent months, Tian's team sees inflation on the horizon, and they think a new secular bull market in commodities is on deck as well.
We'll discuss Tian's forecast for a new commodity bull market in detail in the feature interview, but then we're going to keep it rolling as Patrick and I pick up a chart deck of commodity charts in our postgame segment, including where some opportunities may lie in the months ahead. Then finally, we'll revisit the coronavirus outlook with new cases and deaths both moving to new highs in both the United States and globally.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's talk about this S&P 500. That pre-election volatility is here, and certainly we're getting these big intraday whips, but do you think it's leading to a new big trend?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think what's going on is very specific, and this is conjecture on my part. I could be wrong, but I think it's the combination of a big spike up in new coronavirus cases plus the outlook for a Biden win, which a lot of pollsters still think is, is by far the more likely outcome. That would equate to probably a new lockdown for the United States because Biden has been very outspoken in saying If the doctors and scientists recommend it, he will do another lockdown, whereas Trump has generally said the opposite. So I think a lot of the selling of stocks has been attributed to that particular concern. At the same time, I would say, however, that we're seeing stocks and bonds and even gold and Bitcoin selling off all at the same time. So that really smacks of plain old-fashioned deleveraging, liquidation flows, and that may Just be ahead of election uncertainty. People are de-risking portfolios generally, selling some of everything that they've got.
So it's really interesting to see how gold and bonds are performing here, not just stocks in this particular situation. I think there is a setup for an abrupt recovery in stock prices, either on a Trump win or on a reversal of the virus trends. And I think the reason that a Trump win would be an up for stocks is specifically because the market is concerned that a Biden win plus coronavirus cases spiking to new fresh all-time highs means a lockdown. And they know they're not gonna get a lockdown in a Trump presidency. I would not assume that we're gonna have all the answers next week because the election will have happened. I think a prolonged delay that takes potentially weeks after the election before we really know what the official result is, is a likelihood. So, and I think there's maybe a setup there too where a lot of people are kind Yeah. And I think that's what people are kind of assuming, okay, it's only one more week till the election, then we're gonna know.
I think that if we don't know for longer than consensus expects us not to know, if it turns into weeks as opposed to just days after the election before we get an official answer, I think that could potentially prolong the— and lead to further de-risking and deleveraging, pushing stock prices even lower. I think it would still be probably a setup for buy the dip eventually when we get that answer one way or the other and things start to stabilize. The only way I see it really just outright mushrooming down into a major bear market would be if there was a major, major uprising of civil unrest that escalates dramatically after the election, which is a distinct possibility. But I think some of that's already priced in. So as long as it's just mild civil unrest, that's probably already priced into the market.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to that US dollar because certainly as we are seeing this risk-off impulse, like you were suggesting, everything was selling, the US dollar is been rising in that environment, and we find ourselves a stone's throw away from the top of the multi-month range as we approach 94. Do you think the dollar has more upside, or is this just a little fake out?
Erik Townsend: Well, it might have more upside, but I would not interpret this move in the dollar as being the beginning of a new bull trend or something. What we're seeing here is a sudden and sharp turn up on the dollar coincident with Down in everything else. That is an indication of liquidation flows. People are selling stocks and bonds and gold all at the same time. That results in— those liquidations result in more dollars and more demand for dollars. So I would not assume that just because we are seeing a sharp upturn here, that it means that the macro backdrop has changed and the dollar is going to, you know, appreciate to new all-time highs. I think we're seeing the other side of a liquidation trade.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil 'cause we've got a nasty breakdown here. What's your take on how low oil can go here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think there could be quite a bit more downside here, but it really is gonna depend mostly on the coronavirus data and to a lesser extent on the election. Similar to what I said about the stock market, I think the combination of a Biden win plus increasing coronavirus infections makes the prospect of a US lockdown more likely. That's gotta have demand destruction effects on the demand for energy products. And clearly, that's one factor. It's broader though, because the oil market is a global market. And we're already seeing with Christine Lagarde's comments from the ECB this morning, that there is already in Europe, maybe a situation which is ahead of where it is in the United States. And they're already dealing with a serious escalation in coronavirus problems, and they're already moving back into lockdown mode. So regardless of the Biden win in that aspect, which I think is having an amplified effect on US stocks, oil is a more global asset.
And therefore, even though, you know, we're looking at the WTI crude price when we do these reports, it's still affected by the global price of oil. And, you know, there's a certain amount of transmission effect in prices between Brent and WTI. Inventory this week, crude oil building 4.3 million barrels, but we still had Cushing, Oklahoma drawing down 422,000 barrels, gasoline drawing down 892,000 barrels, and the really big drawdown, distillates, 4.5 million barrels. So even though we had a really big and unexpectedly big build on crude oil inventory, it was fully offset by larger net drawdowns on finished products, resulting in still a net drawdown in petroleum products on the week. The more important number in my mind, though, is not the inventory numbers, but US production not just ticking back up, but really kicking back up to 11.1 million barrels. That's up 1.2 million barrels on the week. And of course, it's not that there's a change in production that has just suddenly, you know, it's increasing at the rate of a million a week.
What's going on is the The storm effects, the tropical storm effects that had pushed us down to that 9.9 million barrel print that we discussed in last week's market wrap, that's been fully compensated. We've fully recovered back to where we were before the tropical storms hit the Gulf. So that pronounced decline in US production that Art Berman has said we might expect by the end of Q4, it's not here yet, at least certainly not this week. Tape action, the, the move down in crude oil prices really started earlier in the week based on API inventory, but more so on the big increase in coronavirus cases. We'll come back to the coronavirus situation, what's going on there, and what to expect next in the postgame segment after the feature interview. Time spreads also obviously rolling over here, but still performing better than the front month contract.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's touch on gold because gold looked like it was ready to break out even just a month ago, but it seems to have completely rolled over. We haven't broken the September lows yet, but, uh, it looks very toppy here. What's your take on what's going on in bullion?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think this is the most interesting market this week because if you wanted to say, okay, the reason the stock market is selling off is because everybody's worried about election risk and there's going to be civil unrest and so forth, You'd expect gold to be up, not down. The fact that you've got stocks and bonds and gold selling off all at the same time, and gold selling off pretty hard at the same time, really says to me liquidation flows. People just de-risking portfolios completely. Some of that may be mechanized. It may be because of the volatility that we've seen in the stock market that people are just de-risking. But frankly, it's kind of a mystery in my mind to see this happen now. If we had had a clean sweep election and it was very Very clear who the President of the United States was, and then gold sold off as big as it has, or even bigger than this, wouldn't have surprised me in the least bit.
But to see this happen now, before we know what the election result is gonna be, and when in fact there's probably good reason to think the election result is less certain than it was a week ago, at least that's the way I perceive it, why is gold selling off already? And I think if you did have a clean sweep and a very clear election result next week, you would see more selling in gold.
The 100-day moving average is now at 1,784. That would be my target if the selling continues. But the big question really in my mind at this point is, okay, how come it's happening already before the election, before we get an answer on whether civil unrest is going to escalate and the various other things that might have been holding it up? Why is it suddenly breaking down now? Could be technicals, just having broken that 100-day moving average might have led to more selling. But we've seen on a couple of daily candles now after breaking down below that level, If it was gonna, you know, just be a fake break to the downside and then suddenly recover, it would've happened by now. And even today's candle is still red as we're speaking. So it's a mystery in my mind, Patrick.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's finally touch on that 10-year Treasury yield because like you were suggesting that bonds were selling off when stocks were, and here we are, the yields at spot 8.4 on the upside. The bonds just have not acted as a hedge during this volatility. What's your take on the yields here?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think, as you say, what's going on is people are selling everything. They're selling stocks, but they're also selling bonds. They're selling gold. Why is that? Is it election-related? Is it coronavirus-related? I mean, those are the, the 2 big things going on. We've got a surprise increase in coronavirus cases and deaths. We'll get into that in more detail in the postgame segment. But, you know, why is, is this all happening at the same time? I, I really am surprised I'm not surprised by it. If this had happened after the election, I might have a different view on it. But for it to be happening right now suggests to me that people are just getting more uncertain. The people that were making directional bets on what was going to happen after the election just decided to go to cash and de-risk and wait this out. One of the things that could be leading to that is the various algorithmic traders, the mechanized systems.
When they get to a certain level of volatility, they just start de-risking portfolios. So it could be that what we're seeing here is risk parity funds are just starting to go through a mechanized de-risking process, selling their bonds and selling their stocks at the same time, because the correlations that they are designed to expect don't exist anymore. That's all I can think of. But something that certainly feels like liquidation flows is afoot here. And I think that also explains the move in the dollar index.
Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Variant Perception's Tian Yang. Erik, why did we invite Tian back?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, the Variant Perception guys always do a great job of approaching macro from a data-driven perspective. So as we've been talking to various guests about the conceptual macro framework of the reasons why it feels like inflation might be making a comeback and why it seems like there's a big question about where bond yields are headed from here, I wanted to I wanted to get somebody with a really data-driven perspective. And Tian is one of my favorite guys in that respect. And it came as no surprise to me when he sent us his slide deck. And sure enough, they're expecting a resumption of inflation and eventually a secular return to a commodity bull market. So it kind of confirms a lot of things we've been hearing from other guests, and I wanted to get it from a data-driven perspective. And the Variant Perception guys have always been good at that.
Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test But as
Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Tian is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Tian Yang, head of macro research for Variant Perception. Tian prepared a terrific chart deck for today's interview. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're not registered yet. Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the download, above Tian's picture.
Tian, it's great to get you back on the program. It's been way too long, frankly. And just looking at your slide deck, you know, it's very timely. We've been talking quite a bit on this program that I'm convinced at some point we get a secular shift to inflation. Commodities eventually have to bottom and we see a new upcycle in commodities. And boy, that's exactly what you've got in the first half of your deck here is the next commodity supercycle starting with inflation as a driver. So where do you guys see this inflation picture? Is it just around the corner or could it still be a year or two off?
Tian Yang: Thanks, Erik, and thanks for having me on the show again. As you say, I think right now there's a number of both structural and cyclical changes that are starting to come together for the next commodity supercycle. Obviously, we know over the past few years it's been somewhat of a widowmaker trade for people to be calling the bottom. But what's very interesting is that historically when you see major recessions, they often tend to kind of signal major trend changes or leadership changes. And obviously coming out of this recession in 2020, we see a number of kind of quite dramatic policy shifts. That means the structural pictures change. And obviously in addition, what we're seeing right now is that cyclically economies led by China starting to pick up at the same time as supply conditions actually quite constrained across a number of commodity sectors. So it's a very interesting point in time right now where we have this broader shift towards a more inflationary policy mix, a cyclical pickup in the economy.
And you also have a situation where financial assets obviously are very richly valued. Obviously, yields are starting to hit zero everywhere, yet inflation is expected to pick up. So you're also going to have this structural flow where investors have to think about what they do with their 60/40 portfolios, what they do with their fixed income assets, and eventually have to think about shifting it away more likely into real assets. And commodities obviously, um, going to be a big beneficiary of that as well. So, you know, there's a number of things kind of coming together right now to drive the next supercycle.
Erik Townsend: And where do you see the inflation story coming into this?
Tian Yang: So I think we need to think about inflation both from a structural point of view and a cyclical point of view. So the thing to say is cyclically, obviously, when unemployment rates are still quite high, when there's still capacity in the economy, you don't expect to see kind of immediate pickup in core inflation. Obviously, headline could tick up a little bit when commodity prices, industrial commodities, so forth, initially pick up. So on the cyclical front, there's not necessarily as much inflation pressure right now. But structurally, you know, we've seen some truly seismic shifts in the kind of policy landscape and the structure of the economy actually just this year. You know, when you see governments and developed market governments around the world start to run giant fiscal deficits funded by central banks, that's obviously a very dramatic shift away from independent central banking and the focus on inflation. You know, this is very much going back to the old Keynesian kind of playbook of essentially fiscal-led growth. And at the same time, we've obviously seen the US Federal Reserve do a number of quite dramatic shifts this year.
Firstly, moving to average inflation targeting is obviously quite a big admission that they don't really know where the NAIRU is. They don't really care where the NAIRU is. They're just going to run the economy and let it run hot. And such a policy is also pretty time inconsistent because it's not well defined, what's the period over which we're targeting average inflation. the incentive will always be, you know, as inflation picks up for policymakers to just run it hot because, you know, it's easier to kind of keep the party going. So, you know, both fiscal and monetary policy are starting to become a lot more expansionary and loose. And, you know, historical precedents for this kind of price action, you know, would probably go back to World War II with the Fed-Treasury Accord that essentially meant, you know, fiscal deficits would be very large. But there was a moral imperative for the central banks to finance the government deficits, and that ended up creating a lot of inflation. And obviously, this time around, the moral imperative is that the central bank's got to play their part with the pandemic.
And obviously, going into the future, the central bank probably has to play their part with addressing inequality, climate change, any of these big issues that essentially justifies why central banks should finance government deficits. So that's quite a dramatic policy shift. The other thing that's happened is that the Fed is now proactively kind of destroying the quality of its balance sheet. So again, at the extreme, if we go back to when we were on the gold standard, if you look at central bank balance sheet, obviously most currency is backed by gold, right? So obviously, a dollar is an asset for us, but for the central bank, a dollar is a liability, and then they back it on the asset side of their balance sheet with gold previously. Obviously, over time, as we abandon the gold standard and so forth, the quality of the central bank's balance sheet, their assets are getting worse and worse.
And obviously this year, the fact that they started buying corporate bonds, the fact that they're willing to take on fallen angels, high yield debt, and take on more credit risk is just another reflection of just the weakening central bank balance sheets that again, it's not necessarily immediate concern, but it lays the foundations for people to increase inflation expectations to really worry about.
You know, what the value of the dollar is. And so, you know, when you have these kind of structural shifts in policy coming together, coupled with the kind of deterioration in central bank balance sheets and government balance sheets, that's typically been the recipe for inflation expectations to become unhinged. So, you know, the way we've kind of described it is that we're moving towards more an ocean regime than a lake regime when it comes to inflation. So, you know, you should think of it as Essentially, if you have a boat that you can sail on the lake, it's probably not going to be good on the ocean. But, you know, you might be able to get away with a decent amount, but if the waves truly pick up on the ocean, then, you know, obviously a lake-worthy vessel might not make it when faced with very big waves. And we think that's the kind of way to think about inflation right now. We're no longer on the lake, we're moving towards more of an ocean where we need to sail through.
And, um, so what investors really need to think about right now is Whether there's any immediate risk of inflation or not, the key is that the risk premium that investors need to price in for inflation, especially in some of the longer duration assets, that needs to start to go up. You know, even though central banks are, you know, here, obviously we're gonna have lower for longer and so forth. You know, we still have term premium being very negative. These are things that don't really make sense when we're moving to a more inflationary kind of environment. And so, you know, even over the past few months, what we've seen with the rise in yields, a lot of it's being driven by the term premium. Which is obviously going from deeply negative to less negative. And so I think a lot of these things need to start to happen right now, just so investors accurately price in the risk of inflation, let alone actually seeing any inflation come through.
Erik Townsend: Tian, I love the picture on page 5, where you're talking about lake and ocean regimes of inflation. Needless to say, you're not talking about necessarily a really calm Easy day out on the ocean, but maybe a stormy day. Now, I wanna go back to what you said, because it seems to me that the game is very different this time around, in that you drew an analogy to, okay, after World War II, we moved to a whole lot of deficit spending, which should be inflationary.
The thing is, after World War II, we were still, as you said, on a gold standard, and the big inflation didn't really get unleashed until we came after the gold standard with the breakdown of Bretton Woods in 1971.
Tian Yang: Right.
Erik Townsend: Now, this time around, we're going to have, I think, the same, if not a greater shift to public policy emphasis on major, major spending programs with a lot of deficit spending. But we're already in a pure fiat environment. So nobody's pretending there's a constraint on how much money you can print in order to finance government spending. I would think that means that the inflation is Certainly not delayed by 20 years the way it was after World War II, but is it immediate or is there still a lag of several years before that inflation really hits the system in terms of consumer price inflation after those progenerative factors like deficit spending kick in? How long does it take before we really see the inflation start to get away?
Tian Yang: Yeah, I mean, obviously that's a great question. I guess it's a little bit like You know, when they say about how people go bankrupt, right? It happens very slowly and all at once. I think this is kind of the analogy we're kind of drawing here, because we're talking about obviously a shift in inflation expectations, which is obviously predicated on just kind of the general belief in the system. These things are obviously inherently fairly hard to predict, but what we can do is kind of position for it when it already makes sense. So So when markets are already not pricing in much inflation risk premiums, and also obviously as the economy cyclically picks up, those are things that are going to help just drive a more kind of normal reflation cycle.
So right now, if you position for that, then obviously when the tail comes through and potentially more inflation picks up later, you're kind of on the right side of it. In terms of the mechanism, you know, it could, as you say, potentially it could happen quickly or it could take a few years. I mean, if we're in a kind of 1960s-style environment, then obviously what you'd need to do is you would need to kind of go along for the excess capacity in the economy to be used up first, and then inflation picks up. And then you would need that to feed into kind of a shifting inflation expectations higher, and then you should move into more of a wage-price spiral. Then when people think inflation is going higher, they're going to demand higher wages. And that's what really kind of kicks off kind of the more uncontrolled kind of inflation right now.
Arguably right now, for a lot of people, you know, say living in the United States, the actual cost of living inflation has actually already been a lot higher than what CPI would be saying. You know, if you look at shadow stats inflation and these kind of different projections, you know, they would say inflation has been running at 4 or 5% annually for the past 20 years. You know, if you get rid of a lot of the hedonic adjustments and so forth.
And arguably, it's actually this mismatch between what official CPI says, and what people feel is their true cost of living, that gap is also fueling a lot of the populism and the kind of general discontent that we have been seeing in society. And by the way, this isn't new, right? It's just, it's just quite rare that we see it in developed markets. If you take emerging market economies, say like Argentina, or these places that have been known to have huge inflations, this is typically what happens. You know, the population doesn't believe in the CPI, they think their real cost of living It's going up a lot higher. So when it comes to wage negotiations, you know, they demand CPI plus 5, plus 10%, and then obviously wages go up a lot more than inflation, and then you get the wage-price spiral.
So I think it will probably take a little bit of time for these dynamics to truly kick in the US, but the first step is obviously use up the spare capacity in the economy, which is going to generate some inflation, and then we'll see how we go from there.
Erik Townsend: Tian, let's talk about how this translates for portfolios. It sounds like we're very much in agreement that inflation's coming. But it's kind of hard to know exactly when and how it shows up. Probably when it does show up, it shows up in a big way. You don't want to be caught by surprise, but you don't know that it's happening right away. So what do you do in terms of your portfolio in order to be ready for that?
Tian Yang: Yeah, well, that's kind of the million-dollar question at the moment, isn't it? So the first thing to note is, I think I mentioned briefly at the start, clearly, So more traditional portfolio constructs, the kind of 60/40 or the heavy allocation to fixed income, it's naturally kind of getting to the end of the road. I think most people recognize that as yields bump up against kind of the zero bound, the ability for your fixed income portion to really offer a diversified impact or a hedge to equity risk is going to obviously diminish.
So going forward, what's very interesting about commodities is that one of the unique properties of commodities is typically when commodity volatility is high, commodity prices actually tend to go up a lot. And this is quite different to equities, because obviously normally for equities, it's only when equities are crashing that volatility picks up. Whereas for commodities, the volatility tends to be to the upside. So there's a few of these natural properties for commodities that lend itself well to mix in with equity risk. So, you know, we do see the potential for people to think a lot harder about commodities and real assets.
Now, the thing to say about commodities obviously is that one of the big reasons why it tends to be very high volatility is that there tends to be quite prolonged periods of demand and supply mismatches for the industry, just because typically supply responses can take a long time. You know, if you're going to build a new mine or, you know, drill a new well or build a new plant, you know, it could, you know, sometimes it could take up to 3 to 5 years. Obviously, if it's like the super efficient shale well, maybe it takes 1 year. To get it going. But for a lot of commodity sectors, if you're going to build a refinery or build a chemical plant, things like that, it's going to be 3 to 5 years. And because of that very delayed supply response, you end up with this prolonged period of demand-supply mismatches. And so that's kind of what we're starting to see right now, where for a lot of commodity sectors that are more capital scarce, there's been a prolonged period of a lack of investment, a lack of CAPEX.
And so, you know, these are sectors that we would expect to have quite explosive upside as the kind of economy recovers and as demand comes back.
So I think in the slide deck, there's a section, page 15, where, you know, I mentioned the capital cycle. So, and I think this is a very interesting framework to actually think about when we're trying to decide where to invest in. So, you know, the capital cycle, I think the best thing that I've read, or that's really inspired us on this, was some pieces written by Marathon Asset Management. And it was basically collated together in a book called Capital Returns: Investing Through the Asset Cycle. And the book was put together by Edward Chancellor. And so the basic idea is that obviously, if there's a lot of money flowing to a particular industry or sector, then that inflow of money will cause a lot more competition within that industry, which drives down returns. And then as returns fall very low, then obviously nobody in the industry can make a profit. So naturally, you know, companies will need to go bust or companies will need to leave the industry.
And in turn, that restores more profitability. So, you know, lots of businesses are kind of going through these cycles over time. And what we've tried to do is take that insight and try to apply it quantitatively and essentially proxy for capital scarcity by looking at things like, you know, how much CAPEX or R&D spending is going on in the industry relative to its asset base, you know, how much are assets depreciating, how much are assets being written down, how much are assets, you know, being amortized away, and they're essentially ranking different industries using this metric.
And so what's very interesting is right now what we see is that for a number of commodity-related industries, they are showing up as incredibly capital scarce right now. Oil and gas, metals and mining, precious metals, gold mining, and gold and silver and so forth. A lot of these sectors are showing up as just very capital scarce, which obviously lends themselves well to kind of a more prolonged upcycle and kind of a longer boom period. So those are some of the things that's come out from our analysis.
And so again, I think this is a quite cute way of combining a more top-down view with a more bottom-up driven approach. So as you say, the top-down view is very much about the shift to inflation, the fact investors are underweight, and the need for them to look for ways to hedge that inflation risk, which drives them towards commodities. And then from the bottom-up side, what we're seeing from an industry level, from a balance sheet perspective, is that a lot of these commodity sectors are very capital scarce, have been for a number of years, which has caused them to delay or cancel CAPEX projects. And, you know, it's caused supply to tighten a lot in a number of these industries so that, you know, as demand comes back or as the cycle picks up again, that there's not much room for supply to respond. So you get very outsized price moves. You know, if we just say, look at gold, right, the kind of magnitude of the move has been quite dramatic over the past few years after a very long and lengthy kind of bear market.
So, you know, that's the kind of dynamic we're trying to look for in some of these other sectors as well.
Erik Townsend: Let's talk about the pandemic and the effects that it has on the macro backdrop and where these trends are headed, because it seems to me, as we're speaking, we're just in the last few days getting a pretty significant spike in both new cases and deaths, both globally as well as in the United States.
It seems to me like on the one hand, this pandemic's probably going to last longer than most people expect. The demand destruction is probably going to last longer. That has has maybe some suppressive effect on prices, but boy, the capital destruction and the lack of investment that you're talking about is really being exacerbated. So it seems to me like this is really a setup for maybe prices to stay depressed because of the pandemic until they're not anymore, and then holy cow, the upside could just be out of sight. Do you see it the same way? Am I misinterpreting that?
Tian Yang: Broadly speaking, I would agree. The one thing I would say is obviously it's almost a little bit dangerous to talk about the pandemic just because it's kind of taken on such a political or moral tone when people talk about it. But obviously what we're trying to do is just try and be objective and just follow the data and see what's going on. And actually, broadly speaking, what we're finding is that in the second and third waves for developed markets, you know, like in Europe and so forth, the kind of follow-through, the impact in terms of hospitalization and deaths versus back in March and April, actually this time around it's actually a bit lower, which is probably why governments are trying to strike more of a balance between the economy, between the economy and health policy. Obviously, you know, I'm based in London and there's a lot more of a focus on more localized lockdowns. But again, this time they're trying to keep schools open. You know, they're trying to let people keep going to work and obviously trying to keep businesses open as well.
So it does feel like the second wave is— the impact is looking a lot less. And that seems to be the way the market's kind of pricing it as well. And in turn, government policy hasn't quite been as draconian as back in March, April. So, you know, you kind of have this factor and obviously potentially, you know, vaccines and things look to be coming as well. So when you put it together, yes, you know, things are bad. But realistically, if you start to look ahead 6 months, 1 year, it seems much more likely things are going to get better than not.
So on the demand side, it does feel like we're at somewhat of an nadir. And then on the supply side, as you say, you know, supply destruction has been real, right? If we look at shale, you know, the drop in production has been huge. There's been lots of bankruptcies that's come through. So yeah, it does feel like quite a rare setup that we're seeing right now. The key is obviously making sure that we position in a way that we can survive if the downturn does go a bit longer than needed and just to capture the upside. But yeah, broadly speaking, I would agree.
Erik Townsend: Tian, it sounds like you and I are in very strong agreement that maybe we can't call the exact timing, but at some point, a really big move up in commodity prices And that is driven by a combination of lack of investment, that capital shortfall that you talked about, increasing inflation expectations, deficit spending. All of these macro forces sooner or later are going to come to bear on these markets. There's lots of different ways to invest in commodities. Some people invest in the commodity itself through the futures market. Other people invest in the commodity-producing Mining companies through either ETFs or direct stock plays. Some people try to do that with a broad brush of commodity producers generally in a very broad-brushed ETF. Other people are, let's look at specifically which junior mining company is going to find the next uranium deposit that's going to change the world.
How do you think about this at Variant Perception? If your view is commodities have a major supercycle ahead of them, Yeah. Are you getting positioned in the equities? Are you getting positioned in commodity ETFs? Or are you taking some different approach? How do you think about this?
Tian Yang: Yeah, so I think it depends a little bit on obviously your ability to execute. But obviously equities, and in particular investing in the equity of the producers, is probably the most simple way to do it. Because obviously you can just execute it once. There isn't the issues with the roll and so forth.
A lot of the bad news of gold group being priced in. And obviously if you can find the better quality management, they can kind of help you address some of the issues with the cycle.
What I would say is if you do it directly via commodities, it's doable. But what we found is that if you're going to invest directly in the commodities, you actually do still need to rebalance regularly. As I mentioned a bit earlier, the nature of commodities is that the volatility is to the upside. And so when you have a basket of commodities, what happens often you'll get one or two that really starts going materially higher. And obviously as a proportion of your portfolio, they tend to get very big. And if you don't regularly rebalance it and balance out the kind of relative risk distribution across the commodities you're long, it's actually quite detrimental. Like a lot of the value comes from the fact that it's very volatile. So rebalancing regularly actually allows you to kind of effectively buy low, sell high. So I think that's probably a bit harder to actually implement in practice for a lot of investors.
So I think for us, we've generally gone down the route of looking at the equities. Now, the issue with the equities is that if you take a step back and look at a lot of these commodity cycles over kind of history, what we find is that because they tend to be very capital-intensive sectors, they're obviously subject to kind of boom-bust cycles. And the nature of boom-bust cycle is that for the industry as a whole, if you buy and hold it through that time, they tend to, you know, a lot of times actually destroy value in aggregate. So then it becomes actually quite important to either time the cycle well, or it becomes very important to pick out the relative winners within the sectors and within the companies. So in our view, we're kind of trying to get the best of both worlds right now, where we feel like the timing is actually pretty good right now coming out of a recession. But at the same time, we think there But, you know, there's a lot of value to be gained from doing some stock selection right now.
So for example, in something like oil and gas, broadly speaking, you can almost break it down into either very safe infrastructure like, you know, midstream assets that you can potentially invest in. So, you know, if some, you know, if say BP Midstream or Shell Midstream, right, if they have the only pipelines that run up from the Gulf of Mexico, nobody else is going to come along and, uh, and just build another pipeline alongside you, right? This is yours. This is basically the entrenched So as the market picks up, this is obviously still a very good quality asset, and obviously you can pick it up for 50 cents on the dollar, let's say, right? So that will be kind of a very conservative way of doing some stock selection and then picking stuff with very good asset values that has a potential to rerate, and that can still be cash flow positive even during the downturn right now.
The other way to then do it, to think about, is look for an aggressive way to gain exposure as well. And then digging through a little bit in terms of the quality producers, say on the E&P side, guys that have more track record, the Lundin family obviously have a very good track record. Companies like Parex and so forth are generally considered to be well-managed, better quality assets. And so these are where you're investing knowing that if the prices go up, the upside can be a lot higher than some of the, say, infrastructure type plays, but also with a bit more risk.
So I think that that's probably the way to play it. Actually, yes, timing-wise is good, and then going for the ETFs, you'll probably be okay. But if it's possible to do some more kind of stock selection on top, there will likely be a lot of value add just because the nature of boom-bust cycles in industries in general is that there tends to be a lot of also-rans in the industry that historically have destroyed a lot of shareholder value.
Erik Townsend: Let's break this down in terms of categories of commodities. Obviously, energy is central to the economy. I think there's lots of reason to want to really look after this election to where the trends are going to be headed in terms of green energy and so forth to make some investment decisions there. But you move on to base metals. Copper, of course, is the widely respected proxy for the general economy. So copper mining seems like a place if you're getting ready for a big economic expansion, a lot of infrastructure spend, Seems like a place to be. Agriculture is probably going to get more important. Precious metals. How do you think about the whole world of commodities and how do you approach those sectors in terms of where you allocate?
Tian Yang: Yeah, so obviously ESG and green energy and the energy transition are very important secular trends, but I think the nature of these trends is They do tend to take time. And actually, the history of a lot of commodity cycles, how things have ended, how the coal cycle has done previously, whale oil, rubber, there's been a lot of secular commodity boom-bust cycles I've already seen over history.
We have previous examples of, and usually these cycles are heavily politically driven at the end. So it's not so much economics, it tends to be politics that comes into it. So certainly, if we're looking energy, some of the more fossil fuels, the headwind is there. But the thing to note is that, you know, the investment is almost a bit like— the worst case is you're treating it like, you know, a last dance kind of investment, right? Things are so bad, but it's still so essential to the economy that there's at least one more upcycle in it.
And even the most aggressive kind of net zero by 2050 plans, you know, you're still going to give a lot of these industries kind of a 5 to 10 year window. That's actually not that dissimilar from the And obviously from 2030 onwards, a lot of the transitions are expected to kind of accelerate. So I think those medium-term headwinds are certainly there. And obviously they're more argument against the kind of buy and hold forever case. But what they also do is obviously discourage a lot of CapEx and investment and R&D into the sector. So if anything, in terms of what these longer-term headwinds are doing is they're exacerbating the current kind of supply-demand imbalance. So you're just going to have a situation where supply is going to be constrained for the foreseeable future.
Nobody wants to invest here. Yet as the economy recovers and picks up, you know, there's still a lot of demand. You know, obviously the transition to electric vehicles and so forth, there's a lot of argument about how quickly it happens. But, you know, I just use simple rules of thumb, right? If I think about how long, you know, cars are well made, you know, a typical new car can probably last, what, like 10— let's say like 6, 7, 8 years, right? I mean, most cars can— you can probably drive it for 10 years and they're still quite good right now. So if overnight everybody goes, stops using petrol-fueled or diesel-fueled cars and moves to electric, because the average car is used for 7, 8, 9 years, it's still going to take you that long, right, to slowly phase out. And that's obviously at the most extreme, assuming everyone changes overnight. So I think it's just more, these are factors that for the more traditional fossil fuels, they are headwinds, but a lot of it does seem to be in the price.
So there you're very much going for like a more value play plus kind of cyclical rebounds. On something like copper, that's probably where you're trying to be more aligned with the kind of ESG megatrends and so forth. So one of the very interesting things is that obviously, because you don't have the ESG or the green headwinds, the valuations will obviously for those sectors naturally be a bit higher. But at the same time, you're a lot more likely to benefit from a kind of arms race between say the US and China to go out and electrify And, you know, go for green technology and to build out, you know, electrical grids and build out, you know, charging stations, all these things. So I think that they do still broadly fit because they're all capital scarce, but conditional on them being capital scarce, obviously energy, fossil fuels are much, much cheaper in terms of valuation than some of the other sectors. But obviously the play is a bit different, right?
If you go for the fossil fuel, you're going for more value, you're going for kind of the last hurrah big cycle. At least, right? Whereas if you're going for the copper or some of the other battery related, right? So like, you know, lithium, nickel, a lot of these sectors. One is a lot of the other ones probably aren't as capital scarce because, you know, people are kind of more open to investing there. And obviously when you have more capital available, it actually is not so good for investor returns. But the plus side is that potentially, you know, because of the world we live in, you know, geopolitics, you know, the kind of arms race in trying to transition economies towards more greener technologies that, you know, we've seen China, you know, their voracious appetite for a lot of these commodities, right?
China consumes half the world's copper, but only, you know, they only have 5% of the production. So they're going around the world trying to buy up mines, secure supplies everywhere. And obviously, as depending on who comes in, obviously the polls suggest Biden comes in. But regardless, we also see that for a lot of developed countries as well, there's a more shift towards embracing fiscal spending, infrastructure spending, and so forth that again necessitates, you know, more demand for commodities.
Erik Townsend: It certainly makes an argument for copper because you've got the double win that an infrastructure spend is going to benefit copper and a green spend is going to benefit copper because of the electric vehicle play. Are there any other, you know, double whammies that you can think of for investors where there's, there's a double win in a particular play that So the challenge with it is not so much just a double win.
Tian Yang: I think it's whether it's in the price, it's in the valuations and what's embedded. So I think that's the challenging thing. Obviously for battery technology things, as I mentioned, lithium, nickel, some of these minerals are actually going to be quite important, rare earth metals, right? These are all things that ultimately are going to be quite essential.
But in terms of where the price is, probably not Not as cheap as some of the more fossil fuels. So I think it's more investor preference and the trade-off rather than necessarily picking one in the absolute sense. I think copper is one we've chosen to highlight because it's still in somewhat of a sweet spot where the industry is being flagged as actually being very capital scarce, and yet it has this double whammy kind of tailwind behind it of infrastructure or green energy. So I think that that's what is probably somewhat more unique about copper. Versus some of the other ones where it's not really as capital scarce.
Erik Townsend: And how do precious metals fit into this whole story?
Tian Yang: Yeah, so obviously gold and silver are slightly different in that a lot of investors don't think of them as commodities, but more as just obviously an alternative to fiat currency. And obviously because of that property, it does fit in with the kind of whole inflation, changing inflation regime we've discussed. But what makes gold miners and silver miners very interesting is that that there's potentially, you know, a bit more upside than even owning the metals themselves. Owning the metals themselves obviously is just more part of the classic hedge. And obviously if you want to own physical gold, it's about, you know, also dealing with the fact that potentially not only the world's going to turn more inflationary, but perhaps, you know, taxes are going to pick up, there's going to be more expropriation of wealth, you know, a lot of these trends that typically accompany kind of more inflation regimes, right? Or that tend to come out from very unequal societies.
So owning the physical metal is kind of the ultimate hedge against a lot of those things. So, you know, that aside, assuming you don't care as much about some of these more, more risk, you know, risks like expropriation and so forth, if you're willing to kind of live with that risk, then what's interesting is obviously gold miners are still relatively cheap compared to the gold themselves, because obviously as a sector, you know, gold last peaked in 2011. You know, the sector's been through kind of almost 8, 9 years of a prolonged bottoming bear market process. You know, capital's fully dried up. So it's a very, very capital-scarce sector. So for the guys that are surviving who still have, you know, the reserves in the ground and the operations, you know, they're potentially set to really benefit. You know, now the gold prices are picking up and then they can start mining and really churning out cash flow. So there, you know, all the same arguments we talked about, right? You know, inflation and so forth apply for precious metals, but going for the miners potentially gives you that extra better performance on the upside.
And the trade-off is obviously that, you know, you don't get to own the physical gold. So if you're really, really worried about, you know, rising taxes, appropriation, you know, you need to have your gold in a vault in Switzerland, then obviously you probably want the physical.
Erik Townsend: Well, Tian, I can't thank you enough for another terrific interview. It's great to have you back. Before I let you go, tell us a little bit more about what you do at Variant Perception and where people can find out more about your work.
Tian Yang: Yeah, so Variant Perception is a data-driven independent research provider. So we're essentially trying to come up with very macro top-down views backed up by data. And then when the top-down data leads us to interesting places, we'll go and do some micro work and come up with a broad thesis as well. So if listeners are interested in a trial or to see some of our reports, please visit variantperception.com and fill out the necessary forms there.
Erik Townsend: It's great to have you. We look forward to getting you back in a few months for another update. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Erik Townsend: Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics.
If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Tian. I'm looking forward to getting into the commodity chartbook and talking about all sorts of the commodity trends, but we got a lot of feedback about our show last week. week with Stephanie Kelton. What's your take on all of that?
Erik Townsend: You know, it was really interesting, Patrick. We've got more feedback on last week's episode than any other episode we've ever done in 5 years of MacroVoices. And what I really found interesting, whether it was the tweets on Twitter or the emails that we received, there were just so many polarized responses. Some people are just hailing Stephanie Kelton as the visionary savior of the The angel who's going to rescue the economy from damage done by capitalism or whatever it is. And then we've got about an equal number of Stephanie Kelton is the Antichrist. I can't believe you had her on your show.
And it's really amazing to me, Patrick, because what I don't think most of the people responding really seem to take to heart is, you know, I'm not endorsing MMT as a good idea. Frankly, I don't think it is. But I'm telling you, it's coming. Yeah. And the most important lesson I've ever learned in investing is not to focus on what you want to happen or what you think should happen or what you're convinced the best thing for the world is, but rather, what are the other people doing? What's the market doing? And what's going on here, whether you like it or not, and I don't happen to like it, is the view that Stephanie Kelton is advocating, which is that it's a good idea for governments to print all the money they need and only be constrained by inflation starting to run away. That's gaining a huge amount of political traction. And I think that governments are likely to print a whole bunch more money before this is over.
I really encourage those of you who were writing in with angry messages about Stephanie Kelton and body parts and 4-letter words, Look, get over it and just accept that whether we like it or not, it's happening. And you've got to start to think about how to structure your portfolio around a reality that you might not happen to personally agree with.
But I'll get off my soapbox now. Let's move on to the Postgame Chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, it means that you're not registered yet at MacroVoices.com.
Erik Townsend: Just go to our homepage, look for the red button that says, looking for the download? just above Tian Yang's picture.
Patrick, commodities and commodity stocks. Let's keep the ball rolling from the great interview we just did with Tian and actually get into the charts and look at this. Starting just as a point of reference before we get to commodities with the S&P 500 stock index on page 2. What do you make of this chart? We haven't quite taken out those September lows yet, but kind of looks like that's coming.
Patrick Ceresna: I think that the pre-election volatility is exactly that. I mean, we had a little bit of a circumstance where dealers are not providing the same amount of liquidity they were before for risk management purposes. At the same time, there's a very large move to deleverage portfolios. And so it's an imbalance, but it's likely an imbalance that lies just before the elections rather than some sustained trend into the new year, at least until we see the results. After the election results, there might be new trends emerging, but I don't necessarily think you wanna overread into the, most immediate price action as a forecast as to where the markets are going to move forward. But what I really wanted to capture, just this chart in reference to what's happening in the Euro Stoxx on page 3. And what's interesting is how the tail is very different in Europe. Obviously, the most recent breakdown is because of the new wave of lockdowns that they're doing across Europe from coronavirus, which we'll talk about toward the tail end of this session.
But what is interesting is the Euro Stoxx never made it back to those March, February, March highs and spent the majority of the summer over the 4 months consolidating sideways before breaking down. The European and many developed markets actually look much more bearish than the US equity markets. And I just thought it was important to reference that when looking at equities. On page 4, I wanted to just reference the dollar because we are gonna talk commodities and one of the drivers of commodities and reflation cycles is currency trend. And so it's interesting that the dollar did not break down to a lower low. And rather now we continue to see the establishment of a consolidation zone throughout the summer and August, September here along that 92 to 94 level. I think it's going to be a really important determinant of the short-term commodity cycle as to which way this dollar moves in the post-election period.
And I think that's something that we have to watch very closely. Right?
Erik Townsend: I couldn't agree more. But again, with the caveat that the big action that we're seeing in the last couple of days, I don't think there's a new macro impetus that's driving the dollar higher. I think it's just the other side of liquidation flows. For some reason, ahead of this election, people got spooked. Maybe it's the combination of the election and the coronavirus fears that have suddenly really hit the tape. People are selling everything, and that results in dollar up, everything else down.
Patrick Ceresna: And so this is where I wanted to go through some of the different commodities, because so many things that Tian was saying I wholeheartedly agree with. In fact, I'm very bullish commodities in general in terms of the opportunity. Of course, the issue with all these commodities in many cases is that they're trading very poorly and they've been consolidating for extended periods of time. And the real opportunity this bull market is about identifying when some of these major lows will come in and establish the, the next big buying opportunity. And, and no better example of that is the energy space. So I wanted to start here with this crude oil chart, and we can see that it's breaking to multi-month lows. We haven't seen these kind of levels on crude oil since that, that May-June period where oil was off of those incredibly awful levels where it was during that crash where, where the front month went negative.
What's going to be really interesting is that if you take, let's say, the bottom of, um, gold and silver during 2015 and '16, there was these prolonged periods where they spent basing and retesting lows to establish where the ultimate bottom comes in. One of the things that I'm going to be watching here on crude In spite of all the demand issues and all of the pressure that's coming here, if crude oil does not make it all the way back to its previous lows and establishes higher lows and really consolidates in here, that might be a really good base to lean on when starting to buy at some point in the new year. But it certainly looks really weak here for the next few weeks, for sure.
Erik Townsend: Yeah, I think it's gonna be really interesting to see what those next few weeks bring. We've been predicting, as our regular listeners know, I've been anticipating all All summer long, I thought we would get a test of the low 30s. Finally, we're either starting to do that or just on the cusp of it or something. One of the things I think that can be a little misleading just looking at this particular contract chart, if you look back at the April highs on this chart, it looks like we're actually already below that level. But the reason for that is this is the contract chart, it's just the December contract, and back in April, the December contract was nowhere close to being the front month. Now it is the front month contract, and that distorts the chart a little bit.
If you look at a continuous contract chart, you see that the April high was around $28 and change, still well below the current market. And I would say that is kind of a target that I think about. It's— you can't see it on this particular chart, but if you look at a continuous Yeah. If you look at the continuous contract chart and you look at where that April high is, it's $28, $28, almost $29.
In that range is where I would kind of expect things to bottom out in this cycle unless we get a major escalation of the coronavirus crisis where, you know, it turns out the, the second wave is much worse than the first wave and, you know, the whole world goes back into lockdown and everything is Completely shut down again.
Short of that, I think that somewhere between 29 and 33 is likely to be my best guess for where this current trend is going to bottom out. Could be that it's already over, but, you know, we've still got a week till the election. Coronavirus numbers are getting higher every day. I think we've still got room to go lower here. I'll be surprised if we get, let's say, below 26. at any point here on the front month contract, that would really say to me that things are substantially breaking down. And who knows where we're headed from there? I don't think it's going to happen though. I would guess that $26 is an extreme and a more likely target is around $28.50 or so for this move.
Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so I want to move on and just touch on what's going on in the energy companies because Tian was talking about the idea of some opportunities in the energy equity space. And so the next 3 charts, page 6, 7, and 8, I have the energy ETFs. Starting on page 6 is just the much broader energy trust ETF by the SPDR, the XLE. And what's particularly interesting about the energy space is that while oil continued to press higher all the way out into August, what's interesting is the energy stocks all peaked out in early June.
Erik Townsend: June.
Patrick Ceresna: And by the time August rolled around, they were already in a multi-month consolidation, you know, 10%, 20%, 30% off of their highs in many cases. And what's interesting is, is that these energy stocks that have been pretty much in a clean downtrend for 6 months are slowly approaching the lows they saw all the way back in March. And while the ETF hasn't made it all the way down there, some of the big behemoths like the ExxonMobils were literally testing their closing lows from March.
And so at some point I asked the question, when have these energy stocks already priced in all of this weakness in oil? They've been selling a lot sooner than oil turned, and they're already at levels where when crude was down in the 20s and even lower. And so it'll be really interesting to see whether or not um, we start to see bottoms establish themselves in the energy company space.
But moving on to chart 7, I have the, um, Alerian MLP ETF, symbol AMLP. And what's interesting about this is that what Tian was talking about, the midstreams and a lot of pipeline and other, uh, plays— and what's interesting is that this is one of these big high dividend paying plays on, on these MLPs. And what's interesting is, is that This right now is paying an extraordinary large dividend, largely because I think most investors are anticipating dividend cuts. And what the question is, is how much of it has been priced in and how deep will those dividend cuts inevitably be? Because at some point, locking in some of these really cheap prices for these big robust dividends may actually be a really interesting idea.
And finally, on page 8, what I wanted to just touch on was the VanEck Vectors Oil Refiners ETF. A symbol CRAK. And what we've seen as well is the gasoline demand has generally been weak and the crack spreads have been incredibly narrow. I think most recently they dropped all the way down to a $7 spread.
And what we're seeing is a lot of those refiners just all the way back down to the lows, whether you're talking about like a Holly Frontier already breaking below March lows or the Phillips 66s of the world.
They've all been incredibly weak And it's going to be really interesting if there is some sort of a commodity bull market that's going to come on the other side of it with these, all of these sectors in many cases trading very close to all-time lows. The question is, is this starting to get to that level where you back up the truck and start buying up some of these companies knowing that inevitably if you have a long enough time horizon, there's big money to be made? As an example, For many of these energy companies, if they just return back to the highs they had in June when coronavirus already was priced in, many of them are doubles from these levels. And so it's really interesting to see what kind of opportunities may emerge here.
Erik Townsend: You know, I do think that there's plenty of room to see a double bottom or even a new lower low on these energy names. And the reason is, if you remember the market mindset, set back in the spring, despite the fact that we had this epic crisis on our hands. Everybody was talking about, okay, is the vaccine that cures everything and gets the V-shaped recovery totally launched 3 months away, or is it 6 months away? And the idea that there's really no good reason to expect a functional vaccine anytime soon, considering that there's never There's never been an RNA virus vaccine that's been effective in humans ever. It wasn't sinking in. Everybody assumed it was just around the corner.
And I think what you're seeing in these charts and the reason that crude oil is performing differently than the equities is at the time when you saw that big rally happening in May and into the beginning of June, whether it be on the XLE or on CRAK or what have you, The assumption was this horrible thing has happened, but, you know, the worst is over and it's all ending now. The idea that the virus crisis might come in multiple waves, that it might become endemic, that it might be something that we just have to learn to live with, and that it could be affecting the economy for the next 10 years— nobody was ready to listen to any of that back then. And now they're starting to get it. So I think that there is potential, especially if we do get another wave of the crisis that freaks everybody out. People are panic selling. I think you could easily see a new lower low on some of these stock prices.
I don't think you're gonna go to a lower low than minus $40 on front month crude oil, but to get to a new lower low in the stocks, I think is entirely possible. And I do think it would be a great buying opportunity because whether there is a vaccine or we just learn to live with this, one way or another, life is gonna go on. We're gonna eventually figure things out. And there's always gonna be demand for energy.
Patrick Ceresna: That's right. So moving on to the uranium chart on page 9. I mean, we had that great uranium special just a few weeks back and just wanted to look at where the charts are. I mean, overall, the spot price of uranium has been slightly consolidating off of its highs, but overall, it really does look like uranium bottomed back in 2016 and '17. And really, we've seen it slowly starting to improve. And what's interesting is that when we go to page 10 and look at where uranium stocks are trading, or the miners of uranium, this is the North Shore Global Uranium Mining ETF, the URNM. We can see here that we're at highs near $34 on this, well off in a very nice uptrend that was established off the March low. And really the last 2 months has seen a pretty clean and substantial correction. And it'll be really interesting as we approach those consolidations in late 2019 and throughout May and June of this year, whether this is going to be where a short-term bottom establishes itself and whether there'll be a buying opportunity here.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. And I think that if you look at what happened in March too, there was no real logical reason for uranium to sell off the way it did. It sold off because everything was selling off and people were panicking. I think that if we do get, whether it be election uncertainty, Mm-hmm. Or if it's a result of another wave of coronavirus. If we get another market freakout where, you know, everybody is just selling everything and uranium tanks again, it doesn't even need to go as low as it did.
If we get back down to anything close to those March lows, I would be buying it hand over fist. I'm really kicking myself because I was following the uranium story after we'd interviewed Marin Katusa on it a couple A couple of times. And I didn't think of it in March when it hit those low numbers. I wasn't paying attention. I wish that I bought that bottom when it happened. And I wouldn't be surprised if we had another opportunity where uranium prices get distressed and it's a real back-the-truck-up opportunity. I've already got some URNM in my portfolio, but I would certainly add more if we had another March-type event.
Patrick Ceresna: So I wanted to just quickly touch on gold on page 11. And this is— we already talked about this in the, at the start of the show when the market wrapped, just the way gold is rolling over. And, you know, the idea that gold could consolidate towards where it was consolidating back in April, May, and June, you know, just below $1,800, is entirely on the table if it breaks to that September low. But one, one of the interesting things is that it is still a very distinct uptrend, and these types of market corrections tend to backfill and correct such big advances. And so what will be really interesting is, is, uh, will we see that this is just contained to like a 50% retracement of that big rally? And if it does, will the buy on dips emerge from there? It's, uh, going to be interesting.
But what I wanted to really though talk about is page 12, which is the gold miners themselves. And Tian also talked about them in there as an opportunity. And what's interesting is that the gold miners— well, I mean, the gold miners more or less seem seem pretty correlated to gold as they pretty much peaked in the same week and have been more or less consolidating. But it'll be interesting to see whether or not these gold miners do consolidate in a similar manner down into the low 30s and whether that's going to be where the compelling buy-on-dip opportunity emerges.
Erik Townsend: I agree, Patrick. And I think it's going to be really interesting to see what happens with this election outcome because Once we get past the uncertainty phase, even if there is a modest increase in civil unrest, if it's not outright mayhem, I think there's room for gold to sell off some more and to, as you put it, backfill some of that exuberance. We saw a lot of upside as a result of election uncertainty and civil unrest increasing over the summer and so forth.
As we get into We're getting into the fall where the civil unrest is likely just for weather reasons, at least in colder cities. People will be less likely to be out on the streets of Seattle and Portland protesting in the cold weather. The election result will, one way or another, be known at some point. I think the ingredients are there unless there's a major up move in civil unrest, which again, I have suggested is entirely possible.
If we don't get outright mayhem, I think there's plenty of room for gold to correct much deeper. And I would say that the first target is the 200-day moving average at $1,783. But you certainly could look lower than that for where we might go before this is over, back down to, you know, the $1,500 level, say, would not surprise me at all. And it wouldn't change my very bullish long-term view on gold.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: The further down it is, the bigger the buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: So moving on to copper on page 13, copper's been actually one of the most bullish commodities. And Tian was also talking about that and the opportunity that's there in the commodity. It'll be interesting to see whether it can maintain this entire consolidation to just like one of these 1 to 2 week kind of corrections that maybe in the post-election period bullishly turn up. What is interesting is when we look on page 14, when we look at the Global X Copper Miners ETF, COPX, it's been such a beautiful uptrend in the copper miners off that March low. And we've— we're finally reaching that overhead resistance where they're just consolidating sideways. And some technicians will, you know, start to fish around whether that will establish some sort of double top formation. But I think that when you really zoom out onto those weekly charts and see just how decimated the space has been over the last many years, I think that all the dips are likely to be bought.
And this— any consolidation here is just probably going to end up being a good opportunity to position yourself in some of these miners.
Erik Townsend: I agree, Patrick. And of course, the opportunity that I'd really get excited about— we know that copper is always a barometer for industrial activity, which means if there is a big increase in coronavirus infections and deaths, copper's probably going to take a nosedive on expectations of slowing economic activity and slowing industrial activity. In the short term, there could be a lot of downside there, but long term, it's a buying opportunity. You know that coming out of this, there's going to be more stimulus. There's going to be more government attitude toward electric vehicles, which are big copper consumers, towards infrastructure build-out, which is a big copper consumer. There's just all kinds of good reasons to be long-term bullish on copper. And I think the coronavirus crisis, if we get another significant wave here that really makes things worse, could easily create a really good buying opportunity.
Patrick Ceresna: All right. Let's wrap up this particular chart series with looking at the volatility index. And this is something we talked about last week, and I was just showing that 2016, just how volatility imploded in the days after the elections and how there was this big volatility premium as everyone's grabbing, uh, left-tail insurance. Uh, and in this case, we even have a lot of right-tail insurance buying as there's some big players out there that are throwing some, uh, billions of dollars into some call spreads on the upside of the S&P. Nonetheless, what's interesting is, is that on page 16, when we look here, we had a big spike in implieds just yesterday. I mean, we hit the 40 handle on the VIX, and it's starting to look a little déjà vu-like of 2016. And while maybe the stock market outcome may not be exactly the same, it'll be really interesting to see whether volatility normalization happens in the post-election period and whether this VIX starts heading back down to the low 20s and whether it even
Patrick Ceresna: happens as rapid as it did back in 2016.
Nonetheless, Erik, we added some charts here starting on page 17 on the coronavirus cases and we just really wanted to get an update from you on what's going on here and what are you seeing with this new second wave of the coronavirus around the world?
Erik Townsend: Well, it's really interesting just looking on Twitter at how divided people are and how much, especially in the United States, this has become a political affiliation thing. The people's opinion as to whether or not deaths are on the rise or not kind of depends on whether they're Democrat or Republican. And, you know, I personally prefer to just go on the data.
So let's take a look at these actual charts. And these are from Worldometers. The source is at the bottom of the page there on page 17 if you want to look at it yourself. Cases and deaths are both increasing on the left side of page 17. More importantly, though, if we look at the daily new cases, which really gives us a better insight into how the trends are going, yesterday we saw the first time ever more than half a million. I think the number was 507,000 new cases globally. Now, a lot of people will tell you the case counts are completely misleading because the better that we get at testing The more people we test, the more cases get detected. The cases might have been there all along and we just didn't detect them. And what you'll hear people say a lot is therefore the case counts are really not meaningful. You have to look at the deaths, and those have been consistently declining for months.
Okay, let's look at the right-hand side of page 17. If you're convinced that Yeah. Those are declining and have been for months, as depicted on page 17. I think you've gotta have a talk with yourself about how much your political ideology is affecting your ability to interpret data, because we're not seeing deaths declining for the last several months. What we're seeing is a resumption. Now, it's not back to a new high the way the cases are. And I think the reason for that is in the beginning of this crisis, we didn't know how to treat We were putting people on ventilators when that was really— we thought it was mostly a respiratory disease. We didn't understand it was more of a bloodborne disease. We didn't know how to treat it yet. We've gotten much better now at understanding what the nature of this disease is and how to treat it. That's the reason that we got off the big spike.
But look what happened there. Before you even got to the end of June, it was already starting to increase again.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: And then we did have a bit of a reprieve there, but now we're seeing an increase as we get back into the colder weather in the Northern Hemisphere. So it's clearly not over yet. The cases are at radically new highs in terms of how many cases. I think that is being affected to some extent by testing skewing the results where we weren't doing as much testing 6 months ago. And so it It exaggerates the number. But those death numbers are not exaggerated, and they're moving back to their previous highs. Now, page 17 is showing us global statistics.
Let's move on to United States statistics on page 18. You see the new cases total on the left side and then the daily new cases. And of course, we are moving to all-time records in terms of new cases per day above 80,000. But again, there is an argument to be made that maybe the cases are being affected more so than the deaths by better testing.
Let's move on to page 19. And you see, even in the case of daily deaths, yeah, it's not above 2,000 daily deaths the way it was in the heights of the April crisis where this was new, hospitals were overwhelmed, they didn't know how to respond to it, they didn't know how to treat Yeah. Things really got crazy for a while there. But frankly, we're back up to consistently more than 1,000 deaths per day. And if you look at this chart overall in terms of the daily counts, it's not declining over a period of months like people will tell you. It's stabilizing. That's a good thing. But if you consider that we're getting better and better at treating this disease, and there are therefore less number of deaths per number of serious cases, then, you know, these numbers are really not very comforting. What I don't have here is a chart of hospitalizations. I would love to have that chart because I think that's a good indication of seriousness of cases, although that's also constrained somewhat by hospital capacity.
But in general, you know, the idea that you'll So the idea here being thrown around that cases have been declining for months and it's all getting better is really not true. And we're seeing a big new uptick in cases that may lead to— there's always a delay between the case uptick and the death count uptick because the disease requires several weeks to progress. We need to be looking sometime around early December at whether or not there is an accordant spike in deaths.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: that really match this big spike we're seeing right now in cases. And I think it's likely that there will be. So already Europe is going into more lockdowns. I think the global trend, what you're going to see is there will be calls for lockdowns in the sense that we'll have just as much of a sentiment among doctors and scientists saying it's time for the government to lock things down again. But I think you'll have a much more outspoken social objection to that, where people say, we just want to get on with our lives. We object to being locked down. We'll accept the risk. Let's move on with life and just keep on going. Of course, the presidential election in the United States will strongly influence the US government's stance on this, because President Trump And Vice President Biden have had very opposite policy statements about what they would do in the face of recommendations to go into another full-on US lockdown.
If that were to be recommended by scientists, Biden would do it, Trump wouldn't do it. The rest of the world is already doing it. So how big is this next wave as we get into cold weather in the Northern Hemisphere? Is it going to be bigger than the first wave? wave and have more economic damage, or have we already seen the worst of it? We don't know yet, but we need to be paying close attention to this and leave the politics out of
Erik Townsend: it. Something else I wanted to cover here in today's episode, because nobody seems to ever talk about it, is to look at these data on a per capita basis, because you hear so much where people say, well, a certain country had X number of new deaths or new cases, and you know, that country is worse than this country. They're not adjusting it for the population sizes of those countries. It doesn't make any sense.
What you care about is the per capita total cases and the per capita total deaths. It's a sort column that's available here on worldometers.com. Just nobody ever seems to click on it. So I just wanted to show first on page 20, this is a ranking essentially. from worst at the top to better as we go down lower, in terms of which countries have been hardest hit in terms of the percentage of their population becoming infected. And the sort column is total cases per million population, which is about 2/3 of the way across there. The top number says 58,430.
Patrick Ceresna: Wow.
Erik Townsend: 30 for Andorra. Well, some of these smaller countries, you know, Vatican City with a grand total of 27 cases, obviously their numbers per million population are skewed by their very small populations. But for the big countries on this list, like Belgium and Kuwait and the United States, obviously, this is a much more meaningful ranking.
And the United States is number 14. 14. 14 on this list. So we're not the worst in the world, but we're really not doing all that great considering we've got more money and resources to throw at this problem than just about anybody else. This is again total cases. A lot of people think the case counts are skewed because of different amounts of testing.
Moving on to page 21, we're sorting now per capita total deaths, and it's very interesting going back to page You see the United States has moved above on the list, meaning worse than a lot of the South American countries like Chile and Brazil and Peru, which were really hard hit over the North American summer, which of course was their winter. As you move on to page 21 though, you see that the United States is still doing better than Spain and Chile and Brazil and so forth.
Patrick Ceresna: Right.
Erik Townsend: So I, for one, find it very interesting to kind of rank the performance of various different governments in handling this crisis by their per capita cases and particularly their per capita deaths. United States at number 10 worldwide in terms of having the most per capita deaths. It's not number 1, it's not the worst in the world, but with 210 countries or whatever are in world, the US is in the worst 10 countries in terms of cases and deaths per million population, is really a pretty damning statement when you consider that the United States is richer and has more resources to fight this crisis than just about anyone else. Moving on to page 22, we'll take a look at the same numbers ranking US states, and I find this very interesting too. Who would've guessed that North Dakota was the worst state in the United States on a per capita basis? Well, of course, they don't have as much capita, so a smaller number of cases will, will have a big effect.
But on a per capita basis, North Dakota, as you can see, is at the top of the list. And this is infections per capita. As we move on to deaths per capita on page 23, New Jersey, New York, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Louisiana are the worst states. And that's kind of consistent with what we've heard in terms of the reporting about where the worst outbreaks have been. So it seems like the deaths rather than the infections are the more telling statistic here. But I find it very interesting just to see these rankings of how different states have performed on a per capita basis as opposed to
Erik Townsend: total numbers, which is what you hear the mainstream media report. We're already over time, folks, so we're going to leave it there for this week's episode. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors, and by toptradersunplugged.com.
Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our post- Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the Variant Perception's presentation slide deck, as well as the chartbook we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to the Variant Perception blog titled Elections Come and Go, as well as a link to an article on OPEC Production Cuts Could Be Extended. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distribution.
If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.
Announcer: That concludes this week's episode of MacroVoices. That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information.
Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly research roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.
And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile. Feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.
MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, Visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Stephanie Kelton — Professor Stephanie Kelton (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 242 was recorded on October 22nd, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode of MacroVoices is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors.
Professor Stephanie Kelton has been making waves in political circles with her book, The Deficit Myth, which advocates for public policy adoption of the principles of Modern Monetary Theory to enable more, not less, government spending, using the power of central banks to conjure new money supply out of thin air to finance government spending. Without necessarily raising taxes or borrowing from foreigners. Professor Kelton joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Due to Professor Kelton's very busy schedule, we were only able to get a 30-minute interview with her. So we'll be supplementing that with an extended postgame segment this week in which Patrick and I will discuss the feature interview in more depth than usual. And then with Patrick back from his break, we'll have another of his signature chart decks to top it all off.
Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, let's jump to that S&P 500. For all of the hype going into the elections, the market volatility is rather narrow. What's your take on what's going on?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think we've reached an equilibrium point where the market has priced in that there is a fair amount of certainty in uncertainty, but that uncertainty is already priced in. So I think that a clean sweep where it's Very clear who has won and nobody's really contesting the outcome of the election is gonna be a big up for the stock market. As far as whether or not there's a big down for the stock market, certainly if you had civil war break out, I think that's a down. But what if it's just a modest uprising of civil unrest? I think a certain amount of that is already priced in too. How much is priced in and how big of a deal does the contested election have to be Before you reach the point where the increase in civil unrest boils over and really causes markets to melt down, I'm not sure. I think one thing that we are seeing, though, is the certainty that some people had, the narrative, if you will, that, well, it's a shoo-in.
The polls say Biden is certain to win. That's breaking down. It's looking like there are echoes of 2016 when Hillary Clinton was up by, you know, everybody thought it was just a done deal. Hillary's got this thing just totally wrapped up. And then in And in the end, there was a surprise. So I think that it is still a close race. It's not at all certain what the outcome is gonna be. Although I will say, at least in my mind, there's some degree of certainty that not everybody's gonna agree on who won by the time it's over.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because back in September, it really looked like there was some sort of a US dollar breakout underway. And really the dollars just came right back into the pocket here. It's consolidating back down to those August, September lows. What do you think's going on in the dollar here?
Erik Townsend: Well, Goldman Sachs comments on Wednesday that a stimulus deal was looking less likely than previously thought sure didn't help. We still need a daily close below 92 to really deliver a technical signal that would cement the message that, hey, the dollar's really in trouble here. We haven't seen that yet. And I think it was the Goldman comments on Wednesday that caused that big drop below 93. We're at 92.88 on the December contract as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon, uh, still below 93, but you know, we're not below 92 yet. So I don't think that, uh, it's time to declare the, the dollar is completely dead. I think what we're seeing though is a wait again for the election. I think all markets are basically in a consolidation waiting for the election. If we have nobody knows who the President of the United States is, major, major unrest cropping up all over the country and the Supreme Court has to decide the election outcome, I think the dollar could really take a nosedive.
Frankly, if we get a clean sweep or anything approximating one, I think it potentially sets the stage for a dollar recovery because I think a lot of the weakness that we've seen so far was based on that uncertainty. So does uncertainty go up or down after the election? I think that that's going to answer which way the dollar moves next.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil, which continues to stay confined in this narrow trading band. Any hope for some action in the energy markets anytime soon?
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, crude oil inventories came in drawing down 1 million barrels this week. Cushing, Oklahoma building 975,000 barrels. Gasoline building 1.9 million barrels. Distillates though drawing down 3.8 million barrels. That's a pretty big drawdown for distillates, and it comes on the back of the biggest drawdown in more than a decade that we saw just last week. Now, most interesting Interestingly to me, US production is still down. We did have that tropical storm go through the Gulf of Mexico, which is obviously going to take things down. That was a couple weeks ago. So is that the reason that we saw another half million barrel drawdown to 9.9 million barrels of US production this week? Is it still storm-related, or are we seeing the beginning of what Art Berman predicted, which would be a steep decline in US production that Art thought would start sometime in Q4, although he was leaning toward the end of Q4. I'm not sure which it is yet.
We'll have to wait and see if that recovers next week. Now, the tape action was down fairly dramatically after inventory came out, but it's likely that the comments from Goldman Sachs about a less likely stimulus deal, which came out about the same time, just a few minutes after inventory data came out, probably had more to do with influencing that sell-off than the inventory numbers themselves. As far as the time spreads at the back of the curve, which I mentioned in the last couple of weeks, they're still performing better than the front month is. But the pattern that we were seeing where they were consistently closing well above their short-term moving averages has changed. We've seen a sell-off in those time spreads. So that early indicator that I thought might be telling us about an upside breakout coming in crude oil So far, that's not really holding up.
We'll have to see what next week brings.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold, 'cause last few weeks it kept looking like gold was gonna start to turn up and potentially break out, but it just continues to also be range-bound in that same pattern. What's the next move for gold in your mind?
Erik Townsend: Well, you could certainly make an argument that Wednesday was maybe an interesting technical signal in gold because we had the first daily close above the descending triangle resistance line. The thing is, It didn't stay there. You know, it was a daily close above it yesterday. We're right back down below that line now. And we almost tested the bottom end of that wedge, which is the 100-day moving average support at 1892.
So we're still consolidating, even though there was technically a breakout above the line. Frankly, I think that was based on the narrative about Biden having a shoo-in for the election breaking down a little bit in the news flow yesterday. I don't think it's really Meaningful yet. I think what we're waiting for is to find out not so much who wins the election, but how much uncertainty there is or how contested the outcome of the election is, and particularly how much of an increase in civil unrest occurs. There's police departments around the United States bracing for— they're not sure what might be coming next. Is it all a big false alarm, or is it the beginning of something really big? I think if it's a clean sweep and nobody is really uncertain as to who the President of the United States is, I think gold continues a correction to the downside. On the other hand, if you had a major escalation of civil unrest, that could be the setup for a big move to the upside.
So I don't think we find out until the election results become clear, or perhaps I should say become unclear.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, finally, let's touch on those 10-year Treasury yields, because while the dollar, oil, and gold seem to be in these range-bound pockets, the 10-year Treasury yield has really started to break out on the upside out of that range it's been in for the last 6, 7 months. We're at 1.84% on the yield. Do you think this is a legitimate breakout here on the 10-year yield?
Erik Townsend: Well, I don't think that we've seen a big enough move yet, but the move is in the direction that I would expect it to be in. You know, as I've been saying for several weeks now, I'm really unsure as to what the timing is, but at some point I think that we, we have a shift to secular inflation. And certainly modern monetary theory and the changes that we're seeing in public policy could bring about more Is the bond market already signaling that with higher yields that inflation is coming, or is this just a blip? I don't think it's big enough yet to really confirm that macro outlook, but I'm leaning more and more toward the, the general opinion that probably the bond bull market, finally after 38 years or whatever it's been, probably is coming to an end, has reached its top, and that we're headed toward higher yields. But, you know, it's a very complex macro picture, and there still are a lot of of open question marks, we definitely
need to get into today's feature interview with Professor Stephanie Kelton and talk about MMT and what it's going to mean in terms of public policy, because that's a big part of the equation.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week's feature interview guest is bestselling author, Dr. Stephanie Kelton. So Erik, why Professor Kelton?
Erik Townsend: Well, as our regular listeners know, we've wanted to get her on the program for months and months. We finally were able to get her to agree. Unfortunately, we could only get a half-hour interview. We really do appreciate that. She has a very busy schedule. She normally doesn't do podcast interviews at all. She made an exception for us, which we very much appreciate. And unfortunately, the downside of that was we could only get a half an hour. And Patrick, in anticipation of what I'm sure we'll get is feedback from our listeners who are gonna say, hey, why didn't you get Warren Mosler to come on the show? Because he's really the father of MMT. Warren Mosler has been a perfect gentleman. I really appreciate his style. He was very polite, very cordial, but also very firm in saying no. He just feels like he's done He said, look, all of my work on MMT has been written down.
Go read it. Please leave me alone. So he seems like a super guy. I appreciate him being so cordial, but he was just not interested in an interview, although I would love to interview him as well. So we're going to just take the half hour that we could get, and then we'll do an extended postgame and have some of the discussion just between us as to what I wish I had had the opportunity to ask Professor Keen.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay.
Erik Townsend: Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure. Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
Erik Townsend: This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test But as
Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen, host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik's interview with Professor Kelton is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Joining me now is bestselling author, Professor Stephanie Kelton, widely known both as an expert on Modern Monetary Theory, and I would say even more so as one of the most active promoters of Modern Monetary Theory in the public policy arena. Dr. Kelton, thank you so much for joining us. The book, of course, is called The Deficit Myth. So I wanna dive right in to the 6 myths that you bust in the book and talk about the first one, which is, you know, that for years and years we've had this debate in public policy where everybody says, okay, we've got too much debt. The political left says that's because we're not taxing the rich enough. And the political right says it's because we're spending too much. But both sides historically have generally been willing to agree that expanding the national debt is a big problem. You gotta balance the budget. You say that's not really true, particularly for monetary sovereigns like the United States that control their own currency.
So why that distinction? And why is it a myth that it's important to pay for what we spend or what the government spends through taxes?
Stephanie Kelton: First, thanks for having me on. And, and so let's just jump right into the very last question that you asked, you know, this idea that governments have to pay for things. And the way that You know, I was taught when I was a graduate student studying economics, and the way that the vast majority of students today are taught, that the government faces a budget constraint, right? And that governments have choices when it comes to how to pay for their spending. That a government can pay for its spending with revenue. That is, you know, they use tax revenue, and if they need to spend more or wish to spend more, then one option is to raise taxes to come up with the money in order to pay for that additional spending.
The other option is that governments can borrow. And so they can go to savers and they can borrow to finance the spending that way. And then the third option, which is the one that quickly gets buried under the rug, is the recognition, well, of course, a sovereign government, and if it has its own currency, it can always print money and pay the bills that way.
And so there There are these— this menu of options, right? 3 choices. Which one will the government choose to pay its bills? And MMT comes along and says, wait a minute. If we look operationally at how government finance actually works, we learn, we discover that there's really only one way to pay.
That all government spending, I'm talking federal government spending. So for a government like the US or the UK or Australia or Japan, that there is only one way to pay. That all government spending is indeed already and only ever paid for, financed with new money creation. There's no other way for it to work. And so, once you get that recognition, once you kind of arrive at that point, then you sort of scratch your head and say, well, then what are the taxes and bond part? What's that about?
And it took me, I will admit, it took me a while to get to that point. I think the first or second peer-reviewed article that I ever published was titled Do taxes and bonds finance government spending? Because again, as a graduate student, I was taught that's exactly what they do. And it was only later when I encountered the work of Warren Mosler that I began to question my own understanding of how government finance works. And then after a period of months really working my way through this stuff and the mechanics of government finance, I was able to persuade myself that I had the ordering, the sequencing wrong, and that the government spends new money into existence, and only after it has spent those dollars into existence are they then available to either pay taxes or buy government bonds.
Erik Townsend: Now, let's go a little bit deeper on those taxes and bonds, because what a lot of people would say is, well, if you figured out that there's, there's kind of a magic source of income here and we don't need those taxes, Let's eliminate taxes and never have them again because we don't need taxes. We can print new money. But the study of MMT says actually taxes are very important, but maybe for an unobvious reason pertaining to inflation. So why do we still need taxes?
Stephanie Kelton: Okay, well, remember, I just want to go take one tiny step back and just sort of reassert the point that it's not that we can print money, it's that there is no other way for the government to spend. to create new money as it spends. So it's newly created digital dollars and there's no other way for it to work. And so, you know, your question is a very good one. So once you recognize that, that the government spends its currency into existence, then you say, well, then why do we have to pay any taxes at all? Why not just let the government, you know, spend and forget the tax piece? Which, by the way, is exactly what Congress has been doing, right?
Let's just take the CARES Act as one example. the biggest relief package that has so far gotten through both the House and the Senate and signed into law. That was $2.2 trillion. And that bill was Congress writing what we in the DC Beltway circles call a clean bill. In other words, it was not offset. The spending was not offset. The government just simply said, Congress said, listen up, Fed, we are ordering up $2.2 trillion.
Get ready because you are going to carry out the payments that we have authorized on behalf of the US Treasury. That's how it works. So this is an example of Congress committing to spending money it did not have, right? It's just what it has is the power of the purse. It can commit to spending $2.2 trillion.
And the Fed, as the government's fiscal agent, will carry out those payments by changing the numbers in the appropriate bank accounts. So for people who got that $1,200 stimulus check, the way that that money got into your account is that the Federal Reserve and the bank that you bank at changed the numbers upward in your account. And so there was no pairing of higher taxes to go along with this.
So why do we sometimes increase taxes? Why do we have taxes at all? So in the book, I go into into a lot of detail on this. If you wanted to start up a currency from scratch, then a tax or something like it, fees, fines, other obligations governments impose to get a population, to put a population of people in a position where they need to earn the state's currency in order to settle their tax or other obligation to the state. And we could talk a lot about this, but I We don't have time, so I'll just say that one reason for taxes is that they allow governments to start up a currency from scratch. Once that currency has been started up and now people are accustomed to having this currency around, they begin making their own payments and transacting in that currency, right?
And the government can use the tax lever to pull some of those dollars back out of our hands. So taxes are important because they're one way that the government can reduce the purchasing power of all the other spenders in the economy.
So if the government wants to come in and do a big ambitious infrastructure project and spend trillions of dollars into the economy, it might be worried that spending trillions of dollars could push prices higher, could lead to inflationary pressure. And to offset or mitigate the inflationary pressure, it matches some of its new spending with higher taxes. So it makes room for the government to be able to spend those dollars into the economy without creating inflationary pressures.
Taxes are important because they allow government to pull a lever if it's interested in rebalancing the distribution of wealth and income. You say, I'm going to put this new tax on or push this existing tax higher because I think the distribution of wealth and income has become so extreme that we want to try to rebalance things. So governments use taxes for things like that. And then finally, you know, you can use taxes to incentivize or disincentivize behavior in the economy. So, you know, a gas tax, carbon tax, earned income tax credit. I mean, you could, you know, work it both ways to try to get people to do or not do certain things. So lots of important reasons for taxes. But in MMT, the one way that that we do not think of taxes is as a source of revenue to pay the government's bills.
Erik Townsend: Now, I know that one of the ways that you do think about taxes in MMT is as a preventive measure to overcome the tendency of that spending to bring about inflation. What I haven't seen addressed, and maybe I just haven't read enough about it, is wait a minute, inflation tends to be a vicious cycle with a long lead time that has to do with inflation leading to inflation expectations, leading to acceleration of velocity of money. And it feeds on itself. And once it gets going, it's hard to break it. So it seems to me like I worry about whether, you know, how do you know the tax is enough to prevent that cycle from starting? And how do you break out of that cycle if some of the money that's being created through MMT by the government financing more of its spending just by printing new money, does start to lead to that widespread inflation.
The other problem that I have understanding this inflation argument is at least some people, and maybe this is the politicians as opposed to the MMT scholars, are saying, well, it's really what we have to do to prevent the inflation.
We've got to tax the rich, specifically tax the rich. Well, wait a minute. The rich are the people whose spending habits are not really directly impacted by their tax burden and their inflation because they've got enough. assets that they can continue spending. So how do you overcome the potential of creating a vicious cycle of inflation? Is it just taxes, or are there other measures that MMT uses to overcome that inflation risk?
Stephanie Kelton: Okay, so let me start by saying there's a terrific, short, accessible piece, but your audience is very smart, so they can handle the, the higher-order stuff. There's a piece in the Financial Times that was co-authored by 3 MMT scholars, and I think I think the title of the piece is something like How MMT Thinks About Inflation or How MMT Manages Inflation, something along those lines. You can, you know, people can find it because I wouldn't have time to do it all justice here.
But look, okay, let's start by recognizing that inflation, as you say, is a dynamic process. It's a continuous increase in the price level. It's not a one-off. It's a complex phenomenon. There isn't an economist on earth who can write down for you a model of inflation that will apply in all times across space and time. Nobody can do it.
The Federal Reserve, Daniel Tarullo, who was a Fed Board of Governors member, he rolled off the Board of Governors and went out and one of the early speeches he gave just made huge headlines because he went out and he said, you know what? The Fed does not have a working model of inflation. We don't know So, I know that economists, I'm one, wave their hands around and use the phrase inflation expectations, but I'll be honest with you, it's pretty much baloney.
Okay? It's what we hide behind when we run out of realistic things to say.
So, once upon a time, there was a quantity theory of money, and man, you could write that equation down, everybody could see it, and you said inflation happens because velocity is constant and the real economy tends to full employment. And once you apply a little calculus, to the quantity theory, to the equation of exchange, then you know that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. Money supply growth rate accelerates, inflation will accelerate, you know, to the same degree. Well, that's clearly silly and wrong. And, you know, we have decades of experience with QE where people who relied on that thinking expected quantitative easing to drive inflation or possibly hyperinflation. Of course, it didn't do any of that.
Then you had the Phillips And you say, well, it's the Phillips Curve. That's the model I'll write down and that's my inflation model. Well, listen, nobody believes this stuff anymore. And you can expectations augment the Phillips Curve all you want and it still isn't workable.
So, I don't believe that we should think of inflation as something that happens because expectations become unanchored and people formulate ideas about where prices are headed and then it becomes self-fulfilling. That's just silly stuff. that we make up. I think we need to be more serious than that.
Prices change because producers raise prices. People change prices. They don't just happen, and they certainly don't just happen across all categories of consumer goods. So let's think a little bit harder. You know, if I go downstairs after this interview, and I hope this doesn't happen, but if I go downstairs and find my basement is flooded, I don't just run to one part of the house and say, oh, I have to stop the flooding in the basement. I don't know what caused the flooding in the basement. I don't know If a kid left a faucet running, if a toilet overflowed, if a pipe burst, if the dishwasher's leaking, I got to find the source of the problem. And I think that's the way we in MMT think about inflationary pressures. You have to look under the hood. You have to go to what is driving that headline price inflation.
I'll give you just one quick example. The Supreme Court's going to take up the case on the Affordable Care Act, right? That's going to happen soon.
Erik Townsend: That's right.
Stephanie Kelton: And there is a chance that the Supreme Court will say the ACA is unconstitutional and provisions like protections against preexisting conditions, that could go away. Some of the cost controls around medical reimbursements and prescription drug prices and so forth, that cost containment, that could go away. And people who look at the US experience in recent years post-ACA compared to the years immediately before the Affordable Care Act passed.
People say, listen, the Affordable Care Act took us a long way toward constraining inflationary pressures in this period because there were all these controls. Now, let go of all that stuff. Imagine that healthcare, health insurance companies are free to raise premiums and price discriminate based on preexisting conditions, and pharma companies can be more aggressive with prescription drug prices and so forth. You can easily imagine headline inflation ticking up for those reasons.
Now, how would you fight that? I mean, would it make sense to say raise taxes in order to combat that kind of inflationary pressure? I think that's crazy. But would it make sense to say the Fed should raise interest rates to fight? Now, that's equally crazy.
So when I talk about inflation and when, when we in the MMT scholarly community talk about it, it's a much more nuanced conversation because you have to recognize That, you know, there are things you can do on the regulatory side. There are a lot of non-fiscal— doesn't have to do with cutting government spending or raising taxes— ways to deal with inflationary pressure, but you got to know what's causing it.
Erik Townsend: I want to move on to what you actually have identified as the next myth in the book, which would also be the feedback that you'd probably get from a lot of people who would say, look, what you're talking about doing here, amounts to stealing from future generations. You're describing a way without having to raise taxes, which makes it more politically viable for the government to spend more money that we don't have and increase the national debt that's gonna have to be paid off someday by our children and grandchildren. That's immoral. Why is that a myth?
Stephanie Kelton: Well, it's a myth because none of it makes any sense whatsoever. I mean, I'm sorry, I'll just be as, as kind of upfront and candid as I can. I think that's just really silly. And, and I know that it's common and I know that people repeat it and I know that sometimes serious people repeat these kinds of things.
So this falls right back into the household analogy, right back into that trap of thinking like government as a household. And when we use words like borrowing, like paying it back, calling this thing the debt, we are falling back into that household trap. And the federal government's nothing like a household. It doesn't operate its budget like a household. Right. So, here's just one example. Okay. When the government runs a deficit, it matches up the deficit spending by selling treasuries, right? We know that. And that's something it chooses to do, not something it must do. Government, sovereign government doesn't need to borrow its own currency from anyone in order to spend. But the government currently matches up its deficit spending with bond sales.
So, what happens? So the government spends $100 into the economy, taxes, let's say, $90 back out. We say the government has run a deficit. We look at it as a shortfall. It's not a shortfall. The government's the scorekeeper for the dollar, right? It's adding $100 and subtracting $90. Somebody gets 10 points. That's $10.
Now the government comes along and says, well, because I ran a deficit, I'm going to sell these Treasuries. Which means the government is going to subtract back out the $10 and replace them with 10 Treasuries.
So, the way that I look at it isn't that the government is borrowing in any meaningful sense. If I go to a bank for a loan and I sit down with the loan officer, I don't plop the money down on the desk in front of the loan officer and then ask for the loan. Okay, I'm there because I don't have the money. That's why I'm there to borrow. The federal government's the issuer of the currency. It doesn't borrow because it doesn't have the money. What it's doing is first supplying its currency and then transforming those dollars into a different financial instrument, into US Treasuries. So, it's allowing us to hold dollars that amplify themselves over time, right? Those are amplifying dollars. Why? Because they pay interest. So, I look at the Treasuries as a form of payment, not a of debt. There's nothing being borrowed. There's something being paid out. And when the Treasury matures, when the bond matures, it simply converts back into its original form.
It converts back to the currency form. So paying it back, quote unquote, involves nothing more than shifting funds, right? Shifting funds from one account at the Fed, a securities account, into what's effectively a checking account, a reserve account at the Fed. That's all the The more complicated it is to quote unquote pay it back. But I think that, you know, we have a communications problem. We don't have a debt problem. We just have chosen very unhelpful words to narrate what's actually taking place.
Erik Townsend: Well, if we don't think of it in terms of actual debt, and as you say, we can just print the money in order to pay expenses, and it's only a convenient that we happen to articulate that through a debt transaction, at least in the current system. Well, hang on a second. Doesn't printing that money dilute the value of the money that everyone who owns money has? And therefore, isn't it really a form of tax on the wealth of everyone holding dollars?
Stephanie Kelton: So look, it isn't a simple thing. I know a lot of people think just in somehow in their heads, there's this supply and demand framework and that if you have more supply of anything, Then that automatically pushes prices down. The value of the thing goes down. But no, I mean, it depends what happens with those dollars. So first, every deficit is good for someone, right? In financial terms, the government's deficit is a deposit. It is a financial contribution to some other part of the economy. Now, every deficit is good for someone, But deficits do different things, right? For whom? Who gets that contribution and what is it being used to accomplish somewhere in the economy?
So, if the government's making investments in infrastructure and education and R&D, those are the 3 categories where economists by and large agree that you get the greatest long-term benefit from that kind of spending.
In other words, if you're worried about the value of the dollar going down over time because the government is spending, How about recognizing that certain kinds of government spending actually improve long-term productivity and boost potential real wealth, real output, real— So no, there's no simple, if the government spends more, then the value of the currency goes down. No, you can have a much stronger economy as a consequence and a much stronger currency along with that.
Erik Townsend: Professor Kelton, I haven't gotten even to all 6 myths in the book, but I want to jump ahead because I know you've got a very I know you have a very tight schedule today and just a couple more minutes for us. I think that your voice, you're extremely articulate, you're very persuasive in your arguments. I won't be at all surprised if you replace Janet Yellen as the most influential woman in the history of finance. Let's pretend that that comes true. What do you want to be remembered for changing? How does the world, or particularly the US government, need to change if you were in charge and applying MMT to make the world a better place?
Stephanie Kelton: Well, boy, Erik. I mean, look, I get frustrated by the nature of the debates that take place in this country and around the world. And I think for me, a lot of this is just— I think gratuitous suffering is just the worst kind of suffering because we have the capacity to do better and to do better by our fellow Americans, to do better by others.
And if we can improve economic life for millions of people without creating harm, why wouldn't we do that? And so I would like to see us begin to have a better debate without reference to the sort of things we've been talking about, some of these myths, right? That we can't do X, Y, and Z because there's no money to do it. We can't do these things because China won't lend us the dollars. We can't do these things because the future generations are already too burdened by debt. We can't do— I want to clear through all of that and get us to a place where we have a more constructive, fruitful national debate about what our priorities are. What is the proper role of government? What programs are we collectively willing to support?
And, you know, in terms of our nation's real resource capacity, what can we afford to do? And so if we could just get to the point where we start having the debate on the right kind of playing field with the right limits in mind, that's sort of what I'm after. I don't have greater ambitions in a sense than trying to open up, help to open up space to have that better debate.
Erik Townsend: One of the myths that you have in the book is entitlement programs like Social Security and Medicare are financially unsustainable. We don't have time to get into that, but I just want to ask, what is the constraining factor? I mean, obviously, if we really can afford those things, we can print money. Why stop with Social Security and Medicare? Why not have a Mercedes and maybe a private jet for every single citizen? There's got to be some reason to stop. Is it just the risk of inflation, or are there other constraints?
Stephanie Kelton: Well, I mean, there are political constraints, but the relevant constraint is inflation. It is our nation's real resource capacity. It's how many people do you have that are of working age and capable of working and producing in the economy? How many factories, buildings, machines? What are your raw materials? What is your state of technology? You combine all of the real resources you have, and that tells you what you're capable of domestically, right? And then the US has the good fortune of also being able to tap productive capacity in other parts of the world because the rest of the world is willing to produce for us, right? They will accept the dollar and we can have access to some of their productive capacity too. So, you know, with respect to seniors, if we want to care for seniors in a way that makes us proud to call ourselves Americans, we say we have this retirement security system in place called Social Security.
People are always talking about how it's unsustainable. We're going to have to make tough choices and cut benefits or means test the program so that everybody doesn't get to benefit from Social Security. That's all wrong. I mean, Alan Greenspan told us how wrong that was years ago, testifying before Congress under oath when he got a question from then-Congressman Paul Ryan who said, look, Social Security's going broke.
We got to do something about this. Don't you agree, Mr. Chairman? And Greenspan leaned into the microphone and I thought he gave the most brilliant and honest answer. And he said to Paul Ryan, I don't agree. He said, there is nothing about the way the system is set up today that is financially unsustainable. His exact words were, there's nothing to prevent the federal government from creating as much money as it wants and paying it to someone.
Okay? That is the first point he made. But the second point is the really important one.
He said, the question is, how do you set up a system which assures that the real assets are created, which those benefits are employed to purchase. And what he meant is that we have changing demographics and the demographic changes have been underway for a long time.
On average, every day in America, 10,000 people hit the age of 65. Okay. They can move into retirement if they want to at that point. And Greenspan And said, you know, basically, we're, we're being left with a shrinking population of people to produce the stuff, right, to actually kick out the goods and services in the economy, and a growing population of retirees. If we continue to mail checks or deposit, you know, digital dollars in their bank accounts, those seniors can turn around and spend that money into the economy competing with all other spenders in the economy. So for Greenspan, like every central banker in the world, inflation is the thing you worry about.
And Greenspan's looking at this and saying, how do we know that in the future, 10, 20, 30 years from now, when those checks go out, the economy, the US is going to be a productive enough economy to produce all the goods and services that both seniors and the current working population want and need? If that's the case, if we are productive enough, there's no— No problem. Keep the system running. You can even make it more generous. The risk is if we are not a productive enough economy going forward, then all we end up with is more intense competition for a dwindling pool of real goods and services, and hence an inflation problem.
So, it seems to me the fight over Social Security should be about which political party has a better We need a plan to increase the probability that in 10, 20, 30 years, we are a productive enough economy to kick those goods and services out, to allow seniors to have a sustained, you know, standard of living in retirement and to raise living standards for working people going forward. We just need a productive enough economy. We ought to argue over who has the best economic platform to get us there.
Erik Townsend: Professor Kelton, I know that we've already gone past the hard stop in your schedule. I can't tell you how much we appreciate A terrific interview. Listeners, the book is The Deficit Myth by Professor Stephanie Kelton. It's also available in audiobook form, narrated personally by Professor Kelton. Stephanie, anything you want to add before I let you go?
Stephanie Kelton: No, I mean, like everybody probably listening, waiting on pins and needles to see whether Congress is going to come through with another relief package. You know, that's, that's kind of the thing that weighs on my, my mind right now.
Erik Townsend: Well, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor. Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade, but the high cost of buying Buying an entire farm put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, Performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes, and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com.
Check out FarmTogether.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Patrick Ceresna: Erik, a great interview with Stephanie Kelton. You know, when I was listening to it, all I was thinking about was, uh, you know, the fact that we are in the late stages of this debt supercycle. And for many people, the only solution to all of this debt is this idea that there's going to be some sort of explicit debt default. But when you go through history, there are other ways dealing with very large sums of debt this way, and one of them is to inflate it away through financial repression and through different ways of printing money and creating that inflation. And it's interesting that MMT seems to be coming around at a time when we need to deal with all of the debt in this late stages of that supercycle. Nonetheless, I want to move on. When you predicted that she might upstage Janet Yellen as one of the most influential women in the history of finance. That was actually the last thing I expected to hear from you to say.
Did you really mean that, or has she converted you to become an MMT believer?
Erik Townsend: Well, those are 2 separate questions, but yes, I absolutely believe that Stephanie Kelton is going to be one of the most influential people of our time and perhaps the most influential woman in the history of finance. I think that's entirely realistic. Now, that doesn't mean that I agree personally with her views, but the biggest lesson, the most important lesson that I've ever learned in investing is not to confuse an objective analysis of what is happening to the market with what you wish was happening or what you think should happen or what you think ought to be good for the world.
What's happening is Stephanie Kelton is making incredible inroads and is having an incredibly influential effect on public policy to promote the adoption of the principles of MMT and to encourage politicians to think more about using the power of central banks to print money rather than assuming that any financing for spending has to be sourced by increasing taxes. So that's what's happening, whether I agree with it or not. And the only thing you can do is an investor is to embrace what's really happening in the market.
Patrick Ceresna: So you never answered my question about whether she converted you to becoming an MMT believer directly, but since your answer was about accepting things you don't want or like, should I interpret that as a no?
Erik Townsend: Well, I think we have to separate monetary theory from political ideology and talk about them separately, which frankly almost nobody does. Now, I hold personally an ideological view that governments are always incompetent and inefficient, and that society is better served when the size and budget of government is kept to a minimum and most functions of the economy are handled by the private sector. That's just my personal belief system. Professor Kelton and a whole lot of other people hold the opposite ideological view that larger governments can and should be used to correct social inequities that exist and which were created by the capitalist system. Now, I completely agree that those social inequities exist and need to be corrected. I don't happen to agree that bigger government and more spending is the way to solve them. But the point is, neither of those ideological views have anything to do with monetary theory and how money really works.
But people with both sets of ideological views are prone to seeing the side of monetary theory that seems to confirm or validate their own ideological biases. People on my side of that divide have been guilty, and I admit to this myself, have been guilty of predicting that, you know, deficit spending is going to ruin us and that we're going to have an Armageddon For 50 years, gold bugs have been predicting deficit spending is going to result in a collapse of the dollar and, you know, the end of the world. Those things haven't happened yet, and none of us would have believed 10 years ago that central banks could literally create $10 trillion of US dollar equivalent across all the different central banks around the world in new money creation through essentially the printing press, through the mechanism of quantitative Quantitative easing, and that it wouldn't blow up the system with some kind of inflation.
So has Stephanie Kelton converted me to her ideological views about more spending and more social programs being the right way to solve society's problems? Heck no, definitely not. But has she woken me up to the fact that there are some aspects of what I thought I knew about the laws of monetary theory which in reality were based on my own biases, my own ideology causing me to embrace and like ideas by people like von Mises, which, you know, just kind of resonated with the way I feel about things, which maybe are not completely accurate. Yes, she definitely has opened my eye to that. So I think the key to this, and it's not easy, is you have to be willing to really put your own ideology in a box and look objectively at how we previously understood, not whether spending is a good idea, but the monetary theory of when governments print money out of thin air in order to finance their spending rather than raising taxes in order to do it.
Does that have the dire consequences that the sound money crowd, myself included, have claimed that it has? Well, certainly the experience of the last 10 years has proven that if the things that we've feared are really the way it has to happen, well, it doesn't happen as quickly as we thought it was gonna happen. Because most of us never thought you could have gone 10 years of doing what they've been doing without it blowing up in our face. So does that mean that it's about to blow up in our face and just hasn't happened yet? Or does it mean that we just plain got it wrong?
My ideology hasn't changed. I still think smaller government is better. But I do recognize that I am overdue in opening my eyes to the fact that some of the assumptions that I had about certain things, that if you do this, it's gonna lead to a Weimar Germany-style hyperinflation, you know, it just doesn't work that way. Or if it does work that way, it takes a heck of a lot longer than I thought for those things to play out. So the key, I think, is to separate that monetary theory and how it really works works from your own ideological biases. And that is what I've gained from this whole experience of evaluating modern monetary theory.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay. Since you seem to be on a roll and willing to admit your ideological biases in this conversation, what have you learned about monetary theory that differs from your prior Sound Money Crowd belief system?
Erik Townsend: Well, I really wish that we had had time to get into this with Dr. Kelton, because I would love to have a long-form discussion. With her about this. But I think the clear and undeniable lesson of the last decade's monetary experiment is that when central banks start conjuring money out of thin air to finance deficit spending, the adverse consequences that have been predicted by the sound money crowd simply did not happen in the timeframe that the sound money crowd said they were inevitably going to happen in. So that leaves you with a little bit of a conundrum. You either have to conclude that means they had it wrong, it doesn't really work the way we thought it did, or it really does work the way we thought it did. There really is no free lunch, but it takes longer for those adverse consequences to really occur than we thought possible. So the dollar hasn't crashed the way a lot of people thought it would.
It hasn't lost its reserve status. There's no sign of hyperinflation. inflation. It's taken a full decade of central banks trying to create inflation just to start to produce any CPI inflation. Now, they certainly produced plenty of asset price inflation with their quantitative easing, but in terms of CPI inflation, you know, we're just starting to get there.
The fundamental premise of MMT is that the only real reason for governments not to just print whatever money they need to in order to finance public spending is the risk of inflation. And I couldn't agree more with that. So there's no doubt that we all agree that the reason to not do this is the inflation risk. Now, you heard Professor Kelton in this interview describe in her own words that the capacity of the economy in terms of how much room you've got, how much energy, if you will, does the economy have to print more money to do more good work with? Because she thinks of all of the spending programs of government as doing good work. How much of that good work can you do before inflation starts to bite you? So she's got definitely a model that's very consistent with my understanding of inflation being the risk.
So on some levels, it's very true. The thing is, if we agree that inflation is the risk, and certainly the credible MMT academics like Professor Kelton and Warren Mosler acknowledge That risk. My take is that it really boils down to 2 manifestations of that inflation risk, which just to categorize them, I'll call it the vicious cycle risk, which is the risk of it really mushrooming out of control before you realize what's happened, and the moral hazard risk, which has to do with how politicians reinterpret the prescriptions of people like Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler. So So frankly, I'm going to admit that I do have ideological biases that make me more skeptical about MMT's ability to deliver its promises without triggering those risks. I also think the other side is just as biased by their ideology. They wanna come up with a reason why it's okay to just do all this spending and it's not gonna have any adverse consequence.
I think everybody has to check their ideology at the door in really look more carefully at what the real parameters of that inflation risk are and how early you're able to see it coming before it's too late.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, Erik, let's circle back here because let's better define those 2 manifestations of risk, inflation risk you mentioned. You called the first one the vicious cycle risk. What did you mean by that?
Erik Townsend: Well, I loved Professor Kelton's answer to my inflation question where she basically said in so So many words. All the experts are full of shit and they don't really know how inflation works. You hear all these different theories about velocity of money and inflation expectations begetting more inflation and more inflation expectations.
There is a vicious cycle. I think that most academics would agree that once an inflation gets started, it becomes a self-reinforcing process. And inflation expectations where people anticipate more inflation and that changes their behavior is a part of this. So the corollary is, and she's right to say that, look, you can't just go based on any of these academic models because frankly they're unproven and nobody really knows for sure. But the corollary to that is, well, okay, if the academics are really kind of full of it and nobody really knows the exact parameters of when an inflation is starting to get out of Then how do you know how long it's safe to keep doing this MMT stuff and printing money before you get to the point where an inflation has started that could start to mushroom out of control and essentially where you could have started a fire that you're not gonna be able to put out?
So I'm willing to acknowledge that the $10 trillion US dollar equivalent of quantitative easing didn't cause a runaway inflation the way a whole lot of people, myself included, thought it would.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: included, predicted that it would, at least not yet. Well, does that mean it's coming? And is it something where once it gets started, you won't be able to stop it? And all those $10 trillion of printing will have contributed to something like allowing a forest to dry out over a period of years to the point where it becomes a major runaway fire risk? Or is it really not such a big deal? I don't know the answer to that. I think A fact that the MMT crowd ought to acknowledge is they don't know either. They don't know whether their prescriptions telling people, look, we can just have central banks print money, is that potentially going to start a fire that can't be put out once it's burning?
Are we gonna get to the point where, yeah, it does eventually start an inflation and that inflation runs away and it's too late to do anything about it? Or is it as simple as monitoring a few indicators And at a certain point, you realize, okay, this is where we gotta stop printing.
I haven't seen anything to persuade me that the MMT crowd is really on top of that risk and knows how to stop an inflation before it starts to run out of control. I'm not saying it doesn't exist, but nothing I've seen persuades me that they've really got that under control. And frankly, I think they're as guilty as I am of having allowed their ideological biases to affect their judgment.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, Erik, but you also referenced that the second major category of inflation risk was the moral hazard risk. What did you mean by that one?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, I think that a perfect analogy here is Keynesian countercyclical stimulus theory. Lord Keynes takes a lot of crap that he doesn't deserve. People think that he advocated spend and spend and spend. He didn't. What What he said is in downtimes, government should come to the rescue by spending borrowed money. And then when the economy recovers, government should pay back all of that borrowed money in order to slow down the expansion and also reset the books. Well, what happens is the politicians just take the part of it they like. They like the spend part in downtimes, but when the economy gets good, the idea of slowing it down in order to pay pay back the borrowed money never seems to happen.
So the risk that I see is the seasoned academics like Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler, they definitely understand that this inflation risk is very real. And if that inflation starts to go out of control, you can have a self-reinforcing vicious cycle that could lead to an inflationary or even hyperinflationary greater depression.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: They understand that risk, but what they're doing is they're handing politicians a recipe book for how to spend and spend and spend without having to tax anyone in order to do that spending. Politicians are going to eat that stuff up. They're gonna love it. And then when we get to the point where Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler are telling their politicians, hey, wait a minute, guys, this is— we've reached the point we told you about. Remember we said that inflation thing, that was the big gating. Our indicators are telling us it's time for you to stop. The politicians are suddenly going to stop paying attention to Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler, just like they stopped paying attention to the part of John Maynard Keynes' prescriptions which says when the economy gets better, you're supposed to pay back the borrowed money, not just forget that it ever happened.
So what I'm concerned with is not that Stephanie Kelton has the wrong But that she's handing a prescription to liberal politicians, which is going to allow them to spend and spend and spend on printed money. And when the indications that Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler say are time to stop doing it because inflation is showing its ugly head, I don't think the politicians are gonna stop. And I think that's the biggest risk.
Patrick Ceresna: Okay, Erik, let's put this all together. Now, how would you summarize your overall view on MMT and where monetary policy is heading after reading Professor Kelton's book and after doing this interview?
Erik Townsend: Well, first things first, get ready for MMT. It's coming and it's coming in a big way and there's no stopping it. I meant what I said about Stephanie Kelton being one of the most influential women in the history of finance. She's She's very smart. She's very well-spoken. She's very articulate. She's very persuasive in her arguments. And she has the attention of a lot of public policymakers right now. So whether you agree or not, it's coming. Focus your attention on investing around the expectation that it's happening, whether you like it or not.
If you hold the old-school view or you have the hesitations that I held about how MMT could go wrong, I think you owe it to yourself to step back and ask whether your own ideology was biasing your views. Because certainly this whole money printing experiment, I mean, it went much farther than I thought was possible. And I recognize now that my ideological beliefs about how I think the world ought to work were causing me to think that certain things were impossible and would blow up the system. Which politicians have done anyway, and the system hasn't blown up yet. I do think we're taking extreme risks. I have huge reservations about the large-scale adoption of MMT eventually leading us to a situation where we get to an inflationary Great Depression that could wipe out the entire developed world fiat money system. Seriously. But that's not today. It's not tomorrow. It's a long way in the future. future.
What I would predict, though, is I'm not saying I think, oh, they're going to try MMT and it's going to flop. I would say the opposite. I think that MMT will be adopted by politicians. There will be more money printing. And I think it will be fabulously successful for the first several years. Because as soon as you're spending a whole bunch of money in order to make the world better, it works at first. It's not until Until the inflation, which is created as a result of that, with a long lag factor, actually kicks in, and you can't fight that inflation until you have a problem. So I think it's gonna be perceived as fabulously successful for the first few years. That's going to beget much more political support. They're gonna do it more and more. Eventually, we're gonna get to the point where there's an inflation problem, and Stephanie Kelton and Warren Mosler will be the the first ones to stand up and say, hey, we told you when you get to the inflation constraint, you gotta stop printing money at that point.
And I predict that the politicians will be addicted as crack addicts to printing money without having to tax anybody in order to spend on whatever their next scheme is to buy votes by promising people some kind of benefit.
So I think we're headed toward a whole lot of spending that eventually leads us to the kind of inflation that Stephanie Kelton herself says, that's time to stop printing money when you get to that inflation limit. And I think they're gonna keep on printing money. And I think that moral hazard risk of the politicians misinterpreting the prescriptions of MMT is the really big risk. But it's not gonna happen right away. I think that it will be perceived as very successful at first.
Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, it's too bad that Professor Kelton wasn't available for a longer interview. I would've absolutely loved to I really wish more people would have heard her take on all of these points.
Erik Townsend: Well, so would I. I really wish that we could have done a longer interview. We'd love to have her back. If she ever wants to come back and do a longer form interview, it would be great. Perhaps she has more time after the election. I do want to make sure though that we express our appreciation. She doesn't usually do podcast interviews at all. The fact she gave us a half an hour was really generous and we really appreciate it. level of depth on these issues with Warren Mosler. As I mentioned at the end of the market wrap, before we even got into this interview, we have been in contact with Mr. Mosler. He's been a perfect gentleman, but also very firm in saying no. I guess I'd say it was listener support on Twitter that got Stephanie Kelton's attention and got her to agree. Perhaps someone in the audience has Warren Mosler's ear and can talk him into it.
We would welcome either of them to, to come back for a long-form discussion about these topics. I am convinced it's going to be one of, if not the most important topics in finance in coming years. And again, folks, whether you like it or not, it's coming.
Erik Townsend: This is going to be a really big trend. In any event, Patrick, what also is coming, and we're glad to have you back from a 2-week break, is another Big Picture Trading chart deck. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you don't have a Research Roundup email, that means you're If you're not registered yet, just go to MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the downloads, right above Professor Stephanie Kelton's picture. Patrick, diving into the chart deck, we've got the S&P 500 futures chart on page 2. What's going on here?
Patrick Ceresna: Well, here we are in the pre-elections. I mean, we're a stone's throw away from seeing what is the outcome, and it's a little surprising how narrow of a range
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: And I think that's a good point. I mean, when you look at the incredible range the S&P has been in, I mean, when you go back to look at what was going on in July and August, we were seeing this huge parabolic rise in the markets. Things were accelerating. Those FAANG stocks were on fire. We were way overdue for a market correction. And well, September did bring one about, but I was suspecting that it'd go a little longer, a little farther. But we really are at a stage at this moment where the very overbought condition that existed in the summer isn't there. More of a range-bound price action. And so it is very likely in the post-election period that there is room for a bigger market reaction.
So I thought on page 3, what was just relevant to reference what happened last time— so this is going back to the S&P chart in 2016, and most people are obviously familiar with this, but it was a surprise when Trump won, and the market initially took it negatively. And in the after hours, the S&P plunged lower. But if you didn't have access to the futures markets in the after hours, you literally didn't have a chance to react on it because by the time the markets were trading the next day, they were already heading to turning up on the day. And that was a surprise. The thing is that if Trump wins this time, I don't think it's gonna catch market participants by surprise, even though, you know, everyone's arguing about what the odds are I think everyone in, uh, that is neutral recognizes that each— there's an equal probability that, uh, the, the election can swing either way. And so the question really becomes, is there room for a risk-off event on the stock market?
And, you know, the one thing is that in my 20 years of trading experience and having gone through so many market crashes in the past, the one thing I've known is that rarely does the market crash on something that everyone is expecting, planning, and/or analyzing. Almost always a market event happens when the market is blindsided by something that it wasn't expecting. And therefore, this election has been over the last 6 months one of the most anticipated things. The likelihood that some big, huge volatile event happens in the S&P That window is closing on that pretty quickly here. Later in the chart book, we'll talk about how the volatility in the markets is setting up. But certainly at this stage, the market is likely to find this little range pocket going into the elections, and then we'll see where it goes from there.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, one place where I strongly agree is I think the setup here is going to be for a move up in stock prices after it's crystal clear to everyone and all disagreement is over with respect With respect to who's president of the United States. The thing is, that's not going to be known on election night this time around. And it's just, in my mind, it's all about the question of, okay, so that means there's a chance of a risk-off, down-in-price event starting on election night or even before then until we figure out that it's clear. And, you know, do we have to have the Supreme Court tell us what the outcome is? You know, what's it going to take? We're in uncharted territory. So I don't know how big the down is, but I think the down eventually sets up a buyable dip, and that's the opportunity to see a rally.
Because once we know and this certainty has been resolved, I think with either candidate, the market's ready to move up.
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. I think there's a lot of traders that have been de-risking and deleveraging and raising some cash just to reduce the overall volatility into the election. And once there's clarity, there is certainly the potential for money flow to come back into the market, at least initially. You know, there's a lot of different scenarios that can play out, especially if there's a blue wave sweep that could be interpreted bearishly down the road. But at least initially, I think that all of this anxiety going into the elections has lots of room for money to be put back to work once there's clarity.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Patrick Ceresna: Anyway, let's move on to, uh, chart 4. And what I continue to find fascinating is, is just how the dollar has remained non-committal. And even there were a number of these attempts for the US dollar to rally, which would be a euro breakdown on this chart, but each time US dollar weakness seems to prevail. And when we go to chart 5, it seems to be so evident on the US dollar against that Japanese yen. And we find ourselves retesting at this moment those August and September lows.
And the, the big question here was that breakdown we saw the other day, the beginning of potentially a retest of the March lows. And, and we see that US dollar yen heading down to the 101 level. Nonetheless, uh, dollar weakness continues to be dominant, and every time the bulls have tried to turn that trend. They've been turned away, and that's, uh, that's some— we have to respect that prevailing trend that continues to dominate here, right?
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to Bitcoin on page 6. I'm particularly curious about Bitcoin's outperformance relative to gold because it's easy to look at this Bitcoin chart by itself and say, oh, it must be anticipation of uncertainty around the election, that's what's driving it higher. But, you know, if that was it, gold ought to be doing the same thing. And it's not.
Patrick Ceresna: Exactly. And so big breakout on Bitcoin. Certainly, uh, there's no other way to put it. I mean, when it's breaking to a 52-week high, uh, especially on such kind of a tailwind, then it's certainly, um, a trend that's established and we have to respect that. But what's interesting is, is that when, uh, we look at gold, which is on page 7, you would think that gold would have a similar style uptick. And the reason we can draw that, at least have inferred that that should have been happening, is if you go to page 8, while the implied volatility of Bitcoin, which is in orange, is obviously far greater, and therefore, uh, it shows it's whipping greater here, but you can identify the correlation of gold and Bitcoin in terms of its movement against the dollar. And, uh, they have— there's many occasions where gold and Bitcoin have, have trended in the same direction, and we've truly seen a divergence here where gold has really stayed range-bound and Bitcoin has taken off.
I mean, we saw similar situations in the past, back in the start of the year and a few other times where this happened, and often gold has caught up. And so it's going to be really interesting to see whether gold is just a laggard here and that Bitcoin is advertising that there's room for gold to go, or whether they're finally going to decouple here and maybe Bitcoin's gonna, you know, march to the beat of its own drum.
Erik Townsend: Moving on to page 9, crude oil, my own favorite chart. What do you make of this? Because boy, from a technical standpoint, this consolidation has been going on an awful long time now.
Patrick Ceresna: Oh, absolutely. At least it's been Yeah, I mean, throughout September and most of October, there's just been such a tight range. And I mean, I think you've already discussed it when we were talking in the market wrap, but, you know, the one question that I just wanted to ask here, I mean, we see this big pickup in yields because a lot of people are starting to anticipate or the idea that inflation is coming.
But crude oil plays an important role in inflation expectations. And certainly we have not seen oil upticking that would create that kind of an assumption to be made. And I kind of just wanted to ask the question, I mean, could we really see inflation expectations continue to surge and all this to go and crude oil not break out? I mean, that's— maybe it can. And so certainly something that we're watching. I think that determining which way it's going to break out of this trend is going to be so crucial. I mean, consolidations in oil could head down to the, again, to the mid to low 30s if there was a catalyst for it on the interim. But I generally think that these energy markets are so oversold that, and so much of this bad news has already been baked into the cake, that at some point the sentiment is going to start to shift in the space.
Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I agree. I think that we're definitely headed much higher on oil prices eventually. The thing is, I think the COVID crisis will take longer to play out than most people assume. So many people just have it in their head that a vaccine that's gonna solve everything and the whole crisis comes to an end and everything goes back to normal just happens one day. There's no good reason to assume that. The SARS-CoV-2 virus is probably going to become endemic and we're gonna have to learn to live with it. But sooner or later, the damage that's been done and the inability, as Art Berman has described, of the US shale patch to really recover to its previous production, we've gotta eventually get to much higher oil prices. The thing is, there's room to go lower first. And I think a return to $30 before we eventually move back to the $50 to $80 range is entirely possible here.
So we'll have to wait and see how it plays out.
Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, moving on to page 10, I just wanted to quickly talk about copper. Now, when you're looking actually right across the commodity complex, particularly the grains have been on fire for the last couple weeks on the upside. But even here we have copper breaking to a 52-week new high. And so we— while oil is staying in that pocket and staying very range-bound, we certainly do have a much broader commodity rally outside of gold and oil. And it's going to be really interesting to to see whether these commodities continue to run. And certainly when we had that breakdown candle on copper that we talked about here on the show back at the start of October, and we really were asking, was that a big breakdown move that was starting a correction? Well, almost immediately the bulls bought the dip and wiped out the breakdown candle within, within, uh, 3, 4 sessions. And that, uh, that just continues demonstrate that this is very well accumulated and the bull trend is pretty intact here on copper.
And it'll be interesting to see how high they're going to make this push. Maybe we can see something north of $3.25 towards $3.50 if this really gains some traction.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to page 11 and the 5s-30s yield curve. Boy, it looks like a new high.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, exactly. And this is interesting. And this comes back to that whole inflation expectations thing that we sort We're talking about just earlier. I mean, really, we continue to see this bear steepening well underway. I mean, it's the long end of the curve that continues to see yields picking up. And when you're going into that shorter end, it's still very much pinned by the Fed on the downside. And to me, a real steepening would only— should only really be happening when true inflation expectations are here, and we clearly are seeing a breakout. And so I asked the question, is that really showing that the market is now fully starting to price in this scenario that inflation is coming? I don't know. I've— something in me, I don't know if I trust it. It's, uh, it will be interesting to see in the next week or two whether or not this breakout fades or whether it sticks. It's certainly going to be on my watch list, uh, of things to watch.
But what I, what I wanted to do though is move on to page 12 to just look at those junk bond credit spreads. What I find fascinating here is that even though we have huge unemployment potential on Main Street, uh, USA, potential bankruptcies and small businesses and all sorts of other issues in there, I find it fascinating that there is no spike in credit risks showing on these spreads. Now obviously some people are saying that Fed manipulation is, is in full play here, but really I'd buy that if we were talking investment-grade bonds. But you know, I would— you would think that you would start to see some risk starting to be baked into the cake here. And really this continues to be pinned very, very low at the— certainly at 6-month lows on the bottom of range. Be really interesting to see if in the post-election period whether we start to see some, some fear starting to be priced into these spreads.
Erik Townsend: Patrick, let's move on to the VIX on page 13. I notice it seems like there's a real pattern here where the VIX just doesn't want to move below 20 back down into the teens. What's going on there?
Patrick Ceresna: You know, there's no shortage of traders out there that are drawing the little trend line breaks on the volatility index, trying to anticipate whether or not a new breakout in volatility is imminent. But I think that in the post-coronavirus market crash period, volatility has been at an elevated level largely because I think everyone was anticipating this volatility into the elections. And I think that there's a lot of risk at this stage to volatility in the post-election period. And I think what's a good idea to kind of anchor off of is if you look on page 14, when we look at what volatility did or volatility index did in 2016, we can see that right in the post-election period, we saw in that case almost a 50% wipeout of volatility premiums in a day.
It was just extraordinary. How volatility normalized in, in that post-election period.
Now, I don't think we're going to see something as dramatic as that in this cycle, but when we do look at page 15 and see the way that the VIX term structure is set up, we have clear backwardation in that term structure, which is not normal. And when we're looking on that chart on the right-hand side there, we can see that natural contango in the VIX market is the natural place where it is. And one would think that this backwardation is really only there because of the election risk.
And so one of the interesting things that we're going to be watching here going into the next 2 weeks as we go past the elections is that will we see the collapse of this term structure, pushing it back into either a flattening or an outright contango on the other side. I actually think that that's a very reasonable proposition, that it actually plays out that way. And more importantly, this is going to have a pretty big impact on a lot of different option strategies, particularly when people are positioning themselves into the elections with options. What would happen if volatility Volatility was to substantially decline in that time frame, and so that is certainly something I think we're going to have to be watching. And I think traders, as being positioned with options into the elections, need to start to explore different ways to hedge out the risk that volatility can move against them, and that Vega risk that would exist in in being long too much gamma.
And so certainly something that we're going to be discussing in the weeks to come at Big Picture Trading.
Erik Townsend: What do you think about the time spread trade, maybe short February VIX futures, long May, anticipating that by February you'll get back to a normal contango structure in that curve?
Patrick Ceresna: I think it's a very reasonable proposition that that happens. I don't see what the catalyst would be for the backwardation to exist. And so this readjusting, I think, is a very reasonable proposition and is certainly something that I think is better odds than not.
Erik Townsend: Yeah. I'm just looking at this chart. My immediate reaction to it is I'm tempted by short February, long May. And the reason I say that is if we get all the way to February and we still don't know who the President of the United States is, it's not going to get any better by May.
I think either we see a normal reversion of this curve or you're going to get to the point where the longer-dated vol is going to start to go through the roof too, as people anticipate whatever's still going on in February. If the civil war has begun, it's only going to get worse by May. More likely, none of that happens and everything reverts to a normal structure. So I like short Feb, long May. I'm going to think about putting that one on myself.
Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, I wanted to leave it with looking at page 16, looking at the S&P 500 volatility surface. Here I have it on the SPY going out 4 months, and we see the typical fat left tail skew here. And what's interesting, if you look at that little green line down the middle, it's showing you where the at-the-money strikes are. We can clearly see the volatility premium picks up going out over the And the pre-election options are priced at a much lower vol premium. So there's clearly that volatility kink that's in there that is pricing that reaction in there. But I think that there are different ways to take advantage of this. And so that's one of the things I'm gonna be doing is looking at what is the way that we can take advantage of that extra vol premium that's being priced in for election risk.
Erik Townsend: Speaking of election risk, Patrick, I wanna move on to page 17 because you are holding holding a webinar specifically about how to hedge your portfolio during the US elections, no matter who wins, which is obviously a very timely topic. Now, that's for your Big Picture Trading clients. Can people who sign up for the free trial get in on that webinar as well?
Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So anyone who wants to join me on that webinar can just sign up for a 14-day trial and join me Thursday, morning at 9:45 AM, and we'll be covering all sorts of the different things to take into consideration. Obviously, the one thing that one has to reflect is, is that just buying a protective put or some other hedge for election risk really at this stage has more or less been fully priced in, and you're going to pay a pretty rich volatility premium. And so there, it's about how do you construct trades that can reduce the overall volatility of your portfolio and take advantage of the volatility pricing versus you just outright paying for all of that rich vol premium.
Erik Townsend: And the rest of the information about that free trial of Big Picture Trading is on page 18. We're going to leave it there for this week's show, folks. This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing a trillion-dollar asset class of available to all accredited investors. And by TopTradersUnplugged.com.
Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at TopTradersUnplugged.com/MacroGuide. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo. Listeners, be sure to register a free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our Research Roundup email, which provides you with all of the best free content that we could find on the internet each week, including downloads associated with our guest appearances, as well as, of course, our postgame chartbooks. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.
Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed here in the postgame. There's also a link to the Variant Perception blog on Don't Fear the Rise in Yields and a link to a Jesse Felder article of Who Said Value Was Dead. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.
You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next time. Thank you. Next week.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions.
The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by. Sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
Guy Keller — fund manager in the uranium mining space (as introduced on the show)
Mike Alkin — fund manager in the uranium mining space (as introduced on the show)
Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.
Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 241 was recorded on October 15th, 2020. I'm Erik Townsend. This episode is brought to you by TopTradersUnplugged.com, a podcast dedicated to quant and rules-based investing, helping investors overcome behavioral biases, and by FarmTogether.com, Bringing farmland, a new trillion-dollar investment opportunity, within reach of all accredited investors. We're going to do a special show on uranium this week, a commodity whose fundamentals are really looking good for a turnaround. Mike Alkin and Guy Keller join me as this week's feature interview guests. Mike and Guy are both fund managers in the uranium mining space, and they've both got some excellent insights on this market to share with you. Patrick Ceresna is off this week, so Kevin Muir, author of the popular Macro Tourist blog, returns again as this week's co-host.
Kevin Muir: And I'm Kevin Muir in for Patrick Ceresna. Erik, let's jump to it. The SPOOs appeared a little rudderless this week, and one day we're watching it march straight up, and then abruptly the next day the selling comes in and is offered. What do you make of the action?
Erik Townsend: Oh, I think it's all about the election. We're into the final weeks. The election is now the predominant force that's affecting the market. And of course, you know, the news is, is up and down. One minute we've got the story breaking about the Biden crime family, and then we see it's from Rudy Giuliani, and everybody crawls down, rolls their eyes, and says, okay, it's just Rudy.
You know, maybe we don't take that too seriously. And then all of a sudden, Twitter and Facebook are censoring it. Well, that really brings, you know, big questions into how this election is being managed. And, you know, it's one thing after another.
I think the reason you're seeing all the volatility in the market is 'cause markets can't figure out what's happening. To me, a contested election, to some degree, is not even a question. It's a certainty. In my mind, the question is how much unrest and political backlash is there gonna be from the people who don't get their way? And how does that compare to what's already been priced in? And of course, it's hard to gauge exactly what's already been priced in. But I think that we're really waiting to see how much, you know, backfire there is or how much resistance there is to the outcome of the election.
And, you know, I don't think it's a clean sweep by any stretch. I think that whoever doesn't win is going to not concede.
Kevin Muir: And we'll see what So let's move on to the US dollar. The decline of the past month seems to have stalled, and now the US dollar is actually poking its head up. Is this the start of something bigger?
Erik Townsend: I don't think there's any reason to conclude that it needs to be. I mean, finally, yeah, we're seeing some strength this week, but it's not enough to set a technical direction. I think you still need a daily close over 95 on the dollar index, or below 92 if you wanna go the other direction, to draw a technical analysis conclusion.
My best guess is the consolidation continues through the election. And then I think if there were a really big surprise in the sense of excessive civil unrest and violence and so forth, I think that would be dollar negative. I think if it all blows over, and particularly if there was a clean sweep and everyone agrees who the president is in 2021, which frankly seems unlikely to me, I think that would be very dollar positive. So I think we need to wait for the election and see what happens.
Kevin Muir: So crude oil continues to stay confined in this narrow trading band. Any hope for some action in the energy markets anytime soon?
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, I want to go back to my comments in last week's show about the back-of-curve time spreads and how they often serve as a leading indicator for what's coming in the flat price. As you say, if we look at flat price action, we're in a narrow trading band. The chart doesn't really speak to me and say anything about direction from here. On the other hand, if I look at those back-of-curve time spreads, and my favorite spread to look at is Z1-Z2, the December '21 through December '22 time spread.
Until today, it was consistently for more than a week just staying rallying above its 5-day moving average, above all of its short-term moving averages. On this morning's spike down in flat price, we did get a retest of those short-term moving averages, just about perfectly touching the 13-day moving average at $0.80, but now recovering nicely above the 8 and almost back to the 5, the 5-day moving average, which is the highest of the moving averages. And again, the market stayed above those short-term moving averages on a closing basis for the last couple of weeks. That number is 57 cents negative, 57 cents of contango. We're at 62 cents of contango right now, which is just above the 8-day moving average.
So, you know, it looks to me like we're seeing a signal from the back of the curve that higher prices may be in the works. A stumble today, a retest of those short-term moving averages. That's gonna be really interesting to see. This was a close below the 5-day, the first one in a couple of weeks on the Z1/Z2 spread. I'm watching that as maybe a precursor of what's coming. If I look at the flat price, it's not really telling me anything on that chart as far as what's coming next.
Inventory this week definitely helped the recovery off of the spike down in price, which we saw this morning. Crude oil drawing down 3.8 million barrels. Now, that's the officially designated commercial storage. If you add the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which these days is also a form of commercial storage, which is another 1.2 million barrels. It was a total drawdown of 5 million barrels. Cushing, Oklahoma, on the other hand, building 2.9 million barrels. Gasoline drawing down 1.6 million barrels. And the really big drawdown this week was in distillates, 7.2 million barrel drawdown. That's the biggest one-week drawdown in distillate inventories in 17 years.
US production was down considerably by half a million barrels to 10.5 million. But again, remember, we had the storm roll through the Gulf shutting in some production last week. So I don't think that's the beginning of the epic fall in US production that Art Berman has predicted later in Q4. I think that significant drop this week was really just a transient effect of tropical storm activity in the Gulf. In any event, tape action was a nice rally as those draws were confirmed. Time spread performance, as I said earlier, is often a reliable signal of where flat price is headed. That chart looks much more bullish than the flat price chart does.
Kevin Muir: Let's move on to gold. It's hanging in there, but really nothing to write home about. Is gold waiting for the election as well?
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, one of the rules that I've learned over the years about technical analysis is when you have 2 converging trend lines, either in a wedge or a descending triangle or what have you, it's always worthwhile to look at, okay, where do those 2 lines converge on the chart, what date is that? And ask yourself, what's significant about that date? Well, in this case, it's really easy. The, the 2 trend lines converge at the election. So it's very clear to me that gold is waiting to see what is going to happen in this election.
And I think the fundamentals here are that we've got a lot of expectation of a potential increase in civil unrest that is already priced in. I think if you had a clean sweep and a widely accepted agreement on who's president, I think it's bearish for gold and we end up moving much lower. And I don't want to say much, much lower, but a more significant correction than we've seen so far.
On the other hand, I think that if you went, you know, in the extreme to incipient civil war, well then I think gold would be through the roof to the upside. Until then, we're hanging out in this descending triangle or wedge pattern. The support is the 100-day moving average now at $1,883, and the resistance is descending triangle resistance at $1,925.
Kevin Muir: Okay.
Erik Townsend: That upper resistance was perfectly tested over the course of last week. It was 1936 at the time. We got a perfect test of it. And, you know, now it looks like we've actually been back down almost perfectly testing that 100-day. I wouldn't be surprised if we continue to bounce around in this range until the election outcome becomes a little bit clearer.
Kevin Muir: Erik, let's end with bonds. Last week we had an uptick in yields, but the bond sell-off seems to have met some buyers. And yields are now down back towards the middle of the recent channel. Is this the new normal we can expect for bonds? A whole lot of nothing?
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, I think a whole lot of nothing is the perfect description for this. And frankly, I'll just say the reason I think it's a whole lot of nothing is because a whole lot of people are just as confused as I am. We know that there's a good argument to be made for a secular shift to inflation, which would be very bearish for bonds and mean yields would be headed much higher. We also know that it's an easy mistake to make to be potentially several years early making a call like that.
And how many people have been wrong saying the, you know, the 30-year bond bull market is over? Well, that was 8 years ago and it wasn't over. Well, the 35-year bond bull market is over. Well, no, it wasn't. Well, we're up to 38 years now. Is it really over or are we headed to 40 years before it's over? I don't know. I think we're near the end. And I think that at a turning point in a major secular trend like this, It's an easy place to be wrong. So the reason there's a whole lot of nothing is because nobody has a whole lot of conviction, because nobody can figure it out.
Kevin Muir: This week's feature interview guests are uranium fund managers, Mike Alkin and Guy Keller. Erik, why uranium this week and why these guests in particular?
Erik Townsend: Well, we've gotten a lot of listener feedback that you'd like more commodity-oriented content, and we're actually working behind the scenes to try to design even more commodity-oriented content in coming months on MacroVoices. But I wanted to start here with uranium. uranium, because I think it's a really interesting story. We've heard about it in the past from Marin Katusa, but I wanted to do a show with fund managers who really focus specifically on this sector of uranium, because I really believe that nuclear energy is going to continue to be very important for a very long time.
And we really need to look at what has happened, the destruction in the market capitalization of the uranium mining industry. This is an industry that's gone from $150 billion in market cap to $5 billion in market cap over a period of several years. So it's, it's really, really important.
Now, what these 2 guests both have in common is they run funds that have had to maneuver because although there's great opportunities in this space, it's capacity limited. In the case of Mike Alkin's fund, it's closed to new investors because he doesn't want more money right now because it's too hard to find the right deals. In the case of Guy Keller, his fund is still open, but they had to spin off a new fund to focus on uranium because their existing natural resources fund was so big that if they had tried to invest in uranium through that fund, they were at a market size where their investments would be too large for what the market can sustain. So they had to spin off a new fund for just that reason. So what does that say to you, Kevin?
What might be coming when you start to see more institutional money pile into this space as the market clearly turns around. We're early in the turnaround story, but I think it is a turnaround and it's a very interesting one.
Listeners, we know many of you agree with us that we're the best financial podcast on the internet because that's what iTunes and Apple Podcasts used to say about us. Unfortunately, we haven't been reminding you to do those ratings and reviews, which keep us in our number one slot, which we really feel like we deserve. And by the way, that's what helps us get the very best feature guests to come on the program. So your ratings and reviews really do help us to get better feature interviews for your future listening pleasure.
Erik Townsend: Writing a 5-star review for MacroVoices is simple. The instructions step by step are in your Research Roundup email.
This episode was made possible by TopTradersUnplugged.com. In recent weeks, we've been reminded of the fragility of world financial markets and how quickly sentiment can shift from risk-on to risk-off. Once again, the mantra of buy the dip and the determination of central banks will be put to the test. But as Chris Cole recently told us, the best approach to investing in the long run is very different from what's worked best in recent decades. To help MacroVoices listeners navigate an uncertain future, Niels Kaastrup-Larsen host of the Top Traders Unplugged podcast, has created a guide to the best investment. books of all time. You can get a free copy at toptradersunplugged.com/macroguide.
And be sure to listen to my full-length interview with Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on trend following. The download link is in your Research Roundup email. Check out toptradersunplugged.com today. You'll be glad you did.
Kevin Muir: Erik's interview with Mike Alkin and Guy Keller is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.
Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.
Erik Townsend: Today's topic is uranium, and I have 2 expert guests joining me. First, Mike Alkin is fund manager and founder of the Sachem Cove Special Opportunity Fund, a fund which invests in uranium. Guy Keller is the portfolio manager for the Nuclear Energy Opportunity Fund for Tribeca Investment Partners. Mike prepared a slide deck, actually shared the, the pitch deck from his hedge fund with us. Registered users will find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not a registered user yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads right above Mike and Guy's photos. Gentlemen, thanks so much for joining us.
Mike Alkin: Thank you.
Erik Townsend: Let's start with kind of the big picture, because I think a lot of people kind of felt like, okay, nuclear energy, really important industry. Well, but then Fukushima happened. And boy, even though people like you and I who tend to focus on logic and reasons understand that nuclear energy is still the safest form of energy we know how to generate, frankly, the world doesn't work on logic and reason. It works on public sentiment and emotion. And that emotion was so strongly anti-nuclear that a lot of people just wrote off nuclear power and said, okay, this industry's done at this point. How should we be thinking about the nuclear power industry? Does it have a future? And how much of a future does it have? Let's start with Mike Alkin from Sachem Cove.
Mike Alkin: It's an excellent question, Erik. Clearly, the electric utility industry around the world plays second fiddle to the alternative energy markets, marketing people. And it's been this way going back since the beginning of time. The word nuclear scares people. And as you mentioned in your question or in your comment during the question was it is the safest form of electricity generation per terawatt-hour of energy produced, but it's not viewed that way. You've had 3 major incidents. You had Three Mile Island in the US in the '70s, and then you had Chernobyl, which people know about in the mid-'80s, and then Fukushima, as you mentioned, in March of 2011.
But there have been very few actual deaths from those. But At the end of the day, there's been a big, big push and a big sentiment change the last couple of years towards nuclear power. And that big push is driven by climate change.
And when you look at the facts, the reality is nuclear power is clean, safe, and reliable. And science shows that if you want to achieve these climate goals over the next few decades, you can't get there Just with renewables. It just doesn't work. There's too much intermittency. Storage costs are very expensive to store the electricity. And many, many scientists and even politicians are starting to recognize if we want to get there and achieve these goals, nuclear power has to be part of the playbook. And so for the first time, when Fukushima had its problems in 2011, At the time, Japan was 13% of global nuclear power and they had 54 reactors and all of them over the next year or 2 went offline.
You're still not back. You only have about 9 operating reactors that are online in Japan. You're quite a way away from getting back to where they originally were. But for the first time in the past year, global nuclear power output is above pre-Fukushima levels.
And that's because there's somewhat of a nuclear renaissance that's taking place. You have over 50 reactors around the world under construction, half a trillion dollars that are in process construction. And so you are seeing people recognize that nuclear needs to be part of the playbook to achieve climate change. It's safe.
And importantly, it's pretty much 24/7. It's there, it's reliable. So you are seeing a— I wouldn't say a major sea change, but you're seeing an acceptance of nuclear power needing to be part of the mix.
Erik Townsend: Guy, what would you add to that?
Guy Keller: Yeah, thanks, Erik. I mean, I think Mike's made some fantastic points there. And I mean, the point to really ram home is that as long as achieving a low or zero carbon future remains the goal of global society, then nuclear energy cannot be ignored. You know, it has to have a part to play because it is 24/7, low carbon or almost zero carbon baseload electricity.
And, you know, we're getting 60 to 80 years out of these reactors now. So when you talk about sort of post-Fukushima, when, when the general public want to, to get their science from, from 20 years of watching The Simpsons and, and more recently of watching a bit of HBO disaster porn, On that Chernobyl series. It does entrench bias and beliefs.
But I point to just the number of high-profile environmentalists. And in the United States over there, there's one very prominent man who basically wrote the book on anti-nuclear, who's done a complete 180 and has now come to the conclusion that for the world to be truly carbon neutral, it needs nuclear. So, you know, and down here in Australia, we have the same thing where, where there's, there's, there's a growing band of scientists and environmentalists who were anti-nuclear energy, who are now realizing as well that, that there needs to be a part to play in the future. So, you know, as I said, you know, to Mike's point that the sentiment is changing, you know, we're seeing that via that. And I think also with political acceptance down here in Australia, there's, there's much more of a, of a dialogue around uranium mining and potentially future nuclear provision, nuclear power provision as new technologies come into play.
But, you know, we've certainly noticed that change in the last 2 or 3 years.
Mike Alkin: And Erik, if I could just jump in real quick, if you look in our deck on slide 8, we talk about the days of full power of different generating sources. Nuclear generates about almost 350 days a year at full power. And you compare that even to coal and natural gas where it's a little over 150 to 175 days. And then you get down to solar and wind and you're looking at less than 100 and a little over 100. And a very interesting example would be in Germany where Germany post-Fukushima decided they were going to wean themselves off of nuclear power, which was a significant portion of their electricity grid.
So So 2012 to today, they have spent hundreds of billions of dollars to get there. And what you've seen is their carbon output is neutral and the cost of electricity is up 4 times. Why? Because the renewables can't be there all the time. So they've actually had to build some coal.
And so it's just a very, very difficult thing to either eliminate nuclear power or to not include it in your future goals.
Erik Townsend: Now, there's something that I'm quite certain has collapsed since Fukushima, and that is investment capital coming into this industry. And that's resulted in just a tremendous collapse in the size of the mining industry. And I'm sure you guys can give me some statistics on that, but why don't we get to how big is the uranium mining industry? And let's pretend that we just need to run the existing power plants. Forget about even building any new ones because that's obviously somewhat politically contentious.
Is there enough capacity in the existing mining industry to service the existing nuclear reactors that are still in service?
Mike Alkin: So it's a good question, a very good question, Erik. The title of our deck is Climbing a Wall of Worry: Price Is Everything. So capacity today exists, but nowhere near the price that that capacity can produce profitably. And so when you look at the amount of less than half of the miners in the world today at these prices, in spot price at $30, and then you go a little bit out on the curve, the long-term contracts are a little bit more, only about less than half make money. So it's not so much the capacity, it's the price at which that capacity can be productive and profitable. And that's where you're talking on average, the marginal producer needs to make about $50.
And so you're at a price today of $30. So yes, there is capacity out there, but the incentive to bring that capacity, which has been cut, you've seen 25% of world supply been cut since the end of '16. That capacity needs a price incentive to be able to produce. And that's the opportunity that we see in uranium.
The price will incent production. If it doesn't, some reactors are going to run out of fuel.
Erik Townsend: Guy, tell me about the size of the industry. How much of a collapse have we seen in the market capitalization of uranium mining compared to where it was, I don't know, pre-Fukushima sometime?
Guy Keller: Oh, I mean, it's a fraction of what it was in the last bull market. I mean, I think the statistic a lot of people throw around is there was around Around about globally 500 listed opportunities that had something to do with uranium. And now there's probably 50, of which maybe only half of those are investable.
I mean, when we looked at the opportunity— so I'm also part of our larger global natural resources fund, which is from that fund is where we started looking at the uranium opportunity. And we could not make an investment case work in that fund to the extent we wanted to because the fund was too big and we wouldn't be able to get the position sizes that we needed. So that's why we ended up spinning out the smaller Nuclear Energy Opportunities Fund, just so that we could have a concentrated portfolio of exposure that wasn't going to mean that we were substantial shareholders in every single thing we moved into.
Mike Alkin: And Erik, if I could just go back to the question about enough capacity. One of the things when you talk about the uranium mining world, you have to have a discussion about Kazakhstan, the country of Kazakhstan, and the state-owned entity called Kazatomprom. And Kazatomprom has a little over 20% of global market share, but there are several joint ventures in Kazakhstan where they participate in. So the country of Kazakhstan is about 40%.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Alkin: And then there are some other state-owned producers that you have, like the Russians, the Chinese, the Uzbeks, the French.
So a lot of times people will say, well, it's state-owned production and that can meet all demand because they're not price sensitive. Actually, the Kazakhs have gone— they floated now 25% of the company starting back in '18, and they've been incredibly supply disciplined. And when you look at all of the productive capacity, in the state-owned entities, it's running at about 70, even pre-COVID, about 70, 75% of capacity because it wasn't incented at price.
But one of the things we do is if we were to look at all of the state-owned capacity in the world, which also includes— we include Olympic Dam, which is the big copper mine owned by BHP where uranium is a byproduct. But if we included all of that and we Included all of the production that comes out of some of the care and maintenance mines, uh, that McArthur River does not come back, which is a big mine owned by Cameco. But we include Cigar Lake, another mammoth mine owned by Cameco. When you start including these back into the mix, when you include all of these pounds being produced, you're still looking at a few hundred million pound deficit over the next decade. And you could see that in our slide deck. We start talking about it from slide 22 to like 25 or 26. The reality is Let's use some round numbers over the next several years. And when you talk mining, as you know, these things take— it could take 15, 20 years to find, develop, permit, and bring it into production.
So a decade is tomorrow. You're looking at a structural deficit right now of over 30 million pounds per year, but that keeps growing because you have some mine depletions that come on. But as the price stays low, And it doesn't incent the development of these new projects, you're talking deficits that can stretch out into the 40, 50 million pound per year range. Now, of course, there are some secondary supplies, but in round numbers, you're talking 200 million pounds of demand.
If you were talking the Kazakhs running at full production, all the state-owned folks running at full production, you still are tens of millions of pounds annually short, including secondary supplies that could come into the market, which would be a structural deficit for many years to come. And again, the elixir for that is price.
In the last cycle, you saw the price of uranium go from $10 up to $137 in the spot market over a few-year period. If we were to look at all the mines that could come online, that could meet all the demand needs, we estimate you're probably in the $70, $75 range. Now, that wasn't too different from last cycle, but what happened?
Erik Townsend: Fear.
Mike Alkin: Fear ruled the day and utilities were contracting like there was no tomorrow. They normally contract your consumption, but they were contracting for years at 120, 130, up to 150% of their annual consumption over multi-year contracts of 7, 8, 9, 10 years. So there is supply out there, but price plays a huge role in it and time because the longer it waits, the less uranium that's going to be available. There's probably $4 billion worth of mines that need to be constructed. And at these prices, nobody's financing that.
Guy Keller: Yeah, sorry. But also, I think just to add there, Mike, as well, it's management, it's permitting, and it's jurisdiction as well. I mean, there's not too many management teams left in uranium that have successfully brought a mine on in the last 10 years. There's jurisdictions where On a headline basis, they look like a safe and friendly— I mean, Australia's a perfect example. Australia looks like a great friendly uranium jurisdiction. But when you go and delve down into state by state, if you're in the state of Western Australia or Queensland, you've got problems.
So price, then assuming you can get invested in a capital investment and you've got a management team that can actually go and construct the mine, there's still a whole bunch of hurdles. So if the price responds tomorrow, for example, that deficit is not magically fixed in 6 to 12 months. It's a much longer process.
Erik Townsend: Mike, I want to go back to what you said a minute ago about these contracts that they're buying uranium from. As a futures trader, I remember a few years ago getting interested in uranium, thinking, okay, I don't need the ETF. I'll just trade it on the futures market. And then I looked, there's no liquidity in that contract. I don't know why they even have it listed. How does this market work? You mentioned the spot market. Who's actually buying and selling uranium and what are the terms that that occurs under?
Mike Alkin: Great question and it's one of the most complicated aspects for people to get their head around who are coming into the market to learn it. Typically, for a nuclear power plant, security of supply is paramount. Just to give some context around what fuel buying is, if you're running a coal-fired or natural gas-fired power plant, the feedstock Nat gas or coal is probably 80 to 90% of the costs.
For uranium, the front end of the fuel cycle, and it goes through many steps. It comes out of the ground, it's mined, it's then converted to something called UF6, and then it's enriched, which everyone has heard of enrichment, and it's fabricated, and then it winds up at the plant gate in fuel rods. Well, that takes a couple of years, but the actual— and that's about 20— that front end is about 20% of the operating cost.
Guy Keller: Wow.
Mike Alkin: Versus 80 and 90 for the other, for the fossil fuel plants. But the uranium itself is mid to high single digits of the actual cost. So it's not a significant input cost. And so historically, because security of supply, there's no substitute. Once you build a plant, you spend several billion to build it, you have to have uranium. It takes a long time. There's fires, there's floods, a lot of stuff happens that typically 75, 80% of this industry is driven off of long-term contracts that are 7, 8, 9, 10, and sometimes many years long.
Guy Keller: Wow.
Mike Alkin: Longer than that.
And so what you saw in the last cycle was you had a lengthy bear market and price had even gone down to $7 at one point, but it was bopping along in the early 2000s at $10, $12, $14. And when you started to see that, and again, not a lot of pounds trading in spot, inventories had been worked down over the years. And then you started to see there was a flood at one mine, there was a fire at another mine. There were a series of events that took place that scared the fuel buyers and they were going out and Contracting, as I said earlier, at 120 to 150% of their annual consumption needs. And when you look at that, what they did is those contracts that started in '05, '06, '07, '08, '09, '10, they started to roll off in the middle part of the teens.
But what happened were there are 2 things that were occurring in the marketplace that were un— that one was anticipated, one wasn't. Nobody anticipated Fukushima. So at that time you had You had over 20 million pounds per year, 13% of world demand, all of a sudden kind of go offline. And so when you saw that, you saw utilities who had contracted heavily were covered out for the years, and that created a buffer for the mining companies.
Everyone assumed at the time in 2011 that the Japanese would come right back online. How can they not? It was almost 30% of their grid.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Alkin: But they didn't. And they found alternative sources to generate electricity, more expensive, but alternative. And so the miners were continuing to explore, develop, and produce throughout the early 20-teens and starting in the mid-20-teens.
And then you had what they were anticipating was that this downblending program that started in 1993 called Megatons to Megawatts. There were thousands of nuclear missiles, ballistic missiles, that the US government was afraid that those missiles would wind up on the black market. So they incentivized the Russian government to downblend them. And they would send 20, 25 million pounds a year of uranium into the market. Well, that was scheduled to go offline in 2013. So as Guy mentioned earlier, the planning that goes into these, there were many mines planning on coming online. Because that program was going offline. But then Fukushima happened, but you couldn't stop those programs. So you saw new production coming online into the downturn. And so what hit a spot price in '07 of $137, by Fukushima it was $70 and it just kept going down. But then something in the market had occurred that you hadn't seen before.
Because interest rates were at the floor, what you started to see was financial intermediaries come into the market and introduce something that commodity investors are familiar with, but really wasn't in the uranium market was the carry trade. And so in the world of physical trading of uranium, there's only a handful of traders and most of them don't have much of a balance sheet.
And they trade this uranium back and forth, very little volumes in the spot market. Like I said, maybe only 20% of annual volumes are there, but they trade for 15, 20, 25 cents a pound back and forth. But then they were very smart Smart, as were the utilities. They said, look, there's a lot of oversupply in the market. There's new production coming online.
Why, when these contracts expire, should we enter into new ones? Let's see where the market settles out. There was excess supply in the market. So these traders would go out and enter into forward carry trades a couple of years out on the curve. And they would say, okay, well, Mr. Utility, Mrs. Utility, we will enter into a 2-year deal with you. I'm making an example.
Enter into a 2-year deal. We'll buy the uranium. We'll carry it. And we'll charge you a little bit out on the curve. We make a little bit of money and everyone's happy. And then in 2 years from now, let's revisit. We don't see a reason why the price of uranium should go up.
And they were right because there was that excess supply. So you saw what was contracting in the '05, '06, '07, '08 period of 120% to 150%. you saw in the mid-teens, even continuing to up until today, contracting into 30% and 40% of annual consumption. So they weren't replacing their consumption. They were drawing down all these excess inventories that built. But the deliveries that are heading into the utilities right now are starting to fall off a cliff.
And that's where something called uncovered demand comes into play. And if you look at the uncovered demand contracts that are required, demand that is out there that's not covered by contracts, it's almost identical. And that's on chart 33, slide 33, as it was right before the last major boom. So utilities are not covered by contracts. And if you look at slide 32, you've got a delivery waterfall into the utilities that is falling off a cliff. It dramatically declines. So now they're left to trying to have to figure out where these pounds will come from. Well, there's not enough. The price isn't high enough to incent new production. The price isn't high enough to get these mines who've cut supply through care and maintenance going idle because price isn't high enough.
Or they can try and go out and secure it in the spot market. Well, 3 years ago, if I wanted to go find 10 million pounds of uranium in the spot market, 15 million pounds of uranium in the spot market, I could do it. Right. If I was to try and go out right now and get delivery within a few months to the converter, and I wanted to find probably more than a million, million and a half pounds, I couldn't find it.
So it's not enough to meet the needs. So contracts are expiring. The future demand is not covered by contracts, and you have a very tight spot market. Sorry to be long-winded on that, but there's a lot of nuance in there, and I just wanted to explain what's going on in the market right now.
Erik Townsend: That's okay. I want to pick up on that though, because we've already discussed the fact that if you just look at the existing nuclear plants and the need to fuel them, there's going to be a major shortfall. I suspect a lot of investors are probably making a mistake that I made until I talked to you guys a little bit off the air, which is I would've assumed, look, post-Fukushima, this can't be a growth industry. They can't be building any more nuclear power plants because this public sentiment is so strong.
I was very mistaken to think that. So, Guy, why don't we start with you on this one? Are there actually new nuclear plants being built? And if so, how many? Does this come anywhere close to the magnitude of the, let's say, the heyday of nuclear energy in the 1970s when they were building plants left and right?
Guy Keller: Yeah, Erik, I mean, we're, we're currently in one of the biggest reactor build programs that we've had and we've seen in decades. And, and, you know, a lot of the market glosses over that. I mean, we always talk to to the number that there's 50-odd reactors under construction and a number planned and a number proposed, but we never actually pause to really scratch the surface of that detail to work out what that is. I mean, it's a number. It is what it is. But when you actually— when you look at, for example, what China are currently building at the moment, so they've got a shovel in the ground on reactor builds, so these are reactors That should be finished and connected to the grid between now and 2025.
It's over 10 to 11 million pounds of uranium per year that they're going to need to fuel those new reactors. I mean, when you consider the Husab mine in Namibia, for example, I mean, there's argument as to what that does each year, and it's certainly not doing what it was supposed to do for the nameplate.
They need another one of those mines and more just to fuel the reactors that they're building. When you look at ex-China as well, I mean, we see China as the big growth engine, and I still believe that there's much more to come from them. But ex-China, there's a lot of reactors being built as well. And again, between now and 2025, that's there or thereabouts another 18 million pounds of uranium per year. Which is equivalent to another McArthur River, one of Cameco's Tier 1 assets that needs to come into production to fulfill that. I mean, I'm ignoring front-loading of fuel for all these reactors, which when you basically start a reactor, you need 3 times the amount of your annual requirement. I'm ignoring that in these numbers even. So when you look at the fact that there's a deficit now with just what is currently running, there's going to be an even bigger deficit in the next 5 years when the reactors that are being currently built connect to the grid.
And when you then look at what China's doing, I mean, China has put out a 2060 carbon-neutral plan, which sounds like a long way away, but that's China. They'll be starting to come out with some headlines on their 14th 5-year plan at the end of October. It's my view that their already ambitious nuclear reactor build program is going to increase because it has to.
So not only are you seeing ex-China with a healthy build program, China's also got a great one at the moment. But if that gets even bigger, then this story just continues to be fundamentally skewed in such a way that price just has to catch up. Or China goes on some massive buying spree of every uranium resource in the world to fulfill their needs, which also fulfills the same goal.
Erik Townsend: Mike, is there anything you want to add on the scope of the building that's going on? And particularly, maybe you can address the timing. When do we see new plants that are being built coming online and actually starting to consume fuel rods?
Mike Alkin: Good question, Erik. So there's a steady stream coming on over the next 5, 6, 7 years. You'll see, and like Guy said, when a new reactor starts, the initial fuel load is up to 3 times the amount that is needed because you're putting a few loads in there to fill the reactor up. And so you will see a steady stream of these coming online. And we don't, in our calculus, we do not include those that are planned and proposed because we just want to know what is. Because once you've started one of these things, with the exception of one in the US, 2 in the US, they finish. And the Western world builds reactors way over budget and way over time, but they've got this down to a science. The Russians and the Chinese who own— the Russians own the nuclear fuel cycle to a large extent.
They build them on time, on budget.
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Mike Alkin: And they have—
Guy Keller: So do the South Koreans as well, right? They've got very—
Mike Alkin: Yeah, South Koreans as well. You're right. They're very efficient at it. So you will see a steady stream of these coming online. And one of the things that was not part of our thesis, we started looking at this really late '15, early '16, spent a year just trying to understand, because I, like you, Erik, and like many people, I'm a deep value investor. I've been in the hedge fund business 25 years.
My view of nuclear power was a layperson's view. I thought for sure, let me go— wow, I see this disconnect. 500 companies down to 50, a market cap of $150 billion down to under $5 billion at the time. We were mentioning offline, when I first started looking, the sell-side models were 3 years old. They were dated. Anyone who was a uranium analyst was fired. Anyone who was— so they gave it to a precious metals analyst to look at it. It's a wildly complicated industry and it's so opaque that if It was ignored. And so from a professional investor standpoint, I still thought nuclear was dead. But as you start looking at the demand, at the end of the day, when you take into all of these closures that in the West that will occur, in Europe there's going to be closures, in the US there will be closures. You factor that into the math and net at the end of the day over the next decade, it's a 2% grower. So it's not a fancy, sexy growth business, but it's a growth business.
And that's the exciting part because the narrative is so entrenched with nuclear's dying. And just the simple 4th grade math doesn't bear out those facts, just based on what exists and what's under construction right now.
Erik Townsend: I want to test out my own hypothesis on this industry with you guys and see what you think. But it goes back to something Mike said earlier in the conversation about environmentalists. I think the The sea change moment for the nuclear power industry is when the environmental community, which clearly, clearly has the public ear, changes their tune and says, hey, it's safe nuclear power that's going to be the solution to our carbon problem, and we gotta really invest in safe nuclear. But frankly, to save face, they can't say old Westinghouse Yeah. And now Westinghouse reactors are safe. We were lying when they said they weren't. There's gotta be something different.
Now, it seems to me, I don't know, a story I heard a few years ago was that there was a change afoot where instead of building these massive, massive nuclear power plants that are built on-site in position and often have all kinds of fraud and stuff going on with the construction project, there was discussion of a new trend where a much safer generation, a new generation of nuclear reactor, which was modular and small, would be built in super high quality control level factories and then shipped to where it was going to be used. And that might be a game changer.
Is that still a big trend that we care about? And would it potentially give the environmental community that— I'll call it a face-saving moment to say, well, if we do it this way, then nuclear is safe? Because I think that changes the world.
Mike Alkin: Without a doubt, there are these small modular reactors, which are, let's say, 50, 60, 100 megawatt reactors, and some even the micro ones, much smaller. It gives the nuclear industry the ability to mass produce. That's not how they're built now. To put it in context, every reactor is 440-ish in the world right now.
The fuel rods that go into those reactors Not one is interchangeable with another reactor. Everyone's different. There's a handful of builders of these reactors, but there's not that consistency. Now post-Fukushima, the safety standards are incredibly— it's incredibly safe. The numbers bear that out. But this enables you to put these smaller reactors in smaller neighborhoods, smaller cities. They're better economics for all involved, for the manufacturers and for the users. And one of the things I think is all of this talk of EVs, EVs and the green future and the Green New Deal.
Well, the more wind and solar you have on the grid, you have all these EVs when they're going to power these cars at night. Well, what's going to power those?
Erik Townsend: Coal?
Mike Alkin: Natural gas? The wind only blows at certain times and the sun blows during the day and the storage, there's not enough storage and it's too expensive. So nuclear power and these smaller reactors can help solve that problem. And I think the safety feature of those too, the added benefits to what already is a very safe model, I think does bode well for the industry. Guy, do you have any thoughts on that?
Erik Townsend: Yeah.
Guy Keller: I mean, I think when, for any sort of naysayers with respect to those technology advances, just need to look at the number of countries that are investing in the innovation and technology advances for nuclear. It's not just the United States who are very vocal, and the US Department of Energy, in my view, are doing a good job with test labs and things like that. But you've got Canada, you've got France, you've got China, you've got Russia, you've got South Korea, you've got some other fringe countries. All of these countries are spending a huge amount of time, money, and effort to advance this reactor technology. And on top of that as well, with existing technology, you've got improvements. There's moves for accident-tolerant fuels and all sorts of things.
And when you come back to safety, you've got to remember that the nuclear fuel cycle, starting from uranium in the ground to the waste at the end of the cycle, is the most scrutinized and the most regulated by multinational organizations as well as country governmental and independent organizations. It's the most scrutinized industry in the world with respect to safety and how they deal with things.
So I tend to think that the technology advances are very exciting. They're still 5 to 10 years away. But my view is that where the industry is at the moment, It's in a very good space, and I wouldn't have any problems with a reactor being built in my neighborhood.
Erik Townsend: Would you guys agree that the world changes completely if the environmentalists get on board and bless nuclear? And if so, what's it going to take? What would be the catalysts if it's not these modular reactors that would get them on board?
Mike Alkin: Economic reality. Economic reality and technological reality. And I think they're starting to see that. You know, it's hand-to-hand combat, figuratively speaking, but it just takes time. But you are seeing, and I just don't have in my head right now who the various names are that have done this, but you're seeing them come aboard because as we said earlier, you can't reach your climate goals without nuclear as part of the mix. And then supporting nuclear is just the of the safety involved. So it's just slowly seeing it. You see it even more now on the Democratic platform in the US. Joe Biden's platform is supportive of nuclear power. I don't think you would've seen that out of the Democrats a few years ago. So I think there's just this realization that it needs to be there.
Erik Townsend: Let's move on to the investment opportunities in this space. If I draw an analogy to another metal that a lot of our listeners listeners are familiar with, which is gold. Some investors, because of gold's store of value characteristic, want to take physical delivery of the metal, you know, in coins, rounds, and bars. I'm guessing that if you take physical delivery of uranium, you might get a visit from the Department of— I'm not sure which department, but let's not do that.
Mike Alkin: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: In terms of the mining companies, the shares in the miners, if I use an analogy to gold where You've got ETFs like GDX, and I know in uranium you've got URNM, which is the predominant uranium mining ETF.
Now, in the gold space, they break down the mining companies into producers that are actually operating gold mines, and then what are called junior miners, which are the companies that are out doing exploration, figuring out where the next gold mine needs to go, but they're not actually operating them.
Mike Alkin: Right.
Erik Townsend: mine yet. Is that how uranium works, and where are the opportunities? Is this something— I got to believe it's much smaller than the gold space in terms of the number of companies. How big is it, and, and what's the best way to invest in it?
Mike Alkin: So yes, you do have a similar setup in, in the uranium mining world. You have exploration companies which are going out looking for uranium, and most of those are very tiny. You know, it's kind of like the pharmaceutical industry, you know how they've They've kind of let the biotech companies do a lot of their R&D. It's kind of similar in the uranium space and other mining sectors where you have the small juniors going out and exploring and they're tiny market cap companies. And once in a while they come up with something.
And then you have the development stage companies. So these junior miners who find something, move it on to the next phase where they'll do a pre-feasibility, a PEA, preliminary economic assessment. They'll move it to a feasibility study, pre-feasibility, and then a feasibility study. All in the— what they're doing is wrangling to bring this into production, and they may or may not. They may get taken out or not. And then you have the producers. In the world of uranium, your big producers in the West are few and far between. It's Cameco, and then you have a couple of other smaller producers that are on care and maintenance right now. And then you have a lot of state-owned entities around the rest of the world.
Erik Townsend: Right.
Mike Alkin: But it is a similar one. And, you know, you just have to really be careful in the junior mining space. It's, you know, it's fraught with promotion. Everyone has the lowest— everyone's a first-tier producer. I'm still waiting to meet the second-tier, the second-quartile producer.
So everyone's a first-quartile producer. They all can bring it on much sooner than one would think, right? So it's heavily promotional, just like all the mining industry is. So you really have to do your due diligence in this space. base in the junior sector to make sure these costs are accurate, to make sure the timelines are accurate. And as Guy said, it was a great point he brought up earlier, there are very, very, very few people running any of these mining companies that have brought uranium mine into production. It's a lot of work. It's a lot of time. It's a lot of expertise.
But the structure's the same.
Erik Townsend: Let me ask Guy a related question, which is, how can investors who are maybe new to this space go wrong in terms of understanding this Very easily.
Guy Keller: As Mike alluded to before, there's a lot of snake oil salesmen around and you can come unstuck. I mean, I think one of the things that we take into consideration very seriously is we get an understanding of what it is we want to own a certain stock for. There's certain holdings in our portfolio that we know Aalo, in its current state, form, and management team, will never get into production.
But we're not owning it for that. And we're aware of the reasons why we think it won't. And we're aware of what steps that company may need to take to do so. So it comes down to, it is a very hot and very volatile sector. I mean, our fund performance has thankfully rebounded very aggressively since Since March this year where it was looking terrible.
And we were able to position ourselves where we thought it would move. And we have turned that portfolio a little bit as it's matured through the year here. But I think it's very easy to come unstuck because even though it's— people, I think investors think because it's a small industry and price has to go up, I can buy whatever and it'll work for me. And that's true to an extent, you know, but I think it's very easy to— as I think Mike alluded to before in previous cycles, you can point to all of these fantastic appreciation in some of these uranium stocks in the previous bull cycles. But when you look at the dilution factor, the raisings and everything else that happened, you know, it hasn't actually been potentially as good for some. So, you know, there's a handful of specialists in this sector that have put in a huge amount of time and effort over the last number of years and getting to know management teams and getting to know the resources.
And I'd even argue that sometimes we come unstuck a little bit too. So it's not without its— yeah, it is buyer beware. I wouldn't be putting your whole retirement savings into it because it's extremely volatile.
Mike Alkin: And what you see, Erik, what you tend to see is with these smaller mining companies, there's not a lot of capital markets expertise You have to be all over management when it comes to how they're spending their capital and burning their cash. Does the market care? You may want to do this, that, and the other thing to bring your mine along in development stage, but the market doesn't care right now and you don't need to do it right now.
Like Guy mentioned with the dilution, a lot of these companies have diluted till kingdom come. Right now, as coming in new to the space, you're dealing with your math and your valuation based on But it requires a lot of, I don't want to say handholding, but you got to— I'm sure Guy is too. We're pretty tough with the management teams that we have meaningful holdings in because you have to be all over them because there is not that necessary, that great expertise there. So it can be challenging.
Erik Townsend: Gentlemen, the most striking thing to me in this interview has been learning a little bit more about what you guys do and specifically Exactly. Your relationship to the market now, because I'm sure that we have a very large accredited investor audience. I'm sure many of them are going to be disappointed to learn, Mike, your Sachem Cove Partners fund, which has done very well in this space, is closed to new investors. And the reason is because you've reached a size where you feel like you can't really deliver that same excellent performance because, you know, too much money. Not chasing not enough opportunity. Guy, by your own description, you were running a much larger fund with much bigger AUM, and as a matter of your mandate, you perfectly well could have gone into this space with that fund, but you decided instead to spin off a new fund because you needed a smaller entity in order to be effective at investing in this space.
And, you know, if I, if I hear your story, Mike, you know, you should Usually equity funds close to new investors when they hit $2 billion or so. You're only at $65 million and you'd had to close at that level. So on the one hand, it strikes me as, oh my gosh, if that's the level you guys have to close at, when this market gets hit with billions of dollars of capital as it turns around, price is going to go through the roof. It's an incredible opportunity. But wait a minute, you guys are really, really good at this, and you're not taking any more money because there's not enough good deals to chase.
Guy Keller: Well, oh, hang on, I'm taking a bit more money, Erik, and hopefully I'll get it in before— hopefully I get it in before those billions of dollars of generalist money chase in too.
Erik Townsend: Okay, but, but you, but you did spin off a new fund because if you had done this in the other fund you were managing, it would have been too big. You would have been buying too big of a piece of the So we have a large institutional audience. I mean, for people who need to put significant amounts of capital to work, it sounds like you really need to be in the know in order to find the next opportunity to put a lot of money to work efficiently.
Mike Alkin: It's a good point. And we capped it because I saw the opportunities that were there. And look, this market cap, the market cap of the industry, like I said, $150 down to, at the time it was $5, Now it's bigger. I don't have it up, but probably $11, $12 billion. But many of these companies, as Guy alluded to earlier, are not investible. But we're not looking at, again, if our work is right, and clearly we can be wrong, right? But if our work is right, we're not looking for ordinary returns. We think the asymmetry is such where the risk reward is an asymmetry that I've not been acquainted with before in my career.
Guy Keller: Yeah.
Mike Alkin: So again, you see, like I mentioned earlier, in the last cycle, you saw stocks just return 10, 20, 30, 50, 100 times. And Guy and I and a couple of the other guys who run uranium funds, we shake our head because people expect 50 and 100 baggers again.
And those don't exist in our minds simply because there's been so much dilution. But there is still significant upside in many of these if the macro work is right and you pick the right stocks.
Guy Keller: Yeah.
Mike Alkin: However, rather than go just hoovering up capital, which we could have to do that, that's not fair to our LPs. So we just decided to cap it here. Maybe in the future, if we monitor it and we can open in the future, but as of right now, we don't see the space to put it. And like I said earlier, I think I used the reference putting a pig through a python. When capital comes back, and again, the sell side That is just warming up to the sector again.
And it's using the wrong cues because it's following the move in spot price of uranium. And the reason they do that is because it's the only really visible one. And that's triggered off the futures price. You got to remember most of the pounds that trade every day, it might not even trade. It's just bid and asks moving around because it trades so infrequently.
Guy Keller: Right.
Mike Alkin: So there is more interest coming back into the sector. What Guy and the folks at Segra Capital and L2, the other uranium funds, what we're focusing on is what's happening in the contracting market and are we seeing acceleration there and what's the price curve looking like there? And so because we are deep in the bowels of this sector, at some point in time we may decide to. Yeah, there's going to be a time where the sell side revisits it en masse, where capital warms up to it, and they want to— and they'll start chasing it.
Erik Townsend: So for our listeners who are interested in investing in this space, Mike, your fund is presently closed to new investors. You've got the URNM ETF. That's an option. Guy, your fund is still open. Are you accredited investors only? Are you everybody? Tell us a little bit more about your fund.
Guy Keller: Yeah. So we run a wholesale investment fund here at the moment. It's set up as an Aussie unit trust because the bulk of our investors are ourselves. We basically started with partner money here, some fairly bullish uranium investors who are still in our Global Natural Resources Fund, and then pushed it out a little bit further to an Australian investor base. We do have the ability to to launch a parallel structure in a Cayman US dollar vehicle. But there was a cost equation with that, obviously.
If the appetite is there, we'd still consider that. But as I said, we've been small and it's been a little bit of a saving grace over the first 2 years of the fund because we did have a few false starts in the sector and it allowed us to be in positions without having a massive financial hit when things weren't going right. I mean, we also do leverage off our global natural resources fund. So we have global relationships because we have been in the resources sector through North America, through Europe, through Australia and Asia for many years. So we have had the ability where we are still getting treated fairly by brokers and what have you, despite the small Small size of the nuclear fund because of the bigger relationship there.
Mike Alkin: Erik, if I could just jump in, there is one other way for bigger investors to express the view, and you saw it significantly in the last cycle, was you can buy physical uranium. You can't have it delivered to your garage, but you can buy physical uranium by establishing an account with one of the converters who will store it. One can go It costs a little bit of money to set up an account, probably $25,000, but they will store the physical uranium. It's yours. It has your name on it. It's an interesting time. In the last cycle, what wound up happening is you saw when the market started to just go through the roof, what you started to see was the physical funds had started coming in and buying it.
The hedge funds started coming in in '05, '06.
Guy Keller: Yeah.
Mike Alkin: Part of '04, started coming in, buying some physical uranium. And then when the utilities needed to start contracting, there wasn't enough production out there. And so they had to go and pay up. And they paid up. And you saw the hedge funds sitting on it. And you saw some huge price appreciation. And that opportunity is available today. And that's where somebody can express their view with significant amounts of capital.
Guy Keller: You also have, Mike, the physical proxies as well.
Mike Alkin: Yeah, that's right.
Guy Keller: That's right. You know, UPC in Canada and Yellow Cake in London. And I mean, full disclosure, we own both of those. But they are somewhat inexplicably both trading at 20% discounts to their NAV. So I mean, not only are you getting access to physical uranium without having to have accounts at converters, but you're picking it up at a 20% discount to the current price.
Mike Alkin: It's nonsensical.
Erik Townsend: Now, why would physical uranium trade at a 20% discount? I mean, why wouldn't somebody buy all of it and liquidate it and consume it?
Guy Keller: Well, I think probably because there's just not the— you know, the obvious buyer would be a utility, and I just don't think that's something that they're focused on. They haven't necessarily had a sense of urgency to be securing front-dated pounds at the moment. And so therefore, if they have considered it, they've sort of shrugged their shoulders and said, well, maybe that's a bit too hard.
I think as well with institutions, liquidity in some of these things makes it a little bit more difficult for them. And again, they've seen the price go from $23 to $34 and they've done nothing. And then it's come back to $30 here and they've said, ah, well, we probably have another chance. So potentially, I mean, it's our view, you'll see that discount quickly disappear when the spot price runs again. But as Mike said before, the spot price running again requires more than just the sort of 5 or 6 guys having a tea committee meeting every day as to where it should be. It needs some actual real buying to come in and take that higher again.
Erik Townsend: Well, gentlemen, to wrap this up again for our investors, you do have the ETF option. The ticker symbol is URNM. For at least Mike's fund, I think the best you can do is just hope for it to reopen again. But Mike and Guy, why don't you both please tell our listeners how they can find out websites or whatever more about your fund? Guy, your fund is still open, so let's start with you.
Guy Keller: Yeah, sure, Erik. I mean, it's the easiest way is to go onto our website. That's www.tribecaip.com, for investment Tribecaip.com. T-R-I-B-E-C-A-I-P.com. And there's links there to our Global Natural Resources Fund, our Global Natural Resources Credit Fund, and also then the nuclear energy opportunities. So it's very easy to navigate.
Erik Townsend: And Mike, Sachem Cove Partners.
Mike Alkin: SachemCovePartners.com. And there's a contact button on there that people can inquire in there.
Erik Townsend: Okay. And again, for now, your fund is closed. So the only reason to contact you there would be if they wanted to find out if it reopens. Gentlemen, I can't thank you enough for a terrific interview.
Erik Townsend: Kevin Muir and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right after this message from our sponsor.
Farmland investing has been a popular macro trend among billionaires and big institutions for the last decade. But the high cost of buying an entire put this asset class out of reach to all but big institutions and the ultra-rich. FarmTogether.com allows any accredited investor to invest in fractional ownership of several different categories of farmland. I recently did a full-length interview with FarmTogether.com founder and CEO Artem Milinchuk. We discussed the macro argument for farmland investing, performance and correlation comparisons to conventional asset classes and the different types of farmland and their investment characteristics. If you're an accredited investor, I recommend that you listen to that interview and learn why farmland investing might be a fit for your portfolio. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email, or just type the word farmland into the search box on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Check out FarmTogether.com to You'll be glad you did.
Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts.
Kevin Muir: It was a great interview with Mike and Guy, Erik. Lots to dig into. What was your key takeaway from it?
Erik Townsend: Well, it really got me thinking about uranium, and I think it's a long-term play and it's an important one. And I'm so frustrated that I didn't think about this 6 months ago because I pulled up a chart of URNM, which is the mining ETF, and it got clobbered in March like everything else did. But But stop and think about that. I mean, it really, really got clobbered. It was just down hard. And of course that happened because everybody's panicking out of everything. Everybody's selling everything to raise cash. But think about it.
Yes, there is a global pandemic. That's very real. It doesn't mean that nuclear plants that have to continue producing electricity are gonna stop needing fuel in the next 10 years. You know, there was no fundamental reason that you should expect a pandemic to affect the industry other than to the extent that if the pandemic resulted in shut-in of mining operations, that would drive the prices much higher initially, and it might hurt some of those miners initially, but eventually, you know, you would think that, that, that, that low was an incredible buying opportunity because you know it had to come back. And there's a lot of other parts of the economy where you're thinking, okay, well, if this pandemic continues for the next 10 years, you know, I don't want to bet on maybe going long on airline stocks because they might never come back. Well, you know that the uranium miners were going to be needed no matter what. So it was just such an incredible value play back in March.
I would, if I ever saw another dip like that, I'm going to be watching URNM closely for that reason. Reason, I'd be buying it hand over fist. I did buy a little bit of URNM this week, just in full disclosure, because I think it's a great long-term story. The thing is, something's got to change in terms of sentiment for it really to go big.
And I think these guys are absolutely right that, you know, the worst probably has to be over for uranium. It's a bullish story. It's a question of when the bullish story kicks into gear. And how to be positioned for it that I think about the most. What was your reaction to it?
Kevin Muir: Well, Erik, it's funny that you mentioned the March sell-off in the uranium companies because I had actually written a piece in January or February about how the Uranium Participation Unit, which is basically a closed-end ETF that owns uranium, was a great place to hide if you were worried about the stock And my thinking was exactly what you just mentioned: the fact that if let's face it, you know the the demand for uranium should be fairly stable, and whether the virus hits and and you know causes all sorts of problems in the market shouldn't affect how much uranium the world uses. Unfortunately, I think that it was one of those things that many other hedge funds were in the same trade as me, and it ended up being that this uranium participation unit. went from a 10% discount to NAV to like a 30% and 40% discount to NAV.
Now, why do I like the uranium participation unit? As, uh, Mike and Guy talked about, the spot price of uranium trades at a discount to the forward prices of uranium, those long-term contracts that they talked about. Well, if you go look at the uranium participation unit, it trades at a discount discount to the spot price. So you're getting a discount upon a discount. I think that this thing right now is trading at a 20-plus percent discount. Eventually, when we get a situation where we get the bull market resume, this thing could likely trade at 20% premium. That's why I like the uranium participation unit as my way to play the uranium bull market.
Erik Townsend: Kevin, picking up on that same theme, they mentioned Yellow Cake in this interview. I actually talked to them a little bit off the air afterwards. And Yellow Cake, which is, I believe, YCA, Yankee Charlie Alpha, on the London Stock Exchange, is another ticker for a company that holds physical uranium metal, Yellow Cake Uranium. And it's trading at upwards of a 20% discount to NAV. And you just know that ultimately, that uranium is going to be needed someday. And the thing that really got me thinking about all this, and we don't know yet, of course, what the outcome of the presidential race is going to be.
But I think about President Trump's attitude, if he were to remain president, and the way that he likes to talk about America first and so forth. It makes me wonder if he understood this issue, that you're basically dependent on a lot of countries that President Trump is not a big fan of for uranium.
Why is it that if the fuel that supplies these nuclear plants is such Such a small percentage of their overall operating cost. Why wouldn't they get a 20 or 30-year supply of fuel stockpiled to make sure they're ready and they're not dependent on anybody? Can you imagine a regulatory change that just says, for the sake of national security, we don't want to be dependent on other nations for our uranium, all the nuclear plants are required or at least encouraged to keep a 20-year supply of fuel, which they can easily afford?
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: A change like that, if it ever happened, would create a sudden demand spike that would just completely overwhelm the capacity of the mining industry and would be potentially, you know, a major win for investments either in things like YCA or URNM, the mining ETF, or anything else. So, and of course, we don't know if that's going to happen. We don't know what the outcome is going to be. outcome of the election is going to be. But at some point, it's crazy for the United States to be dependent on foreign partners for something that you can easily afford to stockpile. It doesn't make any sense.
Kevin Muir: You're 100% right, Erik. And we look at it, it seemed like a no-brainer for Trump to do. And that's why when Energy Fuels and the other companies, the North American producers, got together trying to put that bill through, there was a lot of anticipation that that was going to happen. Unfortunately, it ended up disappointing. But when you're thinking about the bigger term and the longer-term picture, it makes sense. And therefore, you're just kind of shaking your head asking, why haven't government officials figured this out? And this is ultimately my problem with the kind of the uranium story. It's not really a problem, but it's just kind of a little bit of pushback, is that this story has been bullish for a long time, and it just— it's needing a catalyst.
And I don't know if that catalyst is going to be this week, next week, next month, next year even. I know eventually it's going to be a great investment. I'm just not sure about the timing.
Erik Townsend: Well, I'll tell you the way I think about that one. We don't know what the election is going to bring. Maybe it's going to be a clean sweep and a big sigh of relief and everything is straight up. But if we had another big March-sized sell-off in markets, boy, if URNM got anywhere close to where it was, Or for that matter, YCA and the other plays on the metal itself.
Erik Townsend: I'd be buying it hand over fist. I'm so frustrated that I didn't think of this back in March.
But Kevin, speaking of the election coming up and so forth, let's move on to markets more broadly. A lot of people are expecting that, okay, you know, we're going to wait, there's going to be maybe nothing happens until the election, and there's some huge move in one direction or the other. Is that the right way to think about this? If not, why not? And how do you think about it?
Kevin Muir: Yeah, I think that's a good way to think about it. I do think it's the right way, Erik. I did some work because I was kind of curious about it, thinking about the volatility going into the election. I thought to myself, is the move that we're going to experience— like, are we going to have some big, you know, violent move before, or is it going to be after? So I went through and I looked back at the past election since 1992. And what I did was I took September 1st all the way to election date, and what I took was the high range and the low range of that period, and then I figured out the percentage of that move.
And what I found was that on average in those 2 months, the stock market moves 12%, 11.9%. Now, you have to remember this had the 2008 time period in it, and that was 36%, that range. So if we take that out, because let's face it, that's not going to happen again, that was an extraordinary circumstance.
If we take it out, we'll see that the range was actually 7.84%. Now, if we go look at 2020, the time right now, we've already traversed, you know, a range of 10.73%. So when I look at this, you know, coming 2 weeks between now and November 3rd, I think to myself, you know, there's a good chance that the high and low are both in and that we are going to get, as we were talking about earlier, a whole lot of nothing. nothing and that the stock market is just going to end up frustrating both the bulls and the bears. What do you think?
Erik Townsend: Well, you're saying that's up until the election, and I would definitely agree with that. The thing that I don't know about is after the election, I think there's at least a significant chance of an escalation of civil unrest. And the problem that I have in figuring this out is really, if you look at history and even go back to the late 1960s when a huge amount of, you know, civil discourse, division in society, riots and protests and so forth. It really didn't affect the stock market adversely very much at all because despite the fact that that was a very, very challenging time and there was a lot of disagreement in society, it was a very big social issue, you know, people still kept on buying products and, you know, the economy kept going and it didn't really affect the stock market.
On the other hand, if you have a situation that truly escalates to the point where the government's ability to maintain control over society comes into question, well, especially for the US dollar, and I think also for the stock market, okay, that's different. It's a different game at that point. And the question I'm asking myself is at what point does it become different? Let's suppose that, and I think this is very possible, unfortunately, let's suppose that after the election, both sides feel like their guy won. Everybody's pissed off. It's not really clear who the president is. And furthermore, there are outbreaks of violence across America where people are feeling like the other side is trying to undermine the democratic process.
Kevin Muir: Right.
Erik Townsend: and steal the election for their candidate. And they're fighting back violently in the form of riots and so forth. Well, that by itself, you know, it just means that companies that manufacture riot gear for police are gonna, you know, sell more of them.
So it doesn't really adversely affect the stock market. Unless those riots go completely out of control to the point where society starts to shut down. Because, you know, let's say protesters are occupying, you know, downtown areas of cities and shutting down major highways and blocking them so traffic can't get through in order to make their point. Well, now that directly affects commerce and it does affect markets. So what's the point where a political escalation turns into an economic escalation? And how do you know when you've reached I think that's the right question to ask. I don't have any answers.
Kevin Muir: So I will tell you one thing, Erik. A lot of my hedge fund buddies in the States are talking about that possibility. There was one buddy that actually told me that he thought there's a good chance that the stock market will close for an extended period of time. He didn't say that that was for sure going to happen, but he kind of put that out there. He said, this is a possibility that this happens.
Whenever I see that much worry, I feel like that the right trade is to take the other side, and I am hopeful that it is not going to end up being as bad as everyone thinks it is. I am hopeful that you're going to have an election, and even if it's contested, it's going to be done in a in a in a calm measure. And yes, maybe there are pockets and outbreaks of of violence in certain spots, but I just don't think that that selling stocks on that worry is the right.
And listen, it might be that I've just made a fool of myself and we're going to be talking and the S&P will be down 20% lower when this happens. But I just think over time, when I think back to all the worries that when people start telling me that they're worried about something like that, it rarely comes to be. And most often when everyone's worried about something, most likely the trade, the best trade is to go the other way.
Erik Townsend: Well, I want to push back on that just a little bit, Kevin, because when a war starts, One of the most widely known and easily proven facts is that the war is usually gonna be bullish in the long run for the stock market. But there's almost always an initial, oh my God, it's a war, panic selling, knee-jerk reaction, and it's down first. And that's a buy-the-dip opportunity because you know that it was emotion and panic that drove that move down, and eventually it's gonna move back up.
Kevin Muir: Yeah.
Erik Townsend: So don't you think that if you get a situation where violence escalates beyond what we've seen so far in cities across America, that there's a lot of room for at least a temporary knee-jerk panic down?
Kevin Muir: Oh, I won't deny that. You're absolutely right, Erik. But let's remember on the Trump one, he won, we had that knee-jerk panic down, and by the open, it was back up. And I think it finished up on that day. Day. And so I just think that it's one of these— it's when something is so widely watched and so widely expected, I just don't think that going in, especially if you're going and trying to buy protection via options, those will be fully priced into that outcome.
And rarely does that work. And now I will give you credit. I think that the one time that it actually did work was with the virus. And you were there saying, this is going to get worse. And And you said it, and I remember you and I, I was on this show, and after the show you told me this was the market basically doing the largest mispricing in history that you'd ever seen. And you were spot on correct.
Erik Townsend: But this is the opposite. This is the opposite. Everybody is overthinking this. And there's so much optionality that's already been bought. The hedges have already been purchased. And you've gotta think about people lifting those hedges as soon as there is a more certain outcome than the one they feared. So, you know, that's the bullish argument. But frankly, the bearish argument, Kevin, is I think we're gonna go longer than we've ever gone in the history of the nation before we know with certainty who the next president of the United States is. It's not gonna be certain on election night. And I'll be surprised I'll be surprised if by December 1st there is widespread agreement on who that is. And I won't be surprised at all if on January 1st there's still strong disagreement as to who the president really is. And at that point, it'll be in the hands of the Supreme Court.
And, you know, we'll see what happens. But even a Supreme Court decision, it doesn't mean that, you know, the half of the country who feels that that decision is invalid It doesn't change the fact that they're going to be very upset and expressing their anger, and who knows how they're going to be expressing it.
Kevin Muir: I hope not, but I'm going to kind of not sell the American people short, and I'm going to say that I'm confident that they're going to do the right thing and that it's not going to be a case of whoever wins, the other side's going to burn the country to the ground because of it. And I'm hopeful that we're going to look back and whoever happens to win this election, it'll be still, you know, America doing better, you know, a year from now. And we're just going to look back and remember this little blip of some disagreement. And that's all it'll be, a little blip of disagreement.
Erik Townsend: Well, Kevin, I sure hope that you're right. And I'll tell you what, let's leave it there on a positive note for this week's show, folks. Patrick Ceresna will be back next week for those of you who have been missing him. And we look forward to seeing you for next week's show when we've got another terrific guest lined up.
This episode of MacroVoices was made possible by farmtogether.com, making farmland investing, a trillion-dollar asset class, available to all accredited investors, and by toptradersunplugged.com. Remember to get the ultimate guide to the best investing books ever written at toptradersunplugged.com. For information on sponsoring MacroVoices, please visit MacroVoices.com/SponsorInfo.
Kevin Muir: So that does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make this program even better. For those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at ResearchRoundup@MacroVoices.com.
Or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will consider it for our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and Patrick Ceresna @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend, myself, Kevin Muir, and Patrick Ceresna, thank you for listening and have a great week. Thank you.
Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.
You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors.
MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.
MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.
Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.
MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.