John Greenwood — Invesco Chief Economist (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview and new daily content

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 167 was recorded on May 23rd, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Invesco Chief Economist John Greenwood joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Unlike several of our other recent guests, John thinks we're midway through the business cycle and that once the current turbulence is over, stocks are set to move higher. We're getting rave reviews on our new expanded content, and we plan to keep bringing you new content content every single trading day. The 3rd episode of Energy Week aired yesterday, and we also aired All-Stars appearances featuring Juliette Declercq and Professor Steve Keen this week. Kevin Muir's All-Star appearance airs Friday morning. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview when Patrick has prepared another of his famous chart books, this time looking at the pattern in commodities including crude oil, which took a major dive today.

S&P 500: China, trade war and the Fed put

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the S&P 500 had a pretty strong sell day today. At one point, we were down almost 50 points. What's your thinking here on the S&P?

Erik Townsend: You know, when all of this started, Patrick, it was all about China and the trade wars, and that's still a major driver, to be sure. That's one of the reasons that things are falling apart today. But I think the bond market is telling us that the macro environment is souring and souring fast. And I think that what's going on is almost everybody is thinking, okay, this is all about China, because that's what the headline has been. I think the market's figuring out there's more to this than just the China deal, and I think that maybe that exuberance, the irrational exuberance that was in the marketplace, you know, it feels like the sentiment is finally coming a little bit more in line with economic reality, or at least that's the way it feels to me after the last couple of days. Clearly though, China and China relations have been the proximal catalyst for the current move.

2,800 is the major support level to watch immediately.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: 2,600 is the next major level to watch. My predictions here: I think at some point, some sort of China deal will eventually materialize, but I wouldn't be surprised if it takes longer than most people expect. Asian culture thing— Asians are generally much more patient than Westerners in taking their time to negotiate a deal. So I won't be at all surprised if China is willing to drag this out as long as necessary in order to try to negotiate their position. So I won't be surprised I wouldn't be surprised if Jay Powell and the FOMC have to intervene to rescue markets before we get there. Now, if we see that intervention in the markets, it to me is going to be just incredibly important to watch how accommodative Powell is and how he handles himself. If it's just, okay, well, we said we weren't really going to defend markets, but we lied, we really are, and, you know, okay, the Fed put is alive and well, it sets up more exuberance, but, you know, where does it ultimately lead?

I think that what's more What's more likely is that Powell is going to be trying to walk that very difficult balancing act between not wanting to appear like he's in the business of accommodating markets, even though to some extent he really is. And I wouldn't be surprised if we see more of a downside fit and then eventually a China deal. Once we get a China deal, it might be too late. We might have gotten to the point where the sentiment has shifted and people have figured out that there's plenty of reasons far more important than China trade relations to be bearish about this market.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: But at the moment, I think everybody's focused on China. So we really need to watch how the Fed responds if things get softer. And it seems like if today was any indication, softer times may be ahead.

US dollar: failed breakout near 98

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to that US Dollar Index because earlier this morning, we had the dollar poking above those April highs and I was— had my attention seeing whether or not that was going to break out. And well, it's at least come back off of that high. What's your thinking here on the dollar?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, this really has my close attention, and here's the reason why. First of all, as I've said for many weeks on this program, my fundamental view has been bullish. I think we're right on the hairy edge of a major breakout, and that when we do see a daily close above 98, 98.5, it's going to get more buying and there's going to be price acceleration on heavy volume, which is the confirmation signal we need to see that this rally is really taking off.

The thing is, as much as I Every time I revisit the fundamentals, I still come to that same conclusion. If I look at the tape, there have been a few times now where we saw the beginning of the breakout that we were waiting for, and it ended up happening intraday and just getting hammered back down so that by the daily close we were back below the key level. And that's exactly what we saw today. This breakout in the morning looked super-duper bullish while it lasted, all the way up to 98.25 or so, but now we're back down to 97.75. After As of the 4:00 PM close. So each time, you know, as much as I'm saying that the market should be on the precipice or on the edge of a big upside breakout, it seems like each time we start to get one, it gets smashed back down. Those are the ingredients, Patrick, of a topping market, not a market that's on the edge of a breakout.

Now, why would the market be topping here? Certainly Simon White made that argument last week. I haven't agreed with Simon. I still don't on the fundamentals, but boy, this tape action is starting to concern me.

Patrick Ceresna: Interesting.

Erik Townsend: terms of not really jibing with my fundamental view.

Crude oil: inventory builds and the one-day plunge

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to crude oil because, well, that was the biggest one-day move we had probably in months, and I'm certainly curious as to what you think is behind it.

Erik Townsend: Well, the big picture here is the sell-off in crude oil began at the end of April because the market was already overextended too high to the upside. That's my personal opinion. This last couple of weeks, this rally was all about Iran militarily risk. The smartest money knew it was coming before the public news was out, and of course President Trump's tweet last weekend really sealed the deal. That puts people in panic buy mode. Gotta buy, gotta buy. Could be war coming. Everybody knows the price of oil goes up in a war. Oh my God, oh my God, have to buy, have to buy, have to buy. And then eventually they calm down a little bit and say, hey, wait a minute, why are we buying here? We know that if there is a war that disrupts global oil supply, that absolutely, with almost no limit, can cause prices to go radically higher.

But Saudi Arabia is very strongly incented to increase production in order to make sure that the United States can do its dirty work for it and have a war with Saudis' biggest archrival, Iran, without allowing oil prices to get in the way.

So I really don't think, when you consider that Iranian sanctions have already caused the market to pretty much discount most of Iranian production out of the equation, I don't I don't think there's a huge amount of downside in terms of oil market disruption as a result of a US-Iranian military conflict. Now, anytime there's a military conflict in the Middle East, there's always a risk of escalation, and it could suddenly turn into something much bigger than the way it started. But if you look at just what's started so far, which is the risk of the United States taking military action against Iran, I think Saudi would love to see that so much that they will do anything possible, including helping President Trump to achieve lower oil prices. So we actually see prices go down through the course of an Iranian conflict as opposed to up. So I think that as that was coming out of the market, the prices were already selling off, but the market wanted to wait and see what inventory brought.

And inventory brought very bearish news. Crude oil building 4.7 million barrels, great big build. Cushing building 1.3 million barrels. Gasoline building 3.7 million barrels. Distillates building 768,000 barrels. So builds across the board. Now we've got a market that was already looking for an excuse to go lower, and all of a sudden you hit it with a super bearish inventory report. Market goes straight down on that, with RBOB being the hardest hit. And it was no surprise seeing how hard it was hit yesterday. I said in the introduction to yesterday's Energy Week, okay folks, we just closed below all the short-term moving averages. This This looks like a signal that we're probably headed lower. And sure enough, we got that in spades today. US production also ticked back up to 12.2 million barrels. Now, that's only a 100,000-barrel tick up. But the point is, Patrick, we were concerned to watch whether there was a trend reversal in US production growth.

And seeing 2 consecutive downticks 2 weeks in a row kind of raised my eyebrows and thought, hmm, could this be a trend? Well, now we're moving the other direction. It's only 1 tick in the other direction, but the point is we're not seeing an accelerating trend. Imports 6.9 million barrels, exports down this week to 2.9 million barrels, or just over 20 million barrels on the week. Of course, there is no limit to upside potential if there is a geopolitical upset that truly threatens global oil supply. But I don't think that this US-Iran situation really meets those criteria. In the absence of a geopolitical threat, I think that today's action Probably signals we're headed lower, maybe a lot lower, back into the $40s or even retesting the low that we saw on Christmas. But the thing is, Patrick, we saw such a sudden sell-off today. The 5-day gap between the 5-day moving average and the market price is way too wide.

We left, I count, 10 separate repair levels that were left open today and yesterday on the TPO chart for West Texas crude oil. So there's all kinds of levels above the market that we should expect a retrace to. Right. I'm already short this market. I want to add to my short position as we move up higher. And frankly, it's hard to choose what level or what target you think we're going to retrace to. We've got to have some kind of a bounce. This was a huge move today. But if you look at the fact that we closed below the 100-day moving average, couldn't even get that number back before the close, it really portends a lot of downside left to come. So how big of a bounce should we expect? That really is the operative question.

Gold: trendline and the $1,350 level

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because, well, I mean, it certainly has not been selling, at least not today. We're up $10 off of the lows. What's your thinking here on gold?

Erik Townsend: You know, I'm tempted to short it here. It's not doing quite what I expected though. What I thought was going to happen is that we were going to close below the trend lines. This is what I said last week, and that daily close moving back below the trend line proving that the previous breakout was a false breakout, I thought that was going to be a bearish signal that would take the market much lower. And of course, the geopolitical escalations ratcheted back up before that could happen. So in the last 2 days, we've taken out that trendline again, but this time when we took out the trendline, it's a downsloping trendline. In terms of the level that we hit, it's much lower than we hit last time. So we're pulling out of the established channel, but only by a little bit. And last time it reversed lower, and I think that this geopolitical fear is going to de-escalate eventually.

So it's tempting to short here, I certainly think that if there's an escalation of geopolitical tension, if there's other fundamentals that drive gold higher, if you saw a move above $1,350, which is well above the current market, that would really be an indication to me, okay, it's, it's really time to admit I was wrong and just get on the long trade on gold. But until we see that break above $1,350, I'm waiting for the geopolitics to calm down so that that fear comes out of the market, and I think gold will move lower and the dollar will move higher. If I'm wrong about the dollar and the dollar is topping here, which I do see a couple of technical signs of in the chart, although I don't see it in the fundamentals, that would be a good case for gold to move higher. So I'm not going to short it here, as tempting as that is, but I think probably we're about to move back into the channel.

10-year Treasury yield: take profits near 2.30%

Patrick Ceresna: Let's move on to that 10-year Treasury yield, because not only did we take out that April low, making it the low of 2019, we haven't seen this low yield on the 10-year since I mean, we cleared out the entire 2018 range. What's your thinking here on the 10-year yield?

Erik Townsend: Well, I do continue to think that what we're seeing are recession signals and weakening macro fundamentals and lots of reasons to think that this trend toward lower yields should continue in the long run. But you know, Patrick, we've had such a move from 2.60% down to 2.30%. Just as I said when we hit 2.60%, I said, folks, right here, this is it right now. This is your chance to buy the dip. I'd say right here at 2.30 is maybe time to take some profits if you followed that advice last time, because it feels to me like, you know, we're overdue for a pullback. I do think we'll probably get to lower yields eventually, but I won't be at all surprised if yields back up to 2.50 over the next 2 or 3 months before moving decisively lower. We've already moved a little bit too far here.

So I'd be inclined to take some profits and wait for another chance to buy the next dip.

Sponsorship search update

Patrick Ceresna: Now, before we move on to the feature interview, please give us a quick update on your efforts to secure sponsorship for the new programming so that we can keep it free for our listeners.

Erik Townsend: Well, I'll try to keep this super short so we can get on to the feature interview. We're making progress, but we still need your help, folks, to achieve our goal of keeping MacroVoices content free for all of our listeners, for all of the content. So please think about whether your company, or for that matter, any other company where you have contacts in the marketing department, could benefit from sponsoring MacroVoices. We already have a few formative discussions with potential sponsors, but no solid deals as of yet. Sponsorship inquiries should be sent to my attention at info@macrovoices.com.

Why Greenwood: balancing the bearish guests

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update, Erik. So now this week's featured interview guest is Invesco Chief Economist John Greenwood. Erik, why did we invite John onto the show this week?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as a matter of policy, we generally don't We don't go looking for guests based on their view. We try to seek out the smartest people and they say whatever it is that they have to say, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Well, what's happened is in the last several weeks, we've had so many bearish guests that quite a few listeners, for good reason, have said, hey guys, come on, you got to balance this out. So I asked you, I said, Patrick, we got to do a better job as journalists here, even though you and I think that this is definitely late-cycle dynamics, market's getting ready to roll over at some point.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: We got to get the other side represented and I asked you to try to find the best guest that you could to represent the other side of the argument. I'm going to turn the question around to you, Patrick. Why did you come up with John Greenwood in response to those criteria?

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, I had the opportunity to meet John when he was a part of Russell Napier's program here in Toronto. When John was teaching the part of the program on the business cycle, it immediately caught me. He was certainly talking that we're mid-cycle, but it was really the rigidity reasons behind why we were mid-cycle. You'll hear in a moment when John's explaining it, he's going to talk about the transmission mechanisms and how money growth plays an important role. And he asks those important questions as to like, is it debt or is it money growth that really causes inflation? And inflation, how important it is to determining where we are in that cycle. So it was a really great story. He built a good argument why he feels that it's mid-cycle, and I wanted him to share it with our MacroVoices listeners.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I want to thank you for doing such a great job. I think John was exactly the right pick for these criteria. And although I still disagree with some of his conclusions in the end, this interview definitely opened my eye to several things that I hadn't really given adequate attention to. And we'll come back to some of those when we talk about this in postgame.

Patrick Ceresna: For sure. So Erik's interview with John Greenwood is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Greenwood's thesis: mid-cycle, not late cycle

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is John Greenwood, Chief Economist at Invesco. And listeners, John put together a fantastic chartbook for us with some really excellent graphs and charts. I strongly encourage you to download the chartbook. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered Just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, next to John's picture on our homepage.

John, thanks so much for joining us. You know, we've had so many guests tell us that we are at the end of the business cycle, late cycle, and one of the reasons that Patrick, my producer, sought you out is because you are obviously a very credible voice, but one who does not think that we're necessarily at the end of the business cycle. So please tell us, where are we in the business cycle and what's

John Greenwood: Sure. Well, my view is that broadly we're at mid-cycle, not late cycle. I know the cycle has been going on for 10 years almost. In fact, in June will be the 10th anniversary of the trough of the last business cycle. So we've been expanding for 10 years. And in July, this current business cycle expansion will become the longest in recorded US financial history. History.

But nevertheless, I believe that it has several years to run. And basically, I think there are 3 reasons for that. First, money growth has been low and stable. Second, private sector leverage in the US remains low despite some concerns about the non-financial corporate sector. And thirdly, inflation is not a threat, nor do we face a major financial accident.

Those are the two main causes why previous business cycles have come to a premature end. So, in my view, if we take a historical analogy, we're at something like 1995 in the cycle that went from 1991 to 2001, which was the previous longest expansion cycle. So, I think we have several years to go. go because the central bank, the Fed, doesn't have to take any drastic action at this point. And I don't believe that there are serious problems in the private sector that will cause a premature end to the expansion.

Money and credit drive the business cycle

Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and dive into your slide deck and talk about the mechanics of what actually drives the cycle.

John Greenwood: Okay. Well, if we look at this first graphic, slide. It's a flowchart which really sets out the phases and stages of a business cycle expansion. Now, it's important to understand that the business cycle, although there are arguments about this in academia, in my view, there's no doubt at all that the business cycle is fundamentally driven by money and credit.

And while I've put monetary conditions in the slide here, what I really mean is the rate of growth of money and credit. So if we take an example, if the money growth rate accelerates from say 5% to 10%, if it doubles from 5% to 10%, the first thing that will happen is that there will be an impact in the money markets and the asset prices. That's the second box in the flowchart. Chart.

Now, this is what we call the portfolio rebalancing effect, uh, because with more money than people want to hold in their portfolios, they are going to reallocate that money to other areas. Could be to money market securities, it could be to the bond market, it could be to equity market, could be to the housing market, or even commodities and other collectibles.

But in any any case, the first impact is generally on the asset market. And once asset prices have risen and people start feeling wealthier, 2 things will happen. First of all, businesses will start to hire more and invest more, and consumers will start to spend more. And both of those 2 things will drive up consumption and So that will boost economic activity. And along with that, by the way, employment will rise and unemployment will fall.

And then finally, now the 4th in the flowchart, the money growth rate continues to expand at a rapid rate, the 10% that I mentioned just now. Then after a lag of about 2 years, we will start to see that show up in consumer price inflation. So the entire business cycle, or the business cycle covers pretty much everything from assets, economic activity to inflation.

And the effect is built up and spread out over time. It doesn't kind of go immediately from excess money growth into economic activity or inflation. That process takes a while. And because it takes a while, a lot of people fail to grasp or understand where we are in the process. So notice that I haven't talked about interest rates. They're not really a concern here. It's the quantity of money and quantity of credit which is driving the process.

So how do we know that this is a reasonable description of how the process works? Well, if we go to the next slide, number 3, this is a simple chart that shows the S&P 500. That's the black line, and the red line is the level of US real GDP.

And I've also put in the recession bars. And what you'll notice straight away is the way in which pretty much— well, in fact, in this slide, every single stock market peak precedes or comes very early start of a recession. So in other words, asset prices in the previous flowchart are going to peak before the economy peaks.

That's what you'd expect from that flow diagram, and this is validating that. So if you want to understand what's going to happen to the stock market, I always say you've got to understand the business cycle that is If we go to the next slide, that's another illustration of the cycle, only this time I've taken house prices instead of stock prices.

And I've put the house prices this time in terms of rates of change because the US didn't have any significant downturns in house prices until this recent major downturn. But you can just as well look at cycles in terms of levels or rates of change. But if we look at this in terms of rates of change, we've got the rate of change of real GDP in black and the rate of change of house prices in red. And again, you see that pretty much all the house price peaks precede recessions. So again, asset prices peak before we hit recession.

And then the third in this series, slide 5, shows in the blue line capital value is for the commercial real estate market. And once again, peaks in relative peaks in the commercial property market broadly precede any recession. So I think I've made the case fairly strongly there that asset prices are driven by the same sort of forces that drive the business cycle, which normally ends in recession.

And then on slide 6, we have consumer prices. I've skipped one element, that is the GDP, because the GDP is the black line which is shown in this chart, and the recessions I've shown by the vertical bands. So we now move to slide 6 and inflation. Now here you'll notice something different. Inflation tends to peak after the economy turns down and during or well into a recession.

Another thing you will notice is that— and this is particularly clear in the 1980s and then in 1991— that there is a very wide gap between the inflation number and the GDP In other words, the GDP turned down first, but inflation continues to rise for quite a while.

That gives rise to the phenomenon we know as stagflation, that inflation tends to persist some considerable time after the economy has turned down. And this is a period historically when politicians and central bankers get very impatient With the economy being weak, they tend to put their foot on the gas. Danger is that in doing that, they will exacerbate the inflation even more.

So to sum up, if we go to slide 7, we have the same flowchart at the top, but I've filled in the details of some of those boxes lower down. I see broad money accelerating in the first box. And maintaining a faster rate for a sustained period. And then asset prices rising due to the portfolio rebalancing effect.

And then economic activity turning up, reflected in stronger investment, stronger consumption, retail sales, employment, and of course unemployment falling. And then finally, the outcome of this fast just a sustained rate of rapid money growth would be higher inflation. As a digression, I may say at this point that many people put their trust in the Phillips Curve, and I'd like to point out what is wrong with the Phillips Curve. Many of you will know that the Phillips Curve relates the level of unemployment on the horizontal axis to the rate of change of wages or prices on the vertical axis. Because we've had very low unemployment recently, recently, 3.7%.

Many economists at central banks, in academia, and indeed on Wall Street are saying that at some point that we must get inflation. But straight away you can see what's wrong with that analysis. Essentially what it's doing is ignoring those first 2 boxes, saying forget about money. What it's doing is relating unemployment in the 3rd box to prices in the 4th box.

Now, it is true that in the past, strong money growth did produce strong employment and low unemployment, which did produce rising inflation. But that is not what we've had this time. So I've called this— if you look at the title more carefully, I've called this a Type 1 business cycle, one that is generally generated by rapid money growth.

But if we go to the next slide, here's type 2, and this is what we've had this time. Because the private sector was so overleveraged in 2008-9, the demand for credit was very weak and banks were risk-averse. Consequently, instead of having rapid money growth, we've had very low money growth.

And as a byproduct of that, interest rates have remained low. And in addition, asset prices have risen, yes, but mainly because interest rates have been low. That's what I call a capital markets effect rather than an effect of excess money. And then gradually the economy in the third box has improved. Investment has increased, consumption has picked up, retail sales and And of course, we've got the lowest level of unemployment for 50 years.

But because money growth has not been rapid, we have not had inflation. Inflation is broadly unchanged at somewhere between 1.5% and 2%. So you have to understand how strong the monetary forces are driving the business cycle. And in this cycle, they've been quite modest. We'll get into the details of that a little later on, but that's kind of an initial preliminary statement of the mechanics of the business cycle.

Devil's advocate: asset prices, Eurodollars and the Fed

Erik Townsend: Let me just ask a couple of questions about that, because if I play devil's advocate here, the people who think that we're late cycle would look at what you've described and say, John, you know, you're exactly right. What happens is you We tend to see asset prices peak well before we enter recession. We haven't reentered recession officially yet, but that's coming. Look at, at the fact that Eurodollar futures or Eurodollar futures spreads are basically discounting that most of the market thinks the Fed's next move will be to cut rather than to hike rates further. So the Fed seems to be done hiking, getting ready to cut.

Doesn't that mean that we're approaching We seem to be approaching that point of the cycle ending. And it seems to me like the one very clear sign we've seen through these slides is we don't have inflation moving up dramatically even as GDP is falling off. We don't have that signal, but it seems like the other signs of end of cycle are there even as you've described this. What am I missing?

John Greenwood: Well, the end of the business cycle is by no means automatic. Generated by a slowdown or sharp slowdown in money and credit growth. And that's something we really haven't seen. We have had, as I shall show, low and stable money growth. And in addition, as I said at the beginning, the private sector is not leveraged up in any serious way such as to threaten the business cycle, and inflation is low.

So the central bank doesn't have a reason to squeeze from this point on. In fact, I would again make the analogy or parallel with the 1990s or indeed with the early 2000s. After the Fed had initially normalized rates in 1995, it then cut and raised and cut and raised it. So interest rates varied quite a bit between 1995 and 2001. one.

So just because the Fed has largely completed normalization, it doesn't mean that the rates will not change, and nor does it mean that rates are bound to fall because the economy goes into recession. GDP behaves in a fairly erratic way. At the moment, it's been, at least on the official numbers, been quite strong, and I doubt whether it will weaken very sharply, certainly not enough to be classified as a recession.

So short-term variations in interest rates, that kind of fine-tuning of interest rates, is perfectly normal in the late stages, mid to late stages of a business cycle.

Money, not government debt or QE, drives inflation

Erik Townsend: John, why don't we move on then? Because I know starting on slide 9, you've got a series of slides that talk about the role that debt plays in the business cycle. So let's bring that dimension in next, starting on

John Greenwood: Sure. I'd like to spend a few minutes on this because in talking to our clients and investors around the world, I find there's a huge degree of misunderstanding. Many people are very worried about the high level of government debt or about debt in general. So if you look at slide 9, this is a kind of abbreviated monetary history of the United States since 1970. 70.

And what it shows is broad money. I've used M3 and an up-to-date proxy for M3 because the Fed stopped publishing it in 2005, I think it was, or 2006. And that's the dark blue line. And I've also got on this chart the ratio of government debt to GDP.

I like to ask this question: which was responsible for Clearly, the '70s and early '80s were a period of high inflation, high and rising inflation in the US. And you can see from the chart, debt was low and fairly stable. Government debt was low and stable relative to GDP, but money growth was very rapid.

Clearly, it was money growth behind the inflation. And then conversely, if we look at the recent You have very high government debt to GDP, nearly 100%. This is federal, state, and local government debt together as a percentage of GDP. But money growth, in contrast to the '70s and '80s, money growth is very low.

And what do we have? We have low inflation. So I think it's clear from this that it is money that matters, not the level of debt.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

John Greenwood: But another thing that people get hung up about is QE. For some reason, people think that money on the books of the central bank is somehow more important than money in the hands of the public, in the hands of households and firms.

So if you go to slide 10, what I've done here is to index the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve System. That's the dark blue line, which I've labeled QE. And then I've indexed broad money and nominal GDP also to the same date. In this case, they're all indexed to January 2008 as 100.

And I asked the question, so which is it, is the driver of nominal GDP? Is it QE or is it broad money? And from the chart, it's obvious which is the driver.

Erik Townsend: Yeah.

John Greenwood: And you can apply this to other countries. If we go to slide 11, this is the same data for the UK.

And again, it's clear that it's not QE which is important for nominal GDP, it's broad money. If we go to slide 12 for Japan, it's clear that it's broad money that's important for nominal GDP, and that's total spending, not QE.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

John Greenwood: QE. Finally, for the Eurozone, it's exactly the same. It is broad money, in the Eurozone's case M3, which has been important, the important driver of GDP, nominal GDP, not QE.

So by way of sort of setting the scene, this is simply to say broad money is really what you need to monitor in getting that flow diagram for the business

Erik Townsend: Correct.

John Greenwood: Going forward.

Broad money as a ceiling on nominal GDP worldwide

Erik Townsend: John, moving on to slide 14, why don't you tell me about money growth in various different countries and relate that to the concept that you just described to us?

John Greenwood: Sure. Well, nominal GDP, of course, as everybody knows, is total nominal spending, current spending in dollars or yen or euros or renminbi, or you name it, whatever currency. So it combines both real economic activity and goods and service price inflation, not asset prices. And what is very interesting is that broad money growth in effect acts as a kind of a ceiling to nominal spending growth or nominal GDP.

So if we look at slide 14, and particularly the recent period since 2011 or '12, you can see that nominal GDP, which is the red line, has broadly remained below money growth, whether it's M2 or M3, until just recently when we've had a little bit of an uptick, which I think is the short-term reaction to the fiscal stimulus administered by President Trump.

I personally don't believe that will last, but as long as money growth continues at this sort of 4 to 5% growth rate, then I don't think the US economy will come to any great harm. And this is something which is applicable right across the board.

If we go now to slide 15, you can see exactly the same sort of relationship for the Eurozone. M3, in effect, creating a kind of ceiling for nominal GDP. There are occasional occasions when nominal GDP spikes up above money, but those episodes are relatively brief. And for the most part, for those of you who know the quantity theory of money and the fact that velocity is a declining number, those of you who understand that will know why this is. It's because money growth less a falling velocity gives you nominal GDP.

Look also at the UK. Again, we have pretty much the same picture. Recent rates of growth of money are low and fairly stable. And although many people fear that sterling may fall sharply in the event of a hard or medium-hard Brexit, in fact, the money growth rates have been so low as to call that into question.

And then if we go to slide 17, You can see why Japan has had such a low money— a low inflation rate and a low nominal GDP growth rate ever since its bubble burst in 1991. Money, which during the bubble was growing at double-digit rates, slumped, and since 1992, it's averaged only 2.6% per annum.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

John Greenwood: per annum, which is much too low for Japan. And as a result, nominal GDP has averaged only 0.5% per annum with numerous episodes of deflation.

So if Japan wants to end deflation or get the CPI up to 2%, it's going to need faster money growth. I calculate that Japan needs roughly 6% money growth. But you can see that it's never been near that in the past 25, nearly 30 years.

And by the way, we can extend that in slide 18 to China, where we've recently had very slow money growth, money growth slowing from the mid-teens down to the high single digits, a rate of growth of money that we have not seen since China started its liberalization program in 1977.

And then if you go to slide 19, the same applies in India. So right across the board, kind of like the law of gravity, it just applies— it applies in every country. Rates of broad money growth act as some kind of a ceiling for nominal spending growth in all these countries. And given that they are all experiencing rather low rates of money growth at the moment, to me, it seems inconceivable that the inflation rate is going to spike up anywhere. And therefore, there is no need for any of the central banks to suddenly slam their foot on the brake and raise interest rates and terminate the business cycle expansion.

Shadow banking and leveraged loans

Erik Townsend: John, as I look through these last several slides, you're talking about money supply as measured by M2 or M3. Those are measures of money supply in the banking system. What about the money in the shadow banking system? How does that play into this equation?

John Greenwood: Yeah, well, that's very important, and I'm glad you raised that. If we go to slide 20, this is, uh, the measure of the shadow banking system in the US that I use. In fact, you can measure shadow banking in 2 ways. One way is to add up the or the liability side of the balance sheet of the institutions involved in shadow banking.

And that's what I've done here. I'll elaborate on that in just a moment. But the other way you can do it is to look at the instruments that are used in the shadow banking market. So things like repos, commercial paper, asset-backed securities, securitized debt, and so on— CLOs, CDOs, etc. Etc.

Now, when people make payments, when firms and households and individuals make payments, they typically either write a check against a bank account or they make a payment digitally nowadays over the internet or however drawn on accounts of commercial banks. So most of the GDP is reflected in those official sort of money numbers for the banking system.

But the shadow banks have become very important in the asset markets. Now, in this particular chart, we have money market funds, which are essentially banks without capital, and then primary dealers, which were not banks. These were the investment banks before the crisis. Companies like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, and others. But clearly since the crisis, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs have applied to become banks and they are part of the Federal Reserve System now. But they were creating credit prior to the 2008 crisis.

Then we have the next group is the finance companies, mortgage finance companies. And auto finance companies, companies like that, issuers of asset-backed securities, and then the notorious SIVs and conduits, the funding corporations. That's the blue line. If you add those 3— money market funds, primary dealer balance sheets, and the finance company line— you get the total of shadow banks.

And what I want to draw to your attention What I want to mention is that at the peak, the size of shadow banks— so the peak in 2008, shadow banks were $16 trillion. At the time, M2, money in the banking system, was only $8 trillion. In other words, the shadow banks were twice the size of the banks.

Now, the Fed protected the banks, injected liquidity, and the Treasury did the TARP. TARP to recapitalize the banks. So the banks were, if you like, protected, recapitalized, and made healthy again. Whereas the shadow banks, as you can see, contracted very sharply. What happened was when Lehman Brothers went bankrupt, there was a universal realization that lending in these shadow banking markets, so buying the debt, whether it was the commercial paper issued by investment banks or by mortgage finance companies. This kind of paper was very unreliable and the funding of these corporations, these shadow banks evaporated.

And as a result, as you can see, there was a very rapid shrinkage initially of these shadow banks and they continued to shrink until about a year or so ago. And there's only been a very, very modest upturn since then. So, in broad terms, shadow banks were very important, but they were important for the asset markets rather than for the regular goods and services.

So, if we go to the next slide here, what I've done is to show broad money growth again for the US. That light blue line is M2, but I've added in shadow banks during the 1990s. That is during the tech bubble, you can see that credit was growing at 15 to 20% per annum.

And similarly, during the housing bubble of the early 2000s, those are the 2 areas with the solid overall circle. But since the Lehman bankruptcy in 2008, shadow banks contracted abruptly and have been shrinking at a very gradual rate since then, and only recently have just turned up a little bit.

So what I've also done is to combine banks and shadow banks with that green line. So I took the total of the balance sheets of the banks, the M2, and the shadow bank liabilities, and that generates that green line. So whether you look at money in the bank banking in the shadow banking system, the total has been growing at a very modest rate, only 4 to 5%.

Now, people sometimes say to me, but surely there's very rapid growth in areas like leveraged loans. That is true, but leveraged loans are only at about $1.3, $1.4 trillion today. The banking system, as we just saw in the preceding slide, close to $15 trillion. And the shadow banking system altogether is about $10 trillion on this definition.

So we're comparing very different sizes of entity here. The banks and shadow banks together are about $25 trillion. You take just one area of the shadow banking business, business, namely leveraged loans, that's only 1.5%. It's not going to make a big difference to the overall US economy or the asset markets.

Business cycle phases and asset allocation

Erik Townsend: John, moving on to slide 22, why don't we pull all of this together using the concepts that you've defined so far and just talk through where we stand in the business cycle and what comes next?

John Greenwood: Sure. So slide 22 is a kind of simple outline of the business cycle in developed economies. Economies. And as you can see, I allocate assets through the business cycle. And essentially, the business cycle is expanding through stages 1, 2, and 3. And then when monetary policy really tightens in phase 3, then obviously you need to shift towards cash. And as the economy heads towards a recession and rates start coming down, you can move it to bonds. So this is a kind of asset allocation view of the same business cycle that we've been talking about.

But to be specific, if we go to slide 23, there we have the US, which has largely normalized rates now in the middle of phase 2. I guess you could argue with that and say possibly the US is closer to the end of phase 2 because the normalization is kind of at an end. But the important point is that the US has not moved to phase That is where the Fed or the central bank is tightening deliberately in order to squeeze money and credit and to terminate the expansion in order to deal with inflation. That is definitively not today's problem.

And then the UK is somewhat behind the US, only just started on the rate normalization process. And the EU, Eurozone, and Japan are even further behind. They haven't even started to normalize. So that's a kind of very brief overview of the business cycle and where we stand, where the major countries stand.

If you want to apply that to emerging economies, you can do so. But without going into too much detail here, the red line represents the business cycle of developed economies. The blue line represents the cycle of emerging market economies. And all I would say here is that the emerging economies tend to have a shorter, sharper cycle. So, for example, China coming out of the 2008 downturn put its foot hard on the accelerator. We had a very strong boom, but then they had to put their foot on the brake and things have slowed down.

During the 1990s, Asia, many of the smaller economies in Asia had no less than 3 boom-bust episodes of that kind in the space of a single US business cycle expansion. So these short, sharp cycles are nothing new in the emerging markets, and they are still occurring.

Leverage, the Minsky moment and deleveraging by country

Erik Townsend: John, you spoke earlier about leverage being an important aspect of this cycle. Please elaborate. I see on slide 25, it looks like we're illustrating this concept.

John Greenwood: My slide 25, shows what I call 2 overlapping bell curves. The first curve, the red curve, shows what happens in a credit bubble to the private sector. This is a debt-to-income ratio, so it's a leverage ratio. And if monetary policy becomes excessively easy in the sense of rapid credit growth, rapid money growth, and lowish rates, low relative to nominal GDP, GDP, then you tend to get the private sector leveraging up, which is exactly what happened in the '90s and then again in the early 2000s. But when that leverage gets very high, one of two things can happen.

Either the central bank can tighten, popping the bubble, or you can have a major financial accident. So that first black vertical line is essentially what has become known now as the Minsky moment. And after the Minsky moment, you have a radical change in behavior. All people want to deleverage because asset prices have fallen and they are overleveraged. So they hunker down, cut spending, cut investments.

And if they are companies, they're going to cut spending and hiring until they have deleveraged.

Meantime, governments, which abhor recessions, typically will come in with fiscal stimulus policies, but because their tax revenues have declined, they have to borrow to finance that. And so we typically see the public sector debt ratio rising. Now, things will go on like this until the private sector has deleveraged back to a level of households and companies feel that they can start to grow again.

And only once that has happened can the public sector, the government sector, start to deleverage. Unfortunately, in Europe, they're doing it the other way around. They're emphasizing the need for public sector deleveraging. And as a result, the private sector is not getting any help in its deleveraging. But we'll come on to that. So that's the kind of theoretical concept. And I would say that no country has yet moved into phase 3. Every major country is still in phase

Now, if you go to slide 26 very quickly, here we see the data for the United States, the long buildup in private sector leverage from about 205% to 296% of GDP, and then the deleveraging which has occurred since then. Meantime, public sector has leveraged up, the government sector has leveraged up, and as I mentioned earlier, government debt-to-GDP ratio is around 100%. So the US is close to the end of phase 2.

I haven't yet drawn that second vertical line because interest rates are still very, very low. And it may be that as interest rates are raised further, if they are raised further, then there may be more deleveraging to come from the private sector. So that's where the US stands.

The UK is— next slide, 27. 27 is a little bit behind the US. It has deleveraged, but not as much. And these numbers are much higher for the UK because London is such a— relative to the size of the UK economy.

But contrast those 2 countries with Japan on slide 28, where the bubble burst as far back as the end of 1989, the beginning of 1990. And look how little deleveraging there's been in Japan over all these past 25, nearly 30 years. On the other hand, the public sector has continued to ramp up the debt ratio, but of course the inflation rate has remained very, very low. So with this high level of indebtedness, Japan has still found it very difficult to grow, and banks have been risk-averse, reluctant to lend.

Then finally, on slide 29, and I show you this after Japan Because in many ways, having leveraged up during the period to 2008, private sector, the red line, Europe basically failed to deleverage from 2009 to 2014-15. And their attitude was subprime, that's an American problem. Really did very little.

But as I say, they are deleveraging or trying to get debt in the public sector down, which I believe is the wrong way around to do it. But I show you this because it seems to me to point to the risk that Europe is very likely to repeat this long period of very slow growth with near deflationary conditions that Japan has been through for the past 20 years or more.

So, in relation to debt generally, it's imperative after a credit crisis that balance sheets are repaired. The US and the UK, by and large, have done a good job in that. Japan was much slower, and the Eurozone is proving also very slow to do that. And as long as we have those very high debt ratios in Japan and the Eurozone, I think growth will tend to be subpar.

Summary: OECD money growth and inflation

Erik Townsend: John, we're just about out of time, but please talk us through slide 30 before I let you go.

John Greenwood: Sure. Well, this is a kind of a summary slide. What it shows you is broad money growth in all of the OECD countries. That's the black line and inflation averaged across all those countries. These are weighted averages. And what you And that to me is a simple explanation for why inflation has been so low in so many countries.

Basically, we've had since the crisis much lower rates of growth of money and incidentally bank credit on the other side of bank balance sheets. And naturally, along with that, we've had very low rates of inflation. So until or unless we get faster rates of money and credit growth. To me, it's inconceivable that the inflation rate will pick up sharply. And therefore, there is no basis for the— to squeeze and terminate the cycle.

Similarly, as I showed earlier, leverage has come down, particularly in the US and UK. There's no reason to expect a major financial accident. So, for those reasons, I firmly believe that we are much closer to mid-cycle than late cycle.

Erik Townsend: Well, John, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Listeners, John is once again the Chief Economist for Invesco, I-N-V-E-S-C-O. So be sure to check out their website if you want to follow more of John's work. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: guest requests and mailbag

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for future guests. for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: takeaways from Greenwood

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have John on the show. You know, to me, it's so important to be able to look at the business cycle from a much bigger picture perspective to understand how important money supply and credit growth, which provides the money supply, is to determining where we are in the business cycles. And while I'm in the camp that we're late business cycle for sure, It's certainly really valuable to get some different perspectives on it.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, you know, if there's anything I've learned, Patrick, it's listening to people who you disagree with is more important in this game than listening to people you do agree with. You already know what you think. Having that confirmed by more people who just bolster your confidence at what could be an incorrect view doesn't help you. It's listening to the people who see it differently. and looking for what they see that you don't see, that is where the opportunity is. And, you know, I still disagree about where we are, but one thing that really caught my attention in this interview was just the observation that usually when we see all these signals that we're seeing right now that says recession is coming, usually one of those is inflation is spiking.

And that sets up the situation where, you know, the Fed can't really save the day and come to the rescue by accommodative policy because if they If they became too accommodative, it would exacerbate the inflation and their hands are tied. They're screwed. That's the situation they can't really get out of. Well, we don't have an inflation problem, which means the Fed can be accommodative and can rescue asset markets and keep things going. So considering that we don't have that inflation risk, it does change the dynamics from the norm somewhat.

And that's an angle that I hadn't really given a lot of thought to before listening to this All factors considered, I'm still of the opinion that we're at very late cycle, recession is coming, but, you know, it's definitely eye-opening to think about the other side of the argument. In any event, Patrick, I want to move on to your chartbook now. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Postgame Chartbook. Or if you're not yet subscribed to Research Roundup, shame on you, you can find it by going to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads right next to John Greenwood's picture.

S&P 500: 2,800 line in the sand

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as I look at chart 2, you know, when we spoke last week, seemed like, wow, we're out of that green danger zone on that top green block you have, must be headed higher, maybe it's new all-time highs. And then, wow, after the last couple of days, we're right back into the danger zone.

So what's coming next?

Patrick Ceresna: Right. So the theme for our chart book this week is really about commodities, but I just wanted to give everyone a quick update on the S&P chart. Now, our listeners probably all know that I'm short this market, but this is an incredibly important level where it's too early for the bears to make any victory laps. To me, this 2,800 to 2,825 level is really a line in the sand that if the bulls do a good job defending it, particularly on a second retest, that it could establish a correction bottom. You know, it's one of these typical corrections that last 3 weeks in duration, and then it could still reverse and bullishly advance.

So this is still an incredibly important moment in the market. But to me, it's also though the levels below 2,800, because once we get below 2,800, there's going to be almost nothing stopping the market from a quick drop down to about the 2,750 area. But really, that's where a lot of more ominous liquidity events could occur that could accelerate the selling. So I want to sort of leave it at that bigger view that we're at an important pivot, a binary moment where either the bulls are going to hold the or we could have some accelerated selling. So it's going to be a very interesting Friday and Monday price action in the next few days.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I couldn't agree more. You know, the things to watch for here are going to be a daily close below 2,800, and I'd say decisively below 2,800 to really make it count, or a daily close above 2,875 or so, you know, going back to a new high above the recent cycle high a few weeks weeks ago, that would be the indication that the bulls are winning. But you're right, we're right here in the danger zone.

Commodities: Bloomberg index and crude oil

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to commodities though, because boy, we're seeing commodities in general are really not looking fantastic. And I think this fits into our overall, you know, another sign of possible recession coming.

Patrick Ceresna: That's right. Now, what I particularly wanted to focus on in my mind on commodities is, is the impact commodity prices have on, on trends in inflation. Obviously crude oil tends to have one of the largest impacts in that, but it's the entire commodity complex that's so important in inflation expectations. There have been a lot of people that have been really pushing this idea that the tariffs are going to create a transitory inflationary impulse as prices will rise from the tariffs. But, you know, one of the things that I think could offset those tariffs, it would be a potential rise in the dollar and subsequently further deterioration in commodities because the disinflationary impulse from that trend could more than offset the impact of tariffs on China.

And so which way these commodities go, I think, is going to be incredibly important to that bigger theme. And so on page 3, we have just that Bloomberg Commodity Index, which is the basket of all commodities. And this chart continues to look incredibly weak, a pattern of lower highs rolling over, making a little bit lower lows. It really just continues to support this idea that The path of least resistance in commodities continues to be decisively lower.

Erik Townsend: Oh, I couldn't agree more. And, you know, if we look at oil futures on the next chart in a bigger view here, it's possible we're right on a key level here at the 100-day moving average in the continuation chart. If we somehow recover from this and don't move any lower than we went today, there's still room for this to be an intermediate bottom. But I think the more likely case is that we retrace at least part of this really, really big move that we had today. And then eventually, as the market kind of gathers more steam moving up, is just going to bring more sellers into the market. And I think we eventually could very easily be headed back into the 40s, if not all the way down to a retest of that Christmas low.

Now certainly you can turn all of that around in an instant with the right geopolitical news, but just on economic news only, if there's no geopolitical upsets, I think that the stage is set to move considerably lower here. What are your thoughts?

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, you're bang on. And this is why listening to the Energy Week podcast is so important because the price action is one thing, but understanding the geopolitics that are emerging in the background that could drive the next trend move is just equally as important. You know, barring or without some geopolitical event spurring it higher. I do believe that the broader weakness in the commodity complex will drive crude oil weaker. And my short-term targets are right around this $57, $58. But like you were alluding to, if we see failed rallies in the coming weeks, it's just going to solidify a potential new downtrend that could see weakness into the summer.

RBOB gasoline and copper versus iron ore

Erik Townsend: Patrick, moving on to slide 5, we see RBOB gasoline rolling over, and it certainly led today's charge down, although it was interesting. Almost all day today, RBOB was leading the charge down and towards the end of the day, it was WTI that actually made the final push lower. What do you see in terms of the outlook for gasoline?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I think there's going to be that strong correlation between oil and gas the way we've seen always throughout the last many years. But the one observation is that gasoline futures have really started to test those key highs from 2018. And I, I believe that it's pretty asymmetric at this moment. I, I don't see gasoline futures making multi-year highs, and so there's a lot of overhead resistance here and a lot of things that could cause this to mean revert back and down towards some of those lower levels. So at this stage, I don't see much upside here.

Moving on to chart 6 here, Erik, what I wanted to touch on was copper, and particularly between charts 6 2007 is the divergence between copper and iron ore, which not always, but often have a correlation as basic material. And really what we've seen is copper rolling over, far more liquid futures market, and it's weakening back down to 2018 lows, really kind of feeding this global economic slowdown. But there is literally no sign of iron ore stopping or at least rolling over. I don't know what to really make of this. Do you have any ideas as to why they're diverging this way?

Erik Townsend: I have to be honest, Patrick, and say the best I can give you is a guess because I really don't know. But the thing that hits my mind is just who's the big consumer of iron ore? It's China. If China feels threatened by sanctions that could impede its ability to continue to import iron ore, a lot of it comes from Australia, Australia. You know, maybe that could continue to support a bid. But as you say, by the same argument, China is a major consumer of copper. We don't see copper catching a big bid here. So that's all that comes to mind. And it's, it's a complete wild guess. I don't have an explanation for this.

Gold, wedge patterns and other precious metals

Patrick Ceresna: Right. Well, I guess we'll just move on because I really don't know what else to say about that. But when we get on to gold, which is on page 8, this is where it's interesting because Because to me, gold has dug in and actually surprisingly held the line. It's certainly not anything bullish to say of the last couple months other than it's been relatively well defended. We haven't seen those drops of gold heading back down to $1,200, which would have been something if you look at most of the other commodity charts, something we would have anticipated gold to potentially be doing. Maybe there's a safe haven element.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I agree. My base case has been dollar moves considerably higher from here, and that's the reason that I think gold moves lower. Now, if I'm wrong about the dollar, I'm also wrong about gold. And as I look at this chart, again, trying to think about the other view— what if I'm wrong? Well, as much as it looks like we're now in a nice established established downtrend. At the same time, yeah, it almost looks like a bull flag pattern that's forming on gold. And furthermore, if that were to reverse and we were to go above $1,350, boy, doesn't that look like a great big cup and handle formation which would project much higher numbers?

So if I've got the dollar call wrong and we do get above $1,350, then I think, you know, sky's the limit from there. But for now, my base case is that we break out of this descending wedge pattern to the downside. And, you know, there's an argument, a strong argument, that it could go the other way. If you just look at the shape on the chart pattern, a descending wedge like that would often break to the upside. But that's really going to be the next thing to watch for, is when that wedge pattern you can see on page 8 breaks. And, and, you know, what comes next? Are we breaking up or down out of that pattern.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And that's, that's a really good point because to me it's the same thing. This looks like a, like a consolidation wedge pattern that could very easily bullishly resolve itself. And I won't lie that I poked a couple times on the upside of gold last week to try to see whether or not there was a breakout. But what I find troubling about that gold narrative of being on the short-term bullish— because I'm long-term bullish gold, just we're talking about the short-term trends— is, is the weakness that we're seeing in the other precious metals markets.

On page 9, 10, and 11, I have the charts on silver, platinum, and palladium. And what we see here is that they are all very weak. Silver breaking to a multi-week fresh new low. Platinum prices going to retest the 2018 lows on the downside. And palladium, which was in a huge bull run going into the start of 2019, has really been just in full consolidation mode for the last several months. And so there isn't a lot of support from the other precious metals markets to suggest that somehow gold is, is ready to break out.

Erik Townsend: You make a really excellent point here, Patrick, and it's, it's something that I've definitely learned, you know, going back to the oil market. If you're not really sure what to make of the WTI chart, look at the RBOB gasoline chart. It usually gives you clues to what's coming next for WTI.

And I think likewise, you know, looking at what silver's doing— gold chart, that could be a bull flag pattern, it's getting ready to break much higher. But boy, silver sure doesn't look like it's getting ready to break higher. Platinum, no way. So I agree completely with what you've said here. Let's move on to wheat.

Grains and the wet planting season

Erik Townsend: What do you see there?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, I wanted to talk about the grains in general. So on pages 12, 13, and 14, I've got the, the charts on wheat, corn, and soybean. Now soybean on page 14 is obviously being impacted considerably from the tariffs and trade war, which continues to press it down near its 52-week lows.

But what is interesting is that the flooding in the Midwest is creating all sorts of interesting scenarios for corn and wheat. Rather than being correlated to the broader commodities at this stage, are really marching to the beat of their own drum due to the fundamentals of the conditions. And what's interesting, Karen Braun, who tweets on a lot of these grain things, put out a tweet that basically was showing the planting progress in the US. And as of May 19th, corn was at 49%, which was the slowest in record back to 1980. And so the rate of which they're able to plant here is not happening quickly. And when you go to spring wheat, it's at 70%, which is well below its average. And so you have a situation with those weather conditions are actually driving these prices on the short term. It'll be interesting to see how much farther they'll be able to push on that before they go back into correlation with a lot of the broader commodities.

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I know something that Pat Hemsworth mentioned on Energy Week this week is there is apparently, and I don't have the full details on this, there's some kind of decision that, or a date that has been stipulated that's kind of like the line in the sand where you can't plant new corn after such and such a date.

I'm not clear if that's a regulatory thing or what, but I know that a lot of diesel traders are very concerned that there could be a major suppression in demand for diesel fuel if farmers in the Midwest are forced to abandon and not plant the corn that they had planned to plant. So I think that probably has something to do with that spike we see on page 13 in corn prices.

Lumber, cotton, softs and disinflation

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to lumber, which is usually a very good indicator of the broader economy because it has so much to do with construction costs.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, for sure. And lumber just continues to be weak. It's amazing that throughout 2017 and the first half of 2018, there was an extraordinary bull market in lumber that essentially had it almost double in its price. But in the back half of 2018, we saw the bear market kind of rip lumber prices apart, almost halving the price. But we've seen now lumber for the last more or less 6 to 9 months trading right near its 52-week lows, and it continues to be under a lot of pressure. It'd be very interesting to see whether it breaks further or even if this just continues to be very weak, but there's certainly no immediate signs to show that there's recovery in the lumber markets.

Erik Townsend: Well, and if you go back to our earlier conversation about looking for clues by going to other markets, boy, if I look at lumber Hmm, you know, it seems like we're still above that late October low, so maybe it's bottoming here. Maybe this is the support level that's going to hold because it held back in November. And we've seen several other charts where what we're doing now is revisiting lows. But if we go right ahead to one more slide, page 16, cotton is a perfect example of something that got back to that late 2018 low and went right through it. And it says to me that maybe these other commodities— Of course, that's It's a level that held before. There's gonna be some support there, but it seems like the setup is to break through that support. We're seeing it with only a few commodities like cotton so far, but it makes me wonder when the next domino is gonna fall.

Patrick Ceresna: No, that's for sure. Cotton breaking fresh new 52-week lows. And on charts 17 and 18, I also have sugar futures which continue to trade right near the bottom end of their ranges, and coffee futures also making 52-week new lows on the downside. And so continued pressure right along the entire commodity complex. It was interesting, those that did subscribe to Variant Perception's trial offer, they did have information on there talking about some of their leading indicators continuing to show further pressure in the coming 6 months on the commodity complex. So To me, this is a disinflationary pressure. I don't want to say deflationary because they got that boogeyman element to the word, but whenever commodity prices are down like this, and especially when the dollar is so strong, there really is, other than tariffs, there really isn't any storyline where you can build a case where inflation is going to rear its head.

Patrick at Montreal Options Education Day

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it's very hard to call any of these things with certainty, but there's one call I can make out of this whole deck with absolute certainty, which is Saturday, June 1st, a week from Saturday. You will absolutely for sure be at the Westin Montreal where you're speaking at Options Education Day for the Montreal Stock Exchange. Tell us a little bit more. It's only $50, which again is about the cost of a 12-pack in Western Canada.

What, what can people expect there and how do they sign up?

Patrick Ceresna: It's a great event held by the TMX. All sorts of great speakers coming out there, including myself. myself and a whole day of great options education. So I'm looking forward to meeting a lot of our listeners out there, and, uh, and I'm looking forward to teaching them a few option strategies. It's gonna be a great time.

Wrap-up: free trial, reviews, Research Roundup and outro

Erik Townsend: And I want to remind our listeners, we do these post-game chart books with Big Picture Trading chart books when time allows in the program, but Patrick does these webinars every single day of the week with updates on all of the markets. That is part of his subscription service, but you can get a free 14-day complimentary access, no credit card required. Just sign up and check out what it's about in order to get access to more of Patrick's daily commentary. You can contact them by emailing contact@bigpicturetrading.com or just visit the website www.bigpicturetrading.com.

Patrick, we're going to need to leave it there. I do want to reiterate my request to please help us out with a favorable review on iTunes as we are working to secure sponsorship for the program to help keep it free for you, the listener. Boy, those reviews go a long way to help impress sponsors that are considering sponsoring us. So please help out if you possibly can by putting a review of MacroVoices on iTunes. And of course, don't forget to register your free account at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. The benefit is you'll receive our Research Roundup Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: So this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as the link to the chart book for John Greenwood's presentation, as well as the chart book we just discussed on commodities in the postgame. There's also a link to the Market Huddle video where Kevin and I explain Charlie McElligott's gamma graphs, and a Jeffrey Snider article titled What About Copper? So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.

Now, for our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So And please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is MacroVoices brought to you by Aalo Atomics, a leader in semiconductor packaging and packaging automation. is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.

Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its Producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices dot com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Simon White — Variant Perception (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview and new premium content

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 167 was recorded on May 16th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Variant Perception's Simon White joins me as this week's feature interview guest. Simon says something's gotta give here, and he thinks the US dollar is the most likely character to take a fall as this story unfolds. We've adjusted the format of our new premium content to bring you new content on your MacroVoices feed every single weekday. The 2nd episode of MacroVoices Energy Week was released on Wednesday, May 15th, to rave reviews from listeners, and we're releasing new All-Stars interviews almost every day of the week. So keep an eye on your MacroVoices feed for more exciting new content coming your way in upcoming weeks. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, as Patrick has prepared another of his famous chart books.

S&P 500: full retrace and bear trap

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, the one thing we can say about the S&P 500 is that the volatility is back. I mean, we had a pretty ferocious rally off of that 2,800 level. What's your thinking here on the S&P?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I'm not the slightest bit surprised that we've seen a full retrace from last Friday's gap-down open. Like I said last week, this had bear trap written all over it. I think that the market was reacting to the sky is falling because of the Fed and the Fed is going to raise rates.

Yeah, I think that's a good description of the, the whole situation with China and the United States and the trade negotiation. And I think there's a lot of theatrics that are going on here. There's probably more to it than meets the eye. So now what? Back to all-time highs? Well, certainly if a trade deal actually comes together, I think that's where we could be. Given the messaging we're seeing out of the White House, it sounds like it could be a while. So we'll see what happens. But I absolutely, positively still think that the market should be moving much lower. I see signs of recession coming and late-cycle dynamics every place I look. But frankly, what the market is telling me is that it's not worried about the things that I think it should be worried about, at least not yet. Now, our good friend Brent Johnson has one of the most credible bullish arguments that I've heard yet.

He thinks the market is headed much higher, but it's not because of stellar fundamentals. Think about the, the Jeff Snider description where Jeff actually corrected me on the air. I said, Jeff, you're a dollar bull. And he said, no, don't call me a dollar bull. I'm not bullish in the sense of thinking the dollar is very healthy. I just think that for a lot of artificial reasons, it's going to move higher relative to other currencies. Brent's in a similar place. He is describing some dynamics for why he thinks the stock market in the US is going to outperform, perhaps dramatically, in coming months. I don't want to steal his thunder and describe his whole argument. His interview is coming up on Friday morning. That's tomorrow morning's All-Stars appearance on Friday the 17th of May. So be sure to check out Brent's All-Stars interview for a bullish view.

I still think the market should be headed lower, but one thing's for sure is nobody's listening to me right now.

US dollar: bullish, awaiting breakout above 98

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US dollar. Now, the US dollar looks like it's gonna take another stab at breaking out of 98. Is this gonna happen this time?

Erik Townsend: Well, the dollar chart still looks healthy to me. I'm still bullish on the dollar, but we need to see that honest-to-goodness break breakout, that, that acceleration on heavy volume of upside price movement that really confirms the thesis that I have for where the dollar is headed. And I have to admit to being surprised that we haven't really seen it yet, and that causes me to want to at least re-examine my view.

And frankly, I have re-examined it. I'm still bullish, but I do think that I haven't really seen what I was expecting. It's time to at least think about opposing views and try to weigh them. Well, look no further than today's feature interview with Simon White. Simon has the opposing view. He thinks the dollar is done here. So let's give a listen to that coming up in the feature interview.

Crude oil: inventory build vs geopolitics

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil here because getting at least a little bit of strength here today as we're recording. What's your take here on the next direction for oil?

Erik Townsend: Well, I think the big upside today is entirely about geopolitics outweighing what was actually yet another big inventory build. Normally that would've been bearish, and of course, Why are we seeing the price go the opposite direction? Well, it's because of so many things going on, almost too many to mention between the Saudi tanker attacks and everything else. We did the full geopolitical review on the 2nd episode of Energy Week, which is free in your MacroVoices feed. So I'm not gonna spend time now going over all of that. Listen to the energy show if you want the full details. Briefly though, the EIA report, crude oil building 5.4 million barrels.

Patrick Ceresna: Wow.

Erik Townsend: Really big build on inventory, normally a very bearish signal. But as soon as that print came out, the market actually started moving higher. And I think the reason for that, at least initially, was as big as a 5.4 million barrel build on inventory is, it's not as big as 8.6 million barrels, which is the number that API, the private agency, published on Tuesday afternoon.

Cushing, Oklahoma, building 1.8 million barrels. Great big build at Cushing, Oklahoma. Gasoline drawing down 1.1 million barrels and distillates building 84,000 barrels. So the tape action was up particularly on RBOB gasoline. That was the the one place where the inventory number was a bullish indication on top of all of the bullish geopolitical indications. In the case of crude oil, really the inventory numbers were very bearish, but it didn't matter. It was trumped by larger geopolitical forces in the market. Now what not many people noticed is U.S. production ticked. down again to 12.1 million barrels, down another 100,000 barrels. That's a second downtick in a row in as many weeks. And remember, these big 100,000-barrel-at-a-time ticks, you know, the EIA is rounding everything to the nearest 100,000. Normally it takes a few weeks to, to get to the next tick level. We're coming from 12.3, which was an all-time record for U.S. production just a few weeks ago. All of a sudden we're only 2 ticks below that at 12.1.

That's not long enough for it to be a trend yet, but boy, this is something to pay attention to because the rig count has been declining, and that's caused some people to say, okay, that's it, the shale boom is ending. You know, rig count's declining, it's not that economic anymore, shale is going to be dramatically decreasing, US production is going to crater from here and fall apart. Other people are saying, well, no way, that's not true, the US production has gotten more efficient, they need fewer rigs thanks to pad drilling to produce and create create even more wells. It's not going down, it's going up. Well, of course, the production data is what's going to tell us who's right. We haven't seen a big enough change for it to be a trend yet, but you definitely want to pay close attention to what happens to US production in coming weeks. Imports, 7.6 million barrels per day. Exports, a massive 3.3 million barrels.

That's 23 million barrels of US oil exported on the week last week. What's really clear, Patrick, is the market wants to move higher as geopolitics political issues escalate. Well, how much more escalation do we see? Of course, you got to watch the news feed for that. Time will tell, but it's very possible that we could be headed back up to take out that recent $66 high on WTI.

Gold: breakout or fake break

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, Erik, let's move on to gold, because at the start of the week it looked like gold was going to attempt to break $1,300 and potentially, uh, buck the dollar trend and, and actually give a go on the upside. But it's been fading off $1,300. What's your, uh, take here on

Erik Townsend: Well, gold is doing exactly precisely what I expected it to do. But wait, there are multiple explanations possible for what it's doing. Let's take what might be the, the most obvious explanation. You see a well-established downward price channel. As you hit the top of that channel, the resistance level, you see a breakout on heavy volume. Well, that's about as bullish of a technical indication as you can get. So So expectations should be that what you see is that breakout, there's a little bit of a cool-off period. What usually happens on a breakout is the market will come back down and test what was previously resistance as support. And then when you test that support, it eventually moves much, much higher. So that could be what's happening. We're already back down to the trend line at about $1,285, $1,286 So per that logic, right here, right now at $1,286 This is your buy signal. This is the moment at which, per that logic, you ought to be buying gold hand over fist, expecting this big breakout to continue.

But that's not what I think is happening. Scenario number 2 is this is a fake break based entirely on people panicking over all of the China trade war headline news. So you have to understand that gold is not only a risk hedge in the sense of people worrying about big bad things going wrong in the world, But gold is also one of the tools used by wealthy corrupt Chinese to smuggle value out of the country because they have capital controls and you can't directly take the currency out. So I think that gold broke out for exactly the same reason that Bitcoin broke out. It's one of the tools that corrupt Chinese government officials use to smuggle money out of the country so they can buy high-end condos in Vancouver.

I don't think it's going to last because I think that the breakout was based entirely on The sky is falling over the China trade war stuff. Now, if the sky really is falling and the US is about to go to a shooting war with China over trade, well, then obviously both gold and Bitcoin are probably headed much higher. I don't think it's gonna go down that way. I think it's a fake breakout, and I think when people realize there's a lot of theatrics and kabuki theater here, but it's not really as bad as the headlines might have made it sound, then I think that the price is gonna collapse. And you know, Patrick, when you have a bullish technical analysis indication like a breakout on heavy volume, Mm-hmm. that later reverses and turns into a fake break, that becomes an extremely bearish indication. And Patrick, I think just maybe that that is exactly what's about to happen. We see a daily close below $1,285 below that prior resistance line, we're back into the price channel, and it's a quick trip down to the bottom of the price channel, much lower.

Time will tell, I could be wrong.

10-year Treasury yields: buy the 2.60% dip

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields because, uh, we hit 2.35% on the yield again and before it did a quick little reversal earlier today. Where are yields going next in your mind?

Erik Townsend: Well, remember folks, just a couple weeks ago when we retested 2.60% after the Fed surprised on the hawkish side, I said on this program, okay, look folks, right here, right now, this is your opportunity to buy the dip for bonds. Buy this 2.60% because I think we're headed lower in yield. Well, sure enough, that was right. Now, I think we're still headed lower in yield from here, but we've just seen a really big move in a short time. Another pullback is quite possible. So I think you're maybe a little bit late to the party to be jumping in now at this point on the long bond trade. But, you know, if there's another test of 2.60, I'll be looking to buy. I think that we're— we are headed lower in yields, and I think that when you see these brief spikes to higher yields, it's buying opportunity for bonds for sure.

Sponsorship search, donations and why not Patreon

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik, we've been getting rave reviews from our listeners who love the new content, both the new short-form All-Stars interview and the new Energy Week show. Now, before we move on to the feature interview, please give us a quick update on your efforts to secure sponsorship for the new programming so that we can keep this free for our listeners.

Erik Townsend: Well, we're off to a fantastic start, but we still need your help, folks. I'm really committed to being selective and finding sponsors whose products and services our listeners might actually enjoy learning about. We've already said no thanks to a couple of sponsorship offers from companies whose services I felt were not a good fit for our audience. And we're finally starting to hear from some really good matches. For example, Patrick, just this morning I got an inquiry from a guy running a FinTech company that puts investors in private companies in touch with accredited investors. Now, Patrick, that's a perfect example of something that fits our audience profile. Some of our audience might be very interested in that. Some might not care, but at least it's an appropriate service that matches our audience. It's not somebody pushing whole life insurance or variable annuities or whatever else it might be. So we're making progress, but we still need your help putting the word out.

The only way we're going to find sponsors whose products and services are truly a good fit for our audience is with the help of that audience. So please think about who you could reach out to in your network to suggest that they consider sponsoring MacroVoices. We really need your help. But the biggest surprise for me was the number of people who actually expressed disappointment that we're steering away from a paid subscription business model. Quite a few listeners expressed frustration about this on Twitter, saying they were happy to pay for MacroVoices and had no objection to doing so, and wished that we would just start charging them for access to our program.

I guess, Patrick, I haven't been clear in the past, but we absolutely do very, very much need and appreciate your donations. That's the best way for listeners who value the content that we offer to supply the bridge funding that we need right now in order to keep bringing you more content while we're working to secure longer-term corporate sponsorship. We already got more than half a dozen $100+ donations in the last week, and we tremendously appreciate our listeners' generosity. The money you donate now will help us to keep expanding the content even before we secure long-term sponsorship. So for those of you who love MacroVoices content and want to help, please use the Donate button on MacroVoices.com. Now, quite a few of you are still asking us why we haven't set up a Patreon page to accept donations.

Look, folks, with all due respect to your generous intentions, the candid answer is because Patreon is not an intelligent way way for us to accept donations. Patreon is designed to help people who don't already have a website capable of processing credit card transactions. They take an 8% fee off the top, and it's more than 10% by the time you add in their other fees. That makes perfect sense for people who can't process credit card donations on their own, but it makes no sense whatsoever to throw away 10% or more of your donation on transaction fees when you can use the donate button on our homepage at MacroVoices.com. to make your donation, which we will then receive in full. So if you're inclined to donate, thank you, but please do it with our existing donate button and understand that Patreon just isn't a sensible way for us to collect donations.

It doesn't match our business model.

Why Simon White: setting up the interview

Patrick Ceresna: Well, thanks for the update, Erik. So this week's featured interview guest is Variant Perception's Simon White. So Erik, why did we invite Simon back on

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, something that's always impressed me about the Variant Perception guys is they're data-driven. They work from leading indicators, and they have excellent graphs and charts. So they're not just pitching a sentiment message about what they believe in. They're talking about what the data is showing them, and they back it up with the graphs and charts that show the data. And I think that's exactly what we need at a moment in markets when, frankly, there's a lot of sentiment that's running a little bit out of control in some cases. So I'm really looking forward to hearing what Simon has to say. about this market.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik's interview with Simon White is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Variant Perception's process: leading indicators

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Variant Perception's Managing Director, Simon Simon's got a fantastic slide deck for us, as Variant Perception always does. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered yet, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com, look for the red button that says, looking for the download. Simon White Simon, before we dive into the equity market, I know you guys at Variant Perception have a slightly different way of approaching markets. So let's start by doing just a quick summary of the process that you use at Variant Perception to approach and analyze markets.

Simon White: Sure. And thanks, Erik, and thanks for having me on the show again. So as you say, I think what we try and emphasize is it's not so much what you think, it's how you think is very important. So the slide deck you mentioned, we have a very quick diagram there that I think really covers it. So we really tried to focus on leading economic indicators because they tell us where things are going, not where things have been.

And we use these to forecast turning points.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Simon White: And through these turning points, we basically look at markets, but we look at markets through the prism of valuation, sentiment, and momentum. And then we try and look for the biggest mispricings to try and find the best trade ideas. So that's the really kind of succinct version. The aim is to really come up with actionable ideas and using leading economic data to try and find those ideas.

US growth slowdown and inflation outlook

Erik Townsend: Let's go ahead and dive in then with that context to markets, US equity, bond markets, and so forth. Give us the high-level overview. We've heard a number of different views on this program. Some people think we're just getting started here and have much higher to go. I think you may have a different view.

Simon White: Sure. I think what we're looking at today really is, we have— 2019 has really been a bit of a conundrum. 2018, it was equities that were pricing in a recession towards the end of the year. Then in 2019, it was the bond market that was pricing in a recession, while equities made one of the fastest recoveries that we've ever seen. Out of a bear market.

Today, what we really have is that all of the main assets, equities, bonds, and the dollar, they're all up in the year. That's something that's fairly unusual. That behavior is consistent with the US experiencing world-beating disinflationary growth. The thing is, from our perch, we find next to no support for this in the data and in the economic leading indicators.

The first thing that we've been hitting upon this for some time now is that US growth growth is set to slow. So we have our main leading economic indicator for the US, and that's been turning down for some time now. Now that tries to give a 6-month lead on where we think growth is going to go in the US, and almost all inputs to that indicator have been contributing negatively.

And if we look at just across the economy, we're seeing slowdowns in housing and autos manufacturing, which are obviously, you know, fairly interest rate sensitive And especially manufacturing, you know, that's kind of on the front line, if you like, for what's happening in the rest of the world. And we're also seeing tighter bank credit conditions as well. So I think there's a number of signs that suggest that we're sort of entering the beginning of the end of the credit cycle in the US.

And the other thing to note is that this disinflationary part, we don't see inflation as kind of gone for good. We definitely don't fit into the camp of, you know, your inflationists, your deflationists, that kind of, you know, long-term kind of view on these things. I think you need to be more kind of practical and more cyclical.

And the current lull in inflation, I think that was well telegraphed by leading indicators. You had the rise in the dollar, and you had the fall in oil prices. But this lull is temporary, you know, and we expect to see inflation heading modestly higher this year and into next year.

Dollar topping: flows and hedging costs

Erik Townsend: Simon, I have a question for you about, you know, you say here on slide 4, something's got to give. And I certainly agree with you. I'm trying to figure out what, and I'm amazed that we've seen so much resilience in the stock market. As you say, Simon, the bond market is stretched at least as much as the stock market. And it makes me think about this view that a number of people have expressed that maybe what's going on is, as other markets around the world are weakening, which they clearly are, maybe international investors are looking to US stocks, not because they love the market, but because it's, it's the lesser of evils. Do you think that's part of what's led to all this strength in the stock market, which has certainly caught me by surprise?

Simon White: Yeah. I think that could be something in the certainly in the shorter term. I think that really the story for last year, which has kind of lingered on to this year, was the U.S. was if you like the main kind of growth cylinder, and that was outperforming the rest of the world. And you know what we're trying to do is really trying to obviously see where we think things are going. So we still think that's kind of like that's yesterday's thing, and it's today's thing, but it's not really tomorrow's theme. And the reason behind that is first of all, as I already mentioned, we're seeing this sort of slowdown in the US gather pace. Now, it's from a high level, but it is beginning to gather pace. It's becoming deeper and it's becoming wider across the economy. But at the same time, our global leading indicators— so basically, we try and track a number of economic and liquidity leading indicators that look across the globe. Now, they've been flagging a global slowdown since kind of, I would say, mid-2018.

And what we've started to see with these indicators is they began to bottom, the very beginnings of a bottom, and look like they're about to turn up. So I think really what the next thing is going to happen is you're basically going to get rest of the world growth, if you like, is going to stop falling and begin recovering from a low level at the same time as US growth is beginning to gather pace.

And that combination should lead to outperformance of rest of world versus the US in terms of equities. And that also is one of our, you know, our strongest things that we're looking at, makes the dollar rally very hard to continue. So we see the dollar is basically in a kind of topping process right now. And one of the reasons really for that, it being able to struggle to go significantly higher from here, is that kind of re-rotation back towards rest of world outperformance. It's not to say the rest of the world is going to be doing extremely well, well, it's very much a relative idea. And actually, when it comes to flows, actual flows, if you look at slide 5, the left-hand chart, we have the dollar index versus net portfolio inflows. This is using the Treasury data, and they've actually been turning down.

And, you know, there's been a number of reasons for this, right? We have had— the Fed has basically had this very significant pivot, and they have manufactured lower real interest rates. So you have lower real interest rates in the US, US, which at the margin should lead to less capital inflow. There's less attractive reasons for capital going in there.

And the other thing really comes down to the rise in interest rates that we've already seen. So that's caused FX hedging costs to significantly rise. So one of the big parts of capital inflows is bonds, and bonds tend to be FX hedged. You know, you buy a bond generally for income, not for capital gains. So you need kind of stable income, therefore you tend to hedge the FX.

But because the FX has become very expensive to hedge, the net pickup on essentially buying for Japanese, say, or European investors to buy US debt has been negative. So they've kind of largely kind of left the market, or more so that they're certainly buying fewer US securities than they were before. Now, there has been some anecdotal stories of people basically throwing in the towel and buying unhedged. Now, not only is that probably, you know, a longer-term recipe for disaster, It also means that when the unwind comes, you're going to have people that have unhedged positions that they need to sell, which will have an even more dramatic effect on the dollar and taking the dollar weaker.

Erik Townsend: Now, when markets slow down, everything we know historically about markets is that when the economy is slowing and moving toward recession, usually that means bond yields go down, bond prices go up. But we have a different environment. Usually, when you're in those circumstances, bond prices are already depressed, yields are pretty high. Lots of room for that money to move into the bond market. Is the money going into the bond market even at these lofty levels and low interest rates that we're already at?

Simon White: Again, the data doesn't support it. Going back to the chart I mentioned on slide 5, the left-hand side, that's net portfolio inflows. Portfolio inflows are equity and bond flows. There has been some pickup lately. As I say, that could potentially be unhedged flows, but there really is, as I say, a deterrent.

The marginal buyer basically of US debt up until about a couple of years ago was essentially foreign central banks. So they were the ones who were the marginal buyer of US debt. But they, by definition, don't hedge the positions. They're managing currency pegs, so they don't hedge the positions.

Since the dollar started to rally, that took pressure off these guys to manage their pegs. And then the marginal buyer went to other foreign buyers, but not central banks. And these guys are sensitive to hedging costs. So, you know, I Often, you know, I pick up bits of, if you like, anecdotal information. You see, oh, Japan's picked up, it's buying, you know, German banks are buying, whatever it might be.

But often when you go in to look at the data, you see the pickup is actually very marginal. So there isn't really at the minute any significant inflows to the US either through bonds or through equities. And I think that's another reason, as I say, keeping the lid on the dollar. There's certainly quite a few dollar bulls out there positioning. If you look at the speculative positioning and the commitment of traders People are net long the dollar against developed market FX, but we haven't had that follow-through. We haven't had that follow-through, and that one of the big impediments is the rise in LIBOR and the concomitant rise in hedging costs that have gone with it.

Something's got to give: bonds, equities, dollar

Erik Townsend: Okay, Simon. As we move on to slide 6, what I'm struggling with, you're saying here that US equities and bonds and the dollar have all been up. If something's got to give, what do you think is going to give? Because we can't see stocks, bonds, and the dollar all continue to go up. to appreciate indefinitely. What's going to give and why is it going to give?

Simon White: Yeah, as you say, it is a very unusual circumstance. So, you know, as I mentioned, I think that the dollar looks capped. Many different reasons why I can't see the dollar continuing much higher from here. Bonds are also overvalued on some measures. I mean, you have today, obviously, the latest trade tensions have pushed yields even lower. And now you have the 10-year is now a few basis points lower than the effective Fed funds rate.

But, you know, we also see that bonds are overvalued on our own fair value model.

So if we go to slide 6 into the left-hand chart, what we've done there is we've tried to build market-based inputs. So we have the dollar, gold, oil, the Fed funds target rate, and we also use speculative positioning to try and come up with a fair value for the 10-year yield. Now, it's not really a prediction of where we think the actual 10-year yield will go, but the information content really comes is when you have a very wide gap between where the fair value is and where the actual yield is. And that's basically what we have today. And that really tells you what the direction of travel is going to be. So, you know, from that perspective, US bonds look overvalued. But in the shorter term, we have these trade tensions that are driving bonds higher. And also, if you look at the seasonals for bonds, the seasonals for bonds are very positive over the summer. So I think bonds could continue to stay supported in the short term.

When it comes to equities, now, inflation outlook, as I mentioned earlier, we think inflation is going to pick back up soon. And that also makes it hard for us to justify much higher equity valuations. So if we look at the middle chart on slide 6, there's something called the rule of 20. And that basically says that 20 minus the inflation rate should be the sort of fair value for the S&P P/E ratio. But, you know, rising inflation should being that that multiple is based— are biased slightly lower. So again, if you look at longer-term relationships between the cyclically adjusted price-earnings ratio, it tends to fall as inflation rises. So, you know, in many different ways, I think we see equities as kind of at best fairly valued. So the PE multiple is probably biased lower. At best, it will probably stagnate. Also earnings, we see many sort of headwinds for earnings, you know, our wages leading indicator points to higher wage wages over the rest of this year, that's going to be a real problem for, for earnings.

You can also look at, for instance, just simple relationships such as the ISM new orders. When that tends to go lower, as it is today from the manufacturing report, that tends to be a headwind for earnings. So, you know, it's really difficult for us to justify where equities are today, but, you know, momentum obviously can carry stuff forward, although in the very short term we are seeing, you know, obviously some, some kind of flux here.

So overall, we basically need to say either a big change in our leading economic indicators, or we need to see equities, bonds, or the dollar, one of them beginning to sell off. That basically is something that we're looking at today. I think overall, I think it's the dollar is the one that's probably the most vulnerable. That's because we can attack that from many different angles, and we can see from a flow perspective, from a growth differential perspective, and from a hedging perspective, It looks to be the more overvalued, but that's not to say it's going to sell off significantly. I think it's going to be a modest sell-off, whereas bonds, I think, can carry on rallying in the short term.

As I say, equities, you have so many people that are still potentially offside, you have the potential for a quicker recovery there.

Dollar liquidity squeeze vs fundamentals

Erik Townsend: Simon, something that's fascinated me about the people I've had on the program who think the dollar is moving higher is they don't want to be called dollar bulls because they're not bullish the US economy. They're not bullish the US dollar as thinking it's the greatest, strongest most wonderful currency ever. They're saying they think there is an international dollar short squeeze, that there is a demand for dollars on international markets that's not being satisfied, and that that is artificially creating this move higher in the dollar. So give me a little bit more perspective on the reasons that, uh, obviously you guys don't see it that way. You think the dollar has plenty of room to move lower here, even in the face of that international squeeze in dollar liquidity? I know Variant Perception does a huge amount of analysis on liquidity specifically, so you guys have to be looking at this.

How do you juggle the importance of dollar liquidity versus actual dollar fundamentals?

Simon White: I think that's a very good question. And again, it comes down to, I guess, how we look at inflation. You know, as I mentioned earlier, you tend to have people that are inflationists and deflationists. And then tend to kind of pick and choose the sort of data points that suit whatever view they have.

You know, we always try and be much more data-driven and much more agnostic. And when it comes to the dollar, you know, I certainly would never classify us or, you know, being dollar bulls or dollar bears. It's very much a cyclical thing.

But the other thing that you mentioned is always a structural part of the dollar market, and that is the fact that there is a very large structural short. So in times of heightened kind of macro tension, if you like, there will always be a need for dollars. You know, you have this huge amount of offshore dollar liquidity. So if you look at basically the amount of offshore dollar credit, so that's debt and loans, it used to be something of the margin of about $3 trillion, maybe 15 years ago. It's now close to like $10 trillion. Dollars. So you have this huge overhang, if you like, that anytime any kind of the economy, or certainly from a global economy perspective, like we're seeing today with the trade negotiations, hits the buffers, there's always this natural kind of scurry for dollars. It's the same, I guess, it's like, you know, my views or your views or anyone's views in the economy are basically subject to the proviso that, of course, this would all be different if the economy went into recession.

Recession. We try and obviously predict when recessions are. And that's something we've obviously done a lot of work on. But the same thing with the dollar. So obviously, you know, we hit like the— had a global kind of macro kind of upheaval, say, on the back of trade, the trade war really spiraling out of control, then of course, the dollar is going to rise.

But outside of that structural thing, the cyclical things keeping it capped right now, and I think that's why it's struggling to rally, is this rotation back away from the US towards the rest the world. That will mean that the dollar will struggle to rally. Real rate differentials favor— are beginning to favor the rest of the world.

If you look at the gap between rest of world growth and US growth, it's very large. It's at the point where it'll start to rotate the other way, and it starts to take the dollar with it as it goes down.

The IOER cut and fiscal dominance

Erik Townsend: Let's move on to slide 7, because something that I don't think got enough press really is the Fed in the past has primarily used the Fed funds rate as their primary policy adjustment tool. But they recently made a small cut to the interest paid on excess reserves. Why did they do that? What does it mean? And how does it fit into the overall story of what's going on here?

Simon White: So I think, I think this is very interesting. And as you say, it kind of maybe got slightly overlooked, even by Powell himself. You know, he dismissed the cut as a small technical adjustment. But I think it's really much, much more than that. And that's why it's really worth understanding a little bit more. And it really gets to the heart, I think, of much bigger theme, which is the growing tension between monetary policy and fiscal policy, and essentially the growing dominance of the latter over the former.

In essence, you know, the Fed was basically forced to cut one of its main rates to appease the government. Right. So we know that Trump and the government have made it abundantly clear they don't like high rates. And even though that the main reason for this drift higher in rates, which was directly due to government policy.

What this really represents, if you think about it, this is a clear encroachment into monetary policy by the government, and certainly not just an insignificant adjustment. I'll go into very briefly the detail here, but I mean, there's much more to this, which I suggest that your listeners maybe look into a little bit more. The chart we have there on slide 7, that shows the rate that the Fed cut, which is the interest on excess reserves. That's basically the rate that's paid to eligible financial institutions who deposit reserves at the Fed in excess of reserve requirements.

The gist of it basically is that the interest on excess reserves, or the IOER, is supposed to police the top end of the Fed funds target range. The overnight reverse repo rate is basically meant to be the bottom end of the Fed's target range. The effective Fed funds rate is basically where the rate sets each day. It's kind of a weighted average of all the trades.

That effective Fed funds rate is the one that was getting out control. And it's the one that's basically supposed to trade under this IOER. And it started to trade much over it. And this is what really prompted the Fed to cut the IOER rate in early May from 2.40% to 2.35%. And that's the first time they've ever done that outside a change to their main target rate.

And where it gets interesting really is why did this effective Fed funds rate start to trade higher. And the real reason was basically directly linked to the fiscal stimulus. Fiscal stimulus created this glut of bill issuance that caused bill yields to rise until they were higher than the Fed funds rate. And you can see that on the chart on the right in slide 7. That's something that's very unusual. And it really was mainly a consequence of this glut of bill issuance.

And that really began to pull lenders away from the Fed funds market. There's a number of different actors that are heavily involved in lending, and that's why we saw the effective Fed funds rate begin to drift higher.

Erik Townsend: Okay. Why don't we move on, Simon, to slide 8? And how did this actually happen, this collateral glut from fiscal stimulus?

Simon White: Well, yeah, basically, the Treasury had been increasing issuance, as I said, and the primary dealers were being left with more and more inventory. So that's the chart on the left-hand side there. You can see that their has risen very sharply. And, you know, this is because, as I mentioned earlier, the marginal buyer of US debt has moved from foreign central bank buyers, who are managing FX pegs, who don't hedge, to other foreign buyers who do hedge.

And you can see from the middle chart, as FX hedge costs have risen— so basically, the rise in interest rates has caused a rise in LIBOR— it's become unattractive for many foreign buyers to buy US debt. And so the primary dealers are being lumped with it. But they have to fund this. They have these bloated balance sheets. They need to fund this in the repo market.

And this dynamic is creating an acute demand for reserves, but it's not creating an acute shortage of them.

So often, if you ever hear that there's a shortage of reserves in the system, that's not strictly true. And the reason why you're seeing this acute demand, but not an acute shortage, is because reserves are not distributed evenly in the system. And it's really one bank who has the lion's shares and the single biggest chunk of excess reserves. They have about 20%, and that's JP Morgan.

And again, you can see this in action. We're always trying to be data-driven here. You can see this in action that basically when the repo rate trades above the IOER, the interest on excess reserves, this incentivizes banks like JP Morgan to lend their reserves out on repo to people who need reserves like the primary dealers.

There's also other people that are active in the reserve market like the Federal Home Loan banks, and they're also taking advantage of these higher repo rates. So the net effect is there's basically fewer reserves to lend out in the Fed funds market, and that's resulting in this effective Fed funds rate drifting above the interest on excess reserves, and that forcing the Fed to ultimately cut the rate.

Now, it's been fairly successful. The effective Fed funds rate has come down to 2.38% from 2.45%, but that's still 3 basis points above the new interest on excess reserves rate of 2.35%. But really, as I say, the main sort of takeaway here is that you've basically had a situation where fiscal policy has caused interest rates to move up, and it's forced the Fed to cut rates, when actually it wouldn't have wanted to do so otherwise. And as I say, that's a very significant baby step. But it's still significant in terms of it's the direction of travel of I think we're going to see more and more interference from governments into monetary

Erik Townsend: Simon, let's move on to slide 10.

Lending conditions, credit cycle, buybacks

Erik Townsend: Lending conditions improving in the latest survey. What's going on there?

Simon White: A very mild improvement. I think one of the reasons for the Fed's very significant pivot— I mean, it was very difficult to see exactly why they were so decisive when they would change course. But I think one of the things was in the Fed Senior Loan Officer Survey, which came out in early February for the 3-month previous period, we saw a very sharp fall in, you know, banks tightening their lending So the Fed, you know, responded to that. We obviously have been three months of the pivot. The new survey has come out, and we've seen a marginal improvement, but it's not really a huge deal. And slightly more, I guess, concerning from the Fed's perspective is that loan demand has continued to fall. So if you look at the chart on the left-hand side of slide ten, you can see that sort of latest dynamic.

And you know, bank lending is very important to the economy. You know, if you look at the middle chart here, we can see. That if we look at the net percentage of banks tightening their lending standards, that leads US industrial production.

So that's pointing to marginally lower US industrial production over the next 6 months. And this really, as I say, ties into a broader mosaic of a number of things that we're looking at that show the fact that US growth is beginning to slow. And, you know, we're always looking for multiple confirmation. And the other thing to note about lending is that when demand tends to fall for loans, as it is today, that tends to lead to lower loan growth. And you can see that in the chart on the right there. So as demand for loans fall, the supply of loans tends to fall 6 months later.

And then if we go to slide 11, if we go to the next slide, the other implications for this is we're seeing basically a broad-based slowdown in credit. So we had retail sales number was this week. It was disappointed again. I think that can be explained pretty well by this bank's willingness to make consumer loans. falling, and that tends to lead adjusted retail sales.

Another very important thing is one of the things that's kept the market so buoyant in the last few years has been buybacks. You've had these massive buyback programs. It'll be very difficult to see these continuing in quite the same way when we're coming to the end of the credit cycle. If you look at a chart basically of equity buybacks versus C&I lending, which is a proxy for credit conditions, you can see they correlate very So as the credit cycle comes to a close, if you like, we should expect to see much fewer buybacks, which is, I say, a big support for the market likely to come out.

China liquidity and trade war

Erik Townsend: Simon, let's broaden this conversation internationally now because we've been talking a lot about US conditions. I think one of the biggest fears that people have is if China were to fall apart, boy, the deflationary wave that that could send around the world could start the next big global financial crisis. And of course, with the US trade war and the negotiations and so forth that are going on, it's led to a lot of heightened worry about the Chinese financial condition. But you're showing here on slide 12 that China's liquidity is actually improving slightly. What's going on here?

Simon White: So we've been tracking this all the way through over the last year or two. And China, basically, the original reason for its kind of latest bout of tightening tightening was to clamp down on the shadow finance sector. And in that aim, they've been very successful. If you look at basically claims on non-bank financial institutions, which is the kind of epicenter of shadow finance, it's collapsed. So in that end, they've been very successful. And why we've not then seen the normal kind of V-shaped recovery in liquidity and in Chinese growth is because they're very reliant reluctant to undo that good work.

All of the liquidity and easing measures that we've seen have been piecemeal. We've seen cuts to the RRR, we've seen some interbank cuts, we've seen the buying of perpetual bonds. Again, all of these have been different to what we saw in 2016, which was what the Chinese refer to as flood-like stimulus.

They've been very explicit, they don't want to see flood-like stimulus again, because as I say, they don't want to go back and undo all the good work they've done. So we've never really was expecting a V-shaped recovery, but very lately we began to see some response from some of the broader liquidity indicators.

So one of the ones we track most closely is M1, and M1 finally began to look like it bottomed and turn up. So on slide 12, on the right-hand chart, you can see the black line, you can see that M1 has finally begun began to pick up. So we're beginning to see the very kind of early signs of liquidity beginning to pick up in China. But the key message really is not to expect, as I say, a 2016-style V-shaped recovery. I still think that some people are believing that that's what we're going to see. And I think equities were trying to price that in too. But there's nothing that we see in the data that suggests that's going to happen. And that's really basically because it comes down into the Chinese credit system is very different from the Western credit system.

Credit is not awarded necessarily by need, it's awarded by patronage. When credit is created, it tends to go into the state-owned enterprises, but they're not really the people that need it. The people that need it are the private companies, and they're not really seeing credit flow to them as they would normally under this broad flood-like stimulus. That's why we're going to have this much more stop-start And it's the— I would say the recovery in China is going to be more U-shaped or L-shaped than V-shaped.

Erik Townsend: And how does the trade negotiation play into this? If all of these tariffs that have been threatened really do stay permanent and are placed in effect, I would think that that puts a damper on any sign of China turning a corner and moving back into a growth condition.

Simon White: Yeah, I mean, that's, that's obviously another significant headwind. I mean, we were already already kind of seeing this. You know, we try and stay away from making too many comments about geopolitical situations. But obviously, I think it's fair to assume that trade tensions is a severe kind of external headwind for China. And we're basically seeing that already reflected in our leading indicator, leading indicator for growth in China, as I say, has stopped falling, but it's not really turned up very sharply. But you know, you don't even need to to be a geopolitical expert or pass commentary on what you think exactly how these trade negotiations are going to unfold.

I mean, anyone that can do that has clairvoyancy that I don't have. But, you know, we can see already in the leading data that global exports are likely to fall. So one of the best leading indicators for global exports is what's happening in South Korea.

South Korea is an excellent barometer for global trade, given its status as a small, open, export-oriented economy. If you look at South Korean export growth, it's been falling for at least the last 6 months, and that leads global exports by about 6 months.

We have penciled in for China, as I say, at best, a U-shaped recovery, maybe it's an L-shaped recovery. Depending on the severity, of course, of these trade negotiations, that could make that outlook even slightly worse. I think a lot of it's baked into the cake already. As I say, you look at the leading data, it's already pointing to a slow slowdown in global exports. I think we would need to see a real significant downturn from here for that not to have been priced into the economic data.

The main message is, don't expect a quick recovery in China, and further trade tensions will only delay that recovery even more.

Summary and emerging markets

Erik Townsend: Okay. Tying all of this together from all of the subjects that we've discussed, as you've said, something's got to give. We've got US stocks, US bonds, US dollar all at seemingly scary high levels. Something's got to fall apart. And it sounds like one that you see is you think the dollar is topping out here. And the other view, it sounds like, is for quite a few years now, we've had a situation where the US has been the cleanest dirty shirt in the pile. US has its problems, but they're not nearly as bad as other developed market economies. And it sounds like you think that that is changing. And now it will be the US underperforming other developed markets. Is that a fair summary? And I guess where do emerging markets fit into that calculus?

Simon White: Yeah, that's a fair summary. I think you're seeing this— the big theme is the rotation away from the US towards rest of world, which should mean that rest of world equities outperform in aggregate US equities. It also means that the dollar will struggle to rally much more and should sell off at least modestly.

I think when it comes to emerging markets. There's very few markets that look cheaply valued. When I say cheaply valued in emerging markets, you need to look at not only things like their standard valuations, like for instance, their CAPE, you need to look at their currency as well.

And the only countries that look particularly cheap right now are ones that are still in flux. So things like Turkey and Argentina, they do look cheap. And there may be some opportunities But given the outlook, certainly in the outlook right now with the heightened trade tensions, these are kind of very kind of high-risk, potentially high-reward trades. And we are looking for situations where we'd say we'd like to buy Turkey or we'd like to buy Argentina, but we do need to see a stabilization in the external accounts of these places. So for instance, you want to look at FX reserves, you need to see a stabilization in FX reserves. reserves. And you also preferably would like to see significant rate cuts after the big rate hikes. And we're not really seeing that in any of these emerging markets quite yet. You know, the macro environment still has heightened risk attached to it.

And that means that there's kind of no real easy pickings from our perspective, and certainly ones that are cheap in the emerging market sphere.

Variant Perception free trial and The Leading Edge

Erik Townsend: Simon, I know the charts and graphs that we've been looking at in this slide deck are representative of a lot of what use in the reports that you publish. Now, for our listeners' benefit, Variant Perception is fairly protective over their intellectual property, so we're not able to send you any free samples of their reports, but it is possible, I believe, for our listeners to get a free trial of Variant Perception service so that you can see some of the research reports that they typically distribute. Simon, tell us a little bit more about what's on offer and where people can go to find out more

Simon White: Sure. So we have, as you say, we have a trial system. That's the best way, I guess, for people to really get to know our work. I think like a lot of economic research, you need to get familiar with it. So I recommend that. You can go to variantperception.com and see the page there for— to sign up for a trial. We also have a new report called The Leading Edge, which is basically a light, easy-to-digest version of our main product.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Simon White: product focused on the US with asset management recommendations.

And there, if you— we have a special offer for MacroVoices listeners. They go to variantperception.com/macrovoices. Listeners can get the first 2 issues free and they can also sign up for the latest report.

Erik Townsend: Well, Simon, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.

Announcer: listener requests and mailbag

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: something's got to give

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, what a great interview with Simon. I really do agree with at least the first statement that they're making, that something's got to give. Like this idea that we have yields collapsing as bonds are running higher to the top end of the ranges, the dollar's at the top of their ranges, and the stock market's heading right back to their highs. That is an incredibly unnatural place for the markets to be. And one of these asset classes is going to give. And which one? I mean, I have my opinions, but I certainly agree that something in the next month or two is going to break in one of these groups. And it's going to be really interesting where that manifests itself.

Erik Townsend: Well, I agree, Patrick. I think something's got to give is a perfect metaphor for this market for all the reasons that you just described. And it definitely, you know, calls my attention to just really thinking through Simon's view because I am still bullish I'm bullish on the US dollar for all of Jeff Snider's reasons for being bullish on it. But he's right, something's gotta give. So if you don't think that the stock market's about to collapse, and I don't, I think it should, but it doesn't seem to be happening. It seems like we're going in the other direction. And, you know, the bond market, we're moving lower in yield, higher in price. Well, if something's gotta give, what's it gonna be? I don't think it's the dollar, but boy, you know, process of elimination, that certainly is a good argument.

So I'm gonna continue to ponder this view. But meanwhile, I wanna move on On to your chartbook. Listeners, you'll find the chartbook download in your Research Roundup email, or if you're not yet registered, just go to MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says looking for the downloads.

Chartbook: S&P 500 bounce off 2,800

Erik Townsend: Patrick, as I go into page 2 of your chart deck here, you told us last week, hey, if that 2,800 support level holds, be ready for the springboard action to be vigorous to the upside. Well, that's exactly what's happened. Haven't quite taken out 2,900, 100 S&P points higher Yet, but we're close. So what comes next?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, this is a really interesting moment in the market because I think the way you described gold's rally is very relevant for the S&P here. So we hit a major support and we got the bounce. The bounce had quite a bit of velocity behind it, but is it a sustainable rally? One of the most important things is to see follow-through and that the bulls are actually accumulating on that, just like what you were talking about in the gold market in the, uh, at the start of the show. Was that if the rally— after a rally like this, if the first thing that happens is they come in here on Friday and, and on Monday and they just hammer it and we give back the entire rise, that would be a really bad omen. And so, you know, I want to be really on tilt here, really want to see whether or not the bulls have enough in the tank to actually hold this gain, or whether the sellers are going to bring it right back.

Any break below 2,800 in my mind opens a bit of an air pocket floodgate, which could really drive liquidity selling the downside. So I think it's going to be a very interesting week, to say the least.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I have to agree completely. You know, as much as I probably sound like a broken record with thinking that the market ought to be moving lower, it's pretty darn clear that the tape action is pretty strong here. And it feels to me like we're headed toward new all-time highs. And I would expect that when we get there, if we get there, that will become self-reinforcing. Buying will beget more buying, and before you know it, we'll be over I don't think it makes any sense, but the more that I see, the more it feels like we're headed toward melt-up, even though on a fundamental level it doesn't make sense for me.

Gundlach charts: debt and financial repression

Erik Townsend: Moving on to slide 3, Patrick, I see that you've chosen a picture of Jeff Gundlach expressly for the look on his face, which has written all over it, I want so badly to be on MacroVoices. Please, team, hook me up. I need an interview. I, I know that's what the guy is feeling. I can see it in in his eyes. But you probably put this slide here for a different reason. So why Jeff Gundlach?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, we talked about him last week, but from the equity perspective. But really, I wanted to circle back to bonds and interest rates. And Jeff recently did his regular asset allocation webcast. So I grabbed a couple charts out of the chart deck to just speak to and just kind of get an idea of what were some of the things that were on his mind. And I wanted to have the conversation between us sort of on what my thinking is on it. So the first chart Of course, is that 45-degree angle line increase of the US total public debt outstanding. And what's interesting about this is it's a compounding line.

And what's interesting is, is that in that first decade, it doesn't matter whether it was a Democratic or a Republican president that was in office. You basically, in the first decade of 2000 to 2010, we had a doubling of the national debt. And then from 2010 till now, we've had another doubling of the national debt. And And if we see in the next decade another doubling, then we're going to go from $20 to, let's say, $40 trillion of public debt outstanding. And it's an interesting trend that we're seeing develop in there. But obviously, the growth in outstanding debt is a big concern because in chart 5, what Jeffrey Gundlach was showing was the CBO's projection as to the impact of interest payments as a percentage of GDP for the government. Right.

And it's this idea that if interest interest payments are going to be rising, it's going to have a larger and larger impact obviously on this. And this really begs the question, is this really where the crisis is? There's a lot of people that think that yields have to blow out on the upside because there's just too much debt out there. But after we had that great interview with Lacy Hunt and had Russell Napier on earlier in the year, I continue to be in that camp where I actually think that interest rates are heading down towards zero because it's the only way to make this debt sustainable. And we're going to continue to see this financial repression of managing these interest rates down to zero. We're all turning European and Japanese, right?

Erik Townsend: Well, and I can't resist but to just look to a longer timeframe for a minute, Patrick, because not only do I agree with everything that you've just said. But, you know, you can't say forever, and I'm sure that Lacy Hunt would agree with this, you can't say forever that as there's too much debt, the result is that that debt always gets more valuable because there's too much of it. But if you think about it, lower interest rates, that's really what it means, is the value of the debt, which is the reciprocal of the interest rate, is increasing. Well, at some point, you get to the point where the market realizes it's completely unserviceable, and it blows up, and you have a crisis.

And clearly, we're not there yet. Well, guess what? With all of this Modern Monetary Theory stuff coming into vogue, you've got an increasing number of people who feel that increasing the national debt from $20 trillion, or $22 trillion as the case may be, to $44 trillion over the next 10 years is probably a really good idea. And, you know, over the next 10 years, is it then $88 $20 trillion. When do you get to the point where too much debt doesn't mean lower interest rates anymore, and it means an utter collapse of value and through-the-roof interest rates? It's not until you hit that kind of third-world moment where everything's falling apart. I think we're still a long ways away from that. But if you adopt public policy based on Modern Monetary Theory, and you think it's okay to just keep growing the national debt, I think someday you run into really serious problems.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, the kind of bizarre thing is if you go and look back, let's say a couple decades ago when the national debt was $5 trillion, and at the time you suggested to people that it would double to $10 trillion, this was going to be a disaster. And, but, and that, that seemed as bizarre to people as someone today saying going from 22 to 44. It's this strange thing in compounding that we look at at it, but I think that it can sustain much longer. I mean, eventually there's going to be the day that this is all going to come to roost. But, you know, I always say that to me, the vested interest of all parties, everyone has an incentive to kicking the can down the road and keep the existing system going. And I think under a period of financial repression, we can— this can last much, much longer than most people think.

Erik Townsend: I agree completely, Patrick. Modern Monetary Theory gives us the tools that we need to spend the next 10 plus years sowing our ultimate fate. But the ultimate fate is not going to happen right away. And I think that in many ways, the trend is very much toward more openness to more debt. And I think that investors need to just take it to heart that we're going to have increasing debt levels for many years to come.

Patrick Ceresna: So on page 6, though, I wanted to talk about this. It was also one of the charts out of Jeff's chartbook, and it shows the OMB's projection of borrowing from the public from the government. And what I found fascinating here, and if I'm interpreting this right, is that this chart is suggesting that the primary deficit of the government would, by 2024, will approach zero.

Is this real? I mean, is this real? I don't envision a balanced budget on this. I don't know whether I'm reading the chart right, but is that what you interpret when you see this as well?

Erik Townsend: Well, what I interpret when I see this chart, and we've heard this from other guests on the program, is that around 2024, you get to to the point where US tax receipts can only service the interest on the existing debt, 100% of tax receipts being consumed. So perhaps what they're driving this on is that's the point where you've completely run out of credit and you can't borrow anymore in theory. Now, I think they will continue to borrow more, but no, I don't believe this. I'm sure that the chart is accurate, that OMB really said that, but is the US government suddenly by 2024 going to change its ways stop deficit spending and there's going to be a budget surplus, as this graph seems to be showing. I'll take the other side of that bet.

Eurodollar spreads and Fed cuts

Patrick Ceresna: I'll take the other side as well. Anyway, so what I wanted to move on to is on Chart 7 and talk about the Eurodollar spreads. And here I'm doing the spread between the June 2019, June 2020, which often a lot of traders use as a way of forecasting what the Eurodollar markets are suggesting is the number of rate cuts we'll get in, let's say, the next 1 year. And we continue to hover around multi-year lows in terms of them anticipating as much as 2 rate cuts over the next year. And this goes back to the conversation we had with Simon, which is that something's got to give. The bond market and the money markets continue to point toward recession and cutting, and yet we have a stock market and, and a dollar that arguably are, are sending different messages. Which one do you believe? You think we're going to see these cuts?

What's your over-under on this?

Erik Townsend: Oh, I think we're going to see cuts sooner or later, but I, I don't know what the timing is. And I think that it's going to be a game of chicken. I think the Fed is not going to panic nearly as quickly as the incumbent politicians would like them to panic.

In other words, in election year, what President Trump wants to see is for the Fed to just get accommodative starting yesterday, do whatever it takes, and just keep this economy going through the election. I think the Fed is, is in a very different position where they're sort of saying, okay, we know that when we have to cut, we're going to have to cut, and we've still got to have some room left to cut. So let's not start cutting before we have to, because we want to leave ourselves plenty of room to do the cutting when we need to do it. Let's hold out and not blow our wad, so to speak, before we have to.

And I think that there's going to be a lot of contention between the Trump administration and the Fed. And as we know, President Trump is not shy about making his feelings known.

Yield curves and the steepener

Patrick Ceresna: So, Erik, I want to move on, and I want to just look at the charts from pages 8 through 13 as a whole. And particularly starting off on pages 8 and 9, I have the yield curves, and I have the The 5s-30s on page 8 and the 2s-10s on page 9. And really what they're showing, at least initially, is that the yield curves have really done nothing in the last 2, 3 months. We've been pretty much pinned. Actually, I would argue for the 2s-10s, we've been pinned for half a year in a little range.

And what's interesting about that is that even though the yield curves have been pinned, we have seen, if you go look at the actual yields, an actual giving out of the tide on yields. Whether you're looking at the 2-year, the 5-year yield, the 10-year or even the 30-year yield, all of them have more or less dropped about 80 basis points. And so we've seen a structural decline in yields right across the curve. So that hasn't manifested in the curve changing shape much, but rather just yields right across the board declining. And, uh, whether you're bullish or bearish on bonds is one thing, but what I believe is a very realistic chance is that the fact that we've seen these 2 10s wind up the way they have on page 9, that we are very likely to see some sort of a big move in this yield curve, either higher or lower.

And this has been winding up and something's going to give. The question is that, has the little pop in the last month been the first shot across the bow, this idea that, that we're about to see a steepener kick in, particularly the steepener where we see the short end of the curve decline faster?

And that would, in my mind, come back to the Charlie McElligott piece of Fear the Steepener. This idea that once the market starts pricing in those lower interest rates on the short end of the curve and we see a steepening actually occurring, that, that actually will move asset managers away from those long-duration assets, particularly growth and growth stocks, and move to far more defensive areas and higher-yielding areas on the shorter end of the duration curve. And if we saw something like that, would that actually be truly the driver of the next major sell-off in the stock markets? And I, I think that watching this 2s-10s curve is going to be one of the most interesting things for the next month or so.

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more. And in the interest of full disclosure, I should mention that on Charlie McElligott's advice, I do have a curve steepener on the 2s-10s. And by the way, folks, Charlie has in one of his recent Letters, moved his recommended focus away from the 5s-30s steepener in favor of the 2s-10s steepener. And Patrick, I do think that it's going to be a bull steepener. So in addition to being long the 2s-10s curve, I also have an additional position in 2-year Treasuries, long the 2-year, because I think that we are going to see a Fed rate cut. I don't know when, but when it does happen, it's going to hit the 2s most immediately.

Options Education Day and Big Picture Trading free pass

Erik Townsend: And And so I think there's plenty of upside in the ZT futures, which is the 2-year Treasury futures contract.

And Patrick, as I move on to page 14, we're back to Options Education Day in Montreal. Give our listeners an update on what's going on there.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah, last week I was letting our listeners know that the show's going on. If you're in the vicinity of Montreal and you can make it out for the Options Education Day, it's held by the TMX Exchange. It's a great one-day event. Breakfast and lunch are included. Included on a, on a $50 ticket with some great speakers including myself talking about options. So any of you can make it out, the information's on the site there for— in the chartbook anyway— for you to learn more.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it certainly is hard to beat a $50 Canadian event when that includes a free lunch and breakfast. About the only way to beat that is if something is completely free, and of course the free offer is Big Picture Big Picture Trading's 14-day complimentary access pass, no credit card required. So folks, if you enjoy Patrick's chartbooks, you can get them 4 days a week, Monday through Thursday, every single day on his webinars, and you can try that service for free.

Outro: iTunes reviews and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: Just go to bigpicturetrading.com or send an email to contact@bigpicturetrading.com.

On that note, we're going to leave it there for this episode, folks, but I'm going to change up our end of show and ask our listeners to please Help us with a review on iTunes, as we are starting to look for sponsors for our premium content. Those iTunes reviews are more important than ever. We've got a lot of really good ones on there, but a lot of them are older. So, a new batch of fresh, yay for MacroVoices, positive reviews on iTunes will go a long way to help us find the sponsorship that we need to continue bringing you even more new content in Patrick, the benefit of doing what I didn't ask them to do this week would be to receive our free Research Roundup email thanks to registering your free account at MacroVoices.com. See, I've got it in my blood. I can't get it out.

What would they find in this week's Research Roundup?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview as well as a link to the chartbook for Simon's presentation and the charts we discussed in the postgame afterwards. There's also an article from Seth Levine on the opportunity for misplaced inflation, and a link to another interview with Steve Eisman. This time he's talking about a U.S. recession would spur on massive corporate bond losses. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's research roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content. with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions.

If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you Thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit bigpicturetrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. And we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice.

Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily. Narrowly reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Charlie McElligott — Charlie McElligott, who heads up the global Cross-Asset Macro Strategy Group for Nomura (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview and sponsorship plea

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 166 was recorded on May 9th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. Equity market volatility is back with a vengeance this week, so it's time to bring out the big guns. Nomura's Charlie McElligott joins me as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss the equity market situation, where Nomura's CTA model shows the key pivot levels, and much, much more. The first episode of our new MacroVoices Energy Week podcast aired this week, and we'll have more MacroVoices All-Stars interviews coming your way starting next week. So be sure to stay tuned to your MacroVoices feed for a whole bunch of exciting new content that we have planned in addition to the Thursday night podcast.

After processing a ton of listener feedback and much contemplation, we're now focusing on a slightly different business model than I described last week. I'm really proud to have brought you MacroVoices completely free of charge for the last 3 years, and we don't want to give up that heritage. So we're going to try as hard as we possibly can to keep all MacroVoices content, both the original Thursday night podcast and all of the new premium content, completely free of charge to the listener indefinitely.

Folks, there's only one way we can achieve that goal, and that's with your help. To keep MacroVoices free, we need to secure corporate sponsorship for all the new content. We know you don't want to hear screaming announcers pitching their wares on MacroVoices, and neither do we. So we're going to focus on sponsors that will be satisfied with a short, tasteful message acknowledging their sponsorship. Here's my elevator pitch to prospective sponsors: Wall Street Week with Louis Rukeyser was made possible by funding from MFS, providing mutual fund services to institutional investors.

Look, folks, I just recited that line from memory, and it was at least 35 years ago that I used to hear that one line repeated just once every single week. So, that kind of tasteful, understated marketing message really does work. And I would further argue that the MacroVoices audience would be far more receptive to that style than to conventional ad spots where professional announcers scream at the top of their lungs, hard-selling variable annuities. So, we're going to try and be selective and only take on sponsors whose services you might actually want to learn about.

But we can't be that selective without your help, folks. Podcasts are a dirty word in most marketing departments because there's literally thousands of them, some of them run by 16-year-olds in many cases. So that's the image that comes to their minds when they hear the word podcast. For those of you who work for companies that would make good sponsors for MacroVoices, or who know someone that does, we need your personal help making this happen. We need you to get your marketing director's attention. And tell them that MacroVoices is worth sponsoring. They need to hear from you that MacroVoices is something that smart people with money actually listen to every single week. That's what they need to hear, and they need to hear it from someone they trust. So please, do your part to help us secure sponsors whose products and services might actually interest our audience.

We want to expand the MacroVoices brand to bring you even more premium content, including a new show that will feature 2 hedge fund portfolio managers and 2 boutique class institutional investment advisors talking shop about actionable macro trading strategies in the marketplace. It's called Inside the Investment Committee, and you won't find anything like it anywhere else. And we want to give it away free of charge to our listeners, along with all of our other content. But we obviously can't do this without funding.

There are only 2 choices here, folks: sponsorship or a paid subscription model. Let's save the paid subscription model as an absolute last resort. Sponsorship inquiries should be sent to info@macrovoices.com, and it's up to you, our listeners, to get prospective sponsors to send us that email. Think of the time you invest in making that happen as doing your part to save all of us from a paid subscriber model. We can do it, and we can create an absolutely amazing free financial media source, but we can't do it without your help.

Thanks for your patience with the long-winded opening monologue this week. Now let's get right to the markets because it's been a hell of a week.

Market wrap: S&P 500, the trade deal and Patrick's straddle

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, you're absolutely right. It's been a hell of a week. I mean, what a change from last week to this week's episode. The S&P 500 certainly has gone a little bit of a roller coaster ride. What's your take on this?

Erik Townsend: Well, you know, after being so bearish in my outlook, I'm sure most of our listeners are expecting me to say, okay, this is the big one. You know, the S&P is rolling over. It's all over. We're headed, you know, to the 1,500 from here. I don't think so. I think that as much as we still have major, major problems, none of the problems that led to 2008 have been solved. We've got trillions of dollars of negative-yielding debt around the world. We're late-cycle dynamics.

Every place you look, we're seeing recession signals. But you know what? The market is not getting spooked by any of those things, even as much as I think it should be. The reason the market is spooked this week is because of this trade deal with China. And I think this is Donald Trump, Art of the Deal. I think these are all still negotiating games. I think there's just too much at stake for both leaders here not to let this deal happen. And I think what we're seeing is the saber rattling. They want to show their constituents that they're tough players or what have you. And I'm very much informed by the wisdom that Pippa Malmgren shared with us on this when she said, look, traders want to think that everything's about us, that it's all about markets and finance. There's a lot more at stake than just the stock market for Donald Trump and for Xi.

This is a a really big deal. It's going to define the way these leaders are remembered, and I think they both have a lot invested in making a deal happen.

Now, if it really and truly falls apart completely, sure, that could be the catalyst that leads to what I've been waiting for, which is for this market to finally roll over and to enter a serious bear market. But frankly, I, I don't see this playing out this way. I think that what's more likely is that we're going to go through some fireworks and some gyrations, and eventually it's going to play out to be a big bear trap. Now, I don't think the market should be recovering, with all of those other fundamental reasons for it not to be, but I think what's going to happen is this trade thing is going to blow over, and we're probably going to see a full retrace and maybe even new all-time highs. So, I'm happily on the sidelines here. I'm definitely going to ask Charlie McElligott whether he agrees with my view that this could be a bear trap and how he's playing it.

So, look for that in the feature interview. Meantime, we're going to have a full chartbook in postgame, so be sure to stick around for the postgame segment after the interview with Charlie when we'll go into full detail.

And Patrick, I have to assume that you and your Big Picture Trading members are doing fantastically well on your straddle trade because, needless to say, we've seen a blowup in the VIX, and that's got to just work in your favor if you're trading that straddle. Are you guys taking profits on this? Are you going to just ride it? What do you see here?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, we're certainly not taking profits on it, but we did do an adjusting trade. Actually, it's been working out perfectly. I mean, we rolled up and had the straddle up at the top end of the S&P range. And so with this drop, we've had this amazing opportunity to roll down the call and lock— I guess it's not called a straddle anymore when you do that, but we've basically locked in this intrinsic value, creating this beautiful asymmetric scenario where at this stage, if the market decides to tank in a big way, we're gonna have lots of exposure to the downside, But at the same time, we're gonna lose very little if this was to explode higher, and we're not at risk of being stopped out. So I love our position. You're gonna pretty much need a crowbar to take it outta my arms.

Erik Townsend: Well, congratulations then to you and all of your Big Picture Trading members.

Market wrap: dollar, crude oil, gold and Treasuries

Patrick Ceresna: Oh, it's not a guaranteed profit yet, but it's a great position to be in. Nonetheless, let's move on to the dollar because I would've thought with all of this chaos occurring that the dollar would've done something either higher or lower with a little more gusto. Now, we talked last week in the Chartbook about how the emerging markets are breaking down, but it's certainly not manifesting in the dollar index. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: No, you know, the dollar index chart to me, if I look at it in isolation, still looks reasonably healthy to me. We're not seeing the breakout that I expected to the upside after closing above 97.50. But at the same time, the small pullback we've seen is not giving me any reason to get, you know, outright bearish either. I think that we're seeing this market not break out as quickly as I had originally expected. But I don't see any reason to turn bearish.

The one thing I would say is the dollar-yen, if we look underneath the dollar index at the dollar-euro, which is the most important pair, and the other dollar pairs that make up the dollar index, dollar-yen chart is not looking great. So, if I was looking for a reason to be bearish, I wouldn't be yet, but I would be watching the dollar-yen chart carefully in case it's a sign of further weakness to come. But I really think that, you know, what we're seeing is more consolidation.

I definitely do take pause because I thought that breaking 97.50 to the upside was going to beget more buying and that we would see a self-reinforcing virtuous cycle that would take us closer to 100 on the dollar index. That didn't happen. So, that causes me to reflect on, on the view that I've had and why I've had it. But I definitely don't see any reason to be bearish yet.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to crude oil because crude's been relatively weak, but it's not exactly accelerating to the downside. We're still north of $60 on WTI. What's your thinking here on crude?

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I'm going to start with a quick housekeeping note, which is we always welcome our listener feedback. Twitter is the best place to make that feedback about the format of this show. We just launched MacroVoices Energy Week, which is a full-length podcast entirely about the energy market. So, our listeners that are interested have already heard that and maybe don't want to hear my full-length crude oil report. So, I'm going to try to shorten the weekly crude oil reports up now that we have a podcast dedicated to the topic. But I certainly I welcome feedback on that.

But let's come back to the actual crude market, Patrick. It's a mixed picture. You know, we've seen some downside, but so far that 200-day moving average is holding pretty well. Both WTI and RBOB gasoline are flirting with their short-term moving averages, but this time they're testing them as resistance where they had just broken through them as support a little over a week ago. My bearish view was based on a trend, Patrick, of bearish inventory reports.

Patrick Ceresna: Hmm.

Erik Townsend: 5 of the past 6 weeks' inventory reports were unexpected builds on inventory, a bearish signal. And I thought that that trend was the reason to expect further price downside.

One week does not make a trend, but this week's inventory number was a surprise in the other direction. EIA reporting a drawdown, not a build, but a drawdown of 4 million barrels versus API having reported a 2.8 million barrel build. And the consensus expectation was for about a 1.9 million barrel build.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: Cushing, Oklahoma was able to print a build of 821,000 barrels. Gasoline drawing down 596,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 159,000 barrels. Now, this was obviously a very bullish report, a great big drawdown in crude oil along with drawdowns in finished products in a week where everybody was expecting a build on crude oil inventories. But still, the immediate tape action was fairly muted given the extent of that bullish surprise.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: U.S. production ticked down by 100,000 barrels to 12.2 million barrels. Remember, 12.3 million barrels last week was an all-time record high, so we're only just one tick below that. Imports, 6.7 million barrels per day, 46.9 million barrels on the week. Exports, 2.3 million barrels per day, or 16.3 million barrels on the week. Again, one week does not make a trend, but this certainly was the first inventory report that gave us a very bullish signal. A daily close over 63.30 would probably terminate the bearish bias that I've had, but there's also a chance that we could reject the short-term moving averages and go much lower.

I think this will be news flow driven, Patrick. If a trade deal really collapses completely, we find out next week that it just ain't gonna happen, it's all forgotten and it's never gonna be resurrected, well then both stocks and crude oil are heading dramatically lower. I think the more likely scenario though, Patrick, is that a trade deal does eventually I think eventually come together, even if there's a little bit of drama and made-for-public-consumption, you know, antics that go on between now and then. And I think that may be what it takes in order to break crude oil out of this move lower. And we might even go back and test the high if we get a resolution that's favorable in the trade deal. So, I think the news flow is going to drive the market.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, Erik, I'm dying to get your call here on gold, which has been pinned. I guess you can argue that the dollar I know the euro-dollar's also been really range-bound, that it's, it's not moving, but, but I would have thought that we would have seen at least something more out of gold here in the last couple weeks, but it's really kind of continues to hover around this, let's say, $1,285 area. What's your take here on gold?

Erik Townsend: Well, as I see it, the test of $1,292 this week was a perfect test of the very trend line that I described on last week's show. It exactly matches the, the top of the channel, so we're hitting the channel resistance line. It was rejected fairly aggressively, and there was another test that failed a little bit lower. So, right now, channel resistance is holding, and it's holding in an environment where, you know, we don't know what's happening with trade and so forth.

Now, certainly, if the trade deal collapses and there's fear of maybe an escalation of this, a disagreement between leaders turning into some kind of military conflict or something, gold goes through the roof to the upside, no doubt about it. But I think the more likely case is the trade deal gets resurrected That fear comes out of the market. And then where are we? We're right on the top of the channel at a resistance line, which is being rejected already. So as we get confirmation that the trade deal really is okay after all, I would expect gold to drop from here as the dollar moves higher.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yield because the yield just keeps weakening. I mean, we're almost back down to those March lows. We're still around 2.45 here. But what do you think's the next direction here in yields?

Erik Townsend: Well, we moved something like 8 basis points lower just today. So, we're definitely moving quickly here. The thing is, there are so many nuances to both the outright aspects of which way should either end of the curve go, and then, of course, the curve trades themselves in terms of curve steepeners and flatteners and so forth. The fundamentals are overwhelmingly complex, I think. And frankly, this is one of Charlie McElligott's top subjects. So, I'm gonna leave it to Charlie. Let's just suffice it to say that I defer to his views. And let's go ahead and dive into the feature interview.

Why Charlie McElligott: the Nomura CTA model

Patrick Ceresna: This week's feature interview guest is Nomura's Charlie McElligott. Erik, why did we invite Charlie back this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, needless to say, volatility is back in equity markets and we've got a very, very novel situation that traders are looking at. I don't know anybody who's better than Charlie at looking not just at the big picture fundamentals of what's going on in the economy, and he certainly is expert at that, But Charlie's team at Nomura is really good at looking at flows, what's going on, because certain classes of traders can be expected to do certain things.

And I think, Patrick, the thing that Charlie's team is best recognized for is their CTA predictive model, which basically says, okay, we know there's a whole bunch of these guys that are trading what essentially is a trend-following strategy. Based on the price action that has occurred in the market in the past, and it gives them certain trigger levels that cause them to change what their commitment is to the market, whether they're buying or selling. It happens systematically at certain price points. What Charlie's team has done an excellent job of is building a model that predicts where those price points are going to be, and they've just had incredible accuracy at predicting the level at which the S&P is either gonna reverse direction or accelerate a move. And they've been incredibly reliable. So needless to say, this is a week where you wanna know where those levels are.

Patrick Ceresna: I couldn't agree more. So Erik's interview with Charlie McElligott is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, Next, here's hedge fund manager Erik Townsend.

Interview opens: March CTA triggers

Erik Townsend: Joining me now is Charlie McElligott, who heads up the global Cross-Asset Macro Strategy Group for Nomura and is extremely well known for the CTA model, which predicts when algorithmic traders will change their positioning. Charlie put together a fantastic slide deck in support of today's interview. Registered users can find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com. MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, next to Charlie's picture. Charlie, it's really great to have you back on the program, especially this week. There is so much to talk about that's going on tactically with moves in the market and fears about what might or might not happen with this trade deal and so forth. But why don't we start at a high level and begin with the big picture? Last time we had you on the program, you told us to watch carefully as to what the market did in March.

You said around the beginning or middle of March, there was a risk that we might see a big sell-off if we hit certain trigger levels. We started to see that start to come true, but you also told us if we managed to get through the end of March and we still hadn't gotten closing prints below those trigger levels, that it was a setup for a melt-up. And of course, that's exactly what has happened.

So, in terms of the big picture, late-cycle dynamics and so forth, why don't you give us an update on big picture macro landscape, and from there we can start to go deeper into this week's tactical issues.

Bull steepener to bear steepener; curve trade on ice

Charlie McElligott: Absolutely, Erik. I would say that the kind of the 6-month worldview into March is important to set the table here because, as aligned with my kind of core thesis last year, was starting last summer, this view that the yield curve was going to And depending on the catalysts, it could be both a bull steepener and a bear steepener, meaning that the curve is steepening while Treasuries are rallying, or the curve is steepening while Treasuries are selling off. I would say that the best setup for the bull steepener, which was that October through March window, was the fact that my long-held view that the market smelled the slowdown into the back half of last year in the US, and certainly the financial conditions tightening tantrums that we went through last year. The market sniffed the slowdown before the Fed, and thus the curve began to steepen based on anticipated policy change.

Not only the removal of future hikes that had been priced into the short-term interest rate curve, but then ultimately going all the way from removing those hikes to then pricing in easing based on the extent of both the economic slowdown and certainly the tightening of financial conditions into Q4 of last year, and frankly, into Q1 of this year.

That was a bull steepener. And that was important because this is such a change from this perpetual decade-long flattening that we've experienced that has built— so many of the thematic trading themes and narratives have been built around this never-ending flattening of the yield curve story. What ended up happening in March, at the peak of this bull steepener, was that we had a quick scramble of negative global growth data.

And at the same time, there was a real significant capitulation within the rates complex, legacy bearish rates trades that were out there that hadn't been fully cleared out during this growth scare of Q4 and the growth scare into Q1. And that was really exacerbated, particularly, we hit the lows in Treasury yields, the highs in rates on March 27th. That last blast of rate volatility actually was driven by convexity hedgers, so primarily mortgage-backed security types of players who— those are negatively convex products.

So, you had technical factors that really created this false optic with regards to the extent of the global growth slowdown. And the crazy thing was, and thus the opportunity, was that it was happening at the perfectly wrong time. Right? It was happening at the perfectly wrong time in the context that the lagging benefits of the Chinese stimulus, Chinese easing, and Chinese deregulation was really starting to kick in.

And at the same time, the Fed was discussing more openly now this more pro-inflationary stance as part of their overall inflation strategy rethink. So, you had this setup where I saw very long capitulated into rates and Treasuries positioning. You had this really long bullish view on the overall Treasury rates complex at a time where you had a beautiful entry point into a more bearish, more pro-growth trade. At the same time, you had a flurry of data coming over the next week span, led by Chinese credit and new loan and credit social financing data. And what you ended up getting over the course of the week was a massive kick-down-the-doors positive Chinese credit impulse set of data, new loans, shadow financing, social financing, big China pumping credit, pumping liquidity in the system. And then during the same time, You had announcements of property regulation easing, which I believe we've currently discussed as being the area that matters most to the Chinese economy with regards to all the peripheral positives based around the housing industry and how important it is for the Chinese economy overall.

And then, so you have the Fed messaging changing on a more pro-inflationary dialogue back in our end of the universe. And what you ended up getting after you got that big Chinese credit growth data, you had a big set of US data, you had a big ISM beat, I believe you had some PMI beat, you had European retail sales beat, which was— Europe has just been a one-way economic surprise miss. You had some beats there. And all of a sudden, what ended up happening was this catalyst for this overshoot, and the rates market overshot. And then you had this All of a sudden awareness that, hey, you know what? We might have overshot with regards to how negative we are on the overall health of the global economy, and now we have to reprice growth higher. So, boom, pow, April became the month of the bear steepener. And as part of that thesis, I went out that a bear steepener is my bread and butter with regards to reflationary types of trades.

April was pure reflation. It was It was long TIPS over short nominals, meaning just long inflation breakevens. It was long value over short momentum within equities, synonymous, another way of saying long cyclicals, short defensives. And part of the catalyst of this whole concept was how crowded the slowflation positioning has been as a narrative within investors. So, we really wiped that out over the course of April. And then we got to last week's Fed meeting that changed the dynamic again and is causing a meaningful rethink.

Erik Townsend: Let's go a little deeper on this bread-and-butter trade. You have written quite a bit in your daily letters over the last several months about the advantages of the curve steepener, because as you've described just now, it can play either as a bear steepener or bull steepener, and there's arguments for both. So, originally, I think it was a 5s-30s curve steepener that you recommended, and in one of your more recent letters in the last few weeks, I believe that you changed your positioning to be long the 2s-10s curve. Is that still the position, and what's your outlook? How long do you see that trade continuing to, to be the bread and butter that it's been for you?

Charlie McElligott: Sure. The curve cap, which is an option basically on the shape of the yield curve, and it's playing swaps has been a great trade. We talked about it since advocating it starting last summer. The 5s-30s cash curve has tripled, gone from 20 to 60, let's say. Right now, I'm looking at it, it's 60.3 bps. So, it's been a home run. I think part of the idea with regards to— and also, too, we've seen a doubling in the 2s-30s cash curve.

This is the front end of the curve is more reflective of central bank policy. And clearly, that has inflected after what happened in January. The Fed had to catch up with the market and catch up with the deteriorating data and deteriorating financial conditions. The long end has been stickier and harder to move. And that's really the difference between the bull and the bear steepener. The long end is the part that is going to be most responsive to actual— a forward view on growth and a forward view on inflation, which is why in April, you had this narrative changer into the bear steepener, which really boosted that long cyclical, short defensives trade. And even not just short defensives, but short tech, right? Tech is a long-duration asset. Expensive growth stocks are long-duration assets because they need lower rates to justify their valuation.

The 2s, 10s switcheroo was really about a more attractive entry point and the idea that the others had participated, whereas the 2s, 10s had not yet broken out. I think the thing here too was that I really saw a massive long accumulating in the Treasury space. And The best proxy and the thing that everybody owns for that long, of course, is TY, is the 10-year future. So, I liked the fact that the 10-year in particular could reprice and make the 2s, 10s more attractive.

What I would say, Erik, that with regards to the game changer, even though it was a very incremental nuanced message, the game changer that was last week's Fed meeting has put this thing on ice for the near term. And that's because into extremely dovish expectations built into the market due to the Fed's own policy pivot starting since January, Jerome Powell came out and spoke from a much more balanced perspective. And that balanced perspective was best exemplified by his focus on transitory inflation weakness. And that move that, you know what, we're not going to be super reactionary with regards to the inflation issue that they're having, with regards to the forever grinding lower inflation, is a big part of what this repricing of growth higher, reflation type of a trade is. So, he just bought some time, But in the meantime, this very profitable bull steepener of the prior 6 months, and then this big bear steepener— and again, all I care is that the curve is going steeper, not whether it's a bull or a bear necessarily— is on ice, as I said, simply because some folks are taking money off the table, which unwinding the steepener means you're going to flatten for a little bit.

I think from here, to really tie this all up, it's going to come down to the Fed language as we head into their big June inflation symposium, where they're going to have to come out and crystallize where they stand on policy, as well as a second Fed-centric point, which is what they're going to do with their balance sheet as QE light, as I like to call it, begins in October as they take their mortgage-backed security reinvestments and begin buying Treasuries again, thus QE light.

The Fed's asymmetric stance and June symposium

Erik Townsend: Charlie, you mentioned the Fed's inflation symposium that they're having in June. Help me understand this, because as I understand the Fed's messaging, there's absolutely no problem with inflation. They've got it all under control, but somehow they need to have a symposium all about it in June. What's going on here?

Charlie McElligott: So, the Fed has announced a year-long review of policy, and the, the one part of the policy that matters right now And essentially, coming out after that January pivot from the Fed, I went out and basically said, look, the Fed has torched any misconception. They are strictly a one-mandate institution now. And that's basically the mandate has become not just a one mandate around inflation, but it's become asymmetric around inflation, meaning that the lower it goes, the more reactive they're going to be with regards to cutting, with regards to trying to stimulate inflation, than the opposite, which is much less likely to hike in the event that inflation overshoots. And that's a very big deal because the language that helped really trigger so much of that April reflation phenomenon from the guys that matter most, Clarida, Williams, Evans, taking this message too, was the idea that the trajectory of core PCE year over year is a real concern. It's a problem.

It's got to be addressed. And that's why this June symposium, it's a research symposium, is super important. One of the things actually that I think was a clue for us with regards to the future rate of where this policy is heading was that multiple speakers spoke about the potential that NAIRU is below the U-rate.

Basically, this is telling us that you need— the Fed is acknowledging that they need to run the jobs market hot and asymmetrically hot, really message forward guidance-wise that you are going to cut rates in the event that inflation slows more so than the opposite to stimulate inflation. To stimulate the Phillips Curve, and this problem of the zero bound, as we near the zero bound, and certainly the lower bound of where we are right now. So, I think that this then came out along the same time that we got the agenda for the June meeting. And about a third of the meeting is made up of labor discussions, labor working groups, labor research papers, which tells us then that at the same time that some Fed speakers are talking about looking at jobs as a vehicle, labor market as a vehicle to run, to try to play catch-up in this inflation averaging framework that everybody has spoken about from Janet Yellen to Jerome Powell himself, that then too, if you're willing to run hot through potentially cutting rates to stimulate the labor overshoot here, that that's probably where the future state will be.

And at the same time too, They even began piling on with the discussion of insurance cuts. And Clarida specifically mentioned that into a still strong economic backdrop in '95 and '96, the Fed cut rates on weakening price pressures, which is similar to where we are now, and even highlighted in '98 cutting into a still strong economy on account of external factors, which was the emerging markets crisis and the long-term capital management crisis. So, they really set the table for this asymmetric overall policy, far more likely to ease than the bar it would require for them to jump over to hike again. And that's a big deal when we're talking about not just the Fed June Symposium, but the Fed having to update both the composition of their balance sheet into QE light, meaning that our view that they're going to be buying more bonds in the front end, which steepens the curve, which is actually a catalyst for a lot of this reflationary thematic trade that we're talking about, as well as the third point, the third leg of this stool, that China is still in no position to scale back their stimulus.

In fact, and even up to the overnight data that we got, and ex any of the trade war tariff discussion, the very ugly export data again. So, they're going to keep the pressure down there, which is inherently going to be a positive for inflation-sensitives, cyclicals, things of that nature. So, I think that's the view that I want to leave with regarding the structural stuff.

This week's sell-off: gamma, CTAs, VIX inversion

Erik Townsend: Well, Charlie, I know that our listeners are dying to hear you get into the tactical outlook because it's been quite an interesting week. I can certainly say that when I saw Charlie McElligott in my inbox on Sunday, I knew something was up. And sure enough, we've seen that there was a triggering of one of your CTA levels on Tuesday, I believe. So, give us a rundown of how we got here and what comes next.

Charlie McElligott: Sure. So, obviously, as the tariff news came out, something that I had been increasingly aware of, I love to highlight asymmetries in the market and imbalances, crowding, crowding risks, especially when there's a narrative behind them. One of the things that I think we keep seeing with regards to some of the successes that we've had capturing or flagging these directional shifts ahead of time are the convergences of a few different indicators.

Particularly where we were last week was there was 2 really big observations, and frankly, recent weeks. We saw the overall scale of the market gamma position, the gamma profile, in both S&P futures and SPY ETF options. The combined gamma profile reached some serious extremes, both SPY and Q's, representing the NASDAQ side, as well as the delta in the market. And really, what this was critical for me is that when I see 99th percentile, 100th percentile gamma in the market, the next thing I do— and I know that we have extreme sensitivity to changes in underlying, let's say.

From there, when I see that point in our— using our internal estimations, when the long gamma that's been built into the market— and the long gamma is built into the market because in a trending, grinding higher type of a market, Generally speaking, you can assume that short volatility strategies are proliferating, are growing, more people are doing systematic rolldown, more people are selling condors, more people are selling straddles, all sorts of yield enhancement strategies. You can call overwriting put underwriting, you can assume that dealers are getting long gamma. The key for me, though, is where is the point that we actually inflect towards short gamma. Knowing the scale of what Trump tweeted, I knew at an approximation on where we're calculating a flip to short gamma, which means that I think most readers know, as the market goes lower, dealers are getting wrong-sided and have to actually keep selling more to maintain their hedges. That's where you can get in a short gamma environment, get these really slippery moves.

The convergence that I talked about, though, was the fact that on a gap move lower, which I knew we were going to get, generically, I finger in the air, assumed a 1.5% sell-off for the Monday, was that that gap lower was going to gap us down to where our momentum trend, CTA trend model, actually was roughly anticipating the next deleveraging levels. And when you pile those 2 factors together on top of what then becomes an almost inevitable VIX curve inversion— so for all of these people that have been shorting volatility, even though there is an offsetting long in the VIX ETN complex, the VIX curve will invert as a lot of these rolldown strategies are then forced to cover their shorts— that those 3 things converging and you're going to see fireworks. And that's exactly what happened Monday.

There was a reason on the follow-through Tuesday that we actually closed back up, that we rallied, which is not for any trade talk optimism, but instead, almost completely based around options-related behavior, both from dealer desks, people that were long VIX ETNs, that we still have a wave of systematic deleveraging, as well as a catalyst too for a very fundamental part of the universe to sell. And that was the fact that asset managers had accumulated almost $130 billion of US equity futures longs in recent months. And even in just the year to date alone, it was like $65 billion. So, they finally had this catalyst to de-risk into this event risk. And boom, you get the asset managers taking down this exposure. Boom, you trigger dealer negative gamma on the gap lower. Boom, you get the CTA trend deleveraging level, which in S&P did actually go from the +100% signal to selling down to a plus just a 60% signal.

And you got the VIX curve inversion. That's how we've driven this incredibly volatile 2.5-session environment of the past few days.

Slide walkthrough: futures volume, asset managers, CTA triggers

Erik Townsend: Charlie, for our listeners' benefit, I know as you're talking about the gamma, some of that's on page 5 and the VIX inversion's on page 9. I think we may have lost a few people on the slides there. Let's go back to slide 1 in the deck. Why don't you talk us through how you knew that this was going to be futures-driven and what you saw next, and, and just talk us through the slide deck here.

Charlie McElligott: Right, so it was this qualitative observation that for sure that we knew asset managers have gotten this trade right. They bought the dip in December. They kept loading up January, February, March, that they were going to be incentivized to take some risk off the table. So, that got this ball rolling. We knew that as part of that overall $130 billion of US equity futures length, and $65 billion just year to date alone, that that was going to drive a significant uptick in futures volume, because that's where they held the positions.

Additionally, though, is this understanding, of course, that the CTA trend per our model was going to be delevering. So, what we looked at then was this confirmation of this view, where we just took a look of the percentage of notional futures uptick versus the overall cash notional uptick. What it showed you was this 1.3 times behavior, which is the single largest overshoot, let us say, of the past 9 years. It was a 3 z-score event, which really just confirms that yesterday was about likely confirming that this was a futures-led move and that the 2 real inputs here, besides dealer gamma hedging, were the asset manager de-risking, as well as the deleveraging from the CTA universe.

The second slide captures exactly what I spoke about, the scale of that US equity futures long from asset managers. You can see some of that accumulation, which continued all the way up into this last month, still buying an additional $9 billion across S&P, NASDAQ, and Russell. So, you just knew they were long, and it made sense for them to take some chips off the table into this risk event.

The third slide, and this is what I know a lot of folks care about, and as a word of caution, these are not static. These change based on both the new price levels on a daily basis, plus the realized volatility profile over a trailing window. So, these cannot be treated as static. But you can see on that move, let's say from 2897, if you see that position column, the multicolored position column, where we went We went from, in the same span of 2 points, basically 2,897 and down, we went from that 100% signal to the 60% signal. And what you can then see, if you move back left, you see that 2-week column and that 1-month column? Those are the 2 windows of our model that flipped short.

The price momentum signal for S&P lost its strength and actually flipped short. So, that's capturing where the pain points were for the model.

And then I think this is actually one that gets people very interested. And again, snapshot in time, but it's a forward look of our trigger levels. You can see this dynamic where because of the environment, generally speaking, of a year ago, that as those days that were in our 1-year sample lookback set, drop in or out of the picture, our pivot levels change. And what you see up top, that the top is S&P, the middle is NASDAQ, the bottom is Russell, is that those pivot level numbers really jump up.

So, what that means to me is that the pressure is going to be on to stay at this lower overall signal weight for both S&P and even NASDAQ.

NASDAQ had so much wiggle room for the longest time because of the year-to-date performance and the explosive moves in tech. Even NASDAQ is now at risk of deleveraging, even if the market just holds sideways from here. And at the very bottom, you see that Russell is nearing a point of going outright short again. And for what it's worth, Russell has been a great indicator with regards to periods of volatility. So, that's just one to keep on the radar.

Tariff scenarios and deleveraging levels

Erik Townsend: Okay. So, as we interpret this chart on page 4, I want to remind our listeners, this is a moving target. You recalculate these numbers every day, and it depends on the tape action and what the price is. But all other factors being equal, if we just assumed a flat return right now, it looks like as we get about 2 or 3 weeks out, the market has to be above 2,940 or so in order for this signal not to be triggered, which would start more selling. So, do you think we're headed back up to those levels, or do you think we're going to be triggering the selling before we even get to 2 weeks out?

Charlie McElligott: So, it's really just about maintaining this current 60 level, let's say, for the S&P as our example here. The good news is that, at least from the perspective of CTAs, that for the S&P, that we've already deleveraged, and the next level to actually see more selling and actually move outright short is way below the market. So, to get there, we would probably need to see a pretty negative outcome into— by tomorrow at midnight into Friday, the reimposition of tariffs.

If it came out that talks had broken down, the tariffs are back on, in no confusing terms, the market's going to be down 2% or 3% that next day. For sure, even with this next move. And then all of a sudden, that next level of deleveraging happens.

I happen to believe that we understand how much Donald Trump loves the stock market as a weather vane of his, as a scoreboard for him. He had 500 points of S&P in his pocket since the last time he talked this up. The Reuters article today spoke to an almost disrespectful Chinese dismissal of previously agreed-to terms across the boards, across all of the key talking points, that I think he has gotten their attention. And all it takes for him is to say, look, and for him to dictate to Lighthizer and Mnuchin to a lesser extent that, hey, roll back the tariffs. Let's tell them we delay the tariffs. We're making a lot of progress in these talks. And then all of a sudden, I think we're retesting our prior highs, Even just on the idea that we're going to keep kicking the can, we're going to keep extending and pretending to get this thing right. We just needed to get them honest and get some concessions from them again.

I personally think that they will kick off the tariffs tomorrow night at midnight. I think those go through. I do think too, they will counteract that with some language about ongoing discussions, and maybe they put a limit on those tariffs. Maybe they say, We've made a lot of progress. There's a possibility that we take the tariffs off in 2 weeks or 1 month out from now. I think it's going to be a more nuanced message. And I think that's important with regards to knowing that it would take a pretty meaningful negative outcome from these events to get anywhere close to that next level of deleveraging.

The one thing I would like to add, though, Erik, and I always talk about the CTAs because that's been our bread and butter, and my view is I would say

Target-volatility funds and VaR

Charlie McElligott: that it's not simply a discussion of commodity trading advisors. It's the fact that in a post-QE world, almost any trader or fund that operates under a VaR model is a de facto risk-controlled, risk-targeting, target volatility fund.

And that simply means that your exposures, your leverage, your sizing is going to be dictated by the underlying volatility, realized volatility signals. So, So, when I talk about these numbers and these breakpoints, I'm talking about more than just CTAs. I'm talking about where the bodies lie and where things inflect and where stuff becomes painful and where things can go wrong.

There are other systematic strategies out there, though, that matter. And clearly, as I have high confidence that on a 1.90-handle downtrade in a day and a half, that these flows had shifted. Asset managers started deleveraging, CTAs began to delever part of their long, and then you also too had the VIX curve invert, which created knock-on hedging requirements, both for dealers or people short, that also bleed into S&P.

Another part of this are target volatility funds. And this might be a little bit wonky for readers, but this is almost any variable annuity This also can overlap with CTAs, with risk parity, but just to get an understanding of what that is. And if you look at S&P index 20-day realized, right? So, a 1-month lookback, which is standard. And I'd also generically benchmark the typical target volatility fund struck at a target volatility of 10.

Right now, that 20-day realized volatility is, say, 9.5. Okay. Mechanically, though, upon crossing that 10, there will be unwinding flows. And what that requires are another few days just by staying up here in realized volatility. And you can see on the day, stocks are flat, VIX is flat.

That's going to naturally drag up these trailing realized volatility levels. And that's why I still feel confident that there's probably ongoing more supply than demand type flow unless we get a positive outcome for probably just another day or 2.

Only after we clear any sort of downtrade around whatever happens with the tariffs into Friday could I then want to say, hey, let's go out and take advantage of how rich volatility is. Let's go out and sell puts, or let's go out and buy some upside calls or call spreads to take advantage of what eventually becomes a deal. So, I think we got to clear through some chop first. And there still is this flow out there, this deleveraging flow that's got to go through the system before we can then get that purge and get tactically constructive again.

Hedges now, selling puts later

Erik Townsend: Okay, Charlie. So, it seems like we've got a dilemma here because clearly, this trade negotiation is not over yet. It's not clear Even after Friday and the deadline, and who knows what happens this weekend, come Monday, it's not going to be completely over then either. At least I strongly doubt it will be. So, where does that leave us in terms of being able to put a trade on that makes sense?

Charlie McElligott: So, I think that part of what's happening right now is that, and, you know, it's twofold. From a hedging perspective, you know, you still have exposure on, you're not totally flat, you're still leaning long. I personally think that Eurodollar futures as a hedge, which are just a short-term interest rate product, meaning that you're long rates or you're long Treasuries as a de-risking hedge, still works. During this equity volatility spike, that risk parity-like strategy of long a low volatility asset like Treasuries has done its job. Plus, you get the additional kicker that the more this tariff situation devolves, if it were to do so, The more likely that the market is going to price in likelihood of an even more dovish Fed or even a rate hike. It's that same idea. Fed is cornered into an asymmetric policy. There's a much lower bar to ease than to hike. Now, from an actually playing offense perspective, and it's still too early, as I just mentioned, that right now we have to see the outcome.

We have to see that final purge. We saw the first purge and capitulation in the VIX complex. VVIX, which is volatility of volatility, was the first signal. The VIX complex went yesterday. I think any further stuff will then be the Delta One products, structured products, and things like that that were built around equities volatility notes, things like that would be the final thing to purge.

And we talked about this potential that if you get a negative message out of this meeting, you're down 2%. But I have to always look at the next move. And the next move is that right now, the market is pricing in much more crash down than crash up. And that's the opportunity. Upside skew is 3rd percentile.

Downside skew is 81st percentile, meaning really rich, like people are slapping on their tail hedges. The ratio of 25 delta put to a 25 delta call is 91st percentile. So, that's when you want to start inching closer to getting tactically offensive. And I think as it stands right now, that's probably through selling puts more so than calls.

Why short-vol blowups keep recurring

Charlie McElligott: But when this thing turns, it's going to go, and you're going to want to take advantage of this rich volatility market.

I think the one thing that I'd want to say, and I think this is an interesting way to to close the conversation is that why does this keep happening? Why do we keep having these almost quarterly, it seems like, certainly a couple times a year, short vol, easy carry momentum type environments, then we have a blowup, and then we have a V-shaped snapback?

And the V-shaped snapback, let's say, certainly didn't materialize yet today, but that last 20-point rally in the last 15 minutes of yesterday, The market was certainly that. And as I alluded to earlier, that was guys that were long vol, whether that's retail guys that were long the VIX ETNs or dealers like ourselves who were sold volatility from the buy side, or people that were short delta, so short S&P futures, either as they were dynamically hedging or even people who were trying to front-run the systematic trend inflection.

That profit-taking from those players in the last 20 minutes yesterday, was what created that big upswing in the tape. You were unwinding profitable trades. You sold some of your long volatility, and you covered some of your short delta, which just bought futures. So, that's why you get these V-shaped snapbacks.

But I think from a bigger existential, larger level, it's what I talk about often, which is this Minsky moment type of world that we live in. Stability breeds instability. And if you look at the central bank playbook post the crisis, the plan has been large-scale asset purchases and providing forward guidance on lower interest rates forever and flatter curves forever. And what that's done is that it suppresses cross-asset volatility because it's suppressing interest rates.

And ultimately, you create an intentional financial repression which drives, as the Fed likes to call it, portfolio rebalancing. As I like to call it, it's pushing people out on the risk curve. It creates that risk-for-yield behavior. So, why does stuff like yesterday happen, even though these might be largely systematic strategies? It's not some HFT brainiac quant hedge fund necessarily that's the issue here. It's really, to me, it's real money institutions have moved post the crisis from being, before the crisis, buyers of volatility and buyers of tail risk hedges, who are instead now vol sellers in this post-crisis period.

As I mentioned, call overwriting put underwriting, all systematic, all rules-based, condor, strangle selling, VIX curve roll-down, they're all doing this in order to generate yield in a world void of yield. And that's what's so insane about the world that we live in and the central bank daisy chain, where vicious cycle turns to virtuous cycle and then back again.

That's why I don't see this ever stopping, frankly, because the central bank policy has dictated this market structure. And I closed my note this morning with this quote. A buddy wrote it on social media. It's as follows. It says, if you're short vol, you make money, but eventually die. But if you're long vol, you die before you make money.

And that's kind of this current stasis that we're in right now, where you're waiting for the next shoe to drop. But in the meantime, you got to dance, you got to generate yield, you got to short volatility, you got to ride the momentum, grind higher until, you know, a central bank policy or some sort of a market accident tips everything over, and then we start again.

Erik Townsend: Okay, so to summarize, we can expect the fireworks to continue as the This trade negotiation takes whatever direction it's gonna take, that's probably going to induce more fear and uncertainty and pump up those put premiums even higher than they already are. That, when it's finally over, is gonna be your opportunity to sell those puts and maybe go long indices and ride the upside of this. Charlie, before I let you go, for our institutional listeners who already have a relationship with Nomura, which is the prerequisite requirement Tell them how they can get your daily letter because it's really fantastic. It's one of the best pieces of research. I read it religiously every day and very much look forward to it. So, who's it available to and how do they get it?

Charlie McElligott: For sure. And I appreciate that, Erik. You can reach out to your Nomura sales coverage, your Nomura Securities International, Nomura Global Markets sales coverage, and they can reach out and we can make that happen. There are certain There are certain regulatory dynamics with me being a desk strategist as opposed to a research analyst on which domiciles I can send into, as well as revenue thresholds. We want to make sure that we are incentivizing the right client behavior. People that pay for it get to read it and get it kind of hot off the press and get to interact with me.

But if those pieces are in place, make your salesperson reach out and we can facilitate a dialogue.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic, Charlie. We really appreciate it. And folks, please understand, Charlie's not being a jerk. He's limited by regulation. and factors outside of his control. Unfortunately, the letter is only available to institutional investors who already have a relationship with Nomura. Sending email to MacroVoices and asking us to give it to you won't help. Unfortunately, there's nothing that we can do about that. Charlie, we really look forward to getting you back on the program soon. Thanks so much for a fantastic interview. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here on Bloomberg. Here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer We answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: takeaways and Gundlach's view

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Charlie back on. I have so much respect for what Charlie does. For me, being any good at the markets is the study of liquidity. And for the longest time, to me, the study of liquidity was very technical-driven in terms of technical analysis. But there's an important other layer to that, which can be measured very much by seeing how offside investors and traders are on any one trade. And Charlie just does such a great job with his quant work to really size up where the crowding is and where the mean reversion is and what will drive it and what are the levels for those triggers. So, it's always a pleasure to have him to talk about What did you take away from the interview?

Erik Townsend: Well, I agree with everything that you just said, Patrick. You know, we talk a lot on this program about economic fundamentals and the reasons that certain conditions in the economy ought to achieve certain outcomes. And to some extent, there's always a connection between economic fundamentals and what the market is eventually going to do. But Charlie's team doesn't look at it that way. The way they look at it is, okay, let's figure out who's doing the buying and who's doing the selling. Selling, and what makes them tick, and what's going to cause them to change the amount of buying or selling that they're doing, and predict when that's going to happen based on analyzing the behavior of the biggest participants in the market. And that clearly is what it's all about. And of course, it's driven ultimately by economic fundamentals, but understanding who the players are and what they're up to gives you a huge amount of insight and intelligence and perspective on what's most likely to happen next in the So I just

love it each time we get Charlie on, and I've certainly encouraged him now that we have the new All-Stars format. If he ever wants to come back more frequently than we get him on for his feature interviews, he knows he has a standing invitation. But Patrick, speaking of invitations, I want to invite our listeners to download yet another Patrick Ceresna chartbook extraordinaire. You'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not registered, just go to the homepage, look for the red button that says looking for the downloads, and it should be labeled as Postgame Chartbook. Patrick, why don't we go ahead and dive in on page 2 here? We see the familiar face of Jeff Gundlach, who has a look on his face thinking, I want to be on MacroVoices. I gotta email those guys back and say yes.

Okay, what's he really thinking?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, I thought it was great when Jeffrey was just on CNBC a few days ago on May 7th, And in the interview, he basically said, just to paraphrase him, that we're late cycle. And he's looking at everything from the perspective of the evolution of a bear market. And that's very contrary to what we're hearing.

I mean, it's amazing how bipolar it is in the market. There's so many people that are either talking the super bull case, or there's those people that are really entrenched in the bear camp. And it's like only one side is going to prevail. out of this. And I thought it was really interesting to kind of get his take on that. But he kind of looks at it and says, well, look, in the last 15 months, the market has gone nowhere. And so, he flipped the question the other way and he's basically said, look, anybody wants to say, how can I say it's a bear market? Well, he turns around and says, well, how can you say it's a bull market?

I mean, year to date, the market's up. But to characterize the last 15 months as a bull market is wrong. And so I thought that was a really interesting way to start this conversation. And the conversation I wanted to have with you is, is this a big topping formation and is already in the midst of a bear market, or is this just a consolidation before the beginning and continuation of another full bull market leg?

And, and this is, I think, one of the most important questions to be able to answer in the coming weeks. Maybe we don't need to necessarily know the answer right away, but what happens here, I think this is going to be an important pivot in the markets in terms of how this plays out. So what I wanted to do in the subsequent charts from 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, the next 5 pages, is kind of go through some of the major markets and see how they've all positioned in here and really step back on the weekly bigger picture charts and try to understand Is this a bull market or is this a bear market with a big topping formation developing? So the first chart, which is the most bullish of all, has got to be the NASDAQ. And the NASDAQ has not only broken to higher highs, for a while it held at those higher highs. And really, that's where a lot of the bulls turn their attention to, that there's big momentum in these tech names is driving all of this.

But really, once you start going to the S&P and then particularly when you break it down to the New York Stock Exchange Composite Index, and then particularly even the Russell 2000, we're nowhere near making higher highs on the markets in this entire bull phase. Arguably, all you can say that the market has done is in 3 months wiped out 600 S&P points to the downside, and in the subsequent 4 months rallied 600 points to bring us back to the same level we were just 6 months ago. So, Erik, I have to ask you, what's your thinking here on this? Where do you stand on all of this?

Postgame: anatomy of a bull market and global equities

Erik Townsend: You know, great minds think alike because we're thinking about exactly the same question. And there's a big part of me that wants to say, look, it's got to be a topping pattern. Maybe it's a long extended topping pattern. Maybe it's a topping pattern that's still going to bring us more all-time highs before it's over. But if you look at what's happened since the beginning of 2018, As Jeff Gundlach says, it's definitely not a continuing bull market, or if it's a bull market, it's at least on pause.

Now, the thing is, Patrick, as much as I really want to believe that, and as much as I agree with all of our guests who have said, look, late-cycle dynamics, recession signals, there's lots of reasons to have concern here. The one thing that just keeps hitting the, the back of my head is the anatomy of a bull market usually is the final phase is the blow-off, the 1998 to 2000 period, where against all the smart guys in the room saying, this is crazy, these valuations don't make sense, this is nutso, the market just goes straight up anyway. And eventually you get to that blow-off top, and then, you know, the higher they climb, the harder they fall. You get a crash after that. We haven't really had that insane up phase.

Yeah, the end of 2017 going into that early 2018 top, had a lot of bullish exuberance, but it wasn't really hyperbolic crazy blow-off top. And if it had been a blow-off top, we wouldn't have seen the move to new all-time highs. So it makes me wonder if there is still room, if we do get to new all-time highs, if it becomes self-reinforcing and we get a hysterical mania-driven move to a blow-off top. Now, I say hysterical and mania-driven because as far as I'm concerned, there simply is no valid fundamental reason for stocks to be as high as they already are, never mind moving higher. But if I look at how bull markets tend to end, this hasn't really looked like the ending story of most bull markets. So I wonder if there's one crazy leg higher before it's all done.

Patrick Ceresna: You know, Erik, where I will push back on you a little bit on this scenario is going back to 2000. Now, 2000 had a blow-off, but it was a tech blow-off, and the NASDAQ doubled in price in the final phases. But when you actually look at the S&P 500 and you see what the S&P 500 did from November of 1999, it made a high, made a little bit of a higher high on March 1st of— on March of 2000, And then just retested the high again in September of 2000. And all it ended up doing for 15 months was an extended topping formation. And it was only the NASDAQ that blew off. And so the thing is, is that, is it the expectation that the Dow and the S&P were going to do this blow-off? Or is it just a segment of the market that defines the hysteria, maybe the IPO market and other things that have this blow-off, and maybe that we won't see that blow-off in the broader market.

Erik Townsend: Well, okay, let's go back to your NASDAQ chart then on page 3. Look at the— what everybody who's looking at the S&P and saying it's topping, look at what it was doing at the end of 2017, beginning of 2018. Yeah, you had what looks like a perfectly normal consolidation and a very quick move, much sooner than the S&P. To new all-time highs in the middle of 2018. And yes, we saw the sell-off in the end of 2018, but already in less than the first half of 2019, you know, there we are again at a new all-time high. This last weekly candle looks pretty ugly, but you know, we've got this trade deal thing that supposedly, at least in the public consumption version, is on the, the edge of falling apart. I think it's really theatrical. metrics more than anything else. And, you know, this chart doesn't look to me like it's done.

I do think the valuations are crazy. I think the economic signals are all in place to say it should be ending, but I don't see the argument that says the NASDAQ is blown off and is headed down from here.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what? I'm short and I'm staying short, so we'll see how it plays out. I mean, listen, I'm hedged. I'm in a good situation where I've got the asymmetrical kind of trade where it's not going to hurt me badly if the market rallies. But I'm positioning for this. So we'll see. Time will tell as to how this plays out. Now, what I wanted to touch on, let's circle to chart number 7 in the chart book, which I wanted to just show, which was the MSCI World ETF, which is that symbol URTH.

And it's interesting to note that when you look at the global market, we've seen that we have just spent the last year and a half just consolidating sideways in almost all global equity markets. And so, this is not just an S&P story. And a lot of those emerging markets continue to struggle. I know a lot of European markets had a really good recovery. I know the French CAC index and a few others rallied very well. But when you look at the real Broad global equity markets, they certainly aren't drinking the bull Kool-Aid. So, you know, it really would be interesting to see whether it's the S&P that and particularly some component of the U.S. equity market that can keep driving that. You know, maybe we should have Brent Johnson or someone come back onto the show to kind of build that narrative of you know he has that milkshake theory where the U.S.

equity markets will will kind of run independent.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, everything that I'm seeing, with the one exception of I don't see that we've been through the true euphoria insanity phase that usually ends a big bull market, everything else that I see ought to be negative. And, you know, and I think we're in late-cycle dynamics. I think that we're seeing recession signals. I think there's lots and lots of reasons to be bearish here. What What we as journalists need to do is to get more guests on the program that have an opposing view. And particularly, Patrick, one that came to my attention is John Greenwood, who is the chief economist at Invesco, who thinks that we're not in late-cycle dynamics. He thinks that we're more in mid-cycle dynamics. This is not 1998, this is 1995. That's the kind of viewpoint that we need to get on the program. So that we can expand our horizons, because frankly, I don't see that bullish case other than the one little holdout, which is I don't think the market has gotten quite crazy enough yet for it to be finally over.

But aside from that, I see no reason to be bullish.

Postgame: S&P 500 levels at 2,800 and 2,600

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, listen, I wanted to just on chart 8, just touch on one, a couple S&P levels just before we wrap things up here. So what's interesting to me on the S&P While we've seen like these 500-point down days on the Dow that kind of trigger this emotional, here we go again, when you really look at the technicals, we have not seen any real technical damage to the downside on the S&P. There it is way too premature for any bear to be doing a victory lap. As of this moment, this, this entire pullback on the S&P 500, which more or less is just over 100 S&P points just resembles most natural market retracements. And so I marked off here the S&P levels.

Like, any sell-off that is contained to like 2,800 more or less, in my mind, would just still define this as a very natural market correction and could very easily turn bullish off that. The more bearish scenarios are if the 2,800 level on the S&P gives out, where we're going to go and test some much deeper levels that would really start to ask the question as to whether that high that we saw in late April, early May was in fact a major top. And so I'm watching this 2,800 level. I think it's really important. The bulls need to kind of keep the market above there in my mind to leave the window open for another legitimate advance. Below there, I mean, even those lows that were put in November and early December back in 2018 to retest those levels. They line up with some Fibonacci zones. They're all in that kind of 2,600 to 2,650 area. That would be where a much more ominous market throwback or correction would go.

But I'm watching right here, this 2,800 level into these tariff announcements and whether the bulls will hold the line around there.

Erik Townsend: Yeah. And I think that your technical analysis jibes perfectly with the circumstances that we find ourselves in. You know, the way I look at this, If we get through this whole trade scare thing and after the weekend is over and the trade deal is back together and everything's fine, at most you got your test of 2,800 or 2,825 and it's uphill from there. If they screw this up and it looks like it really is falling apart next week, then maybe we get down to 2,600, but I bet they pull a rabbit out of a hat and salvage the deal somehow and it eventually retraces. And certainly, if they really screw it up and they lose the deal and it's truly lost, then you could see taking out that 2,600 level to the downside, and anything's possible at that point. Maybe it does become the catalyst to start what I think is a long overdue cyclical bear market that, that I think we have seen the beginnings of but is just yet to play out.

Options Education Day, Research Roundup and sign-off

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I want to move on though to Options Education Day in Montreal, which we mentioned briefly on last week's podcast, you're going to be speaking again on Saturday, June 1st, 2019, at the Westin Montreal in Montreal, Quebec. What's going on there? Tell our listeners all about what to expect.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, first of all, any of our listeners that would like to come out and see me speak at the Options Education Day and, and join me even for a drink afterwards, please make sure you register the early bird ends here on May 10th, but it's still a very reasonable price of $50-some-odd. You get a lunch and a breakfast included and a whole day of listening to some great options speakers talking. I'm going to be talking throughout the morning on 2 particular topics.

I'm going to have a presentation on options for managing a portfolio of stocks where I'm going to really get into talking about the psychological aspects of investing and how we can use different option strategies to control those emotions and, and how to do risk reversals and other types of strategies overlaying in your existing investment portfolio. And then I'm going to be doing a second topic called the Option Acrobatics, where I'm going to be talking about synthetics and the different types of option writing and diagonal spreads and all sorts of other really neat things. So it's going to be a great session held by the TMX exchange, and I look forward to seeing a bunch of our members out there.

Erik Townsend: And the best part about it is its negligible cost, only $50 Canadian, which is about what a 12-pack of beer costs you in BC. Not in Montreal, but in BC with the taxes. But Patrick, even in BC, it's still completely free to get a 14-day free trial to Big Picture Trading. You don't even have to give a credit card to prove you're serious. Tell us a little bit more about how people can take advantage of that opportunity.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, we've been extending a 14-day complimentary membership to all of our MacroVoices listeners no credit card required. You can come in there and see how we're doing on our S&P straddle position and learn about all of our other market calls in there.

Erik Townsend: Fantastic. And www.bigpicturetrading.com is where you can go to find out all about We're going to have to leave it there, folks, in the interest of time. We really appreciate your help in securing the sponsorship that we need to continue to make MacroVoices free, so thank you in advance for all of you who I know are going to do your part to help us achieve that goal. Meanwhile, if you haven't yet, please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email each week, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just links to all of the best cool free stuff that we could find on the internet. Patrick, what can they expect to find in this week's Research Roundup?

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview with Charlie, as well as the link to the chartbook for Charlie's interview and the charts we discussed in the postgame. There was also a link to an interesting video with Robert Shiller on what will cause the next economic recession and We'll also include a link to the Fed's Financial Stability Report, which I thought was really interesting read. And so, you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com.

Announcer: Thanks, Luke.

Patrick Ceresna: Or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we will do our best to include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Erik Townsend: Thank you.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already.

You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com. MacroVoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants.

and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Juliette Declercq — JDI Research founder (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is. Bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Episode preview: Declercq and the MacroVoices Premium launch

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 165 was recorded on May 2nd, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq returns as this week's feature interview guest. We'll discuss everything from equities, inflation, what's going on, and particularly the reasons why Juliette believes that the Fed is going to be unable to service their inflation mandate. Juliette's interview was recorded before Wednesday's FOMC press release, so at the end of Juliette's interview, I'll also have a quick update of bullet points Juliette sent us to supplement her interview with a little bit of context on her opinions about the FOMC outcome. As most of you probably already noticed, we launched MacroVoices Premium this week, and there's a short 2-minute launch video linked in your Research Roundup in which I introduce viewers to the MacroVoices trading desk and television Be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after today's feature interview with Juliette Declercq, when I'll tell you all about our plans to expand the MacroVoices brand.

And I assure you, it will go on just a wee bit longer than 2 minutes.

Market wrap: S&P 500, dollar, crude, gold, 10-year

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 has reacted quite negatively to the Powell press conference. What's your thinking here on the S&P 500?

Erik Townsend: Well, first of all, we did hit new all-time highs before that happened this week. So we've been talking about 3 scenarios for the last couple of months on this program where we either get a failed rally at a lower number and the reversal to the downside. That option is off the table. We have at least hit the double top scenario, and it looked to me like we were on the verge of really breaking out into a melt-up. Needless to say, the FOMC coming out A little bit more hawkish than most people expected threw a monkey wrench in the works, but I think that's probably to use an overused word a transitory effect, Patrick. I think that eventually what's really going on here is the market was early in anticipating that Powell was going to turn dovish and get accommodative with maybe even a rate cut coming in this meeting, and instead he kind of went the other way with policy.

I think the market has it right that eventually the Fed is reshuffling its deck, getting ready to. Turn accommodative, and I think they're going to have to do that at some point soon. So as long as we stay in this crazy logic where markets go up on accommodative Fed policy even when underlying fundamentals in the marketplace really suggest they ought to be going the other direction, I think there's room for even further upside in reaction to that easing which didn't happen at this meeting but might come at the next meeting. So I think we have to kind of put things on hold and see what happens here. But Patrick, I don't think that the sell-off that we're seeing here in reaction to the FOMC is going to, you know, take us down to new below-Christmas lows or anything like that.

Today's plunge that we saw in the market was probably driven more by rumor of a trade talk breakdown than it was further effect of the FOMC. And even that sell-off that occurred this morning, as we're speaking mid-session on Thursday afternoon— we're recording the show a little bit early this week— that's already retraced most of the way. So, you know, I think that we're getting a dip in reaction to this.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: It remains to be seen whether we get a melt-up to really break out into new all-time highs or if we stay in what looks more like a double topping pattern here. But one way or another, Patrick, you know, I think it's the higher they climb, the harder they fall. At the end of the day, the recession signs are still there. I see no sign of a catalyst that right now is going to cause the final top to be in, in the market. But at some point, I think we're going to get back to the zero bound.

And that's, you know, the accommodation. Maybe it helps the market push to 1,400.

Patrick Ceresna: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: final high.

Eventually, we're going to get stuck in a situation where the Fed runs out of options. And particularly, I think that populism may take some further options away from the Fed. I couldn't be stronger in my conviction that what the market should be doing is going down dramatically from here. But that doesn't mean that it's going to happen anytime soon.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, let's move on to the US Dollar Index, which we spent much of the week kind of backfilling that breakout. But the first response here is some strength in the dollar. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Well, yeah, I mean, we said that pullback was to be expected. We had seen a break to a new high, and very consistent with what you see all the time in technical analysis. You get a breakout, you then take what was a resistance level and you retest it as a support level. And that's what we're seeing. And it looks like we're already headed back up off of that former resistance now acting as support. And I conclude, therefore, that the uptrend is very much intact and perhaps set to really take off from here. Full disclosure, I bought dollar index futures this week on the dip, and looks like I've so far hit the bottom of the dip just about perfectly. There are some smart people on the other side of this trade, so let's watch carefully. And needless to say, I'm definitely going to ask Juliette about this.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to crude oil because I was dying to talk to you about this because it's been a pretty ugly week on the downside of oil. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: Well, I said last week that the uptrend looked tired and exhausted, but I wanted to see a move below the 13-day moving average as confirmation before turning outright bearish. Needless to say, I got that confirmation just hours later. The big news this week, Patrick, was inventory. Crude oil building another 10 million barrels— 9.9 million barrels, actually. Cushing, Oklahoma, building 265,000 barrels. Gasoline building 917,000 barrels. Distillates drawing down 1.3 million barrels. Meanwhile, crude oil production in the United States breaking out to another all-time high of 12.1 million barrels. Wow. 3 million barrels, a new all-time record. So, Patrick, all of this comes back to what Art Berman told us on this program several weeks ago when oil was at least $5 higher in price. He said, look, the market is oversupplied. And we got people on Bloomberg and CNBC screaming about fears of undersupply because that's what Russia and Saudi Arabia are telling them to say. But look at the data.

5 of the last 6 weeks were big builds on inventory well beyond consensus expectations.

Meanwhile, Russian production was reported to have broken to a new high, so it looks like they're not really complying with the supposed OPEC cuts. So clearly I was early, as our regular listeners know. I was way too early in calling the top on this oil market rally, but it seems like maybe finally that top is in. The thing is, how much downside is there really from here? We tested the 200-day moving average just this morning, so that should be good at least for a bounce. It's a very significant technical level, could be the bottom, but I think there's plenty of room to see even lower prices. It's really going to depend on what the economic numbers and the other news flow tell us.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because gold weakened right back down to April lows today. Is this going to keep breaking down in your mind?

Erik Townsend: I think so. You know, gold is doing exactly what I expected it to do, exactly what we've described on this program. There is a strong downward trendline or channel forming. The current top of that channel is around $1,300, so that's the resistance level to watch. And it's a steeply declining trendline. I think we're headed lower as long as the dollar continues to head higher. If we don't get a dollar reversal, which some people do think we're about to get— I disagree with them— if we don't get that, I think that there's going to be a continuing headwind for gold. And we've got several key technical levels to get through, but I think eventually if we break through $1,180, it could be a quick ride down to much lower numbers, around 1,000 or so.

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, let's move on to the 10-year yield because it looked like even just yesterday, we were heading back down to those 2.35 low levels that we put in in March. But the first response has now pushed us up toward the kind of 2.55 level on the 10-year yield. What's your thinking of the next direction in Treasury yields?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, what I said last week on this program is, look, when we tested 2.60, that was your buy-the-dip opportunity for bonds. And at that point, we were back down at 2.51, and I said, you know, it's maybe late to the game. I think that what happened is it looks like I was right because we continued to see yields move lower after that, which is what I was expecting. I think the Fed has given you this gift of a bump back up to 2.55. As I look at my chart this afternoon on mid-session Thursday, I think that's your last chance maybe to get in. on the buy-the-dip opportunity that you might have missed last week. Charlie McElligott says play the steepener, and he's moved his focus from the 5s-30s curve to the 2s-10s curve. He had that out in a note earlier this week. We should get Charlie back on the program, Patrick, for a full-length update sometime soon.

Why Juliette Declercq was invited

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, this week's featured interview guest is JDI Research founder Juliette Declercq. Now, Erik, why did we invite Juliette back this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, Juliette has a fantastic track record across the entire spectrum of macro investing. But foreign exchange and bond rates tend to be some of her strongest topics. Needless to say, that has been the theme this week. So I wanted to get Juliette's take on the dollar. I wanted to get her take on Fed policy and where bond rates are headed. It fits very much in. Now, again, this interview was taped before the FOMC press statement. At the end of this interview, I'll read you a list of bullet points that Juliette sent us.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay.

Erik Townsend: as comments with her reactions to FOMC.

Meanwhile, there is a chart deck that accompanies this interview. I strongly encourage you to download it. You can find the link in your Research Roundup email. If you're not yet subscribed, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com and look for the red button that says, Looking for the Downloads, next to Juliette's picture on the homepage at MacroVoices.com.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, Erik's interview with Juliette is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Fed failing its inflation mandate: core PCE evidence

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest, here's hedge fund manager, Erik Townsend.

Erik Townsend: JDI Research founder, Juliette Declercq, joins me next on the program. Juliette prepared an outstanding chart deck for our listeners, which I strongly encourage you to download. It will be used throughout this interview. You can find the download link in your Research Roundup Or if you're not registered yet, just look for the red button on our homepage next to Juliette's picture, which says, looking for the downloads. Juliette, it's so great to have you back. It was great seeing you live at MacroVoices Live in Vancouver back in January. You know, something that you had been talking about really all through 2018, you brought up again in Vancouver in January, is inflation. And at the time, Juliette, when you started to bring it up, it was very much out of consensus. Now suddenly everybody's talking about inflation.

Juliette Declercq: Yes.

Erik Townsend: So what's up with inflation? What's going on here?

Juliette Declercq: Erik, I think you're right. Everyone is all over inflation today, but the real value was to be talking about it last year and to reiterate the same theme earlier this year to forecast basically a risk parity feast, which is currently ongoing. There's nonetheless still value in going through my thinking here to explain the ongoing risk parity explosion.

So, consider the 2019 supposedly dovish pivot at the Fed. Central banks have allowed financial markets to become a byproduct of real rates as long as earnings growth remains positive, or basically as long as earnings recession is expected to be shallow. So, financial markets effectively have a lower equilibrium rate or R-star. than the real economy when rates are going down.

And of course, the opposite was true in 2018 when financial markets plunged faster than the economy because rates were going up.

So that's the simple explanation behind the fact that financial conditions loosened dramatically this year, whilst market-based inflation expectations are still very much struggling to recover. In other words, and this was the subject of a late March JDI report, don't be fooled by equity markets. There is no real reflation.

This is a theme that the Fed has obviously finally picked up on, with Powell now openly admitting that since officially adopting the 2% target in January 2012, the Fed has not achieved this convincingly. Or in fact, in a symmetric way. What I would like to demonstrate here is that the Fed, much like its G3 peers, namely the BOJ and the ECB, is already failing its inflation mandate. It shouldn't be a fear, it should be like a realization that it's already happening.

Ahead of the Chicago Inflation Framework Conference on June 4th and 5th, there has been talk about moving from a bygones policy, which basically ignores the fact that the 2% targets may have been missed in previous years, to a makeup policy whereby previous misses would mean targeting a higher target.

Personally, I think it's the perfect time to remind our readers and your followers of the fact that moving to a more ambitious inflation policy is delusional. when the commitment to the current target and inflation framework is already in question.

Inspired by Chicago Fed Evans' comment on April 15th that a symmetric 2% target should entail running modestly above target 50% of the time, I illustrated on chart 1 the Fed's inflation plight on a histogram of year-on-year core PCE monthly outcomes. Since the target was formally adopted in 2012.

Note that the explicit notion of inflation targeting appeared in FOMC meetings in the mid-1990s. So, if you look on chart 1, you can see in blue a normal distribution with a mean and standard deviation that matches the one of the core PCE series since January 2012. And the orange normal distribution has the same standard deviation, but a 2% mean. So it's the distribution of outcomes that should prevail if the Fed was doing its job.

The obvious observation here is that the outcome of the Fed's inflation policy framework has been wide off the mark of its stated goal in the past decade. About 35 basis points. So it's especially concerning as far as the Fed's credibility is concerned that pre-global financial crisis, we had a distribution with a 1.72 mean when the target was actually understood to be like 1.5. So in other words, the Fed's inflation performance has slipped away further from 2% since the target was consecrated.

So if you believe that the Fed can affect inflation, which is another discussion, well, the suboptimal post-GFC inflation outcomes suggest that monetary policy has been too tight in the aftermath of the crisis.

Slipping inflation expectations and the case for cutting

Erik Townsend: Okay, Juliette. So now that we have established for the math majors that you've made some academically defensible arguments, let's translate some of this to plain English and explain other reasons if you have some, that might gain conviction on why the Fed is failing in its mission to achieve its inflation objectives?

Juliette Declercq: Well, Erik, I'm very convinced that inflation expectations are slipping away. And I'll name and show you a few reasons here. After all, what I like at JDI Research is for clients to not take my word for what I'm saying, but being able to actually show it through charts. So, let's go through a few charts. Firstly, on chart 2, you will see that even with realized inflation recovering since the 2014 energy slump, survey-based expectations are collapsing. And this is a big deal because inflation expectations are normally reflexive, which means that people expect what was delivered in the past 2 to 3 years.

Even worse, on chart 3 is the fact that low inflation outcomes have become increasingly predictable, and that's ensuring that expectations are not only low, but they're also very well anchored. So you will see on chart 3 that uncertainty about the inflation outlook has been trending down in line with increasingly more restrictive Fed accommodation.

My view is that in the past decade, the Fed has been too focused on normalization at all costs and the risk of financial stability. And chart 4 shows that the Fed has consistently confused brief period of 2% inflation with achieving its end goal. And you will see that on chart 4.

So it's true that inflation has increasingly been a global phenomenon and constrained by deficient final demand and an overall zero-sum game. But when you're the Fed, low inflation is not a fatality.

And I strongly believe that the unduly restrictive Fed stance has cemented the low-forever medium-term inflation outlook. In this respect, the 2018 episode was especially detrimental. Powell's Fed was pushing a dot plot of interest rate projection wildly out of whack with the macroeconomic outlook, e.g., falling long-term growth potential and inflation expectations depressed by years of low realized inflation.

So it was always going to lead to a forced pause in the hiking cycle. However, achieving a pause that refreshes which is what many macro pundits are looking for this year, will necessitate a more decisive policy move. And this is something that is perfectly illustrated on chart 5.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Juliette. So if I understand correctly, the Fed is moving toward acknowledging its failure to meet its inflation mandate, but will be prepared to act to achieve the declared objective.

Juliette Declercq: Look, Erik, the minutes of the March meeting were unambiguous. in highlighting the downside risk to inflation. Meanwhile, so you will see on chart 6, the number of FOMC participants seeing upside risk to core PCE has collapsed to a big fat zero. So with core PCE at 1.55 versus a 2% target and no upside risk to inflation, In a symmetric policy framework, don't you think that immediate action should ensue?

I mean, if all FOMC participants saw upside risk to inflation in the vicinity of 2%, I have no doubt that hikes would follow suit.

A crucial challenge for the Fed has been the lack of inflation responsiveness to tighter labor conditions and basically no wage spiral. Simply put, it suggests pursuing much more aggressive monetary policy to shift the distribution of core PCE outcomes towards targets. In an inflation targeting framework, it suggests scrapping the positive effect of the labor slack component of the Taylor rule when at full employment.

And this is a framework that has allowed me to argue in 2018 for a terminal rate just above 2%.

Now we have core PCE just below 1.6%. My prediction is clearly validated because my modified Taylor rule, would dictate that interest rates should be adjusted to like 1.90%, assuming a circa 50 basis point real R-star. So, if the Fed really wants a chance of achieving its 2% target sustainably, it basically has to cut 50 basis points. In fact, taking the inflation framework seriously would mean adopting a higher target in line with what Evans was saying, Even if it's just temporarily, which would actually dictate a reversal of as much as 3 hikes from 2018.

Why the Fed cannot cut: term premia and asset inflation

Erik Townsend: Okay. Well, if that's the case, what's holding the Fed back?

Juliette Declercq: Well, this is the really interesting part of the discussion about inflation. What would happen with a shock interest rate cut? I think what would happen is that term premia would go screaming higher and re-steepen the yield curve. And this is really the problem. Ironically, in its quest to promote financial stability, the Fed has been breeding instability. And this is because sacrosanctified certainty awakens the wildest speculative animal spirits.

And this is something you can see on chart 8, where VIX net short positioning is basically at all-time high. So on chart 9, you will also see a great illustration of how the Fed's faint-hearted commitment to a symmetric inflation target has rigged the inflation game and basically cemented a lower-for-longer inflation outlook, which has allowed long-term premia to collapse and given risk assets a very welcome boost in a heavily financialized economy.

My worst fear is, and I'm part of the lucky ones because I have savings, that my savings generate no income when I retire. Basically, that rates have collapsed to zero. And my other fear is that those same savings will be depreciated by central banks pumping up the assets I aspire to buy, for example, properties. The issue today is that lower rates no longer steepen the curve or raise inflation expectations. So the positive effect of lower rates for purchasing power is completely offset, and in fact more than offset, by higher asset prices from lower-for-longer yields, and therefore much lower affordability.

I have been trying to source a mortgage recently, And I guarantee you that lower rates are not helping anyone that is not already rich. No bank will lend you money unless you can afford to repay the capital. And this is leading to nothing else than a return to medieval Europe feudalism, which was structuring society around relationships derived from the holding of land in exchange for service and labor.

Lords hold the land and vassals pay rent. Anyway, the crazy thing is that as I contemplate the upcoming slowdown, I'm worried about yields collapsing, asset prices rocketing, and becoming a vassal in a medieval system. This leads me to feel comfortable chasing asset prices higher, which is really crazy ahead of a slowdown.

What's happened basically is central banks have rigged the inflation game and caused a paradigm shift in asset price dynamic that has now become their main problem. Whilst I'll continue to monitor the health of the global economy and its components like a hawk, the biggest macroeconomic risk today is not an economic downturn that will trigger a financial market crash, but it's a financial crash that would cause an economic downturn.

Risk assets have increasingly been priced on the firm conviction that inflation risks were indisputably skewed to deflation. And this has led to the high sensitivity of risk assets to bond yields, which is basically the hallmark of financial repression and asset inflation. And it is today's chief vulnerability. Think about that, including real estate assets, Global risk assets are worth about 5 times the size of the global economy.

The extreme vulnerability of risk assets valuation to higher term premia make higher yields ultimately self-defeating. And that's the reason why no central bank will successfully reflate and normalize monetary policy in this business cycle. The Fed is the next one to fall. A Fed-induced inflation shock So, for example, a large preemptive cut that would cause term premia to mean revert would cause bond yields to rise substantially and risk asset valuations to tank.

Ahead of the much-awaited June Chicago conference, I warn you, be careful what you wish for, because inflation at this point would more likely become the problem rather than part of the solution. And that's where the Fed is stuck at the moment. It has to play not to lose rather than play to win.

It results that it can't win. The specter of inflation when asset valuation depends on low rates is probably one of the reasons why the Fed will choose to turn a blind eye to its evident failure, the failure to reflate the real economy as the desirable side effect of reflating financial assets and keeping what I would call the fake economy afloat.

Consequently, much as I expected tighter financial conditions to eventually sound the knell of the 2018 hiking cycle, I expect a break higher in the dollar to collapse inflation expectations and eventually blow the whistle signaling the start of the Fed cutting cycle. In the meantime, the Fed will remain reluctant to cut, Ironically, ebullient risk assets due to the ongoing disinflation will be a further hurdle to rate cuts.

And that means that the Fed will remain behind the curve, reactive rather than proactive, and therefore too restrictive to promote global reflation.

Policy path: September cut, dollar, gold and positioning

Erik Townsend: Okay. So, it sounds like on the whole, your views are very much in line with mine, which is that the Fed has basically painted themselves into a corner. They put themselves in the business of propping up asset markets using money conjured out of thin air. That has successfully changed the subject from the 2008 crisis to asset prices are going up, which took everybody's mind off of our other problems. But it's now put them in a situation where they have no choice but to continue doing things to keep assets propped up. So what's the policy path ahead given those circumstances?

Juliette Declercq: So, as I expected, Fed officials have started to contemplate inflation thresholds for rate cuts, and that's including a scenario where inflation drifts lower, even without growth faltering. I don't expect the inflation outlook to improve, so we will easily fall towards 1.5% for longer, which Evans defined as his condition for a cut.

Honestly, with final demand still subdued globally, and also really in the US, inflation has been the mirror image of commodity and FX move, with the 30% plus rise in the dollar in the aftermath of the global financial crisis acting as a binding constraint to inflation.

We've had a brief dollar sell-off amidst the synchronized global upturn from 2016 to 2018, and it's been a main source of reflation via core goods reflation, but it's now actually turned into a deflationary force, as you can see on chart 10. Now looking towards China, whilst we got a powerful stimulus which has stabilized activity in China, producer price inflation remains muted there.

And that means that China will keep being a global deflationary force this year. Going back to the US, productivity growth has more than offset wage growth, which is really keeping a lead on unit labor costs and pushing cost-push price pressures down.

If you go back to the leading indicators from surveys, and we just got the ISM survey, for which prices paid came out at just 50, We're still really looking at a downward path for prices ahead. Meanwhile, even if energy has been going up so far this year, energy prices remain a deflationary force year on year, and that's visible on chart 14.

All in all, I don't believe a rate cut is imminent. However, as inflation softens, real rates move higher and monetary conditions are becoming more restrictive despite the Fed pause. And that's really been the key non-consensus view this year from JDI Research, that this is not a pause that refreshes, but the Fed is already too tight and increasingly restrictive.

So that will drive the dollar to continue to appreciate. And add further downward pressure on US and global inflation. And the longer the Fed waits, the deeper it will have to cut later. A strong dollar is the one thing that will eventually force the Fed to cut.

So I'm looking for a first cut probably in September, which would fit well with June 4th and 5th review of the inflation framework. And that's the reason why I stick to my recommendation to be long dollar versus euro and South African rand. And I also warn against long EM equities. And I also still very much like long fixed income, front-end US and Europe as a whole.

I also expect gold to outperform as the global FX war will intensify when it becomes apparent that the China bounce will not defeat global deflationary forces this I also don't see a Fed inflation big bang as likely, which means that the Fed will not be able to spur reflation. And the result will be an endless inflation-free soft landing, allowing financial assets to continue to rerate amidst financial repression.

So the question, of course, is when does the cycle end? Well, I think it could end with an MMT crazy 2020 US president, Triumphing over disinflation, or basically with the Fed joining its monetary policy peers in running out of potent policy tools after a collapse in the yield curve.

Dollar strength, risk parity and China's credit impulse

Erik Townsend: Okay, Juliette. So on the US dollar specifically, there is a large consensus among a number of macro pundits that a China-led bounce in global growth combined with a Fed pause could lead to a weaker US dollar. Now, they've also been proven wrong so far, but most of them struggle to understand why. What's your take on this?

Juliette Declercq: So their prediction really assumes 2 things, which I think are both wrong. Firstly, as I explained earlier, I think the Fed is still restrictive, which makes the dollar irresistible. And secondly, China-led global reflation is equally questionable. Also, the missing link in the global reflationary equation really is the weaker dollar.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Juliette, what's your take on risk then?

Juliette Declercq: So that's my framework. With global central banks traditionally backward-looking, they're basically focused on hard data, and that's what data dependency means. Cyclical assets have been surfing on a combination of weak coincident data and strengthening leading indicators. So we've been so far this year in the very sweet spot for risk parity because of data-dependent central banks becoming increasingly dovish as profit expectations recover with leading indicators. So that's both positive for bonds and stocks.

Now, the weak spot for risk parity and risk assets will return when data starts strengthening meaningfully enough. to lead central banks to adopt a less dovish bias, and/or leading indicator will stop improving.

Today, my main concern really is the pickup, is that the pickup in leading indicators is not only kind of fully discounted, as you can see for yourself on chart 15, but it's also quite indecisive, as you can see on chart 16. So on chart 16, you can see IFO and the OECD leading indicators, and they're kind of like my favorite leading indicators.

Gross exports in Germany represent about half the economy, which makes the country super vulnerable to oscillations in global growth. And because those exports are closely matched to the structure of the global economy, as far as GDP weight by regions are concerned, the IFO survey, which comprehensively surveys real German businesses rather than experts, is one of my favorite coincident leading gauge on global activity.

So last week release showed that much gentle optimism regarding the rest of 2019, had already evaporated. Not only the current assessment component, which is the coincident data, showed that the German economy continued to lose steam, dragged down by manufacturing and trade, but more importantly, as highlighted on chart 16, expectations also faltered.

The truth really is that the Chinese credit impulse which everybody is looking at to say that global deflationary forces will be defeated, is probably overstated as far as its positive effect on the world is concerned, and especially the non-US world.

And there are a few reasons for that. Firstly, because consumption, which is what is favored in China at the moment instead of infrastructure spending, is much less import intensive. Secondly, because China's credit impulse is becoming less efficient. If you consider a report issued by the IMF last summer, 1 trillion yuan of credit was required to generate 1 trillion of outputs in 2008.

In 2017, which is the last available data, the same output would be achieved with 3.5 trillion yuan of credit. So in a nutshell, you need a lot more credit to achieve the same outputs, and even more if you want to achieve the same output, the same effect for the rest of the world, which would be reflected in imports from China.

Thirdly, There is one thing that we're not talking about today is the fact that China's credit impulse for the rest of the world is probably going to be a false signal due to the China and US trade deal.

So, we are at the moment in the last lap of the China-US trade negotiations. And I think negotiators are in Beijing this week and they will be reconvening in Washington next week. Whilst the truce is largely seen as positive for global trade, and it's true that it is as far as uncertainty is concerned, it is really a double-edged sword as far as trade is concerned because the Chinese economy is unlikely to open much further.

Therefore, global demand will remain deficient and the rest of 2019 will be about discovering that global trade is really a zero-sum game. From which the US is trying to carve a much larger share. So what I think will happen is that there will be initially a strong crowding out effect affecting Brazil for soybeans and agriculture products, Australia for gas, EU and Japan for cars, and EU for airplanes, and Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and again, EU for electronics. which will in the end promote a stronger dollar and eventually just result into a global reshuffling of global trade.

So the bottom line is that the trade deal initially comes at the expense of other exporters, which means that the leading indicator that has in the past suggested increased global activity may now be a false signal for markets other than the US.

In fact, the disproportionately positive effect on the US means that the budding global recovery will be reminiscent of the 2018 dynamic, e.g., unsynchronized. And this will add to already strong appreciation pressures on the dollar and will in turn suppress global liquidity and hinder global reflation. So I'm looking for a stronger dollar, lower yields, front-end US and France tenure for reflation forces to subside and force the Fed to cut.

And I'm also saying that optimism about the China stimulus is overdone and increasingly discounted, which has led me to recommend a short copper trade last week. I think the positive effect of the China impulse on the US will be countered by a stronger dollar. And for the rest of the world, it's largely becoming a false signal.

Populism, MMT and inflation risk in 2020

Erik Townsend: Juliette, I want to come back to inflation because this is a topic that's very much been on my mind in recent months. Although I think I'm looking at it not necessarily differently than you are, but maybe in a different timeframe. So let me describe the concerns that I have, and I'd really like to get your feedback because I know that both the social and the economic implications of this are something that I know you think a lot about.

Juliette Declercq: Yeah.

Erik Townsend: Here's how I see things. So many people thought that quantitative easing was going to create runaway inflation, it was going to be hyperinflation. Hyperinflation, the end of the world, and so forth. And of course, they simply failed to understand that the way quantitative easing works is that it creates bank reserves. It doesn't pump money into the real economy. It pumps up asset prices. And it certainly has achieved that. And as you said, it's created this tail wags the dog market where effectively it's not that the market is signaling what's going to happen in the economy.

The market is causing what happens to the real economy, which I think is a very bad place that we're in.

But a bigger trend than that even is I think we've gotten to the point now, and Neil Howe writes about this in The Fourth Turning, telling us that what we can expect in periods of history like fourth turnings as we're in right now is society tends to pivot from one extreme to the opposite extreme. And certainly in the United States, regardless of whether you are a supporter of President Trump or you're not a supporter, you cannot deny that he is an unconventional leader. He's clearly not the norm. And the potential that I see in the 2020 election is we could pivot to an opposite leadership.

Let's say it's Bernie Sanders as president and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez as vice president, and we end up with Stephanie Kelton, the spokeswoman of MMT, as the new Fed Fed chairwoman. In an environment like that, it seems to me, and frankly, I think we're headed there for a lot of very valid reasons. I think that the people who have been on the wrong side of wealth inequality injustice are rightfully upset. Now, personally, I think capitalism is not the problem. I think it's the cure. I think that if we were to get rid of cronyism and replace it with honest capitalism, that would be the solution. A lot of people don't see it that way. They think we need to move to—

Juliette Declercq: Socialism.

Erik Townsend: a lot more social spending. They think we need to move to universal basic income, free college tuition, forgiveness of student debt loans, and various other things. Now, those things, they do pump money into the real economy. They would be extremely inflationary.

So I think we could be coming into a political change that certainly the populism in your own country of France has shown us that the people of France are just fed up, especially the, the working class, are fed up with economic conditions. They're demanding a change. And I'm afraid the change that we're likely to get is not one that's really going to solve the problem, but it is one that's going to unleash a massive inflation and maybe do more damage with that inflation than the money that was pumped into the economy was intended to do good. What do you think about those concerns? And do you think I'm right that if we were to get to helicopter money at some point, that that's got to be extremely inflationary for the broader economy?

Juliette Declercq: That's a great question. So the first part of my answer would be that, you know, we've got the Yellow Jackets in France, but the fact is you have got like free education in France, free healthcare, And there's absolutely no inflation. So that's the first element of answer on that.

In the US itself, I think there's very much room for a little bit more socialism without completely departing from capitalism. After all, the US is like the last emerged country not to offer maternity leave for women, which is, I think, should be like a sort of the God-given right. I actually wrote a note on that last month, and it was called, Is There a Cost to Socialism? And really, my conclusion was that there is a lot of space for more socialism in the US, as you say, more equality on education, more equality on healthcare. And I really don't think that would be inflationary. In fact, that would be one thing that could probably add some credibility and rebalance inflation expectations.

I completely agree with you that I see more and more even diehard Trump supporters thinking you have to be really rich to really continue to support the kind of running up assets at all costs that is currently going on. So I see more and more more inequality becoming a problem. And I could very much see voters next year going for the other side of the spectrum and basically voting for someone that's going to crush the stock market in a way. And by crash, I don't mean like 50%, but just more uncertainty, higher risk premia, and et cetera. But yeah, basically my conclusion was that you don't have to get to MMT to just spend more in the US without risking much on the cost side because you'd probably get, as long as rates are lower than nominal growth, you would basically get a lot of benefit from higher spending.

JDI Research offering for high net worth investors

Erik Townsend: Well, we didn't get to MMT in detail in this interview. Maybe we can bring that up next time. I think we've got you scheduled a couple weeks out in our new MacroVoices MacroVoices Premium All-Stars format for another short-form interview, so maybe we can come back to that then. Before I let you go for today, though, please give us a quick rundown. You know, when I first met you, you were very exclusively an institutional advisor. You really only offered your advisory services to professional organizations that were primarily hedge funds and other major traders. I'd like to think that MacroVoices may have And you have helped to make a difference in that. I know that you have opened your services up to some of our high net worth listeners. So give us a sense of what you do there, and particularly with emphasis on what you offer to high net worth individuals, family offices, and others that don't meet the traditional profile of an institutional advisory client.

Juliette Declercq: Sure. So what JDI Research offers really is a unique trade-driven approach to macro research. And what I mean by trade-driven is I really mean everything I write is written for investors and traders in a view to waste as little of their time as possible and giving them the deepest understanding of what's going on and what is likely to happen.

I still mostly aim at professionals, but I've made high net worth investors quite happy, I think, in the past 2 years as well by opening up the product to them. So really what I'll have to say is get in touch if you'd like to invest in your investment process and learn about macro in the easiest, clearest way whilst making decisive forward steps financially.

I don't really believe that real value is ever given for free, apart of course on MacroVoices. So don't contact me for freebies. But I'm offering bi-yearly a deep discount to MacroVoices followers for the next 2 weeks. So do get in touch for this if you're looking for guaranteed real value. What I mean by guaranteed real value is that I'll refund you for up to 8 weeks if you're disappointed by the product you're getting.

Erik Townsend: And what's the best way for our listeners to contact you, Juliette?

Juliette Declercq: Juliette.declercq@jdiresearch.com, or you can visit my website, www.jdiresearch.com. jdiresearch.com and basically just click on the link there and get straight to me.

Erik Townsend: And listeners, as a little bit of guidance, Juliette's institutional product is in the $40,000 or $50,000 a year range. It is cheaper for sure for individual high net worth investors, but this is not a few hundred dollars a year. If you're in that ballpark, probably better not to waste your time or Juliette's. But by all means, reach out to Juliette and again, you can You can reach her at Juliette.declercq@JDI, Juliette Delta India Research.com. Juliette, thanks so much for joining us today on the program. I look forward to seeing you in just a couple of weeks on our new MacroVoices All-Stars format. Meanwhile, Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Juliette Declercq: Thank you.

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Declercq's post-FOMC bullet points

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Juliette back on the show, but that was recorded before the FOMC, and she sent you some notes and comments on the post-FOMC. So what did she let us know?

Erik Townsend: Well, needless to say, in the interview, which was recorded before FOMC, she was skeptical that the FOMC would be as dovish as the market predicted, and Needless to say, she was right about that. Here's the bullet list that she sent me, Patrick. First point she makes is transitory is the new autopilot, and she says in parentheses, we know how long this one lasted. Powell will be proven wrong big time. She then says Powell argued that inflation can fall for many reasons, not all of which call for lower interest rates, and concluded that the latest drop doesn't qualify because it reflects transient technical factors. Juliette says she thinks that if there wasn't a real inflation problem, there would not be a conference happening about it in June. There's no question in Juliette's mind that disinflationary forces are not transient, but Powell is probably working on building a rationale toward cuts. The main problem with his reasoning is that low inflation, whatever the reason is, lowers inflation expectations and contributes to anchor inflation expectations below 2%, which entrenches lowflation.

The other problem is that the strong US dollar is not a transient force, so he will be proven wrong, according to Juliette. She goes on and she says that she was not particularly surprised by the lack of urgency, and she expects markets to be the force pushing for a cut via lower breakevens and a stronger US dollar. Powell's Fed will therefore be dragged to reverse some of the 2018 tightening kicking and screaming. So that's Juliette's post-FOMC update, Patrick. But before we move on and talk about our MacroVoices Premium launch, you're going to be speaking at Montreal Options Day, and I know that there is a deadline for people who want to get the early bird ticket to attend that event. Tell us all about it.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know, Erik, actually I want to spend more time next week talking about what I'll be doing at the show, but it's the Options Education Day that's being held in Montreal. The reason I just wanted to mention is that there's an early bird pricing that's available till May 10th. And so any of our listeners that want to come out and see me talk about options and are in the Montreal vicinity, or just want a vacation to Montreal and need a reason for it, make sure you click the link in your Research Roundup and learn more about it. It's on Saturday, June 1st, and we'll talk about it in next week's show.

MacroVoices Premium launch and why Erik is charging

Patrick Ceresna: With that said, Erik, let's talk about the premium service. Last weekend, you released a short 2-minute video, which our listeners can find linked in this week's Research Roundup or on the homepage of MacroVoices.com.

And in that video, you announced the launch of MacroVoices Premium. Then on Tuesday morning, we released the first episode of MacroVoices All-Stars, a new podcast format which brings our listeners multiple short-form interviews every week featuring our favorite MacroVoice personalities such as Dr.

Pippa Malmgren, Professor Steve Keen, petroleum geologist Art Berman, Louis-Vincent Gave, Julian Brigden, Juliette Declercq, Luke Gromen, Brent Johnson, and Danielle DiMartino-Booth. Then at the end of Art Berman's All-Stars interview, you and Art jointly announced that next week we'll be launching MacroVoices Energy Week, an entirely new format weekly podcast that will be all about crude oil and energy markets. That podcast will offer another completely new format where you host the program along with 3 expert panelists who will be drawn from a rotating panel including Art Berman, Anas Alhajji, Pat Hemsworth, Joe McMonigle, Tracy Shuchart, and Chris Cook. Then just yesterday we aired our first MacroVoices Hot Topic interview in which Louis Vincent Gave responds critically to Kyle Bass's investor letter questioning the relevance of Hong Kong going forward in the global financial system. As you explained in the introduction, The Hot Topic format will be used when we see a need because of a market development to do an interview with a specific guest or guests on a specific subject that suddenly becomes relevant to the market.

So let me see if I have this straight here, Erik. In the last 5 days, we've seen a video which you produced in the MacroVoices television studio, which in despite of the fact that nobody, including me, knew that MacroVoices had a TV studio. Then on Tuesday morning, we got the first dose of MacroVoices All-Stars with 6 killer short form interviews. Then you announced that there will be a new MacroVoices Energy Week podcast launched next week. Then came Louis Vincent Gave's Hot Topics interview on Wednesday.

Well, obviously, Erik, there's a lot going on here. Let's start from the most obvious question. What brought all of this about? What's your overall vision of MacroVoices Premium here?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, it all started at our MacroVoices live event in Toronto when a couple of listeners took me aside at the bar, and basically what they What I said is, look, Erik, you seem to be stuck in this self-defeating circular behavior pattern where you want to give MacroVoices away for free because you really enjoy making it a free service. We get that. We can see that you love doing this. Eurodollar University and the Dollar Endgame series evidence that. But then the production bills start adding up and the donations that you receive don't fully cover them, and you realize how much it's costing you to give this away for free. So You pull back and stop producing extra content. That's very insightful on their part. That's exactly what we did because I'm a businessman and I know it's crazy to keep subsidizing more content out of my own pocket. So the result is that we produce less content than these guys thought, as I would obviously like to produce, because I'm obsessed with keeping it completely free.

And what they said is, Erik, guess what? We don't want it to be free. We would much rather get more of it and we're happy to pay for it. Why are you so obsessed about keeping everything completely free? Why don't you charge us for it? We want to pay for it, and we can tell that you want to produce more content than you currently do. Patrick, that was the first time in my business career that I had customers take me aside and give me a talking to because they were upset that I wasn't charging them enough. So their point was well taken. You know, I do enjoy producing this podcast, and I'm really I'm very proud of the value that we've created, and I love doing it for free. But as our longtime listeners know, at one point I got to where I realized I was spending more money producing MacroVoices and giving it away for free than I was spending on my own primary residence.

Now, sponsorship from Big Picture Trading has helped considerably, so my personal out-of-pocket expense is lower now than it was at one point. But the fact remains that I can't possibly justify spending spending more of my time and money producing content, even as much as I enjoy doing that, and giving it away for free. And the other thing that has inspired me to do this was just being utterly dumbfounded when I realized how strong the MacroVoices brand has become and the loyalty that we've built in our listener base. I mean, let's face it, Patrick, when we did our Toronto event, you and I planned that on a whim, and we both assumed that the audience would be limited listeners who live in the Toronto area. But to our utter astonishment, more than 75 people flew internationally just to come and attend a one-day MacroVoices live event. 6 months later in Vancouver, it was more than 100 people flying in from as far as Sydney, Australia, and Cape Town, South Africa.

So, Patrick, it has been a wonderful surprise for me to realize how much MacroVoices seems to be appreciated by Okay.

All-Stars format feedback

Patrick Ceresna: So, let's talk more about the MacroVoices Premium. The first new content we aired this week was the MacroVoices All-Stars, a new format where there's 6 short-form interviews, all about 10 minutes in length, all packed together in a single-hour podcast. Now, for anyone who hasn't heard the first show yet, you can find a link for the player in your Research Roundup email or on the homepage of MacroVoices.com. Erik, how has the format been received and what can we be expecting in the coming weeks from more All-Star interviews?

Erik Townsend: Well, on the whole, I think it went extremely well. We're getting fabulous feedback that people love the idea of being kept up to date on the views of their favorite MacroVoices personalities on a more frequent basis in between their long-form interviews here on the main MacroVoices podcast. But several people suggested that it would be to package and release each of these All-Star interviews as its own separate 10 or 15-minute podcast rather than cramming half a dozen different guests into a single program. So there's a good chance that we'll adjust and package and release these interviews a little bit differently, but the basic concept, I think, is very solid. The other problem we ran into is that first I very carefully recruited just the right number of All-Star guests guests to be able to rotate them in a way that would deliver 5 or 6 short-form All-Star interviews every single week. I had everything, you know, all the ducks lined up in a row for that.

Then I realized the opportunity to create MacroVoices Energy Week. And frankly, that was one of the best ideas I've had in recent memory. But the result is I basically Shanghaied half of the cast for MacroVoices All-Stars and reassigned them to a better project. That left us having to take a break from producing more All-Star interviews. interviews until we reshuffle the deck of participants, so to speak. So there probably won't be any All-Stars interviews next week because I stole both the guests and the editing capacity in order to produce MacroVoices Energy Week instead. But just as soon as we can work all the bugs out and get our systems stabilized, I plan to make both Energy Week and All-Stars regular fixtures in the weekly premium lineup.

MacroVoices Energy Week podcast

Patrick Ceresna: Now, since you brought it up, let's talk about MacroVoices Energy Week, which doesn't launch its inaugural episode till next week, but you just described it as one of your best ideas in recent memory. Please elaborate.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this has been a running joke behind the scenes at MacroVoices, really going back to day one when Nathan Egger and I first launched this podcast more than 3 years ago. Nate used to chastise me off the air. He, he'd say, Erik, the show is called MacroVoices. Not crude oil voices. Your market wrap has a perfectly appropriate 1 or 2 minutes on all the other topics except crude oil, where you would go an hour if I didn't shut you off talking about minutiae of the crude oil market that half of our listeners don't even understand. So Nate was right, frankly. The concept at the time was to introduce a macro podcast, and I had a bad habit of just going way too deep on crude oil fundamentals in the market wrap. wrap because it's a subject I have a lot of passion for. So at that time, Nate was absolutely right and well justified to criticize me for biasing the content of the macro podcast way too far in the direction of my own passion for crude oil fundamentals.

Well, Nate, I know you still listen to MacroVoices every week, buddy, so hear this because I'm talking to you. MacroVoices Energy Energy Week is my personal license to go just as deep as I goddamn well want to on oil fundamentals, and I intend to use that license, sir, to create a new podcast completely unlike anything in existence. MacroVoices Energy Week is definitely not going to be about dumbing down oil concepts to the level of the lowest common denominator internet investor. We're going the other direction. We're going to go deep on advanced energy market trading concepts, like what really determines the shape of the forward curves in energy products, why the Brent and WTI term structures often have such different shapes. We're going to get into subjects like tracking the consumption of fracking sand as a statistic to anticipate future production in place of rig count, and we're going to explore much more advanced energy subjects. than we generally have time to get into on MacroVoices.

But what I'm really excited about, Patrick, is the format. I can explain to you why I think the Brent and WTI curves usually take different shape. In fact, I just did that in the postgame segment after Art Berman's recent feature interview. But there's little value to that because I'm expressing my own personal opinion, and there's nobody else here with equal or better knowledge of crude oil fundamentals to keep me honest and call me out when I'm full of crap. MacroVoices Energy Week will be a completely different format. Every show will feature 3 industry veteran panelists who will be there for the entire show. They'll disagree with me and with one another, and our listeners will get to hear the story from all sides, including cases where we disagree on what actually drives oil fundamentals, a subject which frankly more closely resembles religion than science.

We've signed up Art Berman, Anas Alhajji, Pat Hemsworth, Joe McMonigle, Tracy Shuchart, and Chris Cook to be our panelists on a rotating basis. Now, for our listeners who may not follow energy markets, these people are all rock stars in the world of energy investing. So I couldn't be more excited about the perspective that they're going to bring to this new show every single week.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, Erik. So this new Energy Week podcast, is it something that our listeners who are not professional energy traders should just disregard? and would never understand the content you're gonna get into?

Erik Townsend: Oh no, not at all. To be sure, my goal is to create the premier podcast on the internet for professional energy traders. That's definitely one of the main goals, and we do intend to explore topics that are advanced enough that they will appeal to that audience. But just as we found ways to structure MacroVoices itself so that retail investors who are motivated enough to do some homework, can learn about much more advanced subjects that we have on this program, which were chosen to appeal to our institutional audience. I'm confident we can do the same thing with MacroVoices Energy Week and structure it in a way that will allow all investors with at least a cursory knowledge of energy markets to benefit and learn a whole lot more about energy markets.

Hot Topics format and other new content ideas

Patrick Ceresna: Now, Louis Vincent Gave was our first Hot Topics format guest What's planned for future Hot Topics?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, this has been a thorn in my side for years. We routinely come across newsworthy developments in the market that one of our regular guests that we have a relationship would be extremely well qualified to comment on. This week's example was Kyle Bass reigniting the debate over the Hong Kong currency peg. In the past, I used to feel like, oh wow, you know, that would be such a good Louis Gave But we already have Juliette Declercq booked for this week, and we only have budget to produce the one podcast episode that we already planned in advance. So the whole concept of MacroVoices Hot Topics is to keep a separate budget to produce content on demand when a situation or issue arises that warrants it. In this case, you called me on the phone and said, "Hey, have you seen Kyle Bass's investor letter? It's getting a lot." A lot of circulation on the internet. It seems like everybody's really paying attention to this Hong Kong dollar peg thing.

And 2 hours later, we had Louis booked for an impromptu interview. We never used to be able to do that before, and I'm looking forward to being able to do more of it. We need a budget for that, obviously, and that's why we need to build a premium product.

Patrick Ceresna: In the video you released last weekend, you alluded to there being even more new content planned for MacroVoices Premium. You hinted that you'd be telling us what it is today. I'm sure our listeners can't wait. So, what's on the drawing board?

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, a lot of this is still formative, and to be sure, all of it will be listener-driven. We'll continue to solicit feedback on what listeners like the most, and that feedback will play a huge role in determining all of our future programming. Beyond what we've already discussed, there are several more ideas that are still in their infancy. One of them is monthly show where we take you inside the investment committee, so to speak, where you would be able to listen in on conversations between professional hedge fund portfolio managers and their consultants and advisors talking about trading opportunities that exist in the market. And there are quite a few other ideas on the drawing board. For example, I've envisioned entire series about critically important issues. Now, my favorite topic for that at the moment is Modern Monetary Theory. To my thinking, the question of whether or not MMT is good or bad for society and the economy is one that investors will not have the opportunity to make.

That's going to be decided for us by politics. And it's going to be incredibly important for investors to understand when it does and what the implications will be. So, I'd like to produce an entire special series that really goes deep on MMT and what it's going to mean for markets and get the top people on all sides of that debate to participate. And there will never be a shortage, Patrick, of more great ideas that we have and that our listeners suggest for how to create more great content. The challenge is going to come in prioritizing what we actually spend our finite resources producing, and that will be determined by what our listeners value most.

Video studio and the cost of video

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, well, let's talk about the video dimension of all this because you didn't announce MacroVoices Premium with a tweet or a podcast, you announced it with a video. What's more, the videos were recorded in the MacroVoices television studio where we were treated to images of you in that amazing studio with 7— I think I counted 7 monitors. Was it 7 monitors, Erik, in the background? Obviously, you have some serious plans for MacroVoices video on demand. So, what's it all about?

Erik Townsend: Well, in that camera framing that was used in the video, Patrick, you could only see 7 of the 16 Total 4K monitors that comprise the new MacroVoices trading desk and TV studio. So that was just a teaser. Wait till you see more that's coming. But quite frankly, the extent to which we produce video content is an open question. I've invested in building a studio which gives us the optionality that in theory we could do anything we want. But the critical question going forward is going to be what we actually want. Now, it's It's certainly possible that we could produce most or all of our content as video rather than just podcast audio. But Patrick, the production cost for video can be staggering relative to audio. To give you a sense, professional audio recording studios typically charge fees in the hundreds of dollars per finished hour for podcast content. In the video production world, it's not uncommon to see production fees in the thousands of dollars per finished minute of video content.

So if we wanted to, we could make everything, including this podcast, full video, where all of our listeners every week see you and I in a TV studio smiling into a camera instead of just talking on audio. The thing is, if we did that, we'd have to figure out how to monetize a much higher cost overhead than we would for just audio. And what's more, the feedback that we've received from many of our listeners is in, they want to listen at the gym or while driving, where video would not even be welcomed as an improvement. So for now, the answer is we're going to do some experimentation for long-lasting, high-value content. Let's say we did a new rendition of Eurodollar University. Well, it would be so much better to do that in video because we could make so much better graphs and charts, and it would just be a much better interactive format. So For things like that that are high value and are going to be watched over and over again, it makes sense.

But if we did video every time we had an idea for a new hot topic or all-stars interview, that would really run up the clock pretty quickly and we would be forced to charge subscribers a much, much higher annual or monthly fee for subscribing to that service. So it's really a question of economics and what our listeners want. Yeah.

Premium pricing, sponsorship, free podcast and listener forum

Patrick Ceresna: Okay. Well, since you brought up the cost, I'm sure our listeners are already dying to know what the price tag is going to be for subscription to MacroVoices Premium. Obviously, there's a huge amount of new content to offer here, several times more than what we currently deliver with the free weekly podcasts. So, what's the price tag going to look like?

Erik Townsend: Well, the short answer is I really honestly have no idea yet. So, let me explain. One of the reasons that I decided to to just give MacroVoices premium content away for free at first is that I really don't know how much content we can or should produce or what it's ultimately going to cost. The question of how much demand really exists for video is going to dramatically affect the cost of production. So by giving it away for free during an introductory period, it kind of gives me a chance to gauge how much this is going to cost to produce, gauge what the wants, what they expect to pay for it, and so forth. And once I get a better idea of those costs, I'll be able to develop a goal for what kind of annual revenue we need and, you know, start figuring out pricing. But quite frankly, I'm not necessarily convinced that a paid subscription model is even the best way to proceed with MacroVoices Premium.

I love the idea of somehow finding a way to keep it free or close to free, and there's a lot to be said And that's why I'm so excited for finding a way to monetize the project through advertising sponsorship so that we don't have to charge our audience anything to receive MacroVoices Premium. But Patrick, before you even consider whether it's possible to raise enough money through advertising to support a profitable venture, you have to first ask yourself how much of the audience even wants it to be free. I was very interested by one Twitter interaction that I saw this week where one guy said, hey, you know, I understand you guys We've got to make money on this, but how about doing it with advertising so we don't have to pay anything? And then very quickly, another listener chimed in and said, hey, wait a minute. No, I would much rather pay a subscription fee in order to not have to listen to advertising.

I want to pay for it. I don't want to listen to the advertising. So figure that our audience includes both people who can afford to pay a subscription fee and would much rather do so in order to continue getting advertising-free content. There's also an audience component that would rather tolerate advertising and continue getting free content. I know we have people in the audience on both sides of that debate, so I don't yet have a handle on really how big each group is and what the best trade-off is there. At this point, I'm still gauging how much work it's going to be for me to do this and how much it's going to cost. The one thing that I can tell you with certainty is I cannot continue to subsidize this. This from my own pocket beyond an initial free trial period where we're going to give away MacroVoices Premium, frankly, just for long enough for me to figure out what really it's going to take to carry this forward.

So the plan is definitely going to be to monetize MacroVoices Premium through either subscription fees, advertising, sponsorship, or some combination of those things. At this stage, our plans are still formative, and I don't have any specific price point in mind. Still, another dimension to this is going to be how we bundle and price things. For example, if we do a new Eurodollar University or some other video series, do we sell that as a separate product with its own price tag, or do we bundle everything together under a higher annual subscription fee model? I really have no idea. We're not that far along yet. We haven't figured out all the details.

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so I got it. So, what I'm sure though everyone's asking and maybe accidentally mixing up is the idea of the MacroVoices Premium and our Thursday night podcast, which everyone has grown accustomed to enjoying for free every week. Are we going to be charging a fee to access that podcast too, or is it just the premium content?

Erik Townsend: Well, the short answer is we're going to continue doing everything we can to avoid having to charge you a fee, although it may come to that at some point. I'm committed to keeping the Thursday night MacroVoices podcast free. Completely free of charge in some form. I'm also committed to continuing to offer that product in a completely commercial-free format for the listeners who really value that commercial-free format. But we can't keep giving away something that costs money to produce completely for free unless we get more sponsorship. So my strongest hope and desire is that we can land a couple of sponsors that might be satisfied by just adding a tasteful message at the start and the end of the show saying MacroVoices is made possible by the generous support of so-and-so. If we added a little bit of revenue that way, we could keep the Thursday night podcast completely free indefinitely. So that's my first choice, is to find a way that keeps it free.

The other option is to keep it free but monetize it with advertising. And if we have to go that route, I still like the option of creating a separate offer where you can pay a subscription fee in order to bypass the advertising. So at some point it might come down to a choice where you have to pick between free of charge or free of advertising, because I simply can't continue to give away free content indefinitely when I have to pay for the privilege of creating that content. So we— a couple of sponsors would really help us out. The other idea that's been suggested is to delay the release of the podcast by a week or so, so that paying subscribers would get it immediately on Thursday while the content is still fresh, and then it would become free a week later to free subscribers. The rationale there is students could continue to get it for free. They don't care if it's timely because they're not trading it, and the people who do care about it being timely can afford to pay for it.

You know, that's a viable model, I suppose. I'd much rather rather find a couple of sponsors so we can just keep it free and simple, if we can possibly figure out how to make that happen. Now, at this point, we don't even have the technical infrastructure to charge for premium subscriptions. So you can assume that for the immediate future, nothing is going to change. Something else we've had a lot of requests for is to resurrect our listener discussion forum to allow listeners to discuss the content on MacroVoices. Voices with other listeners and with us and even with our featured guests if they choose to participate in those conversations. Now, this was a core part of my original vision for what MacroVoices would be, and I thought it would be really cool to form a community of sophisticated investors where the conversation would begin with each week's feature interview, but then would continue in the listener discussion forums online. That general concept was good.

And I still believe in it, but 2 things went wrong. The first was we launched it in the very beginning when the podcast was brand new. We didn't have enough regular listeners, and there wasn't enough of a critical mass to really get a good conversation going. The other really big problem, though, is we were overrun by spammers. For a while, we had volunteer moderators trying to police it, but, you know, with a free online forum and the sophistication of today's spam robots, it was a losing battle. So, an advantage of a paid subscription model is that we could resurrect a nice, friendly listener discussion forum open only to paying subscribers. That would solve the spam problem, and we could create that global community of sophisticated investors that I originally envisioned when we first launched MacroVoices over 3 years ago. So maybe at some point what we need is like a sustaining membership that costs less than $100 a year, and it gets you a commercial-free version of the Thursday night podcast, plus access to the listener discussion forum, which is only going to be for paying subscribers.

The real point here is that there are lots of options to consider, and our goal in navigating all of this, Patrick, is going to be to do the best we possibly can to keep the Thursday podcast free while minimizing the impact to listeners. If we have to take on sponsors or advertisers in order to at least make it break even on a Okay.

GAIN: Global Accredited Investor Network

Patrick Ceresna: So far we've been discussing your plans for MacroVoices Premium, but a whole bunch of new content that will be given away for free, first through the existing MacroVoices feed. So at least during the free trial period, our listeners can expect to receive this content automatically. But I remember at the end of our live event in Vancouver, you described your formative plans to launch something you called GAIN. Is that still in your plans?

Erik Townsend: And if so, tell us about Yes, I still plan to move forward with my plans for GAIN, but I see MacroVoices Premium as an important first step. So right now I'm mostly focused on launching the new premium content, and once that is set up and running steady state, at that point I'll focus more energy on launching GAIN, which frankly is much more in line with my own personal passions. As I described briefly to our audience in Vancouver, GAIN stands for Global Accredited Investor Network. Now, the name comes from my own passion for wanting to help people who come into wealth avoid being taken to the cleaners the way I was by some of Wall Street's finest investment bankers and private wealth managers. But frankly, the emphasis on accredited investors comes primarily from my own experience with the private wealth management industry. I know that's who they prey on. But in terms of what I envision GAIN to be, it's really a global network of sophisticated private investors, the kind of people who can listen to MacroVoices and understand what we're talking about.

And more importantly, it's the kind of people who are passionate about learning more. Whether or not they meet the legal definition of accredited investor is not really important to me, and it won't be a requirement for membership in GAIN. What GAIN will be all about, though, is creating a global network of serious serious, sophisticated private investors who want to collaborate with one another and gain a much more personal level of access to me and to some of our MacroVoices guests. The best way to illustrate what I'm talking about, Patrick, is with an example. So let's pick an investment topic like Australian housing market bubble, which Professor Steve Keen discussed this week in his All-Stars interview. Subscribers to the Thursday night podcast already know we cover topics like that when they come up. If we have a guest scheduled who wants to talk about it, great, we'll talk about it.

In the MacroVoices Premium level, it's going to be a different story because we're going to be doing hot topics interviews on the subjects that people ask us to cover. So we could certainly include— if listeners want to hear a certain expert talk about Australian housing, we could set that up on demand. At the GAIN level, it's going to be a completely different story. If we had a GAIN member express interest in shorting Australian housing, What we do is put out a call to the entire GAIN network and see who else wants to be involved in that. And all of a sudden, we might be pulling together. Let's say there's a guy in Melbourne, Australia, who is boots on the ground. He owns a dozen properties, and, you know, he knows what's going on in that market and wants to hedge his exposure. Meanwhile, we have another member who's a banker in London who doesn't have the boots on the ground access to the Australian market, but knows more than the first guy does about bank stocks and how to analyze their balance sheets.

Maybe there's another member who used to be a short trader for a long-short equity fund. And we basically, you know, say, okay, let's get our members who are interested in this, let's set up some online Skype calls, let's organize a little task force that's going to look at this trade and share whatever ideas we come up with with the rest of the membership. So it's going to be designed around creating a network of sophisticated investors who want to collaborate and share ideas and investment research with one another. So that's what it's all about, Patrick. And I'm particularly keen to pull family offices into GAIN because a lot of these guys are operating in isolation and they tell me they wish they could interact more with their buy-side peers. But all of those pay-to-play conferences that target family offices are designed to just give them access to the salesmen who have bought the opportunity to speak to them and sell their wares and so forth.

So, I envision GAIN as offering in-person conferences where GAIN members can schedule, you know, from a block of breakout rooms, we can just set up meetings for topics that people are interested in. We can bring in outside experts and do all kinds of cool things. Yet another idea is to do GAIN-only conferences where we would bring speakers in just like we did for MacroVoices live, but where everybody would get much more personal access. So we're having meals with the speakers. Maybe it's a conference of 25 people paying a much higher event ticket price as opposed to 250 people where there's only an opportunity to listen to what the guy at the front of the room has to say. So pulling all of this together, Patrick, figure that the existing podcast that everybody knows and loves is going to stay free forever in some form. It might have to be monetized monetized with advertising someday. If that happens, you'll at least have an option to pay a subscription fee and not receive the advertising.

We're also looking at resurrecting the listener discussion forum, and I'd really love to figure out how to make MacroVoices Premium have a free option. I don't know if that's possible. I think it's more likely that it will be a subscription service, but we'll see what happens. I certainly want to talk to anyone who's in a position And if you have the opportunity within your organization to become a MacroVoices sponsor to help us offer some of these new products and reduce the cost to listeners for signing up, please contact me and we'd love to do that. GAIN is going to have a price tag in the thousands of dollars per year. So to get the most of it, you'd also have to have time to interact and collaborate with other members and so forth.

Recap, listener input on GAIN and sign-off

Patrick Ceresna: Okay, so I got it. So let's recap. For the moment, the free podcast stays completely free, no charges. The MacroVoices Premium will be offered for free as long as it takes you to figure out exactly what it needs to cost in order to produce the content that the audience desires. And we do have the technology to produce both audio and video content now, and you're going to experiment with both. It also sounds like GAIN is still on the drawing board. Is there any further information available at this time?

Erik Townsend: Well, MacroVoices is a listener-driven program, so I'm very interested in hearing from listeners who might be interested in GAIN membership, but at At this point, frankly, my agenda is not to sell you anything. What I want to do is find out what you want GAIN to be so that I can refine my concept of it and decide how to organize it and what to offer. So, I want everyone to first assume that GAIN membership is going to cost thousands of dollars per year. This is not an entry-level thing. It's not for the casual investor. It's going to be a much deeper, more personalized level of access to me, to our interview guests and to other GAIN members. If you would consider GAIN membership based on those parameters, then please contact me. Reach out through info@macrovoices.com. And in particular, what I'd like to hear from you is what you would most like the GAIN service to offer. I have plenty of ideas of my own, but, you know, if there's anything I've learned in business, it's listen to your customers.

So if you're a prospective future GAIN member right now as you're opportunity to tell me what you want GAIN to be so that I can incorporate that into designing the product.

Patrick Ceresna: And obviously the best way for people to reach you is by emailing info@macrovoices.com. Anything else you want to add?

Erik Townsend: No, Patrick. I think this 10-minute post-game segment has probably gone on long enough for most people's taste, so let's leave it there in the interest of time. Folks, please register your free account at MacroVoices The benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email every week. Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: So this week, you're going to find the transcript for today's interview. There's also a link to a chartbook for Juliette's presentation slides. There's also an article about Ray Dalio saying something like, MMT is coming whether you like it or not, and a link to an interview with Howard Marks. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners, and we're always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better. Now, for our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly distributions. If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account, @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases.

You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library.

And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs. So please Register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week, free of charge. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment.

MacroVoices is. Presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Lacy Hunt — Hoisington's Chief Economist (as introduced on the show)

Announcer: This is MacroVoices with hedge fund manager Erik Townsend, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. MacroVoices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Housekeeping and guest preview

Erik Townsend: MacroVoices episode 164 was recorded on April 25th, 2019. I'm Erik Townsend. I want to thank everyone who wrote in with feedback and suggestions on where we might find an expert with contrasting views to Jeff Snider's Eurodollar thesis. 2 names that came up repeatedly were Zoltán Pozsar and Perry Mehrling. We've already reached out to both of them with interview invitations. This week's feature interview guest will be Hoisington's Chief Economist, Dr. Lacy Hunt. We'll discuss Dr. Hunt's outlook for the US and global economy, recession risk, and of course, where they're allocating on the yield curve. And be sure to stay tuned for our postgame segment after the feature interview, when we'll have extended forex and bond market coverage and another of Patrick's famous chartbooks.

S&P 500 double-top retest

Patrick Ceresna: And I'm Patrick Ceresna. Now, Erik, that S&P 500 is literally pivoting off of the double top retest and has not shown any signs of going higher or lower. Which one is it? What's your thinking?

Erik Townsend: Well, that's clearly the operative question. As I said last week, the really important tell here is going to be, do we get a failed rally shy of the previous high? And in order to call it a failed rally, we'd have to see a significant move down, not just the little blip we had this morning. Are we going to see that, or are we going to see a retest double-top scenario where the market kind of doesn't go substantially higher, at least initially? Or are we going to see just a breakthrough to new highs? That really is going to be an important tell, and we don't quite have the answer yet. So far as I can see, I think this tape still has some momentum to it. Now, that's totally at odds with my fundamental view.

If the market was listening to me, it should have rolled over to the downside a long time ago. I think we're headed into recession. I think economic conditions are worsening. I think bond yields are telling us where the market is eventually going to head. But so far, they're not listening to me. I don't have any reason to think they're suddenly going to tune in this week and, oh, Erik told them the market should go down and start selling.

Patrick Ceresna: Right.

Erik Townsend: So I won't be surprised if we get at least a retest and maybe even a breakout to new all-time highs. Doesn't make any sense, but if I look at the tape, I don't really see signs of exhaustion or reversal here, at least not yet.

US Dollar Index breakout above 97.50

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to the US Dollar Index because, well, it looks like it's moving. What's your thinking?

Erik Townsend: Woohoo! Daily close over 97.50 is precisely the signal that we've been talking about and waiting for for weeks and weeks and weeks, and we finally got it. But of course, as the old saying goes, one day does not make a new trend. To my surprise, some of our favorite people, some of our past guests on the program, are fading this move, recommending that their clients short the dollar here.

That's a pretty gutsy call. I think that what we're looking at is a long consolidation that we've finally seen a breakout north of. This looks healthy to me. I think we're headed higher. I think we're headed above 100 on the dollar index, and I am Very surprised that some people who I have a lot of respect for are fading this and think that this is a fake break and we're going the other way. I will acknowledge that one day does not make a trend, so let's wait and see how it looks next week. But certainly if we stay above 97.50 for the next week, that really says to me that the move is on and that we're headed toward higher numbers.

But Patrick, this is an important signal for sure. So I think what we need to do is go the next level on this and dive into not just what's the dollar index doing, but what's the euro Euro and all of the other currency pairs that make it up. So let's come back to this subject in postgame, and I know you've prepared an excellent chart book getting into the individual currency pairs so we can look at what's going on behind this move in the dollar.

Crude oil: Iran waivers, inventories and US output

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So I wanted to though touch on to crude oil because I wanted your take on this. I'm personally shocked at how relentless the rise has been in oil. Today we see the first down day. We're trading somewhere close to $65 at the time of recording here. What's your take on this? Does Does oil still have more gas in the tank?

Erik Townsend: Well, the catalyst for this latest push up was clearly news coming out over the weekend that the United States was not going to renew exemptions that they had granted to Iranian oil sanctions. Now, at first it sounded like, you know, that's it, the jig is up, there's no more. And then it became clearer into the week, maybe in reaction to how quickly the price moved up. They said, well, actually we're phasing it out over the next, you know, 6 months to a year. So it's not happening overnight. In any case, That news seems to have been the catalyst for this latest wave higher. I do think that the market looks tired. We're seeing signs of exhaustion in the tape, but frankly, we've been tricked by a few bear traps in the past.

Patrick, as we came into the pit close on Thursday afternoon at 2:30, there was a sudden puke and dramatically lower prices. Looks to me like somebody was trying to bang the close and get a number below the 5-day moving average on today's close. Now, there could have been some fundamental news that came out that I just haven't seen yet. That only happened half an hour ago. We're recording around 3 o'clock right now. But so far, you know, that move below the 5 seems to have stabilized after the close. It isn't continuing to sell off. So it looks to me like that was more of last-minute tape action before the close as opposed to new fundamental news driving the market. We're still above the 8 and 13-day moving averages.

It looks to me like we could see the beginnings here of a rollover. But boy, how many times have I said that in the last couple of months only for the market to power higher? So I'm not going to short this thing until I see a daily close below the 5, 8, and 13-day moving averages and really get confidence that the move is over. But I do think that the tape is looking kind of tired here. And from a fundamental standpoint, I think it should be rolling over. It's just I've been caught wrong-footed too many times to take the risk of a short right here.

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, how did those inventory numbers come in?

Erik Townsend: Well, crude oil building 5.4 million barrels. Needless to say, that is a good reason to explain why the tape seems to be running out of steam. Steam here. But this sudden move down that we saw into Thursday's close was not a reaction to inventory. Going back to the inventory numbers, Cushing, Oklahoma building 463,000 barrels, gasoline drawing down 2.1 million barrels, distillates drawing down 662,000 barrels. So that big build in crude inventory offset slightly by a gasoline draw, but not nearly as big as the build in crude. I think that's why the market kind of ran out of steam for the last couple of days after inventory. But frankly, we've seen this pattern before. Where a bullish inventory report seemed to be putting in a top in the market. There was weakness for a day or two and then it just powered higher. So it'll be really interesting to see what Friday's tape action brings us. We move back up to 12.2 million barrels of U.S.

production. That is an all-time high. It's not a new all-time high. We hit that all-time high several weeks ago. We ticked down to 12.1. Now we're back up to 12.2. It's going to be really important So it's going to be really important to watch US production.

Some declines in the rig count have suggested— and I think this has led in, in part to some of the bullish speculation that we see in the market— a lot of people are concluding, okay, rig count is rolling over, that means production is about to top out and start going precipitously down. I think that speculation is driving the market. Are we really going to see production top out here and start moving back below 12 million barrels, or is it going to stay stable to higher? That's going to be really important to watch in coming weeks. In any event, let's see what happens.

Gold's response to the dollar breakout

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, let's move on to gold because with the dollar move the way it's happening, I would have thought we would have seen a bigger response from the, the shiny metal, and it seems to be flat on the day in spite of this big dollar move. What's your thinking here?

Erik Townsend: That definitely is what has caught my attention as well. I don't have an explanation for it, but, you know, boy, this, this breakout in the dollar, I was expecting that to be the signal that was going to greenlight the next move lower in gold. And we actually saw, as the dollar was breaking through 97.5, gold was up on the day. And it's retraced some of that now. But, you know, boy, why are we seeing— is it the beginning of that new regime that we've been predicting would eventually occur, where gold and the dollar move up together on a secular basis? Well, we kind of thought that was starting a couple months ago. We talked about that, and just as we were talking ourselves into it, We saw some moves where both the dollar and gold were moving down on the same day. So, the correlation is not as reliable as it used to be. And to my surprise, we're seeing that strength.

I don't have an explanation, but I'm watching it closely.

10-year Treasury yield retest of 2.60%

Patrick Ceresna: Well, let's move on to the 10-year Treasury yields, because we've dropped now down to about the 2.53% level on the yield on Thursday at the time of recording. And we certainly are off of the higher levels from last week. You think this is a key turning point here in the yield?

Erik Townsend: Yeah, I really do think that it is. If we look at going back several months to what the pattern has been, we were stuck between 2.60% and 2.80% on the 10-year yield for I forget how long. When we broke through 2.60% to the downside, higher in price, lower in yield, we went all the way from 2.60% to what was it, 2.37%, 2.38% in a matter of a week or two. So there was that sudden break. Well, what happens when you have a really important break? Oftentimes, as you know, in technical analysis, Patrick, what was previously resistance has to be retested as support. So after getting all the way down to the high 2s 30s, we came back to— I don't know if it touched 2.60 this week It certainly was within a couple of basis points of that, 2.58, 2.59 in there somewhere.

Basically retesting that 2.60 previous resistance level in price, support level in yield, now testing it from the other side. It seems to have held. We're moving in the other direction, 2.53 as we're speaking on Thursday afternoon. Really says to me the next test is can we get back back down below 2.40 again and continue this move.

So as I said last week, I think the buy-the-dip opportunity was that retest of 2.60, and I think we're headed lower from here in yield. Certainly, Dr. Lacy Hunt, I think, will agree with that view, although his views tend to be much longer-term and not so much focused on what's going to happen in the next few weeks. I think that the signals we're seeing are that that 2.60 that was previously a support level in yield, a resistance level in price, is now working in the opposite direction. And I I think that the next big test will be a closing print below 2.40, especially a weekly close below 2.40 would really confirm that we're headed higher in price, lower in yield.

Why Lacy Hunt is back

Patrick Ceresna: All right. Well, this week's featured interview guest is Hoisington's chief economist, Dr. Lacy Hunt. Now, Erik, why did we invite Dr. Hunt back this week?

Erik Townsend: Well, last time we had him on the program, he was the lone voice. Almost everybody in the industry was screaming at the top of their lungs, look at the 10-year breaking north of 3.10. This has to mean the sky is falling, the world is coming to an end. We're headed back to a secular bear market in bonds with higher yields. And Dr. Hunt was just incredibly calm, cool, and collected and said, you know, it's lonely sometimes, but I'm sticking to my fundamental view. There's too much debt in the system. It doesn't make sense. And I think this is a false breakout and it's not going to last. Needless to say, he's been proven right at this point. So I want to get his perspective on where we're headed from here. what the economy looks like, what it's gonna mean for other markets. And before I even had a chance to bring up the question of Modern Monetary Theory, he brought it up.

And so it's gonna be a fascinating interview.

Patrick Ceresna: All right, well, Erik's interview with Dr. Lacy Hunt is coming up as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Dr. Lacy Hunt introduced: his record on bonds

Announcer: And now with this week's special guest,

Erik Townsend: Joining me next on the program is Dr. Lacy Hunt, Chief Economist at Hoisington Investment Management Dr. Hunt, before we get started, I just want to credit you and make sure our audience is aware. The last time that you were on this program, everybody and his brother was screaming at the top of their lungs, okay, look, that's it. It's clear the bond bull market is clearly over. We're headed to much higher yields. The big number that everybody was waiting for, 5%. That's not what happened.

One of the numbers that everybody was watching was 3.10% on the 10-year yield, and so many people said, boy, if we get past that, there's no turning back. It's the end of the world. Sky's falling. That's it for the bond market. And just as that was happening, we had you on the program. I believe it was the same week that we first broke 3.10%, and you were very confident, very assured, and just saying, look, it's lonely sometimes, but I'm sticking to my story. My fundamental view has not changed. It is very much opposite consensus, and this is a buying opportunity. opportunity for bonds, not a reason to panic. That was so out of consensus at the time, and needless to say, you have been proven spot-on correct ever since then.

And I also want to just make our listeners aware, this is not the first time that you've been out of consensus and correct. You caught all of the major bull and bear markets in the bond market since the late 1970s. So congratulations for the excellent track record, and thanks so much for joining us again on the program.

Lacy Hunt: Well, it's my pleasure, Erik. Great to be with you, and thanks for remembering my record.

Overindebtedness, the 2019 growth path and China

Erik Townsend: Well, it's, it's my pleasure to have you back. Let's, uh, for some of our newer listeners, let's start by briefly reviewing your outlook for the economy, what you think is going to come next for both the U.S. economy and the global economy, and then we can get into a little bit more in the fixed income markets.

Lacy Hunt: Well, the overriding concern for us is that the U.S. economy and all of the major other players in the global economy are extremely overindebted, and this debt is a hindrance to growth. It, it is also a factor that retards inflation and is the main ingredient that has controlled the environment of low interest rates for an elongated period of time.

And it has been our view that trying to solve an indebtedness problem by taking on more debt is not the solution, that it only aggravates. You, you can take on more debt, as we have done so many times, and there is a transitory benefit to the economy, but the benefit fades very quickly. And as a result of that, the transitory spurts in economic activity, inflation, which do occur are relatively short-lived, and they give way to periods of weaker economic activity and lower inflation, lower interest rates.

And as long as the indebtedness problem remains at the forefront of the domestic and global economic situation, it's our view that we're going to continue to persist with this lower inflation and interest rate environment for a longer period of time.

Erik Townsend: And what is your outlook, say, for the next 6 to 12 months for the U.S. economy? A lot of people are saying we're headed for recession. Would you agree with that view?

Lacy Hunt: Well, the economy is very weak. We're in a downturn. The economy held up reasonably well in the first quarter, principally because of, um, of a very substantial drop in the current account deficit, which contributed about 1% to GDP growth in the first quarter, and also a very sizable increase in inventory investment in the first quarter after a large contribution to growth in— from inventories in the fourth quarter.

So, the first quarter's growth rate will start off somewhere around 2.5%, which is more or less about the same as it was in the fourth quarter. But more forward-looking elements of the economy deteriorated. The rate of growth in consumer spending was only 1.5% annual rate in the first quarter, down from 2.5% in the fourth quarter.

In fact, it looks like the 6-month rate of growth in real consumer spending for the latest 6-month period is approximately the weakest since 2013, which is a very significant statement. The gain in the trade sector and the buildup in inventories are likely to reverse as we move into the 2nd and 3rd quarters.

And by the end of the year, I think growth will be only barely positive, perhaps even stationary. So we're peaking in terms of the growth rate in the 1st quarter, and we're set to move significantly lower in the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th quarters of the year.

And a couple of things that we're looking at that suggest this: the Federal Reserve has engineered a very significant monetary deceleration, one that has reduced the rate of growth in bank credit and money supply in the United States to very weak levels. And the Federal Reserve's restrictive policy has reduced world dollar liquidity, which is in turn caused a major monetary deceleration in Europe, Japan, and China, and the Fed's restraint has also resulted in a synchronized global downturn. In fact, the downturn is, is more significant in, in Europe, Japan than in the United States.

Now, a lot of folks are optimistic because the Chinese pumped in a record amount of new debt in the first 3 months of this year. And they're assuming that this huge surge in Chinese debt will lift the Chinese economy, and the Chinese economy will provide some propulsion to the global economy.

But one of our critical points is that when one looks at the production function of the U.S. and the global function and the global economy, the overuse of a factor of production such as debt capital. Results in diminishing returns at some point, and we think the Chinese economy is at that point.

And so, contrary to most folks that are very optimistic about China's growth picking up significantly as we go through the year, we expect that the huge injection in debt will be very short-lived and that the Chinese economy will falter as we, as we move into the latter part of the year.

And we think this synchronized global downturn is going to be very, very difficult to shake.

A couple of things that we're looking at on the monetary side. Last year, at the end of the year, the M2 money supply growth was 4.2%, which was in the lower quintile of growth rates on an annual basis since the end of World War II. And as of the first week in April, the rate of growth in M2 has decelerated even further, down to just 3.9%, which is only about half of the long-term rate of increase in M2 since 1900. It's a very, very weak rate of growth.

And in addition, bank credit growth has decelerated, as one might expect. The yield curve has flattened very considerably, and this tends to undermine the profitability of those that are borrowing short and lending long. And so the monetary policy is, is constrictive.

The benefits from last year's big increase in the federal budget, which funded a household tax cut, a corporate tax cut, and also a fairly sizable bipartisan increase in spending— we think that those benefits, which were debt-financed, are largely behind us. And diminishing returns will also take over there as well.

So, we're at the best rate of growth now, and the growth rate is going to get progressively weaker as we move through the rest of the year.

Past monetary decelerations and zero-bound risk

Erik Townsend: So, we're headed down in terms of growth, and obviously, for the reasons that you stated at the very beginning of this interview, that should be constructive for bond prices, meaning lower yields. Do you have a forecast, a rate forecast that you work with for what we should expect in terms of both US and foreign foreign yields, or do you only work in terms of the expected direction?

Lacy Hunt: Well, we're, we're really only good at direction. We try to make a multi-year assessment, but I did a little exercise that I, I will share with you. We looked at 3 significant monetary decelerations that occurred in the post-war period when the Federal Reserve managed to avoid a full-scale recession, but there was a quasi-recession.

So, the Fed engineered a slowdown in money and credit growth, such as they have today. The yield curve flattened significantly, in some cases actually inverted, but a recession did not ensue. And those 3 cases were in 1966 and '67, 1984 and 1986, and then from 1995 to 1999. Now, in each of those cases, the economy got very shaky.

And there was also a financial failure as a result of the monetary restraint. In the 1960s, it was the failure of Westinghouse, also known as Western Equities. In 1984, it was the failure of the Penn Square National Bank and the Great Continental Illinois National Bank. And then in the late '90s, it was the failure of Long-Term Capital Management.

But in each of those cases, the Federal Reserve moved rather quickly. And on average, they they cut the federal funds rate by 300 basis points. Even with that, the inflation rate fell by about 130 basis points.

Now here is the difficulty: in those earlier cases where the Fed faced a weakening economic situation, the demographics were better than they are today. Population growth is at an 80-year low. The economy was not nearly as overleveraged as it is today, and the global economy was considerably stronger.

So those earlier cases presented the Fed with a better opportunity to get out of the mess. But, but today the Fed is not in a position to lower the federal funds rate by 300 basis points. We would be constrained by the lower bound, and a drop of 130 basis points in the inflation rate would take the inflation rate down to You know, to 5 or 6 tenths of 1%, which would mean that there would be some important sectors of the economy that would be in actual deflation.

And so, the risk is that, in the process of trying to contain the slowdown as it moves along this year, we will go back to the zero bound for the policy rates, and they will be stuck there for a multi-year period, much as we've seen in Japan and Europe.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Lacy Hunt: And that, that is the main risk in, in the interest rate environment as we see it.

Erik Townsend: Now, obviously, they can only go as far as the zero bound until they have to consider other mechanisms of unconventional monetary policy. Do you expect once we get to the zero bound that there's a pause there and they, you know, they, they don't go back to quantitative easing? Or do you think that as soon as we get to the zero bound If the conditions warrant further easing, they go right to more QE?

Lacy Hunt: I think that they will take some type of extraordinary measures. I think quantitative easing proved basically ineffective, but because it's an option, a lever they can pull, it's quite possible that they would do so. But here is the risk: the unconventional methods suggest that we will then be stuck at the zero bound for a prolonged period of time. Just as we've seen in Europe and Japan.

Erik Townsend: And what is your expectation as to how the economy— I mean, I guess you could make the argument, okay, once you're at the zero bound, you know, that's the famous situation where it's all over. But of course, as Japan has demonstrated for 30 years now, you can get stuck in this liquidity trap at a zero bound. And where so many people back in the early '90s predicted that Japan was going to completely blow up and, you know, Japanese government bonds Bond yields would, would go through the roof as the price collapsed to zero. None of that happened, and they've just sort of stayed in this stagnant economic condition that has persisted for decades. So if we get to returning the US Fed funds rate to zero, and they're considering and maybe using some other extreme methods, how long can that go on before we get to a complete reset kind of situation where the whole system has to come into question?

Diminishing returns of debt, per capita GDP and demographics

Lacy Hunt: Well, a lot of folks have made that argument that the indebtedness problem is pointing to some sort of blowup, and that argument has been made in the case of Japan, and that argument has been made in the case of the US. And this has caused others to say, well, look, the Cassandras of the debt problem have been wrong because we haven't had a debt blowup.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Lacy Hunt: And in fact, people continue to clamor for fixed income, high-quality fixed income, government securities in Japan, Europe, and the United States at extremely low or virtually unprecedented levels except for recent years. But I think that analysis misses what history has taught us about extreme overindebtedness periods. The use of debt triggers diminishing returns, which is derived from the production function. The production function is determined by technology and how it interfaces with the 3 factors of production: land, labor, and capital.

And if you overuse one of the factors of production, initially output will rise. You continue to overuse that factor of production, then output or GDP will fall. And so, So, what we're basically seeing is that the marginal revenue product of debt is falling substantially as more and more debt is piled onto the system.

And so, the effect of the debt is more insidious. It's more hidden from view than a crisis, but the crisis is there, and the crisis is what's happening to the growth rate and to the standard of living. If you calculate the rate of growth in real GDP per capita, which is the determinant of the standard of living, from the beginning of the republic in 1790 to 1999, the growth rate was 1.9% per annum.

Now, 1999 is a very critical level because that's when a number of almost two dozen different academic studies indicate that debt levels became deleterious in terms. In terms of their impact on growth. And it's also the time period in which the GDP generated by debt began to fall precipitously in Europe, Japan, and the United States simultaneously.

Since 1999, the per capita GDP growth rate has been 1.2% per annum. In other words, it's— we've lost about 45% of our annual growth rate.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Lacy Hunt: Now, I did a little exercise to illustrate this impact. If the GDP growth per capita had been 1.9% in the last 20 years instead of the 1.2%, the per capita GDP right now would be approximately $8,000 higher. It'd be $64,500 versus $56,700.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Lacy Hunt: In other words, the per capita GDP would be 14.6% higher, which would be able to lift economic growth. Economic growth would have been better, would have been lifted. The standard of living would have given greater enjoyment to people, would have produced more jobs, more corporate profits. And so, where the debt is deceptive is that it is undermining the growth rate. To sort of paraphrase T.S. Eliot, the world ends with a whimper, not a bang. It's a longer, slower grind downward.

That's the problem of the debt. And that's what we've seen in Japan. In 1989, government debt was 60% of GDP. In 1998, it was 80% of GDP. And today it's in excess of 210%. And the Japanese have had 4 recessions in the last 10 years. The growth rate has been so poor that the population growth in Japan, which was, was very healthy, was stronger than in the United States in the mid-1970s.

Their population growth was 1.6%, 1.7% perhaps.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Lacy Hunt: Last year, their population declined 0.4% per annum, which was a record decline. So, you get into this period of overusing debt, the growth rate comes down, there's no crisis in terms of the financial markets erupting, but the growth grinds down. And eventually, that undermines the demographics.

And that's a problem now for the entire world.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Lacy Hunt: This feeds into the production function in an adverse way as well. According to the demographic experts at the UN, the world population growth last year was 1.2% per annum, which is an 80-year low. And in 80 years, in other words, 2100, according to the UN demographers, the world population growth is going to be down to 0.2% per annum.

Well, so the world right now is at 1.2%, 80-year low. The US population growth last year was 0.6%, half of the world. The European population growth was 0.3%, half of the US, a quarter of the world. The Chinese population growth was, uh, well, let's call it zero. It actually declined slightly for the first time since the 1960s.

And then Japan is negative 0.4%. And moreover, not only is the population growth deteriorating, Europe, Japan, the United States are getting older. The average population in China is 40 versus 38 in the U.S. because of the one child per family, and they have a mismatch between young men and young women.

The average Chinese age is increasing 6 months every 12 months. And this similar pattern, not quite as rapid, in Europe. And so, we're not only— our population growing more slowly, but we have more older people who have less demands for things.

Babies and young families are conducive to growth. So, if you think of the production function, in the United States, every dollar of public and private debt is generating about 40 cents of GDP growth.

Erik Townsend: Wow.

Lacy Hunt: Growth. In China, it's 36 cents. In Europe, it's 38 cents. And in Japan, it's 27 cents.

So using the production function as a gauge of where we're going, the U.S. is, is going to continue to outperform Europe and Japan, possibly even China, which means that the rest of the world is going to be hanging on us, draining us. And so So, there is no crisis from the federal debt, but there are very serious long-run developments that are undermining economic growth, the standard of living, and also population. And one other factor that needs to be discussed: the debt-induced weakness in growth is causing an increase in the income and wealth divide.

When you get weaker growth, you, you leave a lot of folks behind. And so there is no crisis in the sense of a blowup, but there are, there are clear tangible evidences. The overindebtedness is harming the economic prospects, and that the harm is greater outside the United States than inside the United States. But that creates a problem for us.

Hume, the Japan analogy and the interest rate theorem

Erik Townsend: Okay, so if I can just briefly summarize all of this to make sure that I have your view correct, you're basically saying that, you know, here we go again. We've tried to solve a problem of too much debt with more debt. And just as you can solve a heroin junkie's, you know, withdrawal addiction by giving him more heroin, that works in the very short term, but eventually it just makes the problem worse. We're coming now into, by the end of this year, That next slowdown, where the Fed will very quickly be forced to go back to the zero bound with the Fed funds rate, will probably have to explore alternative, unconventional means of easing. And this puts us back in a situation where, as you say, we're not facing the conspiracy blogger scenario of the whole world blows up, but rather what we are facing is maybe the entire developed world kind of looks like Japan has looked for the last 20 or 30 years, which is extremely weak economic conditions because the country has been burdened with just too much debt.

And it sounds like you're saying that the whole developed world takes on those symptoms and conditions, but just as Japan has not blown up completely, the rest of the world doesn't blow up. We just get stuck in a situation where the entire economy is slaved to excessive debt. Is that a fair summary of your views?

Lacy Hunt: I think it is a fair summary, and I think it is correct with historical analysis. The great David Hume, who's known as the father of the Enlightenment, tremendous thinker. Adam Smith, who was mentored by Hume, said he was the greatest intellect of all, wrote a paper in 1752 called Of Public Finance, which is on the internet. You can read it. It's well worth reading.

And Hume looked at all of these cases of extremely overindebted economies up until the point that he wrote the paper. So, he looked at the Mesopotamian and Roman Empires and a number of much smaller cases that have entirely been forgotten. And this is what he said toward the end of the paper: When a state has mortgaged all of its future revenues, the state lapses into tranquility, languor, and impotence.

And so, that's the pattern. It's a long, slow grind downward.

And this has led me to develop an interest rate theory. I have an interest rate theorem that I think is very useful, and it surprises a lot of folks. But my interest rate theorem is that government debt accelerations lead to lower, not higher, long-term government yields. And when the debt levels are already high and there is an acceleration in debt-financed activity, there's a transitory gain in economic activity, but it doesn't last very long.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Lacy Hunt: And then the economy weakens. When the economy weakens, then the inflation rate moves lower. And when the marginal revenue product of debt declines, as it does today, it pulls the velocity of money down, which results in additional downward pressure on GDP growth. And so, the pattern is toward lower rates. And if you do a little simple exercise, And graph the long government yields in Europe versus the government debt-to-GDP ratio, or just put them on a graph, one on the left axis, one on the right. Government debt-to-GDP, the government bond yield on the other. Do the same thing for Europe. Do the same thing for China. Do the same thing in the U.S.

Erik Townsend: Okay.

Lacy Hunt: And what do you see? In all cases, the government debt-to-GDP ratio is rising substantially, and the bond yield is declining. There's a negative correlation, not a positive correlation. And Japan is more pronounced because they have been in this debt cycle longer than all the rest.

We're just in various stages of lag behind them, and that's the course. So, there's a transitory gain. For example, For example, the big surge in deficit spending last year, it produced an acceleration in GDP growth in the second quarter, a little bit in the third quarter, but by the end of the year, it was really hard to identify.

And I think that that's the case. The benefit from debt-financed activity is very fleeting. There is a benefit, but it does not last very long. And that's, that's what we've seen in Japan in numerous cases, and what we've seen in in Europe in many cases, and I think we're going to start seeing now in China when the big surge in debt that they've engineered this year really doesn't produce the results that it has in the past because we're further along the diminishing returns curve.

MMT and why the Fed cannot print money

Erik Townsend: Let's, let's focus on that diminishing returns curve because you said earlier that you expect the Fed, because of economic conditions, to have to take us back to the zero bound. You said because of this diminishing returns curve that it's likely that they will have to do some kind of unconventional policy action. But you said quantitative easing really hasn't been that effective, and of course it is diminishing in its efficacy the bigger the balance sheet gets. So, what do you think comes next if it's not quantitative easing? Is it outright debt monetization, or is it something else?

Lacy Hunt: Well, there are some folks out there, mainly the modern monetary theorists, that want to make the liabilities of the Federal Reserve legal tender. In other words, allow the Fed's balance sheet to sort of operate as a cash cow and to pay for the Treasury's bills. The Federal Reserve does not have that authority at present.

The 1937 Act, the principal author was Senator Carter Glass of Virginia, who wrote also the Glass-Steagall Act, did not intend to give them that authority. Consulted with Irving Fisher of Yale and Charles Whittlesey of Penn. And other great monetary thinkers of the time, and they did not give the Fed that authority.

The Fed can only use its balance sheet to buy a select group of assets from the banks— government and agency securities— and then those proceeds have to be held at the Federal Reserve Bank.

And so, the money supply is equal to the monetary base and the money multiplier, which is endogenous and which the Fed does not control. And regardless of what you have heard, And there was once a statement, which was eventually corrected from Ben Bernanke, that in quantitative easing the Fed was printing money. But the Fed does not have that capacity; it doesn't have the mechanism or the tools to print money.

For them to be able to print money, you would have to rewrite the Federal Reserve Act. Now you could go down that route, but what would happen in that case is in very, very short order, we would get hyperinflation. Because the aggregate demand curve would shift upward, the money multiplier would no longer be relevant, and prices would rise as fast as the increase in the money supply, and eventually faster.

And something called Gresham's Law would take effect.

The bad money would chase out the good money. People wouldn't— would not be willing to exchange money for commodities, return to barter. There would be massive inefficiencies. In the old days, when countries made the central bank's liabilities legal tender, we of course had many, many smaller producers who maybe somebody produced eggs and someone produced milk and someone else made bread, and you could then sort of barter.

But today we all have specialized skills. It'd be hard to barter specialized skills. And of course we have the mass merchandising. That couldn't operate with a barter system. And also, in the past, when the Federal Reserve's liabilities were made legal tender, those currencies were not the reserve currency of the world.

And so, if we were to do that, it would quickly destabilize the global monetary system. So, that's the siren song, and some people are advocating But, but if we were to make the Fed's liabilities legal tender, in very short order, nearly 100% of our people would be miserable. Absolutely miserable.

Hoisington positioning: 20-plus-year duration

Erik Townsend: I want to come back to Modern Monetary Theory and some of the directions it could take us in just a minute. But before we go there, let's come back to the current system, the way the laws are written now, the system that we live in. You've described this scenario of worsening economic conditions, the Fed eventually returning to the zero bound, And so forth. Based on that, I know that your process at Hoisington Investment Management is you basically decide where on the curve to allocate long fixed income investments. So how do you translate in the current environment? Is it all about duration risk, that your long duration here and going all the way out on the curve, or is it something different?

Lacy Hunt: Well, we, we do have a plus 20-year duration because we've had that for some time. And it's been a bumpy ride. We've had a lot of volatility in the long yields, but let me just give you a perspective. When the Fed first raised the policy rates in December of 2015, the 30-year yield was roughly 3.8%, and it's been below 3.8% since then and been above.

We had 9 increases in policy rates. We had the euphoria of, of generally rising stock markets. But as things stand, as of the end of March, the best-performing part of the Treasury curve was the 30-year. You had a higher coupon, and you outperformed everything on the shorter portion of the curve. In other words, the Treasury market was influenced by a whole host of these transient factors, which were very powerful over the short run. But didn't really matter.

But what did matter is that the overall economic growth rate has been subpar, and the inflation rate has generally been depressed and extremely low. Not that there weren't individual bouts of inflation. You can get transitory bouts in growth and inflation, but they're not going to hold in this environment.

And so, it's been our assessment that the best returning asset on the curve would be the long Treasuries. And that's where we've positioned our clients and ourselves, because we, we invest with our clients.

Erik Townsend: Okay. So, the view in the world as we know it, the current system, is we're in a disinflationary to possibly even deflationary risk scenario. We're in worsening economic conditions. The place to be is all the way out the curve, long-duration risk. And that makes perfect sense. Now, I want to come back to your earlier comments about MMT, and let's take a Let's take it even a step further. You know, one of the things that Neil Howe's work on generational cycles teaches us is that in periods of history like this, we tend to go not only to extreme leaders, but often society will pivot from one extreme to the other.

So let's assume that your scenario plays out. The economy worsens through the rest of 2019. We go into the election year of 2020 in either recession conditions or rapidly approaching recession conditions. It's not looking very good for the incumbent party. Suddenly, we end up with President Bernie Sanders, Vice President Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and they appoint Professor Stephanie Kelton as the new Federal Reserve Chairman. Stephanie Kelton, of course, is one of the major proponents of Modern Monetary Theory, the view that it's perfectly okay for the government to create as much money as necessary, as long as there's not an immediate inflation It seems to me, and obviously that's an extreme hypothetical, I don't know that we would ever get there, but for sake of argument, let's assume that there is a pivot in social mood to where suddenly more government spending, things like universal basic income, using Modern Monetary Theory to pay for more social spending, forgiveness of student debt, maybe even government-subsidized free university tuition.

Those kinds of things that the political left has begun to focus on sort of come true in terms of those people coming into power. What does that do to your outlook for fixed income? Because obviously those would be very inflationary conditions.

Lacy Hunt: Well, if you, if you make the Fed's liabilities legal tender, then all bets are off, and the inflation rate would begin to rise rapidly, and that would require a different investment strategy. There's no question about that. But if there's an attempt made to rewrite the Federal Reserve Act, you're going to have a little bit of time because it would have to go to the House and the Senate. They'd have to pass compatible bills and go to the president. Under the right political circumstances, they could do that. But even in the best of circumstances, the process would take a little time.

And so that would, that would give investment managers an opportunity to reposition their portfolios.

I might also add that the leadership of the Federal Reserve would have to be changed. That could be done as well. But all these things would take time, couldn't be done overnight, because the Fed does not have the current capacity. Now, you might, you might do something like this. You might say, well, we'll have an announcement from the Fed that they will increase the balance sheet. If the deficit's gonna be $2 trillion or $3 trillion, they'll increase the Fed's balance sheet $3 trillion.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Lacy Hunt: But we already really tried that in 2012 and 2013. The increase in the Fed's balance sheet in those 2 years equaled the budget deficit. But you see, in that particular case, existing under the Federal Reserve Act, the money supply is still equal to the base times little m, the money multiplier.

And so, you could buy the— you would have the Fed buy the government securities, But the banks would not be able to employ it unless they had the capital to utilize the excess reserves, which was the same problem that constrained the banks from turning the balance sheet into an acceleration in money supply growth.

And so, when we had quantitative easing, the Fed's balance sheet quadrupled, but the money multiplier dropped from 9 to 3, and the rate of growth in money supply did not accelerate. The only thing that would really be different would be if there was a concerted effort to make the Fed's liabilities legal tender. And my read is that that requires a rewrite of the Federal Reserve Act and also some other companion legislation as well. It could be done under the right political circumstances, but as for the time being, it cannot be done.

Erik Townsend: And do you see that as a— let's say, in the next 2 to 3 years, as we go into the next presidential race? If there was a substantial change in national leadership in a new presidential election, do you think that that scenario where the Federal Reserve Act gets rewritten, as you describe, is that a 1% possibility, or is that a 70% possibility?

Lacy Hunt: I think it's very low, because keep in mind that even advocates of greater budget deficits, such as Paul Krugman and Larry Summers have said that modern monetary theory is not workable. There's an outstanding article by Ken Rogoff at Harvard about the unworkability and what it would mean for higher inflation.

So I, I don't see mainstream academic economists supporting it, and I certainly don't see the Federal Reserve community. Chairman Powell has come out against it. It would take a cataclysmic political to want to rewrite the Federal Reserve Act to do that.

Erik Townsend: Okay, so we'll categorize that as an extreme outlier, but still a plausible risk considering that we're in a very interesting economic environment. That's sobering news, to say the least.

Lacy Hunt: It would make everybody's life miserable, including fixed income managers and everyone else in the economy, because you would, you would barter, and barter is extremely inefficient. The aggregate supply curve would turn vertical. So, every time that they expanded the Fed's balance sheet to pay for bills, it would all go into price. There would be no gain in real GDP. It would just result in rapidly escalating inflation.

But, and eventually, what would happen is that the aggregate supply curve would start shifting inward, as more and more people went to try to operate with In a barter framework, which I don't know how we could even achieve a barter framework in this specialized world that exists today.

Erik Townsend: Well, and of course, that would probably create an opening for alternative currencies, whether they be cryptocurrencies or otherwise, to begin competing with government-issued currency on the argument that they're more stable and less subject to inflation.

Lacy Hunt: Well, the main thing to understand is that Gresham's Law would take effect. In other words, the bad money, the Federal Reserve's liabilities, would chase out good money. People that could— take, for example, some of the cases where central bank liabilities were made legal tender. This was done by the Chiang Kai-shek government in 1935, and it was done by the Weimar Republic in the 1920s, done by Yugoslavia at the end of World War II, Hungary at the end of World War II, numerous cases in Latin America in the last 30 to 40 years, happened in Venezuela contemporarily.

In the late days of the Roman Empire, there was no central bank, but what was done was the pure metallic coins were replaced by worthless metal coins. And people wouldn't use them, wouldn't accept them, so they resorted to barter, which even then was complicated. In the Bourbons of France, they had become extremely overindebted to finance what was known as the Seven Years' War in Europe, the French and Indian War in the U.S., the American Revolution, and they continued living beyond their means.

The government of Louis XVI was unpopular. Couldn't pay off these debts, but they continued their high-living style, so they began issuing worthless metallic coins. Same effect. So, people that could moved their assets into assets that held value, moved some into foreign countries or what have you. But that would be very, very difficult in the current environment, because Because the US dollar is the reserve currency.

So, going along that route would be unimaginably disruptive, in my opinion. Deflation is an uncomfortable environment, but for those that are employed, real incomes generally tend to continue to rise, at least somewhat. In hyperinflation, no one's real income will rise, and everyone would become miserable.

About Hoisington and the Wasatch fund

Erik Townsend: Well, Dr. Hunt, I wish that we could go on for hours. It's fascinating just to hear your musings on all of these interesting scenarios. Unfortunately, we're running out of time. So, before I let you go, give us a quick overview of what you do at Hoisington Investment Management

Lacy Hunt: Well, I'm the chief economist of the company. We manage in excess of $4 billion of institutional fixed-income money. We've been in business since 1980. We really don't have individual clients, but we are the sub-advisor to the Wasatch Hoisington Treasury Bond Fund. And you're able to get the same type of management in that fund, which is symbol WHOSX. as for our big institutional clients.

Erik Townsend: Well, Dr. Hunt, I can't thank you enough for a fantastic interview. I would love to hear you continue to muse on these subjects for hours, but we are unfortunately out of time. Patrick Ceresna and I will be back as MacroVoices continues right here at MacroVoices.com.

Announcer break

Announcer: MacroVoices is a listener-driven program. Please email requests for specific future interview guests to requests@macrovoices.com. You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer them on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. We also welcome your suggestions for how we can improve the program. Now back to your hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna.

Postgame: reaction to Hunt

Patrick Ceresna: Erik, it was great to have Dr. Lacy Hunt back onto the show. One of the things that I think we've heard it before on this show is his entire idea that the more debt that comes into the system, it actually causes lower interest rates, not higher interest rates over the long term. And that's so counterintuitive to what anyone would naturally think when approaching the bond markets. And when you really put it into that perspective, it really touches on this idea that maybe we are heading to a zero-bound world where the Japanification of the American and European economies could actually be a real risk.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think you hit the nail on the head, and it's so fascinating to me. I think Dr. Hunt makes a perfect argument, and it makes perfect sense, which is, look, if you're talking about emerging market debt, you know, little countries that are not systemically important to the international monetary

Definitely. The way it works is too much debt causes a loss of confidence in that country's ability to repay that debt. That results in much higher yields. I don't think Dr. Hunt is disputing that for a second. But that's for little emerging market countries.

What about major economies like the United States that are central to the global financial system? Well, in that case, the system tends to assume that it is impossible for there to be a default on US Treasury debt. So, if we know that's impossible, then we're not going to respond to the default risk. We're going to respond instead to the fact that if the economy is unable to afford higher bond yields, every time bond yields move higher, it's going to collapse the economy. And there's going to be a retreat out of risk assets back to safety, and it's going to support lower bond yields. This all makes sense, but someday you have to get to a reckoning point where if the entire developed market economies and the global financial system is all in a Japanification where it's super low yields and economic stagnation, at what point does somebody just say, hey, even the major systemically important currencies of the world, like the dollar and the US Treasury market, this debt is unsustainable?

At what level, Patrick, of national At what level of national debt does the US Treasury system just hit that point where the market says, wait a minute, this is unsustainable, even if it is the United States of America? Is it $20 trillion, $30 trillion, $40 trillion? I don't know, but it seems like politicians, whatever the number is, they're gonna find out. They're gonna keep borrowing until we test it.

Postgame chartbook: dollar and currencies

Erik Townsend: So, it's gonna be really interesting.

In any event, I wanna come back now to the foreign exchange topic that we discussed in the market wrap, because this move in the dollar index is clearly important. As some of our listeners have suggested in recent weeks, We really need to dive into what's driving it. So let's look at the underlying currency pairs that contribute to the dollar index and talk about what's going on here, both in developed and emerging markets. Listeners, you'll find the download link in your Research Roundup email. It says Postgame Chartbook. Or if you aren't yet registered, just go to our homepage at MacroVoices.com. Look for the red button that says Looking for the Downloads next to Dr. Hunt's picture on our homepage. Patrick, diving into page 2, we're looking at the dollar index on a weekly chart. Talk us through what we're looking at.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, to the visible eye, any technician can identify that the dollar index on a weekly chart basis here has broken out. Now, the week isn't over, so there's always something that could happen the day after we've recorded— we're recording this on Thursday, but this is definitively a breakout. But it reminds me of the circumstance when we were talking about this back in November. So if we rewind a little bit earlier in 2018, we had a huge breakout in the dollar in August, in the middle of August of 2018.

Erik Townsend: Right.

Patrick Ceresna: It made its high near about the 97 level, and then several months later, as we approached November, it actually broke to a higher high. And it was in the middle of November where we went and and popped almost a one point higher, approaching but didn't print 98 on the upside. And we were asking the same question we are today: Is this the breakout? Is this the beginning of the next trend? And rather than that marking a new breakout. We ended up falling into a 6-month consolidation.

And obviously you were saying in the pregame that there was a number of our past guests that are attempting to even fade this dollar move. And that's a pretty bold thing, but I mean, it does remind me a lot of November. And back then they would've been right. And so I'm dying to find out whether this breakout is for real, because if it's for real, I don't see how this doesn't stop without a full retest of the 2016, 2017 high on the dollar index. 104. And so I don't think it's going to take more than a couple of weeks for us to find out whether this actually turns into a big breakout with some serious momentum.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, I think the key to this is there's 2 narratives that people are talking about. You can discuss the fundamentals of the US dollar. That is to say, what should the US dollar be doing relative to other currencies based on the usual factors of interest rate differentials and the health of the economy and so on and If you look at it that way, it's easy for me to see why some people are very dollar bearish and they have this view. But I think what's going on is it really— what I believe is truly driving this market is people are just starting to figure out Jeff Snider's narrative, the one that says, look, this is not about the US dollar being the white knight in shining armor that comes racing in because the US economy is perfect and everything's great.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. Great.

Erik Townsend: This is about a dollar liquidity squeeze, which is driven by a breakdown in the functioning of the offshore Eurodollar system that is not resulting in everybody thinking the dollar is a better currency. It's resulting in a dollar squeeze where we don't have a sufficient supply of dollars to satisfy the needs of the global economy, with the emphasis on global. This is about international capital flows. It's all about Jeff Snider's interview that we just did last week. And I think what's going on here is people that were focused on that fundamentals of the dollar view are starting to come around and say, wait a minute, it's the Snider story. That's the one that's actually governing here. And I think that when more people figure out that's what's happening, you could see a dramatic acceleration to the upside.

Patrick Ceresna: Right. And so, on chart 3, I want to move on here, Erik, because on chart 3, I put up the chart of the euro. Now, this is important to me because, as we've mentioned many times on the show, the dollar index is heavily weighted to the Something like 57% of the index is made up of the euro. So in my mind, I was thinking, well, what could be a fake out? It could be a fake out if the move was only happening on the euro, but the other currencies were not confirming. And so here on page three, I just show the euro breakdown, and with the economic weakness we're seeing in Europe, it's certainly not out of line for this to continue back down toward its 2017 lows. I mean, it's a number we've seen. Just a few years ago.

But what was fascinating to me was that there's a lot of other currencies that are weakening at the same time, particularly— I don't have the Canadian dollar here, but the Canadian and Australian dollar on page 4, I have the Aussie dollar there, are both weakening down to the bottom end of the ranges. Now, there was that one little mini flash crash liquidity event on the Aussie dollar that printed down toward under 68 cents. But overall, the vast majority of the vol volume that is traded on the Aussie dollar has been in this 70 to 72 cent range, and it really looks like that Aussie is rolling over and going to break down. And you're seeing that same pattern on the Canadian dollar and, and a number of the emerging market ones.

Erik Townsend: Okay, Patrick. So the question on my mind, we're seeing developed markets really confirming what the dollar index chart is showing us. What about emerging markets though?

Patrick Ceresna: Well, this is the interesting part, is because the emerging markets are showing considerable weakness outside of those majors. When you start going onto the charts, such as I have the Brazilian real on here, it's now breaking multi-month lows and on the verge of, of heading back down to its 2018 low. On page 6, we have the chart of the Argentinian peso. Obviously, Argentina has its own fundamental issues, but it is still making fresh multi-year lows here at these prices. You go to the Turkish lira and the situation in Turkey continues to worsen and the currency is once again breaking down to multi-month lows, heading almost looking like it's heading right back to those 2018 lows.

Then we had this morning the bad economic data coming out from South Korea and the South Korean You have the Korean won breaking down to new multi-year lows on this breakdown move. You have the Swedish krona on bad economic news breaking to new multi-year lows. Like, currency after currency are breaking down. And so I find it hard to suggest that this dollar is a fake out when you have so many currencies that are breaking down all simultaneously.

Erik Townsend: Well, Patrick, everything that you're saying completely confirms in my mind my strongest suspicion, which is I think this is not This is not about fundamentals of currency trading. I think this is about a dollar short squeeze, and it's about a lack of there being sufficient dollars because of the breakdown in the offshore Eurodollar system to supply the requirements of the global marketplace. And what it says to me is the dollar is gonna continue to squeeze higher against everything, which is what's going on here.

Patrick Ceresna: Absolutely. So, in my view, obviously, we're gonna wanna give the dollar the benefit of the doubt to kind of prove to us from a technical perspective that there's real follow-through. But to me, there's a lot of holes in the dam and the water's starting to break through. I'm feeling that this, after a 6-month consolidation where the dollar has pretty much been in a sideways range, if this breaks out here, this could be one of the biggest macro events of 2019.

Postgame: yields, eurodollar spread, credit spreads

Erik Townsend: Patrick, I couldn't agree more. But let's move on now to the 10-year Treasury yield and look at what's going on there.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you were talking about it earlier in the pregame, and I just wanted to use this as a foundation to talk about the next few topics. What I found fascinating, just off the cuff, notice the similar chart pattern on pages 10 and 11 between the path of the 10-year yield and the path of the spread between the Eurodollar June 2019 and June 2020 contracts. The spread is showing what the expected rate cuts are in the next 1 year.

And it actually— the chart looks almost the

Erik Townsend: Yeah, it does.

Patrick Ceresna: And I don't really even know if I have a proper explanation why it would. But anyway, I continue to believe at this stage that yields are highly likely to go lower. And we heard from Dr. Lacy Hunt as to why he feels that that is the case. And I have to agree in principle with him.

But what I find fascinating is that we now have a Fed that's thrown in the towel. No more rate hikes on the table this year. They've basically already drawn out how they're going to stop contracting their balance sheet in the, in the coming months. And we now have a Eurodollar market that is still clearly pricing in a rate cut in the coming year, June over June.

And that to me is the bond market continuing to signal the fact that we are seeing economic weakness ahead and a slowdown is coming, very similar to Dr. Lacy Hunt's view.

But what I find fascinating on pages 12 and 13, I have the credit spreads on investment grade debt over that of Treasury. And on page 13 is the high yield or junk bonds credit spread over Treasury. And what we have is a huge— or not huge, but a significant reversion back to levels where we were through 2017, 2018. And it's almost like the corporate credit markets are basically suggesting that there are no risks of a recession or slowdown, but yet we're getting a completely different message from the Treasury bond market. And I'm trying to square this in terms of which one is going to be proven right on this.

Erik Townsend: Well, this is utterly baffling to me because I've lost track of how many times I've said to myself, okay, this has to be it for high yield. It doesn't make any sense that we have junk spreads at 300 or 400 basis points when you look at just the ridiculous amount of junk bond issuance that has occurred since 2009. All of the BBBs, we've talked quite a bit on this program about why there is so much both junk and slightly more than junk-rated corporate debt that really just, it doesn't make sense. It's going to be unserviceable if we get into an economic downturn. It doesn't make sense that it is priced as high as it is, and the prices keep going higher. And every time that I've tried to short junk, it's blown up in my face and I've been stopped out out of the trade.

So, I cannot explain this, Patrick. I don't know if you can, but, you know, how is it possible that we see all the signs that we're seeing that the economy is headed for recession? We're seeing much lower Treasury yields generally, but junk spreads are at basically multi-year lows.

Patrick Ceresna: Well, you know what, just like you were just suggesting right over there, that we've been down this road before trying to call these major turning points. I've moved to the sideline during the last plunge, but I'm very tempted here to, to give a shot to the downside for these junk bonds. At some stage, an economic slowdown should cause these credit spreads to blow out. And I think that people are being way too optimistic in this space. But time will find out, won't it?

Outro and Research Roundup

Erik Townsend: It surely will. And I very much appreciate your putting together the chart deck, folks. If you're not aware, Patrick puts together chart decks like this almost every day for his Big Picture Trading membership. If you're not already familiar with the service, I strongly encourage you to take advantage of the free 14-day free trial of Big Picture Trading. You can send an email to contact@bigpicturetrading.com or just go to www.bigpicturetrading.com, Patrick's company. Patrick runs daily webinars Monday through Thursday with similar chartbooks for his members where you can ask questions and so forth. So be sure to check out that complimentary service.

Meanwhile, we need your help promoting MacroVoices, so please tell your friends and colleagues, forward your Research Roundup emails, and most importantly, register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Only takes a few minutes, and the benefit to you is you'll receive our free Research Roundup email, which never contains any advertising or marketing. It's just links to the best content we could find on the internet Patrick, tell them what they can expect to find in this week's Research Roundup.

Patrick Ceresna: This week you're going to find the transcript for today's interview, as well as a link to the chartbook we just discussed in the postgame. There's also an interesting article from Variant Perception talking about the setback to that Turkish recovery, as well as an interesting article from Daniel Lacalle suggesting that the Eurozone slowdown is far worse than the global global one. So you'll find this and so much more in this week's Research Roundup. That does it for this week's episode. We appreciate all the feedback and support we get from our listeners and are always looking for suggestions on how we can make the program even better.

Now, for those of our listeners that write or blog about the markets and would like to share that content with our listeners, send us an email at researchroundup@macrovoices.com or tag it with the #MVRR hashtag on Twitter, and we'll include it in our weekly If you have not already, follow our main Twitter account @MacroVoices for all the most recent updates and releases. You can also follow Erik on Twitter @ErikSTownsend and myself @PatrickCeresna. On behalf of Erik Townsend and myself, thank you for listening, and we'll see you all next week.

Announcer: That concludes this edition of MacroVoices. Be sure to tune in each week to hear feature interviews with the brightest minds in finance and macroeconomics. MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com, the internet's premier source of online education for traders. Please visit BigPictureTrading.com for more information. Please register your free account at MacroVoices.com. Once registered, you'll receive our free weekly Research Roundup email containing links to supporting documents from our featured guests and the very best free financial content our volunteer research team could find on the internet each week. You'll also gain access to our free listener discussion forums and research library. And the more registered users we have, the more we'll be able to recruit high-profile feature interview guests for future programs, so please register your free account today at MacroVoices.com if you haven't already. You can subscribe to MacroVoices on iTunes to have MacroVoices automatically delivered to your mobile device each week free of charge.

You can email questions for the program to mailbag@macrovoices.com, and we'll answer your questions on the air from time to time in our mailbag segment. MacroVoices is presented for informational and entertainment purposes. The information presented on MacroVoices should not be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making investment decisions. The views and opinions expressed on MacroVoices are those of the participants and do not necessarily reflect those of the show's hosts or sponsors. MacroVoices, its producers, sponsors, and hosts, Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna, do not assume any responsibility for any potential losses or gains incurred by participants. MacroVoices is a production of Bloomberg Television and Radio. shall not be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MacroVoices.

MacroVoices is made possible by sponsorship from BigPictureTrading.com and by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management LLC. For more information, visit MacroVoices.com.

MacroVoices transcripts are machine-transcribed, then corrected and edited by AI under MacroVoices' editorial rules: names, terms and figures are checked against the audio where the text is uncertain, and this free transcript is the corrected verbatim text: it keeps what each speaker said, including fillers, repeats and false starts (the subscriber edition is the edited reading copy). Nothing is added; every edit is logged against the verbatim transcript, which MacroVoices keeps. Timestamps refer to the published audio. Errors are still possible — where it matters, listen. Nothing on MacroVoices is investment advice: the views expressed are the participants' own, and MacroVoices, its hosts and producers accept no liability for decisions made on the basis of this material.

Subscribers get the formatted edition of this episode as PDF and HTML — the research-note outline with every market call flagged, the contents with links into the text, the guest's earlier MacroVoices appearances and related episodes, the edited transcript and the glossary — and the one-page Episode Brief. Open the subscriber edition.

Consider a Donation

Looking for the Downloads?

MACRO VOICES is presented for informational and entertainment purposes only. The information presented in MACRO VOICES should NOT be construed as investment advice. Always consult a licensed investment professional before making important investment decisions. The opinions expressed on MACRO VOICES are those of the participants. MACRO VOICES, its producers, and hosts Erik Townsend and Patrick Ceresna shall NOT be liable for losses resulting from investment decisions based on information or viewpoints presented on MACRO VOICES.

Go to top